Writing Our Bodies PDF Free Download
1 / 504
/504
100%
C/H/4,KC6#/$D
.(2(#"--",2!#(
%&,&'!"(0(2
(2#(2.(
-42/ 54'/-
5-9-'&44&29Q'-!33+!2!!Q
!%&-7!!-!9Q- '-5-
?
/3'4'/-+'4944!,!-43
5-9-'&44&29Q'-!33+!2!!Q
!%&-7!!-!9Q- '-5-
B
*-/7+! %,!-43
5-9-'&44&29Q'-!33+!2!!Q
!%&-7!!-!9Q- '-5-
'8
24N,/ '! &!4/2'3
?N&!4/2'+,/ ',!-4
5-9-'&44&29
?C
24N2'4'-%4/&2!-
80!2'!-!
@N,/ '! &!4/2'3I!!0!2'4!29
224'6!V!4'/-6!26'!7W
!%&-7!!-!9
@C
AN5+4'+'-%5+'3,
5-9-'&44&29
AC
BN!&-/+/%9- 4&!/ 9
5-9-'&44&29
B?
CN'3'+'49R'+'49R!52/ '6!2%!-!
!3+'!-%+!3!9
BE
DN_45 '!3
5-9-'&44&29
D?
EN2'4'+!&!/29
5-9-'&44&29
E>
24N2'4'-%4/&!4/2'++9
-+9:!
FN,/ '! &!4/2'+-+93'3I44!- '-%
4/52/ '!3V!4'/-6!26'!7W
'-5-
FA
GN&43&!4/2'O&43&!4/2'+
-+93'3O
'-5-
G?
?>N2'-'0+!3/$,/ '! &!4/2'3
!%&-7!!-!9
?@>
??N'- '-%!844/&!4/2'++9-+9:!
'-!33+!2!!
?@G
?@N !-4'$9'-%335,04'/-3
!%&-7!!-!9
?AF
?AN-+94'+&!3'344!,!-43
!%&-7!!-!9
?C@
24N2'4'-%4/*!4-
?BN2'4'-%4/*!4- V!4'/-
6!26'!7W
'-5-
?DC
?CN2%5,!-44'6!&!3'344!,!-43
!%&-7!!-!9
?EA
?DN!3!2&'-%4/*!4-
'-!33+!2!!
?F?
?EN&!!3!2&2/!33
'-!33+!2!!
?FF
24N2'4'-%4/!6'3!J
!',%'-!J- !<!4
?FN2'4'-%4/!6'3!V!4'/-6!26'!7W
'-5-
@>C
?GN/7!6'3'-%'3'$$!2!-4$2/, '4'-%
'-5-
@??
@>N!<!4'6!2'4'-%
'-5-
@@B
@?N5+4',/ +'49I/!',%'-!- !,'8
5-9-'&44&29
@A>
@@N5!!2'-%522'4'-%
5-9-'&44&29
@AD
@AN- 2'4'-%I&!!842'4!3*
5-9-'&44&29
@B@
24N2'4'-%4/&!4/2'++9
-+9:! !,'!843
@BN&!4/2'++9-+9:'-% !,'!843
V!4'/-6!26'!7W
5-9-'&44&29
@CC
@CN'3/523!/,,5-'4'!3I/52)/23
'3/523!/,,5-'49
!%&-7!!-!9
@DC
@DN !-4'$9'-%4&!/-4!84/$- !,'
4!84
'-!33+!2!!
@F>
@EN!3!2&-42/ 54'/-3J/22!4'-%
!3!2&0!VW
!%&-7!!-!9
A>A
@FN4'6!- 33'6!/'!
!%&-7!!-!9
A?B
24N2'4'-%4/9-4&!3':!
@GN2'4'-%4/9-4&!3':!V!4'/-
6!26'!7W
'-5-
A@G
A>N544'-%/52/52!3'-/-6!234'/-
'-!33+!2!!
AAG
A?N'3'0+'-29Z3! 5' !+'-!3$/2
-4!%24'-%/52!3I/6'-%,/-%J
J-
!%&-7!!-!9
AC>
A@NI/52!3- / '$$!2!-44&'-%3
$/29/5272'4'-%
!%&-7!!-!9
AE>
AAN'44'/-534'!I&//5'4!44!23
'-!33+!2!!
AEG
24N2'4'-%4/*!-
2%5,!-47'4&!3!2&
ABN2'4'-%4/*!-2%5,!-47'4&
!3!2&V!4'/-6!26'!7W
5-9-'&44&29
AFG
ACN43'3&!/29I/74/-+9:!- 2'4!
$/2'$$!2!-443!3
!%&-7!!-!9
B>E
ADN/7/'-4'-P/5P-/52!3!2&
2'4'-%
'-5-- 5-9-'&44&29
B@>
AEN'- '-%3/52!3I&//3'-%9/523!2&
4!2,3
'-!33+!2!!
BA?
AFN+%/2'4&,3I-6'3'+9&0'-%52
!3!2&- !3
'-!33+!2!!
BBC
AGN&//3'-%2! '+!/52!3
'-!33+!2!!
BD?
B>N&//3'-%2! '+!!/52!3I!
+%3
'-!33+!2!!
BDG
B?N&//3'-%2! '+!!/52!3I4Z
&!*'-%
'-!33+!2!!
BEE
B@N&//3'-%2!+!6-43&/+2+93/52!3
'-!33+!2!!
BFE
K4O4/-HH -COE/4$DD2$C$$E
$,-4M$$4$OE4#/4K4
,#.#(! /, )#-1(!0 + !*, &! --/,% 1, 1%!
