Essentials of Management Consulting PDF Free Download

1 / 83
0 views83 pages

Essentials of Management Consulting PDF Free Download

Essentials of Management Consulting PDF free Download. Think more deeply and widely.

CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course
CMC Canada | Essentials of Management Consulting
LEARNER WORKBOOK
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 1
Table of Contents
1. COURSE INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................................. 4
1.1. WELCOME ............................................................................................................................................. 4
1.2. COURSE LEARNING OUTCOMES ............................................................................................................ 4
1.3. APPROACH TO LEARNING ..................................................................................................................... 5
1.4. ATTENDANCE & WORKLOAD ................................................................................................................. 5
1.5. ASSESSMENT OF LEARNING ....................................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
2. COURSE STRUCTURE & AGENDA ................................................................................................................. 7
2.1. GROUP CASE STUDY .............................................................................................................................. 7
2.2. REFLECTIVE SUMMARY ......................................................................................................................... 8
3. INTRODUCTION TO THE PROFESSION ......................................................................................................... 9
3.1. WHAT IS MANAGEMENT CONSULTING?................................................................................................ 9
3.2. MANAGEMENT CONSULTING IS A GLOBAL PROFESSION ..................................................................... 10
3.3. THE PROFESSION OF MANAGEMENT CONSULTING IN CANADA .......................................................... 11
3.4. THE CMC COMPETENCY FRAMEWORK (2018) ..................................................................................... 11
3.5. CMC COMMON BODY OF KNOWLEDGE ............................................................................................... 13
3.6. PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT IN MANAGEMENT CONSULTING ................................................................ 13
3.7. THE CERTIFIED MANAGEMENT CONSULTANT (CMC) DESIGNATION .................................................... 15
3.8. ISO 20700 GUIDELINES FOR MANAGEMENT CONSULTANCY SERVICES ............................................. 16
4. INTRODUCTION TO THE CONSULTING PROCESS ....................................................................................... 17
4.1. OVERVIEW OF THE CONSULTING PROCESS .......................................................................................... 17
4.2. THE THREE ELEMENTS OF MANAGEMENT CONSULTING ..................................................................... 18
4.3. SKILLS & ATTRIBUTES OF A MANAGEMENT CONSULTANT .................................................................. 20
5. WEEK 1: HOMEWORK ............................................................................................................................... 21
6. STAGE 1: ENTRY ........................................................................................................................................ 22
6.1. ENTRY: OBJEcTIVES, INPUTS, and OUTPUTS ....................................................................................... 22
6.2. TOOLS & TECHNIQUES IN ENTRY ......................................................................................................... 24
6.3. CONDUCT INITIAL MEETING ................................................................................................................ 24
6.4. PRELIMINARY DIAGNOSIS ................................................................................................................... 25
6.5. DEVELOP ENGAGEMENT APPROACH & PROPOSAL ............................................................................. 25
6.6. NEGOTIATING & EXECUTING THE AGREEMENT ................................................................................... 27
6.7. THE CONTENT OF THE NEGOTIATED AGREEMENT ............................................................................... 27
6.8. CODE OF CONDUCT DURING THE ENTRY STAGE .................................................................................. 29
7. WEEK 2: HOMEWORK ............................................................................................................................... 30
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 2
8. STAGE 2: DIAGNOSIS ................................................................................................................................. 31
8.1. DIAGNOSIS: OBJEcTIVES, INPUTS, and OUTPUTS ................................................................................ 31
8.2. TOOLS & TECHNIQUES IN DIAGNOSIS.................................................................................................. 33
8.3. RE-CONFIRM PURPOSE ....................................................................................................................... 34
8.4. GATHER DATA ..................................................................................................................................... 35
8.5. ANALYZE DATA.................................................................................................................................... 36
8.6. SYNTHESIZE DATA ............................................................................................................................... 37
8.7. SHARE FINDINGS ................................................................................................................................. 38
8.8. CODE OF CONDUCT DURING THE DIAGNOSIS STAGE........................................................................... 41
9. WEEK 3: HOMEWORK ............................................................................................................................... 42
10. STAGE 3: ACTION PLANNING .............................................................................................................. 43
10.1. ACTION PLANNING: OBJEcTIVES, INPUTS, and OUTPUTS .................................................................... 43
10.2. TOOLS & TECHNIQUES IN ACTION PlANNING ...................................................................................... 46
10.3. DIVERGENT & CONVERGENT THINKING .............................................................................................. 47
10.4. CONCEPTUALIZE: DEVELOPING OPTIONS & ALTERNATIVES ................................................................ 48
10.5. EVALUATE: EVALUATING THE ALTERNATIVES ..................................................................................... 48
10.6. PLAN: DEFINING THE PRELIMINARY PLANS ........................................................................................ 49
10.7. DECIDE: DECIDING WHAT ACTION TO TAKE ........................................................................................ 49
10.8. THE ACTION PROPOSALS REPORT ....................................................................................................... 50
10.9. CODE OF CONDUCT DURING THE ACTION PLANNING STAGE .............................................................. 52
11. WEEK 4: HOMEWORK ........................................................................................................................... 53
12. MANAGING THE ENGAGEMENT ............................................................................................................ 54
12.1. PREPARING FOR AND ENABLING CHANGE .......................................................................................... 54
12.1.1. INDIVIDUAL REACTIONS TO CHANGE ................................................................................................ 55
12.1.2. MODELS OF CHANGE ......................................................................................................................... 57
12.1.3. CRITICAL SUCCESS FACTORS IN CHANGE .......................................................................................... 59
12.1.4. ASSESSING READINESS TO CHANGE .................................................................................................. 59
12.2. PROJECT MANAGEMENT OVERVIEW ................................................................................................... 61
12.2.1. IMPLEMENTING CHANGE THROUGH PROJECTS ................................................................................ 62
12.2.2. APPROACHES TO PROJECT MANAGEMENT ....................................................................................... 63
12.2.3. THE PROJECT MANAGEMENT PROCESS ............................................................................................ 65
12.2.4. BUILDING THE PLAN .......................................................................................................................... 66
12.3. LEADERSHIP IN THE ENGAGEMENT ..................................................................................................... 68
13. WEEK 5: HOMEWORK ........................................................................................................................... 69
14. STAGE 4: IMPLEMENTATION .............................................................................................................. 70
14.1. IMPLEMENTATION: OBJEcTIVES, INPUTS, and OUTPUTS .................................................................... 70
14.2. TOOLS & TECHNIQUES IN IMPLEMENTATION ...................................................................................... 71
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 3
14.3. THE ROLE OF THE CONSULTANT IN IMPLEMENTATION ....................................................................... 72
14.4. CONTRACTING AND IMPLEMENTATION .............................................................................................. 73
14.5. PUTTING THE PLAN INTO ACTION ....................................................................................................... 73
14.6. GROWING CAPABILITIES WITHIN THE CLIENT ...................................................................................... 75
14.7. CODE OF CONDUCT DURING THE IMPLEMENTATION STAGE ............................................................... 76
15. STAGE 5: TERMINATION ..................................................................................................................... 77
15.1. TERMINATION: OBJEcTIVES, INPUTS, and OUTPUTS ........................................................................... 77
15.2. TOOLS & TECHNIQUES IN TERMiNATION ............................................................................................ 78
15.3. PROFESSIONALLY EXITING AN ENGAGEMENT ..................................................................................... 80
15.4. CODE OF CONDUCT DURING THE IMPLEMENTATION STAGE ............................................................... 81
16. WEEK 6: HOMEWORK ........................................................................................................................... 82
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 4
1. COURSE INTRODUCTION
1.1. WELCOME
Welcome to the Essentials of Management Consulting!
Management Consulting professionals are often required to address a client’s most significant
challenges to create organizational value and performance opportunities. While the challenges can
vary, Management Consultants have a foundational approach that enables them to bring clients through
the consulting journey to realize their organization's goals.
The Essentials of Management Consulting course provides learners with the foundational approaches,
skills, and techniques necessary to effectively and ethically address client challenges and deliver value.
Whether an experienced practitioner looking to formalize their expertise through the Certified
Management Consultant (CMC) designation; or, in pursuit of professional growth as a developing
practitioner, the Essentials of Management Consulting course will equip you with a solid foundation
based on industry best practices within the context of cohort-based applied learning.
The Essentials of Management Consulting course focuses on three core consulting competencies:
Helping clients assess their current situations, including the business challenges and
opportunities they can address to improve upon the present.
Helping clients develop strategies for achieving objectives and preserving the benefit of those
achievements.
Helping clients prepare for and address the challenges of implementation.
1.2. COURSE LEARNING OUTCOMES
By the completion of this course, successful learners will be able to:
Define and describe the four core competencies in management consulting.
Describe the five stages of the consulting process and how each stage relates to one another,
including the inputs and outputs of each of the stages.
Select and apply core consulting tools and techniques for each stage of the consulting process
within the context of a client’s circumstance.
Demonstrate awareness of cross-functional areas, including human resources, finance,
operations, information technology, marketing, and strategic planning within the context of a
management consulting engagement.
Apply appropriate change management and project management techniques during the
execution of a management consulting engagement to support implementation.
Demonstrate professional conduct within a management consulting engagement and identify
common situations where professional conduct may be at risk.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 5
1.3. APPROACH TO LEARNING
The course uses a variety of approaches, including:
1.4. ATTENDANCE & WORKLOAD
This course is hard work and planning will be key to your success. Please note the following information
regarding attendance and workload expectations outside of the learning environment:
Group participation is key to success. It is necessary for learners to attend a majority of the
sessions to ensure contributions to group work deliverables. As a result, it is required that a
learner attend no less than 5 of the live classroom sessions.
BLENDED LEARNING
Utilizes various media before
and during the course to
support learning styles.
CASE STUDY
Enables you to work with a
team to apply course concepts
and produce common work
products.
GROUP WORK
Like in a consulting
engagement, you will work
with a team to address the
case study.
ATTENDANCE REQUIREMENTS
§Must attend no less than five live classes.
§Must not miss more than 15 minutes of each class.
WORKLOAD
Please be prepared to spend 5
8 hours of work per week on
the course including class time.
Aside from the course learning outcomes, what outcomes are you personally looking to achieve
throughout the course?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 6
Learners should expect to dedicate approximately 5 8 hours per week to the course. In
addition to the weekly classroom learning session of 3 hours, additional group work will add
another 2 5 hours above this.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 7
2. COURSE STRUCTURE & AGENDA
The course is delivered over six live online sessions and progressively builds upon concepts in each
week. Most weeks will include group work on the case study. You and your group are encouraged to
plan ahead for collaboration and creation of deliverables.
2.1. GROUP CASE STUDY
The group case study was developed to simulate a consulting engagement. While this is challenging to
do with a lack of direct engagement with a real client, it provides an opportunity for each group to
analyze and apply the course learning. A few important reminders regarding the case study and group
work:
The case study is a group-based assessment that requires each team member to work
collaboratively. Be prepared to contribute and support your team.
Like a real engagement, the answer may not be obvious and so disagreement may emerge
amongst the group. You will need to navigate this within the constraints of time and scope.
Be prepared to adapt your style to ensure constructive conflict and collaboration. This is often a
requirement of management consulting engagements.
Your recommendations and findings should be evidence-based and defensible. You will be
asked questions regarding your submissions to the client.
The group case study will require you to work with your team to analyze information and produce
simplified deliverables. For example, you will be asked to create a brief presentation of the letter of
engagement main elements contained within it. The instructor will ask questions about your proposed
letter of engagement.
WEEK 1
Welcome and introduction to the
profession of management
consulting and an overview of the
consulting process which will form
the core of the course.
WEEK 2
Introduction to the entry stage and
agreeing on the scope of the
engagement. Applying preliminary
diagnosis as part of problem and
scope identification.
WEEK 3
Explore more deeply the diagnosis
stage and apply tools and techniques
which enable data collection and
analysis. Prepare to present findings
to the client.
WEEK 4
Introduction to Action Planning and
how options are developed,
analyzed, and presented. Discover
how Action Planning sets the stage
for Implementation.
WEEK 5
Prior to implementation, explore the
management of the project and
change and understand how to
effectively lead a management
consulting engagement to success.
WEEK 6
Dive into the implementation of the
recommendations and how to
navigate the challenges here.
Properly close the engagement and
provide final deliverables.
PRE-COURSE
Complete before Week 1
Review the course outline and
complete the online learning module
provided to you by CMC-Canada. Be
sure to complete the online learning
module prior to Week 1.
POST-COURSE
Complete the course feedback
survey and complete and submit the
reflective summary by the due date.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 8
2.2. REFLECTIVE SUMMARY
The reflective summary is an independently completed assignment where you will be asked to reflect on
your course learning and experiences, integrating that information into an actionable path forward.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 9
3. INTRODUCTION TO THE PROFESSION
Management consulting is a demanding profession and career. The challenges clients face when
engaging with a management consultant are often complicated and impactful on their organization.
Often, attempts have been made to resolve the challenge or acquire an opportunity before the
consultant arrives.
3.1. WHAT IS MANAGEMENT CONSULTING?
Management consulting has several defections which are generally used in the profession to define
what a management consultant does. Two definitions are commonly used:
“An advisory service contracted for and provided to organizations by specially trained and
qualified persons who assist, in an objective and independent manner, the client organization to
identify management problems, analyze such problems, recommend solutions, and help in the
implementation of solutions.”1
“Management consulting is an independent, professional, advisory service assisting managers
and organizations to achieve organizational purposes and objectives by solving management
and business problems, identifying and seizing new opportunities, enhancing learning, and
implementing changes.”2
1 L.E. Greiner, R.O. Metzger: Consulting to management (Englewood Cliffs, NJ, Prentice-Hall, 1983), p. 7
2 CMC-Canada, About the Profession (2021). Link here.
The role of the consultant can also vary from one engagement to another. In some engagements, you
may be a facilitator of reflective exploration where you guide the client through a series of activities
which assists them in seeing their situation more pragmatically and clearly. In other situations, you may
work with the client and blend your expertise with their knowledge of their organization and industry to
develop alternatives. You may also find yourself in the role of advocate where your expertise and
guidance direct the client towards specific actions or considerations.
