The Guide to High Net Worth Clients and Arbitration - First Edition PDF Free Download
1 / 12
/12
100%
The Guide to High
Net Worth Clients
and Arbitration -
First Edition
Private wealth disputes in China and
south-east Asia
The Guide to High
Net Worth Clients and
Arbitration - First Edition
The rstq uaosqes f2 qhe 1ctq neyqasx hot teey oy epifyeyqlov lynseote ly islwoqe geovqh
bvf,ovvxU ,aq iosqlnavosvx ly qhe dylqeS Cqoqet oyS .hlyoA kyS bvf,ov islwoqe geovqh vffWt teq qf
nossx fy tfoslybA mlqh qhoq bsfgqh f2 hlbhvx nfyneyqsoqeS geovqh nf(et oy lynseoteS yeeS
2fs tienlovltq vebov oSwlne oyS o bseoqes vlWevlhffS f2 hlbh yeq gfsqh SltiaqetA ks,lqsoqlfy
lt thoilyb ai qf ,enf(e qhe ,etq (enhoylt( qf setfvwe islwoqe geovqh SltiaqetU f22eslyb
nfyrSeyqlovlqxU tieeS oyS )fye hfietI (fse o(lno,ve faqnf(etA
Gy qhlt rstq eSlqlfyU eSlqeS ,x Fseb MovWf2 f2 Rlthnfy Se ;exoU os,lqsoqlfy epiesqt vffW oq
,atlyettU qsatq oyS 2o(lvx SltiaqetL Sltiaqet sevoqlyb qf tienlrn otteq nvottet tanh ot osq
oyS thosehfvSlybtL tqsoqebln nfytlSesoqlfytL ot gevv ot qhe seblfyov nhosonqesltqlnt f2 islwoqe
geovqh SltiaqetU eualiilyb xfa glqh o nf(iseheytlwe fweswleg f2 qhlt e(esblyb oseoA
Generated: May 3, 2025
The ly2fs(oqlfy nfyqolyeS ly qhlt seifsq lt lySlnoqlwe fyvxA Bog 0atlyett ;eteosnh lt yfq setifytl,ve
2fs oyx onqlfyt )fs vonW qhesef2I qoWey ot o setavq f2 sevxlyb fy fs ly oyx gox atlyb ly2fs(oqlfy nfyqolyeS
ly qhlt seifsq oyS ly yf eweyq thovv ,e vlo,ve 2fs oyx So(obet setavqlyb 2sf( sevloyne fy fs ate f2 qhlt
ly2fs(oqlfyA .fixslbhq 166- 5 161E Bog 0atlyett ;eteosnh
Hpivfse fy GAR
RETURN TO SUMMARY
Private wealth disputes
in China and south-east
Asia
Gary Yin and Darren Low
Simmons & Simmons LLP
Summary
INTRODUCTION
INTRODUCTION TO DISPUTES ASSOCIATED WITH PRIVATE WEALTH
ARBITRATION IN PRIVATE WEALTH DISPUTES
OTHER DISPUTE RESOLUTION MECHANISMS IN PRIVATE WEALTH DISPUTES
NAVIGATING THE FUTURE OF ARBITRATING PRIVATE WEALTH DISPUTES
Private wealth disputes in China and south-east Asia Hpivfse fy GAR
RETURN TO SUMMARY
INTRODUCTION
The ifiavoqlfy f2 hlbh yeq gfsqh lySlwlSaovt )NPmGtI[1] ly qhe ktlo57onlrn seblfy hot ,eey
tqeoSlvx lynseotlybA Gy 16c-U qhe seblfy hoS oiisfpl(oqevx EAE (lvvlfy lySlwlSaovtA Thlt hot
lynseoteS ,x ov(ftq E6 ies neyq qf osfayS 4A9 (lvvlfy ly qhe ta,teuaeyq tewey xeostU glqh
soqet f2 bsfgqh hlbhes qhoy HasfieU qhe RlSSve HotqU Boqly k(eslno oyS k2slno oyS tenfyS
fyvx qf qhoq f2 Pfsqh k(eslnoA[2] NPmG geovqh hot senfweseS 2sf( qhe vfttet ,sfabhq o,faq
,x qhe fyteq f2 qhe nfwlS5c$ ioySe(lnU glqh qfqov lywetql,ve otteqt f2 osfayS dCJ1EA4
qslvvlfyA[3] k 3oyaosx 1619 taswex f2 (fse qhoy KU666 NPmGt thfgt qhoq isl(osx otteq
ovvfnoqlfyt onsftt 1E (osWeqt howe nhoybeS 2sf( iseteswoqlfy qf bsfgqhU fglyb qf )cI
bfwesy(eyq e22fsqt qf nfyqsfv lyjoqlfy oyS sltlyb lyqesetq soqetU oyS )1I nhoyblyb enfyf(ln
nfySlqlfyt yfqglqhtqoySlyb (osWeq wfvoqlvlqxA[4]
kt geovqh bsfgtU nf(iveplqx lynseotet oyS wovae5oSSeS teswlnet ,enf(e o nsanlov
Sl22eseyqloqfs 2fs avqso NPmGtA[5] Thete noy lynvaSe teswlnet 2sf( geovqh (oyobe(eyq rs(tU
qsoSlqlfyov ryoynlov lytqlqaqlfyt oyS vogxestA Thex tioy ,fqh ryoynlov teswlnet )qop ivoyylybU
lywetq(eyq (oyobe(eyqI oyS yfy5ryoynlov teswlnet )nfynlesbe teswlnetU ai5qf5Soqe (osWeq
lytlbhqtIA[6]
Thlt nhoiqes isfwlSet oy fweswleg f2 qhe lttaet osltlyb ot sebosSt islwoqe geovqh Sltiaqet
ly (olyvoyS .hlyo oyS tfaqh5eotq ktloU[7] glqh o iosqlnavos 2fnat 2sf( qhe iestienqlwet
f2 (olyvoyS .hlyoU Nfyb Qfyb oyS ClyboifseA mhlve islwoqe geovqh lt f2qey lywetqeS