-/1&!,#/! &+$+ 4/&1&+$Q2/&*&01,-)!1%!, 6
+ &10)&3! !5-!/&!+!011%!!+1!/,#1%!:/01\6!/4/&1&+$
)00/,,*Q %&)! 1%! ,,( &0 ,/$+&7! /,2+ 0!!*&+$)6
1/ &1&,+)*, !0,#4/&1&+$[4/&1&+$1,0%/!+!5-!/&!+!S
4/&1&+$1,/%!1,/&))6+)67!S4/&1&+$1,06+1%!0&7!S4/&1&+$
1,/$2!S4/&1&+$1,/!*! &1!M/!3&0!M+ /!;!1[!%%-1!/
&+3&1!0&+01/21,/0+ 012 !+101,,+0& !/%,41%,0!*, !0
,# (+,4)! $! ,+01/21&,+ /! 2-!+ ! 4%!+ 4! 1(! ,2/
-%60&), &!0&+1,,2+1Q
+ 1%!&/ &+1/, 21&,+ 1,)#- ) ()1&!C ')#
".),#- #( "),3 ( ,.#DQ 6 +,)2% +
/&!Q,!))!/+,1!1%1](+,4)! $!+ *!+&+$/!+!3!/
&0!*, &! Z1%!6/!)460* !60,*!, 6Z+ 6!1M
0 :!) M 4!`3! ,#1!+ &$+,/! 1%! /,)! ,# 1%! , 6 &+
(+,4)! $! -/, 21&,+^ XFYQ %! ,+0!.2!+! ,# 02%
01/1&,+ &0 +,1 1%1 1%! , 6 !0!0 1, !5&01 21 1%1 4!
,*!1,!-11%!4%&1!M&0$!+ !/! M*)!M)!\, &! -,&+1
,#3&!4 - 1%!+!21/)M,'!1&3!M+ 1%!/!#,/! 21%,/&11&3!
,+!Q +#,/*! 6 1%! 1%!,/!1&) #/*!4,/( ,#)#- )
#(-,).-#)(N
()1&!M,2/:/01\6!/4/&1&+$1!51,,(0!!(01, !*601
1%&0 3&!4 + 1, &+1!//,$1! %,4 )) (+,4)! $!M !3!+
(+,4)! $!1%1-00!0&10!)#,80],'!1&3!M^!*!/$!0,21,#
+ &00%-! 6-/1&2)/0,&)),1&,+Q
11!+ &+$ 1, 1%! , 6 +,1 ,+)6 !,+01/2104%&1! *)!
&0,2/0!21)0,*(!00-!#,/1%!!5-!/&!+!0+ &+0&$%10
1%1 /! ,/+! 6 */$&+)&7! , &!0Q %&0 &0 -/1&2)/)6
/2&)#,/!*-,4!/&+$012 !+13,&!0M0,2/012 !+10,*!
#/,* 3/&!16 ,#($/,2+ 0+ ,2-6 &3!/0!-,0&1&,+0
,#)00M/!M$!+ !/M0!52)&16M+ 0,,+Q!&+3&1!012 !+10
1, -6 11!+1&,+ 1, 1%!&/ -/1&2)/ 460 ,# &+%&1&+$ +
*,3&+$1%/,2$%1%!4,/) M+ 1,,+0& !/%,41%,0!)&3!
/!)&1&!0+,1,+)60%-!%,41%!6/! + 4/&1!21)0,0!/3!
0-,4!/#2)1,,)0#,/+)60&0+ /$2*!+11&,+Q
+ *,*!+14%!+ 1%!20!,#!+!/1&3!%0!,*!
4& !0-/! M &1 &0 *,/! &*-,/1+1 1%+ !3!/ 1, &+0&01 ,+ 1%!
-,4!/ + &+1!$/&16 ,# %2*+ ,$+&1&,+Z%2*+ -/!&0!)6
!20!&1&00&121! 4&1%&+-/1&2)/, 6Q6$!+!/1&+$
,+1!+1 1%/,2$% & !+1&+$ -11!/+0 /,00 )/$! 0!10 ,#
1Z 11%1&0!00! #/!.2!+1)64&1%,21,+0!+1Z!+
+,1,+)6 &0),1!0(+,4)! $!#/,*(+,4)! $!-/, 2!/0
21)0,!)!31!0+,/*1&3!460,#(+,4&+$Q01!%!/0,#
4/&1&+$M4!4+11, ,1%!,--,0&1!+ 9/*012 !+10`,4+
)&3! !5-!/&!+!003&1)&+$/! &!+10#,/ !!-!//!;!1&,++
+)60&0Q
N#(-,).-#)(
HCK HKC$6&661
,#.#(! /, )#-&0 ,/$+&7! /,2+ *',/ $!+/!0 +
*, !0,#4/&1&+$M+ &+01/21,/0/!&+3&1! 1,00&$+1%!,+!0
1%1)&$+4&1%1%!&/4/&1&+$00&$+*!+10Q
%0!1&,+1%1,3!/0*',/$!+/!,/*, !,#4/&1&+$
X#,/ &+01+!M ]/&1&+$ 1, %/! + 5-!/&!+!^ #,20!0 ,+
1%!)&1!/6+//1&3!Y!$&+04&1%+&+1/, 21,/6%-1!/1%1
-/,3& !0 1%!,/!1&) ,3!/3&!4 + &0200!0 1%! /,)! ,# 1%!
, 6&+1%1,+1!51Q1)0,-/,3& !00*-)!012 !+1!0060+
& !0#,/02**1&3!00&$+*!+10Q
%!/!*&+&+$%-1!/0&+1%!0!1&,+#,20,+-/1&2)/
0(&))0+ %&1000,&1! 4&1%1%1*, !,#4/&1&+$M+ 4&))
1%20,+1&+*,/!#,/*1&3!4/&1&+$-/,*-10Q,*!,#1%!0!
-/,*-10/!1&1)! ]/&1!1,!/+M^4%&%/!#!/01,!5!/&0!0
1%120!1%!4/&1&+$-/,!001,%!)-012 !+10$!+!/1!,/4,/(
1%/,2$%& !0Q1%!/0/!1&1)! ],2/2/+,4M^4%&%/!
!5!/&0!0 !0&$+! 1, %!)- 012 !+10 -/1&! 0-!&: 0(&))0Q
%/,2$%,21M4!*&+1&+1%!&*-,/1+!,#11!+ &+$1,1%!
, 6&+1%! !3!),-*!+1,#1%!0!0(&))0+ %&10Q
#(-,).-#)(N
K4O4/-HH -COE/4$DD2$C$$E
$,-4M$$4$OE4#/4K4
-&1&!
