Digital Humanities & Heritage PDF Free Download

1 / 217
0 viewsโ€ข217 pages

Digital Humanities & Heritage PDF Free Download

Digital Humanities & Heritage PDF free Download. Think more deeply and widely.

DIGITAL
HUMANITIES
& HERITAGE
DIGITAL HUMANITIES & HERITAGE
Edited by Koraljka Kuzman ล logar
and Anamarija ลฝugiฤ‡ Boriฤ‡
Edited by Koraljka Kuzman ล logar and Anamarija ลฝugiฤ‡ Boriฤ‡
The conference proceedings
Digital Humanities & Heritage
represent an exceptionally
valuable contribution to the study of digital humanities and the preservation of cultural
heritage. Through an interdisciplinary approach and the innovative application of advanced
digital tools, the collection offers a deep insight into the latest research and practices in
this dynamic area. The scholarly value of these proceedings is evident in several key areas:
the application of advanced digital tools such as Building Information Modelling (BIM) and
the International Image Interoperability Framework (IIIF); the development and implemen-
tation of new methodologies, including semantic modelling and approaches aimed at en-
hancing access to digital collections; and the support for scholarly research by providing
essential sources and information for its implementation. The diversity of topics makes
these proceedings relevant not only to the academic community but also to a broad-
er audience interested in digital humanities and cultural heritage. Particularly impressive
is the focus on accessibility and the comprehensibility of materials for different target
groups, reflecting the authorsโ€™ commitment to promoting inclusivity and open access to
knowledge. This collection is essential reading for anyone engaged in digital humanities
and cultural heritage, serving as a significant source of information and knowledge in this
rapidly growing field.
Boris Bosanฤiฤ‡
Josip Juraj Strossmayer University of Osijek,
Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences in Osijek, Croatia
Digital humanities is an emerging and innovative field, and activities within it need to
be disseminated through publications of this kind: international and interdisciplinary.
Digital Humanities & Heritage
demonstrates the commitment of the Croatian scholarly
community to this global scholarly turn.
Cรฉcile Chantraine Braillon
La Rochelle University, France
Price: 25 EUR
Digital Humanities & Heritage
1st and 2nd DARIAH-HR International Conference
Zadar, Croatia โ€“ Rijeka, Croatia
13โ€“15 October 2021 โ€“ 12โ€“14 October 2022
Publisher
Institute of Ethnology and Folklore Research
University of Zadar, Department of Information Sciences
DARIAH-EU
For the publisher
Iva Niemฤiฤ‡
Josip Fariฤiฤ‡
Toma Tasovac
Editors
Koraljka Kuzman ล logar, Anamarija ลฝugiฤ‡ Boriฤ‡
Proofreading
Marta Brkljaฤiฤ‡
Layout
Vesna Beader
Cover design
Anja Tkalec
ISBN 978-953-8518-10-2
This book was funded with the support of the Ministry of Science, Education and Youth.
Zagreb โ€“ Zadar โ€“ Paris 2024
Zagreb โ€“ Zadar โ€“ Paris 2024
Digital Humanities & Heritage
Proceedings of the 1st and 2nd DARIAH-HR
International Conference
Digital Humanities & Heritage
Zadar โ€“ Rijeka, Croatia 2021 โ€“ 2022
Edited by
Koraljka Kuzman ล logar
and Anamarija ลฝugiฤ‡ Boriฤ‡
CONTENTS
Toma Tasovac
A Note from the DARIAH Director 7
Koraljka Kuzman ล logar, Anamarija ลฝugiฤ‡ Boriฤ‡
Introduction 9
1. Susan Schreibman, Kelly Gillikin Schoueri
3D Digital Scholarly Editions: The Text as Object 15
2. Stefano Cursi, Letizia Martinelli, Filippo Calcerano,
Michele Calvano, Luciano Cessari, Elena Gigliarelli
Digital Processes for the Conservation and Valorisation
of Built Heritage 33
3. Mirna Willer
Relevance of โ€œScienti๎Ÿ–c and Cultural Informationโ€
for Digital Humanities 59
4. Daniel Ihrmark, Zoi Tsiviltidou
Analysing Online Horror Fiction with Corpus Linguistic
Techniques for Engaging Museum Labels: Creepypasta
Wiki and the House of Terrorโ€™s Mobile Application 73
5. Natasa Thoudam
The Gender of AI-Generated Arts in Sarah Kenderdineโ€™s
โ€œDeep Fakesโ€ and Aishatu Gwadabeโ€™s AI Artivism 97
6. Danijela Birt Katiฤ‡, Martina Kriviฤ‡ Lekiฤ‡
Teachers as Creators of Ethnographic Knowledge โ€“
Presentation of Collected Material in a Digital Environment 115
7. Edward J. Gray
Adapting English-Language Pedagogy to Cultural
Heritage and Digital Humanities in France: Results
from using the IIIF Online Workshop with Future
Research Engineers, Librarians, and Archivists 133
8. Elena Lazarenko, Aleksandr Riaposov
Community versus Corpus: Accessible Language
Resources for Indigenous Speaker Communities as
a Way to Preserve and Promote Cultural Heritage 145
9. Laura Grzunov, Marta Ivanoviฤ‡, Marijana Tomiฤ‡
Enhancing Access to Digitised Glagolitic Material
of Zadar County Through GlagoLab Portal 163
10. Martina Petrinoviฤ‡
Participatory Mapping of the Cultural Heritage in
the Mountain Region of Gorski Kotar in Croatia 185
11. Miha Seruฤnik
Slovenian Historical Topography: A Medievalistโ€™s Gazetteer 199
7
A NOTE FROM THE DARIAH
DIRECTOR
The application of digital methods in the traditional humanistic disci-
plines has ushered in a new era of scholarly exploration, preservation,
and understanding. The digital humanities, a dynamic interdisciplin-
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎กฝ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎•๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚
cultural heritage, and how we question and interpret our identities.
The DARIAH-HR International Conference Digital Humanities &
Heritage stands as a testament to the diversity, creativity and innova-
tive potential of humanistic inquiry using cutting-edge technologies.
๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎™๎™ฟ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขด๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
Digital Research Infrastructure for the Arts and Humanities (DARIAH-
๎˜ฆ๎š๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎ขฃ
๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ-
tral services โ€“ such as DARIAH-Campus๎กพ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šƒ๎™๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎œผ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž2
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎ค๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚โ€“๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎™๎™ฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜๎ขด๎œผ๎œ”๎ขด
๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ค๎œ”๎–๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขด๎›‘๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎ค๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎กพ https://campus.dariah.eu/.
2 ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎œด๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎ขฃ๎›•๎๎ขฉ๎œด๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขด๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎ขด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎œผ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•.
8
๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช-
๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
process a myriad of data formats, etc.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
commercial interests, who may not care as much as we do โ€“ as schol-
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚โ€“ ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œด๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ
Building infrastructures for arts and humanities is particularly chal-
๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
qualitative and quantitative methods. Traditionally, the humanistic da-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎ขด๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎ขด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚
help us develop a more comprehensive understanding of human cul-
ture, heritage, values, and identities.
๎™…๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎™“๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™“๎๎Ÿ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎š…๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎™๎™ฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚
as well as all the authors, reviewers, and participants who have con-
๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎™๎™ฟ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚Digital
Humanities & Heritage๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎›Š๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
may we all, sooner rather than later, meet again!
Toma Tasovac
President of the DARIAH Board of Directors
9
INTRODUCTION
KORALJKA KUZMAN ล LOGAR,
ANAMARIJA ลฝUGIฤ† BORIฤ†
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›•๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
gaining recognition, informally yet impactfully, as a dynamic area of
scholarly inquiry, particularly following our nationโ€™s alignment with the
๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎˜ฆ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜œ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
has catalysed a heightened awareness and propelled the advancement
of digital humanities, fostering investment in educational initiatives,
research endeavours, and the development of cutting-edge digital
tools and methodologies across the humanities, social sciences, and
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”-
tential of digital humanities, enriching the academic community and
๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
innovate and revolutionise traditional humanities scholarship.
๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘-
scape of digital technologies, contemporary research methodologies,
and advanced analytical and synthetic practices. Concurrently, there
๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขฒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎ขฒ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎˜‚
operating within its distinct paradigms. This plurality of perspectives,
while presenting a challenge, also holds the promise of enhancing col-
๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎›Š๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚
scholarly pursuits.
The idea of initiating the Digital Humanities & Heritage ๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎™๎™๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ-
๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎™๎™๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎—๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
KORALJKA KUZMAN ล LOGAR, ANAMARIJA ลฝUGIฤ† BORIฤ†
10
๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚
archival science, and cultural resource management in museums, this
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต-
ties and cultural heritage. The DHH conference advocates for a para-
digm shift, urging the adoption of digital technologies not merely as
๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚
equip ourselves to comprehensively understand, preserve, and explore
๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
adapting to the dynamic interplay of technology and human inquiry in
our modern world.
The core principles guiding DARIAHโ€™s initiatives, as well as this
๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ-
๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œ”๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
academic exchange and acts as a catalyst for fostering deeper under-
standing, innovation, and participation within the scholarly, artistic,
and cultural communities. Consequently, this conferenceโ€™s primary
๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎-
๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
aims to drive a shift toward an approach that is open, inclusive, and
dynamic.
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
and interactions, we aim to cultivate an environment that promotes the
๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ-
๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎ค๎๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚
for advancing progress.
11
INTRODUCTION
๎™๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎™๎™ฟ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ-
ence Digital Humanities & Heritage๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎™๎™๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ-
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
understanding of digital humanities when it is applied to cultural heri-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
landscape.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎™๎™๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎™๎™๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎˜ฆ๎š๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ-
๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขด๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ-
๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
and relevance. The authors of these articles are scholars and experts
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†-
๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚
and methodologies are reshaping our understanding and manage-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎›Š๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œด-
ing their potential to create a new, multimodal space for research and
๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šค๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎-
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
KORALJKA KUZMAN ล LOGAR, ANAMARIJA ลฝUGIฤ† BORIฤ†
12
digital technologies on heritage sciences, particularly in the areas of
survey, representation, modelling, and information management, high-
lighting the importance of preserving digital resources to prevent data
๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™ฟ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎ขพ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฟ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ-
๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™…๎•๎œ”๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
cultural heritage.
The next two articles investigate the intersection of digital narra-
tives and artistic practices, highlighting how digital content and meth-
๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ข๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎-
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฎ๎œ”๎›ต๎˜‚๎š‹๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎›‘๎œ”๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขด๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎ขด๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œŒ-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขด๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎ขด๎˜ป๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขพ๎˜ข๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎˜‚๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎ขด๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
technology.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
dissemination of cultural heritage through educational initiatives,
concentrating on how historical and ethnographic data are collected,
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎š‹๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎™“๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™“๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›•๎œƒ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™ผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข†๎ข„๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข‚๎ข๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎š๎˜ž๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
13
INTRODUCTION
๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎ค๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
aims to popularise ethnology through a digital platform. The article
๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขด๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎›‘๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ข๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎š‹๎™๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™–๎ขฟ๎˜ง๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
valorising cultural heritage.
The following two articles showcase the potential of the digital
environment in enriching and safeguarding endangered or extinct lin-
guistic cultures. They emphasise the development of user-friendly dig-
๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚
๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎๎œด๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›•๎œƒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œ”๎•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎Ÿ๎๎œ๎œ”๎•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™…๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›ต๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎๎›๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
KORALJKA KUZMAN ล LOGAR, ANAMARIJA ลฝUGIฤ† BORIฤ†
14
๎š‹๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด-
๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
names and geographical features, especially in regions where multiple
๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขด๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ
Through Digital Humanities & Heritage๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
technological advancement, where the past informs the present, and
innovation paves the way for a richer, more inclusive understanding of
our shared cultural heritage.
15
3D DIGITAL SCHOLARLY
EDITIONS: THE TEXT AS
OBJECT
SUSAN SCHREIBMAN
Maastricht University, Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences
Maastricht, The Netherlands
s.schreibman@maastrichtuniversity.nl
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8782-0794
KELLY GILLIKIN SCHOUERI
Maastricht University, Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences
Maastricht, The Netherlands
k.gillikinschoueri@maastrichtuniversity.nl
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6350-2380
Digital scholarly editions have a long history in the area of digital
๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
digital scholarly edition is novel, it has the potential to re-imagine
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘-
๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
studied within a multimodal and archontic space for inscription and
investigation.
๎™“๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ-
ship, annotation, apparatus, paradata, long-term preservation, virtual
research environment
INTRODUCTION
๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•-
๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
Original scienti๎Ÿ–c paper
SUSAN SCHREIBMAN, KELLY GILLIKIN SCHOUERI
16
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ (including The Rossetti Archive, The
๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜ป๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎•๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฅ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”-
๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›ซ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
to contextualise, analyse and display, as well as, particularly over the
๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚
creation. In short, a rationale for digital scholarly editions is to create
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช-
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ผ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎Ÿ๎œ”๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
The development of digital scholarly editions created an environ-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ-
๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
terms, the digital archive is a space for gathering together texts on a
๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•-
ation into a multimodal and archontic space for inscription and inves-
๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎›Š๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ-
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎˜๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฑ๎กพ or test hypotheses of, for instance,
๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎œฐ๎๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎œ”๎›Š๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎–๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎˜-
potheses or conclusions utilising the model are developed, researchers
tend to write traditional scholarly articles in which the three-dimen-
๎กพ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎กพ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎ขฃ๎œ๎œด๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎œ”๎—๎ขฃ๎šฒ๎›‹๎ขฃ๎๎œƒ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎กพ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎ขฉ๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•.
17
3D DIGITAL SCHOLARLY EDITIONS: THE TEXT AS OBJECT
๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎ค๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎ขด๎›‘๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
the realism and detail generated through realistic texture materials
and accurate lighting simulations create an illusory nature as accurate
๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ฆ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
of presenting their research in a more dynamic modality, often contex-
๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šง๎œ”๎๎š‹๎๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
derivatives are appealing due to their general ease of use and dissemi-
๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”-
๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎›Š๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎๎›ซ-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎ขด๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฃ2 Currently,
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎-
๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ-
๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎ขด๎˜œ๎™ฃ๎˜บ๎™ฃ๎™ฟ๎™œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ผ๎›ต๎œผ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™๎›ต๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›ต๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎˜ฆ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šƒ๎ข€๎˜ข๎™ผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎ขด๎๎œญ-
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ-
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ-
๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œญ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขด๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขด๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
2 https://tei-c.org/.
SUSAN SCHREIBMAN, KELLY GILLIKIN SCHOUERI
18
๎™ผ๎š๎™ฟ๎˜ฆ๎ข€๎˜ข๎ข€๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎œผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎˜ข๎™…๎ขด๎šƒ๎šƒ๎™๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎™ผ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
FROM SCHOLARLY EDITIONS TO 3D DIGITAL SCHOLARLY
EDITIONS
The roles inherent in digital scholarly editions, particularly those that
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขด๎›‹๎๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
the novel Ulysses๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™…๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎˜๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎™‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎˜๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
the edition of Ulysses๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™‘๎œ”๎˜๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข…๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
As editor of this edition, ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
of the text through the editorial process, correcting errors introduced
๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”-
nale for these edits, as well as augmenting the text with annotation
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚
personal, and literary.
๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
text, who then is the author? If the model is a reproduction of, for ex-
๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขค๎˜‚๎™…๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขค๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขค๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎ขค๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ†๎ขค๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜›๎œฐ๎๎œด๎šฒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
pos๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎ข€ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ข€๎›‘๎ขฃ๎›•๎๎ขฉ.
19
3D DIGITAL SCHOLARLY EDITIONS: THE TEXT AS OBJECT
๎œด๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎–๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
to different textual traditions, with editors interpreting the manuscript
๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šค๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎œ”๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ-
tions of modelled physical artefacts created with different methods (e.g.,
๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œด๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฉ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
the digitisation and processing process according to theories of the text
๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›•๎œผ๎›‹๎ขฃ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎˜๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ฃฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
ANNOTATION FOR 3D DIGITAL SCHOLARLY EDITIONS
๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎๎Ÿ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ขด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
long-standing textual practices such as annotation, apparatus, and com-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
SUSAN SCHREIBMAN, KELLY GILLIKIN SCHOUERI
20
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ-
๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎˜๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ขค๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขค๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎›•๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎˜๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š-
๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
๎ฃ๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†-
๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™๎๎๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚
annotation (e.g., camera views, hypothesis layers, certainty index lay-
๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ”๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด-
๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ-
๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต-
ties and environments for annotation raise new issues, such as how to
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
editions, as well as for the scholarly record.
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ค๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ค๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฉ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ค๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚
contemporary analogies to the siteโ€™s region and period. Archaeologists
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ-
nologies have improved in that we can create photorealistic models. In
these cases, archaeologists have used different methods to signal the
๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
21
3D DIGITAL SCHOLARLY EDITIONS: THE TEXT AS OBJECT
material or colour as oppose๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎ขด๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜›๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎˜-
๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎˜๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ค๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด-
๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ฃ๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ฃ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎—๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฉ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
structure. The musicologist/modellers might speculate on the sonic
๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‘๎˜๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต-
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ point of view.
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎—๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎œผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šค๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขด๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ฃฒ๎˜‚๎™๎๎๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
SUSAN SCHREIBMAN, KELLY GILLIKIN SCHOUERI
22
In the case of archaeological research, archaeologists typically collect
information during the excavation to document their process. Yet, in
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜›๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ข†๎ข…๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
over years, documenting the excavation process. After an excavation
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎-
๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎›•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎šฒ๎–-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›‹๎ขฃ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
vast amounts of materials collected. To this end, the role of the editor,
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎˜๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎๎๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด:
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฑ๎ขจ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚
๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด-
๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฑ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™–๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ
Thus the goal is that the edition should supply users with the tools,
apparatus and annotation to understand, contest, and learn from the
๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”-
cesses of ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
23
3D DIGITAL SCHOLARLY EDITIONS: THE TEXT AS OBJECT
DEVELOPING A 3D DIGITAL SCHOLARLY EDITION
๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎˜๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
there is still the technical challenge of holding all this information in
๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ-
ply, or only, what the user interacts with, it is also the infrastructure
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขจ
๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
the interface, as well as information contained in the annotation and
๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขจ
๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚
created, as well as the metadata and paradata.
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎š๎™ฟ๎˜ฆ๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
Voyager๎ข๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ-
sive and engaging way๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜œ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
for the Arts and Humanities๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚
๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™๎šƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎œผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ข„
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด-
๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
sustained.
๎ข ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œด๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎›Š๎ขฃ๎›ต๎œ”๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œญ๎œ”๎ขด๎•๎œ”๎˜๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฉ.
๎ข‚๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎ข€๎›‘๎ขฃ๎œด๎›ต๎ขฃ๎›•๎›‘๎๎ขฉ.
๎ขƒ https://www.clariah.nl/.
๎ข„ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎œƒ๎œ๎šฒ๎–๎ขฃ๎œ๎œ†๎ขฉ๎›•๎œ๎ขฉ.
SUSAN SCHREIBMAN, KELLY GILLIKIN SCHOUERI
24
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎šค๎œ”๎˜๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ฃฒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ-
๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎ขด๎›‹๎˜๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚
digital scholarly edition is principally concerned with the viewing
layer โ€“ where explicit and implicit forms of annotation are integrated
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚
๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šค๎œ”๎˜๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎Ÿ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎ขฉ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎ขด๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ-
๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
nonlinearly:
๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขจ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎™๎š‹๎™œ๎™–๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎›ต-
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎ขจ๎˜‚
๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎ค๎›•๎—๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ-
era movements and a set of analytic features, such as alternative
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎ขจ๎˜‚
๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
25
3D DIGITAL SCHOLARLY EDITIONS: THE TEXT AS OBJECT
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šค๎œ”๎˜๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎š๎™ฟ๎˜ฆ๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎ขด๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎š๎™ฟ๎˜ฆ๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šค๎œ”๎˜๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚Contested Memories: The Battle of Mount Street Bridge.๎ข…
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ-
๎œด๎๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กพ๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ข๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‘๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎›•๎œผ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™…๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•-
๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต-
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”-
sives and cannons, against which the Irish had little defence (Hughes
๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ-
tle. On the Irish side, this was clear โ€“ four Irish soldiers lost their lives.
๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข‚๎กฝ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข‚๎กฝ๎˜‚
casualties. The goal was to utilise the model to help provide a more de-
๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎ข… ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎กพ๎ข†๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎›ต๎›•๎ขฉ.
SUSAN SCHREIBMAN, KELLY GILLIKIN SCHOUERI
26
was not arrived at via analytics within the model itself as we had origi-
๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎•๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
if the intention of gathering sources was to write a traditional scholarly
article. It was not until the research team engaged with the spatial af-
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด-
๎œญ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กพ๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
team did, or, indeed, arrive at alternative hypotheses. Thus, the idea of
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎ขฃ๎ข†
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†-
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎™…๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•-
๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎ขจ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎ขด๎›Š๎˜๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚
๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†-
timedia, including camera views, to help guide the readerโ€™s attention.
๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
variety of camera positionings contextualised in space. This edition is
intended to test and explore the limits of the Voyager system in terms
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎กพ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ฃ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
from a diverse range of multimedia resources collated from the previ-
๎ข†๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ค๎›•๎—๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
therefore, a different semantic language on how to interact in the space is developed.
๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎๎œด๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎›ต-
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กพ๎กฝ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ข€๎›‘๎ขฃ๎›•๎๎ขฉ๎กฟ๎ข‚๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฉ.
27
3D DIGITAL SCHOLARLY EDITIONS: THE TEXT AS OBJECT
๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚
๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œŒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎™ฟ๎™–๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ-
๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ-
notations within Voyagerโ€™s hotspot annotation and longer articles.
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ค๎›•๎—๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šค๎œ”๎˜๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
guided tour allowed us to provide set camera views in and around
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎™…๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šค๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ข๎ข๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎ข‚๎˜‚ ๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎™…๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šค๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ค๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
SUSAN SCHREIBMAN, KELLY GILLIKIN SCHOUERI
28
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎›ช๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎˜๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎šค๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎š‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šฅ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚
other words, annotation needs to have as its starting point a location on
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™“๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎˜ข๎‚๎œ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
city centre. This annotation utilises documentary and archival sources
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›ซ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
Our theory of the edition was tested during the testing phase of
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎›Š๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ-
riety of multimedia resources only added value to their contextual
๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ-
tions. They also appreciated content which provided individual stories
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
also appreciated as it enlivened the more neutral narrative provided
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
29
3D DIGITAL SCHOLARLY EDITIONS: THE TEXT AS OBJECT
well-achieved through text and multimedia, they did, however, men-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚
the set camera viewing perspectives could have shown more details of
the surrounding environment or representations of the soldiers in the
street, hence providing more implicit visual annotation to help users
in their own interpretations of the environment. These comments re-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
explicit editorial interventions. One comment that several individuals
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต-
ated an audio narration of the text so they could listen to the annota-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
future iterations of the edition.
CONCLUSION
๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
interacts with โ€“ it is the annotative apparatus surrounding that model
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
in providing an environment for scholars to communicate the results
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
textual centre, and for users to interrogate and test their hypothesis
within the virtual research environment created.
REFERENCES LIST
๎˜›๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข…๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Understanding Archaeological Excavation. ๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜›๎˜‚๎š‹๎˜‚
๎˜›๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜›๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•-
๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Virtual Heritage: A Guide๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œƒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎™“๎ข๎˜‚
๎š๎›Š๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎ข€๎ข€๎ข๎ขฉ๎›Š๎›‹๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎›‹ (ac-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎œฐ๎๎œด๎šฒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด-
๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Handbook of
Research on Emerging Technologies for Architectural and Archaeological
Heritage. ๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›ช๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎™…๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎˜ƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎šƒ๎˜ƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎˜ป๎™…๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎œ”๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎ขƒ๎ขณ๎ข†๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†-
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฉ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข…๎ขด๎กพ๎ขด๎ข‚๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข‚๎ขด๎กฝ๎ขƒ๎ข„๎ข‚๎ขด๎กพ๎ขฃ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚
๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
SUSAN SCHREIBMAN, KELLY GILLIKIN SCHOUERI
30
๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œƒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎›ฑip Behind Virtual Her-
๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎˜‚ Eurographics Workshop on Graphics and Cul-
tural Heritage, GCH 2016. ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™–๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข„๎ขณ๎ขƒ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://doi.
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎ข€๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฉ๎›ซ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎กพ๎ข€๎ข…๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜œ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎š‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Cyber-archaeology.
๎™œ๎šฒ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎—๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎™“๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎ข€๎ขณ๎ข„๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎šฒ๎–๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎•๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎-
๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜ข๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด-
๎œด๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ World Archaeology ๎ข€๎ข†๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎ขณ๎ข€๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข…๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข๎ข€๎ข…๎กฟ๎ข๎กฝ๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขƒ๎ข€๎ข†๎ข„ (ac-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ข๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎๎Ÿ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›–๎œ†๎›ต๎—๎˜‚๎˜ป๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚EPZ Thousand Plateaus๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎™“๎ข๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎ฃฏ๎˜œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎™…๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎œ”๎-
๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขด๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Internet Archaeology๎˜‚ ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ https://doi.
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กพ๎กพ๎ข๎กพ๎ขฉ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Litera-
ture Compass๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข๎ข€๎ขณ๎ข‚๎ขƒ๎ขฃ
๎˜ป๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขด๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Ecdotica๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข๎กฟ๎ขณ๎ข‚๎กฝ๎ขฃ
๎˜ป๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šค๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎™ฟ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Virtual
Reality in Geography๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎–๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎™“๎ข๎˜‚
๎š‹๎šฒ๎˜๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎ขณ๎ข€๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎œฐ๎๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎›ฑ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎›Š๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™…๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ Proceedings of the 38th
Annual Conference on Computer Applications and Quantitative Meth-
ods in Archaeology, CAA2010. ๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎—๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎™“๎ข๎˜‚๎˜›๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ข„๎กพ๎ขณ๎ข„๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œƒ๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎˜ฆ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Digital Heritage. EuroMed 2010.
Lecture Notes in Computer Science vol 6436๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎™…๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎œ”๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ป๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ-
๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ข๎ข‚๎กฝ๎ขณ๎ข๎ขƒ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ https://doi.
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฉ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข…๎ขด๎ข€๎ขด๎ขƒ๎ข๎กฟ๎ขด๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ข…๎ข„๎ข€๎ขด๎ข๎ขช๎ข€๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎›Š๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข†๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ British
Journal for Military History๎˜‚ ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›Š๎œ๎œŒ๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฃ
๎šฒ๎›‹๎ขฃ๎๎œƒ๎ขฉ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎ขฉ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎ขฉ๎ข„๎ขƒ๎ข†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™๎๎๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎๎›ซ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎™๎๎›Š๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขด๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ-
๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎ขด๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Open Archaeology๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚
๎ข€๎กพ๎ข๎ขณ๎ข€๎ข€๎ขƒ๎ขฃ
๎™‘๎œ”๎˜๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข…๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚Ulysses, corrected text edited by Hans Walter Gabler. ๎™๎›•๎–๎˜‚
๎šง๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎šƒ๎˜ƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎›•๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ 3D
Data Creation to Curation: Community Standards for 3D Data Preserva-
tion. Chic๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎™–๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎šƒ๎˜ƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ
31
3D DIGITAL SCHOLARLY EDITIONS: THE TEXT AS OBJECT
๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎›ช๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎ขด๎˜ข๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ-
๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œด-
๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฆ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎Ÿ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œƒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขฑ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ Jour-
nal of Archaeological Science๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎ข…๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎ข„๎ข‚๎ขณ๎ข€๎ข…๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ https://doi.
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎œ๎ขฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎ขด๎˜ข๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎˜‚ Spatial Analysis
and Social Spaces: Interdisciplinary Approaches to the Interpretation of
Prehistoric and Historic Built Environments๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎›ช๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต-
๎›•๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎–๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎๎˜๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข€๎ข‚๎ขณ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†-
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ข‚๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฉ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข…๎ข€๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ขƒ๎ข๎ข€๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ข€๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™ผ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎Ÿ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Digital Scholarly Editing: Theories, Models and Methods.
๎™ฟ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ
๎™ผ๎›ต๎œผ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›•๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎ข€๎˜ข๎ขด๎˜œ๎™ฃ๎˜บ๎™ฃ๎™ฟ๎™œ๎ข๎˜‚
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Virtual Archaeology Review๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข๎ข‚๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://doi.
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข๎ข†๎ข†๎ข‚๎ขฉ๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎ข๎ข‚๎ข„๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎›Š๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎ขด
๎˜ข๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Interna-
tional Journal of Digital Humanities๎˜‚๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://
๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฉ๎œด๎ข๎กฟ๎ข…๎กฝ๎ข€๎ขด๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขด๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขด๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎›Š๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šค๎œ”๎˜๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎ข๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขฎ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚Journal of Digital History].
๎š‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Studies in Bibliography๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข†๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ข„๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฃ
๎šค๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ฟ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ The Journal of the European Society for Textual
Scholarship๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข€๎ข€๎ขณ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎กพ๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œƒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›ซ๎›•๎–๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™“๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎ข€๎˜ข๎ข๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎™“๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Near Eastern Archaeology๎˜‚๎ข„๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข€๎ข€๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚
33
DIGITAL PROCESSES FOR
THE CONSERVATION AND
VALORISATION OF BUILT
HERITAGE
STEFANO CURSI
ISPC Institute of Heritage Science,
National Research Council
Montelibretti, Rome, Italy
stefano.cursi@ispc.cnr.it
LETIZIA MARTINELLI
ISPC Institute of Heritage Science,
National Research Council
Montelibretti, Rome, Italy
letizia.martinelli@ispc.cnr.it
FILIPPO CALCERANO
ISPC Institute of Heritage Science,
National Research Council
Montelibretti, Rome, Italy
๎Ÿ–lippo.calcerano@cnr.it
The impact of digital technologies on heritage sciences has increased
the speed and automation of processes and practices aimed at the
survey, representation, modelling, and information management of
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
and disseminated, resulting in data loss, which means loss of connec-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ช๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚genius loci related to
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†-
๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
Preliminary Communication
MICHELE CALVANO
ISPC Institute of Heritage Science,
National Research Council
Montelibretti, Rome, Italy
michele.calvano@ispc.cnr.it
LUCIANO CESSARI
ISPC Institute of Heritage Science,
National Research Council
Montelibretti, Rome, Italy
luciano.cessari@ispc.cnr.it
ELENA GIGLIARELLI
ISPC Institute of Heritage Science,
National Research Council
Montelibretti, Rome, Italy
elena.gigliarelli@cnr.it
STEFANO CURSI, LETIZIA MARTINELLI, FILIPPO CALCERANO, MICHELE CALVANO, LUCIANO CESSARI, ELENA GIGLIARELLI
34
๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
and strategies in the search for information models that can repre-
sent the uniqueness of the architectural heritage, and thus provide
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
correlation with different disciplines and fully reveals its value.
๎™“๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ
INTRODUCTION
The๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
order to prevent any loss or damage, also ensuring that any restoration,
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎œ†๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ
๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
plex, multidisciplinary processes aimed at research, conservation and
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œฐ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด-
๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎ฃ๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™…๎˜œ๎š‹๎ขฑ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
tools for the collection, analysis, production, interpretation, and dis-
๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
digital transformation has paved the way for important methodologi-
cal changes, advancing documentation and conservation processes,
35
DIGITAL PROCESSES FOR THE CONSERVATION AND VALORISATION OF BUILT HERITAGE
favouring participative ac๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•-
๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚
and the decreasing costs of instruments and software have favoured
their diffusion to transdisciplinary communities of practice, increasing
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ-
๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎œฐ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต-
๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ-
mation systems can optimise and integrate conservation, restoration
and enhancement processes, applied at different scales of intervention
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ฃ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด-
semination to the community of researchers and practitioners.
๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎ขด๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ-
๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขด๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚
attention to aspects concerning data exchange among different disci-
๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎œด๎๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚
๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜›๎™๎›ต๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎™…๎šƒ๎™ผ๎˜œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜›๎™๎›ต๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
at improving the semantic enrichment of digital models for the preser-
๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•.
STATE OF THE ART
With the advent of digital transformation, survey activities have un-
๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
STEFANO CURSI, LETIZIA MARTINELLI, FILIPPO CALCERANO, MICHELE CALVANO, LUCIANO CESSARI, ELENA GIGLIARELLI
36
container of information from which to extract different forms of rep-
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ-
veying and modelling and integration with 2D images aimed at cre-
๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎›ต๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™‘๎›ต๎œŒ๎›–๎œ๎›•๎Ÿ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šณ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขด๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎š๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜›๎๎œด๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š๎œ†๎•๎›ถ๎ค๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎™œ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›‹๎˜ป๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด-
๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™–๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎˜๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขจ๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎œ”๎›‹๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎šค๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎•๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
documents and written testimonies, allows us to reconstruct the will
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œ†๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎šฒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›‘๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎˜บ๎˜œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎˜›๎™œ๎šƒ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›Š๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ช๎›ช๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ค๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ-
๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎—๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹-
37
DIGITAL PROCESSES FOR THE CONSERVATION AND VALORISATION OF BUILT HERITAGE
cession of soil layer formation, surface use, masonry construction, and
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎ขด
automatic construction and the mapping of stratigraphic units directly
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎šฒ๎œ๎ฃ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ-
ment of architectural components. We can place within this strand the
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†-
ling created from historical data with procedural modelling developed
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎šฒ๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎Ÿ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
The new generation of tools that support the integration of data
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜›๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™ฃ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
limitations of the traditional 2D system and exploiting the full potential
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฎ๎๎›‹๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎ขด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต-
๎œ”๎๎œด๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šค๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚
who proposed a system for monitoring ashlar masonry walls of historic
๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผhe other hand, proposed two alternatives for creating
STEFANO CURSI, LETIZIA MARTINELLI, FILIPPO CALCERANO, MICHELE CALVANO, LUCIANO CESSARI, ELENA GIGLIARELLI
38
three-dimensional semantic ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎ขด๎›‘๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎šฒ๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎ขด๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฎ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎˜๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขด๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚
ontology deals with the analysis of degradation, its diagnosis, and pos-
๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎œถ๎œƒ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šค๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†-
๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขจ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎Ÿ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™พ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›Š๎›ต๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šง๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎ขด๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขด๎œผ๎œ”๎ขด๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎˜๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™…๎˜บ๎˜œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎˜ข๎˜บ๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎—๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎˜๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎˜‚
๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎œ”๎š‹๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™–๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขจ๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
39
DIGITAL PROCESSES FOR THE CONSERVATION AND VALORISATION OF BUILT HERITAGE
The architecture envisioned for this line of research involves a
๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎˜๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ
DIGITAL STRATEGIES FOR UNDERSTANDING, PRESERVING,
AND SHARING CONSTRUCTIVE KNOWLEDGE
COLLABORATION AND KNOWLEDGE EXCHANGE IN BUILT
HERITAGE PROCESSES
๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
within the complex historical-archaeological framing of an artefact,
๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
the present and facilitate its interpretation.
๎˜บ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
evident how the past decade has witnessed a sharp increase in the use
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
the technological evolution of digital surveying tools and the growing
๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
testing ground.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ-
๎œƒ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขด๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
It is also true that the introduction of new technologies while help-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
STEFANO CURSI, LETIZIA MARTINELLI, FILIPPO CALCERANO, MICHELE CALVANO, LUCIANO CESSARI, ELENA GIGLIARELLI
40
understanding of actors having ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†s, while referring to the
๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ
As already mentioned, however, the architectural heritage sector
๎œด๎๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š-
uted in numerous independent archives, especially regarding unstruc-
tured artistic and cultural heritage. A further element of suffering is
๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ-
tion of models.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ-
๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜›๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎œ”๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎šฒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹-
tors in the process is always a necessary prerequisite for the successful
๎œ”๎๎œผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚
of the ICT tools used, and the synchronisation methods they are forced
to use to exchange information at a high level.
In fact, the proper formalisation of exchanged information and tech-
๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
low-level information exchange, cause and effect of the potential of the
๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎™…๎˜œ๎š‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
their effective communication.
41
DIGITAL PROCESSES FOR THE CONSERVATION AND VALORISATION OF BUILT HERITAGE
It is therefore evident how much the methodologies used to digitise
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•-
๎›•๎œ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎ฃ-
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šค๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขด๎™ฟ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘-
๎›•๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขด๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚
that allows the creation of a coherent conceptual model in which the
๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขด๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚
allow for the representation of semantically more complex associations
and thus for the provision of a high enough level of formalisation to en-
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎๎›Š๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ•๎œŒ๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขด๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚
to create geometries adherent to the needs of specialists involved in
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
what we are going to model is crucial. This requirement aligns with the
STEFANO CURSI, LETIZIA MARTINELLI, FILIPPO CALCERANO, MICHELE CALVANO, LUCIANO CESSARI, ELENA GIGLIARELLI
42
๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚
๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚
contrast, considering the processes that characterise the activities of
๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
to continuous changes, interpretations, uncertanties, and gaps that
๎œŒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘. This limitation also
๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”-
๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚ ๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
experimenting with a path that rediscovers, highlights, and traces the
set of design and construction criteria of those artefacts, analysing the
๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘-
ing process.
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎ฃ๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎™“๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
Below, new modelling approaches and prototypes are illustrated
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎™๎›ต๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
other research institutions, universities, and industrial partners.
DIGITAL APPROACHES FOR BUILT HERITAGE MODELLING
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎•๎›•๎ขด
mentioned issues from different perspectives: the information system
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
43
DIGITAL PROCESSES FOR THE CONSERVATION AND VALORISATION OF BUILT HERITAGE
๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขจ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎ขจ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎˜๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขจ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œฐ๎›•-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขจ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ
๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ-
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎ค๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎™๎šฒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐMuseo Archeologico Nazionale di Napoli โ€“ MANN๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•-
๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘-
ing management and maintenance processes as a digital environment
๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
In this case, as mentioned earlier, data collection assumes a funda-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹-
tion systems.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎—๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎Ÿ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›ต๎ขด๎˜›๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด
destructive analysis technique, coupled with environmental monitoring
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ-
standing of ancient settlement principles, construction techniques, and
๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚
STEFANO CURSI, LETIZIA MARTINELLI, FILIPPO CALCERANO, MICHELE CALVANO, LUCIANO CESSARI, ELENA GIGLIARELLI
44
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎™…๎˜ข๎˜ฆ๎™๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™…๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎˜๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…th๎ขด๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›Š๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ค๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขด๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚
data collection and monitoring services.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•-
๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขฉ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
piled within the model, which therefore assumes the role of common
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎˜ข๎˜ฆ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎–๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™๎šฒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚
๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ข๎™œ๎˜ƒ๎™๎™๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜›๎™๎›ต๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎ขด๎™…๎šƒ๎™ผ๎˜œ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
45
DIGITAL PROCESSES FOR THE CONSERVATION AND VALORISATION OF BUILT HERITAGE
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎˜๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎š‹๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎šฒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎˜ข๎˜ฆ๎™๎˜ƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜›๎™๎›ต๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎ขด๎™…๎šƒ๎™ผ๎˜œ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
STEFANO CURSI, LETIZIA MARTINELLI, FILIPPO CALCERANO, MICHELE CALVANO, LUCIANO CESSARI, ELENA GIGLIARELLI
46
๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎ขด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•rface will allow users who are not ex-
๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
formation present in the model, and dynamic information coming from
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
monitoring of room temperature and humidity, in support of preven-
๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”-
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎˜œ๎š‹๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ-
tion of cultural offerings with multi-channel front-end applications
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘-
ed value for tourism, enhancement, and development of cultural sites.
๎šฅ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ข๎œ†๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ”๎™๎˜ฆ๎™ฟ๎™…๎š‹๎˜ƒ๎˜ป๎˜ฆ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎™๎›ต๎™–๎˜ƒ๎˜›๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œ”๎š‹๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด-
๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•-
๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขด๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎š‹๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด-
plays, and cultural events of contemporary art are organised.
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎ค๎œ”๎–๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
model will allow the storage, consultation and sharing of data resulting
from the historical-architectural analysis that involved on-site study
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎ขด๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขฉ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
providing a historical-critical guideline for other analyses.
๎šƒ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎ขด๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขด๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ค๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œ”๎š‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎™…๎šƒ๎™œ๎™…๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎›ช๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎˜‚
๎™๎๎œ”๎•๎œ”๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ค๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘-
47
DIGITAL PROCESSES FOR THE CONSERVATION AND VALORISATION OF BUILT HERITAGE
elling environ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™พ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎—๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™…๎™พ๎™œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ-
๎œ”๎›‘๎ขจ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎›•๎œฐ๎๎›ซ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎๎œญ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎›•๎™–๎š๎™…๎šƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šค๎™ผ๎™–๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™พ๎™œ๎ขฃ
Also in this experience, the construction of the system presupposed
๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ-
tion is paid to the retrieval and organisation of data aimed at under-
๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎ค๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
struction nodes, etc.
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™พ๎™œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎™…๎šƒ๎™œ๎™…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜›๎™๎›ต๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎ขด๎™…๎šƒ๎™ผ๎˜œ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎—๎›ต๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎ขด๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
process and necessary for its documentation and informed decisions
regarding its preservation. At this stage, the proposed integration has
๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
domains, namely typological components, structural components,
๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ช๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต-
๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘-
๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•nt and necessary to control the geometric and
STEFANO CURSI, LETIZIA MARTINELLI, FILIPPO CALCERANO, MICHELE CALVANO, LUCIANO CESSARI, ELENA GIGLIARELLI
48
technological characteristics of the architectural heritage artefact. In
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚
location in which to formalise information, as well as what information
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขด๎œผ๎œ”๎ขด๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
used as a reference for the development of ad-hoc solutions to transfer
data from one environment to the other.
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ข๎ข๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ค๎›•๎—๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎˜›๎˜๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐTecnologie
multidisciplinari per lo studio e la conservazione dei Monasteri Post Bizantini in Albania
meridionale๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜›๎™๎›ต๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎ขด๎™…๎šƒ๎™ผ๎˜œ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด-
๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
49
DIGITAL PROCESSES FOR THE CONSERVATION AND VALORISATION OF BUILT HERITAGE
๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ-
ing software representation hierarchy. At the same time, technologies
๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎ขฉ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
roles, and, consequently, refer to different classes, in the evolution of
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
from different points of view.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹-
๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
piece of information is part of a coherent and integrated, up-to-date
representation. This faces several issues of current information sys-
tems, such as inconsistency or data duplication.
CONCLUSIONS
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”-
๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎›‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ช๎œผ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎šฒ๎•๎œ”๎›ต๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
to record the various expressions of local history, tradition and tech-
๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ
๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎œญ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”-
lutions can facilitate the search, dissemination and sharing of content
and help the understanding of cultural assets and the logical connec-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ
STEFANO CURSI, LETIZIA MARTINELLI, FILIPPO CALCERANO, MICHELE CALVANO, LUCIANO CESSARI, ELENA GIGLIARELLI
50
๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
expert preservationists and researchers interested in implementing
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ-
tion models that can represent and witness the multifaceted richness
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”-
logical heritage in the arts and humanities.
In this perspective, a research infrastructure such as DARIAH would
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขด๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šค๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™๎๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
guidelines and practices for the representation and management of
๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚
heritage.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขด๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎๎›Š๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
to reconstruct a new picture of the construction techniques spread
around the world, the permanences and mutations of common ty-
๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ-
ing related to the permanence and mutations of common architectural
๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
heritage in modern society.
REFERENCES LIST
๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎™“๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขด๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Journal of Cultural Heritage๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚
๎กพ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข€๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎œ๎ขฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ (ac-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎œฐ๎๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎›‹๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚
๎™๎›•๎–๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Remote Sensing๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข„๎ข‚๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข€๎ข€๎ข†๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎œฐ๎œด๎กพ๎กพ๎กพ๎ข‚๎กพ๎ข„๎ข‚๎กพ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎กฝ๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎™…๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ-
๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขด๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ค๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ-
51
DIGITAL PROCESSES FOR THE CONSERVATION AND VALORISATION OF BUILT HERITAGE
struction an๎›‘๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Remote Sensing๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข€๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚
๎ข๎ข…๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข€๎ข€๎ข†๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎œฐ๎œด๎กพ๎ข€๎กฝ๎ข€๎กฝ๎ข๎ข…๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎šฒ๎œ๎ฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›ช๎›ช๎šฒ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎๎œด๎›•๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎š‹๎๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎šค๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•-
๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขด๎™–๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Virtual Archaeology Review๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข€๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข๎ข†๎ข†๎ข‚๎ขฉ๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ข€๎กพ๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™๎œ”-
๎•๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎œƒ๎œ”๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎†๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎Ÿ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œด๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎–๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎™“๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œƒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎œด-
๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šง๎๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎™“๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎˜‚ 3D Research Challenges in Cultural Heritage II. How to
Manage Data and Knowledge Related to Interpretative Digital 3D Recon-
structions of Cultural Heritage๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎†๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›•๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎ขด๎™๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ช๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎™“๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎Ÿ๎˜๎œŽ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎™…๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข€๎กพ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข‚๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฉ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข…๎ขด๎ข€๎ขด๎ข€๎กพ๎ข†๎ขด๎ข๎ข„๎ขƒ๎ข๎ข„๎ขด๎ขƒ๎ขช๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ข„๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎›•๎œ†๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ฆ๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎˜‚ The
International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial
Information Sciences. GEORES 2019 2nd International Conference of Geo-
matics and Restoration๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›ช๎›ช๎šฒ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œฐ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šค๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ-
๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฆ๎™–๎™…๎™…๎ขด๎กฟ๎ขด๎šฅ๎กพ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข‚๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขด๎šฒ๎œฐ-
๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขด๎šฆ๎™–๎™…๎™…๎ขด๎กฟ๎ขด๎šฅ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขด๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข‚๎ขด๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œด๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šค๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎๎Ÿ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎š๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎ขด๎˜ƒ๎๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Brick
and Block Masonry โ€“ From Historical to Sustainable Masonry๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™“๎-
๎›Š๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎๎œด๎Ÿ๎˜‚๎™“๎–๎›ต๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œŽ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™›๎๎œƒ๎šฒ๎œด๎Ÿ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎›‘๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜œ๎™ฟ๎˜œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎ข„๎ข„๎กพ๎ขณ๎ข„๎ข„๎ข…๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜บ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ข๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎˜‚IS-
PRS โ€“ International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and
Spatial Information Sciences๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฆ๎™–๎™…๎™…๎ขด๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขณ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œŒ๎›Š๎™๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
at: ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขด๎šฆ๎™–๎™…๎™…๎ขด๎กฟ๎ขด๎กพ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขด๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚
๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šค๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎๎–๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎™“๎œ†๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™…๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขด๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Proceedings of the Institution
of Civil Engineers โ€“ Smart Infrastructure and Construction๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎กฟ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข๎ขณ๎ข‚๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ข…๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎œ๎œด๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ-
๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎—๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œญ๎›ต๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Graphi-
STEFANO CURSI, LETIZIA MARTINELLI, FILIPPO CALCERANO, MICHELE CALVANO, LUCIANO CESSARI, ELENA GIGLIARELLI
52
cal Heritage. Volume 1 โ€“ History and Heritage๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎›ท๎œ๎ขด๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šณ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎šค๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›ท๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›–๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šณ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขด๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ข„๎ข‚๎ข„๎ขณ๎ข„๎ข„๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฉ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข…๎ขด๎ข€๎ขด๎กฝ๎ข€๎กฝ๎ขด
๎ข๎ข„๎ข†๎ข„๎ข†๎ขด๎ข๎ขช๎ขƒ๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎–๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎Ÿ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎š‹๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Automation in Construction๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขณ๎ขƒ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎šƒ๎กฝ๎ข†๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ขด๎ข‚๎ข…๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฐ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎กฝ๎ขด
๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎๎œด๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎ขฟ๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎š๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™พ๎๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎ขฑ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Archeologia e Calcola-
tori๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎กพ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข†๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ https://www.archcalc.cnr.it/indice/
๎™ผ๎˜ข๎˜บ๎ข€๎กพ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขช๎˜›๎๎œด๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎ขช๎›•๎œผ๎ขช๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎œญ๎›‘๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎›‹๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎œถ๎œƒ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎•๎˜‚๎šค๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ๎œ”๎œด-
๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Journal
of Cultural Heritage๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข๎กฝ๎ขณ๎ข๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎œ๎ขฃ
๎›‹๎๎œ†๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎•๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™“๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œ-
๎›‘๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ-
๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ-
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Building Research
& Information๎˜‚๎ข‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข‚๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข…๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎ข†
๎ขƒ๎กพ๎ข€๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ข๎ข๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†-
๎œ†๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ขฒ๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎-
๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎—๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎™พ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข†๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†-
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข€๎ข€๎ข†๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œ†๎๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎˜‚ ๎™–๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚
๎š‹๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚Conoscere Collaborare Progettare: Teoria Tecniche e Appli-
cazioni per la Collaborazione in Architettura๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎ขฃ
๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎šฒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™–๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎™“๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚The International
Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information
Sciences๎˜‚๎šฆ๎™–๎™…๎™…๎ขด๎กฟ๎ขด๎šฅ๎ข‚๎ข๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขณ๎ขƒ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขด
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขด๎šฆ๎™–๎™…๎™…๎ขด๎กฟ๎ขด๎šฅ๎ข‚๎ขด๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขด๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜œ๎›ต๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ค๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขด๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎š๎œฐ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote
Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences๎˜‚๎šฆ๎™–๎™…๎™…๎ขด๎กฟ๎ขด๎šฅ๎กพ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข๎กฟ๎ข„๎ขณ๎ข๎ข€๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
at: ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขด๎šฆ๎™–๎™…๎™…๎ขด๎กฟ๎ขด๎šฅ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขด๎ข๎กฟ๎ข„๎ขด๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข† (acces-
๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜œ๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™๎›ต๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œŸ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™–๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™“๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
53
DIGITAL PROCESSES FOR THE CONSERVATION AND VALORISATION OF BUILT HERITAGE
Automation in Construction๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข๎ข๎ข๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข https://
๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎œ๎ขฃ๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข๎ข๎ข๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜œ๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ-
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Computer-Aided Architec-
tural Design Futures. The Next City โ€“ New Technologies and the Future
of the Built Environment๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎šฒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™‘๎๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎Ÿ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚Communications
in Computer and Information Science๎˜‚ ๎ข‚๎กฟ๎ข„๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎ข…๎ข€๎ขณ๎ข๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ข๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฉ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข…๎ขด๎ข€๎ขด
๎ขƒ๎ขƒ๎กฟ๎ขด๎ข๎ข„๎ข€๎ข…๎ขƒ๎ขด๎ข€๎ขช๎กฟ๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ข๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎–๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎œด๎šฒ๎˜๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎šค๎›–๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขด๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Computers & Graphics๎ขž๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚
๎ข€๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข„๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎œ๎ขฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข† (ac-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ข๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™ฃ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚The International Archives of the Pho-
togrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฆ๎™–๎™…๎™…๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚
๎ข€๎กฝ๎ข€๎ขณ๎ข€๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œŒ๎›Š๎™๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขด
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขด๎šฆ๎™–๎™…๎™…๎ขด๎กฟ๎ขด๎ข€๎กฝ๎ข€๎ขด๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ข๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›‹๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎—๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚
๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ขฑ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข https://doi.
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎ขฉ๎™…๎šƒ๎™ผ๎™ฟ๎šƒ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎˜œ๎™๎™…๎šค๎˜ฆ๎šƒ๎ขด๎šฆ๎™–๎ขด๎ข‚๎ขด๎šฅ๎ข๎ขด๎ข€๎ข‚๎กพ๎ขด๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ป๎šฒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Automation in
Construction๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎šƒ๎กฝ๎ข†๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ขด
๎ข‚๎ข…๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฐ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ข…๎ขด๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎šฒ๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎œฐ๎๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”-
๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎œ”๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ Arqueolรณgica 2.0. 8th International Congress
on Archaeology, Computer Graphics, Cultural Heritage and Innovation.
๎™‘๎œ”๎œด๎›–๎˜‚๎™–๎๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šค๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ-
๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ข๎›‹๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šค๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ข๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ข€๎กพ๎ข๎ขณ๎ข€๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎ขฃ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›Š๎œ”๎ขฃ๎›ต๎œผ๎ขฉ
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ข…๎ข‚๎ขฉ๎ข‚๎ขƒ๎ข€๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขข๎ขฃ๎šฆ๎—๎™ฟ๎›ช๎๎™๎œผ๎—๎›‘๎™ผ๎šง๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šค๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎šƒ๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Automation in Construction, Computer Aided Architec-
๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข๎ข†๎ข‚๎ขณ๎ข๎ข†๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://doi.
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎šƒ๎กฝ๎ข†๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ขด๎ข‚๎ข…๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฐ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ข‚๎ขด๎ข†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ป๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™…๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Digital Heritage. Progress in Cultural Heritage: Documen-
tation, Preservation, and Protection๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎œ”๎๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎ขด๎šƒ๎šฒ๎๎œญ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎๎œ-
๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œฉ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šค๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎œ๎›๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚
STEFANO CURSI, LETIZIA MARTINELLI, FILIPPO CALCERANO, MICHELE CALVANO, LUCIANO CESSARI, ELENA GIGLIARELLI
54
series Lecture Notes in Computer Science ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œger Inter-
๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ข†๎กพ๎ขณ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฉ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข…๎ขด๎ข€๎ขด
๎ข€๎กพ๎ข†๎ขด๎ข๎ข…๎ข๎ข†๎ขƒ๎ขด๎ข†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ป๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎›ต๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™–๎๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎•๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎ขฟ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎œผ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Archeo-
logia e Calcolatori๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข€๎ข‚๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ข†๎กฟ๎ข…๎กฟ๎ขฉ
๎šฒ๎›‹๎ขฃ๎ข€๎ข€๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎ข…๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ป๎œ•๎œŒ๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขด๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขด๎šƒ๎œ”-
๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎๎›ต๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ท๎œ๎ขด๎˜›๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎Ÿ๎Ÿ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ-
๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Automation in Con-
struction๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎œ๎ขฃ
๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎ข๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œŒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›ต๎˜‚๎š๎œ†๎•๎›ถ๎ค๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎˜๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎œŒ-
๎œญ๎›•๎›ต๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Tรผrkiye ฤฐnsansฤฑz Hava Araรงlarฤฑ Dergisi๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข‚๎ขณ๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎ขฃ
Herman, Grigore Vasile, Tudor Caciora, Dorina Camelia Ilies, Alexandru Ilies,
๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œ”๎œ๎œƒ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขด๎šƒ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œ†๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎›Š๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎-
๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Journal of Applied Engineering Sciences๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข„๎ขณ๎ข€๎กฝ๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎ข๎ข„๎ข…๎ขฉ๎œ๎šฒ๎›•๎œด๎ขด๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขด๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ข„๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™‘๎›ต๎œŒ๎›–๎œ๎›•๎Ÿ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šณ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขด๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขด๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜ข๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎š๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Journal of Cultural Heritage๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™‘๎šฒ๎œ๎๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข๎กฝ๎ขณ๎ข๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎œ๎ขฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™“๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šง๎›•๎›ฑ๎๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎ขด๎˜ข๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Automation in Construction, Design
๎™ฟ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎กฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ข„๎ข๎กพ๎ขณ๎ข„๎ข‚๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ
๎šƒ๎กฝ๎ข†๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ขด๎ข‚๎ข…๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฐ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข†๎กพ๎ขด๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™–๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎ขด๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šƒ๎šƒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›•๎›Š๎œฐ๎๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข„๎ข€๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
at: ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎œ๎ขฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข„๎ข€๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™–๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›ช๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎˜๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ISPRS Annals
of Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences
๎™…๎™…๎ขด๎ข‚๎ขฉ๎šฅ๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎ข„๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ-
๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขด๎™…๎™…๎ขด๎ข‚๎ขด๎šฅ๎ข€๎ขด๎กพ๎ข„๎ข„๎ขด๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™–๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎›‘๎œฐ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎œ†๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ•๎œŒ๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขด๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ท๎šฒ๎ขด๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎š๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚International Journal of
Architectural Heritage๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข†๎ขƒ๎ข‚๎ขณ๎ข†๎ข…๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ
๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข…๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ข‚๎ข…๎ข€๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ข…๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ข€๎กฟ๎ข‚๎ข‚๎ข๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™œ๎šฒ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
Peter ๎˜›๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
55
DIGITAL PROCESSES FOR THE CONSERVATION AND VALORISATION OF BUILT HERITAGE
๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Digital Cultural Heritage๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎™…๎œ”-
๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด Lecture Notes in Computer Science
๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข๎ขณ๎กพ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฉ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข…๎ขด๎ข€๎ขด๎ข€๎กพ๎ข†๎ขด๎ข„๎ข‚๎ข…๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ขด๎ข…๎ขช๎ข†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ-
๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎—๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œญ๎›ต๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Graphi-
cal Heritage. Volume 1 โ€“ History and Heritage๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎›ท๎œ๎ขด๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šณ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎šค๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›ท๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›–๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šณ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขด๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ข„๎ข‚๎ข„๎ขณ๎ข„๎ข„๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฉ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข…๎ขด๎ข€๎ขด๎กฝ๎ข€๎กฝ๎ขด
๎ข๎ข„๎ข†๎ข„๎ข†๎ขด๎ข๎ขช๎ขƒ๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™พ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Sustainability๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข‚๎กพ๎ข„๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข https://
๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข€๎ข€๎ข†๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎œด๎๎กพ๎ข€๎กฝ๎ข†๎ข‚๎กพ๎ข„๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™œ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ค๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Journal of Cultural Heritage๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข„๎ข„๎ขณ
๎กฟ๎ข…๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎œ๎ขฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ (accessed
๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎œด๎›–๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎๎›ท๎œด๎˜‚๎˜บ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎šค๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›ต-
๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šณ๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขด๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ๎Ÿ๎šณ๎œ†๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขด๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขด๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚International
Journal of Architectural Heritage๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข…๎ข๎ข๎ขณ๎ข…๎ขƒ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://doi.