Figure 1 - Roles of the Consultant during an engagement
The role of the
consultant when
working with a
client.
When engaging with a client, it is
important to be aware of what
role you are assuming and
ensure that it is aligned with the
nature of the engagement.
Reflective Inquiry
Identifies Alternatives
Advocate
Client
Consultant
Level of consultant activity in problem solving
Non-Directive Directive
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 10
Whatever the role you take in an engagement, it is important to be clear with the client and yourself
about that what the role is and is not. A directive management consulting style may lead the client to
conclusions that exclude their input and knowledge of their organization. Meanwhile, a reflective
approach may leave the client feeling they are not receiving sufficient support and expert direction from
the consultant.
3.2. MANAGEMENT CONSULTING IS A GLOBAL PROFESSION
While management consulting has an established North American context, it is also part of a global
profession. For those interested in international relationship building and consulting opportunities,
there are many ways to be involved and grow your network.
Figure 2 - Global presence of Certifying Institutes
The International Council of Management Consulting Institutes (ICMCI) stewards the Certified
Management Consultant (CMC) designation, giving authority to Certifying Institutes to grant the
designation to their members within various geographies across the world. The ICMCI establishes
criteria and competencies that must be met before the CMC designation may be granted. This is done
through the development of uniform global standards which are administered by the Certifying
Institutes.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 11
3.3. THE PROFESSION OF MANAGEMENT CONSULTING IN CANADA
Management consulting in Canada is unique amongst our international peers. While many Certifying
Institutes are national in scope, Canada has Institutes in various provinces and regions that together
create the Canadian management consulting profession. Each of the Canadian Certifying Institutes have
unique regulations that guide their scope of work; however, work with CMC-Canada to ensure national
coordination and cooperation.
Figure 3 - Relationship between CMC Canada, Canadian CIs, and the ICMCI
CMC-Canada integrates the ICMCI management consulting standards and competencies into the
Canadian Certifying Institutes through establishing with the Canadian Institutes processes and
requirements for achieving the Certified Management Consultant designation in Canada. This allows
CMC-Canada and the Canadian Certifying Institutes to ensure compliance with Canadian and Provincial
regulations, while adhering to the international standards established by the ICMCI.
3.4. THE CMC COMPETENCY FRAMEWORK (2018)
Competency plays a critical role in ensure that the profession of management consulting is populated
with practitioners who are reliably able to complete an assignment with independence and without
supervision. It is important to understand the Uniform Code of Professional Conduct is directly related
to the application of the competencies found within the framework. If you are pursuing the Certified
Management Consultant (CMC) designation, you will want to be familiar with the Competency
Framework as part of structuring your engagement summaries and completing the oral assessment.
CMC-Alberta
CMC-Atlantic
CMC-British Columbia
CMC-Manitoba
CMC-Ontario
CMC-Quebec
CMC-Saskatchewan
l'Ordre des administrateurs agréés du Québec
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 12
Figure 4 - The CMC Competency Model
Business Competence
Demonstration of fact-based knowledge in business, industry sectors, and external awareness.
Competency classes include:
Client Business Insight
Consulting Business Insight
Technical Competence
Demonstration of the consulting skills, tools, and techniques in the delivery of professional services.
Competency classes include:
Functional Specialization
Engagement Management Skills
Values & Behaviour Competence
Combination of professional values, skills, credibility, and trust creating results for clients. Competency
classes include:
Ethics & Professionalism
Analytical Skills
Personal Interaction Skills
Continued Learning & Development
Client Business Insight Consulting Business insight
Business Competence
Functional Specialization Consulting Skills
Technical Competence
Ethics & Profesisonalism Analytical Skills
Values & Behaviour Competence
Personal Interaction Personal Development
CMC Breadth of Skills
& Experience
Continued Learning
& Development
Reflection &
Feedback
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 13
3.5. CMC COMMON BODY OF KNOWLEDGE
The Common Body of Knowledge is the collection of shared principles and practices which supports the
application of competencies within a consulting engagement. The CMC Common Body of Knowledge is
included in your course package and provides some greater insights into the topics we will cover during
the course.
3.6. PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT IN MANAGEMENT CONSULTING
Certified Management Consultants are expected to demonstrate in words and action the highest level of
professional conduct. Certified Management Consultants have a duty to protect the public, the client,
and the profession. We each hold each other accountable for ensuring that the professional code of
conduct is diligently and consistently adhered to.
Acts within jurisdictional laws and
ensure conduct protects the public
and ensures confidence in our
profession.
Public
Maintains knowledge of the profession
and industry and ensures that all
management consultants under their
leaderships act appropriately.
Profession
Recognizes that the interests of the
client organization as being
paramount by providing objective and
evidence-based guidance within their
area of competence & qualification.
Client Organization
Reports inappropriate conduct by other
management consultants and does not
accept review assignments where a
conflict of interest may affect pragmatic
evaluation.
Other Members
As a management consultant, you have an obligation to put the public, client, and professions needs
ahead of your own. This includes your business. To do anything else is to potentially contravene the
code of conduct.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 14
Ethics is core to management consulting. The advice and insights provided by a management
consultant to a client can impact the client’s workforce, financial performance, customers, regulators,
stakeholders, and investors. As consultants, we earn value for ourselves and our firms by participating
in engagements which create values and desired outcomes for clients.
Despite this, it is important to that we:
Acknowledge we cannot be the expert at everything. Know when you are qualified and
competent to provide a service, and when you are not.
Focus on areas of expertise that create a unique value proposition.
Avoid selling where there is not a genuine need. Your advice and guidance can have a
substantial impact on a client organization.
Always treat your status as a consultant and trusted advisor as a privilege.
Leverage colleagues and professional connections when you need support.
Throughout the course, we will touch on aspects of the Code of Conduct. Especially important during an
engagement is the responsibility to the client. Following is a summary of key aspects of this professional
conduct obligation:
Due Care: A member shall act in the best interest of the client, providing professional services
with integrity, objectivity, and independence. A member shall not encourage unrealistic client
expectations.
Business Development: A member shall not adopt any method of obtaining business that
detracts from the professional image of the Institute or its members.
Competence: A member shall accept only those assignments that the member has the
knowledge and skill to perform.
Informed Client: A member shall, before accepting an assignment, reach a mutual
understanding with the client as to the assignment objectives, scope, workplan, and costs.
Fee Arrangement: A member shall establish fee arrangements with a client in advance of any
substantive work and shall inform all relevant parties when such arrangements may impair or
may be seen to impair the objectivity or independence of the member. A member shall not
enter into fee arrangements which have the potential to compromise the member's integrity or
the quality of services rendered.
Conflict: A member shall avoid acting simultaneously for two or more clients in potentially
conflicting situations without informing all parties in advance and securing their agreement to
the arrangement. A member shall inform a client of any interest that may impair or may be seen
to impair professional judgment. A member shall not take advantage of a client relationship by
encouraging, unless by way of an advertisement, an employee of that client to consider
alternate employment without prior discussion with the client.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 15
Confidentiality: A member shall treat all client information as confidential.
Objectivity: A member shall refrain from serving a client under terms or conditions that impair
independence and a member shall reserve the right to withdraw from the assignment if such
becomes the case.
3.7. THE CERTIFIED MANAGEMENT CONSULTANT (CMC) DESIGNATION
The Certified Management Consultant (CMC) designation is the globally recognized certification in over
50 counties representing a commitment to the highest standards of consulting and adherence to ethical
canons of the profession. Becoming a CMC will invite you to join local, national, and international
management consultants in a global community of practice.
Global Community of Practice: Certified Management Consultants are part of a global
community of practices spanning many diverse countries and communities. Through the
International Council of Management Consulting Institutes, the CMC designation is recognized
internationally.
Commitment to the Highest Standards: Protecting the public, the profession, and the client are
key standards that CMCs are expected to constantly uphold and protect. No stealing your
watch to tell you the time of day.
Local and National Connections: Through local Certifying Institutes and CMC-Canada, CMCs
build local connections and acquire new knowledge and skills through professional development
opportunities.
Reflect on your own career or consulting engagements. What are some connections you see
between the code of professional conduct and a potential live engagement?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 16
3.8. ISO 20700 GUIDELINES FOR MANAGEMENT CONSULTANCY SERVICES
To better support the definition and adherence to global standards in the practice of management
consulting, the ICMCI worked collaboratively with over 20 countries and global stakeholders to define
ISO 20700 Guidelines for Management Consultancy Services. ISO 20700 focuses on reinforcing sound
professional practices which can be measured for adherence to industry best practices. It also provides
clients of management consultancies the assurance of professional behaviour and ensures trust is
protected consistent with the code of professional conduct. To support standardization, a Self-
Declaration Checklist for ISO 20700 provides a means to ensure adherence to ISO 20700 for both large,
and small consulting engagements.
While the ISO 20700 standard for Management Consultancy Services is not the focus of this course, the
consulting process we will discuss shortly adheres to this standard closely. As you will soon learn,
adherence to the code of conduct and the information within this course closely aligns with the ISO
20700 standard.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 17
4. INTRODUCTION TO THE CONSULTING PROCESS
Management consultants use a defined approach to ensure consistency in each engagement. While
there are various approaches, most adhere to the consulting process we will focus on during this course.
Throughout this course, we will employ the Kubr model of management consulting.
Milan Kubr dedicated much of his career to defining an approach to management consulting that was
firm, yet able to adapt to unique consulting engagement demands. You will see many similarities
between the Management Consulting Body of Knowledge and the work of Kubr. Kubr’s model provides
an approach for management consulting engagements, but must often be adapted. Engagements may
require less diagnosis for example, and more focus on implementation. All engagements require “Entry”
and “Termination” to comply with the code of conduct.
4.1. OVERVIEW OF THE CONSULTING PROCESS
The Kubr model represents a sound approach to management consulting engagements. It is meant to
be adapted based on the unique needs of each client and engagement and provides a framework to
ensure compliance with the Code of Professional Conduct while ensuring the client receives the
necessary consulting services to achieve their desired outcomes.
Figure 5 - Kubr Management Consulting Process - Adapted from Kubr, M., Management Consulting: A guide
to the profession (2017) p. 21
Stage 1
Entry
Stage 2
Diagnosis
Stage 3
Action Planning
Stage 4
Implementation
Stage 5
Termination
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 18
Throughout the course we will spend much time going into detail within each of the stages of the
consulting process. A summary of each stage is provided here:
Entry: What needs to be addressed is determined and an agreement is made between the
consultant and the client.
Diagnosis: Data collection and analysis is applied to diagnose the true problem, communicating
those findings to the client for consideration.
Action Planning: Options are developed that address the findings of diagnosis and actions are
proposed to address the purpose of the engagement, in alignments with the findings of
diagnosis.
Implementation: The accepted recommendations are implemented in an attempt to achieve
the desired outcomes of the client and engagement.
Termination: The engagement is formally closed in an orderly manner and the relationship is
continually developed to make the consultant available to support current and future needs that
may emerge.
4.2. THE THREE ELEMENTS OF MANAGEMENT CONSULTING
Management consultants offer clients the ability to combine tools and techniques with the human
dimensions of change, applying that integration through the consulting process.
Tools & Techniques: Consultants will use various tools and techniques to collect, analyze,
synthesize and communicate data and findings in order to address the client’s challenge.
The Consulting Process: The consulting process provides a structured approach to engagements
that maximizes the ability of the consultant to correctly identify the problem and solve it.
People: People form the core of consulting. Client staff will have information needed by the
consultant, sponsors will make decisions, and the consulting team will need to work together to
see success.
There are many hundreds of tools and techniques available to a management consultant. A
management consultant must understand what tools or techniques will be most effective in a specific
circumstance.
We use tools and techniques to improve our effectiveness. For example, we may use a SWOT analysis
to help define a contextual picture as part of planning a strategy for an organization. Throughout the
course, we will focus on common tools that are available. For some of these tools, there is an
accompanying video and explanation of the tool or technique and how to use them. Each stage of the
consulting process will have tools and techniques that are commonly used. Sometimes, it is necessary
to create a tool or technique for a specific situation where none is available.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 19
Project & Change Management
Tools & Techniques
Consulting Skills
Each stage of the consulting process will require the application of tools and techniques in order to
navigate effectively. While some tools and techniques may only be applicable to a single stage, others
are transferable. The management of change and management of the project are continuous
throughout.
Figure 6 - Integration of the Three Elements - Adapted from Kubr, M., Management Consulting: A guide to
the profession (2017) p. 21
Throughout any engagement, the people dimension will be present and constant. Success will often
depend on navigating the stakeholder landscape with political tact and interpersonal savvy. To neglect
the engagement of stakeholders will lead to critical success factors not being possible and an increased
risk of the engagement failing to deliver the expected outcomes.
No matter what engagement you are on, stakeholders will demand much of your attention as you
proceed through the consulting process. Stakeholders are critical to the success of the engagement.
They often have information or data that is needed to correctly diagnose a problem. They are also the
ones who must support and sustain the implementation of changes that may be recommended.
Many tools and techniques are focused on eliciting information and data from stakeholders. Others
focus on navigating change to help stakeholders transition to a changed future. Several videos
Consulting
Process
People
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 20
4.3. SKILLS & ATTRIBUTES OF A MANAGEMENT CONSULTANT
Management consultants offer clients the ability to combine tools and techniques with the human
dimensions of change, applying that integration through the consulting process.