0&0$!+ !/! 4,*+,#,),2/#/,*+ &M,2-6
3/&!16,#-,0&1&,+0M0,*!8,/ &+$*!-/&3&)!$!M4%&)!,1%!/0
)!000,Q/,4&+$2-)),3!/1%!4,/) M&+)2 &+$!6%!))!0+
+ &M)),4! *!1,!5-!/&!+!/! &+$+ 4/&1&+$0101%1
,2/+,1,+)6&+ &8!/!+1)+$2$!0[+$)&0%M!+$)&M&+ &M
/!+%M+ !0!)4/!,)
-/! ,*&++1)6+$),-%,+!M :+ *60!)# 0(&+$ !3!+ *,/!
2/$!+1)6[%,4 , 1!% 0,*!,+! 1, )&3! ,*#,/1)6 &+
*2)1&-)!)+$2$!0R,4 ,1!))1%!*1%1(+,4&+$1%!0*!
4,/ &+ &8!/!+1 1,+$2!0 &0 1%! 2)12/) -&1) 1%1 *
-00&+$,+1,1%!*R%!0!/!1%!.2!01&,+01%1/&+$1,1%!
)00/,,*M1,*6012 !+10M+ 1,!3!/6)&+$2&01&11%1*6
, 6-!/#,/*0M,+0&,20)6+ 2+,+0&,20)6M!5-)&&1)6+
&*-)&&1)6Q
!&
* 4%&1!M &0$!+ !/M 01/&$%1M !4&0%M )!\, &!
4,*+Q40/&0! 6,))!$!\! 21! -/!+10&+4!)1%6M
*,01)6 4%&1!M 022/+ 1,4+ &+ )&#,/+& 1%1 40)2 !
#,/&10-2)&0%,,)0Q)),#1%&0*!+140/&0! 4&1%1%!
002*-1&,+1%14,2) $,1,,))!$!M+ ,+!$,11%!/!M
#!)14!))\-/!-/! 1,4/&1!&+1%!$/**/+ $!+/!01%1*6
-/,#!00,/0!5-!1! Q
)4601%,2$%140]$,, 4/&1!/M^!20!$,1$,,
$/ !0+ -,0&1&3!#!! (#/,**61!%!/0Q,4!3!/M*6
X4%&% 4!+1 2+ &$+,0! 2+1&) 40 B>Y *!+1
4/&1&+$ 1,,( *! *2% ),+$!/ 1%+ *6 -!!/0M 21 40
%/,+&-/,/01&+1,/4%,,#1!+%2/+! ,21*6!00601%!
+&$%1 !#,/! 1%!6 4!/! 2!Q + 4%&)! ;2!+1)6 *&*&(!
1%!3,2)/6+ 01/212/!,# !*&4/&1&+$M01/2$$)!
$/!1)6 4&1% /!1&3! 4/&1&+$Q 1 40 ,+)6 ,+! !*!
*$7&+!4/&1!/+ ! &1,/X!#,/!!*!)&//&+Y1%1
/!)&7! % *2%*,/!4,/(1, ,1, !3!),-+,/&$&+)
3,&!+ -,&+1,#3&!4&+*64/&1&+$Q
*)#-#)(&#-2--'(-N
2/1%!/*,/!M 1%1 0*)) 1,4+ 1%1 -/!-/! *! #,/
!*& ]02!00^ )0, &+01&))! &+ *! *+6 2+,+0&,20
&0!0 ,21 /!M!1%+&&16M )00M + %&!3!*!+11%1 `3!
% 1, 2+)!/+ 1%/,2$% /! &+$M )&01!+&+$M + )&3!
!5-!/&!+!Q `3! )0, % 1, )!1 $, ,# + ,0!00&,+ 4&1%
,//!1+!00+ ,+#,/*&16&+#3,/,#3)2&+$*2)1&-)!460
,# (+,4&+$ + ,**2+&1&+$Q 0 )&//&+M 1%&0 *!+0
%3! % 1, !3!),- *,/! +2+! + /&1&)
2+ !/01+ &+$ ,# -,4!/ + 21%,/&16 &+ 0,2/!\0!
4/&1&+$Q
,4 1%1 `* &+ *6 B>0M 01/2$$)! 1, (!!- 2- 4&1% 1%!
-)1#,/*0 + 01/1!$&!0 *+6 ,#,2/ 012 !+10 20! 1, 0!/%
#,/M,+02*!M+ 0%/!&+#,/*1&,+Q%!/&$%10& !,#1%&0
%2*)&+$ !5-!/&!+! &0 1%1 &1 $&3!0 *! 1%! ,--,/12+&16 1,
)!/+#/,**6012 !+10Q00,*!,+!4%,$/!42-),+$0& !
1%!+1!/+!1M%,-!1%11%!/&1&)-!/0-!1&3!0+ ,+1!51
#,/0!/%!+$&+!0+ 0,&)*! &%3! ! 1,1%&0,,(M
04!))0%,41,2+ !/01+ 1%! !*&/!0!/%-/1&!0
1%1 /! !5-!1! &+ ,))!$!M + %!)- 012 !+10 1%&+( !!-)6
,211%!&/,4+/!0!/%%&10+ %,41%!&/0,2/!0+%!)-
&+#,/*1%!&/,4+& !0+ 2+&.2!3,&!004/&1!/0Q
&
04%&1!M&0$!+ !/! M%!1!/,4,*+M*,3!#&/)6!0&)6
1%/,2$%1%!4,/) Q*+,1)!\, &! M21*6 &0&)&1&!0
/!&+3&0&)!+ ,+,18!1*!,#1!+Q6#*&)6%0 !!-
%&01,/6 4&1% 1%! *&)&1/6M 4&1% #1%!/M 2+)!0M +
$/+ #1%!/0 0!/3&+$ 0 ,9!/0 + :$%1&+$ )) 1%! *',/
N*)#-#)(&#-2--'(-
*!/&+4/0Q%&02-/&+$&+$*!+10-!+1*6%&) %,,
)&3&+$,++3)0!0+ &++3)%,20&+$&+4&&M%, !