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข…๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ข‚๎ข…๎ข€๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ข…๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขƒ๎ข…๎ข†๎ข…๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™œ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›‹๎˜ป๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ขฑ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Structural Survey๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎กพ๎กพ๎ขณ๎ข€๎กฟ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
at: ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข…๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข€๎กฝ๎ข…๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข†๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ข…๎ข‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข…๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›ช๎›ช๎šฒ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚
๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚International Journal of Heritage in the Digital Era๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™‘๎๎œ๎›•๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขณ
๎ข€๎ข€๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ข๎ข„๎ขด๎ข๎ข†๎ข„๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎ข€๎กฟ๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™ผ๎šฒ๎๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•-
๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚2013 Digital Heri-
tage International Congress (DigitalHeritage)๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎˜ฆ๎˜ฆ๎˜ฆ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://
๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขฉ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎ขƒ๎ข„๎ข๎ข€๎ข„๎ข…๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™ผ๎šฒ๎๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎˜‚๎šฎ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šง๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ-
๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎˜ฆ๎˜œ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎›‘๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Automation in Con-
struction๎˜‚ ๎ข„๎ข€๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™‘๎šฒ๎œ๎๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข๎ข‚๎ขณ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎œ๎ขฃ
๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™ผ๎œ”๎›‹๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎›‘๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ”๎›•๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œฐ๎˜๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎๎ขด๎˜›๎œ”๎•๎›–๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Heritage Science๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎œด๎ข๎กฝ๎ข๎ข†๎ข๎ขด๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขด๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎กพ๎ขด๎ข (accessed
๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
STEFANO CURSI, LETIZIA MARTINELLI, FILIPPO CALCERANO, MICHELE CALVANO, LUCIANO CESSARI, ELENA GIGLIARELLI
56
๎™พ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›Š๎›ต๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎™“๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขด๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎ขด๎™พ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚
๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎š๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขด๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Journal of Cultural Heritage๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข…๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œŒ-
๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ข†๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข€๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎œ๎ขฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข
๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™ฟ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขด๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ฃ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ-
๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Latest Developments in Reality-Based
3D Surveying and Modelling๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎ข๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎˜ข๎™ผ๎™…๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎›‘๎œ”๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ-
๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎ขฉ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ข…๎ข‚๎ข๎ขฉ๎ข‚๎กพ๎ข๎ข๎ข…๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›ต๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ฟ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ขด๎˜œ๎›•๎œ-
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œ”๎š‹๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎˜๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
ISARC Proceedings๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข…๎ขณ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ข„๎ข‚๎ขฃ
๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขด
๎˜ฆ๎œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Automation in Construc-
tion๎˜‚ ๎ข†๎ข„๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™‘๎šฒ๎œ๎๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข€๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎œ๎ขฃ๎šฒ๎๎œผ-
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎šƒ๎๎œ๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œ”๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š‹๎œด๎๎˜๎œ”๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ-
๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Auto-
mation in Construction๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎˜ƒ๎˜ƒ๎˜ข๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎กฝ๎ข€๎ขณ๎ข€๎กฝ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://
๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎šƒ๎กฝ๎ข†๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ขด๎ข‚๎ข…๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฐ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข๎ขƒ๎ขด๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›‘๎ขด๎˜›๎œ”๎Ÿ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฆ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎œ”๎š‹๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Automation in Construction๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎ข„๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข€๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
at: ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎œ๎ขฃ๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ข๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎ขด๎˜ข๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข€๎˜ข๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต-
๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎š๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šค๎›•๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎š๎˜ƒ๎šค๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚International Journal of
Remote Sensing๎˜‚๎ข๎กฟ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข…๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎กพ
๎ข๎ข€๎กพ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข€๎ข๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎šค๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎›–๎›‘๎›–๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›–๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎–๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎˜๎œด-
๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎˜๎œ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎ขด๎œ”๎›ช๎ขด๎˜ข๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Conference: 35th
International Symposium on Automation and Robics in Construction
(ISARC), Berlin๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™‘๎๎œ†๎˜๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ข„๎ข๎กฝ๎ขณ๎ข„๎ข๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎ขฉ
๎™…๎šƒ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎˜œ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎šค๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›Š๎›•๎œƒ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขฒ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Automation in Construction๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข…๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขณ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
at: ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎œ๎ขฃ๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎šง๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฆ๎›ต๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šง๎›ต๎ขด๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎™–๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎˜๎œ”๎œด๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎›•๎›ฑ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎œฐ๎๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™๎˜›๎™…๎™œ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›•๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™“๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ISPRS Interna-
tional Journal of Geo-Information๎˜‚ ๎ข…๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎ข„๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ https://doi.
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข€๎ข€๎ข†๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎ข…๎กฝ๎ข„๎กฝ๎ข€๎กฝ๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
57
DIGITAL PROCESSES FOR THE CONSERVATION AND VALORISATION OF BUILT HERITAGE
๎šฎ๎๎›‹๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎๎›‹๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™œ๎˜ฆ๎˜ข๎˜ฆ๎˜ƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต-
๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›‘๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šค๎๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎™–๎ขฟ๎˜ƒ๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Summary Report of the Cooperative
Activities of the COST Action C25, Sustainability of Constructions. ๎™–๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎šฒ-
๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎๎œƒ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎›ช๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šค๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šค๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎œƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎ฃฏ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ
59
RELEVANCE OF โ€œSCIENTIFIC
AND CULTURAL INFORMATIONโ€
FOR DIGITAL HUMANITIES
MIRNA WILLER
University of Zadar, Department of Information Sciences
(retired professor)
Zadar, Croatia
willer.mirna@gmail.com
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚Archives,
Libraries, Museums: Possibilities for Co-operation Within the Environ-
ment of the Global Information Infrastructure๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ƒ๎™“๎™œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎ขด๎™ผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎œด-
๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข„๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต-
tage information sectorโ€™s place in the complex of digital humanities.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”-
๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œด-
sential to the organisation of information within the cultural heritage
๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ-
ed at the 2nd๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™“๎™œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎™…๎˜บ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎™œ๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•-
๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ
๎™“๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขจ๎˜‚
๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎™œ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขจ๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด
INTRODUCTION
The paper opens with an overview of the history of and underlying
๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
text of annual seminars Archives, Libraries, Museums: Possibilities
for Co-operation Within the Environment of the Global Information
Review Article
MIRNA WILLER
60
Infrastructure๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข„๎ขณ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ-
nology and state-of-the-art in standards development, issues of infor-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
in information systems and user services, and presentation of current
๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”-
logical change. As part of the theoretical discussion of the topic at the 2nd
๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข…๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™…๎•๎œ”๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎™…๎˜บ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎™œ๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎œด๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต-
ties sector and recognising their interdependence with the current in-
formation technologies.
ON SEMINARS
ARCHIVES
,
LIBRARIES
,
MUSEUMS
The annual seminars Archives, Libraries, Museums: Possibilities for
Co-operation Within the Environment of the Global Information
Infrastructure (Arhivi, knjiลพnice, muzeji: AKM๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎ขด๎™ผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข„๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
archives and museums are faced with the same, common challenges
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขด๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚
quite clear that an interdisciplinary approach in which experts from
these three communities would learn from and teach each other was
not enough, and that active cooperation with the ICT sector, academia,
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
dustries was needed.
61
RELEVANCE OF โ€œSCIENTIFIC AND CULTURAL INFORMATIONโ€ FOR DIGITAL HUMANITIES
To accomplish that, it w๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•-
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎˜๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
archives, and museums provide for their present and prospective users.
The organisers of the annual seminars are three national associa-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎ขด๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚
Documentation Centre and the departments for Information and
๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™ฃ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ-
๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™…๎˜œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎š๎šƒ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎ขด๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข€rd๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ช๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
evidence and as an archive documenting the progress, development of
๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚Rules for Description and Access
to Resources in Libraries, Archives and Museums๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šค๎๎œƒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
The seminars are organised within the structure of paper presenta-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›‹๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด-
๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข€th๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™“๎™œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜›๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ข ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
Topics of the following seminars evolved out of the ๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚
MIRNA WILLER
62
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ฃ๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚
๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™…๎œด๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขค๎ขฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ฃ๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ป๎œ†๎œ”๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎œ”๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎™–๎™ฃ๎˜œ๎˜ƒ๎™–๎ขฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†-
ogy, user studies, what, why, how and for whom to digitise, education
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
information organisation: description, analysis, and questioning of cur-
rent content and technological principles, models and standards, and
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฅ๎šฅ๎šฅ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎ขจ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต-
๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ขด๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฉ
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎›‹-
๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
terested in getting answers to a particular question regardless of which
๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎›ต-
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›‹๎ขฃ
ON THE RELEVANCE OF POLITICS AND NORMS
UNDERPINNING INFORMATION-FINDING AIDS
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎ขด๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต-
๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
63
RELEVANCE OF โ€œSCIENTIFIC AND CULTURAL INFORMATIONโ€ FOR DIGITAL HUMANITIES
and presentation aspects of the cultural heritage held in these institu-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
curatorial traditions, come to the foreground of our dealings with the
๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎ขฃ๎›•๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎˜ข๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎ข€๎˜œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
designed on two operational principles โ€“ AAA and OWA:
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜ƒ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
๎œด๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎›Š๎œ”๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎˜ข๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎˜ข๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฃ๎šฅ๎˜ƒ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜ƒ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ-
ciple, means that at any time some new information can appear. This
implies that none of the entities have complete descriptions, and it is
๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎˜ข๎˜บ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข๎ข„๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎™ฟ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขŸ๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข€๎ข„๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™…๎™ฟ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚
๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ-
๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ-
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขŸ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขŸ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎-
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฏ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚๎ข…๎ขณ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎˜ข๎˜บ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎˜ข๎˜บ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎—๎ข๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ข๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฉ๎•๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎›Š๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎˜ข๎˜บ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
๎™…๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎ข€๎˜œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎˜ข๎˜บ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ
MIRNA WILLER
64
IVO MAROEVIฤ† ON SCIENTIFIC AND CULTURAL INFORMATION
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎•๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟnd๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™“๎™œ๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™…๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™…๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎˜‚๎š‹๎๎›”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•-
๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚
information is
analytical and precise. It deals with the detail consisting of usually
๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎—๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚identify
the topic of the material. Although the data differ depending on the
type of resource and institution, its import into information systems
produces enormous information resources. However, its fundamental
disadvantage is in its increase in quantity and therefore decrease in
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œด-
๎œด๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚secondary meaning of
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด-
๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
spirit of the time of their creation. In other words, cultural informa-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎˜๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขŸ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎šฒ๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
that will transfer in time the testimonies of some other times in rela-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œ†๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ข€rd๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™“๎™œ๎˜‚
๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š-
๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚Uvod u muzeologiju (Introduction to Museology๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
65
RELEVANCE OF โ€œSCIENTIFIC AND CULTURAL INFORMATIONโ€ FOR DIGITAL HUMANITIES
๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”-
๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™“๎œ”๎œ†๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
IFLA ISBD FOR MANIFESTATION: TRANSCRIBED AND
RECORDED DATA
The requirements put on information organisation politics and norms
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•-
๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎˜บ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎™–๎™ฟ๎™œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ-
๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎˜บ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎ข๎˜‚
๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ข€
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎กฝ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
then-current technology โ€“ printed card catalogue, since then under-
๎–๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ-
๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎˜œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
used and highly functional national and international catalogues and
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขด๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎˜บ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎™–๎™ฟ๎™œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎˜บ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎ขด๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™–๎™ฟ๎™œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ข€๎˜‚๎š๎œญ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
MIRNA WILLER
66
๎™…๎˜บ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎™–๎™ฟ๎™œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑin an enhanced entity-
๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎ขฃ๎›•๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎˜-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚
that are assumed to share the same characteristics as to intellectual or
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขด
๎šƒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด-
๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎™œ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎ขด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ-
๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
sources external to that resource, and without forming explicit rela-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜ƒ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎šฅ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎˜ข๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต-
๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ-
๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎ข๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
67
RELEVANCE OF โ€œSCIENTIFIC AND CULTURAL INFORMATIONโ€ FOR DIGITAL HUMANITIES
๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎™œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ-
tion, in form and content as it is found there, without any intervention
from the part of the cataloguer. In this respect, the description follows
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎˜บ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚Statement of International
Cataloguing Principles (ICP)๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎˜บ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ข๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎™ฟ๎™œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎™…๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎ขฎ๎œผ๎ขฏ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚
๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎ขด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ-
๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•-
creases the precision of the system as a whole, i.e. much of the retrieved
๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขŸ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎๎œด๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข„๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘-
ing is a complex process, requiring the high expertise of a cataloguer
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎™–๎™ฟ๎™œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐefer to the entities and their properties:
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด-
๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ-
๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
MIRNA WILLER
68
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎˜บ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚Statement of International Cataloguing
Principles (ICP) the recorded data supports the general principles of
๎ขผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎˜บ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ข๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ขณ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
the context of entity of interest in the information universe. This type
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
the product of a process of normalisation/authorisation according to
๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—-
๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
of description. On the example of the choice and form of authorโ€™s name
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ-
๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
social constructs, the rules that govern and underpin data produc-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
rules that govern and underpin data production for machine process-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚๎ข†๎ข†๎ขณ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚
technologies support this approach [of semantic coherence in the cat-
egorisation of entities and relationships of interest], especially in the
context of social construction and deconstruction. The context of the
AAA principle and Open World Assumption implies an increasing im-
๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎œด๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
CONCLUSION
๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
69
RELEVANCE OF โ€œSCIENTIFIC AND CULTURAL INFORMATIONโ€ FOR DIGITAL HUMANITIES
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด-
๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜ƒ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™ฃ๎šฅ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎—๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎˜๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎ขฏ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
testimonies of some other times in relation to the material that we had
๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
at a particular point in time, and of recognition of their interdepen-
๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ
REFERENCES LIST
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎ก๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎Ÿ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎ข๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›Œ๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎˜‚ ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎˜‚๎œ”๎œƒ๎œฐ๎๎ก๎›•๎œ๎œ๎๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ†๎œ”๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎œƒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œƒ๎›‘๎œฐ๎๎œด๎œผ๎•๎œ”๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎ขฉ (ac-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข…๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚Digital Humanities: Knowledge
and Critique in a Digital Age๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Empowering the Visibility of Croatian Cultural Heritage
through the Digital Humanities๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎š‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œถ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎–๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎š‹๎˜๎œ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎ข๎กฝ๎ขณ๎ข‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ป๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฏ๎ขฃ
๎˜ข๎๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™…๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Authority, Provenance, Authenticity,
Evidence: Selected Papers from the Conference and School Authority, Prov-
enance, Authenticity, Evidence, Zadar, Croatia, October 2016๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎™‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎•๎›•๎๎›๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œถ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œฐ๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎ข…๎ข„๎ขณ
๎กพ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎๎œ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎ขฉ๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎—๎ขฃ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œญ๎ขฉ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฉ
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎ขฉ๎ข๎ขƒ๎ขฉ๎ข๎กฟ๎ขฉ๎ข‚๎ข†๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข…๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขƒ๎ขƒ๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข…๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Cataloging & Classi๎ฅcation Quarterly๎˜‚ ๎ข‚๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ข…๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขณ๎ข…๎ข€๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข…๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ข€๎ข†๎ข€๎ข„๎ข๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฃ๎ข†๎กฟ๎ข†๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข…๎˜‚
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™…๎˜บ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎˜บ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ Statement of International Cataloguing Principles
(ICP)๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎›ช๎ฃ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ท๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™–๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›‘๎œฐ๎›ท๎›ซ๎๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚
MIRNA WILLER
70
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎™œ๎›‹๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎›ต๎ค๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎–๎œญ๎ขด๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฉ
๎๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฉ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฉ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขฉ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎›ต๎›‹๎œญ๎ขฉ๎›ต๎›‹๎œญ๎ขช๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขด๎›•๎œ๎ขฃ๎œญ๎›‘๎›ช (accessed
๎กฟ๎ข…๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™๎šฒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎›ต๎ค๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎–๎œญ๎ขด๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฉ๎๎œญ-
๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฉ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฉ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขฉ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œด๎›Š๎›‘๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œด๎›Š๎›‘๎ขด๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขช๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข€๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎œญ๎›‘๎›ช (ac-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข…๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎˜‚๎š๎œญ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎›ต๎ค๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ-
๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ข๎ข‚๎ขƒ๎ข„๎ข…๎ข†๎ขฉ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข€๎ข†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข…๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™“๎œ”๎œ†๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎•๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚2. i 3. seminar Arhivi, knjiลพnice,
muzeji: moguฤ‡nosti suradnje u okruลพenju globalne informacijske infra-
strukture: zbornik radova๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ข๎˜‚
๎™๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎Ÿ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎๎œถ๎œผ๎•๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎ข†๎ข†๎ขณ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
๎™œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฏ๎ขฃ
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎•๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎Ÿ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎ก๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎ขฑ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚2. i 3. seminar Arhivi, knjiลพnice,
muzeji: moguฤ‡nosti suradnje u okruลพenju globalne informacijske infra-
strukture: zbornik radova๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ข๎˜‚
๎™๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎Ÿ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎๎œถ๎œผ๎•๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
Willer].
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎•๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚Uvod u muzeologiju๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ข๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎Ÿ๎œ”๎›ช๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎•๎›•๎๎›๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œถ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎๎˜‚ ๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฎ๎šฒ๎•๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎›‘๎œด๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚
๎Ÿ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎ขฃ
๎™ฟ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œฌ๎๎›ช๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šฐ๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚ IFLA Library Reference
Model: a Conceptual Model for Bibliographic Information. Den Haag: Inter-
๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎›ต๎ค๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎–๎œญ๎ขด๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฉ๎๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฉ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฉ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขฉ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎›ช๎œฐ๎›Š๎œฐ๎ขด๎œ†๎œฐ๎œŒ๎ขฉ๎›ต๎ค๎šฒ๎ขด๎œ†๎œฐ๎œŒ๎ขด๎šฒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขช๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎œญ๎›‘๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎ข…๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚The Intellectual Foundation of Information Organi-
zation๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎™…๎š‹๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ
๎šค๎๎œƒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›”๎›ต๎˜‚๎๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎ก๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›ต-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎Ÿ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ข๎˜‚๎™๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎ก๎šฒ๎•๎œ๎›ต๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎Ÿ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œƒ๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚
๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎˜‚๎œด๎•๎›•๎๎›๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œถ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎ก๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜‚๎๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://
๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข…๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™…๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™–๎™ฟ๎™œ๎ขด๎šฒ๎˜‚๎๎˜‚๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎ขด๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚IFLA-ina knjiลพniฤnog
referentnog modela๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™–๎™ฟ๎™œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎•๎œ”๎›ซ๎šฒ๎˜‚Meฤ‘unarodnog standardnog biblio-
grafskog opisa๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜ข๎ขฑ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚24 seminar Arhivi, knjiลพnice, muzeji: moguฤ‡nosti
suradnje u okruลพenju globalne informacijske infrastrukture: zbornik ra-
dova๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š…๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ข๎˜‚๎™๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›‘๎œฐ๎๎œถ๎œผ๎•๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขณ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚Bibliographic Information Organiza-
tion in the Semantic Web. Oxford: Chandos.
71
RELEVANCE OF โ€œSCIENTIFIC AND CULTURAL INFORMATIONโ€ FOR DIGITAL HUMANITIES
๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Authority,
Provenance, Authenticity, Evidence: Selected Papers from the Conference
and School Authority, Provenance, Authenticity, Evidence, Zadar, Croatia,
October 2016๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎•๎›•๎๎›๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œถ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œฐ๎๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://morepress.
๎๎œ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎ขฉ๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฉ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฉ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎ขฉ๎ข๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข…๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎ข€๎˜œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎˜ข๎˜บ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ https://www.
๎–๎ข€๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎™ฟ๎˜ข๎˜บ๎ขฉ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข…๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
73
ANALYSING ONLINE HORROR
FICTION WITH CORPUS
LINGUISTIC TECHNIQUES
FOR ENGAGING MUSEUM
LABELS: CREEPYPASTA WIKI
AND THE HOUSE OF TERRORโ€™S
MOBILE APPLICATION
DANIEL IHRMARK
Linnaeus University
Vรคxjรถ, Sweden
daniel.o.sundberg@lnu.se
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0930-644X
ZOI TSIVILTIDOU
University of Leicester
Leicester, England
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3526-6602
This paper explores how the language and content of a collection
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎ขด๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขด๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”-
๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ข„๎ข†๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ-
tion of the House of Terror museum in Hungary. The analysis focused
on categorisation and frequent nouns and pronouns. The results in-
๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
used to create immersion and engagement in the horror narratives,
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขด๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
a more distant perspective.
๎™“๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”-
๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
Preliminary Communication
DANIEL IHRMARK, ZOI TSIVILTIDOU
74
1. INTRODUCTION
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ข The aim is
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขด๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎กพ๎ข‚๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขด
rated stories, suggesting that certain stylistic traits lead to immersion
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข„๎ข†๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ-
tively in order to highlight differences. The understanding of different
language patterns and their implications in inducing reader responses
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎ขฑ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ-
๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
2. CONTEXT
2.1. CREEPYPASTA WIKI AND USERSโ€™ PREFERENCES
While discussing the contents of Gothic horror, Bloom connects it to
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎ขจ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
In Gothic Romanced๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎ค๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
later text, Limits of Horror๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎ค๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
through new modes of media.
๎ขผ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ข ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎๎ขฉ๎›•๎œ.
๎กพ๎ข‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ๎–๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎ขฉ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขช๎šฅ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต.
75
ANALYSING ONLINE HORROR FICTION WITH CORPUS LINGUISTIC TECHNIQUES
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œ”๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›‹๎™๎›•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎๎—๎ขด๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ-
๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎šฒ๎–๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œฐ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™๎›•๎œผ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•-
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎Ÿ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
the new focus of the digital setting, Creepypastas rely heavily on en-
gagement and immersion to drive the story. This plays into the form of
the story, commonly framed as the author having a conversation with
the reader online, immersing the reader in the faux-reality of the story
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎šฒ๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
the internetโ€™s text forums.
2.2. STORYTELLING IN MUSEUM LABELS
๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•-
๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜›๎›•๎›‘๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›‘๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
stories through the collection, curation and meaningful display of ar-
tefacts and the use of explanatory visual and textual content (Roussou
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
places, events and ideologies, and communicating certain messages
๎ขฐ๎˜›๎›ต๎œผ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎กฟ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ข‚๎กฝ๎ขด๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎ขด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”-
๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
the name, age, place of manufacture, museum owning it, and catalogue
๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
clude a heading.
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎ขฎ๎œผ๎ขฏ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚
DANIEL IHRMARK, ZOI TSIVILTIDOU
76
๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฐ๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
and through these visitors were led to different associations depend-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎™ผ๎๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎ขด๎š‹๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขด๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ฃ๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎ฃ๎—๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎œฐ๎๎๎œ†๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎ขด๎šค๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
or emphasising some interpretations over others.
๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ-
๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™“๎›ต๎œ†๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚
longer a monolithic output of the museumโ€™s written communication
๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ช๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
whether user preferences could initiate a dialogue on how engaging
๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎ขฑ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚
2.3. HORROR-RELATED EXHIBITIONS
๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎•๎๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎ขด
๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎•๎›–๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ๎œ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œ†๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขƒ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขจ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†-
๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜›๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎™œ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™“๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎™–๎›•๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎š‹๎œฉ๎œ๎›‘๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™“๎›ต๎›‘๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†-
77
ANALYSING ONLINE HORROR FICTION WITH CORPUS LINGUISTIC TECHNIQUES
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎œด๎๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜›๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ข๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎ข„๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™–๎›•๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
ror- and horror-related events in sites associated with death, suffering
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎š‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›Š๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขพ๎œฐ๎๎›Š๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฉ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œด๎˜๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข„๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
In our research, horror-related content is considered any textual
information that includes direct or implicit references to traumatic
๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
through storytelling, it connects visitors to a shared humanity, fosters
๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎ขฑ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ-
๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎›ต๎œผ๎ขฏ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘-
๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚do ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›ช๎๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎›•๎›‘-
๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎ขด๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ข…๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ-
tion is attracted and how a response is elicited. In that light, museum
๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎œ”๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
DANIEL IHRMARK, ZOI TSIVILTIDOU
78
3. METHODOLOGY
3.1. OBJECTIVES
The purpose of the study was to identify similarities and differences
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œญ-
plication of the House of Terror and, therefore, to explore a theoretical
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
written communication and as a proposal for re-examining the lan-
๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ-
๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎ค๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข…๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‘๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ข‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”-
๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต-
๎ฃ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝth
๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎˜‚๎œฐ๎๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
of communist rule after World War II, when Hungary was part of the
๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข‚๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜๎ขฃ
3.2. DATA COLLECTION
๎™พ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œด๎œผ-
๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎๎œ†๎šƒ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขด๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎˜๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜‚๎ฃฒ.๎กพ๎ขƒ
๎กพ๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขฃ
79
ANALYSING ONLINE HORROR FICTION WITH CORPUS LINGUISTIC TECHNIQUES
Corpus: Word count: ๎™๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎ข
CreepyCorpus ๎ข๎ข‚๎ข๎ขž๎ข†๎ขƒ๎กฝ ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ข‚
HoTCorpus ๎ข…๎ขž๎ข๎ขƒ๎ข ๎ข„๎ข†
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎˜‚๎ฃฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šค๎œ”๎˜๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ฃฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎™–๎š‹๎™“๎˜‚
๎ฃฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜‚๎ฃฒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎—๎˜‚๎˜›๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—-
๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚
story perspective.
In the CreepyCorpus, the inclusion criteria were original content for
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขด๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข๎ข€๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎—๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ-
mation on which categories were found engaging. The content analysis
of the non-duplicate dataset initially made use of a visualisation of the
texts with the stop words removed. We then moved on to focusing more
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
pronouns, we intended to provide insight into the preferred narration.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎š‹๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎–๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
๎š‹๎šฒ๎›ซ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎ฃฒ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขด๎œ”๎›ช๎ขด๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™ผ๎™ฃ๎šƒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
which specify the function and word class of every word in the stories.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎š‹๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ข†๎ข๎ฃซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚
analysis was then performed in the HoTCorpus.
3.3. LIMITATIONS
The datasets used for this study are small, and no general conclu-
๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
drawn from our analysis due to data sparsity. However, due to the
CreepyCorpus including only the top-rated stories from each category,
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎š‹๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ
DANIEL IHRMARK, ZOI TSIVILTIDOU
80
๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
expected to yield interesting results in what language conventions
visitors report as engaging and how audiences relate to the text and,
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎ขฃ๎˜‚
4. FINDINGS
4.1. COMMON LANGUAGE CONVENTIONS IN THE
CREEPYCORPUS
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ข๎ข€๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œด๎๎›Š๎ขด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฃ
81
ANALYSING ONLINE HORROR FICTION WITH CORPUS LINGUISTIC TECHNIQUES
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”p two counts in the category dataset seem to
๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚
the reason for the high counts, though, as there are much larger cat-
๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขด๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎—๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
In the non-duplicate dataset, initial content analysis is visualised as
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผo the frequency of the word.
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎ขฃ
The hig๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎—๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›Š๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›ซ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›ต๎ขฃ๎›•๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†-
๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎˜๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต-
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹y.
DANIEL IHRMARK, ZOI TSIVILTIDOU
82
๎™–๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”-
ries. The nouns were extracted from the non-duplicate dataset using
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข™๎ขช๎™๎™๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ข™๎ขช๎™๎™๎šƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎ขฃ
๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎กพ๎กพ๎ข€๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎ข„๎ข๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎ข„๎ข€๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎ขƒ๎ข„๎กพ๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎ขƒ๎ขƒ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™“๎šฅ๎™…๎˜œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™“๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œด๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
was performed to further understand the use of the environment. The
๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›•๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎กพ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
listed to the left.
83
ANALYSING ONLINE HORROR FICTION WITH CORPUS LINGUISTIC TECHNIQUES
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œด๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎™–๎กพ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ
DANIEL IHRMARK, ZOI TSIVILTIDOU
84
Among the collocates, two possessive p๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œŒ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
are found. This goes further to indicate the home or living quarters as
a common setting.
๎ขผ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎ข„๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎™–๎กพ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎˜๎œ”๎๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œด๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎˜๎œ”๎๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™–๎กพ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
within the categories of age and physical appearance. Outliers would
๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎ขด
digit frequencies.
๎ขผ๎šฅ๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™–๎กพ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎ขth๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚th
๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎ข€rd๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข‚๎˜‚๎œ”๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ข๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎ข™๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎ข™๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎•๎๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด-
tress, as a particular choice of words may intensify the message more
than another.
The noun overview showed rooms as a frequently occurring space,
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
space and how reference to an enclosed, indoor milieu, particularly to
an intimate and familiar room, could intensify emotional connections
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎œ”๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ-
sonal memories or framing scenarios.
๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™…๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
wh๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขด๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™…๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
85
ANALYSING ONLINE HORROR FICTION WITH CORPUS LINGUISTIC TECHNIQUES
included due to the rather high frequency of non-human characters in-
volved in certain categories, such as monsters, ghosts and other crea-
๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜๎œ”๎๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
In order to expan๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜๎œ”๎๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™“๎šฅ๎™…๎˜œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜๎œ”๎๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
the immersive intent of the stories, as the faux-reality upheld through
the formatting of stories as diaries, forum posts or similar demands a
๎œด๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎–๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
the interpreting experience that not only supplies the frame through
DANIEL IHRMARK, ZOI TSIVILTIDOU
86
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎›•๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎˜๎œ”๎๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›ซ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎ขด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎œ”๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขจ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขจ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ช๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎-
๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
and a re-appropriation of the content. In order to engage visitors, mu-
๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ-
ing perceptions along the way. Visitors are demanding a greater say
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ฃ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚
4.2. COMMON LANGUAGE CONVENTIONS IN THE HOTCORPUS
As with the previous corpus, the initial step of analysis is a general
overview of frequently occurring items in the texts. While the focus of
the Creepypastas was immersion and audience engagement, the focus
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
of Hungary.
The initial language overview showcases the main content of the
๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข„๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›ซ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›ซ-
87
ANALYSING ONLINE HORROR FICTION WITH CORPUS LINGUISTIC TECHNIQUES
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šค๎œ”๎˜๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›ซ-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘-
๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข„๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎š‹๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎ขฃ
๎™–๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ-
๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
insights gained from the initial overview hold true.
DANIEL IHRMARK, ZOI TSIVILTIDOU
88
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎š‹๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎ขฃ
Interestingly, after the collective nouns and territorial descriptors
๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎˜๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎™“๎šฅ๎™…๎˜œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•-
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข†๎ข๎˜‚๎™“๎šฅ๎™…๎˜œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ
89
ANALYSING ONLINE HORROR FICTION WITH CORPUS LINGUISTIC TECHNIQUES
๎™œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎˜๎œ”๎๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
the perspective given are very different in the two corpora.
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎š‹๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎ขฃ
In ad๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎ข€๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขฉ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขž๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™๎œ”๎š‹๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ข๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎ข€๎˜‚ ๎ขฉ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ขž๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
The pronoun used in the HoTCorpus indicates a descriptive narrative
focusing on the actions of parties, collectives and other groups rather
than on the individual experiences of the events. The emphasis is on
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
parties and armies. It seems that any emphasis on or repeated refer-
ences to individuals would overshadow the impact of such collective
actions.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎š‹๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚
and one of the occurrences is an incorrect OCR reading of a numerical.
The remaining three occurrences stem from short quotations provid-
ing accounts of the events as seen in the KW๎™…๎˜œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
DANIEL IHRMARK, ZOI TSIVILTIDOU
90
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎™“๎šฅ๎™…๎˜œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™…๎ขฝ๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎š‹๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚
๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚
highlights how an awareness of the language conventions at play could
๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎šฒ๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎—-
๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚
that relate to historical events examined through the lens of traumatic
๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›‘๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
explore these themes further and prompt visitors to situate themselves
in the context.
๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
in the HoTCorpus indicate that personal stories are already used to
๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
to the high frequency of collective nouns.
5. CONCLUSION
The preferences in the two corpora are quite clear and could theoreti-
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎ขฑ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎•๎๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•-
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ
๎™๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ฃ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚
91
ANALYSING ONLINE HORROR FICTION WITH CORPUS LINGUISTIC TECHNIQUES
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎ขด
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ-
๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
is required is an in-depth long-term examination of pre-visit and post-
๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
conventions and to measure the impact and value of having user pref-
๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
REFERENCES LIST
Ardito, Car๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œด๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Jour-
nal of Knowledge Technology and Policy๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข„๎ข†๎ขณ๎ข…๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎๎œผ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Proceedings of the IADIS International
Conference on Mobile Learning, Mobile Learning 2005. Pedro Isaias, Car-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™พ๎šฒ๎–๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎˜ƒ๎˜ข๎™…๎šƒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎ข‚๎กพ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข‚๎ข‚๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ-
๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Museum Management and Curatorship๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข€๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข…๎ข‚๎ขณ๎ข€๎ข†๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜›๎›•๎›‘๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎œด๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Curator: The
Museum Journal๎˜‚๎ข๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข„๎ขณ๎ข€๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜›๎›ต๎œผ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Journal of Interpretation Research๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎กพ๎ขณ๎ข๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Transforming Museums in the Twenty-๎ฅrst Century.
Oxon: Routledge.
๎˜›๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚Gothic Horror: A Readerโ€™s Guide from Poe to King and
Beyond๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎›‹๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎›•๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎ขพ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›ต-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Museum and Society๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎ข‚๎ขณ๎ข…๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜›๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚Gothic Romanced: Consumption, Gender and Technology
in Contemporary Fictions๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎›Š๎œ”๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎˜๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚Limits of Horror: Technology, Bodies, Gothic๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ข๎˜‚
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎˜๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Hot Topics, Public Culture, Muse-
ums๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎–๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎š‹๎˜๎œ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Hands-On Exhibitions: Managing Interactive Museums
and Science Centres. Oxon: Routledge.
DANIEL IHRMARK, ZOI TSIVILTIDOU
92
๎˜ข๎๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎›•๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™‘๎›•๎œ-
๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Narrating Objects, Collecting Stories. Oxon:
Routledge.
๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎šฒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œฐ๎›Š๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜บ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขค๎˜‚
๎ขณ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎šƒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚GSCL 2015. Inter-
national Conference of the German Society for Computational Linguistics
and Language Technology. Proceedings of the Conference๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œด-
๎œด๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎๎›ต๎œด๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขด๎˜ฆ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขณ๎ข€๎กฝ๎ขฃ
๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Trauma and Dissociation Informed Psychotherapy:
Relational Healing and the Therapeutic Connection๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎–๎˜‚ ๎šง๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฃ
๎™“๎›ต๎›‘๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎›•๎œ๎œ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎˜‚
Challenging History in the Museum: International Perspectives๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎›•๎œ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚
๎™“๎›ต๎›‘๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎˜๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™“๎›ต๎œ†๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Electronic Visualisa-
tion and the Arts (EVA 2013)๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™“๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎–๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›‹-
๎˜ข๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šค๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขƒ๎ขณ๎กพ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™–๎›•๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎˜๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฃ Cu-
rating Dif๎ฅcult Knowledge: Violent Pasts in Public Places๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎šง๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ†-
๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ
๎™–๎›•๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎›ฑ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Dark Tourism: The Attraction of
Death and Disaster๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎๎œŒ๎ขฃ
๎™œ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Dif๎ฅcult Heritage: Negotiating the Nazi Past in
Nuremberg and Beyond๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎œ”๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œฐ๎๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Museums and Written Com-
munication: Tradition and Innovation๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›ต๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ซ๎˜๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›Š๎œ”-
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎–๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎š‹๎˜๎œ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข€๎ขณ๎ข€๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šณ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขด๎šค๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚Interactive
Storytelling. 7th International Conference on Interactive Digital Storytell-
ing, ICIDS 2014, Singapore, Singapore, November 3โ€“6, 2014. Proceedings.
๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ
๎™ผ๎๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎ขด๎š‹๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎•๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎œ”๎๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎™ผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•-
๎๎œŒ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎™๎˜ฆ๎šƒ๎šƒ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎˜‚ Archaeology in the Digital Era. Volume II:
e-Papers from the 40th Annual Conference of Computer Applications and
Quantitative Methods in Archaeology, Southampton, 26โ€“29 March 2012.
๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎˜๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขด๎˜บ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ-
๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œŒ-
๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎ข„๎ข„๎ขณ๎ข†๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Displaced Heri-
tage: Dealing with Disaster and Suffering. Ian Convery, Gerard Corsane,
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎˜๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎›•๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ข†๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ
๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Interpreting Dif๎ฅcult History at Museums and Historic Sites.
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ข๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎–๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ
๎™ฟ๎œ”๎๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚Form, Story, and History: The
๎š๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Virtual
93
ANALYSING ONLINE HORROR FICTION WITH CORPUS LINGUISTIC TECHNIQUES
Storytelling. Using Virtual Reality Technologies for Storytelling. Interna-
tional Conference ICVS 2001. Avignon, France, September 27โ€“28, 2001. Pro-
ceedings.๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜›๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›–๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ†-
๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎กพ๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข†๎กฝ๎ขฃ
๎™ฟ๎๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎๎๎œ†๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎ขด๎šค๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚The Transformative Museum: Proceedings of the DREAM
Conference. 23โ€“25 May 2012, Roskilde University, Denmark๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œƒ๎˜‚๎™“๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ-
๎œด๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ข๎™ฟ๎˜ฆ๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ข€๎กฟ๎ข‚๎ขณ๎ข€๎ข€๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚Museums, Prejudice and the Reframing of Difference.
๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ILVS Review
๎กฟ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข€๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฃ
๎šƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Exhibit Labels: An Interpretive Approach. California: Al-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ
๎šƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎•๎›–๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ๎œ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œ†๎๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Dif๎ฅcult Matters: Objects and
Narratives that Disturb and Affect๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚The Participatory Museum๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Museums and the Web 2004. Selected Pa-
pers from an International Conference๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™‘๎›•๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข€๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Annals of Tourism Research๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข„๎ข๎ขณ๎ข‚๎ข†๎ข‚๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขพ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Niche Tourism: Contemporary Issues, Trends and Cases๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ-
๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎—๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎œด๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ข๎ข„๎ขณ๎ข‚๎ข„๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚The Ambivalent Potentiality of Vulnerability: Museum
Pedagogy in Exhibitions on Dif๎ฅcult Matters and its Ethical Implications.
๎˜ข๎œ”๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œ†๎๎œญ๎ขฃ๎œ†๎๎›Š๎ขฃ๎œ†๎๎ขฃ๎œด๎›•๎ขฉ
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฉ๎–๎œด๎ขฉ๎ฃ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขฉ๎ข€๎ข๎ข๎ข‚๎กฟ๎ข„๎ข…๎ข…๎ขฉ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎ขช๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขช๎™ผ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขช๎œ”๎›ช๎ขช๎šค๎๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎ขช๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขช๎š‹๎™…๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎œญ๎›‘๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎œฉ๎œ๎›‘๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Nordisk Museologi๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขณ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šค๎›ต๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎š‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Theory, Culture
and Society๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขƒ๎ขณ๎ข„๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚Memorial Museums: The Global Rush to Commemorate
Atrocities๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎—๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ข๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šฅ๎›ต๎œผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ-
๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎›‘๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Museum Management and Curator-
ship๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข…๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข‚๎ข‚๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข„๎กพ๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎ขพ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฟ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚MW2015: Museums and the Web 2015.
๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œŒ๎–๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฉ
the-whole-story-and-then-some-digital-storytelling-in-evolving-mu-
seum-practice/ (accessed 2๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
94
APPENDIX
๎˜ƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ
Category headings Pastas
๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎›‘๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎ขด๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ข๎ข…๎ข„๎˜‚
๎˜›๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎ขž๎ข„๎ข…๎ข‚๎˜‚
๎˜›๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œ๎ขฟ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ข†๎ข„๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
in red.
๎ข๎กพ
๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎ฃ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ข‚๎กฝ๎ข„๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œฐ๎˜๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‘๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎˜๎œญ๎œผ๎œ”๎Ÿ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขด๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎ขฉ๎˜ข๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎ข๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขƒ๎ข„๎ข…๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฉ๎™‘๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขƒ๎ข†๎ข๎˜‚
Disappearances: People vanish every day. Perhaps the answers to some of their
๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ
๎ข…๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ขž๎กพ๎ข‚๎ข‚๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฉ๎šƒ๎œ†๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎๎œผ๎ขด๎›•๎˜๎›•๎ขŸ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ขž๎กพ๎กพ๎กฟ
Ghosts: How can you have a Creepypasta site without ghost stories? ๎ข†๎ขƒ๎ข…๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข‚๎˜‚
๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขƒ๎ข…
๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎ข‚๎กพ๎˜‚
Holders: They must never come together, for these are the original Holders series
stories.
๎กฟ๎ข…๎กพ๎˜‚
๎™๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ข„๎ขƒ๎˜‚
๎™…๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฉ๎™ฃ๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ข…๎ข„๎กฟ๎˜‚
๎™–๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œญ๎›ต๎œด๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎–๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขด๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œญ๎›ต๎œด๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
other digital media through a special screening or meeting usually directed to a
๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎œญ๎›ต๎œด๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ข๎ขƒ
๎™–๎œ”๎•๎›•๎›‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎˜ƒ๎ข ๎˜‚๎™…๎˜ƒ๎ข ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›ฑ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข„๎ข†
๎™œ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขด๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎ข๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฝ
95
ANALYSING ONLINE HORROR FICTION WITH CORPUS LINGUISTIC TECHNIQUES
๎™œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œ†๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎ขž๎ข‚๎ข€๎กฝ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขƒ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ ๎กพ๎ข†๎กฟ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œŒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฉ
devils.
๎ข†๎ข…๎ข†
๎™œ๎๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎ข๎˜‚โ™ช๎ฃ ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข„๎กพ
๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎ข€๎ข€๎˜‚
๎™๎šƒ๎˜บ๎šฅ๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
caution.
๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข†๎˜‚
Photography: Pastas pertaining particularly to peculiar photos. ๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎ขด
of-the-ordinary experience someone had at a certain place, usually local. These
pastas can also recollect the scary history that this place has had.
๎กพ๎ขž๎ข๎ข…๎ข€๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎œ”๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎–๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
These stories are poems.
๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข†๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎œ”๎œƒ๎›–๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎ข๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎ขพ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎œƒ๎›–๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ข†๎ข…
๎™ฟ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜๎œ”๎๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ขž๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ข€๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ขฟ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ†๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ข๎ข๎กฟ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎ขด๎›ช๎๎›‹๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
is located here.
๎ข๎ขƒ๎ข‚๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข๎ข†๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎ขฟ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎š‹๎šค๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™–๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œญ๎›ต๎œด๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ข๎กฟ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎ข…๎กฟ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กพ
๎šค๎›•๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œผ๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎—๎›ต๎œŒ๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กพ๎กพ๎ข„
๎šค๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข๎ข…
๎šฅ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฟ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขƒ๎ข๎ข†๎˜‚
๎šฎ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ข…
DANIEL IHRMARK, ZOI TSIVILTIDOU
96
B: Tools used for the data analysis
๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚AntConc ๎ขฐ๎šค๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต-
๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ https://www.laurenceanthony.net/software (ac-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ข๎›•๎œŒ๎œถ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎ก๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›•๎œถ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ž๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎ก๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎›๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎ก๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎ก๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›๎ขž๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š…๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎š๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฐ๎›Š๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎ก๎˜‚๎šฎ๎๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎›Š๎œ”๎—๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎˜๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Journal of
Machine Learning Research๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข€๎ข๎ข†๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ข‚๎ข€๎ขฃ
๎šƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎›–๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›‹๎œƒ๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Voyant Tools๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚
https://voyant-tools.org/๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
97
THE GENDER OF
AI-GENERATED ARTS
IN SARAH KENDERDINEโ€™S
โ€œDEEP FAKESโ€ AND AISHATU
GWADABEโ€™S AI ARTIVISM
NATASA THOUDAM
School of Liberal Arts and Digital Humanities-Interdisciplinary
Research Platform, Indian Institute of Technology Jodhpur
Jodhpur, Rajasthan, India
nthoudam@iitj.ac.in
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎ขด๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ-
๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎˜‚๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚
to arrive at her new media art practice on digital replicas for which
๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Gender and
Technology: A Reader๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎–๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›ฑ๎๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎›‹๎๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข€๎ข„๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎›ช๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
this gendered practice of categorising technologies into a racial one.
๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎›•๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข„๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚Processed Lives: Gender and Technology in Everyday Life, in
๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ค๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”-
๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎˜๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต-
๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎›‹๎๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข‚๎ขณ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ขด๎›•๎—-
๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎ขด๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎ขฃ
๎™“๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•
Original scienti๎Ÿ–c paper
NATASA THOUDAM
98
INTRODUCTION
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎ขด๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎šฎ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎˜‚๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‘๎œ”๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ-
๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ-
๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎ขด๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ-
tends to two questions through these two practitioners. One is wheth-
๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
question is, if so, how are they gendered? To attend to these questions,
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚Gender and Technology:
A Reader๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎™๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎–๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎›ฑ๎๎œ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ†๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™‘๎›•๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข„๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚Processed Lives: Gender and Technology in
Everyday Life๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
emergence of AI-generated art, which, as argued, is also gendered. It,
then, interrogates the artistic methods of these practitioners through
the lens of gender.
GENDER AND AI ARTS
In Gender and Technology: A Reader๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎–๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›ฑ๎๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ†๎˜๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎ขฝ๎ขž๎กพ๎ข„
๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎™…๎ขฟ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎›‘๎ขž
๎™๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎›•๎œ๎ขจ
99
THE GENDER OF AI-GENERATED ARTS IN SARAH KENDERDINEโ€™S โ€œDEEP FAKESโ€
they argue th๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ”๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ†๎˜๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎›‹๎๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขค๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขค๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎™…๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขฏ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต-
๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขค๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎›‹๎๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›ช๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎›ฑ๎๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šง๎›•๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎›•-
๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขพ๎œด๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎ขฟ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎ขฐ๎›ช๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹-
๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขพ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฟ๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ-
๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎›Š๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎™๎›•๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎˜๎›‘๎œ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ข…๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข†th century
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎ขฎ๎œผ๎ขฏ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎•๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎›‘๎ขฃ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž
๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฃ
๎™…๎ขฟ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขž
๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎ขจ
๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎ขž
๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•
๎ขฐ๎™–๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›ฑ๎๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎กพ๎ข… ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ๎˜บ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎ขช๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขด๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œŒ๎œ†.
NATASA THOUDAM
100
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎ขฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขพ๎˜บ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฃ
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ๎˜บ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎ขช๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขด๎กพ๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œŒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎ขพ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎˜๎›ซ๎œ๎๎œด๎ขฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข…๎ข‚๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ๎˜บ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎ขช๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขด๎กพ๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œŒ๎œ†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎šฒn Rothschild who reviewed Gender and Technology:
A Reader๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข‚๎กฝ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข‚๎กฝ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข๎ข๎˜‚๎ข†๎กฝ๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ฃ๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎›‘๎ขฃ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎›‹๎๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ช๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขพ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขพ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฟ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™–๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›ฑ๎๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
101
THE GENDER OF AI-GENERATED ARTS IN SARAH KENDERDINEโ€™S โ€œDEEP FAKESโ€
๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎™‘๎›•๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚Processed Lives: Gender and Technology in Everyday
Life ๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข„๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
gendered? By what assumptions can we, for example, entertain the
claim that guns are masculine machines and curling irons are feminine
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎ขค๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ-
๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขค๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ช๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎œด-
๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎˜๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎›‹๎๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข‚๎ขณ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
moves on to trace the history of the emergence of a particular technol-
ogy, namely, AI and its role in artistic production. The section titled
๎ขผ๎™ผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚Artist in the
Machine: The World of AI-Powered Creativity๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ข†๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚Gaussian Quadratic.
๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎ขฎ๎™๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎ขฟ๎œด๎ขฏ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขด๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎›ต๎›ซ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎•๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขด๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ-
ages using Convolutional Neural Networks๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎•๎™๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ข†๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎•๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚DeepDream, a
๎œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐeate art, resulting
๎กพ๎ข†๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎šฒ๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œ๎›•๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™๎›•๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขŸ๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎˜๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎•๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎-
๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎˜๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
NATASA THOUDAM
102
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎˜๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎š‹๎˜๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ฃ”๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎™…๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎†๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขด
๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œƒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎ค๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ DeepDream๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ Learning
to See: Hello, World!๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎›ต๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ-
๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚ ๎œ๎›•๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎›•๎›‘๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ-
๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
Henryโ€™s computer-generated Music for 18 Musicians โ€“ Steve Reich๎ขฝ๎ขฃ
Another machine learning technology that simultaneously emerged
along with DeepDream was the Generative Adversarial Network๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขฑ๎ขž๎กฟ๎กฝ
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™…๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎›ช๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎š‹๎˜๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚Portraits of Imaginary People
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎™๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎™…๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜œ๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎™๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐConditional Generative Adversarial
Networks๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กพ This system is named as Pix2Pix ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™…๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ-
๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
of Pix2Pix ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฟ๎ข…๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต-
๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œŒ๎˜‚Fall of the House of Usher๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™ฃ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎™๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎๎œ๎ขด๎šง๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฎ๎›ฑ๎๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
Pix2Pix CycleGAN๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎๎œ๎ขด๎šง๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎™๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด-
๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎™๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎ขฎ๎œผ๎ขฏ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎œผ-
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎ขฑ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎™๎›•๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ป๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜-
๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ป๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ป๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ-
๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กพ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎™๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎ขฎ๎œผ๎ขฏ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
103
THE GENDER OF AI-GENERATED ARTS IN SARAH KENDERDINEโ€™S โ€œDEEP FAKESโ€
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎Ÿ๎›•๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎˜๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎ขฎ๎›ฑ๎ขฏ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ-
๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎›•๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎ขฎ๎šฒ๎ขฏ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎˜๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜œ๎˜ƒ๎™๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐCreative Adversarial
Networks๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎™๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎˜ƒ๎™๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎™๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎˜ข๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ป๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎™๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎™๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚Portrait of Edmond de Belamy, cre-
๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›Š๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
Coltonโ€™s The Painting Fool๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด-
๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ†๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ The Painting Fool๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›ซ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚The Painting Fool๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎–๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฉ๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฉ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚The Painting Fool,
๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฃ
๎™œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขด๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎ขด๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎œผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎๎œ†๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎›‘๎ขฃ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ22๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
survey highlights a gendered history of AI-generated arts. The glaring
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ
22 ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ.
NATASA THOUDAM
104
GENDER IN KENDERDINEโ€™S โ€œDEEP FAKESโ€ AND
GWADABEโ€™S AI ARTIVISM
One of the texts used for analysis in this๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šง๎œ”๎๎š‹๎๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ข๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎œ”๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ Preservation of Cultural
Material๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎˜‚๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎šง๎œ”๎๎š‹๎๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎—๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ†๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฝ๎ขฃ
As indicated in the caption of Kenderdineโ€™s presentation video on
๎šง๎œ”๎๎š‹๎๎›Š๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎›Š๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎œ”๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฏ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ-
๎œ๎›ต๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช-
๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ขฎ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎ขฏ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™“๎œฐ๎šฒ๎๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎›ช๎›•๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ-
tion, she explores six installations from a total of twenty-one in this
๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
mediated through participatory interphases such as mixed, augment-
๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚
while also emphasising a particular temporal and critical stage of these
๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎๎›ซ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎Ÿes outdated no-
105
THE GENDER OF AI-GENERATED ARTS IN SARAH KENDERDINEโ€™S โ€œDEEP FAKESโ€
tions ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•-
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›ช๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
confronting authoritative discourses, historical sedimentation, and
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎œ”๎›ต๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†-
lation titled Speaking Back๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
counterparts instead of the originals is exploding systems and codes of
๎œ”๎–๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
which was made citing her installation titled Pure Land Augmented
Reality Edition๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎ขฎ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฏ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎˜๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด-
๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†-
lation titled The Next Rembrandt๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ-
other installation titled 89 Seconds Atomized๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎œด๎œด๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎˜๎œด๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎œƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
installation she discussed was titled Helin ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™–๎œ”๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎—๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฏ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขจ๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎›‘๎ขฃ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
Kenderdine herself, what emerges is Kenderdine as a collector or as-
๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚
fus๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
NATASA THOUDAM
106
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ƒ๎™…๎—๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎˜๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎•ism with Aishatu
๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎ค๎-
๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎ค๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎ขด๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขด๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
hand, or they are gendered as in the historical case of female human
computers. In the lecture, she puts her art practice within the domain
of design, and in light of this intersectional discrimination, she advo-
cates the need to reimagine this domain in a postcolonial context. This
๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎ขด๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขด๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎ขด๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขด๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎ขด๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œด๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎ขด๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎–๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ”๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎ขด๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎ขด๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎ขฎ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฏ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎ขด๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œ๎›–๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œด๎๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œด๎˜๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™…๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ฆ๎›‹๎œ”๎ขด๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขด๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ตs is also
107
THE GENDER OF AI-GENERATED ARTS IN SARAH KENDERDINEโ€™S โ€œDEEP FAKESโ€
๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎ข€ Continuing
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎›Š๎๎œ๎œผ๎๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œ”๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œ”๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œญ๎œ†๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œ”๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎ขด
๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜บ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎œญ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎›‘๎ขฃ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
To examine these two art practices through the lens of gender, the
๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”-
๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›ซ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎˜ข๎™ผ๎™ฟ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ขฏ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฏ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•-
๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฃ๎œƒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎›Š๎๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎˜บ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขฏ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฏ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™“๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎–๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎›ต-
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎œด๎ขฉ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”-
๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎œ†๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ”๎›Š-
๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎กฟ๎ข€๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎ค๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚Staying with the
Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
NATASA THOUDAM
108
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎˜๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š-
๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎ขด๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•-
๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›ต๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎•๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚
๎๎œ๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎œผ๎˜๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎๎ขด๎™–๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎š๎œ†๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎˜๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎๎ขด๎™–๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ”๎๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎œ”๎๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎š๎›Š๎๎œ๎œผ๎๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œ”๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œญ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขพ๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†-
๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขพ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฟ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎˜๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎๎ขด๎™–๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎œผ๎˜๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎๎ขด๎™–๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ”๎๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎œ”๎๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฏ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
that are not exclusively related to meani๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
109
THE GENDER OF AI-GENERATED ARTS IN SARAH KENDERDINEโ€™S โ€œDEEP FAKESโ€
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎›‘๎ขฃ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
question regarding gender. The category gender is used as a lens to ex-
๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
same as a feminist lens. While this category critiques the gendering of
๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
institutions such as patriarchy, racism, sexism, classicism, colonialism,
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
are attentive to the gendered nature of their contexts, namely digi-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œ”๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œญ๎›ต๎œด-
๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
Afrofuturism.๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚
The question that remains is whether the intersectionality of the two
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎ขด๎–๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎›‹๎๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขด
feminine, original-replica, production-consumption, Western-African,
๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ขด๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขด๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
REFERENCES LIST
๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎™…๎—๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎˜๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎˜‚๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎˜๎œ”๎๎œผ๎๎›Š๎›•๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขค๎•๎ฃ˜๎›•๎ข€๎™๎˜ƒ๎˜œ๎˜œ๎œผ๎Ÿ๎™ฃ๎˜ป๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”-
๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎ขผ๎˜ข๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฑ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎˜๎œ”๎๎œผ๎๎›Š๎›•๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขค๎•๎ฃ˜๎˜ƒ๎›•๎ข‚๎œผ๎™–๎˜œ๎Ÿ๎œญ๎™ผ๎–๎ข (ac-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ Black
Athena: The Afroasiatic Roots of Classical Civilization๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎›ช๎œƒ๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎Ÿ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚Not Out of
Africa: How Afrocentrism Became an Excuse to Teach Myth as History.
NATASA THOUDAM
110
๎ขผ๎˜บ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š-
๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ๎˜บ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎ขช๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขด๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œŒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎ขผ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Emerging Technologies and Museums: Mediating Dif๎ฅcult Heri-
tage๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎˜๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎๎ขด๎™–๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ-
๎šฒ๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎œ”๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎šง๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎šง๎ข๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ
๎ขผ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Gender and Technology: A
Reader๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎–๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›ฑ๎๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต-
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎˜ข๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎›ฑ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œญ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขณ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฉ๎™–๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Processed Lives: Gender and Technol-
ogy in Everyday Life๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™‘๎›•๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎šง๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎šง๎ข๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ
๎™“๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎ขฃ๎™–๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขค๎ขฝ๎˜‚
Internet Policy Review๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ
๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Artist in the
Machine: The World of AI-Powered Creativity๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ-
๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎™…๎š‹๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎ขด๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎ขฃ
๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ฟ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚Gender and Technology: A Reader๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Tech-
nology and Culture๎˜‚๎ข๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข†๎กฝ๎ข…๎ขณ๎ข†๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ
LIMITATIONS
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขด๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎ขด๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚
respectively curated and created. Hence, the history that was traced
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
paper is aware of the emergence of AI art generators and demonstrates
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
111
THE GENDER OF AI-GENERATED ARTS IN SARAH KENDERDINEโ€™S โ€œDEEP FAKESโ€
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜บ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎˜๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎˜๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚https://creator.nightcafe.
studio/.
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎˜๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚https://creator.nightcafe.
studio/๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ†๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎ขด
ween an original and its replica and the issues associated with it.
