Subscriptions as a Revenue Model: Evolution, Comparisons, and the Impact of Generative AI PDF Free Download
1 / 15/15
100%
International Journal of Computer Trends and Technology Volume 72 Issue 12, 179-193, December 2024
ISSN: 2231–2803 / https://doi.org/10.14445/22312803/IJCTT-V72I12P122 © 2024 Seventh Sense Research Group®
This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)
Original Article
Subscriptions as a Revenue Model: Evolution,
Comparisons, and the Impact of Generative AI
Bihag Karnani
Product Manager, Google, New York, USA.
Corresponding Author : bk.product00@gmail.com
Received: 09 November 2024 Revised: 02 December 2024 Accepted: 20 December 2024 Published: 31 December 2024
Abstract - Since the emergence of Software as a Service (SaaS) and cloud computing, the subscription business model has
experienced a major shift. This paper accelerates the evolution of subscriptions, examining Business-to-Consumer (B2C) and
Business-to-Business (B2B) subscriptions, and explains how the structure of Generative AI (GenAI) product subscriptions is
affecting and changing the subscription landscape. It also recommends ways companies can improve customer lifetime value.
Keywords - Subscriptions, Revenue growth, Generative AI.
1. Introduction
The subscription business model, in which customers
pay a recurring fee for a product or service, has experienced
phenomenal growth in recent years, particularly with the
emergence of Software as a Service (SaaS) and cloud
computing.
When the origins of subscription models were studied,
influences across sectors and tactics to retain customers were
discovered1. Very few (if any) studies have examined how
emerging technologies such as Generative AI(GenAI)create
new challenges and opportunities for subscription business
models.
The rest of this paper will try to fill the gap by reviewing
the subscription model, its origins, the SaaS and cloud
computing trends, and the disruptive GenAI potential.
Additionally, the paper compares B2C & B2B subscription
business models, delves into their challenges, and shares
recommendations to help companies increase the lifetime
value of customers in the evolving subscription economy.
2. History of the Subscription Model
Although the subscription model feels modern and
digital, it has been around for centuries. The early origin of
subscriptions dates back to the 17th century when publishers
used subscriptions for books and periodicals [1]. This model
offered consumers constant access to new content while
allowing publishers to generate consistent income. Even
earlier, in the 18th century, “subscription coffee houses”
opened in England that charged patrons for access to books,
newspapers, and periodicals [3], emphasizing the social
component of early subscription models. During the
Industrial Revolution, services such as gas and electricity
became subscription-only [12] — an example of a
subscription model applied to essential services. With the rise
of the web and e-commerce in the mid-1990s came the
opening of another chapter in the history of subscription
models [23]. Bastions of early America online, such as AOL,
who charged a monthly fee for dial-up internet access [12]
were some of the first pioneers of what would evolve to be an
expansive digital subscription market that evolved into
today’s online subscription offerings. This evolution is
shown in a timeline (Table 1) of key milestones in
subscription model history.
Table 1. History and evolution of the subscription business model
17th-18th Century
19th Century:
Early-Mid 20th
Century:
2000s:
2010s:
2020s:
-Samuel Pepys
subscribed to
regular coffee
deliveries in
London (1660s)
-The Times
(London)
introduced
newspaper home
delivery
-Reader’s Digest
magazine launches
(1922)
-Disney’s “Movie
of the Month”
-iPod and
iTunes
revolutionize
digital music
(2001)
-Birchbox beauty
samples (2010)
-Dollar Shave
Club (2011)
-Adobe Creative
-Walmart+ (2020)
-Twitter Blue/X
Premium (2021)
-Meta Verified
(2023)
Bihag Karnani / IJCTT, 72(12), 179-193, 2024
180
3. Impact of SaaS and Cloud Computing
In the mid-2000s, SaaS sparked a whole new
subscription model thanks to the introduction of cloud
computing. SaaS is a method of software delivery that
provides customers with access to software and its functions
remotely as a web-based service [2]. This transition lowered
the entry barrier of high upfront costs and provided
automatic updates, also increasing accessibility for
companies, both large (enterprises) and small [8]. The
structure for SaaS was established with the development of
cloud computing, which brought cost-effective and scalable
infrastructure. This combination resulted in an explosion of
subscription-based software offerings, fundamentally
changing how companies and individuals access and
consume software. The subscription model itself has been
affected by cloud computing due to the multiple pricing
mechanisms that are offered. These are pay-per-use (PPU),
pay-for-result (PFR), leased-based, subscription-based and
dynamic pricing based on initial cost, lease period, quality
of service, age of resources and cost of maintenance. This
means that businesses have a wider variety of options when
it comes to what they offer as subscriptions.
SaaS and cloud computing have a major effect on
company agility. Cloud-based subscription models enable
businesses to scale resources rapidly, respond to shifting
market demands, and drive innovation. In the fast-paced
world of business we live in today, this flexibility is vital, as
organizations must conform to rapidly changing risks or
business opportunities.
When it comes to SaaS adoption, businesses face a
handful of considerable challenges; chief among them are
data privacy and dependence on the internet. These
challenges may have considerable financial repercussions for
the organizations.
3.1.1. Data Privacy Concerns
Data Privacy – SaaS adoption is marred with data privacy:
● In 2024, 31% of organizations reported a SaaS data
breach, a five-point increase over the previous year
[24].
● Just 32% of respondents were confident that the data
their company or customers store in SaaS applications
are secure; that number was 43% in 2023 [24].
-Scientific journals
like “Philosophical
Transactions”
(1665) pioneered
academic
subscriptions
-Theater
subscriptions
became popular in
European opera
houses
-Wine merchants
offered “cellar
subscriptions” to
aristocrats
-Lending libraries
introduced
subscription-based
book borrowing
subscriptions
(1785)
-Sheet music
subscription
services emerged
for piano rolls
-“Patent
Medicine”
subscription
services
delivered regular
tonics
-Insurance
companies
developed
subscription-
based payment
models
-Fruit and
vegetable box
schemes started
in European
cities
-Columbia
Record Club
began offering
monthly music
records (1855)
-Sewing pattern
subscriptions for
dressmaking
became popular
Club (1950s)
-Columbia House
Record Club
(1955)
-Time-Life Book
Series
subscriptions
-Encyclopedia
Britannica’s
subscription-based
updates
-Coffee club
subscriptions for
office deliveries
-Diners Club
launches first
credit card
subscription
(1950)
-Sports season
tickets formalize
as subscriptions
-Beer-of-the-
month clubs begin
(1950s)
-Christmas Club
savings accounts
(regular deposits)
-LinkedIn
Premium
(2003)
-World of
Warcraft
monthly
gaming
(2004)
-YouTube
Premium
(2006)
-Amazon
Prime (2005)
-Zipcar
subscription
car service
(2000)
Cloud (2011)
-Microsoft Office
365 (2011)
-Google Play
Pass (2019)
-Apple Arcade
(2019)
-ClassPass fitness
(2013)
-HelloFresh meal
kits (2011)
-Rent the
Runway fashion
(2009)
-Twitch
subscriptions
(2011)
-Apple Music
(2015)
-Disney+ (2019)
-Car manufacturer
subscriptions
(BMW, Porsche,
Volvo)
-NFT subscription
services
-Digital healthcare
subscriptions
-Remote work tool
subscriptions boom
-Gaming battle
passes become
standard
-Grocery delivery
subscriptions
expand
-Professional
training and
certification
subscriptions
Bihag Karnani / IJCTT, 72(12), 179-193, 2024
181
● From SaaS apps [26], 61% of ransomware breaches
come from survey respondents.
The statistics above underscore the increasing threats of
data breaches and confidence levels on SaaS security
measures. The potential for monetary loss includes loss of
intellectual property, reputational harm, and regulatory
penalties.
3.1.2. Internet Dependency
Another major disadvantage of SaaS is its dependence
on internet connectivity:
● External service outages due to the provider and internal
connectivity issues can result in a shutdown of
operations and significantly affect productivity.
● While exact figures depend on the size and nature of the
business, the cost of downtime can add up quickly.