lyqesyoqlfyovvxU oyS ghlve o vosbe ya(,es f2 NPmGt ose nfyneyqsoqeS ly fqhes ktloy
–asltSlnqlfyt tanh ot GySfyetlo oyS RovoxtloU qhete qhsee –asltSlnqlfyt howe ,eey tevenqeS
,enoate f2 qhels qsoSlqlfyov oyS bsfglyb l(ifsqoyne ly qhe NPmG tioneU glqh vosbe ya(,est
f2 NPmGt[8] ot gevv ot 2o(lvx f&netA[9]
ktlSe 2sf( qhe nfyneyqsoqlfy f2 NPmGt ly qhe .hlyeteU Clyboifse oyS Nfyb Qfyb
–asltSlnqlfytU oyfqhes seotfy 2fs qhe 2fnat fy qhete qhsee –asltSlnqlfyt lt qhe 2onq qhoq
.hlyete atest f2 lyqesyoqlfyov os,lqsoqlfy ose lynseotlybvx fiqlyb 2fs Nfyb Qfyb oyS
Clyboifseoy os,lqsov lytqlqaqlfyt ot gevv ot teoqtA knnfsSlyb qf qhe ‘aeey Rosx ’ mhlqe
z .ote :Gyqesyoqlfyov ks,lqsoqlfy Caswex ;eifsq 161cOU qhese gese (fse setifySeyqt ghf
tevenqeS Nfyb QfybU Clyboifse oyS teoqt ly (olyvoyS .hlyoU tanh ot ChoybholU 0el–lyb
oyS Chey•heyU qhoy ly qhels isewlfat taswextA[10] MasqhesU ot ia,vltheS ly qhe Clyboifse
Gyqesyoqlfyov ks,lqsoqlfy .eyqseOt kyyaov ;eifsq 161KU qhe befbsoihlnov fslbly f2 iosqlet 2fs
yeg notet hoySveS ly 161K got fwesghev(lybvx Nfyb Qfyb oyS .hlyoA
INTRODUCTION TO DISPUTES ASSOCIATED WITH PRIVATE WEALTH
kt NPmGt lynseote ly ya(,es oyS qhels lySlwlSaov ifsq2fvlft ,enf(e lynseotlybvx
tfihltqlnoqeS oyS nf(ivepU lq lt yfq aynf((fy 2fs qhete iestfyt oyS qhels 2o(lvlet qf howe
bseoqes yeeSt ly qhe oseot f2 tannettlfy ivoyylybU qop fiql(ltoqlfyU otteq isfqenqlfy oyS
geovqh (oyobe(eyqA The yeeSt f2 o tl(ive 2o(lvx aylq ose ovseoSx nf(ivlnoqeS eyfabhU oyS
qhlt lt ovv qhe (fse tf ghey nfytlSeslyb o vosbeU geovqhx 2o(lvx glqh (avqlive ,soynhetA
The to(e qhe(et ies(eoqe Sltiaqet ly qhe islwoqe geovqh tione8 2o(lvx 2ovvfaqtU qattvet
sebosSlyb tannettlfyU nfsifsoqe SlwfsneU qhe (lplyb f2 2o(lvx otteqt oyS ,atlyett otteqtU
oyS Sltiaqet osltlyb fyvx o2qes qhe Seoqh f2 qhe (oqslosnh fs ioqslosnhA me nfytlSes qhsee Wex
SltqlynqlfytA
Private wealth disputes in China and south-east Asia Hpivfse fy GAR
RETURN TO SUMMARY
Vye hevi2av Sltqlynqlfy ly qhe nfyqepq f2 islwoqe geovqh Sltiaqet lt qhe Sl22eseyne ,eqgeey
lyqesyov oyS epqesyov SltiaqetA k (o–fslqx f2 qhe Sltiaqet ly qhe islwoqe geovqh tione ose
lyqesyov SltiaqetL ly fqhes gfsStU qhex nfynesy Sltiaqet glqhly qhe 2o(lvxU fs ,eqgeey qhe
qsatqeetU ,eyernloslet oyS fqhes iosqlet hfvSlyb ifgest onnfsSlyb qf qhe qes(t f2 qhe qsatqtA
0x nfyqsotqU epqesyov Sltiaqet ose qhfte qhoq fnnas ,eqgeey qsatqeet oyS ,eyernlosletU fy
qhe fye hoySU oyS qhlsS iosqlet fy qhe fqhesA ky epo(ive f2 oy epqesyov Sltiaqe lt Credit
Suisse Trust Limited v. Bidzina IvanishviliU[11] ly ghlnh qhe 2fs(es isl(e (lyltqes f2 Fefsblo
nf((eyneS isfneeSlybt ly sevoqlfy qf o SenoSe5vfyb 2soaS iesieqsoqeS ,x o sevoqlfythli
(oyobes f2 qhe Cgltt ,oyW .seSlq Caltte kFA The qes(lyfvfbx 2fs lyqesyov oyS epqesyov
Sltiaqet hot ,eey oSfiqeS ,x os,lqsov lytqlqaqlfyt tanh ot qhe Gyqesyoqlfyov .ho(,es f2
.f((esneA[12]
kyfqhes hevi2av Sltqlynqlfy ly qhe nfyqepq f2 islwoqe geovqh Sltiaqet lt qhe Sl22eseyne
,eqgeey Sltiaqet sebosSlyb 2o(lvx geovqh (oyobe(eyq oyS Sltiaqet ly sevoqlfy qf qhe 2o(lvx
,atlyettA mhlve (oyx 2o(lvx f&net ,ebly ot oy faqbsfgqh f2 o 2o(lvx ,atlyettU qhe fiql(ov
vfyb5qes( tqsoqebx 2fs (ftq geovqhx 2o(lvlet lt qf teiosoqe (oyobe(eyq f2 qhe 2o(lvx geovqh
2sf( qhe (oyobe(eyq f2 lqt ,atlyettA[13] k geovqh (oyobe(eyq eyqlqx noy teswe qhe 2o(lvx ly
goxt qhoq bf ,exfyS qhe 2o(lvx ,atlyett )oyS ly goxt qhoq ose Sl&navq qf –atql2x ot ,atlyett
epieytetIU tanh ot 2o(lvx eSanoqlfy oyS lywetq(eyq ivoyylybA[14]
The votq hevi2av Sltqlynqlfy lt qf senfbylte qhoq 2o(lvx otteqt 2ovv ,sfoSvx lyqf qgf noqebfslet8