0)+ M &/$&+&M + )&#,/+& )) !#,/! 1%! $! ,# CQ
11!+ ! 1%/!! &8!/!+1(&+ !/$/1!+0&+1%/!! &8!/!+1011!0
4&1%&+,+!6!/Q/,4&+$2-4&1%0,*2%*,3!*!+1!/)6
,+/!1! #,/*1&3!M-!/0,+))&1!/6/&0&0Q%!+*,3!
1,*60!,+ (&+ !/$/1!+M4%&%4,2) 11!+ #,/A*,+1%0
&+&/$&+&M1%!1!%!/0$/!4,+!/+! 1%1,2) +,1/! M
!3!+ 1%,2$% *6 -/!3&,20 (&+ !/$/1!+ 1!%!/0 &+ %, !
0)+ % +,,+!/+0Q6*,*/!)&7! % 1,)!/+1,/!
2/&+$1%! 1%/!!\ 6*,3!/,001%! ,2+1/61, +&!$,M
)&#,/+&M4%!/!4,2) :+&0%(&+ !/$/1!+Q, & Q
+ 01&)) #!!) 1%1 /,00\,2+1/6 *,3! &+ *6 , 6Q 1
&+)2 ! *+& 01,- 1 / & /0 + + &1%6 0! ,#
%&(!+-,5Q %&0 !*, &! !5-!/&!+! 8!10 *6 /!0!/%
1, 6Q+0-&/! 61%&0#,/*1&3!)&1!/6/&0&0M+,420!*6
2)12/)-&1)0-/,#!00,/1,/!0!/%)&1!/6 !3!),-*!+1
*,+$ 012 !+10 ,+ 1%! #/&+$!0 ,# 1%! 2+&3!/0&16 + 1, 20!
.2)&11&3! *!1%, 0 1, $&3! 3,&! 1, 1%! 3,&!)!00M 1,
&0!*-,4!/! $/,2-0 4%, %3! !!+ 0&)!+! 6 %&$%!/
! 21&,+0601!*0Q
!&
* %&+!0! &0$!+ !/ %!1!/,0!52) 4,*+ 4%, 40
,/+&+%&+M$/!42-&+&+$-,/!M+ &**&$/1! 1,1%!
#,/ ,))!$!Q :/01 )!/+! 1, 0-!( +$)&0% 1 :3! 6!/0
,) 4%!+*6#*&)6*,3! 1,&+$-,/!M+ #,/*+66!/0M
!3!+#1!/--!/! 1,! ,+3!/0+1&+ +$)&0%M1%,2$%1
*)#-#)(&#-2--'(-N
&+ + /&+ %&+!0! + 1%!+ &+1!/+))6 1/+0)1! *6
]%&+!0!^1%,2$%10&+1,+$)&0%4,/ 0Q%!+*!1,1%!
&+,))!$!M $/!4 !-1 1 , !04&1%&+$M04&1%&+$ ,21
*6&+$-,/!+!+1#,/+*!/&+\0,2+ &+$,+!Q+1%!
)00/,,*M *6 /&)&7! , 6 + +,+\+1&3! 1,+$2! %3!
0,*!1&*!0!01/+$! *!#/,*,1%!/)00*1!0M+ !/)6,+&+
*6/!!/0-/,#!00,/M1%!0!&+;!1&,+0%3!)0,2+ !/*&+!
*6 &)&16 1, -/,'!1 21%,/&16M 0 012 !+10 ,21! *6
!5-!/1&0! 2!1,%,4-/!0!+1! 06,2+$M+,+\4%&1!-!/0,+Q
%!0! !5-!/&!+!0 %3! 21!)6 0%-! *6 0!+0! ,#
)+$2$
K4O4/-HH -COE/4$DD2$C$$E
$,-4M$$4$OE4#/4K4
%!,+1!+10,#1%&0,,(4!/! !3!),-! 2+ !/$/+1#/,*
1%!2+ #,/1%!*-/,3!*!+1 ,#,010!,+ /6 21&,+M
XYM QQ !-/1*!+1 ,# 21&,+Q ,4!3!/M 1%,0!
,+1!+10 , +,1 +!!00/&)6 /!-/!0!+1 1%! -,)&6 ,# 1%!
!-/1*!+1 ,# 21&,+M + 6,2 0%,2) +,1 002*!
!+ ,/0!*!+1 6 1%! ! !/) ,3!/+*!+1Q ,/ *,/!
&+#,/*1&,+ ,21 #,/ ,&) 201&!M 3&0&1 ,2/ -/,'!1
4!0&1!Q
!4,2) )0,)&(!1,1%+(*!*!/0,#1%!/&1&+$12 &!0
/,$/*M 9)&1! #2)16M 012 !+10 4%,0! 4,/( %0 &+0-&/!
1%&0,,(M)&//60184%,-/,3& ! &+3)2)!02--,/1+
/!0,2/!0M,2/ #!)),4 &+1 /6`0 ,))!$! 1!*0M +
-/1+!/ 0%,,)0Q %&0 %0 !!+ 1/2)6 ,)),/1&3! -/,'!1M
+ 4!%,-! 1%1/&1&+$ 12 &!0&+01/21,/0M 012 !+10M +
1%,0!&+1!/!01! &+%,4,2/, &!0&+1!/0!14&1%,2/)&1!/6
',2/+!604&)),+1&+2!1,,+1/&21!1,1%!,,(Q
%!,3!/&*$!#,/1%!,,(&06,%+&+#/,*&56Q
&#&'/$%&,
01%! ,**2+&16,#&+1 /6`0 ,))!$!,#)&#,/+&M
4! (+,4)! $!4! /! $1%!/! ,+ 1%! !1%+,%&01,/&1/&)
%()0&!'(-N
1!//&1,/6 ,# 1%! &+1!/*//&! )+T).2&+ X%)\
(!!+YT2%&2+ X%,,\%,,+YT +!01/) 24!(* 6
&4,(+ %),+!!//&1,/6Q
%!-/!0!+1\ 624!(*%),+!/&!M4&1%+!+/,))!
2/!2 ,# + &+ 8&/0 ,2*!+1! *!*!/0%&- ,# ,3!/
D>>M&0,*-/&0! ,#)),#1%!(+,4+02/3&3&+$+ &+)&+!$!0
,/&$&+)1, 1%!+ /+&0,6/!$&,+Q %!61/!1%!&/
/&!`0+!01/61%/,2$%1%!*&00&,+&71&,+-,)&&!0 !-),6!