Tools and techniques are only as effective as the skilled professional applying them. It is important to
not only understand when to use a specific tool or technique, but also how to apply that tool or
technique to a specific situation. While we cannot be good at everything, we must be aware of areas
where we must have a minimal level of efficacy and areas where we are each naturally strong or
experienced.
Technical Knowledge
Business Understanding
Change Management
Ability to Execute
Project Management
Interpersonal Skills
Knowledge Sharing
Creative Thinking
Ability to Analyze
Ethical Conduct
Cross-Functional
Facilitation
Conflict Resolution
Rapport Building
Political Savvy
Ethical Standards
Self-Motivated
Mobility
Empathy & Trust
Team Player
Energy
Positive Thinking
Self-Fulfillment
Self-Awareness
Reflecting on what we have discussed so far, what skills and attributes do you have that you feel
make for a good management consultant? What skills or attributes do you see yourself needing
to improve?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 21
5. WEEK 1: HOMEWORK
Please complete the following before our next class:
Ensure you and your group have established a regular date and time to work through the case
study materials. Consider using tools that enable asynchronous collaboration such as Google
Docs, Google Meeting, or Dropbox.
Read the following case study documents:
EMC Case Study 0 Overview
EMC Case Study 1 Initial Video Call
Recommended: Review the tools and techniques videos for the entry stage.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 22
6. STAGE 1: ENTRY
The entry stage is about matchmaking
the consultant and the client, ensuring
that the consultant can deliver, and the
client trusts the consultant will deliver
the expected outcomes. During entry, it
is not uncommon to feel as though you
do not have enough information. The
tools and techniques used attempt to
elicit and make available data for use in
matchmaking.
6.1. ENTRY: OBJECTIVES, INPUTS, AND OUTPUTS
Ultimately, the goal of the entry stage is to come to an agreement and terms regarding the initiation of
the consulting engagement. Despite that, in some cases the consultant and/or the client may determine
that there is a poor fit between what is required by the client and what is possible or within the
capability of the consultant. In this situation, the consultant and/or client will not arrive at an
agreement. When this occurs, the consultant should consider professional peers who may have the
needed skills and provide value to the client through an introduction.
Inputs
§Client has identified the need
for outside support and
believes a consultant may be
helpful.
§Contact between the
consultant and the client is
made.
§Initial meeting is planned and
scheduled.
Activities
§Conduct initial meeting with
potential client.
§Preliminary problem diagnosis.
§Developing engagement
approach and plan.
§Develop proposal for client
review and acceptance.
§Negotiation of scope and
contractual terms.
§Client and consultant
evaluation of fit.
Outputs
§Approval and acceptance of
contracted engagement.
Or
§Rejection of contracted
engagement.
Entry sets the foundation for a successful engagement by establishing trust and terms.
Stage 1
Entry
Stage 2
Diagnosis
Stage 3
Action Planning
Stage 4
Implementation
Stage 5
Termination
Adapted from the Common Body of Knowledge, CMC-Canada, 2009, pp. 16, 17
Adapted from Kubr, M., Management Consulting: A guide to the profession (2017) pp. 153 - 178
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 23
Depending on the complexity of the engagement, the entry stage can be quite rapid or a lengthier
process. It is important to remember that although a formal engagement has not yet been agreed to,
the consulting process has begun and information and insights can be gathered through these initial
interactions that will help ensure the engagement begins in a professional and prepared way.
The following summarizes the key activities undertaken during the entry stage:
Conduct Initial Meeting: Sets the tone of future meetings and is key for starting rapport
building. Generally, desirable to meet with the decision maker. Preliminary research on the
industry and organization should be undertaken in preparation. The outcome should be
agreement on next steps.
Preliminary Diagnosis: Begins prior to the initial meeting with review of publicly available
information. Goal is to not propose solutions, but to define an approach that will do so. Focus
is on rapidly collecting information for input into defining the problem and an approach to
resolve it.
Develop Engagement Approach: Using the data and information collected in preliminary
diagnosis, the consultant will develop an approach that will result in the desired outcome being
achieved by the client. The approach may be constrained by time, budget, and available
resources.
Develop Proposal: The proposal outlines the problem to be solved, results expected, estimated
budget, timelines, scope, resourcing and other information. While generally a sales document,
the proposal may eventually become a contractual artifact.
Negotiate Terms: Based on feedback from the client, aspects of the proposal may be adjusted
such as cost, timelines, scope, and resourcing. For the engagement to be successful, the
finalized terms must provide value to both the firm and the client at a reasonable investment.
Execute Agreement: Agreement is arrived at with a Letter of Engagement, Statement of Work,
or other Agreement. In addition to the finalized proposed approach, cost, resourcing etc., the
agreement also has terms around confidentiality, intellectual property, and payment schedules.
Conduct Initial
Meeting Preliminary
Diagnosis
Develop
Engagement
Approach
Develop
Proposal Negotiate
Terms Execute
Agreement
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 24
6.2. TOOLS & TECHNIQUES IN ENTRY
A summary of common tools and techniques is provided below. In addition, you will find several videos
as part of the course which demonstrate some of the tools and techniques.
6.3. CONDUCT INITIAL MEETING
The first meeting with the client set the “mood” for future interactions and is critical in establishing
rapport and credibility, the foundations for trust. From this moment forward, the consultant should be
collecting information and data from the client interactions to better understand the client context and
what needs to be addressed. Especially important is that the consultant it prepared to credibly engage
with the client. Reviewing annual reports, media coverage, employee review sites, and social media can
provide valuable insights into the client’s industry and potential circumstance. It is critical to enter the
meeting having done background research. Be prepared.
During the meeting, you will engage with the client in an exploratory discussion to understand their
needs and circumstance better. Specifically, you will want to understand what they are seeking to
accomplish and how they feel a management consultant can add value towards that objective. You will
want to be mindful to not jump to conclusions at this point, but you may want to consider developing
some mental hypotheses as part of conceptualization the client’s challenges in achieving their desired
outcomes.
Documentation Review
Consider reviewing publicly
available information such as
annual reports, employee review
sites, social media, and litigation
databases. This information can
provide insights into the
companys culture and brand.
Interviews
Several meetings focused on
discovery may be conducted and
these are a form of interviewing.
Use these opportunities to gather
insights into the perceived
problem and begin to determine
what needs to be addressed.
Management Survey
Some problems may be broad
enough to require a survey of the
organization to gather information
on the clients activities,
performance, and perspectives.
This is often used as part of more
complex engagements.
Problem ID Workshop
Individuals are brought together in
a facilitated sessions where they
share perceived problems and
opportunities. The group agrees
on a prioritized list of problems
and opportunities, breaking out
for further analysis and action.
Contract Template
You may use a standard template
for contracting which ensures you
have all the required terms clearly
laid out. If you are working in a
firm, be mindful to adhere to the
templates provided by your
organization.
Estimation Tools
You will likely use a spreadsheet to
estimate the effort and cost of
your engagements. If you are in a
firm, there are likely already
established estimation models you
can use. Make estimates
reasonable for you and the client.
Proposal Template
Proposal templates provide a
standardized form to
communicate information
regarding the approach proposed,
resourcing, costs etc. If you are in
a firm, this may be a mandated
template you must use.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 25
The client will also want to understand information about the consultant. For example, where has the
consultant done similar work in the past? What might be the approach the consultant would
recommend taking in this situation? The consultant will also want to assess their ability to assist the
client. In some situations, the consultant may not be a good fit for what the client is attempting to
achieve. In this situation, the consultant should connect and introduce the client to professional peers
who may be better able to assist.
It is not uncommon for a client to ask about the expected costs to address their problem. Be very
cautious responding to this without having done preliminary diagnosis which is a key input into
estimating what it will take to achieve the expected client outcomes. A statement like “I will certainly
provide that; however, I’d like to better understand what needs to be addressed so I can provide reliable
numbers to you can be helpful in this situation.
6.4. PRELIMINARY DIAGNOSIS
Each interaction with a client is an opportunity to gather
information and data. To effectively define what needs to be
addressed with the client through the engagement, a
preliminary diagnosis will need to be made and used as an
input into defining a proposed approach to resolving the
client’s needs.
Some clients may provide preliminary diagnosis, while others
may only be able to communicate symptoms and not the actual root problem. As the consultant, you
must be able to determine the reliability of this information and remain pragmatic in assessing it. A
client may strongly believe that they know what the problem is; however, it is important to evaluate
such beliefs based on data and evidence, not confidence and opinion.
To support preliminary diagnosis, various surveys and interviews may be used to collect data for input
into problem definition. These are often rapidly done and so thoroughness must be balanced with
speed. Be mindful that clients may attempt to self-diagnose themselves and indicate that what they
need is a solution and not problem definition. It is important to verify that the true problem has been
identified during entry and throughout the engagement in such cases. Clients often confuse symptoms
with causes which can lead to incorrect problem identification.
6.5. DEVELOP ENGAGEMENT APPROACH & PROPOSAL
Using the outputs of preliminary diagnosis, you will need to develop an approach that you and the client
believe will lead to their needs being resolved within the identified constraints. The consulting process
may differ than the engagement approach. This is normal. For example, a technology project may
adhere to the consulting process; however, incorporate agile methods in project execution during the
implementation phase.
As part of this, you will define at a high level the following information:
The right answer to the
wrong question is still
the wrong answer.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 26
Summary of the problem to be addressed.
Objectives to achieve and supporting actions.
Phases and timetable (may differ from consulting process).
Defined roles and responsibilities between client/consultant.
Once the approach is defined, clients will naturally want to also understand other information before
agreeing to proceed. In addition to the information you defined as part of developing the approach to
the engagement, you will also need to define in the proposal the following:
Resourcing of the project including relevant experience and qualifications. Clients will often also
want to know how much of their time will be required.
Firm background and similar work relevant to the engagement. Financial items such as the total
cost, estimate, and how the fee will be structured. For example, fixed fee, time & materials, or
outcome based.
Additional terms such as confidentiality, intellectual property, and terms for exit from the
engagement.
Be very clear about defining the end of the agreement and what specifically must occur for it to
conclude. This is a common area of struggle where the consultant may feel they have delivered;
however, the client had a different expectation of what “Finished” is.
Why would you want to adapt your approach to the engagement for each client and what
benefits would this provide?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 27
6.6. NEGOTIATING & EXECUTING THE AGREEMENT
When providing the proposal to the client, it is helpful to view this as a starting point for discussion.
Clients will often want to incorporate their feedback into the proposal to ensure that their unique
situation, enablers, and constraints are acknowledged. Common areas of negotiation include:
Aspects of the approach, scope, and stakeholders.
Deliverables and what a successful outcome is.
Costs and payment schedules.
Resourcing and timelines.
Other terms such as intellectual property.
Clients may not fully understand the value of some aspects of an approach. For example, they may wish
to shorten or skip diagnosis because they feel they know what the issues are. Be careful not to allow the
client to narrow the focus so much so that the true problem is not identified.
Me mindful that the goal of the negotiation is to arrive at a fair agreement where the consultant and the
client both derive reasonable and fair value from the engagement. The client expects to have their
challenges and situation competently addressed, and the firm expects that the client will pay a
reasonable fee for the services provided.
Once terms have been agreed to in principle, a formal agreement is required. The agreement should be
approved in writing by both the consultant and the client and may take several forms:
Letter of Engagement Shorter than typical contracts. Sound for smaller, less
complicated engagements.
Verbal Agreement Does not comply with code of conduct.
Written Contract Generally created by a legal professional, includes more
comprehensive terms and conditions than a Letter of Engagement.
Master Services Agreement An overarching agreement that subsidiary contracts must
comply with.
6.7. THE CONTENT OF THE NEGOTIATED AGREEMENT
Agreements can take many forms; however, there are common terms and conditions that should be
included in addition to specific information required from the Code of Business Conduct. At a minimum,
an agreement between a client and a Certified Management Consultant should include:
Legal name of the consultant/firm and the client organization.
Objectives, scope, timetable, milestones, and associated deliverables.
Roles and responsibilities for the consultants and the client.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 28
Fees and expenses that are expected.
Resume and profiles for the consulting team.
Billing and payment terms and processes.
Statement regarding the Uniform Code of Business Conduct.
Copyright and Intellectual Property rights.
Liability and limitations.
Confidentiality, warranties, and indemnities.
Process for making changes to the contract.
Termination process and conditions.
Jurisdiction and arbitration of disputes.
Signatures from authorized persons.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 29
6.8. CODE OF CONDUCT DURING THE ENTRY STAGE
The Entry stage can be exciting as you move closer to agreement and the engagement. That said, be
mindful of the code of conduct and avoid common pitfalls that can create problems later in the
engagement. Here are aspects of the code to be mindful of during entry:
Knowledge: Remains up-to-date on development within areas of the profession where the
consultant claims to have expertise.
Responsible for Others: Ensures that the supporting engagement team adheres to the code of
conduct and understands the obligations found within it.
Business Development: Ensures that professionalism is demonstrated throughout the business
development process.
Due Care: Consultant does not make guarantees that are beyond the direct control of the
consultant. Ensures transparency in any quantified benefits provided. Does not accept
assignments that disadvantage the public or the client. Always acts in the best interests of the
organization as a whole, not just one person.
Competence: Consultant only accepts engagements for which they are qualified and competent
to deliver and does not profess competency in areas the consultant is not.
Informed Client: Mutual understanding of the engagement objectives, scope, work plan, and
costs are known and put in writing.
Fee Arrangement: Consultant ensures that the fee arrangement is in writing and agreed to
before substantive work is started.