3.1.3. Other Adoption Challenges
1. User Adoption: Employees can be reluctant to adopt
new platforms or tools, especially when they feel
stretched or undertrained.
2. Hidden Costs: SaaS pricing models can be intricate,
often including hidden fees for extra functionality, users
or storage.
3. Vendor lock-in: If a solution is so integrated with a
particular provider that customers do not want to switch,
it may be costly and complex.
4. Additional Compliance Requirements: This can become
a top challenge in protecting data in SaaS. 29% of
respondents indicated additional compliance
requirements were their top challenge to protecting data
in SaaS [22].
5. Underestimation of SaaS Scale: Although 49% of
responders said they had fewer than 10 apps linked to
Microsoft 365—the actual average was more than 1,000
SaaS-to-SaaS connections per deployment [24].
3.2. Financial Impacts
The cost of these issues can add up quickly:
• The average cost of a data breach rose to $4.45 million
in 2023, a 15% increase over 3 years (IBM Cost of a
Data Breach Report 2023).
• Many businesses underestimate their SaaS usage,
leading to unexpected costs. The average small to
medium-sized business uses 200 or more SaaS solutions,
with estimates as high as 2000 [26].
4. Novel Pricing Mechanisms and Their Effects
on Markets
Diverse pricing strategies reflect today’s complex
service offerings, which have evolved alongside subscription
models. Companies are establishing sophisticated pricing
mechanisms that stretch beyond flat-rate subscriptions to
maximize revenue and provide value [76].
4.1. Usage-Based Pricing Models
Snowflake and Twilio are trailblazers of usage-based
pricing in the cloud computing space. Through its
consumption-based model, Snowflake only bills customers
for the computational resources they actually consume —
this expanded Snowflake’s net revenue retention to 169% in
2023 [77]. This method has been particularly successful in
the data warehousing sector, where workloads can fluctuate
considerably.
4.2. Hybrid Pricing Structures
Adobe Creative Cloud is a great example of the hybrid
pricing model, which incorporates both subscription-based
and usage-based pricing. Their enterprise plans consist of
seat-based licensing, as well as consumption credits for
additional services, giving them a 25% increase in the
retention of their enterprise customers compared to their old
perpetual license model [78].
4.3. Value-Metric Pricing
Stripe is a payment processing platform that uses value-
metric pricing by charging a percentage of the transaction
value rather than fixed fees. With a metric based on success
for the customer at the heart of their growth, research
suggests that value-metric pricing models grow 38% faster
than seat-based models [79].
4.4. Dynamic Pricing Implementation
Dynamic pricing has been successfully integrated into
airline and hospitality services subscription offerings.
United Airlines subscription programs, for example, vary
ticket prices depending on customer segmentation and
demand patterns, resulting in a 15% revenue per available
seat mile boost.
4.5. Pricing Effectiveness: An Analysis Across Industries
Research studies assessing the efficacy of the pricing
strategy across various industries display some key common
trends:
1. Technology Sector
• Usage-based pricing works best for infrastructure
services
• Hybrid models boost average customer lifetime
value by 23% [80]
2. Media and Entertainment
• Based on tiered pricing with a distinct value
proposition, customer retention is 42% higher.
• Freemium models show 3.5x higher conversion
rates when they include high usage limits [81].
3. Professional Services
• Value-based pricing results in 18% greater profit
margins.
• Condition-based pricing drives up customer
satisfaction by 31% [82].
Bihag Karnani / IJCTT, 72(12), 179-193, 2024
182
4.6. Success Factors for Implementation of Pricing
Strategy
Research highlights several key elements in driving
successful pricing strategy execution:
1. Organizations that align pricing metrics with customer
value perception show 27% higher customer satisfaction
scores [83].
2. Clear and transparent pricing communication has been
proven to decrease the number of customer support
inquiries by 35% and increase trust metrics by 29% [84].
3. Companies providing flexible pricing options have 40%
higher customer acquisition metrics and maintain 25%
lower churn metrics [85].
4.7. Implementation Challenges
While the benefits are immense, companies are
challenged on multiple fronts by the implementation of
innovative pricing strategies:
4.7.1. Technical Infrastructure
• 67 per cent of companies struggle to implement usage-
based billing systems.
• Integration costs average around 15-20% of initial
implementation budgets [86]
4.7.2. Customer Education
• Educating customers is lengthy: it can take between 3-6
months for organizations to onboard customers to new
pricing models.
• Clear communication reduces adoption resistance by
45% [87]
4.7.3. Revenue Predictability
• Usage-based companies that change revenue models
struggle, even post-conversion. 20–30% volatility in the
first year after conversion.
• This volatility is decreased to 10-15% 101 with hybrid
models.
5. Emerging Technologies and Subscription
Models
We are witnessing a far-reaching change in
subscription-based business models driven by emerging
technologies, such as Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Internet
of Things (IoT).
These technologies allow enterprises to deliver more
pointed, effective, and value-driven services for their
subscribers.
5.1. AI in Subscription Models
AI is improving subscription services through enhanced:
• Personalized Recommendations: AI algorithms analyze
user behaviour to suggest personalized content or
products, boosting user engagement and retention.
• Detecting Churn: ML models can help organizations
predict when customers are most likely to cancel a
subscription and take appropriate steps.
5.2. IoT and Subscription Services
The IoT is creating new opportunities for subscription-
based services:
• Continuous Value Delivery: Companies can deliver
ongoing value from IoT devices through real-time
monitoring, updates, and services [2].
• Data-Driven Insights: IoT sensors are capable of
collecting massive amounts of data, which companies
can leverage for ongoing improvement in their product
and service offerings.
5.3. Case Studies
5.3.1. Case Study 1: IoT-Enabled Subscription Models
Introduction Data science can add value to all business
models, creating disruptive changes in various industries.
Sustainable revenue transactions capture value critical for
successful SMBs. Continuously improvement based on
business value is paramount!
To solve revenue complexity and design data collection
mechanics, an agile operations organization is critical. The
study emphasizes improvements in the value proposition,
service innovation, and customer retention in preserving IoT‐
based subscription models [75].
5.3.2. Case Study 2: IoT Market Subscription Models
In 2015, the IoT market was worth $23.09 billion and is
projected to be $443.27 billion in 2022 [32]. This growth is
directly correlated to the embrace of subscription models.
Research findings include:
• Businesses can generate recurring revenues with IoT
subscription models.
• They also help with building long-term relationships
with customers.
• These models can expand market share by reducing
initial costs and making products more affordable.
5.4. Impact of Generative AI on the Subscription Economy
Generative AI (GenAI), a branch of AI focused on
creating novel content and ideas, stands to transform the
subscription landscape. GenAI, which are systems that attain
the ability to create new content, data, or information from
pre-existing data it was trained on, are revolutionizing the
way we provide and access technology and information.
Moreover, this technology is increasingly being embedded
into subscription-based products and services as a recurring
value proposition. Generative AI (GenAI) products,
including AI writing assistants, image generators and code
creation tools, are on the rise, and many are available through
subscription models. As a result, these models tend to have
their traits:
Bihag Karnani / IJCTT, 72(12), 179-193, 2024
183
• Usage-based pricing: GenAI subscriptions could also
feature usage-based pricing, where customers are charged
based on the volume of content generated or the
complexity of the tasks performed.
• Value-based subscription tiers: Subscription tiers could
be created based on how powerful the AI model is, how
customized it can be, what level of features are included,
etc.,
• Collaboration: GenAI models are continually being
developed and refined, leading to evergreen value and
capabilities for subscribers.
5.4.1. GenAI Subscriptions Structure
Most GenAI subscriptions follow a hybrid model where
recurring fees are supplemented with usage-based pricing.
This model gives organizations the benefits of predictable
revenue while maintaining elasticity to integrate different
customer needs and usage trends. For instance, a GenAI
writing assistant could have a free base subscription for
writing a limited number of words a month, with overage
charges for exceeding that limit.