NATASA THOUDAM
112
APPENDIX
AI AND CREATIVE ARTS
๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎›‹๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎›‘๎›ฑ๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ
โ€œCAN COMPUTERS BE CREATIVE?โ€
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚The Artist in the Machine:
The World of AI-powered Creativity๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›Š๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎ขฃ
The group that favours computer creativity say the following:
๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขŸ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
sidered innate to humans โ€“ imagination, creativity, even conscious-
๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎™๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œด
๎ขผ๎™œ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฃ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎™…๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎›ช๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•
๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎ขฃ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜
๎ขผ๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎ขฃ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ†๎›•๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ
๎ขผ๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ขฟ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฃ๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
Aguera y Arcas, Google
The other group, against such creativity, claims:
๎ขผ๎™…๎ขฟ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•-
๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฃ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎šง๎š
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
are as follows:
๎กพ๎ข†๎ข‚๎ขƒ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎›ฑ๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›‹๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜
๎กพ๎ข†๎ขƒ๎ข‚๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚
๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎›ต๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
113
THE GENDER OF AI-GENERATED ARTS IN SARAH KENDERDINEโ€™S โ€œDEEP FAKESโ€
๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎›ต๎›ต๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†
๎กพ๎ข†๎ขƒ๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚AARON, that creates original artis-
tic images
๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎กฝ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›ต๎›‹
๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎›•๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”
๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎กฝ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›ต๎›‹
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›Ž๎œ”๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚Continuator (a system that can improvise with
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฑ
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ข๎˜‚ ๎™…๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎›ช๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎™๎œด๎ขฑ
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ข๎˜‚ DeepDream๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎•๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎•
๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎™…๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘
๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎™“๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚Monalisa
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚DeepDream: The Art of Neural Networks
๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚Recognition
๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›•๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚Neural Style Transfer algorithm
๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‹๎œƒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚Project Magenta๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฑ
๎˜‚ ๎™–๎šฒ๎๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚WaveNet, NSynth, and Coconet
๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›ต๎›‹
๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚Hyperscore
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œ๎Ÿ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚Learning to See: Hello
World๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œƒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ
Damien Henryโ€™s computer-generated Music for 18 Musicians โ€“
Steve Reich
๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎˜๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚Portraits of Imaginary People
๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎ขด๎˜ข๎๎›Š๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚A(.I.) Messianic Window๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘
๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎–๎›•๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚Latent Space
Phillip Isolaโ€™s Pix2Pix
๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎๎œ๎ขด๎šง๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎›ฑ๎๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚cycleGAN
๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚Creative Adversarial Networks๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚Portrait of Edmond de Belamy๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎™
๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚The Painting Fool
๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œผ
NATASA THOUDAM
114
Computer creativity in India:
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎™…๎ขด๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
Gradient Descent๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
Open Codes๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎™“๎™œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎œด๎œฐ๎๎›ฑ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œ†๎›•๎›•๎›Š๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜
๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚Juggernaut made use of video game
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™“๎™“๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚La Petite Mort ๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎˜บ๎š‹๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
Harshit Agrawal,
๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›Š๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ
๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎–๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚ (author)rise ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต
๎˜‚ ๎šง๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ”๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šง๎šฒ๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎›ฑ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
authorship of digital texts
Agarwalโ€™s Strange Genders๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎™๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
gender
๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎–๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚EXO-stential โ€“ AI Musings on the
Posthuman๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎๎œผ๎œผ๎šฒ
Rahalโ€™s ๎ฅnalforest.exe ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚Cyborg Desires
๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎›•๎œ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›ซ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขพ๎™œ๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎ขฟ๎ขฝ
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚Metamind: In๎ฅnite Possibility ๎ขผ๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›•๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎กฝ๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œ๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎ขด๎˜บ๎›ต๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ
๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ข https://mapacademy.io/article/ai-art-in-india/ and ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ
indiatimes.com/india/how-indian-artists-are-using-ai-ar-to-let-creativity-soar/
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎ขฉ๎ข†๎ข…๎ขƒ๎ข๎ข๎ข€๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎ขฑ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขค๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
of the creative, ethical, sociological, and critical quests of this specialisa-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขฃ
115
TEACHERS AS CREATORS
OF ETHNOGRAPHIC
KNOWLEDGE โ€“
PRESENTATION OF
COLLECTED MATERIAL
IN A DIGITAL ENVIRONMENT
DANIJELA BIRT KATIฤ†
University of Zadar
Department of Ethnology and Anthropology
Zadar, Croatia
dbirt@unizd.hr
MARTINA KRIVIฤ† LEKIฤ†
State Archives in Bjelovar
Bjelovar, Croatia
krivic.lekic@dabj.hr
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8826-5956
๎ขผ๎™ผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข†๎ข„๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข‚๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎™“๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚
๎š๎˜ž๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ-
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†th๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝth
century. By reviewing, researching, and critically analysing the archi-
๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎ค๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข†๎ข„๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข‚๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
the understanding of the role ethnologists have in the contemporary
context, as well as disseminate and popularise the topics of ethnol-
๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
Preliminary communication
DANIJELA BIRT KATIฤ†, MARTINA KRIVIฤ† LEKIฤ†
116
we decided that it was necessary to develop a way of displaying and
sharing the collected archival material. Considering the diversity of
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
terpretation and valuation.
Keywords: teachers, ethnography, digital platform, digital space,
๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ
PRESENTING THE PROJECT TIMELINE, AIMS, ACTIVITIES, AND
EXPECTED RESULTS
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”-
๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎ขด๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
the developments of ethnological thought in Croatia with an empha-
๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œŒ๎๎œด๎ฃ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎š‹๎™ฟ๎˜ƒ๎™๎šƒ๎˜œ๎˜ƒ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎ข‚๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š-
๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎˜ž๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
and ethnographic materials.
๎กฟ๎ข‚๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎™ฟ๎˜ƒ๎™๎šƒ๎˜œ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎š‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎ขด๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œŒ๎๎œด๎ฃ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎šฒ๎œ†๎œƒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎ฃฏ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
main resource on this page is different concepts from sociocultural anthropology,
which are prepared for teachers to use in their classrooms.
117
TEACHERS AS CREATORS OF ETHNOGRAPHIC KNOWLEDGE
๎šƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข†๎ข„๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข‚๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎™“๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚๎š๎˜ž๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
for experts from university departments to gather in the team, with
great support from experts coming from cooperating institutions.
๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ-
๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎˜ข๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›ต๎›๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎›•๎›‘๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎˜ข๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎œƒ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚ ๎™“๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œถ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™“๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎œƒ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎˜ข๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎š‹๎๎œฐ๎›๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šค๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎˜ข๎˜‚๎™…๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š…๎œผ๎œ”๎œƒ๎œ”๎•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚
๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎™…๎šƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎๎œ๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
title Osnova za sabiranje i prouฤavanje graฤ‘e o narodnom ลพivotu.๎กฟ๎ขƒ The
found material will serve in the interpretation and valorisation of the
๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ต-
๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎๎œ๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎˜ž๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข†๎ข„๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ-
๎œผ๎๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚Zbornik za narodni ลพivot i obiฤaje (Collection for Folk Life and Customs๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š-
๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข†๎ข„๎˜‚
under the title Osnova za sabiranje i prouฤavanje graฤ‘e o narodnom ลพivotu (Foundation
for Collecting and Studying Materials on Folk Life๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚
DANIJELA BIRT KATIฤ†, MARTINA KRIVIฤ† LEKIฤ†
118
๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข‚๎ข๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎ฃ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
Zbornik za narodni ลพivot i obiฤaje, i.e. the change occurred in the edi-
๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ-
ers that are not stored in the Academyโ€™s archive or written exclusively
๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚Osnova ๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
Therefore, school funds, and personal funds of individual people, stored
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎กฟ๎ข„ with
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
the territory of Banovina of Croatia (Banovina Hrvatska๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎™…๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎š…๎๎›Š๎šฒ๎œถ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎šฒ๎œ๎๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎กฝ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
schools. The goal of the writing was to acquaint the teacher with the
everyday life of the peasants/people with the aim of accepting these
๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ขด๎›•๎›‘-
ucated. Immediately after the decree was adopted, the Department of
๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚Instructions for Managing Ethnographic Memory
Books๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š-
๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎๎›ช-
๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
ignorance, inadvertently destroyed or participated in the destruction
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
down a๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š-
๎กฟ๎ข„๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œ†๎šฒ๎–๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™“๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎•๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข„๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฐ๎๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
well as the native or local history, among other things they contain otherwise scarcely
๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
119
TEACHERS AS CREATORS OF ETHNOGRAPHIC KNOWLEDGE
uted to the multi-y๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ
To write down the data, teachers were recommended to use Antun
๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
four-year period, that is, the material collected during that period was
supposed to serve in the planning of new educational programmes and
๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎ขž๎กฟ๎ข… was en-
๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎ข† In
๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎กฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎˜›๎˜œ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ†๎๎›Š๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›‹๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎›•๎–๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
of this practice.๎ข€๎กฝ
๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚
revealed a manuscript entitled Village and Villagers๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎œ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œฐuvar. The
๎กฟ๎ข…๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝth
๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
new generations of ethnologists who strive to understand, follow, and criticise his
research approach.
๎กฟ๎ข†๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝth๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ-
๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ขฃ
๎ข€๎กฝ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œด๎๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎กพ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎ขด๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข๎ข…๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚
complete.
DANIJELA BIRT KATIฤ†, MARTINA KRIVIฤ† LEKIฤ†
120
๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎Ÿ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎šฒ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎˜ž๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ-
๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎ข€๎กพ
TEACHERS AS CREATORS OF ETHNOGRAPHIC KNOWLEDGE
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎ค๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝth๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข†๎ข„๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚Zbornik za
narodni ลพivot i obiฤaje๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขด๎›ต๎œ๎ขด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎›ช๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎›๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›๎œƒ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚
in a text entitled Osnova za sabiranje i prouฤavanje graฤ‘e o narodnom
ลพivotu. The Osnova, sometimes referred to as the Questionnaire, is a
methodological guideline for the collection of ethnographic material,
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎ข€๎กฟ
๎ข€๎กพ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎ข ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ฃ๎ขฃ
๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ.
๎ข€๎กฟ Foundation for Collecting and Studying Materials on Folk Life consists of three
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚
121
TEACHERS AS CREATORS OF ETHNOGRAPHIC KNOWLEDGE
๎˜›๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›‹๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎˜๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
the peasants. In those initial years, the Academy encouraged external
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‹๎›ช๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ž๎๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข†๎ข๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œ†๎šฒ๎–๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹-
๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚Friend of the People
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข†๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚
arriving and was stored in the Academyโ€™s archive awaiting the review
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚Collection for Folk Life and Customs๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ-
๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œŒ-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šค๎›•๎œด๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜ž๎๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚ ๎™“๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚
notes that the main aim was to guide collectors on how to write an
๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข†๎ข๎˜‚๎ข„๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข‚๎กฝ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎-
๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎˜๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข†๎ข…๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฝ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
๎ข€๎ขƒ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎•๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ”๎œด๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎Ÿ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œ†๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข„๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ž๎๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
importance of the Osnova ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚Osnova encompasses
the overall content of the peopleโ€™s life and culture, as they try to direct
the recording to the monographic description of individual, mostly ru-
๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข„๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚Zbornik, and Dragutin
๎˜›๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข‚๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™–๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œด๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™–๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขž ๎ขผ๎™–๎šฒ๎–๎ขฝ๎ขž ๎ขผ๎˜œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž
๎ขผ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขž ๎ขผ๎™ผ๎œ”๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขž ๎ขผ๎˜›๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎›ช๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œด๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
DANIJELA BIRT KATIฤ†, MARTINA KRIVIฤ† LEKIฤ†
122
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎-
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
down the ethnographic material, i.e. literate peasants or people from
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ž๎šฒ๎œญ๎œ”๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข„๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚amateur collectors,
๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚
implied certain advantages and disadvantages. The position of insid-
๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎œ”๎๎œด๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
other hand, it was a position that did not allow them a certain distance
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œŒ๎๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
records were prepared as idealised descriptions of everyday life, and if
they were in tune with real-life situations and events. Despite this, the
records remain an important source for contemporary researchers of
๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต-
ties. We can say that on many occasions they are the only witness to a
time and way of life that passed.
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚Zbornik za narodni ลพivot i obiฤaje, selected parts of
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜-
๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™–๎๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™–๎๎œƒ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šค๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œถ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ-
๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข‚๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กพ๎ข†๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฟ๎ข๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฟ๎ข‚๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™“๎œ†๎šฒ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚Luka Lukiฤ‡:
Description of the Village of Klakarja 1905 โ€“ 1953.๎ข€๎ข€
๎ข€๎ข€๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™–๎๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎๎œƒ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ Luka Lukiฤ‡:
Teacher, Ethnographer and Melographer in Klakar๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎˜ƒ๎šฎ๎š๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚Description of the Village of Klakarja: Stories and
Poems Collected from the Mid-19th Century to the 20th Century and Description of the
Village of Klakarja: Construction, Furniture, Appliances and Tools at the Beginning of
the 20th Century ๎ขฐ๎šค๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚Luka Lukiฤ‡: Description of the
village of Klakarja 1905 โ€“ 1953๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚Zbornik za narodni ลพivot i
obiฤaje๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ
123
TEACHERS AS CREATORS OF ETHNOGRAPHIC KNOWLEDGE
๎šฅ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎˜ƒ๎šฎ๎š๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ-
๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œƒ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚Ivan Filakovac: ลฝupa Retkovci
1898 โ€“ 1902๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‹๎›ช๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎œŒ๎œถ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
the Academyโ€™s employees and associates invested in the preparation
of the manuscripts, one part of them remains stored in the archives.
๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎˜ž๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†-
oped activities such as a digital interactive map. The interactive map,
among other things, indicates the frequency and regional prevalence
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
tains the record of the teacherโ€™s manuscripts from the Archives of the
๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎˜›๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎›ซ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎•๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ”๎›ซ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™“๎œฐ๎›๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œƒ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œ†๎ฃ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œด๎œ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฐ๎›ต๎ก๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™…๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š…๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎ขด๎˜›๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎œถ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฐ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Osnova๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
school are included in the third part as the last chapter, and it contains
๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฟ๎ข†๎ข๎˜‚๎ข๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎-
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†-
๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚
i.e., the importance that education had in communities that depended
DANIJELA BIRT KATIฤ†, MARTINA KRIVIฤ† LEKIฤ†
124
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
sight into teachersโ€™ views on the living culture and everyday life, also an
insight into the positioning of teachers in relation to the communities
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ
THE MANUSCRIPT OF STJEPAN AUGUST: BETWEEN
PUBLICATION AND DIGITISATION
๎™ฃ๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
manuscript Village and Villagers๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎ข€๎ข The manuscript is dated
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฝ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กพ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
listed the dates as he wrote other parts of the text.
Considering the different quality of the handwriting some parts of
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ-
๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
school life which the author supplemented more extensively with in-
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜-
๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข…๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•-
๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‘๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›•๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ก๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด-
๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›‘๎œ๎ขฟ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚
๎ข‚๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
125
TEACHERS AS CREATORS OF ETHNOGRAPHIC KNOWLEDGE
๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎˜‚
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘-
๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œด๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ฃ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
writes from his own experience and advises his future successor on
๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ†๎ฃ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎˜๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎ฃ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
The manuscript Village and Villagers is divided into three parts. In the
๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œ†-
๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜›๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ ลฝivopis๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
village, portraying in detail individual families, their negative attitude
towards childrenโ€™s schooling in the Croatian language, and in the same
context he also mentions the hygiene of the household and the attitude
๎œผ๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฉ๎˜ƒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎๎œŒ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜‚
๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
the schoolโ€™s history.
๎˜บ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎-
๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
shaped the everyday life of the population, from immigration, and in-
teraction of settlers and domiciled population to the development of
DANIJELA BIRT KATIฤ†, MARTINA KRIVIฤ† LEKIฤ†
126
crafts and agriculture. The r๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
nected to the Austrian administration, the arrival of the colonists, and
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎˜๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎•-
eryday life and the affairs of the local population. The authorโ€™s opinion,
๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
the manuscript. The strong voice of the author who does not refrain
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎—-
๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
the entire manuscript.
The process of rewriting lasted a little over six months, considering
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
the terms that are no longer in use. Also, due to the authorโ€™s tendency
to use Germanisms, written down in literal translation, it was rather
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‹๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎–๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚
and once independently. In the second phase, critical processing of the
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚
entailed writing an introductory study, which explains all the steps of
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚
Part of the literature was related to enlightening the teacherโ€™s role and
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚
required the editors to employ a sharp and critical eye as we meticu-
lously examined whether the author expresses himself clearly in the
๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎›Š๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‹๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œด๎๎›Š๎ขด๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎œ”-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎œ†-
ogy. The third step was the ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
127
TEACHERS AS CREATORS OF ETHNOGRAPHIC KNOWLEDGE
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎๎›Š๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹-
๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†-
๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚Village and
Villagers๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฝ๎ขฃ
THE PLATFORM OMEKA.NET TAILORED FOR THE UฤŒEKA
PROJECT
๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎š๎˜ž๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
institution and funds, collecting information regardless of its direct
๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
tended to share all collected materials, thus saving each participant
from the need to visit multiple archives to access the same documents.
๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
of high-quality recording of archival material. All participants were
familiarised with the Instructions for the Digitization of Documentary
and Archival Material๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎ขด๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
in a digital environment.
๎˜ข๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎˜‚๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ-
plications of the collected material in a concise and visually interesting
format. Therefore, it was necessary to come up with a way of displaying
and sharing the collected archival material.
Considering the diversity of the material and previous experience
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎˜๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ๎Ÿ๎–๎›•๎›ต๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
DANIJELA BIRT KATIฤ†, MARTINA KRIVIฤ† LEKIฤ†
128
๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎ฃ๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
an open-source content management system that allows users to use
๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต-
versity and a greater level of customisation of the platform to users
๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎šณ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎šƒ๎˜ƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ-
age on the userโ€™s server and certain system requirements that were
๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ข‚๎กฝ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™œ๎˜›๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎Ÿ-
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ-
๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขด๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
the hierarchical arrangement of document collections and the creation
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ฃ๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›Š๎œ”๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹-
tion, you can create a visual layout along with the text commenting on
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œญ-
๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ-
๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜›๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†-
lections that are made on the principle of respecting the provenance of
the source. The next criterion is the grouping of the collected materials
129
TEACHERS AS CREATORS OF ETHNOGRAPHIC KNOWLEDGE
into section๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ-
data. In this way, easier navigation through a large amount of collected
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎•๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎›ช๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ๎›ต-
๎›•๎œผ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ฃ๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎—๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎ขด๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ-
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎ขฃ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•-
๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข€๎ข†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
charge of contacting the schools were sending instructions regarding
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎ขฃ๎›•๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
site visitor is interested in. The participantsโ€™ materials, collected from
๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜-
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
audience.
CONCLUDING REMARKS
The reason for using a digital platform is the need to ensure the wider
๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
this way, users do not have to download additional materials or applica-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
DANIJELA BIRT KATIฤ†, MARTINA KRIVIฤ† LEKIฤ†
130
๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎œ”๎๎œด๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚
interested in the topic and material.
REFERENCES LIST
๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‘๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ก๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œถ๎œƒ๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œƒ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎Ÿ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œฐ๎ก๎šฒ๎•๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎•๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Anali za povijest odgoja
๎กพ๎ข๎ข๎˜‚๎ข๎ข†๎ขณ๎ขƒ๎ข…๎ขฃ
๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎šณ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ-
๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎ขด๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎œด๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Cultural Heritage Care
and Management: Theory and Practice. ๎˜œ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ข๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎–๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ฃฏ๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข‚๎ข€๎ขณ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ข†๎ขฃ
๎˜ž๎šฒ๎œญ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎œด๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎˜‚๎œด๎๎•๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎œถ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ก๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
Narodna umjetnost๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข†๎ขณ๎ข€๎ข€๎ขฃ
๎˜ž๎๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚ ๎™“๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šค๎›•๎œด๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œƒ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œผ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎œถ๎œƒ๎›ต๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ก๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎šฒ๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ๎๎˜‚๎œƒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎๎˜‚๎๎˜‚๎™๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎œƒ๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Etnoloลกka tribina
๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎ข„๎ขณ๎ข…๎ข…๎ขฃ
๎˜ข๎›ต๎œŒ๎œถ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™…๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œƒ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฐ๎๎œญ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œผ๎œƒ๎œ”๎•๎›‹๎›ต๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข†๎ข…๎ขฃ๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข†๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ขด
๎šค๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎œ”๎•๎›‹๎›ต๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Rad Hrvatske akademije znanosti i umjetnosti. Razred za
druลกtvene znanosti๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข‚๎กฝ๎ฃ˜๎ข‚๎ขƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข€๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚
131
TEACHERS AS CREATORS OF ETHNOGRAPHIC KNOWLEDGE
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Etnografske spomenice i etnografske zbirke u narod-
nim ลกkolama Banovine Hrvatske๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ข๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎ขด๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œญ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š…๎œƒ๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎šฒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎œด๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›ต๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎˜‚๎œถ๎œƒ๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎œผ๎•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎˜‚๎œ”๎œƒ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Memo-
rabiLika๎˜‚๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œผ๎๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข†๎กฟ๎ข†๎ขฃ Osnova za sabiranje i prouฤavanje graฤ‘e o narodnom
ลพivotu. (Drugo izdanje)๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ข๎˜‚๎™‘๎˜ƒ๎šฎ๎š๎ขฃ
๎šค๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™–๎๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™–๎๎œƒ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œญ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ†๎šฒ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข‚๎ข€๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚
๎™“๎œ†๎šฒ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Rad Hrvatske akademije znanosti i umjetnosti. Razred za
druลกtvene znanosti๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข‚๎กฝ๎ฃ˜๎ข‚๎ขƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข„๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข„๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šฐ๎๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎ขพ๎šฐ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎œ†๎›ต๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎ข ๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎˜‚๎œถ๎œƒ๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎˜‚
๎›ต๎Ÿ๎•๎œ๎›•๎œถ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎ก๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™“๎๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎ขด๎™๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎ก๎๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข…๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎›ต๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข†๎ข€๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Scrinia Slavonica๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚
LIST OF SOURCES
๎˜ƒ๎๎›ซ๎๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Village and Vil-
lagers๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎™ฟ๎ขด๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎˜›๎™‘๎˜‚๎ข…๎ข๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™ฃ๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ข‚๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š๎›๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ๎›ต๎˜‚๎œƒ๎šฒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎œ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ช๎œด๎œƒ๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎œ๎œ”-
๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ฃ๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
133
ADAPTING ENGLISH-LANGUAGE
PEDAGOGY TO CULTURAL
HERITAGE AND DIGITAL
HUMANITIES IN FRANCE:
RESULTS FROM USING THE
IIIF ONLINE WORKSHOP WITH
FUTURE RESEARCH ENGINEERS,
LIBRARIANS, AND ARCHIVISTS
EDWARD J. GRAY
DARIAH-EU / Huma-Num (CNRS)
Paris, France
edward.gray@dariah.eu
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5201-1014
The preservation of cultural heritage is one of the fundamental mis-
sions of Lโ€™ร‰cole nationale des chartes๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
the ร‰cole๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚Technologies numรฉriques
appliquรฉes ร  lโ€™histoire๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎š‹๎™๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด-
๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
engineers in a common program that focuses on the technical as-
๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•-
๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚
years, as a chargรฉ de cours๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚
(๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎›ต๎›ต๎›ต๎›ช๎ขฃ๎›ต๎œ”๎ขฉ๎›ต๎›ต๎›ต๎›ช๎ขด๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขด๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎—๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œŒ๎œ†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚
standard, from understanding its uses to manipulating the image API,
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ-
๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
Professional paper
EDWARD J. GRAY
134
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
munication, alongside a technical standard that is increasingly more
in demand.
๎™“๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎-
manities, cultural heritage
๎šฅ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎ข€๎ข‚ It is used in documentation,
๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ-
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—-
change their ideas. Thus, it is commonplace for Digital Humanities de-
๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚Technologies
numรฉriques appliquรฉes ร  lโ€™histoire๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚Lโ€™ร‰cole nationale
des chartes in Paris is no different. As the instructor of this class, I wish
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ-
struction on digital humanities content, including relevant and practi-
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
The solution adopted to confront this challenge and provide the
most useful course was to adopt units and assignments geared towards
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎•๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
introducing students to a DH-relevant professional experience, as it
๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚use
๎ข€๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘-
๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚
the three cohorts ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎™๎˜ƒ๎™๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™“๎๎Ÿ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎š…๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎™๎™ฟ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚
in running the Digital Humanities & Heritage international conference and for the op-
๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
135
ADAPTING ENGLISH-LANGUAGE PEDAGOGY TO CULTURAL HERITAGE AND DIGITAL HUMANITIES
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚
as if they were enrolled in it as part of their professional duties. This
๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚how to under-
๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎˜๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—-
๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚
colleagues.
In terms of pedagogical outcomes, this approach leads to a holistic
๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
fronted with written and oral comprehension activities, in the process
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ-
๎œ๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ why it exists and how it
๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎ขด๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎™๎˜ƒ๎™๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”-
๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎™๎˜ƒ๎™๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚Lโ€™ร‰cole nationale des chartes
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚Lโ€™ร‰cole nationale des chartes, which
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚grande รฉcole๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
preservation and study of cultural heritage and has a long and storied
EDWARD J. GRAY
136
๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎™๎˜ƒ๎™๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
preservation of cultural heritage, adapted for a new, digital age. Alumni
๎›ซ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎™๎˜ƒ๎™๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”-
cused on the study of sources, with a short introduction to technical
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฆ๎™œ๎™–๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎ขด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‘๎ขด๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎ขด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎ขด๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต-
vate institution during which they will put their digital humanities
๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ-
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
the program.
๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎ขค๎˜‚๎™…๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ร‰cole in their
๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚Anglais:
Langue de lโ€™informatique๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•-
ful and productive for our students, no matter what career path they
๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎•๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎›Š๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ-
๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎˜ƒ๎˜บ๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎ขด๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
137
ADAPTING ENGLISH-LANGUAGE PEDAGOGY TO CULTURAL HERITAGE AND DIGITAL HUMANITIES
๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎œ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚
powerful, open-source standard that allows patrimonial and research
๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎ขด๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎ขด๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎•๎˜๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
lated to transmitting such massive amounts of data. Institutions host
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎ขด๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎›•๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚
๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎—๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ†-
ity. This provides for a smoother viewing experience, that is friendly
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎ขด๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚
also has a Presentation API, which allows for the institution to provide
๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™‘๎šƒ๎™ฃ๎™๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต-
๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎•๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
annotations on those images. While the Image API and the Presentation
๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ-
๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎™๎˜ƒ๎™๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
research or cultural heritage institutions.
๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†-
opers that maintain, implement, and continue development on these
๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขจ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
EDWARD J. GRAY
138
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ช๎›ช๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ-
line for anyone to use at any time and at their own pace.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎œผ๎™๎๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎ฃ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎œผ๎™๎๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ-
๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
reconstruction of a damaged manuscript from Chรขteauroux, in central
๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚Grandes Chroniques de France, were
cut out of the manuscript at some point in the nineteenth century,
and are today found at the Bibliothรจque nationale de France๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
construct and repair manuscripts that otherwise are held in separate
๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚
advance patrimonial collections.
The second section, Image API, leads off with an hour-long video (a
๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎ขด๎›Š๎˜๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ†๎๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎™ฟ๎™–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎™ฟ๎™–๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎ขด๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
given several options, including hosting on Internet Archive, using the
๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
stitution and are interested in pursuing a more structurally-sound and
๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎™๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜๎˜‚
139
ADAPTING ENGLISH-LANGUAGE PEDAGOGY TO CULTURAL HERITAGE AND DIGITAL HUMANITIES
to deploy. I require my s๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎œผ๎™๎๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚
have continuous access to and control over their images, as they are
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎œผ๎™๎๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚
well after the end of the class, without relying on the third-party solu-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎๎œญ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎ขด๎กฝ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขด
๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎™๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
The next section focuses on the Presentation API, which is where
๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎ขด๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•-
๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎ขด๎›Š๎˜๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ†๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
these images, and complete that manifest with appropriate metadata.
๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎ขด๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”-
๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
next step is to create an environment that will allow students to edit
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™‘๎šƒ๎™ฃ๎™๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
manually editing the manifest, through which students will gain deeper
familiarity with the mechanics of a process that is usually automatic.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œญ๎-
lating these mechanics that students gain an appreciation for the inner
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šค๎šƒ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎ขด๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎ขด๎›Š๎˜๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
EDWARD J. GRAY
140
๎›•๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎šค๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎˜๎ขด๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
annotation.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎šฒ-
tion of the previous lesson and expands upon the functionalities of the
๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎-
๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎ข€๎ขƒ These annota-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎ขด๎›Š๎˜๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ-
stand the effects of future, more automated processes that they will
encounter in their professional lives. After a discussion of multiple an-
๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎ขด๎›Š๎˜๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎–๎œ๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎˜ƒ๎šƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ขด๎๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎˜๎ขด๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚
to add search functionality to their annotations. At the end of the les-
๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
๎ข€๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขฃ
141
ADAPTING ENGLISH-LANGUAGE PEDAGOGY TO CULTURAL HERITAGE AND DIGITAL HUMANITIES
annotation server options, which students can reference for future
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›ช๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•-
๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ-
๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œด๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎-
๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎ขด๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ†๎ฃ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œŒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ฃ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎—๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ-
๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚
more invested, and in some cases, continue previous or ongoing re-
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎ข€๎ข„
๎™œ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขด๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎˜๎˜‚
inspiration came from my own experience with the paid version of this
๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚
in the interface. This course, thus, represents a true-to-life experience.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ข๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎ข€๎ข„ It is not uncommon for students to have completed masters-level or even doc-
๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎™๎˜ƒ๎™๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ
EDWARD J. GRAY
142
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎™๎˜ƒ๎™๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
the semester, I introduce the assignment during class, which includes
๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขด๎œผ๎œ”๎ขด๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต-
๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‹๎œƒ๎ขด๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚
questions during the semester to ensure that they are not feeling left
๎›Š๎›•๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ค๎šฒ๎–๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
these young professionals. In light of procrastination, which is emi-
๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œ-
derstand what they are doing and not wait until the last minute to
๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎™…๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช-
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
the reliance upon multiple tools โ€“ and thus multiple points for failure
๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎˜ƒ๎šƒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
tools are temporarily down, or there is a setting in the studentโ€™s own
๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎ขด๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ต๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎œ”๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›‹๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
143
ADAPTING ENGLISH-LANGUAGE PEDAGOGY TO CULTURAL HERITAGE AND DIGITAL HUMANITIES
๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ-
๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚valuable experience for our graduates, as it
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ฃ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎—๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎ขด๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎™๎˜ƒ๎™๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”-
๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ฃ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›Š๎œ”๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›•๎ขด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
seminar โ€“ in the course of oneโ€™s professional life, which corresponds
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎™๎˜ƒ๎™๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ-
๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
with APIs โ€“ so that students understand intimately how this fundamen-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚
๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
and creativity, thus increasing their engagement with the assignment.