Objectivity: Engagements where the terms and conditions limit the objectivity are not
accepted. The consultant can exit should objectivity not be possible.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 30
7. WEEK 2: HOMEWORK
Please complete the following before our next class:
If not already complete, read the following case study documents:
EMC Case Study 0 Overview
EMC Case Study 1 Initial Video Call
Each group will prepare a maximum 5-minute presentation summarizing a letter of engagement.
Please include the following:
Legal name of the consultant/firm and the client organization.
Objectives, approach, scope, timetable, milestones and associated deliverables.
Roles and responsibilities for the consultants and the client.
Fees and expenses that are expected.
Statement regarding the Uniform Code of Business Conduct.
Recommended: Review the tools and techniques videos for the diagnosis stage.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 31
8. STAGE 2: DIAGNOSIS
The diagnosis stage focuses on the collection, analysis, and
synthesis of data to accurately define the true problem and the
factors contributing to it. During the Entry stage, your engagement
with the client organization may have been limited to a few
individuals who have decided to engage an external consultant for
assistance. Diagnosis expands the stakeholder landscape
significantly which can present both opportunities, and challenges.
Stakeholder engagement allows the consultant to increase the
awareness of the need to change and provides an opportunity to
improve the organization’s internal capacity through the transfer of
knowledge. This allows the client organization to improve its sense
of ownership and preserve the value created because of the
engagement.
8.1. DIAGNOSIS: OBJECTIVES, INPUTS, AND OUTPUTS
The purpose of the diagnosis stage is to accurately define the true problem along with the factors and
circumstances that allow it to occur. As you might imagine, this can be challenging when dealing with
complex problems where multiple causes and triggers create a highly complex circumstance. This must
be balanced with the constraints of the engagement and so there may not be sufficient time available to
gather all the data, making it critical to understand how much data is enough to reliably define the
problem and move forward.
Inputs
§The purpose of the
engagement is known.
§A formal agreement is in
writing and approved as an
output of Entry.
§The initial problem is defined
as a result of preliminary
diagnosis.
§The approach to the
engagement is defined. This
will inform data collection.
§The engagement team is
available and ready to begin.
Activities
§Re-confirm problem and
purpose of the engagement
and adapt approach if needed.
§Begin gathering data as
outlined in the engagement
approach.
§Analyze and organize the data
to ensure quality and
completeness.
§Synthesize the data to
determine root causes and
what must be truly addressed.
§Present findings to the client.
Outputs
§Diagnosis Report or Summary
of Findings.
§Decision on whether to
proceed further.
Define and model in detail the true problem and factors that influence or cause it.
Stage 1
Entry
Stage 2
Diagnosis
Stage 3
Action Planning
Stage 4
Implementation
Stage 5
Termination
Adapted from the Common Body of Knowledge, CMC-Canada, 2009, pp. 22 - 25
Adapted from Kubr, M., Management Consulting: A guide to the profession (2017) pp. 179 - 210
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 32
Diagnosis begins with re-confirming the purpose of the engagement with the client. From there, data is
gathered, analyzed, and synthesized to thoroughly diagnosis the problem and influences affecting it.
This cycle may iterate as the problem is progressively elaborated upon. Once complete, the findings are
formally shared with the client.
The following summarizes the key activities undertaken during the diagnosis stage:
Re-Confirm Purpose: Between the conclusion of entry and the initiation of diagnosis, time may
pass, and the client’s needs and information may change. Re-confirming the purpose and what
needs to be addressed helps ensure this critical alignment remains in place.
Gather Data: Data will be collected from sources and people as an input into analysis and
synthesis activities. It is important to minimize the risk of missed data by properly planning for
and ensuring data is collected from relevant sources.
Analyze Data: Collected data will be analyzed and transformed into models and structures that
allow it to become information. The collected data once modeled will provide a more complete
picture of the problem and it’s causes. There are additional tools and techniques to consider at
this stage.
Synthesize Data: Synthesis is when we take the information created from the data and
determine what root causes are affecting the client’s ability to achieve their desired outcomes.
The result of synthesis are several statements about what needs to be addressed in order for
the client to achieve their desired results.
Share Findings: Once the synthesis of data is complete and what needs to be addressed is
clearly defined, the complete findings are shared with the client organization. Ultimately, the
client must decide whether they wish to proceed in addressing the findings, or accept the
current state.
From Entry
1. Re-Confirm Purpose 5. Share Findings
2. Gather Data
3. Analyze Data
4. Synthesize Data
Occurs until problem
properly defined
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 33
8.2. TOOLS & TECHNIQUES IN DIAGNOSIS
A summary of common tools and techniques is provided below. In addition, you will find several videos
as part of the course which demonstrate some of the tools and techniques.
Documentation Review
In addition to external
documentation, internal
documentation may now be
available. Reports, policies,
procedures, financial information,
performance metrics, and project
documentation are examples.
Interviews
Interviews with stakeholders can
provide important insights.
Contextual factors which may
highlight the interaction of various
problem components may also be
found and give important context
to the problem.
Workshops
Various workshops can be
conducted with stakeholders using
frameworks such as 5 Forces,
PESTLE, SWOT, Fishbone, and
process mapping. These tools can
help define relationships and
influences on the problem.
Observation
Observation enables the
consultant to directly see
performance of an activity,
process, or interaction. This
provides insights that other
techniques may not be able to
provide.
Report Template
The Diagnostic Report provides
the outcomes of the diagnosis
stage and informs the client of
what the likely true problem is. A
template may be available for you
to use if you are within a firm.
Benchmarking
Using various data sources, data
collected on actual performance
of a client is compared to industry
peers or historical records. This
enables the client to see how they
perform relative to industry peers
and target improvement goals.
Surveys/Questionnaires
Provides an opportunity to gather
data from many more
stakeholders than other
techniques. Must be carefully
constructed to not affect the
responses from participants. Has
contextual limitations.
Data Visualization
Data often tells a story when it is
presented in a format that conveys
meaning. Using visualization
tools, data can be represented to
show relationships such as
causation, correlation, confidence
levels.
Force-Field Analysis
Provides a means to define the
forces which enable and
organization to perform and those
forces that constrain performance.
Focuses on reducing constraints
on enabling forces so that
improved results are possible.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 34
8.3. RE-CONFIRM PURPOSE
Entry and Diagnosis may be separated by a period where the client is
reviewing your proposal or acquiring internal support for the
engagement. During this period, client needs and information may
change requiring you to adapt your approach to the engagement
prior to starting diagnosis.
During this step you will want to re-confirm:
The scope and purpose of the engagement are unchanged.
The timeline remains feasible for you, and the client.
Consultant and client resources remain available to perform
the work.
Any assumptions that were made during Entry which may no
longer be true.
Re-confirming the problem to be addressed is an important to step. This provides the consultant an
opportunity to orient focus towards what is relevant. For example, what kind of data to gather, from
who, and from where. When defining the problem, there are various elements of the problem to
consider:
Substance: Examples: financial under-performance, falling sales, lack of scalable business
model, organizational efficiency.
Alignment at this stage is
critical to the success of
the engagement.
Should there be substantial
changes in scope, or should
the purpose of the
engagement fundamentally
change, you may need to
return to the Entry stage to
properly understand and
realign the engagement to this
new information.
What challenges might you face in diagnosis and how would you overcome them?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 35
Structure: What organizational unit(s) and/or physical locations have observed the problem?
Are there external impacts?
Magnitude: Relative to other priorities, how important is the problem to be addressed? Are
the impacts material to the organization?
Time: How long has the problem existed? How frequently does it occur? Is the impact
increasing or decreasing?
Ownership: Who is impacted by the problem and who expresses interest or need in resolving
it? Who is accountable for resolution?
Other Elements: Incudes client’s capacity to solve the problem, relationships between problem
elements, and other options for action.
8.4. GATHER DATA
Much effort will be invested in locating and collecting various forms of data from inside and outside the
organization. Success during data gathering will require a constant focus on the purpose of the
engagement and what is attempting to be resolved, otherwise it may be difficult to focus your area of
inquiry feasibly. Be mindful that as you engage in data gathering, you are also engaging with
stakeholders and their expectations. Be prepared to respond to questions or feedback that may be
outside of the scope of data gathering. Managing expectations with stakeholders is critical.
When you begin planning for how and where you will source data from, you will want to consider
several key items. First, you will want the data to be sufficiently uniform that it is comparable outside of
the context it originated from. Second, you will want to consider the level of detail required in the data
so that it can be appropriately used. Data that is not sufficiently detailed will require you to re-visit past
source to gather further detail. Third, consider time and how this impacts the reliability of the data.
Generally, the older the data is the less reliable you may find it. Fourth, ensure the data is sourced from
areas of relevancy. This is important to ensuring your approach to data collection acknowledges the
constraints of the engagement. Finally, organizing the collected data so that it can be more easily
analyzed and synthesized is key. Time can easily be wasted on locating data and may impact the ability
of the data to be analyzed in a timely way.
Some common sources of data might include:
Internal Records: Internal records may include various reports, electronic data found within
technology systems, training documentation, etc.
Purpose & Pragmatism.
Gathering data will bring forward a large amount of information to be considered. It can be
tempting to jump into solution or to contaminate the data with opinions and past
experiences. Always remain focused on the purpose of the engagement and ensure that the
information and data you collect is pragmatic and evidence-based.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 36
Memory of Stakeholders: Very rich in information; however, be mindful of prejudices and
assumptions. Valuable for gaining stakeholder insights.
Events and Activities: Observable by the consultant and often found in work processes,
methods, technology processes, and interpersonal interactions.
Benchmarking Data: Relevant and comparable data from other organizations can inform
opportunities for improvement.
Financial Data and Reports: Internal and external financial data and regulatory reports provide
historical data on internal value generation.
Competition: Often over-emphasized, provides context on activities of competitors. Be mindful
that the client sets their own path, which may be different from competitors.
8.5. ANALYZE DATA
Once the data has been collected, it will need to be analyzed and transformed into structures that will
enable it to become information. Although the analysis and synthesis of data are separate stages, they
are often simultaneous, and as a result some analysis may occur during gathering. Data must be
modeled or structured in a way that allows it to become information, which can be interpreted.
Before analyzing the data, it must often be assessed for quality and
reliability. The following may be done to assist with this:
The captured data should be organized as defined during
gathering.
Data may need to be corrected, edited, and normalized before
it can be analyzed.
Data may need to be classified. This may include the time,
place, responsibility, structure, or influencing factors.
You may also need to define relationships between previously
separate data.
All management consulting work will have an orientation towards the future as results and outcomes
will be found there. While the future cannot be known, it can be somewhat predicted based on current
data and trends. It will be necessary to model the future so that variables found in the past and present
can be incorporated. PESTLE and Five Forces analysis can be combined with a SWOT analysis as part of
future modeling. Be mindful not to become consumed with predicting the future. It can be effort
intensive and reduce focus on what is occurring today.
Getting the Whole Picture.
Remember that each piece of
data describes only a piece of
the problem you are working
to address. Until we can
associate evidence and facts
with the problem, we are
working with a hypothesis.
The outcome of diagnosis
must be defensible to a client
and the engagement team.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 37
Modeling data as part of
analysis can be
accomplished with many
tools and techniques.
Some select technique
are provided; however,
there are many more
available for a
management consultant
to use. Also, there are
times when a tool or
technique must be
developed by the
consultant to address a
client engagement
where those available
will not be effective.
8.6. SYNTHESIZE DATA
Synthesis is when we take the information created from the data and determine what root causes are
affecting the client’s ability to achieve their desired outcomes. The root cause is often not able to be
addressed directly. The consultant must address the contributing factors, influences, and elements that
create the root cause. To accomplish this, the consultant will Identify relationships between elements,
determine trends and causes of those trends, and classify primary and secondary events and factors.
The outcome will ultimately be several statements about what needs to be addressed in order for the
client to achieve the desired outcomes. As we collect and analyze data, we must evaluate what is
reliable, relevant, and material to the desired outcomes of the client. The process of synthesis allows us
to make these determinations and create the answer to the question, “What must be addressed to
achieve the outcomes desired by the client?”
PESTLE Analysis
Classifies data as being Political,
Environmental, Social,
Technological, Legal, or Economic.
Provides context for external
factors that are or may affect the
client organization.
Process Flowchart
Visually models the steps, roles,
and decisions within a process and
the relationship of that process to
others. Often used as part of
analysis for process improvements
or refactoring.
Affinity Analysis
Data that is uncorrelated may be
grouped and organized based on
characteristics that are shared.
This enables data to be better
analyzed by defining shared
relationships and elements.
Financial Ratios
Enable the comparison of complex
data by converting them into
various ratios. While a reliable
and commonly used technique, be
mindful of the complexity behind
ratios that may also be important.
Causal Analysis
Various techniques that enable the
modeling of a problem by
decomposing contributing
elements. Data may be used to
identify linkages, enabling analysis
and eventually resolution.
Four Ps
Enables the analysis of product or
service positioning which may be
affecting performance. Includes
Price, Placement, Promotion, and
the Product itself. Be mindful of
digital channels when doing this
analysis.
SWOT Analysis
Used to identify internal Strengths
and Weakness of an organization
in addition to external
Opportunities and Threats.
Enables the organization to see a
conceptual picture of its
circumstance.
Five Forces Analysis
Defines the threat of new
entrants, power of suppliers,
power of buyers, threat of
substitutes, and rivalry amongst
competitors. Shifts in these
industry structures means shifts in
the organization are needed.
Fishbone Diagram
Decomposes a problem into
contributing elements and
decomposes those elements into
contributing factors. Enables
visibility into causes that once
addressed, will resolve the core
problem.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 38
Figure 7 - Taking data from collection through to synthesis
At the start of Diagnosis, we reconfirmed the problem (or opportunity) that needs to be addressed. As
you near the conclusion of diagnosis, the original problem may remain, or additional problems that
contribute to it may be found. Either way, you will need to determine what precisely must be addressed
before you can determine how it will be addressed.