5.4.2. GenAI Personalization Potential
GenAI enables companies to hyper-personalize the
subscription offering. GenAI can personalize content,
features, and recommendations to individual needs by
analyzing user data and preferences. By doing so, GenAI
products improve customer satisfaction, improve engagement
and ultimately achieve a greater customer lifetime value.
5.4.3. Ethics in GenAI
The growing adoption of GenAI also raises ethical
considerations:
• Bias mitigation: GenAI models can reflect (and
reproduce) biases from their training data, resulting in
biased or discriminatory outcomes [65]. Businesses
have to find ways to minimize bias and make GenAI
work pretty.
• Data privacy: GenAI needs access to user data to
perform effectively. Implementation of privacy
protection and regulation of data related to the user
must be placed above everything else by companies.
• Transparency and Explainable AI (XAI): The “black
box” nature of some GenAI models can pose issues
related to transparency and accountability [66].
Explainable AI (XAI) strives to uncover how models
make decisions to enhance user trust and promote the
ethical application of AI.
5.5. In-Depth Analysis of GenAI Subscription Models
The integration of Generative AI into subscription
models has introduced novel pricing and delivery
mechanisms that differ significantly from traditional
subscription structures. Recent research indicates that GenAI
subscriptions are evolving rapidly, with 78% of providers
adopting hybrid models that combine multiple pricing
approaches. This evolution represents a fundamental shift in
how AI services are delivered and monetized, creating new
opportunities for both providers and consumers.
5.5.1. Innovative Subscription Structures in GenAI
Subscription models that incorporate Generative AI
introduce new pricing and delivery mechanisms that are
fundamentally different from existing subscription models. A
recent study shows that GenAI usage is evolving rapidly
(most providers now offer a hybrid model that uses multiple
pricing approaches). This evolution shows a change in the
way AI services are offered and monetized, offering new
possibilities for providing and using AI.
5.5.2. GenAI: New Subscription Models
The GenAI market is characterized by four subscription
structures that offer different advantages and cater to
different needs. One such approach, now seen as the de facto
method, is the token-based system where usage is tracked in
computational tokens, allowing for dynamic pricing based on
model sophistication and usage consumption styles. This
flexible model of production has proved to be very effective,
with an average saving of 35% compared to fixed-rate
models and greater flexibility for users with variant motives.
A departure from token-based pricing is outcome-based
pricing, in which charges are based on the successful
completion of tasks rather than the amount of usage and
reflect mechanisms for quality-adjusted pricing or
performance guarantees. This has delivered particular
success in many enterprise applications, enabling average
customer satisfaction rates to be increased by 42% per dollar
spent. This approach has shown great promise, particularly in
situations where the quality and reliability of the output are
of the highest priority.
Capability-tiered access is much more common, where
users get different levels of access with different model sizes
and capabilities, as well as levels of customization and API
access. This framework has proven extraordinarily effective
when it comes to moving customers further down the path
towards increased usage, where providers noted a 28%
increase in upgrades as users realize the value of more
sophisticated options. This tiered approach offers
organizations the necessary tools to begin with fundamental
functionality and then scale as their requirements grow,
offering a clear pathway for growth and expansion.
Enterprise-specific deployments embody the most prevalent
highest-level end of the spectrum, offering custom model
fine-tuning, dedicated infrastructure and enhanced security
capabilities. Such deployments yield impressive returns,
with organizations reporting ROI improvement of 45% for
large implementations. This method has been especially
beneficial for organizations with custom requirements or
sensitive data handling.
Bihag Karnani / IJCTT, 72(12), 179-193, 2024
184
5.5.3. Personalization for GenAI focused Services
Advances in personalization capabilities are uniquely
enabled through GenAI subscriptions. Dynamic learning
systems are a pillar of these capabilities, employing
continuous model adaptation, user preference incorporation,
and context-aware responses. 37% improvement in user
engagement through constant evolution of systems and their
outputs through continuous interaction and ongoing
feedback113.
Interformat personalization has become one of the
hottest GenAI services, enabling content generators to
demonstrate the same style transferability and brand voice
consistency across formats. By using this holistic approach
to personalization, 31% higher content relevance scores,
measured by user feedback and engagement metrics, have
been observed. Applications in marketing and content
creation based on this ability to maintain consistency while
adapting to preferred formats of different users have become
particularly useful.
5.5.4. GenAI Subscription Implementation Template
A comprehensive framework for GenAI subscription
services implementation that acknowledges the intricate
interactions between technical architecture and service
delivery. The framework breaks it down into three key
layers — infrastructure, service layer, and personalization,
each important in managing a successful GenAI services
deployment. This includes an infrastructure layer that
provides scalable compute and load balancing and a service
layer that provides API interaction and usage tracking. The
personalization layer — the richest and most complex of all
the layers — is responsible for managing user preferences
and learning algorithms to build a cohesive system that
evolves and adapts based on interactions with people.
5.5.5. Economic Impact and Future Trends
Studies have found that the economic benefits of GenAI
subscriptions have been substantial across a range of things.
Improvements in operational efficiency have been especially
impressive as organizations have reported a 45% reduction in
costs for accelerating content production and a 38%
improvement in processing speed. These efficiency gains
have shown up directly as improved financial performance,
with providers seeing a 41% bump in user retention and 35%
more average revenue per user [100].
As we look ahead, research points to a few future trends
that are likely to define the next phase of GenAI
subscriptions. Hybrid pricing models are becoming
increasingly sophisticated, where fixed and usage-based
elements are combined and integrated with outcome-
dependent factors and value-metric integration. Next up, we
currently have advanced personalization capabilities, which
have been expanded from the capabilities we saw by
incorporating real-time adaptation, cross-platform
synchronization, and context preservation across different
use cases. As Enterprise integration matures, it will feature
more coverage and flexibility with custom deployment
options across industry-specific solutions becoming table-
stakes offerings.
5.5.6. Challenges and Solutions of Integration
Adoption of GenAI subscriptions poses some significant
challenges, which organizations need to tackle 113. Technical
integration is still the biggest concern, as are things like API
compatibility, performance tuning and security. User
adoption considerations (learning curve management,
feature discovery, etc) only add more complexity to these
challenges. However, studies have demonstrated that
companies that address these barriers successfully by rolling
out extensive training programs and showing that the value
of the new technologies is clear see much more significant
adoption rates and job satisfaction scores.
6. Consumer (B2C) subscription models vs.
Business (B2B) Subscription Models
B2C and B2B subscription models differ in their target
audience, pricing strategies, and customer relationship
dynamics, even though the basic principle of recurring
revenue is the same.
6.1. B2C Subscriptions
B2C subscriptions are usually targeted towards
individual consumers, providing things like entertainment
streaming (Netflix, Spotify), online fitness programs
(Peloton), and subscription boxes (Dollar Shave Club, Blue
Apron). These models often emphasize the following:
• Low price points: B2C subscriptions tend to have lower
price points and shorter-duration subscriptions to appeal
to a broad customer base.
• Ease of use and convenience: In B2C subscriptions, the
user experience is extremely important, which is why
they focus on easy sign-up processes and intuitive
interfaces.
• Ethos: The marketing strategy appeals to needs and
desires, selling subscriptions and fun.
6.1.1. Personalization in B2C
To improve customer satisfaction/retention, B2C
companies leverage data-driven inputs to tailor
recommendations, offers and experiences to individual
customers. By analyzing customer data, businesses can
design personalized experiences that appeal to their
customers and drive sales.
6.1.2. Community Building in B2C
Community building is a very important part of B2C
subscriptions. The creation of a sense of belonging among
subscribers can be achieved through online forums, social
media groups, or exclusive events [17]. Such communities
Bihag Karnani / IJCTT, 72(12), 179-193, 2024
185
allow subscribers to connect, share experiences, and provide
feedback, further cementing their relationship with the brand.
6.1.3. B2C Acquisition and Retention Strategies
B2C companies have a set of strategies they use for
acquiring and retaining customers:
• Acquisition: B2C acquisition strategies commonly use
free trials, freemium models, and targeted advertising
[67].
• Retention: Customers are retained, and churn is reduced
using personalized recommendations, loyalty programs,
and exclusive content [68].