๎™…๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ-
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ฃ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขด๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
perspective, the course is pedagogically sound, as it confronts students
๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขด
language pedagogy in digital humanities and the preservation of cul-
tural heritage.
EDWARD J. GRAY
144
REFERENCES LIST
๎˜›๎œ”๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎›Š๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ๎›Š๎œ”๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฉ
iiif-manifest-editor๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™œ๎›ต๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://code.visualstudio.
com/๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šค๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šค๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎›Š๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎šฒ-
dor/mirador๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://training.iiif.
๎›ต๎œ”๎ขฉ๎›ต๎›ต๎›ต๎›ช๎ขด๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขด๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขฉ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎™…๎™…๎˜บ๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎›‘-
mrdigital.com/index.xhtml๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎›Š๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ
๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขฉ๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎›Š๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ๎๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฉ๎๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ-
salviewer๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
145
COMMUNITY VERSUS CORPUS:
ACCESSIBLE LANGUAGE
RESOURCES FOR INDIGENOUS
SPEAKER COMMUNITIES AS
A WAY TO PRESERVE AND
PROMOTE CULTURAL HERITAGE
ELENA LAZARENKO
University of Hamburg, Institute of Finno-Ugric/Uralic Studies
Hamburg, Germany
elena.lazarenko@uni-hamburg.de
ALEKSANDR RIAPOSOV
University of Hamburg, Institute of Finno-Ugric/Uralic Studies
Hamburg, Germany
aleksandr.riaposov@uni-hamburg.de
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
motivation, concept, and choice of materials and tools are discussed.
๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ†๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›•๎œ†๎œƒ๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ
๎™“๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด-
tics, online resources, language preservation
INTRODUCTION
๎˜บ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ข„๎ขž๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎Ÿ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
well represented online. While even some of the languages considered
๎ขผ๎œด๎šฒ๎›ช๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎™๎˜ฆ๎šƒ๎˜œ๎™ฃ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚
Original scienti๎Ÿ–c paper
ELENA LAZARENKO, ALEKSANDR RIAPOSOV
146
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขด๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜๎ขด๎œผ๎œ”๎ขด๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚
๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต-
mately does not help much to achieve language preservation goals.
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚
๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด-
๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ
1. THE INEL PROJECT
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎ข€๎ข… started
๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚
from highly endangered languages and language varieties that stem
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขด๎œด๎œญ๎›•-
๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ค๎œ”๎–๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š-
๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ฃ›๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎ฃ›๎˜‚๎š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ†๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ฃ›๎˜‚๎š‹๎๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ฃ›๎˜‚๎š‹๎๎œ๎›ซ๎๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œ†๎œƒ๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ฃ›๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎ฃ›๎˜‚๎š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™–๎›•๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข„๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎™๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ฃ›๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎ฃ›๎˜‚๎š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ฃ›๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎ฃ›๎˜‚๎š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎ข€๎ข…๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ
147
COMMUNITY VERSUS CORPUS
The st๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
travelled through various tools and formats during the pre-process-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฆ๎™œ๎™–๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎ขด
๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฆ๎™œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎™–๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎ข€๎ข†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‘๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฆ๎™œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎™–๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
audio and video sources. This always allows end users โ€“ as a rule
๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎šฆ๎™œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎™–๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎œด๎šฒ๎œƒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎ข๎กฝ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ-
ing search queries through multiple layers of corpus annotations, and
๎™“๎›ต๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›Š๎œ”๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ-
๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ค๎œ”๎–๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎™“๎›ต๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™“๎๎Ÿ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ข๎กพ and the Dulson catalogue๎ข๎กฟ that contain im-
๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œ†๎œƒ๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
Other visual resources include a map comprising all geographical
๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ†๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™“๎๎Ÿ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™“๎›ต๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขด
๎›‘๎œฐ๎šฒ๎–๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎™–๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œ”๎•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ข€๎ข† www.exmaralda.org.
๎ข๎กฝ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎›Š๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ฑ๎ขฉ๎œผ๎œด๎šฒ๎œƒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎ขฉ.
๎ข๎กพ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎๎œ๎›ต๎ขด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎›‘๎›•๎ขฉ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฉ๎œƒ๎๎Ÿ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฉ.
๎ข๎กฟ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎๎œ๎›ต๎ขด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎›‘๎›•๎ขฉ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฉ๎›‘๎๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขฉ.
ELENA LAZARENKO, ALEKSANDR RIAPOSOV
148
1.1. THE INEL PORTAL
๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ข๎ข€๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ-
๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎™๎šฒ๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎œ”๎•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
terest to language researchers. To date, the main operating language
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎›ช๎šฒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขด๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด-
๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
2. LANGUAGE COMMUNITIES AND LANGUAGE VISIBILITY
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎•๎๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š-
๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ข€๎กฝ๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข…๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—-
๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎ข‚๎ขž๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขž๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ†๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎Ÿ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œ†๎œƒ๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜›๎œฐ๎˜๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎™๎šฒ๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎Ÿ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎๎œด๎›•๎•๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎๎›‘๎œฐ๎˜๎šฒ๎œƒ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
rapidly declining. According to the catalogue of endangered languages,
๎™๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š‹๎๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎™๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ค๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขจ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎ข๎ข€ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎๎œ๎›ต๎ขด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎›‘๎›•๎ขฉ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฉ.
149
COMMUNITY VERSUS CORPUS
๎šƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซuage endangerment criteria include, among others, the
๎œผ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎๎›Š๎œผ๎›ช๎๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜›๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•-
๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™“๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎๎œƒ๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎˜๎›ช๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚
of language communities do not always have easy access to the re-
sources that linguists have gathered (naturally, from the communities
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
and transcription of target language materials, preparation of grammar
๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎œผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ-
๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎•๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚
primary target audience, the needs and wishes of which do not neces-
๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
endangered language not only as a collection of linguistic information
๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎œ”๎œ†๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œด๎๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขฉ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚
professionals in their documentation efforts โ€“ the parts which, while
๎šฒ๎›‘๎œŒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘-
๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™“๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™–๎๎œƒ๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎˜๎›ช๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚
๎ข‚๎ข๎กฝ๎ขณ๎ข‚๎ข๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
collected data to the communities saved on various physical storage
๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎˜ข๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎š๎šƒ๎˜›๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
and cultural heritage of the communities. However, even with the shift
to digital language archives and similar initiatives that advocate for
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚
audience of๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
ELENA LAZARENKO, ALEKSANDR RIAPOSOV
150
two main factors: the interface language of the said resources is often
๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™“๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎๎œƒ๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎˜๎›ช๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข๎กฝ๎ขณ๎ข‚๎ข๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขฉ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œƒ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›Š๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎ขด๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข๎ข‚๎ข๎ข€๎ขณ๎ข๎ข‚๎ข๎ข๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎˜๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ๎œ”๎ขด๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œ-
dangered languages offers its scarce users to navigate through mounds
of lingua franca content in order to arrive at that one target language
๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎–๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œ†๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข…๎ขณ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™๎™–๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎˜๎šฒ๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎–๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎Ÿ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎˜›๎›•๎šƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
found in Kh๎šฒ๎›ต๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎๎œƒ๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎˜๎›ช๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข๎กพ๎ขณ๎ข‚๎ข๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ข
151
COMMUNITY VERSUS CORPUS
โ€“ poor technical infrastructure in the areas where the communities
๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
this can hinder access to the data even more, especially when it
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
even a registration procedure/authorisation with an institutional
๎™…๎˜ข๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎˜œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขฉ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
compiled.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎›•๎–๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
that users might want to familiarise themselves with the corpus docu-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•-
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎šฆ๎™œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎™–๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎œด๎šฒ๎œƒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™“๎›ต๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›Š๎œ”๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎ขด๎›ช๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎ค๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎œƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฆ๎™œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎™–๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎–๎œ๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚
๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ค๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎๎›Š๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ-
๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚
however, for someone wh๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚
ELENA LAZARENKO, ALEKSANDR RIAPOSOV
152
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขค๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎ขด๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขค๎ขฝ๎ขฃ
3. SOLUTION
3.1. GENERAL CONCEPT
In order to address the challenges outlined in the previous section,
we developed the following approach to present endangered language
data online.
๎˜บ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎˜ข๎™ผ๎™ฟ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎š๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›ซ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”-
tivation to restrict access in any way, shape, or form. The corpora are
๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎˜œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎šง๎ขด๎™๎˜œ๎ขด๎šƒ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎ข๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎ข๎ข
๎šƒ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
notation โ€“ which the corpora are ripe with โ€“ from the community ver-
๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›ช๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎›Š๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
to date are minority languages of Russia.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
munities, we pay much attention to the technical aspects of presenta-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต-
๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎œƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†-
lowing sections.
๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขด๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚
๎ข๎ข ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขฉ๎›Š๎˜๎ขด๎œ๎›‹๎ขด๎œด๎šฒ๎ขฉ๎ข๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎œ†๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‹๎œ”๎›‘๎›•.
153
COMMUNITY VERSUS CORPUS
๎šฒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚
๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ฃ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚
๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ-
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
information in Russian and populating it with materials in the target
languages.
3.2. FROM INEL CORPORA TO INEL COMMUNITY
The most up-to-date version of the Community pages category is
๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎ข๎ข‚๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎ขด๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎ขด๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•-
๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™ฃ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ†๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œ†๎œƒ๎๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ†๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎œ†๎œƒ๎๎œญ๎˜‚
pages followed the same principle: on top of the page, there was some
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
texts, for example, fairy tales, legends, or personal stories on various
๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎š‹๎™œ๎™–๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
transcripts were naturally not served as they would appear in the cor-
๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฆ๎™œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎™–๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎˜‚
๎ข๎ข‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎๎œ๎›ต๎ขด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎›‘๎›•๎ขฉ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฉ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฉ.
ELENA LAZARENKO, ALEKSANDR RIAPOSOV
154
transcriptions were p๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฆ๎™พ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
transcription tiers only โ€“ namely transcription in the target language
and its translation to Russian โ€“ which were then transformed into
๎™๎š‹๎™œ๎™–๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขด๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎™‘๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎šƒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
goal of presenting target language information alongside its Russian
๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎™๎š‹๎™œ๎™–๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎›ช๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
summarised as follows:
โ€“ new m๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขจ
โ€“ concept and development of further materials.
When it comes to the concept, the core idea of it is user-friendli-
๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚
section starting from its main page. The next step was to generate a
๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ-
guistic team. We maintain focus on the gradual upgrade of the older
๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œ†๎œƒ๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ†๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
line with the idea of user-friendliness. This is particularly important
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ-
๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
original corpus data with ease. Hence, it would draw more attention
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
and cultural heritage.
155
COMMUNITY VERSUS CORPUS
3.2.1. MAIN PAGE
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘-
๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›ช๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹-
๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›Š๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
Russian, yet not fully. Other than that, it also contains some of the gen-
๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ข
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขด๎–๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎ขด๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎—๎›ต๎œŒ๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ-
๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎›ช๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎˜๎›•๎ขด๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š-
๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ-
๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎š‹๎™œ๎™–๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎œƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šƒ๎šƒ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
oversee all the ways how and with which means the end users interact
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎ขด๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚
and development strategy and chose to use the Bootstrap frontend
๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎ข๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎ขด๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ-
๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎œƒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎˜‚
๎ข๎ขƒ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ.
ELENA LAZARENKO, ALEKSANDR RIAPOSOV
156
๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎œƒ๎œด๎ข
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎Ÿป๎Ÿผ๎Ÿบ๎Ÿฌ๎Ÿต๎Ÿพ๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ-
๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎Ÿต๎Ÿบ๎Ÿท๎Ÿท๎Ÿฌ๎Ÿต๎ „๎Ÿฑ๎ •๎˜‚ ๎Ÿพ๎Ÿฌ๎Ÿต๎Ÿฝ๎Ÿพ๎Ÿบ๎Ÿง๎˜‚ ๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ†๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎œ†๎œƒ๎๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎™๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขจ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎– ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ the
๎ขผ๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎Ÿฅ๎Ÿฟ๎Ÿซ๎Ÿฑ๎Ÿบ๎Ÿง๎Ÿฑ๎Ÿฐ๎Ÿฟ๎Ÿฅ๎Ÿท๎ ˆ๎Ÿน๎ Š๎Ÿฌ๎˜‚ ๎Ÿผ๎Ÿฌ๎Ÿฝ๎Ÿฟ๎Ÿผ๎Ÿฝ๎ Š๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎šƒ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜บ๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎–๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
This mode of presentation creates a compact and intuitive overview
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต-
sually engaging, prompting the user to explore the page further.
3.2.2. LANGUAGE PAGES
๎™…๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ†๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎œ†๎œƒ๎๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎š‹๎™œ๎™–๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
taining the following information extracted from the corpus metadata
๎ฃ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎™ฃ๎™œ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎Ÿน๎Ÿฅ๎Ÿฐ๎Ÿง๎Ÿฅ๎Ÿน๎Ÿฑ๎Ÿฌ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š-
๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎Ÿซ๎Ÿฅ๎Ÿพ๎Ÿฅ๎˜‚๎Ÿฐ๎Ÿฅ๎Ÿป๎Ÿฑ๎Ÿฝ๎Ÿฑ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขจ
157
COMMUNITY VERSUS CORPUS
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎Ÿธ๎Ÿฌ๎Ÿฝ๎Ÿพ๎Ÿบ๎˜‚๎Ÿฐ๎Ÿฅ๎Ÿป๎Ÿฑ๎Ÿฝ๎Ÿฑ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎Ÿซ๎Ÿฑ๎Ÿฅ๎Ÿท๎Ÿฌ๎Ÿต๎Ÿพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎˜ข๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎Ÿผ๎Ÿฅ๎Ÿฝ๎Ÿฝ๎Ÿต๎Ÿฅ๎Ÿฐ๎ ƒ๎Ÿฑ๎Ÿต๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎šƒ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎˜‚
๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎Ÿฐ๎Ÿง๎Ÿฟ๎Ÿต๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎šƒ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฉ๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ”๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎Ÿต๎Ÿบ๎Ÿซ๎˜‚ ๎Ÿพ๎Ÿฌ๎Ÿต๎Ÿฝ๎Ÿพ๎Ÿฅ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎š‹๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎™ฃ๎™œ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ
๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
page, however, they are organised in a slightly different manner: in-
๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎™ฃ๎™œ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚
also video sources.
๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ-
๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎™ฃ๎™œ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฃ
๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
contains only the information that is relevant for a non-linguist โ€“ text
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
the original media source.
๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎˜๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎š‹๎™œ๎™–๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”-
๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎ขด๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎šƒ๎šƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎˜๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šƒ๎šƒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
ELENA LAZARENKO, ALEKSANDR RIAPOSOV
158
๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ช๎๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œญ-
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œ†๎œƒ๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ†๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎›ช๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ช๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎š๎™…๎ขฉ๎š๎šฆ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ-
tion of media sources into the text pages โ€“ this is especially important
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎ขณ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ”๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขฃ
3.2.3. FURTHER RESOURCES
Anticipating what potential visitors of the Community pages might
want to see apart from the relatively simple text collection, we attempt
to provide them with several resources that are more interactive. In the
๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎œ”๎๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ-
๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎ขด๎›ช๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎๎œญ๎ขด๎œผ๎œ”๎ขด๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎–๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œŒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎ขด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ-
๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขจ๎˜‚
๎˜›๎˜ƒ๎˜›๎˜ƒ๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ†๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œ†๎œƒ๎๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†-
๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
called in the target language, its translation to Russian and point to text
and audio samples containing that word from the corpus. We expect
159
COMMUNITY VERSUS CORPUS
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›•๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎›Š๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ-
๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ-
gered and shifting languages.
Another concept with a similar mission of visual data presentation
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ข‚๎กฝ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œ†๎œƒ๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™“๎›ต๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚
we intend to create such tag clouds for other languages and parts of
๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚
to present the corpus data visually and provide an overview of topics
covered in the texts.
CONCLUSION
๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
community of linguistic experts who aim at documenting endangered
๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
no access to said documentation.
To sum up, creating language archives and corpora is a great way
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ-
๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
as well. There is something wrong with situations where the data pro-
๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต-
tories, which require an institutional account or completion of some
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›Š๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
structure of such datasets, which is often oriented at researchers and
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎ขจ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎ขด
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎—๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
ELENA LAZARENKO, ALEKSANDR RIAPOSOV
160
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
professional use. The online part is of particular importance here, as
๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ-
๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚
and promote cultural and linguistic heritage is not that easy, and ap-
proaches to achieve that need further coverage.
In this paper we have presented our way of doing it โ€“ starting from
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎ขฃ
REFERENCES LIST
๎ขผ๎˜›๎˜ƒ๎˜›๎˜ƒ๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎˜ƒ๎˜›๎˜ƒ๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œŒ๎›Š๎™๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎›Š๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎ขฃ
com/๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎–๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎šฒ๎›ช๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™“๎œฐ๎šฒ๎๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œด๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›ต๎˜๎šฒ๎œ”๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œด๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ท๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šง๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šง๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›ช๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šค๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚International Ex-
pert Meeting on UNESCO Programme Safeguarding of Endangered Lan-
guages๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขณ๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎š๎™๎˜ฆ๎šƒ๎˜œ๎™ฃ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜›๎œฐ๎˜๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎•๎›•๎œผ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎šณ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎™๎šฒ๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ ๎ขผ๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œ†๎œƒ๎๎œญ๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ ๎šค๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ข€๎กพ๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ฑ๎›‘๎œ†๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขด๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขด๎˜บ๎ข๎˜ข๎ข†๎ขด๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚The INEL Corpora of In-
digenous Northern Eurasian Languages๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://hdl.handle.
๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขด๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขด๎˜บ๎ข๎ข‚๎˜ƒ๎ขด๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎—๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎›•๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Pro-
ceedings of the Tenth International Conference on Language Resources
and Evaluation (LRECโ€™16). ๎™๎›ต๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎Ÿ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™“๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œƒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ซ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต-
๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œด๎๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎›ต๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
eds. ๎™ผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ”๎ก๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎ข๎ข‚๎ข๎ข€๎ขณ๎ข๎ข‚๎ข๎ข†๎ขฃ
๎˜ข๎›๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎™–๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™“๎๎›‘๎œฐ๎˜๎šฒ๎œƒ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎๎›ซ๎›–๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ†๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šค๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†-
161
COMMUNITY VERSUS CORPUS
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ฑ๎›‘๎œ†๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขด๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขด๎˜บ๎ข†๎˜ƒ๎ข„๎ขด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ข๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎˜‚ The INEL
Corpora of Indigenous Northern Eurasian Languages๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://
๎›ฑ๎›‘๎œ†๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขด๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขด๎˜บ๎ข๎ข‚๎˜ƒ๎ขด๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ข๎›๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šค๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎๎œด๎›•๎•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™…๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šค๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://hdl.handle.
๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขด๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขด๎˜บ๎ข๎ข€๎˜œ๎ขด๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚The INEL Corpora of Indigenous Northern
Eurasian Languages๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ฑ๎›‘๎œ†๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขด
๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ขด๎˜บ๎ข๎ข‚๎˜ƒ๎ขด๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎ขผ๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Catalogue of Endangered Languages๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
Haw๎šฒ๎›ต๎ขพ๎›ต๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://www.endangeredlanguages.com/
๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎ข€๎ข€๎ข†๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™๎œ”๎œ†๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎ขฟ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Potentials of Language Documentation: Methods, Analyses, and
Utilization๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎›ต๎›ช๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œƒ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎™ผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎›ซ-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎œด๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œ†๎๎ข๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
Hawai๎ขพ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขณ๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ
๎™“๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎œ†๎˜๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎๎œƒ๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎˜๎›ช๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™พ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎›•๎ขด๎ขฑ
๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚The Electronic Library๎˜‚๎ข๎กฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข€๎ข†๎ขณ๎ข‚๎ข‚๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://
๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข…๎ขฉ๎˜ฆ๎™–๎ขด๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขด๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขด๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™–๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œƒ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›•๎œƒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œ”๎•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™๎œ”๎–๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ-
๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎Ÿ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œผ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™“๎๎Ÿ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Proceedings of the Workshop on Resources and Technologies
for Indigenous, Endangered and Lesser-Resourced Languages in Eurasia
within the 13th Language Resources and Evaluation Conference. Atul Kr.
๎™ฃ๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ”๎ขด๎™๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎›ฑ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›‹๎˜œ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎›•๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎ขด๎กพ๎ขฃ๎ข๎ขฉ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™–๎›•๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎๎œ†๎ขค๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”-
๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Working Pa-
pers in Corpus Linguistics and Digital Technologies: Analyses and Meth-
odology๎˜‚ ๎ข„๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ข„๎กพ๎ขณ๎ข„๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ข๎กฟ๎ข€๎กฟ๎ขฉ
๎–๎œญ๎›‹๎œ†๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šค๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™–๎œ”๎–๎ขด
๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
ArXiv. ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฆ๎›ต๎•๎ขฉ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎ข„๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎›‹๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜œ๎™–๎ขฏ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข๎ข…๎ข‚๎ข‚๎กฝ๎ขฉ
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฆ๎›ต๎•๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎ข„๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎™๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Catalogue of Endangered Languages๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎›ต๎ขพi
๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ https://www.endangeredlanguages.com/lang
๎ขฉ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข…๎ข†๎ข€๎ขฉ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎ขผ๎™ฃ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚INEL๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎™๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎œด๎œ†๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎๎œ๎›ต๎ขด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎›‘๎›•๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎ขฉ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ-
๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎ขฉ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎œผ๎๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขฉ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขด๎กฟ๎ขด๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขด๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎ขด๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œŒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
ELENA LAZARENKO, ALEKSANDR RIAPOSOV
162
๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‘๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข. ๎ขผ๎˜ฆ๎šฆ๎™œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎™–๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ In Handbook on Cor-
pus Phonology๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎œ†๎œฐ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™“๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™ฃ๎—๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎™“๎ข๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎—๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎ข๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ขณ๎ข๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ
๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎–๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ-
๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎˜›๎›•๎šƒ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Po-
tentials of Language Documentation: Methods, Analyses, and Utilization.
๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎›ต๎›ช๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚ ๎™๎šฒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™๎›ต๎œƒ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎œด๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œ†๎๎ข๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎›ต๎ขพ๎›ต๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ขณ๎กพ๎กฟ๎ข…๎ขฃ
๎ขผ๎š‹๎๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Catalogue of Endangered Languages๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎™๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎›ต๎ขพ๎›ต๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://www.endangeredlanguages.com/
๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขƒ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎ขผ๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™พ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚http://www.
visualdictionaryonline.com/index.php/๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šฅ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎™๎šฒ๎›ซ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎šณ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎œ”๎•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚INEL Bibliographie (Ver-
sion 1.0) ๎ขฎ๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎ขฏ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎ข‚๎ข‚๎ข†๎กฟ๎ขฉ๎๎›ฑ๎›ฑ๎›ช๎›‘๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎ข„๎ข€๎กพ (ac-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
163
ENHANCING ACCESS
TO DIGITISED GLAGOLITIC
MATERIAL OF ZADAR
COUNTY THROUGH
GLAGOLAB PORTAL
LAURA GRZUNOV
University of Zadar, Department of Information Sciences
Zadar, Croatia
lgrzunov@unizd.hr
MARTA IVANOVIฤ†
University of Zadar, Of๎Ÿ–ce for Publishing Activities
Zadar, Croatia
mivanovi1@unizd.hr
MARIJANA TOMIฤ†
University of Zadar, Centre for Research in Glagolitism /
Department of Information Sciences
Zadar, Croatia
mtomic@unizd.hr
๎š‹๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎™๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•-
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎—๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎ขด๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚
the digitisation of Glagolitic manuscripts of Zadar County and its frag-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•-
๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
and is intended for creating a common repository for research of the
Preliminary Communication
LAURA GRZUNOV, MARTA IVANOVIฤ†, MARIJANA TOMIฤ†
164
๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต-
๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎—๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
exploration of Zadar Glagolitics digital collections.
๎™“๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”-
๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†
INTRODUCTION
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ-
๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎—๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜บ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎—๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขค๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
ways. This chapter explains the reasons for switching from the search
๎›Š๎œ”๎—๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›ช๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚
diverse needs.
๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎—๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚
clearer to the readers what each interface refers to, this chapter analy-
๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•-
mentioned portal developed as part of the Centre for Research in
165
ENHANCING ACCESS TO DIGITISED GLAGOLITIC MATERIAL OF ZADAR COUNTY
๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜-
๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œŒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ
1. FROM SEARCH BOX TO MORE LIBERAL INTERFACES
In the last few decades, d๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ†-
๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
possesses. The search interface is the place where searchers interact
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ-
๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™–๎›ต๎๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขณ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎—๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚
๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎ขฃ๎›•๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚
๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
search interfaces๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขด๎œด๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚
LAURA GRZUNOV, MARTA IVANOVIฤ†, MARIJANA TOMIฤ†
166
not support non-expert users, who are often unfamiliar with the collec-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›ซ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎ฃ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ-
๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ขฟ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚
with the digital collection or who use materials from the digital col-
๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
and what they need to enter into the interface in order to get results.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎ฃซ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ป๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต-
๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต-
๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
collection. Because of that the need for richer interfaces that reveal the
๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด-
ingly emphasised. Today, most often when searching for digital cultural
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎—๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎–๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎œ”๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šง๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขค๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ช๎๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
they๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฃ
167
ENHANCING ACCESS TO DIGITISED GLAGOLITIC MATERIAL OF ZADAR COUNTY
2. RESEARCH AIM, PHASES, AND METHODOLOGY
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
enhancing access to cultural collections in order to analyse and pro-
๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚
Glagolitics.
The research consists of three phases:
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎กพst๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
enhancing access to cultural collections, with the aim of research-
ing different ways of searching and viewing digital collections that
๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขจ
โ€“ 2nd๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎ข€rd phase โ€“ application of research results from the preceeding
phases and implementation of new collection search strategies on
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
through:
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎˜ฆ๎˜ƒ๎˜ข๎™๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎˜ฆ๎˜ƒ๎˜ข๎™๎˜‚๎œ๎ขฃ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎˜ƒ๎˜ข๎™๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
LAURA GRZUNOV, MARTA IVANOVIฤ†, MARIJANA TOMIฤ†
168
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพst phase, in which different ways of
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†-
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚
interface.
3. A SHIFT FROM SEARCHING TO BROWSING
๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
faces require querying, discourage exploration, and withhold more
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎–๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
and in a targeted manner.
๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎–๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
main question is: Why donโ€™t we provide other alternatives in addition
to the search option, and what alternatives are there?
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต-
ous experience with the topic and therefore need more help and infor-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ
3.1. EXPLORATORY SEARCH INTERFACES
๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎–๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚Exploring Digital Cultural Heritage through Browsing. They
๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
and to help them narrow down their search, using features such as
๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œด๎๎›ซ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
authors clarify that, although such interfaces give users a form of in-
structions, this way of searching still does not allow an overview of the
169
ENHANCING ACCESS TO DIGITISED GLAGOLITIC MATERIAL OF ZADAR COUNTY
collection as a whol๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขด๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ข„๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎›•๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œƒ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ-
ter a search term, the user can select a value from the facet list and see
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขด๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ-
๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚
to results.
๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š-
lem is that this type of search is still focused only on search. To delve
๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด-
๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ
3.2. BROWSING
๎˜›๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ-
๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎›ต๎›Š๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜œ๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด
๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
LAURA GRZUNOV, MARTA IVANOVIฤ†, MARIJANA TOMIฤ†
170
option is crucial in digital collections, especially for less expert users
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›•๎›ต๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎–๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•-
๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ข
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
detailed understanding of the content.
๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎™–๎˜ƒ๎™œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎ข
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎š๎˜ข๎™“๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ข๎˜œ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ป๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎šƒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘-
ing an interface that does not require a priori expertise in either the
interface or the collection in order to use the interface successfully.
๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚
on providing the user with an overall overview of the collection, and
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
171
ENHANCING ACCESS TO DIGITISED GLAGOLITIC MATERIAL OF ZADAR COUNTY
3.2.1. RICH PROSPECT BROWSING
Rich prospect interfaces represent an entire collection at once, where
the user has a meaningful representation of every single item in the
collection. Interactive control and detailed access to elements should
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎ขž๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
the entire collection itself.
๎™๎›•๎–๎˜‚ ๎šง๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎šง๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ-
๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎—๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช-
๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ
LAURA GRZUNOV, MARTA IVANOVIฤ†, MARIJANA TOMIฤ†
172
By selecting a photo from the grid, the user gets a metadata descrip-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
is viewing are listed.
3.2.2. GENEROUS INTERFACES
A generous interface is an interface that should allow initial insight and
๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด-
๎œด๎๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎šฒ๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
collection and not all the items. The sample provides a starting point
and clues to help the user explore the collection.
Generosity in generous interfaces, in contrast to the search slot
implemented as a default starting point in many digital interfaces, is
๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ข
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ขฟ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎œด๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎ขจ
โ€“ share high-quality primary content.
๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›ต-
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขž๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ
๎™…๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›‹๎ขฃ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
in exploration and discovery of the collection then there is an option
173
ENHANCING ACCESS TO DIGITISED GLAGOLITIC MATERIAL OF ZADAR COUNTY
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎œŒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
cultural heritage datasets is achieved through implementation of time-
๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ
Generous interfaces use multiple representations to reveal the com-
plexity and diversity of cultural collections, such as visualisations. The
most common visualisation methods include:
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œด๎ขจ
โ€“ word clouds.
Timelines are the simplest solution for mapping time to space in a
linear, one-dimensional fashion. They commonly visualise events as
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎ข‚๎กฝ๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎™‘๎šƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎ขด๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜-
๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”-
๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎™๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎ข๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚
LAURA GRZUNOV, MARTA IVANOVIฤ†, MARIJANA TOMIฤ†
174
๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฉ๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
demonstrate that the events emphasised in the construction of a time-
๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต-
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขด๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
history content.
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎ข‚๎กฝ๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ
We can use spatial displays to visualise spatial metadata on a two-di-
mensional map. The advantage of this type of map is that the user can
๎Ÿ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎œ”๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด
๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎™…๎›‹๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•-
cialists and non-specialists around the รslendingasรถgur ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎šƒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™…๎›‹๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ รslendingasรถgur
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎ขด๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ Landnรกmabรณk ๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†th century saga enthusi-
๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎ขด๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ
175
ENHANCING ACCESS TO DIGITISED GLAGOLITIC MATERIAL OF ZADAR COUNTY
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™…๎›‹๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ
๎™๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎—-
๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎™๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ
๎ขผ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขž๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎ขด๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
LAURA GRZUNOV, MARTA IVANOVIฤ†, MARIJANA TOMIฤ†
176
layout that places frequently co-occurring nodes closer together, while
๎œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎ขด๎œ”๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ-
tists, historians, HCI researchers, and interface designers. To create the
๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†-
๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขฉ
๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฉ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขฉ
description or generated through crowdsourcing/computer-vision
๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฃ
177
ENHANCING ACCESS TO DIGITISED GLAGOLITIC MATERIAL OF ZADAR COUNTY
๎™ฃ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขž๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎ขด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘-
๎›•๎›‘๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขž๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚
collections, tagging each image. The archive allows users to use word
๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
the four editions and access each individual playโ€™s digitised illustrations
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ
๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎™๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎›ต-
๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
of users.
4. GLAGOLAB PORTAL
๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพst๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”-
๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
to the settings of the generous interface.
๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
research and promotion of the Croatian Glagolitic script. Centre for
๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
and promotion of Croatian Glagolitic, especially its Zadar department,
i.e. coordinating the activities of scientists focused on Glagolitic re-
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎๎œŒ๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œ๎ขฃ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ-
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎—๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
LAURA GRZUNOV, MARTA IVANOVIฤ†, MARIJANA TOMIฤ†
178
๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎—๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข„๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ
๎šค๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ
By entering the Catalogue of manuscripts or the Catalogue of water-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
manuscripts according to the type of material, place, and institution,
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
certainly necessary to survey the two types of users (the scholars and
179
ENHANCING ACCESS TO DIGITISED GLAGOLITIC MATERIAL OF ZADAR COUNTY
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎—๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎›ช๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข†๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™๎šง๎™ผ๎™–๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ
LAURA GRZUNOV, MARTA IVANOVIฤ†, MARIJANA TOMIฤ†
180
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎šฒ๎๎œฐ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฅ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎šฒ๎๎œฐ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎ข๎ข„
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎šฒ๎๎œฐ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
terms from the thesaurus has its associated icon, according to which
๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
as a visual representation of the motif in the thesaurus itself (whether
๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎šฒ๎๎œฐ๎๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎ข๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜›๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎ข๎˜‚https://www.
memoryofpaper.eu/BernsteinPortal/appl๎ขช๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ.
181
ENHANCING ACCESS TO DIGITISED GLAGOLITIC MATERIAL OF ZADAR COUNTY
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎šฒ๎๎œฐ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ
According to the ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›ซ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
generous interface:
โ€“ home page should show a sample drawn from the collection that
provides a starting point and clues to help the user explore the
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขจ
โ€“ the interface should display options upfront rather than requiring
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎ขจ
โ€“ using more visualisations such as:
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขจ
โ€“ spatial diagrams โ€“ the collection contains manuscripts and wa-
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขจ
๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
easy to create word clouds and that could help users with initial
research.
LAURA GRZUNOV, MARTA IVANOVIฤ†, MARIJANA TOMIฤ†
182
๎˜บ๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
their preferences, is needed. Therefore, the 2nd phase of this research
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œด๎ขฃ
5. CONCLUSION
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎˜๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š-
๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
is an increasing emphasis on visual information retrieval, which should
๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
the collection. Although the literature often emphasises the impor-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎กพst phase
of research focused on literature review, analysis of the interface of
๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚
cultural heritage. The analysis showed that the portal contains some
segments of exploratory search interfaces and provides the option
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
2nd๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข€rd phases of research, which involve surveying users (experts
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ
183
ENHANCING ACCESS TO DIGITISED GLAGOLITIC MATERIAL OF ZADAR COUNTY
REFERENCES LIST
๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ https://www.printsand-
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎œ”๎•๎ขฃ๎šฒ๎๎ขฉ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ฑ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ https://
eadh.org/๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎˜‚ ๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ก๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ๎šฒ๎œถ๎œผ๎•๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎•๎›•๎๎›๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œถ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎๎˜‚ ๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œฐ๎๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ซ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎ขฃ๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ
๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ป๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎›•๎–๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚DHQ: Digital Humanities Quarterly๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚http://
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎›ฑ๎œฏ๎ขฉ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฉ๎กฟ๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข†๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข†๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œŒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎˜›๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚Information and Knowledge Organisation in Digital Humani-
ties: Global Perspectives๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ†๎๎›Š๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šง๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด๎™๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขƒ๎กพ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข…๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข๎ข€๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฉ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข…๎กพ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎กพ๎ข€๎กพ๎ข…๎กพ๎ขƒ
๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™๎›ต๎›Š๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™œ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎ข๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™ฃ๎๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ https://www.
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฉ๎กฟ๎ข…๎กพ๎กฟ๎ข€๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขƒ๎ขช๎™œ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขช๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎ขช
๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎ขช๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขช๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎ขช๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎ขช๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎ขช๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎ขช๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขช๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด
๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ http://histograph.eu/๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎ข‚๎กฝ๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎˜๎๎œฐ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ข‚๎กฝ๎ข€๎ขด๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•-
๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขด๎œด๎œญ๎กพ๎ข…๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™…๎›‹๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚http://sagamap.hi.is/is/๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•-
๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™–๎›ต๎๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šง๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด๎™๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Foundations and Trends in Information Retrieval
๎กพ๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข€๎ขด๎ข๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข๎ข€๎ขณ๎ข๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎—๎ขฃ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขƒ๎กพ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎ข‚๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข„๎ข€ (ac-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™๎šง๎™ผ๎™–๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œญ๎๎›Š-
๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขฃ๎œ๎˜๎œญ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎œญ๎›‘๎ขด๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฉ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎–๎›ต๎›‹๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎–๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎-
๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™พ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Information Processing & Management๎˜‚๎ข๎ข๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ข€๎ข„๎ข๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข€๎ข†๎กฟ๎ขฃ
๎™ฟ๎๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขด๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š‹๎˜๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Designing the Search Experience:
The Information Architecture of Discovery๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š๎šƒ๎˜ƒ๎ข๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎๎›ช๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šค๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•-
speareillustration.org/๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
184
๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎˜๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚Exploratory Search: Beyond the Query-
Response Paradigm๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขฎ๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎ขฃ๎ขฏ๎ข๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎ฃฏ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎œญ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎—๎˜‚๎™–๎ขฃ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎™“๎๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ฑ๎œ๎›•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜บ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎™“๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎›Š๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Foundations and Trendsยฎ in Web Science๎˜‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขณ๎ข†๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
at: ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎—๎ขฃ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขƒ๎กพ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎ข…๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎†๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ-
๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎œ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎•๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎˜๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎šค๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚IEEE
Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข‚๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข€๎กพ๎กพ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ข€๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขฉ๎š‹๎šค๎˜œ๎˜ป๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎ข…๎ข€๎กฝ๎ข„๎ข‚๎ข†๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎กพ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
185
PARTICIPATORY MAPPING
OF THE CULTURAL HERITAGE
IN THE MOUNTAIN REGION OF
GORSKI KOTAR IN CROATIA
MARTINA PETRINOVIฤ†
Croatian Society of Art Historians
Zagreb, Croatia
dpuh@inet.hr
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1972-0158
Art history, as a discipline within the humanities, has the potential to
๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎•๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต-
ety of Art Historians, a professional association whose goals include in-
๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ-
๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
area of Croatia. The initiative of participatory mapping of the cultural
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎ขด๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚
๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚
to help communities document and preserve their cultural heritage.
๎˜›๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
and protection of cultural heritage for future generations.
Keywords: art history, topography, cultural heritage, conservation,
open access
๎™ฃ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
creasing importance of digital technology and the growing role of the
digital humanities. This includes the use of digital tools and methods to
study, preserve, and share cultural heritage, as well as the exploration of
๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
Professional paper
MARTINA PETRINOVIฤ†
186
of cultural heritage in a remote rural area in Croatia with collected data
in open access.
PROJECTโ€™S PURPOSE, OBJECTIVES, AND STAKEHOLDERS
๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ขž๎ข€๎กฝ๎กฝ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ-
๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚
๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‘๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎™ผ๎š๎™๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚ ๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•-
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
๎œด๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎•๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎š‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎๎œถ๎›•๎œƒ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”-
187
PARTICIPATORY MAPPING OF THE CULTURAL HERITAGE
vides great potential for a more detailed understanding of its cultural
heritage and a chance to preserve it from its decay. The cultural heri-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œ๎ฃ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™“๎›•๎œ†๎–๎›ต๎›ซ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎ฃ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข‚๎ขƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎๎œด๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
the values of cultural heritage and the importance of visual arts. Art his-
tory is a discipline in the humanities that can have a vital role in provid-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎šฒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›ช๎๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
open science used in correlation with long-term visionary actions ad-
๎•๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎™ผ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
Humanities scholars and organisations can use several strategies to reach
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ข๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ-
๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขจ๎˜‚๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚
communities, and engaging those communities in the research process.
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎ฃ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
prominent voice in cultural advocacy in Croatia, promoting the value of
visual art and heritage. The scholarly communityโ€™s reluctance to fully
MARTINA PETRINOVIฤ†
188
๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›ซ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎œผ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ฃ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ-
๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šค๎›•๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
However, we still did not witness the large-scale application of the no-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œด๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ฃ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
DOCUMENTATION OF HERITAGE
๎˜ข๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ-
atic documentation of cultural and artistic heritage in Croatia was
๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝth๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜๎ขด๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎›Š๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
those duties as a rule involved engaged, enthusiastic, and committed
๎›ต๎œ๎•๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข„๎ข†๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šƒ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข„๎ข‚๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›”๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ข†๎กพ๎กพ๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข…๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
out extensive research of sites throughout Croatia. Their approach
๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹-
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š…๎œญ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎–๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ-
๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎œผ๎˜‚
t๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด
friendly. Potential users of the data accompanied with metadata are
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ
189
PARTICIPATORY MAPPING OF THE CULTURAL HERITAGE
The importance of๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎š๎™๎˜ฆ๎šƒ๎˜œ๎™ฃ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
cultural and natural heritage is effectively recognised at all levels of
๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎š๎™๎˜ฆ๎šƒ๎˜œ๎™ฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
catastrophes, a lot of energy is invested in reconstruction, and good
sound documentation is vital for such processes. It is more critical for
developing countries where often the case is poorly understudied.
Croatia today has an institutionalised and developed system of heri-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
of Cultural Property is a visual presentation of the protected cultural
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
cadastre.
The Geoportal of Cultural Property presents the scope of protec-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ-
en in compliance with the Act on the Protection and Preservation of
๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘-
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ
PARTICIPATORY MAPPING: THE PRIMARY METHODOLOGY
The past twenty years and more have witnessed an explosion of partic-
๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎™…๎š‹๎ฃฏ๎šƒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎ขด๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต-
cation purposes to support social learning, dialogue, and negotiation
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
MARTINA PETRINOVIฤ†
190
๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ-
๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
within it. In our case, we are directing the conversation in the areas that
we are interested in. Participatory mapping is a method of mapping in
๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
creating and maintaining a map. This approach is often used in situa-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
as in remote or rural areas, or communities with little or no access to
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
a variety of different things, including cultural and historical heritage.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œฐ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™–๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข…๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ-
ticipatory mapping can also help to foster a sense of ownership and
๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
the community and promote a sense of pride in the communityโ€™s heri-
๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎™ผ๎š๎™๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
191
PARTICIPATORY MAPPING OF THE CULTURAL HERITAGE
The aim of our initiative is to record the diverse range of voices and
๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
strategy is not envisaged as a traditional form of an educational pro-
gramme, in the direct two-way communication we encountered true
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎œด๎œผ๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎ขด๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
Documenting cultural landscapes or landscapes around cultural
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
mapping expenditure was too high. With modern surveying and visu-
alisation techniques, landscape documentation and visualisation have
๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
Although it is interesting and revealing โ€“ also it is time-consuming.
We have to process a lot of information, that should function as cu-
๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎-
๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
only accurate information.
PINNING VISUAL DATA ON A DIGITAL MAP
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚ ๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œ๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎œ๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎š…๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎๎œถ๎›•๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
connected to the area and familiar with the sites, which is one of the
๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขด๎œด๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
in scanning the area if a researcher is familiar with the area, exact loca-
๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ-
๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
and the information holder that could end up in more accurate data
collection.
MARTINA PETRINOVIฤ†
192
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›•๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ-
chitecture, monuments, World War II memorials, industrial architecture,
historical transportation infrastructure, documents, postcards, photo-
๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚
locations are coordinated with the Register of Cultural Property of the
๎™œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
the areaโ€™s geographic features, and precise coordinates of a pinned en-
๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
tools, providing detailed maps and information for millions of locations
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
information and details to provide a comprehensive view of a location.
๎š๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ-
cial proprietary platforms maintain ownership of data, they possess a
๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎ขด๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ-
๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎œ†๎œ†๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎™ผ๎š๎™๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
193
PARTICIPATORY MAPPING OF THE CULTURAL HERITAGE
๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚
with those. At this stage we are not interpreting, we are collecting vi-
sual data. After entering the location in the digital map, data on lit-
๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™…๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ข๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎™ผ๎š๎™๎ขž๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
COMMUNITY AWARENESS OF HERITAGE
We intend to stimulate connections with the local municipalities to
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
mapping is the starting point for additional, more thorough, and in-
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ-
ical-artistic stylistic analysis of each property of cultural importance,
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
settlements in which they are located.
MARTINA PETRINOVIฤ†
194
๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎ขด๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
held an event aimed at increasing the local populationโ€™s awareness of
the unique identity of their settlements. The residents are well aware
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎›ช๎›•๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
developing spatial plans for all nine local administrative units within
๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎ขด๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
Cultural landscape refers to the physical and cultural environment
๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ-
๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†-
๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎›ช๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ-
ment and each other. Cultural landscapes are dynamic and evolving,
๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œฐ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎œ†๎๎œถ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚
๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
NAVIGATING PROJECT CHALLENGES: EXPLORING PITSTOPS
ALONG THE WAY
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขด๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
on individual and micro, on the fundamental and physical, with the po-
tential to identify opportunities through idiosyncrasies. This organic
๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ†๎œ”๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
But with planned optimisation of the process of collecting we try to
195
PARTICIPATORY MAPPING OF THE CULTURAL HERITAGE
๎œด๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›•๎›‹๎๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎™๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ค๎๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ-
๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ†๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ค๎๎›ต๎›‘๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎ขพ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎˜๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™๎œฉ๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
DIGITAL INFRASTRUCTURE FOR ENGAGING DIVERSE
AUDIENCES
๎š๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด-
tic topography in a digital map will speed up the process of research
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ”๎œด๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎Ÿ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚
and Italy for researching the historical impacts on the area. Besides
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎-
๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎–๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
community aware of the values they inherit.
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎–๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎šฒ๎๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ค๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎š๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎-
๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
MARTINA PETRINOVIฤ†
196
๎๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎š๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎›ช๎›•๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ-
sures through digital infrastructure. The Cloud aims to foster coopera-
tion and co-creation among cultural, creative, and technology sectors.
๎™๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎›ช๎๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎•๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎ฃˆ๎กพ๎กพ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข‚๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎ขž ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขด๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ-
chivists and conservators. It will provide cutting-edge technologies
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œ-
sion to cultural heritage preservation, conservation, and restoration.
๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œฐ-
๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ป๎šฒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎ขด๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
pinning this area as an interesting and inviting living area โ€“ as through
๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขด๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ†๎œ”๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎œฐ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œ”๎›‘๎๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
Humanities scholars and especially learned societies can help to
๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต-
๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎-
manities research.
197
PARTICIPATORY MAPPING OF THE CULTURAL HERITAGE
REFERENCES LIST
๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎œ๎›•๎›Œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›”๎›•๎œ†๎๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Peristil๎˜‚๎ข‚๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข‚๎ขณ๎ข€๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†-
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎œด๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข…๎ข„๎ข€๎ข…๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ.
๎˜ข๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎›ต๎œ†๎๎œถ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Krajolik kao kulturno naslijeฤ‘e๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ข๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎•๎œ”๎˜‚๎œƒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œถ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎˜‚๎œƒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›Š๎šฒ๎œถ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎›Œ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎•๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎˜‚๎œด๎•๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎œ†๎๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎œ๎œ”๎•๎œฐ๎œด๎œ๎›ต๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ก๎›ต๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
Problemi sjevernog Jadrana๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข€๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚ https://dx.doi.
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข‚๎ข„๎ขฉ๎ข†๎—๎œ๎ข€๎กพ๎›‹๎œ”๎ข€๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œ”๎œญ๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎›•๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œญ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ต๎ขฃ๎›‘๎Ÿ๎œด๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎ขฉ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฉ๎›•๎œ๎ขฉ๎กฟ๎ข†๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข„
๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎˜๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™๎œฉ๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ†๎๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šค๎œ”๎œ†-
๎๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚A Research Agenda for Civil Society๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™“๎›•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎œ”๎–๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ†๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข…๎ข†๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
at: ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข๎ข€๎ข€๎ข„๎ขฉ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข…๎กพ๎ข…๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข€๎ข„๎ข…๎กพ๎ข‚๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ข‚๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™–๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Artur Schneider: 1879.โ€“1946.: zbornik radova
znanstveno-struฤnog skupa Hrvatski povjesniฤari umjetnosti๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ข๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎œฐ๎๎œถ๎œผ๎•๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎•๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œ๎›ต๎›๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎๎œŒ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎šฒ๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎˜๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎™–๎šฒ๎๎œ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ†๎œ”๎๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กพ๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œฐ๎๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šค๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œผ๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œด๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚
๎˜ฆ๎œ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ฃ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚HEPI Policy Note๎˜‚๎ข๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎—๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ข๎˜‚
๎š‹๎šฒ๎˜๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃฏ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎ขฃ
๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎ขด๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต-
๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚The Spatial Identities of the Rural Settlements of Gorski Kotar
Workshop Was Held in Delnice๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎•๎œ”๎›‘๎ขฃ๎œญ๎›ซ๎Ÿ๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎ขฉ๎›•๎œ๎ขฉ๎›ต๎œ-
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฉ๎œ๎›•๎–๎œด๎ขค๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎ฃ˜๎š‹๎™๎˜ฆ๎ขช๎šƒ๎™ผ๎˜ƒ๎š‹๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™–๎ขช๎™…๎˜ข๎˜ฆ๎™๎š‹๎™…๎š‹๎™…๎˜ฆ๎šƒ๎ขช๎™ฃ๎˜บ๎ขช๎š‹๎™๎˜ฆ๎ขช๎™ฟ๎š๎™ฟ๎˜ƒ๎™–๎ขช
๎šƒ๎˜ฆ๎š‹๎š‹๎™–๎˜ฆ๎™œ๎˜ฆ๎™๎š‹๎šƒ๎ขช๎™ฃ๎˜บ๎ขช๎˜ป๎™ฃ๎™ฟ๎šƒ๎™“๎™…๎ขช๎™“๎™ฃ๎š‹๎™ฃ๎™ฟ๎ขช๎šฅ๎™ฃ๎™ฟ๎™“๎šƒ๎™๎™ฃ๎™ผ๎ขช๎šฅ๎˜ƒ๎šƒ๎ขช๎™๎˜ฆ๎™–๎˜ข๎ขช๎™…๎™๎ขช
๎˜ข๎˜ฆ๎™–๎™๎™…๎˜œ๎˜ฆ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Infrastrukturni projekti i druลกtveno-kulturno oblikovanje
prostora u Gorskome kotaru (Infrastructural Projects and Socio-Cultural
Construction of Space in Gorski Kotar๎ขฑ๎ขฃ ๎˜ข๎œ”๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ข๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎Ÿ๎œ”๎›ช-
๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎•๎›•๎๎›๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œถ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎กพ๎ข„๎กฟ๎ข€๎ข๎ขฉ
๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎ข…๎ข‚๎ข†๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™“๎›•๎œ†๎–๎›ต๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎œ”๎œ๎œ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ ๎ขผ๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™…๎œด๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎ขค๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎›‘๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎œƒ๎ขฃ
๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎ขฉ๎›Š๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ขด๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขด๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎ขฉ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™–๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎š‹๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎œฏ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎™…๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎š‹๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚The International
Journal of the Inclusive Museum๎˜‚๎กพ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข†๎ข„๎ขณ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚
198
๎™œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†-
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚h๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎œƒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ”๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎ขฉ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œŒ๎œ†๎ขค๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎ฃ˜๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎ขข๎ขฉ
๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚ELPUB 2020 24th
edition of the International Conference on Electronic Publishing๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
at: ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฉ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขด๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข‚๎ข๎ข๎กฟ๎ข…๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎šฒ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎–๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎ขค๎ขฝ๎˜‚URISA Journal ๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข€๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฉ๎ข๎กฝ๎กพ๎กพ๎ข„๎ข†๎ข‚๎กฟ๎ขช
๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎ขช๎œ”๎–๎œ๎œด๎ขช๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎ขช๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎ขช๎™–๎›•๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š…๎œญ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚Gjuro Szabo: 1875.โ€“1943.: zbornik radova znanstveno-
struฤnog skupa Hrvatski povjesniฤari umjetnosti๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎ข๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎œฐ๎๎œถ๎œผ๎•๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ”๎•๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œ๎›ต๎›๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎๎œŒ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข„๎ขฃ๎˜‚Sakralna arhitektura ฤabarskog kraja u 18. i 19. stoljeฤ‡u.
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎•๎›•๎๎›๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œถ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎Ÿ๎œ”๎›ช๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎ขฃ๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎ขฉ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎ข๎œ๎›Š๎œ๎ข๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎ข๎กพ๎ข…๎ขƒ๎ข๎ข‚๎กพ๎ขƒ๎ข„๎ข๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”-
๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎๎œถ๎›•๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Stambeno graditeljstvo brodmoraviฤkog kraja do prve
polovine 19. stoljeฤ‡a (Residential Architecture in the Brod-Moravice Re-
gion till the End of the First Half of 19th Century๎ขฑ.๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎•๎›•๎๎›๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œถ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ”๎Ÿ๎œ”๎›ช๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œƒ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚https://urn.
๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎ขฉ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎ข๎œ๎›Š๎œ๎ข๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎ข๎กพ๎ข…๎ขƒ๎ข๎ข‚๎ข…๎กฝ๎ขƒ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š๎™๎˜ฆ๎šƒ๎˜œ๎™ฃ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Convention Concerning the Protection of the World Cultural
and Natural Heritage๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›•๎œผ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข„๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กพ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎šค๎›•๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ข๎›•๎›Š๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ Pop!Public. Open.
Participatory๎˜‚๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎œ”๎›ต๎ขฃ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎ข๎ข‚๎ข†๎กฝ๎ขฉ๎œญ๎œ”๎œญ๎ขฃ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฟ (ac-
๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
199
SLOVENIAN HISTORICAL
TOPOGRAPHY: A MEDIEVALISTโ€™S
GAZETTEER
MIHA SERUฤŒNIK
ZRC SAZU Milko Kos Historical Institute
Ljubljana, Slovenia
miha.serucnik@zrc-sazu.si
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2784-0275
Place names are a part of a language that tends to change less than
๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎›Š๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต-
๎œ”๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขด๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™…๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขด๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎™ฟ๎˜œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎˜ƒ๎šฎ๎š๎ข๎ข…๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™‘๎œ”๎ก๎›•๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚
application that allows researchers to search and view the data freely.
๎˜œ๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
An important addition is also the introduction of line geographies for
waterways and larger geographical features (mountain ranges, for ex-
๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ
๎™“๎›•๎˜๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•-
๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ
๎ข๎ข…๎˜‚๎šฎ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎•๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œด๎œƒ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™ฟ๎›•-
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
Professional paper
MIHA SERUฤŒNIK
200
INTRODUCTION
This paper is an extended version of a presentation give๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎™๎™ฟ๎˜‚Digital Humanities & Heritage
conference.๎ข๎ข†๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎ขด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด-
๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฎ๎™ฟ๎˜œ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎˜ƒ๎šฎ๎š๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎กฝ
Place names are a part of a language that tends to change less than
๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎›Š๎๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช-
๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขด๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™…๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขด๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚
๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•-
๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œญ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ
๎ข๎ข† 2nd DARIAH-HR international conference Digital Humanities & Heritage๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•-
๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฟ๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž
https://dhh.dariah.hr/home/.
๎ข‚๎กฝ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ขผ๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎™๎š‹๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎›ต๎œด-
๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฑ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™‘๎ขƒ๎ขด๎ข๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ๎›•๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎ขฉ๎œด๎›ต๎ขฉ๎›•๎œ๎ขฉ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฉ๎ข„๎กฝ๎กพ๎ขƒ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎ขผ๎š‹๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™ฟ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฝ๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎™–๎ข„๎ขด๎ข†๎ข๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎ขฃ๎›‹๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ๎›•๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎ขฉ๎œด๎›ต๎ขฉ๎›•๎œ๎ขฉ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฉ๎กพ๎ข„๎ข€๎ข†๎กพ.
๎šƒ๎™๎š‹๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎š‹๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎œด๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎œด๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™–๎ขƒ๎ขด๎ข๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎ขƒ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎–๎–๎–๎ขฃ๎Ÿ๎œฐ๎›‹๎ขด๎œด๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎๎ขฃ
๎œด๎›ต๎ขฉ๎›•๎œ๎ขฉ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎ขด๎›ต๎œ๎ขด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎œผ๎›ต๎ขฉ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎œ๎šฒ๎ขด๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขด๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขด๎›ต๎œ๎ขด๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎ขฃ
201
SLOVENIAN HISTORICAL TOPOGRAPHY: A MEDIEVALISTโ€™S GAZETTEER
WHAT ARE GAZETTEERS AND WHY CREATE A HISTORICAL
ONE?
๎˜ป๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎—๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ฆ๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•-
๎œŒ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚
names of settlements and geographical features that are no longer in
๎๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎˜๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
on how the name of a locality changed over time and the sources from
which the data are derived. Place names change over time. This is due
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ข๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎กฟ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ-
๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ช๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚
encounters. This is not surprising, since all living languages change over
time. In addition, modern orthographic conventions did not emerge
until the modern period as a result of the printed word. Before that,
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎ค๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚
๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›‹๎ขฃ๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎กพ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šง๎๎›ซ๎œ”๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™“๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›Š๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™…๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ-
๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎›Š๎œด๎›Š๎๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
northern Adriatic coast, the local variant of mediaeval Italian was in use
๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎™…๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎›‹๎œ†๎๎œด๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ-
istrative sources from the last two decades of the nineteenth century
๎œ”๎œ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œ†๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎-
๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
MIHA SERUฤŒNIK
202
๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
German. Others preferred to try a transliteration of the phonetic image
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›‹-
๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
orthography. As a result, the historian is often confronted with place
๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎ขฃ
In addition, one must consider the issue of localities that are no
๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎๎œ†๎›ช๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ๎›•๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œผ๎›•-
๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
communist authorities after the end of World War II.