Area to be Addressed: Example: The organization must address the quality of the product
which is contributing to the high percentage of returned product and resulting in increasing
negative impacts on profitability and customer satisfaction.
Implication of not Acting: Example: Based on the data collected and analyzed, it is reasonable
to conclude that should the quality issue not be addressed customers will continue to return
product and post unfavorable reviews, reducing profitability and market share.
Implication of Acting: Example: Addressing the quality issues resulting in returned products
will allow the firm to prevent further growth in returns while reducing the percentage of
returned product. Customer reviews will improve and prevent further erosion of market share.
8.7. SHARE FINDINGS
Once we have synthesized the data and clearly defined the problem and the contributing factors, we are
ready to formally share this information with the client. Whenever possible, the findings should not be
a surprise to the client. Throughout diagnosis, the client should be engaged and kept up-to-date around
progress and the narrative being shaped by the data.
Collected Data
B
A
C
Root
Cause
Analyzing Data Synthesizing Data
B
A
C
Modelled Data
Synthesized
Information
Constant Feedback.
Communication with the client during diagnosis should be continuous. The Diagnosis Report is a
formal artifact but should not replace the client being involved and aware during Diagnosis.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 39
While the Diagnosis Report provides valuable information to the client, it is also a business development
document. The next steps and actions that may be taken to address the problem provides an
opportunity to assist the client further. The client may need to be motivated to act and may choose to
do so. The client may also decide that the problem isn’t worth addressing and may end the
engagement.
The Diagnosis Report (or Summary of Findings) provides a formal summary of the data, information, and
conclusions made by the consultant. Accompanying this may be a presentation to key stakeholders
summarizing the key information from the report itself. Key to this report are the descriptions of what
needs to be addressed and next steps for the client and consultant to take.
The following is the minimum content of a Diagnosis Report:
Executive Summary
Provide a summary overview of the report findings (strategic direction, problems,
underlying root causes, and areas to be addressed) in such a way that will allow
senior management to quickly understand the breadth of the diagnosis, grasp the
key issues, and decide why, how, and where to proceed.
You should present a coherent, persuasive argument as to the relationship between
the strategic direction, future success of the organization, and the 4-6 critical issues
you have identified to be addressed by the client. Any assumptions or insights into
the case which support these arguments should also be woven into the narrative.
Summary of the engagement’s purpose and the problem to be addressed.
Restate the purpose of the consulting engagement and briefly reconfirm the scope.
(Did the purpose and objectives need to be clarified or redefined in light of new
information gathered during this stage? Did this affect the scope of the
assignment?) State what the consulting team set out to achieve in this stage of the
engagement.
Statement regarding the code of conduct and commitment to public, client,
profession, and pragmatism.
Purpose of Diagnosis and approach undertaken including stakeholders and information
sources utilized.
Conclusion section with four to six statements indicating the area to be addressed,
implication of acting, and implication of not acting.
Include both the implication of acting, and not acting.
For each statement, provide a summary of the fact-based rationale.
Include any assumptions made which affect the validity of the findings.
You may wish to include relevant constraints. For example, “Organization has
limited internal capability to develop software”.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 40
Next steps including the decision to proceed; or not proceed.
In some situations, you must communicate difficult information to the client. How would you
approach this situation in a professional manner?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 41
8.8. CODE OF CONDUCT DURING THE DIAGNOSIS STAGE
Diagnosis can be an exciting stage as you get into the actual work of consulting. That said, there are
important Code of Conduct expectations to be aware of. Here are aspects of the code to be mindful of
during diagnosis:
Competence: Ensure that the team has sufficient competence and knowledge to perform the
work that emerges from Diagnosis.
Responsible for Others: Ensure all members of the engagement team are aware of the code of
conduct and adhere to it.
Business Development: Be mindful that in pursuit of selling the next stage, you do not
contaminate facts with a desire to sell more work.
Critical Review: When critically reviewing the work of another CMC, you have an obligation to
inform the member of your review. The client must be aware of this requirement.
Confidentiality: Ensure that individual responses during surveys and interviews remain
confidential. Do not disclose client information to others.
Objectivity: Engagements where the terms and conditions limit the objectivity are not
accepted. The consultant can exit should objectivity not be possible.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 42
9. WEEK 3: HOMEWORK
Please complete the following before our next class:
Read the following case study interviews in the order provided below:
EMC Case Study 2 Diagnosis Bill Bauer Master Brewer
EMC Case Study 3 Diagnosis Katie Neil Marketing & Events Manager
EMC Case Study 4 Diagnosis Brad Schultz Brewery Manager
Each group will prepare a maximum 10-minute presentation summarizing the diagnosis report.
Please include the following:
Summary of the engagement’s purpose and the problem to be addressed.
Statement regarding the code of conduct and commitment to public, client, profession
and pragmatism.
Purpose of Diagnosis and approach undertaken including stakeholders and information
sources utilized.
Conclusion section with 4 6 statements indicating the area to be addressed,
implication of acting, and implication of not acting.
o Include both the implication of acting, and not acting.
o For each statement, provide a summary of the fact-based rationale.
o Include any assumptions made which affect the validity of the findings.
o You may wish to include relevant constraints. For example, “Organization has
limited internal capability to develop software”.
Next steps including the decision to proceed; or not proceed.
Recommended: Review the tools and techniques videos for the action planning stage.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 43
10. STAGE 3: ACTION PLANNING
The action planning stage is focused on conceptualizing
potential solutions to address the findings of the
diagnosis stage. This is accomplished through a process
of divergent and convergent thinking which seeks to
generate alternatives that are then evaluated so that
what remains are a select few action proposals. The
selected action proposals are presented to the client for
consideration.
10.1. ACTION PLANNING: OBJECTIVES, INPUTS, AND OUTPUTS
The purpose of the action planning stage is to conceptualize, develop, and present options to the client
that inform the decision to proceed and how the problem will be addressed. While there may be many
options available, those presented to the client for consideration must be both feasible to implement,
and feasible to sustain.
Inputs
§Diagnosis Report which details
areas that need to be
addressed.
§Acceptance from the client of
the findings in the Diagnosis
Report.
§Shift from analysis to more
divergent ways of thinking.
Activities
§Conceptualize and define
possible solutions which
address the findings of the
Diagnosis Report.
§Select solutions to be pursued
considering clients readiness
for change.
§Develop selected solutions and
conduct preliminary
implementation planning.
§Present the action proposals to
the client.
Outputs
§Report or presentation
summarizing the Action
Proposals and preliminary
implementation plans.
§Decision on whether to
proceed further.
Develop and present alternatives to address the problem, deciding on how to proceed.
Adapted from the Common Body of Knowledge, CMC-Canada, 2009, pp. 25 - 28
Adapted from Kubr, M., Management Consulting: A guide to the profession (2017) pp. 213 - 227
Stage 1
Entry
Stage 2
Diagnosis
Stage 3
Action Planning
Stage 4
Implementation
Stage 5
Termination
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 44
Action planning starts with the creative process of conceptualizing solutions that may address the
identified problems in Diagnosis. Solution options are then evaluated and reduced to a select few
options which are most likely to produce the desired outcomes for the client. The selected solution
options are transformed into Action Proposals which are considered by the client as part of deciding on
next steps.
The following summarizes the key activities undertaken during the action planning stage:
Conceptualize: Potential options and solutions are conceptualized in preparation for
evaluation. Not all conceptualized options will move forward, especially when the application of
constraints is made during evaluation.
Evaluate: Judgement is applied to assess which options are most likely to achieve the desired
outcome in the most feasible ways. The options remaining are more thoroughly planned for
and turned into action proposals that the client may consider.
Plan: Taking the remaining options from evaluation, action proposals are generated detailing
more specific approaches and estimates for each of the options. It is not uncommon to return
to evaluation in some cases when detailed plans indicate a lack of feasibility or fit.
Decide: The final action proposals are presented to the client for feedback and discussion. A
formal report is provided detailing the specific action proposals and how they were arrived at.
It is not sufficient to have a solution that addresses the problem or opportunity the client wishes to
address. The client must be able to implement and adopt the proposed solution and sustain it
afterwards. Implementing a solution that the client cannot reasonably adopt and sustain will lead to the
creation of value followed by the erosion of that value due to a lack of feasibility.
Conceptualize Evaluate Plan Decide
Conceptualize Evaluate Plan Decide
Clients Readiness to Change
Clients Ability to Preserve Value
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 45
Throughout the engagement, understanding the client’s readiness to change and ability to sustain a
proposed change is critical. If a client cannot implement a proposed change, it is unlikely that an action
proposal will achieve the intended results. Further, if the client cannot sustain a change after it has
been implemented, the value created will be temporary and a reversion to the former state is likely.
Implementing a solution that is not feasible will lead to the failure of corrective action and a relapse back to
the original state. Action Proposals must be feasible to both implement and sustain by the client.
What are some ways you can evaluate ideas to determine which ideas you will pursue further
and which you will not? How do you involve the team in this decision-making?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 46
10.2. TOOLS & TECHNIQUES IN ACTION PLANNING
A summary of common tools and techniques is provided here. In addition, you will find several videos in
your online resources folder as part of the course which demonstrate some of the tools and techniques.
Conceptual Thinking
Conceptual thinking enables the
consulting team and client to
envision a future and identifies
potential options in the present
which enable achieving it. This is a
creative thinking process that
relies on divergent thinking.
Affinity Analysis
Enables the consolidation of the
outputs of divergent thinking
exercises through grouping and
evaluation. The result are
potential solutions that represent
the best opportunity to address
the challenges faced by the client.
Scenario Planning
When developing options, it will
be necessary to plan for the
specific scenarios that may arise
as part of implementing that
option. Specific focus may be on
factors that would affect the
validity the options planned for.
Report Template
The Action Proposal Report
summarizes the alternatives,
preliminary implementation
information, and a recommended
path forward. A template may be
available for you to use if you are
within a firm.
Brainstorming
Removes judgement and enables
the team to develop as many ideas
as possible regarding potential
solutions. Supports divergent
thinking and is often followed by
affinity analysis to consolidate
outcomes.
6 Thinking Hats
Participants are assigned a hat
which defines their thinking and
role in idea evaluation. For
example, Yellow seeks
advantages and benefits, while
black may assume a critical role.
Breakthrough Thinking
Uses seven principles of creative
problem solving to drive creativity.
Focuses on either a brilliant idea,
significantly better results, or
incubating a good idea to improve
a current state.
Estimation
Action proposals will need to be
estimated. For example, what
might the expected cost be,
resources required, and time
needed
Cost Benefit Analysis
Enables the evaluation of various
options as an input into decision
making based on the cost and
expected benefit. It is important
to also consider the opportunity
cost of a specific course of action,
not just the cost of doing it.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 47
10.3. DIVERGENT & CONVERGENT THINKING
Whereas Diagnosis focused on collecting, analyzing, and synthesizing data, Action Planning requires
more conceptual skills. There will be times that you engage in divergent and exploratory thinking, and
other times when you must evaluate and eliminate outputs from that exploration.
Figure 8 - Example of divergent and convergent thinking
It is important to ensure that divergent and convergent thinking in workshop settings is well-facilitated.
Teams can easily lose focus during divergent conversations and a good facilitator will ensure that
exploration occurs and that the transition to convergent thinking occurs so that a decision can be made.
There are many ways to approach creative thinking, and all include some form of divergent and
convergent thinking which seeks to expand the exploration of ideas and eventually bring them to a state
where they can be evaluated. Creative thinking focuses on connecting ideas and things that were
previously unrelated. As you can imagine, this is critical to developing options based on the analysis of
data from Diagnosis
Identify the
Problems
Select the
Right
Problem
Identify
Possible
Solutions
Select
Solutions
Diverge
Diverge
Converge
Converge
Decide!
Decide!
Give an example of a facilitation technique you might use to ensure divergent thinking stays
focused and within the time allotted during a workshop?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 48
10.4. CONCEPTUALIZE: DEVELOPING OPTIONS & ALTERNATIVES
The nature of strategic challenges or opportunities means there is often no single recommendation that
will be sufficient. The consultant must define multiple alternatives. Generally, the more complex the
problem or opportunity, the greater the number of potential alternatives. Conceptualization challenges
the client and consultant to generate as many salient alternatives as possible.
When generating options, consider:
What the new solution must achieve for the client?
How will the future differ from the present?
Will the effects of the change last?
Where might alternatives be found?
What challenges may occur? Opportunities?
Which stakeholders will be impacted and how?
What is the best time for the change to occur?
10.5. EVALUATE: EVALUATING THE ALTERNATIVES
It is not feasible to fully define all conceptualized options in preparation for evaluation. As a result, pre-
selection is necessary. How many ideas you retain for further definition is a judgement call; however,
you may wish to consider constraints such as information available, timelines, and effort available from
both you and the client. Client involvement is key during preliminary evaluation as they can provide
commentary on the feasibility and internal capabilities to support a proposed action. Options coming
out of evaluation will be planned and defined at a more detailed level.
When eliminating options, consider:
Relevancy to the findings of Diagnosis.
Feasibility of implementing the option.
Feasibility of sustaining the option after implementation.
Readiness of the client to adopt the changes.
Constraints which may eliminate the option. For example, schedule, cost, and resource
availability.
Potential undesirable impacts the option may generate.
Risk of the option and the tolerance of the client to risk.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 49
10.6. PLAN: DEFINING THE PRELIMINARY PLANS
In preparing the plans that will be associated with your final proposals, it is important to understand
what criteria is most important to the client and the success of the engagement. For example, cost,
urgency, risk tolerance, resources etc. You may find yourself in the situation where there are more
alternatives remaining than time to properly build out plans, estimates, and other information.
Consider understanding what level of detail the client desires and negotiating the needed time to meet
those expectations.