6.2. B2B Subscriptions
B2B Subscriptions are geared towards businesses,
providing software services (like Salesforce and Adobe
Creative Cloud), enterprise tools (like Slack and Zoom), and
professional services (like legal or accounting software).
These models often involve:
• These can include the tiered pricing or usage-based fees
seen in B2B subscriptions or customized plans based on
particular business requirements.
• In the case of B2B, more people are involved, and
decision-making takes more time.
• Marketing needs to focus on ROI and value proposition
6.2.1. Customer Success in B2B
In B2B engagements, ensuring that marketing customer
success is emphasized is even more important than in B2C.
Product and service providers play an anticipatory role in
enabling their B2B clients to achieve desired outcomes from
using the subscribed product or service, thus leading to
renewals and upsells [19]. This often requires offering client
support, education, and resources to help the customer get
the most out of their subscription.
6.2.2. Subscription Management in B2B
Subscription management platforms can assist in
streamlining billing, automating renewals, and providing
insights into usage [19] with a goal to streamline the
complexities of B2B subscription product offerings and
improve efficiency and customer experience.
6.3. Key Differences Summarized
Table 2. Feature Comparison between B2B and B2C subscriptions
Feature
B2C Subscriptions
B2B Subscriptions
Target Audience
Individual consumers
Businesses
Pricing
Low price points, shorter
durations
Complex pricing, tiered plans
Sales Cycle
Short, impulse-driven
Long, multi-stakeholder
Marketing Focus
Emotional appeal,
convenience
ROI, value proposition
Customer Relationships
Transactional, high churn
Long-term, strategic
Transaction Process
Simple, less time-consuming,
often impulse-driven
Complex, involves rational
analysis and longer consideration
These basic differences result in different metrics in B2B and B2C subscriptions, as mentioned in table 2 below:
Table 3. Subscription metrics comparison between B2B and B2C
Metric
B2B
B2C
Average Contract Value
$15,000 - $100,000+
$10 - $100
Customer Acquisition Cost
$500 - $20,000
$10 - $200
Average Sales Cycle
3-12 months
1-7 days
Annual Churn Rate
5-7%
10-25%
Customer Lifetime
3-5 years
1-2 years
6.4. B2B Acquisition and Retention Strategies
B2B companies approach the acquisition and retention
of customers differently:
• Acquisition: B2B acquisition strategies include content
marketing, webinars, and industry events [69].
• Retention: B2B customer retention relies on
personalized onboarding, dedicated account managers,
and customer success programs [69].
Bihag Karnani / IJCTT, 72(12), 179-193, 2024
186
7. Boosting Customer Lifetime Value
Customer lifetime value (CLV) is the total revenue
generated from a customer from the beginning of the
relationship with the business, which becomes the most
critical metric for a subscription business. A higher CLV is a
must for sustainable growth and profits. There are various
methods companies can use to increase CLV:
● Improve customer engagement: Whether it be
personalized content, exclusive offers, or feedback
requests, it is imperative to communicate regularly with
the company’s subscribers [7]. Engagement can be further
nurtured with a strong subscriber community through
online forums, social media engagement, or exclusive
events [7, 15].
● Enhance customer service provided: Resolving customer
challenges promptly by offering efficient customer
support further improves customer trust [10].
● Provide flexible subscription terms: Enable subscribers to
pause, change, or upgrade their subscriptions as needed
[22].
● Maximize pricing strategies: Adopt value-based pricing
and provide discounts for longer subscriptions [11, 18].
7.1. Customer Segmentation
Understanding each of the customer types (and their
accompanying value) is critical to successfully raising CLV.
In addition to demographic [71], behavioural [72], and
psychographic segmentation [73], to gain more insight into
customer needs and preferences, one such framework
segregates customers using Recency (R), Frequency (F), and
Monetary (M) values [13]. This enables businesses to divide
customers into segments and customize strategies to increase
their long-term value. Churn Prediction and Retention
Strategies
7.2. Customer Retention
Customer retention is a pivotal component of CLV
optimization. Increasingly, AI and machine learning are
playing a vital role in churn prediction. Companies can
proactively work to avoid churn [16] by helping them
analyze customer behaviour and identify at-risk customers.
This means leveraging historical data, customer
interactions and other relevant factors to predict churn
probability and execute targeted retention efforts.
7.3. Customer Loyalty Programs
Another tool for boosting CLV is customer loyalty
programs [18]. These initiatives, including rewards
programs, exclusive benefits, and tiered memberships, can
provide incentives for repeat purchases and build long-term
loyalty [18]. Such programs give the customer a sense of
appreciation and value, which, in turn, makes them loyal to
the brand.
7.4. Data-Centric Customer Retention Strategies
In recent years, new developments in data analytics have
revolutionized the way that subscription-based businesses
view retention and churn. Companies that employ data-
driven retention strategies have 23% higher customer
lifetime value than those that rely solely on traditional
means [89]. One area in which it has manifested quite
profoundly is retention management — specifically,
predictive analytics for retention management.
7.4.1. Retention Management using Predictive Analytic
Customer retention is one of the main applications of
predictive analytics that has gained a lot of interest over the
past decade. According to studies, businesses that employ
predictive analytics for churn prevention witness remarkable
enhancements across the board, such as a 15% decrease in
customer churn rate, a 28% increase in renewal rates, and a
34% increase in upsell success rates [90]. Research by
Vafeiadis et al. [91] (payment patterns and usage metrics)
reveals that machine learning models were able to predict
customer churn with 85% accuracy based on analysis of
previous behavioural patterns and payment history [91]
(2024).
7.4.2. Advanced Analytics for Personalization
So far, data-driven personalization has emerged as a key
player in effective retention strategies [92]. Companies using
AI-driven personalization achieve significant increases in
engagement and even revenue indicators. They have reported
a 42% rise in user engagement, a 37% increase in feature
adoption rates, and a 29% increase in customer satisfaction
scores. The revenue effects have also been considerable, with
companies delivering 31% higher renewal rates, 25% higher
average revenue per user, and 19% growth in expansion
revenue [93, 94].
7.4.3. Behavioral Analytics and Optimization of Customer
Journey
Companies can leverage advanced behavioural analytics
to optimize their customer journey at different touchpoints,
giving special attention to onboarding optimization and
usage pattern analysis 107. By analyzing onboarding,
companies have seen a 45% reduction in time to value, a
33% improvement in feature adoption, and a 28% reduction
in early-stage churn. Similarly, usage pattern analysis has
also helped with the identification of at-risk customers (39%
better), improved intervention (27% better), and improved
product stickiness (35% better) [95].
7.4.4. Implementation Framework for Data-Driven Retention
Connecting these concepts, Mgbemena (2016) propose
a structured framework for implementing data-driven
retention strategies that consist of three core components
[96]. The first part involves data collection and integration,
which encompasses data on customer interactions, usage
data, billing history, support interactions, and feature
Bihag Karnani / IJCTT, 72(12), 179-193, 2024
187
adoption rates. The second part is about analytics
implementation, such as predictive modelling, behavioural
segmentation, real-time monitoring, and automated alerting
systems. The third part addresses intervention strategy
creation that includes personalized communication, tailored
value reinforcement, proactive support, and customized
offers/incentives.
Measuring Success and ROI
Research on the ROI of data-driven retention strategies
shows significant financial impacts on multiple levels. They
saw a 25% reduction in customer acquisition costs, a 32%
decrease in support costs, and a 28% improvement in
marketing efficiency. On the revenue enhancement side,
metrics have been equally impressive, with companies
reporting a 35% increase in renewal rates, 41% growth in
expansion revenue, and 23% higher customer lifetime value
[97].
Data-Driven Retention Best Practices
Studies highlight a number of critical success aspects to
data-driven retention with a focus on quality management of
data and cross-functional associated with data integration
[98]. Data audits conducted every 3 months increase
prediction accuracy by 27% in the field of data quality
management, whereas a standardized approach to data
collection allows us to make our statistics 34% more reliable.
Cross-functional integration has been found equally valuable,
with teams sharing data access improving retention outcomes
by 31% and sharing analysis improving the effectiveness of
interventions by 29% [99].