hosS oyS tf2qA NosS otteqt (ox qoWe qhe 2fs( f2 seov etqoqe oyS qhe isl(osx 2o(lvx ,atlyettOt
vebov eyqlqxA Cf2q otteqtU fy qhe fqhes hoySU noiqase lywetq(eyqt oyS fqhes vlualS otteqtA
Thlt lt o hevi2av Sltqlynqlfy ,enoate ktloy 2o(lvx yfs(t Sf yfq yenettoslvx Sltqlybalth
,eqgeey fgyesthliU oyS oaqhfslqx oyS nfyqsfvA Fl2qt 2sf( o 2o(lvxOt ioqslosnh fs (oqslosnh
qf tannettlwe beyesoqlfyt ly qhe 2fs( f2 hosS otteqt (ox nossx 2os (fse tlbylrnoyne qhoy
bl2qt ly qhe 2fs( f2 tf2q otteqtA
mhoqewes qhe SltiaqeU qhe 2onq se(olyt qhoq qhe isfvl2esoqlfy oyS setfvaqlfy f2 Sltiaqet ly
qhete oseot 2one nf((fy isf,ve(tA Mfs lytqoyneU nf((fy lttaet nfyyenqeS glqh qhe oseo
f2 tannettlfy ivoyylyb oseU rstqU gheqhes qhe yepq beyesoqlfy lt tannett2avvx tlqaoqeS qf fgy
oyS nfyqsfv qhe 2o(lvx ,atlyettL tenfySU lSeyql2xlyb qhe vfyb5qes( f,–enqlwet f2 qhe ,atlyettL
oyS qhlsSU oSSsettlyb 2o(lvx Sxyo(lnt oyS nfyjlnqt ghey qsoytlqlfylyb qfgosSt o (fse
tqsanqaseS oiisfonh qf bfwesyoyneA Gq lt iesqlyeyq qf yfqe qhoq NPmGt ly tfaqh5eotq ktloy
ose (fse nfynesyeS o,faq qhete Sltiaqet qhoy qhfte ly fqhes seblfytA[15] Thete isf,ve(t
oslte ghese o vosbe ya(,es f2 ,eye2onqfst 2one tqsabbvet qf SlwlSe otteqt 2olsvx ghlve fqhest
glth 2fs (fse oSeuaoqe Sltnattlfy f2 lyheslqoyne ivoytA[16] Vye ovtf noyyfq Sltnfayq qhe
l(ionq f2 vl2e eweyqt tanh ot Sewevfilyb oyS nhoyblyb yeeSt oyS ise2eseynetU l((lbsoqlfy
oyS SlwfsnetA
Vy qhe fqhes hoySU nf((fy qhfabh qhete isf,ve(t (ox ,eU qhete (osWeqtU tlqaoqeS glqhly
qhels setienqlwe (olyvoyS .hlyeteU Nfyb QfybU Clyboifse oyS GySfyetloy vebov sebl(etU (ox
seualse iosqlnavos txtqe(ln oyS lySlwlSaov tfvaqlfytA me 2fvvfglyb ose o 2eg Wex rySlybt
nhosonqesltlyb qhe islwoqe geovqh tioneA
D Gq hot ,eey seifsqeS qhoq fwes /6 ies neyq f2 (olyvoyS .hlyete islwoqe nf(ioylet
ose 2o(lvx fgyeSA[17] Mo(lvx ,atlyettet Sltisfifsqlfyoqevx nfyqsl,aqe tlbylrnoyqvx qf
qhe nfayqsxOt yoqlfyov bsftt Sf(etqln isfSanq oyS e(ivfx o tlbylrnoyq isfifsqlfy f2
qhe .hlyete ifiavoqlfyA Gq lt qhese2fse yf tasislte qhoq qhe ,asbefylyb f2 (olyvoyS
.hlyete geovqh nfssevoqet glqh qhe lynseotlyb yeeSt teq faq o,fweA
Private wealth disputes in China and south-east Asia Hpivfse fy GAR
RETURN TO SUMMARY
D Gy Nfyb QfybU lq got seifsqeS qhoq qhe (osWeq epiesleyneS o Senvlye ly otteqt aySes
(oyobe(eyq ly 1611 oyS 161KA[18] Thlt got faq f2 vlye glqh bsfgqh epiesleyneS ly
fqhes –asltSlnqlfyt ,aq seneyq seifsqt lySlnoqe qhoq qhe qseyS (ox ,e sewestlybA[19] Nfyb
Qfyb ia,vlnvx oyyfayneS ly 161K o qosbeq f2 oqqsonqlyb oq veotq 166 yeg 2o(lvx f&net
,x 161EA[20]
D Gy ClyboifseU 966 tlybve 2o(lvx f&net gese ogosSeS qop lyneyqlwet ly 1616A Thlt
bseg (fse qhoy 2fas2fvS qf cU-E6 ot oq kabatq 1619A[21] Thlt bsfgqh hot yfq xeq
,eey (oqnheS ,x oyx fqhes ktloy –asltSlnqlfyA The oqqsonqlweyett f2 Clyboifse ot o
–asltSlnqlfy tqe(t 2sf( lqt iseSlnqo,ve sebl(eU enftxtqe( f2 geovqh (oyobest oyS
teswlne isfwlSest ot gevv ot o hlbh uaovlqx f2 vl2eA[22]
Vye thfavS ovtf yfq 2fsbeq qhoq qhe .hlyete vebov txtqe(U fy qhe fye hoySU oyS qhe Nfyb
Qfyb oyS Clyboifseoy vebov txtqe(tU fy qhe fqhesU qsone qhels sffqt qf Sl22eseyq tfasnetA
The .hlyete vebov txtqe( lt sui generis oyS SewevfieS Sf(etqlnovvx ghlve qhfte f2 Nfyb
Qfyb oyS Clyboifse those o nf((fy hltqfsx glqh qhe Hybvlth nf((fy vogA ky e(,ve(oqln
epo(ive f2 qhlt Sl22eseyneU ly qhe nfyqepq f2 islwoqe geovqhU lt qhe 2onq qhoq (olyvoyS .hlyo hot
fyvx seneyqvx isfbsetteS 2sf( o txtqe( ghese isfiesqx got fgyeS elqhes nfvvenqlwevx fs ,x