Also, remember that it is not unusual to return to evaluation. The number of options considered for
planning may be too great to feasibly accomplish in the engagement. Some options may be eliminated
or consolidated through affinity analysis.
Each Action Proposal should include:
Principal recommendations and supporting secondary actions.
Prioritization. High, medium, low for the recommendations.
The client’s readiness to adopt and sustain the change.
Estimated costs, benefits, and schedule. May include major milestones.
Financial and human resource requirements.
Role of the consultant in implementation.
Primary risks to be aware of for each recommendation.
Assumptions made which must remain true.
Critical Success Factors that must be in place to enable the option to be successful.
10.7. DECIDE: DECIDING WHAT ACTION TO TAKE
The presentation to the client will summarize the proposed actions and the supporting information
available. In addition, the Action Proposals Report is provided to the client and outlines key information
on the various proposals and may include a recommendation from the consultant.
The level of detail will vary based on the complexity of the engagement and involvement of the client. It
is common to submit a formal report summarizing the information and providing greater detail and
rationale. The presentation is likely to spark conversation and inquiry. While this can be challenging, it
is a sign of engagement. It would be wise to prepare for anticipated questions which may include:
How did you arrive at the recommendations made? Who was involved?
What were some of the alternatives you considered that are not included?
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 50
Why were there only X options presented? Are there not more?
If you were me (client), what would you do?
What are the assumptions you are making?
Do the recommendations made prepare us for the future? Will they last?
The client’s response to the Action Proposals can provide valuable information and inform readiness to
change. Watch for the following signals:
Disagreement on the problem to be addressed. May indicate a lack of alignment and
insufficient engagement early in the consulting process.
Lack of convergence on a specific Action Proposal by stakeholders. May indicate a lack
of emerging consensus which risks leading to indecision.
Sticker shock on the duration and/or cost of the Action Proposals. May indicate that
the Action Proposals are not feasible.
Immediate acceptance. There should be some level of constructive discussion. This
may indicate lack of engagement.
10.8. THE ACTION PROPOSALS REPORT
You will likely produce a report that summarized the Action Proposals and supporting information. In
addition, a presentation to review and discuss the report is also probable. Although the format may
vary, the following would be considered the minimum to include in an Action Proposal Report:
Executive Summary
Summary of the engagement’s purpose and the problem to be addressed. You may wish to
emphasize the outputs from Diagnosis.
Statement regarding the code of conduct and commitment to public, client, profession and
pragmatism.
Purpose of Action Planning and approach undertaken including stakeholders, techniques used,
and rationale for the recommendations to be presented.
Section reviewing each Action Proposal and containing the information found on slide 19.
Ensure that each recommendation you make is defensible to the client using pragmatic
information and analysis. To make a recommendation without supporting evidence is
simply giving an opinion and is contrary to the code of conduct.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 51
A specific recommendation, if applicable.
Next steps including the decision on which Action Proposal to pursue and next steps upon that
decision being made.
Appendices which may provide additional backup information to Action Proposals.
At the conclusion of Action Planning, the client must decide what course of action will be taken. This is a
challenging moment for the client as the reality of situation becomes clear and the work to address it
becomes known. This can also be a challenging moment for you, the consultant. The client may not
accept your recommendations, may not be ready to decide and invest in the change, or may not have
the risk appetite to act. The following should be done to help make the decision-making process
smoother:
Involve the Client Early: Involving the client throughout the entire consulting process is key.
The client will understand the information and findings emerging early and be more prepared to
act. Ensure the client knows a decision will be required at some point soon.
Know the Culture: Understanding the client’s culture is key to navigating an engagement, but
especially so during decision making. Understanding who influences decision making, how
decisions are made, and other factors such as whether the client is decisive or slow to decide
will also be helpful.
Know the Decision-Maker: Often there is one person making the decision; however, they may
do so collaboratively. Understanding how the decision will be made, by who, their risk
tolerance, speed of decision making, and who they may gather input from will be key to framing
the recommendations appropriately.
Assuming the client wishes to move forward by accepting one of the action proposals, a more detailed
plan will be required. This is a natural opportunity to revisit the original consulting agreement and
consider changes given the new information that is available. As such, a potential return to the entry
stage may be required at this point.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 52
10.9. CODE OF CONDUCT DURING THE ACTION PLANNING STAGE
The Action Planning stage can present some difficult challenges as you take the outcome of Diagnosis
and formalize Action Proposals that will challenge the client to commit to a specific course of action:
Due Care: Ensure expectations are managed and do not set unrealistic expectations that the
client may not actually realize after implementation.
Business Development: Be mindful when quantifying benefits that they are based on data and
not opinion. Ensure you are putting the public and client first and not the firm.
Informed Client: The client should be informed of risks, assumptions, and benefits prior to
making a decision. Ensure appropriate detail and data are provided to the client.
Objectivity: Be mindful of contaminating recommendations with your own emotions and
desires. Remain pragmatic and objective to ensure you provide sound advice.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 53
11. WEEK 4: HOMEWORK
Please complete the following before our next class:
Each group will prepare a maximum 10-minute presentation summarizing the action proposals
you would make based on the information in the case study. Please include the following:
Summary of the engagement’s purpose and the problem to be addressed. You may
wish to emphasize the outputs from Diagnosis and their relationship to the information
to be presented from the action planning stage.
Statement regarding the Code of Conduct and commitment to the public, the client, the
profession, and pragmatism.
Purpose of Action Planning and approach undertaken including stakeholders,
techniques used, and rationale for the recommendations to be presented.
Section reviewing each Action Proposal and containing the following information:
Three principal recommendations and supporting secondary actions.
Assessment of the client’s readiness to adopt and sustain the change for each
recommendation.
Estimated financial, time and human resource requirements.
One risk to be mindful of for each recommendation.
One assumption that must remain true for each recommendation.
One key critical success factor for each recommendation.
Of the three Action Proposals you presented, select one recommendation to would
advocate for and establish your rationale for that recommendation. Include in this a
high-level schedule of key milestones.
Next steps including the decision on which Action Proposal to pursue and next steps
upon that decision being made.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 54
12. MANAGING THE ENGAGEMENT
Successfully navigating an engagement presents its own challenges and opportunities for both the
consultant and the client. The complexity increases at this point as the engagement shifts from
analyzing, synthesizing, and developing options to applying those changes in a context where there are
real impacts.
In this section we will focus on the management of change and the management of the project. We will
cover some of the foundational concepts within change and project management; however, not dive
deeply into each one. While we will discuss various approaches, there are many alternatives which can
provide value beyond what is covered here.
12.1. PREPARING FOR AND ENABLING CHANGE
In management consulting, every assignment is a change assignment. Understanding and navigating
change is key to effective management consulting. To achieve the desired outcomes of the client,
changes to the organization will be necessary. Bridging today with tomorrow and ensuring that bridge is
successfully crossed is critical. To effectively navigate change you will need to be familiar with several
key areas:
Process of Change: Understanding the types of changes that can be experienced and their
relationships to challenges with change.
Individual Reactions to Change: Support from members of the organization will be key to
making the change last. People must understand and be willing to participate in the change
during and after the transition.
Models of Change: Models of change provide various approaches to maximize the probability
that change will be supported and sustained. We will explore several of these; however, there
are a wide variety available.
Elements of Effective Change: Critical success factors that must be in place for change to
effectively occur. The absence of one of these factors will impact the probability of a successful
transition and sustainment of the changed state.
Readiness to Change: Not all client organizations are able to implement and sustain a proposed
change. Being aware of the readiness to change and feasibility of sustaining it is a key question
throughout an engagement.
Organizational change will generally fall into three categories which define the magnitude, impact, and
challenges that will be encountered.
Developmental: Understanding the types of changes that can be experienced and their
relationships to challenges with change.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 55
Transitional: Support from members of the organization will be key to making the change last.
People must understand and be willing to participate in the change during and after the
transition.
Transformational: Models of change provide various approaches to maximize the probability
that change will be supported and sustained. We will explore several of these; however, there
are a wide variety available.
Some engagements may have multiple layers of change that are required. Generally, the more complex
and significant the change, the more likely that more than one type of change is needed. This will
increase the complexity and need to manage change.
12.1.1. INDIVIDUAL REACTIONS TO CHANGE
No matter the change required to achieve the client’s desired outcomes, success will depend on the
decisions made by individual stakeholders. Reactions to change will vary based on the type of change
being pursued and it is critical to understand the impact a proposed change may or will have on
stakeholders inside and outside the organization. Neglecting the individual impacts of change will
introduce substantial risk to the engagement. This can be a frequently under-estimated component of
an engagement unless it is emphasized as being a priority.
Figure 9 - Difficult and durations of change based on type
Change challenges individuals to alter their work methods, behaviours, attitudes, and competency. This
includes those at the leadership level. For change to be effective across the enterprise, individuals must
adapt their knowledge, attitudes, and behaviours. Individuals must clearly understand the future state
and be able to envision their efficacy within it.
Knowledge
Attitudes
Individual Behaviour
Organizational / Group Behaviour
Long
High
Duration
Difficulty
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 56
Stakeholders can respond to potential changes in various ways including excitement and support;
however, a more challenging response is resistance to the change. Some common sources of change
resistance include:
Fear of the Unknown: General fear of the unknown and what the change actually means. Can
be addressed through communication and connecting today with the future state.
Perception of Loss: Emotional attachment to the current state. Change is perceived to create a
loss. For example, a changed process the individual person designed.
Change Fatigue: Occurs in organizations where there have been multiple large changes.
Emotional exhaustion can lead to apathy and reduce support for changes in the organization.
Inadequacy: Concern that the stakeholder may not be able to perform in the changed future.
Can be addressed through training and knowledge development.
Loss of Power / Influence: Changes in structures, reporting, or job duties may result in the
individual feeling a loss of power or influence. Potential to mobilize other stakeholders to resist
change.
Fear of Job Loss: Pre-occupies an individual’s mental space, leading to anxiety and distraction.
Careful communication must be made to provide facts regarding potential impacts.
Lack of Trust: A lack of trust in the sponsoring leader who is moving the changes forward. May
also not trust the process.
Lack of Belief: Does not believe the organization is truly committed or able to execute on the
changes. May be caused by previous failures.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 57
New Ways of Doing Things: General discomfort with changing how things are done. “We’ve
always done it this way. Benefits of change should be emphasized.
12.1.2. MODELS OF CHANGE
There are many models of change available today; however, we will discuss several common ones which
have generally formed the foundation of other models.
The Kotter model of change describes an eight-step process through which successful change is made
possible.
Step 1: Create Urgency: Urgency is critical to ensuring motivation to change is established.
Using internal and external reasons, ensures that opportunities and threats are defined and a
rationale communicated.
Step 2: Establish a Guiding Coalition: A coalition of stakeholders that has the authority to lead
the change and support each other and their colleagues through it. Key to this is providing the
team with the authority to make things happen.
For many individuals, change is an emotional process. Be mindful
of this as you navigate the engagement. Empathy is important.
Create
Urgency
Establish
Guiding
Coalition
Develop
Vision &
Strategy
Share Vision
of Change Empower
Action Get Quick
Wins Leverage
Wins Integrate
Change
Figure 10 - Kotter Model of Change - Adapted from Kotter, J.P., Leading Change (2012) Harvard Business Review Press, p. 23
Some clients may need to be convinced that change management is an important area to invest
in. How would you justify the need for change management focus with such a client?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 58
Step 3: Develop the Vision & Strategy: Developing the vision is a key step in creating alignment
and intention on the change. Supporting the vision are strategies that will help see its eventual
realization.
Step 4: Share of the Vision of Change: Involves the constant communication and
reinforcement of the vision and strategies. The guiding coalition plays a key role in ensuring
that the sharing of the vision reaches all stakeholders.
Step 5: Empower Action: Enablement of action involves changing the systems and structures
that restrict the change. This involves removing obstacles and encouraging non-traditional ideas
and ways of doing.
Step 6: Get Quick Wins: Sustaining momentum can be difficult when change is gradual and
over a longer period. Highlighting early wins and converting those successes into excitement
creates positive momentum and grows credibility.
Step 7: Leverage Wins to Build Momentum: Leverages wins to create credibility and
momentum towards the desired vision. Involves promoting individuals who support the change
and re-energizing new projects as part of implementation.
Step 8: Integrate the Change: The changes are integrated into the operation of the
organization. Behaviours are established and reinforced through the creation of new norms,
processes, and systems.
Lewin’s model of change is a second foundation approach. Lewin’s model of change is based on
three stages that involves opening the organization to change, applying the change, and integrating
the change. Although developed in 1947, it has endured as the foundation to many change
management approaches.
Figure 11 - Lewin's Model of Change - Cummings, S., Bridgman, T., Brown, K.G. Unfreezing change as
three steps: Rethinking Kurt Lewin’s legacy for change management 2016, Vol., 69(I) pp. 33 - 60
Step 1: Unfreeze: This is where the need for change is identified. Many sources may be found
within SWOT or PESTLE frameworks. The unfreezing ultimately creates the sense of urgency
needed to compel individuals to change.
Step 2: Change: During change, the organization communicates the reasons for change and
begins implementing corrective actions that address the reason for change. Internalization of
the changes into individual behaviours and beliefs begins hardening the change.
Unfreeze Change Re-Freeze
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 59
Step 3: Re-Freeze: The organization has integrated the change and the change becomes “how
we do things here. Team members see confirmation that their changes behaviours meet
expectations and reinforcement is provided.
12.1.3. CRITICAL SUCCESS FACTORS IN CHANGE
Change is a complex process and there are many factors that can together create risks and issues that
may affect the engagement. There are several success factors that when in place, can support a smooth
transition for a client organization. While it may seem obvious that change management is critical,
some clients may not share the same perspective. Be prepared to advocate for change management to
be a priority and demonstrate its value.