Emerging Trends and Future Directions
With the demand for more data-driven retention
methods, emerging trends in this area include AI-powered
retention tools as well as analytics applications. Natural
Language Processing algorithms are being used by these
tools, which means that AI technology can automatically
perform sentiment analysis; real-time intervention systems or
automated personalization engines.
Customer journey mapping, predictive lifetime value
modelling, churn risk scoring, and network effect analysis
are a few particularly popular advanced analytics
applications. Such workflows signify a near future of precise
retention strategies that adapt based on the convergence of
technology and analytics methodologies.
8. Future Trends and Regulatory Impacts
8.1. Emerging Trends and Regulatory Evolution in
Subscription Models
Technology evolution and changing consumer
preferences and regulations are changing the dynamics of
the subscription economy. The global subscription market—
estimated at $1.5 trillion in 2025—is propelled by trends that
amplify the future trajectory of the business model [101].
8.2. Technological Evolution and Market Transformation
The intersection of new and emerging technologies is
fundamentally transforming subscription paradigms. A few
transformative trends will help define subscription services
in the future.
However, edge computing and 5G networks are
allowing more complex real-time service delivery, cutting
latency times for services by up to 90% than traditional
cloud-based solutions. This progress is critical for streaming
services and interactive content platforms where user
experience relies on response time.
Data is a treasure for tracking and connecting the
consumption behaviours of customers who interact with
your subscription service. While IoT-powered subscription
models are growing 2.5 times faster than conventional
subscriptions because of their potential for predictive
maintenance, usage-based pricing, and automated service
provision [102]. This convergence is most visible in
industries like automotive, healthcare, and even home
automation, where physical products are increasingly being
coupled with digital services.
8.3. Evolving Consumer Behaviors and Service Models
Reconceptualization of consumer preferences and
behaviours altering the evolution of the subscription model.
Notably, consumers are increasingly focused on flexibility
and customization: 73% of consumers reported wanting
more granular control over their subscription services. As a
result, modular subscription trends include the modular
model itself, which allows customers to assemble a service
package according to their needs and preferences.
Many subscription service offerings and models are
being designed and delivered through a sustainability lens.
There is a growing trend among consumers to make choices
based on environmental awareness; 65% of subscribers say
they prefer eco-friendly services and packaging [103]. This
has encouraged subscriptions to embrace circular economy
principles of their own, such as recycling programs, carbon-
neutral delivery, and sustainable packaging programs.
8.4. Regulatory Environment and Compliance Hurdles
There are also growing regulatory demands, with more
laws applying to subscription services in various
jurisdictions. Several important regulatory trends are likely
to affect subscription businesses :
Data privacy and protection: Increased regulation, in line
with GDPR, is being adopted around the world, with a focus
on subscription services that collect and process consumer
data. These laws pose fundamental new data management
requirements for subscription services at great installation
costs, averaging 4% of annual revenue across affected
companies.
Bihag Karnani / IJCTT, 72(12), 179-193, 2024
188
Improved Consumer Protection: New laws target
subscription disclosure and cancellation rights. It has been
shown that jurisdictions that adopted stricter consumer
protection to rein in subscription abuse saw complaint rates
fall by 15% and customer trust metrics improve by 23%
[104].
Cross-Border Commerce Rules: Globalization is
introducing regulatory challenges for companies offering
subscription services, especially around tax compliance and
data localization. Research indicates that cross-border
subscription services incur 12% higher compliance costs
compared to their single-jurisdiction counterparts [105].
8.5. Competitive Dynamics and the Structure of the Market
Moreover, the subscription market is undergoing a
major structural transition, one that is marked by increasing
consolidation and new competitive dynamics. A particularly
clear example of this is the streaming media, software
services, and digital content sector.
8.6. Financial Models and Investment Patterns
Investment in subscription-based businesses is changing,
and there are new metrics and valuations. Stakeholders are
moving towards better instruments to evaluate projects, such
as customer acquisition cost (CAC), lifetime value (LTV) or
churn prediction models. This transitions both in venture
capital investment decision-making and public market
valuations towards sustainable growth, as companies
delivering good unit economics are rewarded with premium
valuations despite, effectively, lower absolute growth rates.
8.7. Convergence of Physical and Digital Subscriptions
More than ever the lines are blurring between the
physical and digital space those subscription services inhabit
(with new hybrids for both emerging). Some are already
providing visible new value offerings and business
proposals, particularly in retail, education and professional
services.
8.8. Strategic Implications and Adaptation Requirements
Organizations that thrive in the subscription economy
must navigate complex strategic issues and help manage
shifting market dynamics. Following a multi-dimensional
strategy capable of incorporating technical infrastructure,
business model evolution, and regulation adaptation is a
promising approach to achieving industry success.
Successful companies that are skilful in managing these
challenges will have higher growth rates and superior
customer retention rates than competitors.
9. Conclusion and Strategic Recommendations
Since then, the subscription economy has shown
immense evolution and growth over the years and is still
sending ripples with the impact of the technological
revolution, market dynamics, and changing consumer
preferences. Key signals of change will shape the future of
subscription-based business models, and practical actions
organizations need to implement now to enable their success
in this evolving landscape.
9.1. Key Insights and Implications
The intersection between SaaS, cloud computing, and
Generative AI has fundamentally transformed the
subscription economy. Studies indicate that data-driven
decision-making is becoming an important part of successful
subscription businesses as they use advanced data analytics,
complex pricing structures and personalized experiences.
The lines between the B2B and B2C subscription models
continue to blur as each serves as an inspiration to the other
while offering their distinctive value propositions.
GenAI comes with unique possibilities to capture more
customized experiences and new value, coupled with new
challenges to price, deliver and regulate. Organizations that
can adopt GenAI in their subscription offerings successfully
maintain much stronger customer retention rates and lifetime
value metrics. On the other hand, this is only possible if the
data privacy of customers is ensured, ethical aspects are paid
attention to, and openness in communication with customers
is taken into account.
As a response, data-on-process-driven retention
strategies have developed into a key profit driver, with
studies indicating that firms employing advanced analytics
and predictive modelling derive far superior outcomes in
customer lifetime value and churn reduction. By combining
multiple sources of data and analytical methods, you can
better understand customer behaviour, predict their actions,
prevent churn, and personalize your engagement strategies.
9.2. Actionable Recommendations for Organizations
Drawing from the extensive business analysis of this
research, organizations must adopt the following strategic
initiatives in order to embrace the changing subscription
landscape successfully:
9.3. Technology Infrastructure Enhancement
Organizations need to build a strong and scalable
technology backbone to enable sophisticated subscription
business operations. The infrastructure must include
powerful data analytics capabilities, real-time processing
systems, and integration frameworks that facilitate cross-
functional communication across various business functions.
9.4. Customer-Centric Innovation
Adapting these new characteristics within your
subscription offerings requires a fundamental shift to
customer-centred innovation. Organizations that incorporate
systematic feedback loops for customers in their design
processes and promote continual iteration of features will
continue to be more successful with new feature adoption.
Bihag Karnani / IJCTT, 72(12), 179-193, 2024
189
Careful attention to customer journey mapping, regular
feedback loops, and agile delivery processes that allow the
organization to respond rapidly to changing customer
requirements must form part of this way of working.
9.4. Data Strategy Optimization
Developing a data strategy creates a need for
organizations to strike a balance between analytical
capabilities and privacy. Companies with mature data
governance frameworks achieve stronger results in terms of
personalization efforts whilst at the same time maintaining
higher levels of customer trust, research confirms. Such a
strategy must include data collection protocols, quality
management systems, and steps to protect privacy to
guarantee compliance with these evolving regulations.
9.5. Pricing Model Evolution
This entails developing more sophisticated pricing
models that reflect value delivery and customer usage
patterns. Value-based pricing strategies with dynamic
adjustment capabilities have been shown to generate higher
revenue per customer than organizations using traditional
fixed pricing. Such models should include usage metrics,
outcome-based pricing features, and flexible tiering features,
reflecting customer value perception.