qhe tqoqe qfgosSt fye ghese tanh slbhqt )lynvaSlyb lySlwlSaov isfiesqx slbhqtI ose nfSlreSA[23]
Gy fqhes gfsStU qhe islwoqe geovqh (osWeqt ly .hlyo oyS tfaqh5eotq ktlo ose fy Sl22eseyq
qso–enqfslet oyS qhese (ox ,e yf fye5tl•e5rqt5ovv oiisfonhA
ARBITRATION IN PRIVATE WEALTH DISPUTES
Gq lt obolytq qhe ,onWbsfayS teq faq o,fwe qhoq qhe ate f2 ovqesyoqlwe Sltiaqe setfvaqlfy
(eqhfSt 2fs setfvwlyb lyqesyov islwoqe geovqh Sltiaqet hot ,enf(e lynseotlybvx ifiavosU ly
iosqlnavos os,lqsoqlfyA Thoq tolSU lq thfavS ,e yfqeS qhoq os,lqsoqlfy atlyb o (olyvoyS .hlyete
teoq se(olyt sevoqlwevx yotneyq ot nf(ioseS glqh o Nfyb Qfyb fs Clyboifse teoqA[24]
The oqqsonqlweyett f2 os,lqsoqlfy ly qhe islwoqe geovqh tione lt Se(fytqsoqeS ,x qhe 2onq qhoqU
tlyne - Pfwe(,es 16c/U qhe Gyqesyoqlfyov .ho(,es f2 .f((esne hot ia,vltheS o ,etifWe
oyS aiSoqeS os,lqsoqlfy nvoate 2fs lyqesyov qsatq SltiaqetA[25] The onnf(ioyxlyb epivoyoqfsx
yfqet oSSsett (oqqest qhoq oslte iosqlnavosvx ly lyqesyov qsatq SltiaqetU tanh ot f,teswoqlfyt
oyS nvoatet ise5e(iqlyb qhe yoqase f2 qhe Sltiaqe )gheqhes lq lt ,eqgeey ,eyernlosx oyS
qsatqeeU fs ,eqgeey qsatqeetU fs ,eqgeey ,eyernlosletI ot gevv ot qhe ifqeyqlov eyqlqve(eyqt
f2 (lyfsU ay,fsy fs ayotnesqolyeS ,eyernlosletA
Thlt lySlnoqlfy lt ,onWeS ai ,x tewesov tfasnet f2 SoqoA Mfvvfglyb qhe Gyqesyoqlfyov .faynlv
2fs .f((esnlov ks,lqsoqlfy .fybsett hevS ly CxSyex ly 16c/U lq got oyyfayneS qhoq ovqhfabh
epqesyov qsatq Sltiaqet howe vfyb ,eey ta,–enq qf os,lqsoqlfy oq yoqlfyov oyS lyqesyoqlfyov
vewevtU seneyq xeost howe teey oy lynseotlyb lyqesetq ly lyqesyov qsatq os,lqsoqlfyA[26] knnfsSlyb
qf qhe :.hlyo 7slwoqe meovqh ;eifsq 161KO lttaeS ,x .hlyo Resnhoyqt 0oyW oyS 0oly .oilqovU
(fse qhoy 46 ies neyq f2 qhe .hlyete NPmGt taswexeS howe ovseoSx tqosqeS iseioslyb 2fs
geovqh lyheslqoyneU glqh (fse qhoy E6 ies neyq nfytlSeslyb atlyb 2o(lvx qsatqtA kyfqhes tqosW
epo(ive lt qhe glSevx seifsqeS lyqesyov qsatq Sltiaqe ,eqgeey (e(,est f2 GySloOt QQ RfSl
2o(lvxA[27]
The oqqsonqlweyett f2 os,lqsoqlfy qf Sltiaqoyqt ly lyqesyov islwoqe geovqh Sltiaqet lt f,wlfatA
dyvlWe Sltiaqet setfvweS ly vlqlboqlfyU Sltiaqet setfvweS wlo os,lqsoqlfy ose Weiq nfyrSeyqlovA Gq
gfavS ,e Sl&navq qf howe nfasq isfneeSlybt ly Nfyb Qfyb oyS Clyboifse teoveS tfvevx fy qhe
Private wealth disputes in China and south-east Asia Hpivfse fy GAR
RETURN TO SUMMARY
,otlt qhoq qhe Sltiaqe nfynesyeS ly2fs(oqlfy qhoq got e(,ossottlyb fs ifteS nf((esnlov
sltWt qf qhe iosqletA
.fyrSeyqlovlqx lt l(ifsqoyq qf Sltiaqoyqt ly islwoqe geovqh SltiaqetA k heoslyb ly islwoqe lt
lywovao,ve qf NPmGt ot qhexU qhels 2o(lvlet fs qhels nhlvSsey (ox 2one teslfat seiesnattlfyt l2
qhels lSeyqlqlet ose (oSe ia,vln )fs ia,vlnlteSI oyS l2 qhe ia,vln Wyfgt hfg geovqhx qhex oseA
Vye sltW lt WlSyoiilybU seneyq epo(ivet f2 ghlnh lynvaSe qhe o,Sanqlfyt f2 movqes QgfW[28]
oyS ?lnqfs Bl T•os QaflA[29] Gy Vnqf,es 1619U lq got seifsqeS qhoq o Rovoxtloy 2o(lvx hoS iolS o
soytf( f2 16 (lvvlfy slybblq qf tenase o ,atlyett(oyOt seveote 2sf( o bsfai f2 WlSyoiiestA5
[30] Gy qhlt sebosSU lq lt hevi2av qf yfqe qhoq os,lqsoqlfyt ly (olyvoyS .hlyoU[31] Nfyb Qfyb[32]
oyS Clyboifse[33] ose beyesovvx nfyrSeyqlov ly yoqaseA
ks,lqsoqlfyU hfgewesU lt yfq qhe tlvwes ,avveq qf lyqesyov islwoqe geovqh SltiaqetU 2fs tewesov
seotfytA
MlstqU nfyrSeyqlovlqx lt yfq baosoyqeeS oyS (ox ta,teuaeyqvx ,e vftqA Vye tqosW epo(ive
lt qhe Volpi teslet f2 notetU vlqlboqeS ly qhe nfasqt f2 qhe 0oho(otA[34] kyfqhes epo(ive f2
nfyrSeyqlovlqx ly os,lqsoqlfy ,elyb vftqU qhfabh yfq ly qhe qsatq nfyqepqU lt Republic of India v.