61%!1%,)&%2/% &+,++!1&,+1,&00&,+0 ,),/!0M
+ ,0!M + +1 )/M 2/&+$ 1%! !5-+0&,+ ,# 1%!
&0-+,\2/,-!+*-&/!&+1,)1)&#,/+&!$&++&+$&+
?EDGQ%!&/24!(*#*&)&!0/!1%!02!00,/0+ )&3&+$
*!*!/0 ,# 1%! 0,3!/!&$+M -/!3&,20)6 ! !/))6 !,$+&7!
!/,++ ,#)*! ,2+16M+,4#,/*))6/!,$+&7! 0
1%!24!(*%),+!/&!,# 1%!+ /+&0,6 /!
4%,4,2) )&(!6,21,(+,41%11%!6/!)&3!+ 1%/&3&+$
*!*!/0,#1%!/, !/6/!,**2+&1&!01, 6Q
%!24!(*%),+!+ &+#*&)&!0%3!+!3!/)!#11%!&/
,/&$&+)+!01/)%,*!)+ 0,#1%!6/!+ *&+1&+
1%!&/ & !+1&16M 1/ &1&,+0M 2)12/! + )+$2$! 1%/,2$% 1%!
1!+&16M 01/!+$1% + )!$6 ,# 1%!&/ +!01,/0 + !) !/0Q
, 6M 1%!6 11!*-1 1, /!-&/ 1%! 0201&+! !,),$&)M
!+3&/,+*!+1)M + 2)12/) !3011&,+ 1, 1%!&/ /&!
4/,2$%1 6 ,3!/ @CB 6!/0 ,# ,),+&) -/,!00!0 ,#
&0!+#/+%&0!*!+1 1%/,2$% 1%! -,)&1&0 ,# !/02/!Q %!&/
-/&,/&1&!0/!*,3! #,/4/ 1%/,2$%1%/!!!01)&0%! !+1&1&!0L
1%! 24!(* %),+! /&) ,2+&)M 24!(* %,),+!
N%()0&!'(-
/&!M +Q + 1%! 24!(* %),+! /!0!/31&,+
,2+ 1&,+Q
%!6 /!0-!1#2))6 /!.2!01 1%1 1%! $,, &1&7!+0 ,# &+1
/6`0 ,))!$! + 1%! ,4+ ,# ,/$M + 02//,2+ &+$
1,4+001/&3!1,!#&1%#2)01!4/ 0,+!%)#,#1%!24!(*
%),+!/&!6*&+1&+&+$1%!6M#/!0%41!//!!(0M+1&3!
-)+10M+&*)%&110M+ 1%!&/4!))/!1%!Q!/!,$+&7!
1%1 1%! ! ))! /,1%!/0 ,# &+1 /6`0 ,))!$! +
1%!0))&+*&)6%3!4,/(! 1,0!/3!%,+,/)60$,,
01!4/ 0,#1%&0)+ 0&+!&10-2/%0!&+?G@DQ
%()0&!'(-N
N%()0&!'(-
')#,"-),#N
N')#,"-),#
7;
K4O4/-HH -CO
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H !;-!!,/ '! 2&!4/2'33/-!04
H - !234- &/7'42!+4!34/2! '-%-
72'4'-%
$(4/4,36#/$#-$H6C/ D
%1 ,!0 &1 *!+ 1, 4/&1! 0 -!/0,+ )&3&+$ &+ , 6R
,"-),#&')#'(-N
*, &! /%!1,/& 0(0 6,2 1, 1%&+( ,21 1%! ,++!1&,+
!14!!+4/&1&+$+ 1%!)&3! !5-!/&!+!0,#6,2/0+ ,1%!/0`
, &!0Q 1 1(!0 &+1, ,2+1 1%1 !% ,# 20 ,*!0 #/,*
&8!/!+1 2)12/)M )&+$2&01&M /&)M $!+ !/! M + !,+,*&
& !+1&16-,0&1&,+0M+ 1%1))1%!0!!)!*!+101,$!1%!/*(!
2-%,44!4/&1!+ 1%&+(,214/&1&+$Q
,/ ,2/ -2/-,0!0M !*, &! /%!1,/& + ! !:+! 0
#,)),40L
-002/&4/72'4'-%4&4,*!36'3'+!4&!
54&/2^3' !-4'49- +'6! !80!2'!-!N&!
/-4!84$/24&!72'44!-0'!!J7&!4&!2'4'34/
3&2!-!80!2'!-!J4*!34- J-+9:!
2&!4/2'+3'454'/-J/22!6'3!- 2!,'8J
2!02!3!-437&!2!4&!54&/2/,!3$2/,N44&!
3,!4',!J!,/ '! 2&!4/2'+3/4*!3'-4/
/5-44&!54&/2^32!+4'/-3&'04/4&!2! !2J
/4&2!+- ',%'-! J3'43*3534/3!!
72'4'-%3-'-4!20!23/-+02/!33N,/ '!
2&!4/2'4&53,*!32//,$/2 '$$!2!-4J/$4!-
/-<'4'-%J/0'-'/-3J+-%5%!3J!80!2'!-!3J
349+!3/$+!2-'-%J- 0/3'4'/-3N42!/2'!-43/52
4&'-*'-%/5472'4'-%4/6'!7!+!,!-4335&3
349+!- +2'49-/435-'6!23+' !+35424&!2
302/ 543/$/52/7-/ '!3- 4&!'2
N,"-),#&')#'(-
,/6!,!-43'-4&!7/2+ N
#6,2/!&+1!/!01! &+)!/+&+$*,/!,211%!1%!,/!1&)
#/*!4,/(1%12+ !/-&+01%&0,,(M6,2,2) /! *,/!