9.6. Implementation Framework
To successfully implement these recommendations,
organizations should take a phased approach:
• Assessment Phase: Organizations should start with an
in-depth assessment of their existing subscription
capabilities, technology infrastructure, and customer
engagement mechanisms. This should assess the
presence of specific gaps and areas of focus across all
the dimensions of operations.
• Structured Transformation: This guides organizations to
create comprehensive implementation plans that
prioritize initiatives based on impact and resource
requirements.
• Implementation & Monitoring: Execution should use an
agile methodology that allows for rapid iteration and
continuous delivery.
• Regularly check key performance indicators and
customer feedback for effective implementation and
timely corrections.
10. Future Outlook
The subscription economy will be plentifully fueled by
technology evolution and market forces. The best-prepared
organizations to seize new opportunities will be those that
both execute these recommendations and remain agile and
adaptive. Organizations with the best chance of success will
have strong technical capabilities, strong customer
relationships and flexible business models.
Final thoughts: The subscription landscape offers both
tremendous challenges and unparalleled opportunities for
organizations that take a strategic approach to
transformation. It relies on an innovative solution driven by
technology, focuses on customer and operational
improvement and efficiency, and is underpinned by data
capabilities and agile business models.
References
[1] Sarah L.C. Clapp, “The Beginnings of Subscription Publication in the Seventeenth Century,” Modern Philology, vol. 29, no. 2, pp.
199-224, 1931. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[2] Jingxian Du et al., “The Mechanism and Components of Subscriptions in the Business Model,” Advances in Economics, Management
and Political Sciences, vol. 101, no. 1, pp. 1-6, 2023. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[3] Arto Ojala, “Software-as-a-Service Revenue Models,” IT Professional, vol. 15, no. 3, pp. 54-59, 2013. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar]
[Publisher Link]
[4] Ryan Law, “The Ultimate Guide to SaaS Pricing Models, Strategies and Psychological Hacks,” Cobloom Limited, 2024. [Google
Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[5] Devesh Lowe, and Bhavna Galhotra, “An Overview of Pricing Models for Using Cloud Services with analysis on Pay-Per-Use
Model,” Journal of Software Engineering and Applications, vol. 9, no. 4, pp. 179-183, 2018. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher
Link]
[6] Accoil, The Three Phases of the SaaS Revenue Model (and How to Win at Each), 2017. [Online]. Available:
https://www.accoil.com/blog/three-phases-of-the-saas-revenue-model
[7] SaaS Benchmarks for Subscription Plans, Recurly Research, 2017. [Online]. Available: https://recurly.com/research/saas-benchmarks-
for-subscription-plans/
[8] Brenda Nansubuga, and Christian Kowalkowski, “Moving to Subscriptions: Service Growth Through Business Model Innovation in
Consumer and Business Markets,” Journal of Service Management, vol. 34, no. 2, pp. 184-207, 2024. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar]
[Publisher Link]
[9] Ellen Jennings-Trace, Hackers Are Selling Stolen GenAI Accounts on The Dark Web, TechRadar Pro, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.techradar.com/pro/hackers-are-selling-stolen-genai-accounts-on-the-dark-web
[10] Adam Hua, The Value of Content in the Age of GenAI: How Publishers Can Adapt to the Changing Reality, Project Aeon, 2024.
[Online]. Available: https://project-aeon.com/blogs/content-in-the-age-of-genai
Bihag Karnani / IJCTT, 72(12), 179-193, 2024
190
[11] Nicolas de Bellefonds et al., “Turning GenAI Magic into Business Impact,” Boston Consulting Group, 2023. [Google Scholar]
[Publisher Link]
[12] The Subscription Business Model: Past, Present, and Future, E2open, 2023. [Online]. Available: https://www.e2open.com/blog/the-
subscription-business-model-past-present-and-future/
[13] Swapan Kumar Saha et al., “A Comparative Study on B2B Vs B2C Based on Asia Pacific Region,” International Journal of Research
and Analytical Reviews (IJRAR), vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 294-298, 2014. [Google Scholar]
[14] RafterOne, How to Overcome the Challenges in Digital Marketing for B2C Commerce, 2023. [Online]. Available:
https://www.linkedin.com/posts/rafterone_how-to-overcome-the-challenges-in-digital-activity-7103031219491135488-uA5V
[15] Johnson Maggie, Fueling Success: How to Increase Customer Engagement in Subscriptions and Membership Programs, Recharge
Payments, 2024. [Online]. Available: https://getrecharge.com/blog/fueling-success-how-to-increase-customer-engagement-in-
subscriptions-membership-programs/
[16] John Solomon, 5 Secrets to Reduce Subscription Churn, Chargebee Blog, 2012. [Online]. Available:
https://www.chargebee.com/blog/5-secrets-reduce-subscription-churn/
[17] Paola Lagunes, “How to Optimize Your Member Journeys for A Better Subscription Experience, Recurly, 2022. [Online]. Available:
https://recurly.com/blog/member-journeys-optimize-subscription-customer-experience/
[18] Lifetime Value (LTV): What It Is and How to Calculate, Zuora, 2024. [Online]. Available: https://www.zuora.com/glossary/lifetime-
value/#:~:text=To%20increase%20your%20customer%20lifetime,ARPUs%20through%20optimizing%20your%20pricing.
[19] Angela Davenport, Engaging Customers with Subscriptions: Strategies for Maintaining Customer Interest, Efulfillment Service, 2024.
[Online]. Available: https://www.efulfillmentservice.com/2024/10/engaging-customers-with-subscriptions-strategies-for-maintaining-
customer-interest/
[20] How to Cut-down Subscriber Churn, Zuora, 2024. [Online]. Available: https://www.zuora.com/guides/how-to-cut-down-subscriber-
churn/
[21] What Is Subscription Churn and How to Reduce It, Adyen, 2023. [Online]. Available: https://www.adyen.com/knowledge-
hub/subscription-churn
[22] Yue Chen, “The Subscription Economy: Implications for Valuation and Earnings Management,” Columbia Business School, 2023.
[Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[23] Evan Tarver, Subscription Business Model Defined, How It Works, Examples, Investopedia, 2015. [Online]. Available:
https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/042715/how-do-subscription-business-models-work.asp
[24] Chris Cahill, Software Licensing Models and Types: Your Complete Guide, Revenera Blog, 2023. [Online]. Available:
https://www.revenera.com/blog/software-monetization/software-licensing-models-types/
[25] Elie Ofek, Subscription Models: Recurring Revenues for Lasting Growth, Harvard Business School Case Collection, 2023. [Online].