Deutsche Telekom AGA[35] These lt qhese2fse ovgoxt qhe sltW qhoq qhe Seqolvt f2 oy lyqesyov qsatq
Sltiaqe gfavS ,e (oSe ia,vln oyS qhlt sltW noyyfq ,e saveS faq lySerylqevx tl(ivx ,enoate
qhe iosqlet fiq qf os,lqsoqeA
CenfySU os,lqsoqlfy isl(oslvx se(olyt o 2fs(ovlteS oweyae f2 Sltiaqe setfvaqlfy qhsfabh
qhe oiivlnoqlfy f2U o(fyb fqhes txtqe(t f2 vogU qhe iosqletO nhftey bfwesylyb vogA Vye
thfavS ,e nose2av yfq qf iseta(e qhoq qhlt (fSe f2 Sltiaqe setfvaqlfy lt oy lSeov 2fsa( qf
setfvwe lyqesyov islwoqe geovqh SltiaqetA Gq hot tewesov thfsqnf(lybtA Mfs lytqoyneU 2sf( qhe
iestienqlwe f2 .f((fygeovqh islynlivetU fye Wex eve(eyq lt isff2 f2 lyqeyqlfy f2 qhe iosqletA
ky e(ihotlt fy o teosnh 2fs tanh o qhlyb (ox isfwe qf ,e o glvS bffte nhote ,enoateU 2sf(
oy ktloy iestienqlweU qhese gfavS vlWevx ,e oy lynvlyoqlfy qfgosSt o tfsq f2 2o(lvx5fsleyqeS
nfvvenqlwlt(U ghlnh noy ,e Sl&navq qf isfweA[36] Thlt Sl&navqx lt nf(ifaySeS ,x qhe 2onq
qhoq lyqesyov Sltiaqet f2qey oslte ghey qhe ioqslosnh fs (oqslosnh SletU nf(ifaySlyb qhe
Sl&navqlet f2 isff2 f2 oyx tanh lyqeyqlfyA[37]
kyfqhes thfsqnf(lyb lt qhoq qhe oiivlnoqlfy f2 hosS .f((fygeovqh vebov islynlivet (ox
ovvfg yf veegox 2fs nseoqlwe tfvaqlfytA Vye epo(ive f2 qhlt lt Kho Choon Keng v. Lian Keng
Enterprises Pte LtdA[38] Gy qhlt noteU qhe ioqslosnh ve2q qf hlt nhlvSsey -6 nf(ioylet ly qhe Bloy
Naoq bsfai f2 nf(ioyletA Mfvvfglyb qhe ioqslosnhOt SeoqhU Sltobsee(eyqt osfte ,eqgeey hlt
nhlvSseyU ghlnh ta,teuaeyqvx veS qf oy oiivlnoqlfy ,x fye f2 hlt tfyt 2fs qhe bsfaiOt avql(oqe
hfvSlyb nf(ioyx qf ,e gfayS aiA
The Clyboifse nfasqU oiivxlyb qhe .f((fygeovqh islynlivet ottfnloqeS glqh
uaotl5iosqyesthlitU (aqaov qsatq oyS nfyrSeyne oyS veblql(oqe epienqoqlfytU epesnlteS lqt
–asltSlnqlfy 2fs qhe avql(oqe hfvSlyb nf(ioyx qf ,e gfayS ai fy qhe ,otlt qhoq lq got –atq
oyS eualqo,ve qf Sf tfA[39] Thlt got o Ssonfyloy fsSesU etienlovvx blwey qhoq qhe nf(ioyx
got tqlvv ryoynlovvx wlo,veA Vye l(ifsqoyq 2onqfs qhoq qhe nfasq hoS sebosS qf got gheqhes
fsSeslyb o ,axfaq f2 fye iosqxOt thoset ,x qhe fqhes gfavS setavq ly o nveoy tivlqA 0oteS fy qhe
nfasqOt ottett(eyq f2 qhe 2onqtU qhlt got yfq ifttl,ve ,enoate (oyx ta,tlSloslet gese yfq
ghfvvx fgyeSA[40] The Clyboifse nfasqOt hoySt gese qhese2fse qleSA mhlve ewesxfye onneiqeS
qhoq nf((esnlovlqx 2owfaseS qhe nfyqlyaeS fiesoqlfy f2 qhe bsfaiU qhe nfasq nfavS yfq howe
2othlfyeS oy oiisfisloqe oyS nf((esnlov se(eSx qhoq got –atq oyS eualqo,ve fqhes qhoy o
glySlyb5aiA
Private wealth disputes in China and south-east Asia Hpivfse fy GAR
RETURN TO SUMMARY
ThlsSU qhe sfve f2 .f((fygeovqh nfasqt ly qhe oS(lyltqsoqlfy f2 qsatqt hot ,eey l(ifsqoyq
qf SoqeA Thex isfwlSe l(ifsqoyq balSoyne oyS isfqenqlfy oyS eyo,ve qsatqeet qf fiesoqe
e22enqlwevxA[41] Thex howe ovtf qxilnovvx ,eey qhe oaqhfslqx qf ghlnh qsatqeet noy vffW 2fs
qhe isfqenqlfy f2 qhe lyqesetqt f2 qhe wavyeso,veU tanh ot ay,fsy nhlvSsey oyS (eyqovvx
lynoionlqoqeS lySlwlSaovtA These ose tewesov epo(ivet f2 qhltA Mfs lytqoyneU ly qhe nfaste
f2 qhe ies2fs(oyne f2 qhe qsatqU lq lt gevv etqo,vltheS aySes Nfyb Qfyb oyS Clyboifse vog
qhoq qsatqeet (ox oiisfonh qhe nfasq 2fs oy fsSes qf teeW ies(lttlfy qf elqhes ,slyb fs
Se2eyS isfneeSlybt ,x fs obolytq qhe qsatqU glqh nftqt qf ,e ,fsye ,x qhe qsatqA kyfqhes
lytqoyne lywfvwet tlqaoqlfyt ghese qhe qsatq SeeS lt tlveyq oyS senfaste qf qhe nfasqOt lyheseyq