,21&1&+%/&01&+Q! &)),`0-&!!M]%1,!01!+
1,,3!RL!M&0&)&16M+ /&1&)*, &*!+1
! $,$6Q^
E84><A:#GBJA
&!3!2!4&!*!94*!793$/2!,/ '! 2&!4/2'
34&!/2!4'+- 024'+002/&4/72'4'-%
H 2'4'-%'3+793 /-!93/,!/ 9
H -/7+! %!'3+79302/ 5! 93/,!/ 9
H &43/,!/ 92'-%34/4&!'272'4'-%4&!'2
0&93'+J!,/4'/-+J- 3/'+!80!2'!-!3
H ++30!43/$72'4'-%J'-+5 '-%2%5,!-4J
349+!J- ,!&-'32!<!44&!3!!80!2'!-!3
H '-!4&!2!'3-/5-'6!23+/2-/2,4'6!/ 9J
,"-),#&')#'(-N
4&!2!'3-/5-'6!23+/2[425!\*-/7+! %!
H ','+2+9J4&!2!'3-/5-'6!23+/2/-!/22!4
794/72'4!
$$/4,H-$-$6COH6C1
,41%16,2%3!/! 1%! !0/&-1&,+,#!*, &! /%!1,/&M
)!1`0 0!! &1 1 4,/(Q %! #,)),4&+$ -/$/-% &0 #/,* 1%!
&+1/, 21&,+ 1,)#- ) ()1&!C ')# ".),#- #(
"),3(,.#Q1&04/&11!+6,+!,#1%!,\! &1,/0,#
1%!,,(M6+,)2%Q06,2/! 1%!-/$/-%M1%&+(
,21 %,4 1%! 21%,/ &0 /&+$&+$ 1%!&/ , 6 1, 1%! 1 ,#
4/&1&+$Q,4/!1%!64/&1&+$0-!/0,+)&3&+$+ *,3&+$
1%/,2$%1%&04,/) R
9
-3/,-9793J,/6!4&2/5%&4&!7/2+
!3'+9N^,7&'4!'3%!- !27/,-7&/'3
02!35,! &!4!2/- '3V,/34+9W+!Z/ '! N^,
,/2!7!+/,!'-,-930!34&-,-9/4&!23
N,"-),#&')#'(-
2!J- -002/8',4!4&!!,/ '!
!80!44'/-3'-793,-9/4&!23-^4N54
!'-%$47/,-22'!3'43/7-
'-4!2/--!4! '335!3N3-6'%4!7/2+ -/4
, !7'4&,!'-,'- J^,6!2972!/$&/7
,9/ 94*!35030!- &/72!30/- 4/
4&!!80!44'/-3/$/ '!3J!30!'++97/,!-^3
/ '!3J'-05+'N&!-!-4!230!J-^4
,*!,93!+$3,++!6!-'$7-44/J- 3/,!
93 /7-44/N4&!2 93J2!++9 /-^4N&'3
053&- 05++/$7-4'-%4/;4'-V/4&+'4!2++9
- ;%524'6!+9W- 7-4'-%4/!,2!4&!
!8!3353!3,!4/%26'44!4/72 7/2*4&4
</73/6!24&/3!/5- 2'!3J!,2'-%4&4
7&'&'3/$4!-!80!4! 4/!!8'3! N
V-/+5&- /!++!2J[-42/ 54'/-J\?AWN
KHH/4,H-$-$6CO/4H6C H/ $
3&+$ 0!!+ %,4 ,1%!/0 /! 1%&+(&+$ ,21 !*, &!
/%!1,/&M +,4 12/+ 1%! )!+0 ,+1, 6,2/0!)#Q 0 6,2 -!/#,/*
1%! #,)),4&+$ !5!/&0!M )0, 1%&+( ,21 %,4 *+6 & !+1&16
-,0&1&,+0 6,2 ,2-6M + 1%! *+6 460 &+ 4%&% 1%!6
&+1!/0!1Q
,"-),#&')#'(-N
#AI<G4G<BAGB0E<G8
*!$2!3&0'!!/$00!2J/2/0!-50-!7
/5,!-4N'6!9/523!+$;6!,'-54!3V34244',!2W
4/2!30/- 4/4&!$/++/7'-%15!34'/-N
H 2'4! /7-/-!79'-7&'&9/52' !-4'49
$$!439/5272'4'-%N/52!7!+/,!4/
'-4!202!4[' !-4'49\- [72'4'-%\&/7!6!29/5
7-4N
',,'&+,*-,'*+:
*, &! /%!1,/&0#,/*01%!1%!,/!1&)(,+!,#1%&0
,,(Q0-! $,$&)01/1!$6M1%!21%,/0,#1%&0,,(4,2)
)&(!1, /!,**!+ /!3&0&1&+$1%&0 ,+!-14%&)!&+1/, 2&+$
0!1&,+0T00&$+*!+10 1, 012 !+10Q 2% + --/,%M 4!
!)&!3!M4&))%!)-012 !+10 !3!),- !!-!/2+ !/01+ &+$,#
!*, &! /%!1,/&0M4%&)!)!/+&+$%,41,0&121!1%!&//! &+$
+ 4/&1&+$-/1&!04&1%&+1%!&/)&3! !5-!/&!+!00-%60&)
!&+$0 *,3&+$ 1%/,2$% 1%! 4,/) Q , %!)- !+,2/$! 02%
/!&1!/1&3! 20! ,# 1%&0 ,,(M )&+( 1, 1%&0 1%!,/!1&)
N,"-),#&')#'(-
&+1/, 21&,+ %0 !!+ &+)2 ! &+ 1%! :/01 0!1&,+ ,# !%
%-1!/Q
Works Cited
! '++/J&2'34'-N[&4/!34!-4/
/6!OI!J'3'+'49J- 2'4'+
,/ ',!-4! %/%9N\-/,0/3'4'/-
/25,J6/+NAGN33/'4'/-/$!&!23/$
6-! /,0/3'4'/-J@>?FN
-/+5&JN9- 2'!N/!++!2J
/ '!3/$-/7+! %!I,/ '! &!4/2'3'-
&!/29- 24'!J
/+/2 /I4&44!
-'6!23'492!33J@>@@N
,"-),#&')#'(-N
N,"-),#&')#'(-
0,#-#(!-)",(1*,#(N
N0,#-#(!-)",(1*,#(
J;
!