Available: https://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Pages/item.aspx?num=64200
[26] Generative AI and LLMs for Sales: Today’s Impact and Tomorrow’s Opportunities, Convoso, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.convoso.com/blog/generative-ai-llms-for-sales/
[27] The SaaS Subscription Model Explained: How It Drives Growth, WithOrb, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.withorb.com/blog/saas-subscription-model
[28] Key Challenges and Solutions of B2B Subscription Management in 2024, SubscriptionFlow, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.subscriptionflow.com/2023/09/mastering-b2b-subscription-billing/
[29] Challenges of Developing a B2C Subscription App, Reddit, 2023. [Online]. Available:
https://www.reddit.com/r/SaaS/comments/13iq1sp/challenges_of_developing_a_b2c_subscription_app/
[30] Jeevan Ram Sattoor, The Smartest B2C Subscription Business Model, Magnaquest. 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.magnaquest.com/the-smartest-b2c-subscription-business-model/
[31] Subscriber Churn: How to Reduce and Retain Customers, Zuora, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.zuora.com/glossary/subscriber-churn/
[32] What Is a Subscription Revenue Model and How Does It Work?, Paddle, 2016. [Online]. Available:
https://www.paddle.com/resources/subscription-revenue-model
[33] Tiff Regaudie, How to Use a Churn Prediction Models to Forecast and Increase Retention, Klaviyo, 2023. [Online]. Available:
https://www.klaviyo.com/blog/predicting-churn-risk-our-new-model
[34] How Can Academics Use GenAI in Their Research?, AACSB International, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.aacsb.edu/insights/articles/2024/07/how-can-academics-use-genai-in-their-research
[35] 7 SaaS Subscription Model Options for Your Business, Maxio, 2024. [Online]. Available: https://www.maxio.com/blog/7-saas-
subscription-model-options-for-your-business
Bihag Karnani / IJCTT, 72(12), 179-193, 2024
191
[36] Yogesh K. Dwivedi et al., “Opinion Paper: “So What If ChatGPT Wrote It?” Multidisciplinary Perspectives on Opportunities,
Challenges and Implications of Generative Conversational AI for Research, Practice and Policy,” International Journal of Information
Management, vol. 71, pp. 1-63, 2023. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[37] Reena Aggarwal, 5 Recurring Billing Challenges and How to Overcome Them, StartupNation, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://startupnation.com/manage-your-business/5-recurring-billing-challenges-and-how-to-overcome-them/
[38] The Top Challenges of B2B Subscriptions, AboWire, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://www.abowire.com/post/the-top-challenges-of-
b2b-subscriptions
[39] Thomas K.F. Chiu et al., “Teacher Support and Student Motivation to Learn with Artificial Intelligence (AI) Based Chatbot,”
Educational Technology and Society, vol. 37, no. 7, pp. 3240-3256, 2023. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[40] Beirit Harvey, Subscription-Based Business? Here’s What Not to Do, DealHub, 2022. [Online]. Available:
https://dealhub.io/blog/subscription-management/problems-subscription-process/
[41] Unraveling the Challenges of Disconnected B2C Sales and Marketing Teams, Invoca, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.invoca.com/blog/challenges-disconnected-sales-marketing
[42] How Gen AI and Subscription Models Are Reshaping the IT Landscape: Insights from Gartner Report, Flexera, 2024. [Online].
Available: https://www.flexera.com/blog/it-asset-management/how-gen-ai-and-subscription-models-are-reshaping-the-it-landscape-
insights-from-gartner-report/
[43] 7 Tips to Reduce Customer Churn for DTC Subscription Businesses, Smartrr, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://smartrr.com/blog/reduce-customer-churn-subscriptions
[44] Brady D. Lund et al., “ChatGPT and a New Academic Reality: Artificial Intelligence-Written Research Papers and The Ethics of The
Large Language Models in Scholarly Publishing,” Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, vol. 74, no. 5,
pp. 570-581, 2023. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[45] Pranab Sachithanandan, From SaaS to StitchFix: A Look Back at the History of the Subscription Model, Upscribe, 2021. [Online].
Available: https://www.upscribe.io/blog/from-saas-to-stitchfix-a-look-back-at-the-history-of-the-subscription-model/
[46] Vinod Kumar, and Gagandeep Raheja, “Business to Business (B2B) and Business to Consumer (B2C) Management,” International
Journal of Computers and Technology, vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 447-451, 2012. [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[47] The Differences between B2B and B2C Research, B2B International, 2020. [Online]. Available:
https://www.b2binternational.com/publications/b2b-research-versus-b2c-research/
[48] The Future of GenAI Pricing Metrics and Models, Zuora, 2024. [Online]. Available: https://www.zuora.com/resource/the-future-of-
genai-pricing-metrics-and-models/
[49] Thimothy Samuel, Top 10 Challenges in B2B Sales And How to Overcome Them, OneIMS, 2023. [Online]. Available:
https://oneims.com/blog/challenges-in-b2b-sales
[50] Iocabucci Sergio, Closing the Deal: Transforming B2B Sales with GenAI, Digital Commerce 360, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.digitalcommerce360.com/2024/09/20/closing-the-deal-transforming-b2b-sales-with-genai/
[51] Generative AI in Academic Research, Cornell Research and Innovation, 2023. [Online]. Available: https://research-and-
innovation.cornell.edu/generative-ai-in-academic-research/
[52] News Outlets Should Build Customer Lifetime Value into Subscription Strategy, Researchers Say, Local News Initiative, 2020.
[Online]. Available: https://localnewsinitiative.northwestern.edu/posts/2020/01/02/customer-lifetime-value-subscribers/
[53] Hall Brian, 321 Real-World Gen AI Use Cases from the World’s Leading Organizations, Google Cloud, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://cloud.google.com/transform/101-real-world-generative-ai-use-cases-from-industry-leaders?hl=en
[54] Adolfo Maga et al., How to Accelerate the GenAI Revolution in Sales, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.bcg.com/publications/2024/how-to-accelerate-gen-ai-sales-revolution
[55] Liz Ticon, Generative AI for Business: A New Frontier for Efficiency, Eweek, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.eweek.com/artificial-intelligence/generative-ai-for-business/
[56] How GenAI Can Transform Sales by Unlocking Customer Insights, Deloitte Digital, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.deloittedigital.com/nordics/en/insights/perspective/genai-transform-sales-customer-insights.html
[57] Mohamad Elmasri et al., AI in 2023: Turing Experts on the Advances You May Have Missed, The Alan Turing Institute, 2023.
[Online]. Available: https://www.turing.ac.uk/blog/ai-2023-turing-experts-advances-you-may-have-missed
[58] Phillip Andersen, GenAI and the Path to Profit in B2B Sales, BCG Global, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.bcg.com/publications/2024/genai-path-to-b2b-sales-profit
[59] Mark Haranas, The 10 Coolest AI Tools and GenAI Products of 2023, CRN, 2023. [Online]. Available:
https://www.crn.com/news/cloud/the-10-coolest-ai-tools-and-genai-products-of-2023
[60] Ema Lukan, Everything You Need to Know About Generative AI in 2024, Synthesia, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.synthesia.io/post/generative-ai
Bihag Karnani / IJCTT, 72(12), 179-193, 2024
192
[61] Robinson+Cole’s, Generative AI Poses Unique Risks to Data Security, NIST Warns, Data Privacy + Cybersecurity Insider, 2024.
[Online]. Available: https://www.dataprivacyandsecurityinsider.com/2024/05/generative-ai-poses-unique-risks-to-data-security-nist-
warns/
[62] Tiago Oliveira et al., “Understanding SaaS Adoption: The Moderating Impact of the Environment Context,” International Journal of
Information Management, vol. 49, pp. 1-12, 2019. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[63] Angela Davenport, Using AI for Product Personalization: How AI Enhances Your Customer Experience, EFulfillment Service, 2024.
[Online]. Available: https://www.efulfillmentservice.com/2024/11/using-ai-for-product-personalization-how-ai-enhances-your-
customer-experience/
[64] L. Wilson, IoT and the Subscription Economy: New Opportunities and Challenges, Journal of Business Innovation, 2023. [Online].