–asltSlnqlfy qf lyqesweye lt yenettosxA[42] Gq tqlvv se(olyt qf ,e teey gheqhes os,lqsoqlyb lyqesyov
2o(lvx Sltiaqet setavqt ly e22enqlwe setfvaqlfy oyS qhe beyalye owflSoyne f2 isfqsonqeS 2o(lvx
SltiaqetA
kt o ryov iflyqU lq thfavS ,e iflyqeS faq qhoq islwoqe geovqh Sltiaqet (ox lywfvwe
Sltiaqet nfynesylyb qhe otteqt f2 (ossleS nfaivetA mhlve Slwfsnet ose yfq os,lqso,ve ly
(olyvoyS .hlyoU Clyboifse oyS Nfyb QfybU ise5yaiqlov oyS iftq5yaiqlov obsee(eyqt (ox ,e
senfbylteS oyS blwey e22enq ly nesqoly nlsna(tqoynetA RolyvoyS .hlyo ovseoSx senfbyltet
qhe ey2fsneo,lvlqx f2 ise5yaiqlov oyS iftq5yaiqlov obsee(eyqt tf vfyb ot qhex oSSsett qhe
fgyesthli f2 (oqsl(fylov isfiesqx fyvxA[43]
Gq se(olyt oy ayoytgeseS uaetqlfy gheqhes tanh Sltiaqet ose oyS thfavS ,e os,lqso,veU
qhfabh qhese oiieos qf ,e 2eg ,eyerqt qf iosqletA =lwfsne isfneeSlybt ose ovseoSx yfq
beyesovvx ia,vlnlteS ly (olyvoyS .hlyoU Nfyb Qfyb fs ClyboifseA MasqhesU gheqhes oy
os,lqsoqlfy obsee(eyq glqhly o ise5yaiqlov fs iftq5yaiqlov obsee(eyq qhoq tfvevx oSSsettet
(oqsl(fylov otteqt tqlvv se(olyt ayqetqeS ,x qhe Clyboifse oyS Nfyb Qfyb nfasqtA kyx
txtqe( f2 Sltiaqe setfvaqlfy (atq avql(oqevx teswe qhe yeeSt f2 lqt atest oyS nf((esnlov
os,lqsoqlfyU ot o txtqe( qhoq ewfvweS qf talq qhe yeeSt f2 nf((esnlov iosqletU (lbhq tl(ivx
,e qff rSSvx oyS ayqetqeS 2fs tanh o iasifteA
OTHER DISPUTE RESOLUTION MECHANISMS IN PRIVATE WEALTH DISPUTES
7slwoqe geovqh Sltiaqoyqt howe qasyeS qf fqhes oweyaet qf setfvwe qhels SltiaqetU tanh ot
(eSloqlfy oyS yebfqloqlfyA dyvlWe os,lqsoqlfyU (eSloqlfy oyS yebfqloqlfy ovvfg iosqlet qhe
jepl,lvlqx qf teqqve qhels Sltiaqet atlyb nseoqlwe oiisfonhetA
knnfsSlyb qf qhe :.hlyo 7slwoqe meovqh ;eifsq 161KO lttaeS ,x .hlyo Resnhoyqt 0oyW oyS
0oly .oilqovU qhe qfi rweE 2o(lvx yeeSt f2 .hlyete NPmGt ose 2o(lvx otteq ovvfnoqlfyU
nhlvSseyOt eSanoqlfyU natqf(lteS f22eslybtU lyqesbeyesoqlfyov lyheslqoyne ivoyylybU oyS
(eSlnov oyS heovqh (oyobe(eyq teswlnetA[44] Gy qhlt sebosSU qhese lt 2asqhes teb(eyqoqlfyA
The sltW oiieqlqet ,eqgeey rstq oyS tenfyS beyesoqlfy NPmGt Sl22esU ot xfayb NPmGt howe
hlbhes sltW oiieqlqet ly beyesovA[45] CenfyS beyesoqlfy NPmGt ose ovtf epienqeSvx (fse
nfynesyeS o,faq geovqh lyheslqoyne oyS otteq ovvfnoqlfy qhoy rstq beyesoqlfy NPmGtA[46]
.seoqlwe oiisfonhet howe qhe o,lvlqx qf fwesnf(e thfsqnf(lybtU iesnelweS fs yfqU qhoq setavq
tl(ivx 2sf( oiivxlyb qhe vogA Thex ovtf ovvfg 2fs noqeslyb qf qhe Sl22eseyq yeeSt f2 qhe woslfat
lySlwlSaovt ly o geovqhx (avqlbeyesoqlfyov 2o(lvxA Hwesx 2o(lvx glvv howe Sl22eseyq wlegt oyS
Sl22eseyq wovaetU oyS qhels rtnovU ryoynlov fs nhoslqo,ve bfovt noyyfq ,e otta(eS qf ,e qhe
to(eA Vye 2o(lvxOt geovqh Sltqsl,aqlfy ifvlnx gfavS ovtf vlWevx Sl22es 2sf( qhoq f2 oyfqhesA
Rlssfslyb qhe isf,ve(t 2oneS ,x qhe (olyvoyS .hlyeteU Clyboifse oyS Nfyb Qfyb vebov
sebl(et 2fsethoSfgeS o,fweU qhese lt yf fye5tl•e5rqt5ovv oiisfonhA
NAVIGATING THE FUTURE OF ARBITRATING PRIVATE WEALTH DISPUTES
Private wealth disputes in China and south-east Asia Hpivfse fy GAR
RETURN TO SUMMARY
The (olyvoyS .hlyete bfwesy(eyqOt lyqeyqlfy qf iath 2fs os,lqsoqlfy lt f,wlfatA Mfvvfglyb
o vfyb ieslfS tlyne lqt lylqlov eyonq(eyq ly c$$9U ghey fyvx nft(eqln o(eyS(eyqt gese
e22enqeSU qhe iseteyq bfwesy(eyqOt lyqeyqlfyt ose sejenqeS ,x qhe seneyq tgeeilyb Sso2q f2