9
:
$,-4M$$4$O
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'33!4'/-/-72'4'-%4/3&2!-
!80!2'!-!J9/57'++!+!4/
H 2'4!+'4!29-224'6!4&42'4'++92!<!43
/-9/52,5+4'0+!' !-4'4'!3'-2!+4'/-4/
2! '-%- R/272'4'-%
')#,"-),#*,&#-,2(,,-#/
-#)()/,/#0N
!6'3'4I&4'3,/ '! &!4/2'3O
!#,/!4!!$&+M-)!0!/!;!1,+6,2/)&1!/6%&01,/6&+?>>
4,/ 0,/*,/!Q
&<G8E46LA4EE4G<I8E8W86G<BA
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`ADM&C0Z?
&1!/6 +//1&3!0 + -/,3! 20!#2) #,/ ,))!$! 012 !+10 1,
4/&1!#,/0!3!/)/!0,+0Q+3!/6-/1&))!3!)M+//1&3!0/!
16-!,#4/&1&+$+ 0-!(&+$1%1/!0,%2*+1%11%!6/!
N')#,"-),#*,&#-,2(,,-#/
-#)()/,/#0
20! &+)*,01!3!/6 &0&-)&+!,/*',/,+*-20Q!0-!(
&++//1&3!04%!+!5-)&+&+$,2/0!)3!0M,+ 21&+$4,/(&+
),/1,/6M ,*-)!1&+$ -/,'!10M ,/ 0%/&+$ !5-!/&!+!0 &+
&+1!/+0%&-0Q1`0)0,&+1!$/)1,*+6 &0&-)&+!0)&(!%&01,/6M
4%!/! +//1&3!0 ,# -01 !3!+10 /! ,+01/21! 1%/,2$%
,))!1&,+0,#-/&*/60,2/!0Q
0& !#/,*1%!3!/6-/1&)M)&1!/6+//1&3!0)0,,8!/
,))!$! 012 !+10 1%! ,--,/12+&16 1, /!;!1 ,+ + /&1&))6
!5*&+!1%!&/-01!5-!/&!+!04&1%/! &+$+ 4/&1&+$0,0
1, '2011%!&/2//!+1& !+1&1&!0+ /!)1&,+0%&-01,)&1!/6Q
,44!& !+1</! !/0+ 4/&1!/0&+1%!-018!1020
0/! !/0+ 4/&1!/0&+1,1%!#212/!Q,4!3!/M6/&1&))6
!5*&+&+$%,4& !+1&1&!0#,&01! 2-,+20,/!*/! 620
8!1,2//!)1&,+0%&-04&1%)&1!/6M4!+ '201,2/)&1!/1!
& !+1&1&!0Q
!/! 4! + !!-!+ ,2/ 2+ !/01+ &+$ ,# ,2/ )&1!/6
!5-!/&!+!0 6 )0, &+1!$/1&+$ !*, &*!+1 &+1, ,2/
,+0& !/1&,+Q 0 4! /!*!*!/ #/,* %-1!/ ?M 4! /! ))
!*, &! M04!%3!, 6Q+ 1%1, 6&0,++!1! 1,
&8!/!+1 -)!0M 1&*!0M+ 2)12/!0Q 0 /!02)1M 1%! -/,!00
,#,/&!+1&+$,2/, &!0&+0-!+ *,+$,1%!/0/!1!0,2/
!5-!/&!+!0 + (+,4)! $!Q ,4 4! *(! *!+&+$ ,# ,2/
4,/) 0&0!*, &! 0&1&00! &+1%!)&3! !5-!/&!+!0,#,2/
-01+ -/!0!+1M,#,2/, 6+!$,1&1&+$0-!*,+$,1%!/0
X,!))!/+ +,)2%YQ
,M %,4 ,!0 1%! ,+!-1 ,# &+1!/0!1&,+) & !+1&1&!0 +
)&3! !5-!/&!+!0 #/,* ,2/ !*, &*!+1 ,++!1 1, )&1!/6
')#,"-),#*,&#-,2(,,-#/
-#)()/,/#0N
+//1&3!0R $,, !5*-)! + ! #,2+ &+ 1%! )&1!/6
+//1&3!6M-2)&0%! &+.3&/-Q+]//6&+$1%!!&$%1
,#1&,+L %!1,/6,# 21!*)+,6M^1!))0 1%!
01,/6 ,# %&0 !5-!/&!+!Q &0 01,/6 !$&+0 4&1% &92)1&!0 &+
(&+ !/$/1!+ 4&1% *2)1&)&+$2)&0*M 0 %! 0-,(! -+&0% 1
%,*! 4&1% %&0 #*&)6 #/,* 21!*)Q #!4 6!/0 #1!/
%))!+$&+$%&*0!)#1,)!/++$)&0%M%&0-/1*!+140/& !
6 -,)&!M + %&0 #1%!/M 4%, ,2) +,1 .2&/! )!$)
--!/4,/(1,*(!%&0&**&$/1&,+)!$)M40 !-,/1! Q&0
40`0&$$!0102--,/1!/4%!+&1*!1,%&0! 21&,+M
0,),0&+$%&*11%&06,2+$$!8!1! + `0)&1!/6
! 21&,+ !!-)6Q
%&0!5*-)!-/,3& !0$)&*-0!&+1,%,4)&3! !5-!/&!+!0M
,2/ !*, &! !5-!/&!+!0M 8!1 ,2/ )&1!/&!0Q `0 , 6
,/&!+1! &+0-!+ &+/!)1&,+1,,1%!/0L%&0 M1%!,9!/0M
1%!1!%!/0&+0%,,)Q+ 1%!0!/!)1&,+0&+1!/0!14&1%/!M
$!+ !/M+ )00Q,*!012 !+10 ,+,10%/!1%!!5-!/&!+!,#
),0&+$-/!+11,&**&$/1&,+,9!/0,/%3!1,4,//6,21
&1Q%&0&0`0)&3! !5-!/&!+!Q1!/&+%&0)&1!/6+//1&3!M
%! !$&+0 1, ),0! %&0 & !+1&16 0 &0-+& 012 !+1M 0 %&0
;2!+6&++$)&0%!$&+01,02--)+1%&0;2!+6&+-+&0%Q
04!))M%&0! 21&,+/!02)10&+ %&0!&+$)!)! 0 ]4%&1!\
40%! ^6%&0,4+#*&)6Q%!0!!5-!/&!+!0/!2+&.2!1,
+ /!)0,0%/! *,+$,1%!/012 !+10*,3&+$1%/,2$%
1%!&/,4+)&1!/1!!5-!/&!+!0Q
+1%&0&+1/, 21&,+1,1%!%-1!/,+4/&1&+$1,0%/!,2/
!5-!/&!+!0M 4! &+3&1! 6,2 1, /! 0,*! 0*-)! )&1!/6
N')#,"-),#*,&#-,2(,,-#/
-#)()/,/#0
+//1&3!0 #/,* ,1%!/ &+1 /6`0 ,))!$! 012 !+10M /!;!1
,+6,2/,4+!5-!/&!+!0 1,!$&+ 6,2/ 4/&1&+$',2/+!6Q!