Clear and Compelling Reason to Change
Provides a focus for the organization and describes what is being pursued and why.
Communicates the risks and responsibilities involved in the change.
Should be delivered by the leadership within the client and not the consultant.
Engagement of Stakeholders
Defining the rationale and vision for change is a good place to begin engaging
stakeholders.
Identifying and enabling change agents can give empowerment to stakeholders.
Critical to this is gaining the support of the middle layer of the organization. Failure to
create support here can lead to lack of alignment between the frontline workers and the
intentions of leadership.
Communication and Education
Recall our discussion on the challenges experienced by affected stakeholders.
Providing information and frequent communication will help ensure stakeholders are
equipped with facts, not rumours and hearsay.
Education is critical to connecting efficacy in the current state with perceived efficacy in
the future state.
12.1.4. ASSESSING READINESS TO CHANGE
Assessing the client’s readiness to change may seem subjective; however, there are questions to
consider which will help pragmatically inform your assessment. Key to this is understanding how much
change an organization can absorb while pursuing the desired outcomes.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 60
A low readiness to change may not mean the project does not move forward. Consider staging the
implementation in a way that builds readiness to change. The challenge may be implementing the
change within the constraints of time, budget, and scope.
Change is rarely uniform. Understanding the readiness to change from the perspective of various
stakeholders is key. Those stakeholders with a low readiness for change may require more support than
others.
Some factors you will want to consider when assessing readiness to change include:
Urgency and importance of the change being considered.
Is the need to change reactive, proactive, or critical?
Are there other change efforts underway that may lead to fatigue?
Are there sufficient financial and human resources to make the change happen and sustain it
afterwards?
Is there sponsorship and support from the executive leadership?
Is the change uniform or will specific stakeholder groups be more affected than others?
Are the costs and benefits compelling?
How will the changes being implemented interact with one another?
Are the right structures in place? For example, communication channels, change champions,
training.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 61
12.2. PROJECT MANAGEMENT OVERVIEW
Knowledge of project management is a critical factor in ensuring the success of the engagement. A
management consultant must be able to select the appropriate project approach, build and estimate a
plan, and execute the plan to ensuring the engagement is stewarded towards a successful conclusion.
To effectively see the project through to completion, you will need to be familiar with several key areas:
Approaches to Project Management: Various approaches to project management exist ranging
from traditional waterfall to agile iterative based.
The Consulting Approach and Relationship to Project Management: Explore the relationship
between the project management approach and the engagement approach, highlighting the
integration of both.
Building and Estimating the Plan: Explore the key components of the project plan and how
each relates to one another. Define various approach to estimating project components.
Executing the Plan: Key components to be aware of during execution including how to monitor
and manage the project towards completion.
Challenges in Project Management: Discuss key challenges found within project management
and determine potential ways to reduce the risk of them impacting the project.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 62
12.2.1. IMPLEMENTING CHANGE THROUGH PROJECTS
The relationship of project management to desired outcomes of clients is key to executing on strategy
and integrating changes into operations.
Figure 12 - Relationship between strategy, performance, and change - Adapted from PMI, PMOBK 7th
Edition 2020 p. 11
To be of value, all change must be connected to the objective of the organization and support their
realization. When the enterprise strategy is developed, it is cascaded into the organization such that
performance of the organization is enabled by alignment. Each portfolio within the executive team is
assigned objectives that must be met for the organization to realize the enterprise strategy. To do so,
programs and projects are created to enable new performance within the operations. Once projects
and programs are complete, their outputs are operationalized enabling the performance of routine work
processes.
Operational activities then generate operational data which is reported upward into benefits realization
and program/project performance data. This data then in-turn informs the performance of each
portfolio and, when aligned and connected to the overall enterprise strategy, enables measurement of
the strategy and the progress towards its realization.
Executive
Leadership Enterprise
Portfolios Programs &
Projects Operational
Activities
Enterprise Strategy Desired Outcomes Operationalization
Operational Data
Program/Project
Performance
Portfolio Performance
Enterprise Performance Information
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 63
12.2.2. APPROACHES TO PROJECT MANAGEMENT
Projects may be executed in various ways. While traditionally predictive projects have largely been used
in management consulting, adaptive project approaches are increasingly being used as a means of
producing early value for clients.
Figure 13 - Level of Incrementation & Iteration between Predictive & Adaptive Projects
In predictive projects, there is a focus on up-front planning and needs analysis. Once the needs are well-
known, the project begins executing on addressing those needs monitoring progress against several
baselines. Value is generated during a single event near the conclusion of the project when the change
is applied in a short period of time and then integrated into operations.
Works well for projects where the requirements and needs can be defined early, and with good
reliability.
Large investments with high risk are also suitable for this approach.
Scope, schedule, costs, and resourcing are defined early to reduce the level of uncertainty.
Performance is monitored and reported based off the established baseline.
Predictive Adaptive
Level of Incrementation & Iteration
Defining Planning Executing
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 64
Adaptive approaches to project management focus on the incremental creation of value with an
emphasis on collaboration and stakeholder accountability. Whereas predictive projects may see change
as undesirable, adaptive project see change as inevitable and put in place mechanisms to leverage it.
Each sprint lasts a maximum of four weeks after which a minimum viable product is produced and
reviewed with stakeholders for feedback. After a fixed number of sprints, the project is expected to
conclude.
Works well for projects where there is a high level of uncertainty in the needs.
Implementation is adapted based on stakeholder input and feedback.
Planning and execution occur in small sprints producing incremental value using a backlog of
requirements.
Estimation is done at the sprint level incrementally.
Sprint Planning
Needed
Feature
Needed
Feature
Needed
Feature
Sprint Planning
Needed
Feature
Needed
Feature
Needed
Feature
Requirements
Execution
.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 65
12.2.3. THE PROJECT MANAGEMENT PROCESS
Project management uses a series of process groups regardless of the project approach selected. It is
important to note that although the process groups are presented as sequential, they interact with one
another throughout all stages of the project.
Initiating: Initiating is where the project is given formal authorization to proceed. A key
deliverable of this process is the Approved Project Charter.
Planning: Planning is where stakeholders and the project team compile a feasible plan. It
includes scope, schedule, resource, and financial plans. The kick-off meeting is held.
Executing: The work defined in planning is executed by the project team. This process group
generated performance data which is used by Monitoring & Controlling.
Monitoring and Controlling: Performance data is used to measure progress and identify
required corrective actions. Changes to approved plans are reviewed and a decision made.
Closing: The project is formally concluded, and lessons learned are documented. Performance
data is reviewed, and benefits realization are measured.
Initiating
Planning
Executing
Closing
Figure 14 - Project Management Process - Adapted from PMP Exam Prep 9th Edition, 2018, RMC
Publications, p. 63
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 66
The project approach is closely related to the consulting approach you selected to address the needs of
the client. Although the phases are different, they are related. Also, the Project Management Approach
may repeat itself throughout the stages of the consulting process. Recall our “Return to Entry
discussion as part of Action Planning, for example. During this stage you may need to properly estimate
and plan for Implementation depending on the Action Proposal accepted.
Figure 15 - Example to demonstrate how the consulting approach and the project management process
align.
12.2.4. BUILDING THE PLAN
Depending on the project approach selected, building the plan will vary. Adaptive projects apply smaller
planning cycles with greater frequency. Predictive projects invest more heavily in planning up-front.
The goal of the planning process group is to create a plan that is realistic and acceptable to stakeholders
involved and achieves the desired outcomes.
The information provided here shares key areas of planning. There are additional areas proper project
management will require you consider. When planning, you will want to consider several variables that
will affect your approach to planning:
The project approach. Is it predictive, adaptive, or a combination?
Project deliverables required.
Policies, procedures, and cultural norms.
Market conditions that may affect the validity of the project’s purpose.
Legal or regulations constraints that may limit options or actions.
When these items are understood clearly, you can begin more detailed planning in preparation for
implementation. This will include the following key areas:
The reason for the project.
Ensure stakeholder outcomes and requirements are understood.
Define the project scope and ensure it is connected to the reason for initiating the project.
Entry Diagnosis Action Planning Implementation Termination
Initiating
Planning
Executing
Closing
Initiating
Planning
Executing
Closing
Initiating
Planning
Executing
Closing
Initiating Closing
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 67
Using high-level deliverables, decompose the deliverables into smaller units. You may use a
Work Breakdown Structure for more complex projects.
Develop the project schedule and supporting activities including duration and dependencies.
Develop the project budget and related contingency funds.
Estimate the resources required to execute. This may include human resources and capital such
as technology.
Develop the communications plan. Ensure this is integrated to the change management plan, if
applicable.
Define how changes to the project management plan will be managed. For example, a change
request process.
Define how the project’s performance will be monitored and reported.
Estimating the plan occurs when you develop the preliminary plan as part of your Action Proposals and
occurs again during Implementation when the plan is further built out. Estimation normally involves a
decomposition of the project deliverables into specific inputs of input that are then estimated and
rolled-up, for example. All estimates share a common set of elements that together inform the
reliability of the estimate.
Range: At the start of the project the range may be broad and open to deviation. As the project
progresses, the range becomes more accurate due to greater information being available.
Accuracy: Accuracy is how close the estimation and actual performance are. Closely related to
the range, estimates early in the project will be less reliable than those later in the project.
Precision: Relates to how precise the estimate is; however, is not the same as accuracy. For
example, a cost estimate of between $1,000 and $10,000 is less precise than $1,000 - $5,000
Confidence: Confidence increases with greater experience in similar projects. If the client and
the engagement team have little experience, confidence may be lower.
Estimating should be carefully done and be proportional to the work being
estimated. Clients will associate estimates with their expectations and
poor estimates will lead to defeated expectations.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 68
12.3. LEADERSHIP IN THE ENGAGEMENT
In many consulting engagements, you will be dependent on a team and the team will be dependent
upon you. To be successful, you must influence your team and the client as you navigate the various
stages of the consulting project. Be especially careful to be self-aware during periods of high intensity
on an engagement. Natural styles can become dominant and may not always support constructive
relationships and progress.
Self-Awareness: Each of us has strengths and weaknesses. Being aware of our limitations and
conduct when engaging in the profession of management consulting is key. We are faced with
many situations that require tack, diplomacy, and honesty.
Influence: Management consultants will rarely have authority, even over their own consulting
team. Being able to build support, credibility, and motivation through influencing is key. This is
especially critical when working with clients.
Coaching: Working with the client and the consulting team to improve their own confidence
and capabilities is important. Being able to coach through inquiry will help others improve their
self-awareness, confidence, and performance.
Feedback: Feedback is core to consulting. You may need to provide constructive feedback to a
team member or the client. Also, be open to receiving feedback and improving yourself. Be
appropriate when and how you share feedback.
Why would a consulting engagement require leadership? How is leading an engagement
different than managing an engagement?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 69
13. WEEK 5: HOMEWORK
Please complete the following before our next class:
Read the following case study material:
EMC Case Study 5 Action Planning Email Canadian Craft Brewers Association
Each group will prepare a maximum 10-minute presentation summarizing change management
and project management approaches that will be used to implement the option you
recommended from action planning. Please include the following:
Summary of the selected project management approach and explanation for this
decision.
An assessment on the organization’s readiness to change and what factors were
considered in making this assessment. Explanation of how the implementation plan
acknowledges this and seeks to address it.
A more detailed project schedule that includes updated milestones (if applicable) and a
financial estimate. Explanation of considerations made in arriving at these estimates.
Description of how progress will be monitored and measured and how the client will be
kept informed of progress.
Summary of top three critical success factors from a project management and change
management perspective.
Top three risks and top three assumptions underlying the plan.
Next steps.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 70
14. STAGE 4: IMPLEMENTATION
The implementation stage is where the accepted
action proposal is implemented in an attempt to
change the situation and achieve the desired
outcome for the client. The role of the client and
the role of the consultant may change during
implementation when compared to previous
stages. Here, the client may take greater
ownership as the expertise the client has about the
organization is used to guide the implementation
and integration of changes into the client organization.
The consultant may take on a support-orientated role or may oversee the tactical implementation of the
change. This is often dependent on experience of the consultant and the capabilities of the client.
Clients with low capabilities in project management and change management may require greater
support than those with established project and change management practices.
14.1. IMPLEMENTATION: OBJECTIVES, INPUTS, AND OUTPUTS
The purpose of the implementation stage is to support the client in implemented the accepted action
proposal(s). The level of involvement from the consultant may change based on the capabilities of the
client.
Inputs
§Accepted Action Proposal.
§Feedback regarding selected
Action Proposal.
§Preliminary Implementation
Plan associated with the
accepted Action Proposal.
Activities
§Integrate feedback into
recommendations and
planning.
§Contract for the
implementation stage.
§Plan and implement tasks and
processes such as project and
change management.
§Monitor and control the
implementations
performance.
Outputs
§Implementation of changes
that address the desired
outcomes of the client.
Support the client in implementing change that will achieve the desired outcomes.
Adapted from the Common Body of Knowledge, CMC-Canada, 2009, pp. 28 - 31
Adapted from Kubr, M., Management Consulting: A guide to the profession (2017) pp. 229 - 244
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 71
Without implementation, the consulting process is not considered complete. A client may not accept
the recommendations made and not proceed with implementation. This is the outcome of poor
management during the engagement by both the client and the consultant. When there is sufficient
collaboration and engagement with the client, there are few reasons that one of the recommendations
put forward should not be implemented.
14.2. TOOLS & TECHNIQUES IN IMPLEMENTATION
A summary of common tools and techniques is provided here. There are many tools, techniques, and
templates available for implementation. The scope of this course is not to cover these in detail, but you
are encouraged to reference external professional bodies where this detail may be found.