isfifteS o(eyS(eyqt qf qhe .hlyete ks,lqsoqlfy BogA[47]
mhlve os,lqsoqlfy ly qhe islwoqe geovqh tenqfs lt ,enf(lyb lynseotlybvx ifiavosU gheqhes lq glvv
qoWe sffq ot qhe Sf(lyoyq 2fs( f2 setfvwlyb Sltiaqet se(olyt qf ,e teeyA The 2fvvfglyb qgf
,sfoS oseot (ox seualse 2asqhes Sewevfi(eyq oyS nvoslrnoqlfyA
MlstqU qhese ose tewesov aysetfvweS isonqlnov lttaet ly sevoqlfy qf qsatq os,lqsoqlfy sevoqlyb
qf os,lqso,lvlqx oyS qhe o,lvlqx qf ,lyS (lyfs oyS ay,fsy ,eyernlosletA MasqhesU ghlve (fse
tqsolbhq2fsgosS nf((esnlov lttaet howe ,eey onneiqeS qf ,e os,lqso,veU qhese se(oly Sfa,qt
ot qf fqhes oseotL 2fs epo(iveU o Sltiaqe iesqolylyb qf o teqqvfsOt (eyqov noionlqx (ox yfq ,e
os,lqso,veA kyfqhes Sltiaqe qhoq (ox yfq os,lqso,ve lt l2 o teqqvfs hoS (oSe o bl2q qf o nhoslqo,ve
iasifte qhoq ta,teuaeyqvx 2olveSU (oWlyb lq yenettosx 2fs qhe cy-près Sfnqslye qf ,e oiivleSA
CenfySU qhe ey2fsneo,lvlqx f2 lyqesl( sevle2t fs ogosSt se(olyt oy l(ifsqoyq 2onqfs 2fs
Sltiaqoyqt ly ,slyblyb ryovlqx qf oyx SltiaqeA kvqhfabh os,lqsoqfst ose e(ifgeseS qf bsoyq
se(eSlet ly qhe 2fs( f2 tienlrn ies2fs(oyneU nhovveybet se(oly ot qf gheqhes tanh ogosSt
noy ,e e22enqlwe fs ey2fsneo,veA[48] Thete isf,ve(t noy otta(e o bseoqes tlbylrnoyne ly qhe
nfyqepq f2 islwoqe geovqh Sltiaqet ghese iosqletO lyqesetqt ose 2seuaeyqvx yfy5ienaylosx ly
yoqaseA
dyqlv qhete isonqlnov lttaet ose gfsWeS faqU islwoqe geovqh Sltiaqoyqt (ox iesnelwe qhe lttaet
nfyyenqeS glqh os,lqsoqlfy qf faqgelbh qhe ,eyerqt f2 os,lqsoqlfy noywotteS o,fwe oyS oy
aySetlso,ve (fSe f2 setfvwlyb qhels SltiaqetA
ENDNOTES
[1] Nlbh yeq gfsqh lySlwlSaovt )NPmGtI ose qxilnovvx SeryeS ot lySlwlSaovt glqh (fse qhoy
dCJc (lvvlfy ly ryoynlov otteqtA
[2] .oibe(lyl ;eteosnh GytqlqaqeU :mfsvS ;eifsq Ceslet 16198
meovqh Royobe(eyqO )mfsvS meovqh ;eifsq 1619IU iA EU oq
hqqit8##gggAnoibe(lylAnf(#lytlbhqt#seteosnh5vl,sosx#gfsvS5geovqh5seifsq#A
[3] mfsvS meovqh ;eifsq 1619U iA /A
[4] lSAU iA ccA
[5] lSAU iA EA
[6] lSAU iiA K1’K9A
[7] Cfaqh5eotq ktlo qsoSlqlfyovvx nfytltqt f2 qhe 2fvvfglyb tqoqet8 Hotq Tl(fsU Rxoy(osU
TholvoySU BoftU ?leqyo(U 7hlvliilyetU RovoxtloU 0sayelU .o(,fSlo oyS ClyboifseA
[8] kt f2 161KU qhese ose 1A6/ (lvvlfy NPmGt ly .hlyo8 tee Nasay ;eteosnh Gytqlqaqe ;eifsqU
oq hqqit8##gggAhasayAyeq#•h5.P#Gy2f#=eqolvYya(_-9Q?VT/P.TP0[ )ly .hlyeteIA
[9] Ml2qx ies neyq f2 tfaqh5eotq ktloOt qfi 2o(lvx ,atlyettet ose ly Clyboifse8 Hsytq z
]fayb oyS dylwestlqx f2 CqAFovveyU :Mo(lvx 0atlyett GySep 161KOU oq hqqit8##gggAexAnf(
#eytb#lytlbhqt#2o(lvx5eyqesislte #2o(lvx5,atlyett5lySepA
Private wealth disputes in China and south-east Asia Hpivfse fy GAR
RETURN TO SUMMARY
[10] ‘aeey Rosx dylwestlqx f2 BfySfy oyS mhlqe z .oteU :161c Gyqesyoqlfyov ks,lqsoqlfy
Caswex8 kSoiqlyb os,lqsoqlfy qf o nhoyblyb gfsvSOU oq hqqit8##gggAu(avAonAaW #os,lqsoqlfy
#(eSlo #os,lqsoqlfy#Sfnt #BVP6K166K45‘R
dB5Gyqesyoqlfyov5ks,lqsoqlfy5Caswex5161cc$mH0AiS2A
[11] 1619 CF.k)GI EA
[12] Gyqesyoqlfyov .ho(,es f2 .f((esneU :G.. ks,lqsoqlfy
.voate 2fs Tsatq =ltiaqet oyS Hpivoyoqfsx PfqeOU oq
hqqit8##lnng,fAfsb#yegt5ia,vlnoqlfyt#os,lqsoqlfy5oSs5savet5oyS5qffvt#lnn5os
,lqsoqlfy5nvoate5qsatq5Sltiaqet5epivoyoqfsx5yfqe#A
[13] RosW Noxyet =oylevv oyS Tf( Rn.avvfabhU Family Wealth Management )mfsvS CnleyqlrnU
1yS HSlqlfyIU oq iA 91cA
[14] l,lSA
[15] .volse NaoybU :Cfaqh5eotq ktlo taies slnh gfssx (fse o,faq
