
ASSIGNMENTS
1) Thoreau at Walden, John Porcellino
For this common-read book, you will receive a grade for how well you annotate your book according to the
following assignment, which is twofold:
A. You will read and annotate the book’s Introduction and then later the Afterword and the Panel Discussion
sections in a conventional way. These sections must contain underlining, circled words, notes in the margins,
etc.
B. You will annotate the graphic novel itself with sticky notes that comment on the 5 dimensions listed below.
Compose 15 thoughtful sticky notes total—3 for each category—spread throughout the book. On each note,
write the category title and page number(s) at the top of your sticky note, and then write your 2-3 sentences of
commentary beneath the category title (which can be abbreviated, e.g., “Phil./Ethical” or “Lang./Rhetoric”).
NOTE: your sticky notes should be distributed throughout the text: approximately 3 to 5 in each of the
graphic novel’s 4 numbered sections.
1. Central Themes (3): Notice examples of Thoreau’s key values like simplicity, solitude, nature, independence,
time, consumerism. → Why do these ideas matter in today’s world of noise and entertainment?
2. Philosophical / Ethical Claims (3): Identify where Thoreau offers life lessons or challenges to societal
norms. → Respond to the implicit or explicit claim: Do you agree? Is it realistic? Why or why not?
3. Visual Choices (3): Analyze how the art supports or enhances the message. Consider contrast, repetition,
symbolic images, and panel layout, → What mood, tone, and/or idea do the visual techniques create in each case?
4. Powerful Language or Rhetoric (3): Highlight metaphors, cool phrases, or rhetorical questions. Paraphrase
or respond to them in your own words. → How does Thoreau use language to persuade or provoke thought?
5. Critical Questions or Personal Reactions (3): Ask questions where you're confused, challenged, or curious.
Connect passages to your own experiences or to current events. → What might Thoreau say about social media?
2) 1984, George Orwell
DURING THE FIRST WEEK OF SCHOOL, YOU WILL TURN IN YOUR ANNOTATED COPY OF
1984 FOR A GRADE. Your annotation grade for the book will take into account how diligently you follow the
directions below as well as the quantity and quality of your annotations in general. See below for lots of helpful
general info regarding how to annotate well. STUDENTS SHOULD ALSO BE PREPARED FOR AN
OPEN-BOOK TEST OVER THE NOVEL (meaning the more you legitimately read and mark the text, the
better you’ll do on the assessment).
For each of the book’s 3 sections, you must:
● Circle any words you don’t know.
● Underline any and all descriptive details pertaining to characters and setting (i.e., info about how the world of
this novel looks, feels, and works).
● Use squiggly underlining for any sentences or passages that present significant political ideas or realities in the
book.
● Double underline any instances of figurative language (similes, metaphors, hyperbole, etc.) and any images or
objects that seem symbolic.
● **Finally, for each of the book’s 27 chapters, you must put a star in the upper left or right corner of at least
one page that contains a passage you find important, interesting, or complex. Then, at the bottom of that
page, you must write out 1 or 2 sentences of commentary or a thoughtful question about the passage.
● Any and all additional annotations are welcome and great!