A HISTORICAL GAZETTEER FOR THE SLOVENIAN MIDDLE
AGES
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎–๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›Š๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ตstorians from
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎•๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข€๎กฝ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™–๎œ๎๎›‘๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎๎œญ๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†-
๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œผ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎๎œญ๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฟ๎ข†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎๎œญ๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
the upheavals of World War II, Hauptmann lost all his materials con-
๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎™๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎œƒ๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎šฒ๎•๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข‚๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚Materials for
the Historical Topography of Slovenia (Carniola until 1500). This was not
a p๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎–๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
203
SLOVENIAN HISTORICAL TOPOGRAPHY: A MEDIEVALISTโ€™S GAZETTEER
stone on the path to a more complete edition that was to follow. The
Materials๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎•๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ข„๎ข„๎ข„๎˜‚๎›‹๎˜๎›‹๎œ†๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎—๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎กพ๎กฝ๎ข๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข‚๎กฝ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”-
๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขด๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด-
torians and was seminal in several ways. Incidentally, the formulation
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‹๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ
๎™œ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎•๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‘๎ขด๎กพ๎ข†๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎˜๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™“๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›‘๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎›Š๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šง๎๎›ซ๎œ”๎œด๎œ†๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฅ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ-
๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œด๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข…๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข…๎ข†๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ-
๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™…๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎›•๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎ขด๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›•๎œƒ๎œŒ๎๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข…๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎›ช๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‘๎ขด๎กพ๎ข†๎ข…๎กฝ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎™…๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎—๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†-
league Hauptmann, the index card catalogue pertaining to the western
๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎šฒ๎–๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎Ÿ๎˜‚๎š…๎๎œŒ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎กพ
GOING DIGITAL
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎กฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎™–๎›•๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œƒ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œƒ๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎ข‚๎กพ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎œญ๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ข„๎ขณ๎ข†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎ข…๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข‚๎ข๎ขจ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข‚๎ขฃ
MIHA SERUฤŒNIK
204
๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎˜œ๎™ฟ๎ขด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎˜œ๎™ฟ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
This coincided with the long-running sentiment at our institute that
๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎๎œ๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
than a simple revision and a reprint was called for. Those who had
๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ-
cies which called for careful critical revision. Besides, it was deemed
๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎›•๎ฃ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
update the data. As a result, a team๎ข‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎™๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎ข€
The idea was to transfer the information from the digital text (then
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ-
๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎•๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎ขด๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขด๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎š…๎›ต๎œ†๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™‘๎œ”๎ก๎›•๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎™‘๎šƒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎ข
๎™พ๎๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œด๎›ต-
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข‚๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚
๎ข‚๎กฟ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต-
๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎™–๎œ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ข‚๎ข€๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎™๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฑ๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎Ÿ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œƒ๎ขฃ
๎Ÿ๎œฐ๎›‹๎ขด๎œด๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎๎ขฃ๎œด๎›ต๎ขฉ๎›•๎œ๎ขฉ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎ขด๎›ต๎œ๎ขด๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎œผ๎›ต๎ขฉ๎œด๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎ขด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขด๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎ขด๎›ต๎œ๎ขด๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎ขด๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขด๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขด
historical-topography-of-slovenia-from๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎ข‚๎ข๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎š…๎›ต๎œ†๎›‹๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ”๎œถ๎›•๎›‹๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎ขด๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎ก๎›•๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ
205
SLOVENIAN HISTORICAL TOPOGRAPHY: A MEDIEVALISTโ€™S GAZETTEER
๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚consulted and the results were included in our
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต-
๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎ขจ๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎›‹๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›ช๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฉ๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎ขด๎™๎๎œ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎ขด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚
series of maps covering the former Austro-Hungarian territory, drawn
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎กพ๎ข๎ข„๎ข‚๎ขž๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎ข‚๎˜‚ ๎™–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜บ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎˜๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข†๎ข‚๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎ขƒ
๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ-
๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ urbaria๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขด๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
creation of timelines for the morphologic changes of placenames and
๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขด๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚
๎›•๎œผ๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎•๎›•๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎ขด๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ข€๎ขž๎ข‚๎กฝ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎ขด๎ฃ๎›ช๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎ข…๎ข€๎ข‚๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ”๎๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎ข†๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎œ”๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™‘๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎šƒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎™๎™ผ๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎˜๎šƒ๎™พ๎™–๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎ข‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎›•๎Ÿ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œƒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข๎ข„๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎กฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข„๎กฟ๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข†๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ
๎ข‚๎ขƒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฝ๎ข๎˜‚https://maps.arcanum.
com/en/.
MIHA SERUฤŒNIK
206
๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ-
๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚
in the list, a detailed view of the historical names of the location (we
๎›‘๎๎›Š๎›Š๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎›ช๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
pane is reserved for the map. The right-hand pane displays paleonyms of the selected
toponym. Paleonyms contain further details.
๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎ขด๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ-
๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎ก๎›•๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ช๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œ†๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›‹๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œญ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎—๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎˜œ๎™ฟ๎ขด๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‹๎›•๎›•๎›‘-
๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎ขด๎๎œญ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚
๎›‘๎œ”๎๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎ขด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‹๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎™ฃ๎šค๎™…๎˜ข๎ขด๎กพ๎ข†๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎œƒ๎›‘๎œ”๎–๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œฐ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‘๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ช๎๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ฃ๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚
to archives in Italy.
๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
previous experiences as well as introducing changes and new function-
๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚
207
SLOVENIAN HISTORICAL TOPOGRAPHY: A MEDIEVALISTโ€™S GAZETTEER
๎™œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎›ช๎œผ๎–๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™œ๎˜๎šƒ๎™พ๎™–๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ-
๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎™๎™ผ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎™ฃ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œญ๎›•๎œ๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œผ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎ขด๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ†๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
can specify the time interval in which they are interested. The clos-
๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œƒ๎œ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎œญ-
proximate date, terminus ante quem, terminus post quem๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œฏ๎๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
the years dynamically from the map features at the time of page load-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œญ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™‘๎šƒ๎™ฃ๎™๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›• server.
๎˜บ๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ
MIHA SERUฤŒNIK
208
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”gy, inherited from
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฟ๎˜‚ ๎›‘๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎›‹๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ข…๎ข๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ฃ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ-
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ขผ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œฏ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต-
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขด๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•-
๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘-
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚
from the High mediaeval period onward and their development was
in no way homogeneous. Thus, trying to provide historically accurate
๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎šฒ๎•๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎ขผ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎–๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎™–๎›ต๎œผ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎•๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›•๎›‹๎๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎ขฐ๎™‘๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎šƒ๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎œ”๎›ต๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎œƒ-
๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ†๎œ”๎–๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎–๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œŒ๎œ”๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎œด๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎๎œญ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚
๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šƒ๎šƒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎˜๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎Ÿ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎œ”๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขฃ
๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œญ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต-
๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ-
๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎˜๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎–๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎˜๎›ซ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œด๎ขฃ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ข‚๎ข‚๎ข„๎ข๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ†๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”ning that the
209
SLOVENIAN HISTORICAL TOPOGRAPHY: A MEDIEVALISTโ€™S GAZETTEER
๎œด๎œผ๎๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขƒ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œฐ-
ther toponyms in the Carniola region. A query of paleonyms currently
๎˜๎›ต๎›•๎œ†๎›‘๎œด๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข‚๎˜‚๎กฟ๎ข…๎ข†๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎›‘๎œด๎ขฃ
DISCUSSION AND OUTLOOKS
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎›ช๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎ค๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›Š๎œฐ๎œ”๎–๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œด๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ-
formation on the territory which would otherwise remain only sporad-
๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎๎œ๎œด๎˜๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
As such, our team has mainly pursued practical concerns on how to
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎–๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘-
๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎๎œฐ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œ๎ขด๎ฃ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹-
๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎•๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œƒ๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎–๎œ๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎›ต๎œ†๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‘๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎›ซ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎›‹๎ขฃ๎ขฑ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚
we do not cover administrative or political entities, though in some
๎›‹๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›•๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎œŒ๎›ต๎›‹๎œฐ๎œ”๎ขฑ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎šฒ๎›ต๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎ฃ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎›‹๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎›ซ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎˜๎ขฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎˜๎œ”๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎›‹๎œ”๎œญ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎ข‚๎ข„
๎™ฃ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎–๎šฒ๎˜๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚
focused on our primary sources which are predominantly charters. In
cases where the documents themselves do not contain information
๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ-
๎ข‚๎ข„๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎œผ๎–๎›•๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎œญ๎›ฑ๎˜๎œด๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎ฃ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎ขด๎›‘๎›•๎œญ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ-
teers and investigates several issues connected to the mediaeval period, such as the
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ช๎ฃ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎ฃ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎›ซ๎๎›•๎œ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
MIHA SERUฤŒNIK
210
phy. Thus every paleonym is equipped with at least one time stamp at
which it is valid.๎ข‚๎ข…
๎šƒ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎›•๎šฒ๎›‘๎ขค๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎–๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎ขด๎œƒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚
๎œผ๎›•๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›ช๎๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ-
๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎˜๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎•๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎›‘๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚
team grappled with. Due to different geographic characteristics, this
๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›•๎—๎›ฑ๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎–๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œด๎œ”๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎œƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎œ†๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚
๎™‘๎๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎œญ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎›ต๎ฃ๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ๎๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›•๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œ”๎œ†๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œด๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ-
teer in half and concentrate on the western and southern parts of the
๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›Š๎œ”๎œ”๎œƒ๎ขž๎ข‚๎ข†๎˜‚๎œ†๎›•๎šฒ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œด๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎›•๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎›Š๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚
minorities.
๎˜ƒ๎œด๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚ ๎›•๎—๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฟ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚ ๎›‹๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚
planning to provide a translation of the interface which at the moment
๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎™ผ๎™…๎˜‚
๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขจ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎•๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎๎œ†๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎™‘๎šƒ๎™ฃ๎™๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
Also, an advanced search mode interface for the site is long overdue.
๎šฅ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎œ†๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎๎œ†๎œ†๎ขด๎›ช๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚
๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›Š๎šฒ๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ-
๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎œ†๎๎›‘๎›•๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œŒ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎˜‚
accurate and the most inclusive collection of primary sources and
๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›‘๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎›‘๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎›Š๎›•๎œด๎œญ๎œ”๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎•๎›ต๎›•๎–๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎›‘๎œ”๎๎›Š๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œญ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎๎œด๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›ช๎›•๎œด-
sional or amateur.
๎˜บ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎–๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œ๎›•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›‘๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฏ๎๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œฐ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚ ๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™ผ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ต๎œ”๎œด๎ขฝ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎ข‚๎ข…๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎œ”๎œŒ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎œญ๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œ”๎œ๎˜๎œŒ๎œด๎˜‚๎–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ต๎œŒ๎›•๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œญ๎œด๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œŒ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚
๎›‘๎›ต๎œด๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎›ซ๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎œด๎›•๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›•๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎˜‚๎ข„๎ขฃ
๎ข‚๎ข† This territory largely corresponds to the area under the control of the Counts of
Cilli from the fourteenth century onward.
211
SLOVENIAN HISTORICAL TOPOGRAPHY: A MEDIEVALISTโ€™S GAZETTEER
๎ขผ๎šฅ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œด๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎˜‚
is only poorly covered regarding historical placenames and offering our
๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎˜‚๎–๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‹๎›•๎œฐ๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎˜๎˜‚
such endeavour would of course entail meeting the requirements of
๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎œด๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎œ๎œ”๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎˜‚๎›‹๎œ”๎๎œ†๎›‘๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎›•๎˜‚๎›ต๎œผ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎๎œŒ๎ขด๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขฃ๎˜‚
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚ ๎–๎œ”๎œฐ๎œƒ๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚ ๎–๎šฒ๎œด๎˜‚ ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œญ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎œ”๎๎›ซ๎›ฑ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎˜‚
๎œญ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎ขž๎ขƒ๎กฝ funds provid-
๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›‹๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎œด๎๎œญ๎œญ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œผ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›Š๎˜๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎šƒ๎™…๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎›ช๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎›•๎ขฃ๎˜‚
REFERENCES LIST
Arcanum maps. Availa๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข https://maps.arcanum.com/en/๎˜‚ ๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚ ๎ข‚๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎˜›๎œ†๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎•๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎›ต๎›๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข…๎ขƒ๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข†๎ข…๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚Historiฤna topogra๎ฅja Slovenije
II. Slovenska ล tajerska in jugoslovanski del Koroลกke, do leta 1500 (3 deli).
๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎ข๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎›Š๎Ÿ๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ
Gemeindelexikon von Krain. Bearbeitet auf Grund der Ergebnisse der Volk-
szรคhlung vom 31. Dezember 1900.๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎กฝ๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎๎œด๎›ซ๎›•๎›ซ๎›•๎›Š๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎•๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎œด๎œผ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎›ต๎œด๎œด๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™๎šฒ๎๎œญ๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎ขฎ๎œ๎ขฏ๎๎›‘๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข€๎ข†๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎™“๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Erlauterungen zum Historischen Atlas
der รถsterreichischen Alpenlรคnder ๎™…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ข๎ข๎˜‚๎ข€๎กฝ๎ข†๎ขณ๎ข๎ข…๎ข๎ขฃ
๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚Srednjeveลกki urbarji za Slovenijo 2. Urbarji Slovenskega pri-
morja 1. ๎™–๎œ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข‚๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚Srednjeveลกki urbarji za Slovenijo 3. Urbarji Slovenskega pri-
morja 2๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎ขฃ
๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข„๎ข‚๎ขฃ๎˜‚Gradivo za historiฤno topogra๎ฅjo Slovenije: (za Kranjsko do
leta 1500)๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œถ๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›Š๎›๎œ”๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎›ซ๎œ”๎›‘๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎œ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œƒ-
๎šฒ๎›‘๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎˜‚๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎๎œŒ๎›•๎œผ๎œ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎ขฃ
๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ๎šฒ๎ก๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎Ÿ๎œ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎๎›๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎š…๎›ต๎œ†๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข‚๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎ขผ๎šƒ๎™๎š‹๎˜‚๎ขณ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎›๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข ๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œผ๎œ”๎œญ๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎ฃ๎œ๎šฒ๎ขฃ๎Ÿ๎œฐ๎›‹๎ขด
๎œด๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎๎ขฃ๎œด๎›ต๎˜‚๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
๎™“๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ๎šฒ๎ก๎˜‚๎˜›๎›ต๎Ÿ๎œ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎๎›๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎š…๎›ต๎œ†๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กพ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Historiฤna topo-
gra๎ฅja Kranjske (do leta 1500). Druga dopolnjena izdaja๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎œ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎ก๎›Š๎šฒ๎˜‚
ZRC.
๎ขƒ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎œผ๎œ”๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎•๎›•๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œ๎œ”๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎˜๎ขฃ
MIHA SERUฤŒNIK
212
Orts-Repertorium des Herzogthums Krain. Auf Grundlage der Volkszรคhlung
vom 31. Dezember 1869 / Imenik krajev vojvodine Kranjske. Sestavljen na
podlagi ljudskega ลกtetja od 32. decembra l. 1869๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข„๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎›ต๎›Š๎šฒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขฉ๎™–๎œ๎๎›Š๎œ†๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎œฐ๎๎›‹๎œƒ๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šค๎›•๎œฐ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎•๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™…๎›ซ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ†๎›•๎›ต๎œ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎œฐ๎˜‚๎ฃฏ๎˜‚๎˜บ๎›•๎›‘๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜›๎šฒ๎œŒ๎›Š๎›•๎œฐ๎›ซ๎ขฃ
๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›•๎›ต๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œญ๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎›ต๎œŒ๎˜‚๎™‘๎œ”๎œ๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œฐ๎œด๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎˜‚๎™๎›ต๎œ†๎œผ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎˜‚๎™“๎šฒ๎๎œญ๎œญ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚
๎ขผ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขด๎˜ข๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎˜ป๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต-
๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Semantic Web Journal ๎ขฐ๎กพ๎ขฑ๎ข๎˜‚๎กพ๎ขณ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œผ๎ข๎˜‚
๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขด๎–๎›•๎›Š๎ขด๎œ๎œ”๎๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขฃ๎œ๎›•๎œผ๎ขฉ๎›‹๎œ”๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎ขฉ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขด๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎›‘๎ขด๎›‘๎›•๎œด๎›ต๎›ซ๎œ๎ขด
๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎œญ๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขด๎œด๎›•๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎ขด๎›ซ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎›•๎œผ๎œผ๎›•๎›•๎œฐ๎ขด๎œŒ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎•๎šฒ๎œ†๎ขด๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œ†๎˜๎ขด๎œŒ๎œ”๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎ขด๎œญ๎œ†๎šฒ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขด๎กพ
๎ขฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎œด๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎ข‚๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ†๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎ข€๎ขฑ๎ขฃ
Special-Orts-Repertorium des Herzogthums Krain/Obลกiren imenik krajev na
Kranjskem๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข…๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎œ๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎›ช๎ขด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎˜‚๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›๎œผ๎œด๎ขด๎˜›๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ฑ๎›๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ
Special-Orts-Repertorium von Krain. Neubearbeitung auf Grund der Ergeb-
nisse der Volkszรคhlung vom 31. Dezember 1890/Specijalni Reperto-
rij krajev na Kranjskem. Na novo predelan po rezultatih popisa ljud-
stva dne 31. decembra 1890๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข†๎ข๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎œ๎œ†๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎œƒ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎™๎œ”๎›ช๎ขด๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›๎œผ๎œด๎ขด๎˜›๎๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›ฑ๎›๎œ๎›‘๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขฃ
Spezialkarte 1:75.000๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข…๎ข„๎กฟ๎ขณ๎กพ๎ข†๎กพ๎ข…๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎ข๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œ†๎›ต๎œผ๎›๎œฐ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ”๎›ซ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œญ๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œด๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎ขฃ
๎š…๎›ต๎œ†๎›‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œฐ๎œ”๎œถ๎›•๎›‹๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กฟ๎กฝ๎กฟ๎กฝ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Programska orodja in pripomoฤki za prip-
ravo podatkov in vnos ter izpis v oz. Iz podatkovne zbirke Historiฤna topo-
gra๎ฅja Slovenije. Report.
๎šฎ๎›•๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎•๎šฒ๎œ๎ขฃ๎˜‚๎กพ๎ข†๎ข…๎กฟ๎ขฃ๎˜‚Historiฤna topogra๎ฅja Slovenije I. Prekmurje do leta 1500.
๎™œ๎๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›Š๎œ”๎œผ๎šฒ๎ข๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎œŒ๎๎œฐ๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎Ÿ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ”๎ก๎›Š๎šฒ๎ขฃ
213
๎˜บ๎œ”๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚Digital Humanities & Heritage conference: DARIAH-HR
๎˜œ๎œ”๎œ๎›ช๎›•๎œฐ๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎˜‚๎–๎›•๎›Š๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎›•๎ข๎˜‚๎›ฑ๎œผ๎œผ๎œญ๎œด๎ข๎ขฉ๎ขฉ๎›‘๎›ฑ๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎›ฑ๎ขฃ๎›ฑ๎œฐ๎ขฉ
COMMITTEES:
2021
ORGANISING COMMITTEE:
Koraljka Kuzman ล logar
๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎™๎™ฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Anamarija ลฝugiฤ‡ Boriฤ‡
๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎™๎™ฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Ana Antolkoviฤ‡
๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎™๎™ฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Irena Miholiฤ‡
๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Marijana Tomiฤ‡
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
Centre for Research in Glagolitism, Croatia
Zrinka Dลพoiฤ‡
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Laura Grzunov
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Nevenka Kalebiฤ‡
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Drahomira Cupar
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Vlatka Lemiฤ‡
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎ขฉ๎˜‚๎™…๎˜œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎š๎šƒ๎˜‚๎™๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Saลกa Potoฤnjak
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
Croatia
PROGRAMME COMMITTEE:
Koraljka Kuzman ล logar
๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎™๎™ฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Marijana Tomiฤ‡
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
Centre for Research in Glagolitism, Croatia
214
Saลกa Potoฤnjak
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
Croatia
Cรฉcile Chantraine Braillon
๎™–๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•
Antoine Doucet
๎™–๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎ข€๎›ต๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎š‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•
Anne Gilliland
๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎ฃฏ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎˜œ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎šƒ๎˜ƒ
Vlatka Lemiฤ‡
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎ขฉ๎˜‚๎™…๎˜œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎š๎šƒ๎˜‚๎™๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Benedikt Perak
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
Croatia
Erich Renhart
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šค๎˜ฆ๎šƒ๎š‹๎™…๎˜ป๎™…๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ
Anna Maria Tammaro
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜
Mirna Willer
๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Tihomir ลฝiviฤ‡
๎™‘๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚
๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
2022
ORGANISING COMMITTEE:
Koraljka Kuzman ล logar
๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎™๎™ฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Antonia Hladilo Duspara
๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎™๎™ฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Anamarija ลฝugiฤ‡ Boriฤ‡
๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎™๎™ฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Irena Miholiฤ‡
๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
215
Benedikt Perak
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
Croatia
Kosana Jovanoviฤ‡
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
Croatia
Barbara ล panjol-Pandelo
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
Croatia
Luca Malatesti
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
Croatia
Vlatka Lemiฤ‡
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎ขฉ๎˜‚๎™…๎˜œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎š๎šƒ๎˜‚๎™๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Marijana Tomiฤ‡
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
Centre for Research in Glagolitism, Croatia
PROGRAMME COMMITTEE:
Koraljka Kuzman ล logar
๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ”๎›ซ๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œ”๎œ†๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎™…๎˜ƒ๎™๎ขด๎™๎™ฟ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Kosana Jovanoviฤ‡
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
Croatia
Antonija Primorac
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
Croatia
Barbara ล panjol-Pandelo
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
Croatia
Cรฉcile Chantraine Braillon
๎™–๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•
Josip ฤ†iriฤ‡
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Antoine Doucet
๎™–๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎›‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎ข€๎›ต๎ข๎˜‚๎™…๎š‹๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎œŒ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™–๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎›‹๎›•
Anne Gilliland
๎š๎˜œ๎™–๎˜ƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›‘๎๎šฒ๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ”๎œ†๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ฆ๎›‘๎๎›‹๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎ฃฏ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
Department of Information ๎šƒ๎œผ๎๎›‘๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎œ”๎œด๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎šƒ๎˜ƒ
216
Koraljka Golub
๎™–๎›ต๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎›•๎๎œด๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œด๎˜‚๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎–๎›•๎›‘๎›•๎œ
Juan Gomis Coloma
๎˜œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œ†๎›ต๎›‹๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šค๎šฒ๎œ†๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›ต๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œญ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ
Simona Grigaliลซnienฤ—
๎™“๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œญ๎› ๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œญ๎› ๎›‘๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ
Ulrike Henny-Krahmer
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎›‹๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜
Meike Klettke
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎œ”๎œด๎œผ๎œ”๎›‹๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œด๎œผ๎›ต๎œผ๎๎œผ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎›‹๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜
Vlatka Lemiฤ‡
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎›•๎›Š๎˜‚๎ขฉ๎˜‚๎™…๎˜œ๎˜ƒ๎™ฟ๎š๎šƒ๎˜‚๎™๎œฐ๎•๎šฒ๎œผ๎œด๎œƒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Erich Renhart
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šค๎˜ฆ๎šƒ๎š‹๎™…๎˜ป๎™…๎˜ƒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œ๎๎œด๎›‹๎œฐ๎›ต๎œญ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎›•๎œด๎›•๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›‹๎›ฑ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ
Dalia Marija Stanฤienฤ—
๎™“๎œ†๎šฒ๎›ต๎œญ๎› ๎›‘๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎ขž๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎œผ๎›ฑ๎๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎šฒ
Anna Maria Tammaro
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ผ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜œ๎๎œ†๎œผ๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎›•๎œฐ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎›ซ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›•๎›‹๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎›Š๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎œด๎›ฑ๎›ต๎œญ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜
Marijana Tomiฤ‡
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚
Centre for Research in Glagolitism, Croatia
Georg Vogeler
๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎˜œ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›ต๎›ซ๎›ต๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™๎๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎šฒ๎Ÿ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎๎œด๎œผ๎œฐ๎›ต๎šฒ
Mirna Willer
๎œฐ๎›•๎œผ๎›ต๎œฐ๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎œ”๎œŒ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎šฎ๎šฒ๎›‘๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎›•๎œญ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎œผ๎œŒ๎›•๎œ๎œผ๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎›ช๎œ”๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚
๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
Ulrike Wuttke
๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œญ๎œญ๎œ†๎›ต๎›•๎›‘๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ”๎œผ๎œด๎›‘๎šฒ๎œŒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›•๎œฐ๎œŒ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜
Tihomir ลฝiviฤ‡
๎™‘๎œ”๎œด๎›ต๎œญ๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎œฐ๎œ”๎œด๎œด๎œŒ๎šฒ๎˜๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎š๎œ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎œฐ๎œด๎›ต๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜บ๎šฒ๎›‹๎๎œ†๎œผ๎˜๎˜‚
๎œ”๎›ช๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎œฐ๎œ”๎›Š๎›ต๎œ”๎œผ๎›•๎›‹๎›ฑ๎œ๎›ต๎›‹๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›‹๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎›‹๎›•๎œด๎˜‚๎™ฃ๎œด๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎œ”๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎šฒ
217
REVIEWERS OF THE EDITION: ๎˜›๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎œ”๎œด๎šฒ๎œ๎›๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›–๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚
Braillon
PAPER REVIEWERS: ๎™ผ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎šฒ๎›ซ๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎˜›๎›•๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›–๎›‹๎›ต๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚ ๎˜œ๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ๎›•๎˜‚
๎˜›๎œฐ๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ฅ๎๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎œ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜ป๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎œ๎›‘๎ขž๎˜‚๎™“๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œ”๎œ†๎๎›Š๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œถ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎˜ป๎œฐ๎›‘๎›•๎œถ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ†๎›Š๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎™…๎œฐ๎œ”๎œ†๎œ†๎œ”๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎›ซ๎šฒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™‘๎๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šค๎œ†๎šฒ๎œผ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎›•๎œŒ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎šƒ๎šฒ๎œ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™–๎œ”๎œ๎›๎šฒ๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎™ผ๎›•๎œผ๎œฐ๎šฒ๎˜‚ ๎™œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎œ”๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚ ๎˜ƒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎œ†๎œ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ๎œƒ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎œ†๎œ”๎œถ๎›•๎•๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜›๎›•๎œ๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œƒ๎œผ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎›•๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™…๎•๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ผ๎œ†๎›•๎œถ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎œ”๎œ๎›‹๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™ฟ๎šฒ๎œŒ๎œถ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎™œ๎›ต๎›ฑ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎›•๎œฐ๎๎›๎œ๎›ต๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ข๎šฒ๎œ†๎›ต๎šฒ๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šƒ๎œผ๎šฒ๎œ๎›๎›ต๎›•๎œ๎› ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎šฒ๎œฐ๎›ต๎œ๎šฒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎š‹๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎šฐ๎›•๎œ†๎œ๎œƒ๎œ”๎˜‚๎š‹๎œฐ๎›Š๎๎œถ๎›ต๎›Œ๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎›•๎œ”๎œฐ๎›ซ๎˜‚๎šค๎œ”๎›ซ๎›•๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™‘๎๎œฐ๎›•๎˜‚๎šค๎œ”๎œ†๎›๎œ๎šฒ๎œƒ๎ขž๎˜‚๎˜ƒ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šค๎๎œƒ๎šฒ๎›‘๎›ต๎œ๎ขž๎˜‚๎™œ๎›ต๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎˜‚๎šฅ๎›ต๎œ†๎œ†๎›•๎œฐ๎ขž๎˜‚๎š๎œ†๎œฐ๎›ต๎œƒ๎›•๎˜‚๎šฅ๎๎œผ๎œผ๎œƒ๎›•๎ขž๎˜‚
๎˜ป๎œ”๎œฐ๎šฒ๎œ๎˜‚๎šฎ๎œ†๎œ”๎›‘๎›ต๎ขž๎˜‚๎š‹๎›ต๎›ฑ๎œ”๎œŒ๎›ต๎œฐ๎˜‚๎šฐ๎›ต๎•๎›ต๎›Œ
๎š‹๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎›•๎ขด๎›•๎›‘๎›ต๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎˜‚๎›ต๎œด๎˜‚๎›ช๎œฐ๎›•๎›•๎œ†๎˜๎˜‚๎šฒ๎•๎šฒ๎›ต๎œ†๎šฒ๎›Š๎œ†๎›•๎˜‚๎๎œ๎›‘๎›•๎œฐ๎˜‚๎œผ๎›ฑ๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œฐ๎›•๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎•๎›•๎˜‚๎˜œ๎œ”๎œŒ๎œŒ๎œ”๎œ๎œด๎˜‚๎˜œ๎˜œ๎˜‚๎˜›๎šง๎ขด
๎™๎˜œ๎ขด๎™๎˜ข๎˜‚๎ข๎ขฃ๎กฝ๎˜‚๎™…๎œ๎œผ๎›•๎œฐ๎œ๎šฒ๎œผ๎›ต๎œ”๎œ๎šฒ๎œ†๎˜‚๎™–๎›ต๎›‹๎›•๎œ๎œด๎›•๎ขฃ