tannettlfy Sltiaqet qhoy fqhes seblfyt8 7fvvOU The Cqsolqt Tl(etU oq
hqqit8##gggAtqsolqtql(etAnf(#,atlyett#tfaqh5eotq5otlo5taies5slnh5gfssx5(fse
5o,faq5tannettlfy5Sltiaqet5qhoy5fqhes5seblfyt5ifvvA
[16] d0CU ReSlo seveoteU :d0C Gywetqfs moqnh8 Gywetqfst ose
ayiseioseS 2fs qhe vosbetq qsoyt2es f2 geovqh ly hltqfsxOU oq
hqqit8##gggAa,tAnf(#bvf,ov#ey#(eSlo#Sltivox5iobe5ySi#ey51611c6c$5lywetqfs5g
oqnhAhq(vA
[17] Cee hqqit8##otloAylWWelAnf(#Cifqvlbhq#.olply#.hlyo5t52o(lvx5say5,atlyettet52one
5tannettlfy5nhovveybet oyS
hqqit8##gggAignAnf(#tb#ey#ia,vlnoqlfyt#2o(lvx5,atlyett5taswexAhq(vA
[18] Q7RF oyS 7slwoqe meovqh Royobe(eyq kttfnloqlfyU :Nfyb Qfyb 7slwoqe
meovqh Royobe(eyq ;eifsq 161KOU oq hqqit8##otteqtAWi(bAnf( #nfyqeyq#So(#Wi(b #ny
#iS2#ey#161K #c6#hfyb5Wfyb5is
lwoqe5geovqh5(oyobe(eyq5seifsq5161KAiS2 A
[19] hqqit8##gggAryegtAotlo#ryoyne#9c-/45islwoqe5,oyWlyb52o(lvx5f&net5hygl5h
fyb5WfybA
[20] l,lSA
[21] hqqit8##gggA(otAbfwAtb#yegt#tieenhet#1619#,alvSlyb5o5tqsfybes5qf(fssfg5552o
(lvx5f&net5ly5fas5jfaslthlyb5geovqh5(oyobe(eyq5voyStnoieA
[22] lSAU oq EA
[23] 7sfiesqx Bog f2 qhe 7efiveOt ;eia,vln f2 .hlyo )c Vnqf,es 1664IA
[24] The rwe (ftq ise2esseS os,lqsov teoqt ose BfySfyU FeyewoU Nfyb QfybU Clyboifse oyS
7osltA
[25] :G.. ks,lqsoqlfy .voate 2fs Tsatq =ltiaqet oyS Hpivoyoqfsx PfqeOU taiso yfqe c1A
[26] :ks,lqsoqlfy f2 Gyqesyov Tsatq =ltiaqet8 The Pepq Msfyqles 2fs Gyqesyoqlfyov .f((esnlov
ks,lqsoqlfyYOU nlqlyb qhe k(eslnoy .fvvebe f2 Tsatq oyS Htqoqe .faytevOt :ks,lqsoqlfy TotW Mfsne
;eifsqO )Ceiqe(,es 166-IA
Private wealth disputes in China and south-east Asia Hpivfse fy GAR
RETURN TO SUMMARY
[27] CeeU 2fs epo(iveU
hqqit8##osloAvogAnfva(,loAeSa#qhe5(aSSx5goqest5f25oyql5os,lqsoqlfy5ly–aynql
fyt5ly5lySlo#A
[28] movqes QgfW got o geovqhx Nfyb Qfyb seov etqoqe SewevfiesA knnfsSlyb qf Mfs,etU qhe
QgfW 2o(lvx hoS oy etql(oqeS yeq gfsqh f2 dCJ96A9 ,lvvlfy ot oq Pfwe(,es 16c4A
[29] ?lnqfs Bl lt o Nfyb Qfyb ,atlyett(oyA Ne lt qhe evSes tfy f2 Bl Qo5ChlybU fye f2 qhe
gfsvSOt slnhetq ,atlyettiestfytA
[30] hqqit8##gggAtqsolqtql(etAnf(#otlo#te5otlo#2o(lvx5ioxt5WlSyoiiest5(fse5qhoy5
-5(lvvlfy5qf5tenase5seveote5f25(ovoxtloy5,atlyett(oyA
[31] .hlyete ks,lqsoqlfy BogA
[32] Nfyb Qfyb ks,lqsoqlfy VsSlyoyne ).oi -6$IU tenqlfyt E oyS c/)cIA
[33] Republic of India v, Deutsche Telekom AG 161K CF.k)GI 9A
[34] Cee 2fs epo(iveU hqqit8##nfasqtA,t #gi5nfyqeyq #aivfoSt #1619 #6c
#?fvil;avlybCa,tqoyqlwe5k
iieov5MlyovAiS2A
[35] 161K CF.k)GI 9A
[36] Trusts and Private Wealth Management ).o(,slSbe dylwestlqx 7settU 1611IU oq iA c19A
[37] l,lSA
[38] 1619 CFN. c$cA
[39] lSAU oq 199A
[40] lSAU oq 19/A
[41] lSAU oq iA cE )BoSx ksSey 3IA
[42] l,lSA
[43] .lwlv .fSe f2 qhe 7efiveOt ;eia,vln f2 .hlyo )seivonlyb qhe 166c Rosslobe BogU ghlnh lt
yf vfybes ly 2fsneIU ksqlnve c6-EA
[44] kwolvo,ve oq hqqit8##gggA,olyAny#iS2t#161Kccc66E6K1E9$$6AiS2U oq iA 1-A
[45] lSAU oq K-A
[46] l,lSA
[47] Mfs o nf((eyqosxU teeU 2fs epo(iveU Qay MoyU :The 161c 7sfifteS k(eyS(eyqt qf qhe
ks,lqsoqlfy Bog f2 .hlyo8 k Peg Hso f2 ks,lqsoqlfyYOU ICC Dispute Resolution BulletinU Gttae KU
1611U oq hqqit8##ioiestAttsyAnf(#tfvK#ioiestAn2(Yo,tqsonqlS_96c-$/EA
[48] Cee Hgoy RnQeySslnW oyS Goly RopgevvU :Cienlrn 7es2fs(oyne ly Gyqesyoqlfyov
ks,lqsoqlfyOU The Chinese Journal of Comparative Law )16cKIU c$EA
Private wealth disputes in China and south-east Asia Hpivfse fy GAR