Project Charter
The project charter formally
authorizes the project. It has
scope, risks, schedule, costs,
resourcing and desired outcomes
defined at a high-level.
Information Mgt.
Defining information management
ensures that the team can easily
put and find documentation and
information during the
engagement. This avoids the
issues caused by improper
versioning and organization.
Training & Development
Anxiety about the changed future
can grow. Training supports
stakeholders in seeing how they
can be efficacious in the future
state. Training should be
reinforced to ensure knowledge is
applied and retained.
Templates
You may use various templates
during this stage. Larger clients
may have defined processes and
templates you must use. Others
may depend on you to bring these
tools as part of the engagement.
Communication Plan
Ensuring stakeholders are
informed, educated, and engaged
in the implementation. The
Communication Plan is also closely
related to the Change
Management Plan.
Gantt Chart
Show planned activities, their
dependencies, timing, and effort
requirements in a visual format.
Adaptive project may use a
backlog and spring planning rather
than a Gantt Chart.
Monitoring & Control
Utilizes performance data from
the project to monitor progress
against an established plan.
Requested changes are reviewed
and approved/denied and
communicated back to
stakeholders.
Change Mgt. Plan
Used to define a process through
which change will be managed. It
may detail stakeholders groups,
their readiness for change, how
their readiness will be improved
and integrated. Closely related to
the Communications Plan.
Knowledge Transfer
Ensuring that the client builds the
capabilities to support the change
and preserve value is key. This can
involve coaching, training, and
directly involving the client in the
implementation.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 72
14.3. THE ROLE OF THE CONSULTANT IN IMPLEMENTATION
The ultimate responsibility for the implementation of the
changes is with the client, not the consultant. Clearly
defining the role of the consultant and the role of the
client in implementation is key to ensuring that
accountabilities are clear, and roles are defined.
Depending on the needs of the client and their ability to
implement the changes, a new contract will likely be
required when the consultant will continue to be part of
implementation.
The case for involving the consultant in implementation may be strong when:
The client lacks the technical ability to implement the changes without support.
The implementation is complex and requires experience and expertise not available to the client
internally.
The client may not understand how to navigate changes during implementation and how those
changes impact the implementation plan.
The client may engage the consultant in various ways during implementation. The consultant
may:
Assist with more complex tasks
Provide oversight and guidance
Provide the entire implementation team
Only become involved at the request of the client.
The case for excluding the consultant in implementation may be strong when:
The challenge being addressed has low complexity and can be addressed procedurally.
The consultant and client agree that the client is able to implement the changes based on
demonstrated capability throughout diagnosis and action planning.
The client is ultimately
accountable for the
implementation of the changes.
Be cautious of contracting with
clients where the accountability
may be re-assigned to the
consultant. You may not have the
authority necessary to implement.
When cost is a concern, be flexible. Coaching, decision support,
and other arrangements can still allow the consultant to support
the client, while respecting the cost constraint.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 73
14.4. CONTRACTING AND IMPLEMENTATION
Depending on the needs of the client and their ability to implement the changes, a new contract will
likely be required when the consultant will continue to be part of implementation. There are important
considerations when undertaking this.
Clearly Defined Roles: The roles and responsibilities between the client, consultant, and team
members for each must be clearly defined. The consultant should never accept accountability
over implementation as the authority necessary may not be available. The client must own the
outcomes.
Measure Success: Being clear about what success looks like and how it will be measured it
important. Be mindful that a consultant should not commit to outcomes where there is no
direct control. Poorly defined success measures can make closing the engagement difficult.
Duration and Cost: The preliminary plan associated with the proposed action will need to be
decomposed into more reliable duration and cost estimates. If cost is a concern, the consultant
should consider arrangements that are more flexible and continue to support implementation.
14.5. PUTTING THE PLAN INTO ACTION
The Implementation stage is where the expectations established throughout the engagement meet with
the reality of the situation. For stakeholders, this is the stage when the realization that change will be
happening is made and being able to communicate and support that change becomes critical.
Initiating:
Project charter is approved along with preliminary plan.
Stakeholders are identified.
Relationship to organizational priorities is clear.
High-level milestones are known and scheduled.
Documentations such as risk, assumptions, and issues logs are created.
Planning:
Detailed planning is undertaken, and schedule, budget, and resource requirements are
defined.
Project team is assigned including client resources.
Various plans area created including communication, quality management, and change
control. These plans are integrated into the Project Plan and approved.
Formal kick-off meeting is held.
Be mindful to ensure the implementation plan is
feasible. There may be pressure to commit to impossible
dates and outcomes and this must be avoided.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 74
Monitoring the implementation enables the consultant and the client to determine whether the
implementation is performing at the expected level and according to the plan. It is not uncommon for
changes to be requested and these requests should be handled in a consistent manner.
Measuring Progress: Progress will generally be measured based on the schedule, budget,
quality, and scope. The baseline plans are compared against actual work performance data
which informs the progress made (or not made). This information can then inform corrective
action or possible changes to the baseline.
Measuring Engagement: Stakeholder engagement can be difficult to measure; however,
measuring progress on communication and change management activities can ensure
adherence to the plan. Lack of engagement may indicate that stakeholders are not bought in or
there may be issues to address.
Monitoring Risks: Risks are initially identified at the outset of implementation; however, the
probability and impact they have may shift during the implementation. As a result, it is
important to monitor risks so that appropriate mitigations strategies can be put in place for
those risks that are high-impact and high-probability.
It is not possible to predict the future with certainty. Changes will likely be requested at various points
through the implementation stage. It is important to have a defined process for how requested changes
are captured, reviewed, decided, and communicated.
The need for change can come from several sources. A problem may be more complex to resolve than
first anticipated, a vendor may be affected by supply chain issues requiring additional time to complete
a project, or significant new scope is needed to complete a project. In all these situations, a change
request is likely to be needed.
Once the need is identified, the requestor should be asked to submit a change request to the project for
evaluation and consideration. In doing this, the project may assess the impact on cost, duration, and
resourcing. Like action planning, options must be generated and evaluated. Once that is done, a
Need for Change
Identified Change Request
Submitted
Impact Assessed
Options Identified
Decision Made
Updates Completed
Inform Requestor
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 75
decision on the change request is made and the updates are implemented. It is important to ensure the
requestor is updated on the outcome of the change.
14.6. GROWING CAPABILITIES WITHIN THE CLIENT
Implementation occurs during a fixed duration; however, as the changes are integrated into operations,
the value created during implementation must be sustained by the client alone. Through change
management and knowledge sharing, the consultant can help the client preserve the value created and
sustain the changes after implementation.
Involving the Client in Implementation: Throughout the consulting process we have advocated
for the client to be involved. This becomes critical to implementation. Through involvement,
clients will learn tools and techniques which may assist them in sustaining the change after the
implementation is finished.
Training and Reinforcement: Training provides clients with the tactical knowledge necessary to
believe they will be effective in the change future. To ensure the knowledge is applied,
reinforcement will be necessary so that a reversion to former work methods does not occur.
Integrating Change into Operations: Understanding how the client currently performs their
work and integrating changes into that model will help ensure that the client is able to sustain
the changes after the implementation stage. If you are unable to integrate the changes into
operation, it is unlikely the implementation will be effective.
Supporting Tools and Processes: Providing support tools such as technology and
documentation will assist the client in delivering enablement to a wider group of stakeholders.
Defining processes and ensuring their continuous improvement will also support the client in
owning the changes.
Feedback and Coaching: Providing feedback through coaching will enable the client to practice
the change in a safe environment and gain confidence. This rehearsal and adjustment will help
the client understand where improvements are possible and pursue them.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 76
14.7. CODE OF CONDUCT DURING THE IMPLEMENTATION STAGE
Implementation will have many challenges and situations that will require you to conduct yourself in
compliance with the code of conduct. It is important to be aware of these situations to ensure proper
execution and management of the engagement.
Responsibility for Others: If additional team members are brought in to support
implementation, they are required to adhere to the Code of Conduct.
Due Care: As appropriate, stakeholders are involved in the implementation and their influence
does not adversely affect the pragmatism of the consultant.
Objectivity: Being involved in implementation, ensure you remain pragmatic and objective in
your guidance and decisions. Do not let implementation affect impartiality.
Informed Client: Ensuring that expectations are aligned with contractual commitments. A new
consulting contract is often required to reflect emergent needs.
Fee Arrangement: Fee arrangements are part of the new consulting contract, and the client is
informed of assumptions underlying them.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 77
15. STAGE 5: TERMINATION
The termination stage is when the consultant seeks to
make an orderly exit from the engagement. While is
normal for this to occur because an engagement is
ending with its purpose fulfilled, the consultant may
also exit an engagement part way through. In either
situation, it is important that any exit be orderly and
professional.
At the conclusion of an engagement, various artifacts
will be created including the termination report,
updates to consulting approaches, the financial
closure of the project, and the foundation for a future
relationship with the client.
It is also wise to acquire a reference from the client and document the engagement summary for use in
business development and marketing. Be mindful of confidentiality obligations when using engagement
summaries for business development and marketing purposes.
15.1. TERMINATION: OBJECTIVES, INPUTS, AND OUTPUTS
The purpose of termination is to bring an orderly close to the engagement. Several documents and
artifacts are produced as a result of the completed engagement, and internal consulting approaches
may be updated or improved.
Inputs
One of three possibilities:
§Implementation is complete
and the consultants role has
been fulfilled.
§Implementation is being
discontinued.
§Support from the consultant is
no longer required.
Activities
§Plan for an orderly withdrawal
from the engagement.
§Prepare the termination
report.
§Assess the performance of the
engagement.
§Update consulting approaches
and supporting templates.
§Financial closure of the
engagement.
§Grow the relationship and
identify further ways to help.
Outputs
§Report or presentation
summarizing the work
undertaken and the benefits
realized.
§Final billing is completed.
§Confirmation of client
references.
Professionally conclude the engagement and set the foundation for future work.
Adapted from the Common Body of Knowledge, CMC-Canada, 2009, pp. 32 - 35
Adapted from Kubr, M., Management Consulting: A guide to the profession (2017) pp. 245 - 257
Stage 1
Entry
Stage 2
Diagnosis
Stage 3
Action Planning
Stage 4
Implementation
Stage 5
Termination
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 78
15.2. TOOLS & TECHNIQUES IN TERMINATION
Termination focuses on the professional and complete ending of the engagement. As part of this,
various reports and information are exchanged to assess whether the engagement achieved the desired
outcomes and how the consultant can improve their future work. In addition, the consultant may
identify additional opportunities to add value to the client through a continued relationship.
Benefits Realization
Measurement of the benefits
realized as an outcome of the
engagement. This may be
completed by a party not involved
in the engagement. May also be
deferred to months after the
implementation.
Termination Report
The termination report
summarizes the engagement from
start to finish. It demonstrates the
work undertaken and the benefits
achieved.
Lessons Learned
The lessons learned summary
allows the consulting team and
the client to provide areas of
improvement and effectiveness.
This feedback allows the
consultant to make improvements
to approaches in the future.
Engagement Summary
If the consultant has a done a
satisfactory job for the client, the
client may provide a reference.
Engagement summaries help
demonstrate the consultants
record of good work and is used as
part of business development.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 79
What is the relationship between the entry stage and termination? What consequences may
emerge if these two stages are not aligned?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 80
15.3. PROFESSIONALLY EXITING AN ENGAGEMENT
Exiting the engagement in an orderly and professional manner is key to ensuring that the transition of
the consultant out of the engagement does not harm the client and leaves them feeling supported and
capable.
The following summarizes the key activities undertaken during the termination stage:
Prepare Termination Report: The termination report summarizes the engagement from start to
finish. It outlines the various stages of the engagement and the findings from each. Included
should be a summary of what was achieved and information on relevant next steps for the
client.
Assess Performance: Client and team feedback is elicited to determine the level of
performance during the engagement and whether the expected outcomes were achieved. The
client will also provide feedback which may help the consultant improve in the future.
Continuously Improve: Utilizing feedback from the client, stakeholders and the consulting
team, the consultant updates relevant artifacts such as approaches, tools, techniques, and
templates. Relevant internal records are also updated such as contacts and future needs
identified.
Perform Financial Closure: The final outstanding invoices and expenses are created and
provided to the client. The consultant will also review the financial performance of the
engagement to determine profitability, noting areas for improvement and efficiency in the
future.
Close Engagement: The consulting team will be released to their next engagements and the
records and documentation created and used are securely archived for future reference.
Disposition of information may also be required as part of confidentiality.
Celebrate Success: Showing appreciation to the consulting team and the client is key.
Recognizing the challenges and successes and thanking the client, stakeholders, and consulting
team provides an opportunity to end the engagement on a positive note.
Prepare
Termination
Report
Assess
Performance Continuously
Improve
Perform
Financial
Closure
Close
Engagement Celebrate
Success
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 81
15.4. CODE OF CONDUCT DURING THE IMPLEMENTATION STAGE
Although not a long stage, Termination will require you to be awareness of some key aspects of the
code of conduct.
Conflict: You may work with client stakeholders who may make for great consultants. Never
solicit client staff for employment without first discussing with the client.
Business Development: Inform the client of opportunities where you can be of further
assistance. Be mindful to only do this where there is a clear need and not to sell services for the
sake of selling.
Confidentiality: All client information is confidential, even the fact that they are a client.
Negotiate agreement from the client to provide a reference for future work.
Objectivity: It may be necessary to exit an engagement where the consultant’s objectivity is
impaired. Consider referral to another member in such a situation.
CMC-Canada Essentials of Management Consulting Course Learner Workbook 82
16. WEEK 6: HOMEWORK
Please complete the following before our next class:
Congratulations! There is no case study assignment.
Please complete and submit the reflective summary within seven days of the conclusion of the
course.