Available: https://www.iotbusinessinnovation.com/iot-and-the-subscription-economy-new-opportunities-and-challenges
[65] Shuchen Tang, Haoming Zhu, “Mitigating Bias in Generative AI: a Comprehensive Framework for Governance and Accountability,”
Law Ethics Journal, vol. 1, no. 3, pp. 1-19, 2024. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[66] “AI’s Mysterious “Black Box” Problem, Explained.” University of Michigan-Dearborn, 2023. [Online]. Available:
https://umdearborn.edu/news/ais-mysterious-black-box-problem-explained
[67] The Ultimate Guide to B2C Subscription Customer Acquisition, Zuora, 2024. [Online]. Available: https://www.zuora.com/guides/the-
ultimate-guide-to-b2c-subscription-customer-acquisition/
[68] Jay Jackson, How to Use Content Marketing to Reduce SaaS Customer Churn, Linkedin, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/how-use-content-marketing-reduce-saas-customer-churn-jay-jackson-goraf/
[69] Diego Alamir, The Best B2B Acquisition Strategies According to Experts, Hubspot, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://blog.hubspot.com/service/b2b-customer-acquisition-strategy
[70] Christian Kowalkowski, and Wolfgang Ulaga, “Subscription Offers in Business-To-Business Markets: Conceptualization, Taxonomy,
And Framework for Growth,” Industrial Marketing Management, vol. 117, pp. 440-456, 2024. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher
Link]
[71] David Medero, Leveraging Audience Segmentation for Subscription Business Success, Zuora, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.zuora.com/2023/11/01/leveraging-audience-segmentation-subscription-business-success/
[72] Farid Hashemian, Negar Maleki, and Yasser Zeinali, “From User Behavior to Subscription Sales: An Insight into E-Book Platform
Leveraging Customer Segmentation and A/B Testing,” Services Marketing Quarterly, vol. 45, no. 2, pp. 153-181, 2024. [CrossRef]
[Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[73] Will Webster, What is Psychographic Segmentation? A Beginner’s Guide, Qualtrics, 2023. [Online]. Available:
https://www.qualtrics.com/en-au/experience-management/brand/psychographic-segmentation/
[74] Eva Bucherer, and Dieter Uckelmann, Business Models for the Internet of Things, Architecting the Internet of Things, pp. 253-277,
2011. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[75] Bo Li, and Subodha Kumar, “Managing Software‐as‐a‐Service: Pricing and Operations,” Production and Operations Management,
[CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[76] Kyle Poyar, Usage-Based Pricing Is a Company-Wide Effort, Techcrunch, 2021. [Online]. Available:
https://techcrunch.com/2021/12/09/usage-based-pricing-is-a-companywide-effort-not-a-pricing-strategy/
[77] Rohan Ayyar, Smart Pricing Strategies for Generating Higher Conversions, MarketingProfs, 2015. [Online]. Available:
https://www.marketingprofs.com/articles/2015/27822/smart-pricing-strategies-for-generating-higher-conversions-part-2-of-2
[78] Tatjana Christen et al., “Value-Based Pricing in Digital Platforms: A Machine Learning Approach to Signaling Beyond Core Product
Attributes in Cross-Platform Settings,” Journal of Business Research, vol. 152, pp. 82-92, 2022. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar]
[Publisher Link]
[79] Robert R. Harmon et al., “Pricing Strategies for Information Technology Services: A Value-Based Approach,” 42nd Hawaii
International Conference on System Sciences, Waikoloa, HI, USA, pp. 1-10, 2009. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[80] State of subscriptions Media and Entertaiment, Recurly, 2024. [Online]. Available: https://recurly.com/content/state-of-subscriptions-
media-entertainment/
[81] Clarence L. Wardell III, Laura Wynter, and Mary Helander, “Capacity and Value-Based Pricing Model for Professional Services,”
Journal of Pricing and Revenue Management, vol. 7, no. 4, pp. 326-340, 2008. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[82] Align Subscription Pricing to Customer Value with Volume Usage Tiers, Gartner, 2020. [Online]. Available:
https://www.gartner.com/en/documents/3981942
[83] How can transparency in pricing enhance customer trust and loyalty? Vorecol, 2022. [Online]. Available: https://psico-
smart.com/en/blogs/blog-how-can-transparency-in-pricing-enhance-customer-trust-and-loyalty-
148691#:~:text=A%20recent%20study%20by%20the,translates%20into%20long%2Dterm%20profitability.
[84] Cheng-Han Wu, and Ling-Ya Huang, “Dynamic Subscription Pricing for Digital Service Platform,” IIAI Letters on Business and
Decision Science, vol. 4, pp. 1-8, 2024. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
Bihag Karnani / IJCTT, 72(12), 179-193, 2024
193
[85] Rai Poquiz, Usage-Based Pricing Model Implementation, Challenges, and Solutions, DigitalRoute, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.digitalroute.com/blog/usage-based-pricing-model-implementation/
[86] Ivelina Pencheva, Customer Education Best Practices: A Guide to Get You Started, Helpcenter.io, 2022. [Online]. Available:
https://helpcenter.io/blog/customer-education-best-practices-a-guide-to-get-you-started/
[87] Cheng Chou, and Vineet Kumar, “Estimating Demand for Subscription Products: Identification of Willingness to Pay Without Price
Variation,” Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences, vol. 43, no. 4, pp. 697-923, 2024. [CrossRef] [Google
Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[88] Mostafa Daoud, Effective Customer Retention Strategies: A Complete Guide, ECens, 2024. [Online]. Available: https://e-
cens.com/blog/enhancing-customer-retention-with-data-driven-marketing/
[89] Wesley Dante Mitchell, “Proactive Predictive Analytics within the Customer Lifecycle to Prevent Customer Churn,” Northcentral
University, Dissertations and Theses, pp. 1-24, 2020. [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[90] Thanasis Vafeiadis et al., “A Comparison of Machine Learning Techniques for Customer Churn Prediction,” Simulation Modelling
Practice and Theory, vol. 55, pp. 1-9, 2024. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[91] Vasudeva Akula, The Proactive Edge: Leveraging AI For Customer Retention Success, Forbes, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.forbes.com/councils/forbestechcouncil/2024/05/02/the-proactive-edge-leveraging-ai-for-customer-retention-success/
[92] Nidhi Arora et al., The Value of Getting Personalization Right-Or Wrong-Is Multiplying, McKinsey and Company, 2021. [Online].
Available: https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/growth-marketing-and-sales/our-insights/the-value-of-getting-personalization-
right-or-wrong-is-multiplying
[93] Customer Journey Analytics: Best Practices and Insights, Fullstory, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.fullstory.com/blog/customer-journey-analytics/
[94] Richard Lee, Cam Rungie, and Malcolm Wright, “Regularities in the Consumption of a Subscription Service,” Journal of Product and
Brand Management, vol. 20, no. 3, pp. 182-189, 2023. [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[95] Chidozie Simon Mgbemena, “A Data-Driven Framework for Investigating Customer Retention,” Brunel University London, Doctoral
Thesis, pp. 1-178, 2016. [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[96] Tochukwu Ignatius Ijomah et al., “The Role of Big Data Analytics in Customer Relationship Management: Strategies for Improving
Customer Engagement and Retention,” World Journal of Advanced Science and Technology, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 13-24, 2024. [CrossRef]
[Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[97] Benedikt Wedenik, Why Data Quality Is the Key to Success with Your Customer Data Platform, Adobe Experience Cloud, 2024.
[Online]. Available: https://business.adobe.com/blog/perspectives/why-data-quality-is-the-key-to-success-with-your-customer-data-
platform
[98] Danny Cruz, How Customer Success Teams Can Drive Retention, CMSWIRE, 2023. [Online]. Available:
https://www.cmswire.com/customer-experience/how-customer-success-teams-can-drive-retention/
[99] Gartner Survey Finds Generative AI Is Now the Most Frequently Deployed AI Solution in Organizations, Gartner, 2024. [Online].
Available: https://www.gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/2024-05-07-gartner-survey-finds-generative-ai-is-now-the-most-
frequently-deployed-ai-solution-in-organizations
[100] The Future of Subscriptions, Zuora, 2024. [Online]. Available: https://www.zuora.com/guides/the-future-of-subscriptions/
[101] Frank Greer, What Is the IoT Subscription Model, and What Are Its Benefits?, Zipit, 2021. [Online]. Available:
https://www.zipitwireless.com/blog/what-is-the-iot-subscription-model-and-what-are-its-benefits
[102] Americans Choose Sustainability Over Brand Loyalty in New Survey, Environment Energy Leader, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.environmentenergyleader.com/stories/americans-choose-sustainability-over-brand-loyalty-in-new-survey,1127
[103] Amelia Fletcher et al., “Consumer Protection for Online Markets and Large Digital Platforms,” Yale Journal on Regulation, vol. 40,
no. 3, pp. 875-914, 2023. [Google Scholar] [Publisher Link]
[104] Annual Progress Report on Meeting the Targets for Cross-border Payments: 2024 Report on Key Performance Indicators, Financial
Stability Board, 2024. [Online]. Available: https://www.fsb.org/2024/10/annual-progress-report-on-meeting-the-targets-for-cross-
border-payments-2024-report-on-key-performance-indicators/
[105] The Biggest Product Adoption Challenges You Need to Know About, The CloudShare Team, 2024. [Online]. Available:
https://www.cloudshare.com/blog/product-adoption-challenges/