%3!)0,&+)2 ! 0,*!&+3&11&,+01,4/&1!0%/! 64/&1&+$
-/,#!00,/01&+1/6`0,))!$!Q
GH78AGJE<G<A:
!7/5+ +'*!4/'-+5 !345 !-472'4'-%'-4&'3
3!4'/-N$9/52!'-4!2!34! '-05+'3&'-%9/52
7/2*J0+!3!;++/544&'3$/2,- 35,'40'!!/$
9/5272'4'-%$2/,9/5272'4'-%+33N!7'++7/2*
7'4&9/54/%!4'405+'3&! N
!2!2!3/,!+'4!29-224'6!372'44!-9
345 !-43- 05+'3&! 4/4&!25-'6!23'4'!3N!
4&'-*9/5^++;- 4&!3!,!-4/24!84353!$5+I
H /-34254'-%/,,5-'49I-!24&'-%3!3
/$!04-!T!7U9'&/+326!9
V2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7UW
H 5+4',/ ++'4!29-224'6!I[-!--/7
/5+ 0!*'*!4I!6!+/0'-%'4!29
'-94'6!'+!4\9&+/!9+/2
')#,"-),#*,&#-,2(,,-#/
-#)()/,/#0N
V2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7UW
H 5+4',/ ++'4!29-224'6!I[&!7/Z
/-! /52-!9/$'+'-%5+\9,-4/&'
V2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7UW
H !84Z3! -224'6!I&!5452!/$&'3
,'+9I&!4/29/$/9$2/,/-!+9
/5-4'-T!7U92+/3+6--4/3
V2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7UW
H !84Z3! -224'6!I229'-%4&!!'%&4/$
4'/-I&!4/29/$54!,+-/9
T!7U9V2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7
UW
#1!//! &+$,+!M,/*,/!M,#1%!0*-)!)&1!/6+//1&3!0M
1(! 0,*! 1&*! 1, /!;!1 ,+ %,4 6,2 ,++!1 1, 1%!&/
!5-!/&!+!0&+1%!0-!!),4&+?>>4,/ 0,/*,/!Q
N')#,"-),#*,&#-,2(,,-#/
-#)()/,/#0
,8W86G<A:BABHE?<I878KC8E<8A68F
4A7<78AG<G<8F
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`ADM&C0Z@
,41%16,2%3!% 0,*!1&*!1,/! !5*-)!0+ 1%&+(
,216,2/,4+!5-!/&!+!0M4!&+3&1!6,21,4/&1!*,/!
!51!+0&3!)6,216,2/)&1!/1!!5-!/&!+!0Q
')#,"-),#*,&#-,2(,,-#/
-#)()/,/#0N
#AI<G4G<BAFGBJE<G8&<G8E46L(4EE4G<I8
FF<:A@8AG*EB@CGF
-;86;4CG8EF<AG;<FF86G<BAF;BH?7CE8C4E8LBH
9BE6B@C?8G<A:BA8B9G;8F8FH@@4G<I8JE<G<A:
4FF<:A@8AGF-;8F88K4@C?8F4E84FF<:A@8AGF
G;4GJ8E86B@@8A7
11'%,+$,26 +.*$
!<!450/-9/52/7-/ '+9!80!2'!-!3
2! !2J72'4!2J/2+-%5%!+!2-!2- ' !-4'$9/-!
!80!2'!-!/2!6!-47&!2!4&!72!-!33/$9/52
0&93'+/ 90+9! *!92/+!'-9/52 !6!+/0'-%
+'4!29/544&!!84!-4/$4&!02'6'+!%! R
5-02'6'+!%! 0/3'4'/-9/5&/+ '-/527/2+ N- /'-%
3/J/-3' !24&!5+452++9!04! '3%!- !2! J
,+!J7&'4!J- +!Z/ '! 0/'-4/$6'!7- 9/52
/7-/ 9^30/3'4'/-7'4&'-4&'3 /,'--4 '3/523!N
&4 ' 9/5+!2-- &/7O&4',04&3'4
& /-9/52+'$!O
11'%,+$,26 +.*$
!'%*$
N')#,"-),#*,&#-,2(,,-#/
-#)()/,/#0
!,'- 05+'72'4'-%/$4!-2!15'2!4&47!
53!-224'6!4/,*!-2%5,!-4N!-224!+
2!0/243'-3'!-!V+4&/5%&'-5-'15!79WN!
-224!&'34/2'+J3/'+J- 5+452+!6!-43'-,-9
3/'+3'!-! '3'0+'-!3+'*!3/'/+/%9J&'34/29J-
/,,5-'4'/-N/5+ *!!0%/'-%N/24&'3;234
!339J7!7'++%!4024'!53'-%-224'6!34//+
$/23&2'-%/52+'4!24!!80!2'!-!3N!7'++;234
2!<!4/-/52!80!2'!-!3J30/-3/23J- +-%5%!3N
94*'-%4&'34',!4/2!<!4/-/52+'4!29&'34/29J
7!-!44!25- !234- &/7/52+'4!29&3!!-
3&0! 9,-9$4/23J'-+5 '-%&/,!
+-%5%!V3WJ+33J2!J%!- !2J%!/%20&9J'+'49J
*%2/5- 3J- ,/2!N
(!
&!0520/3!/$+'4!29-224'6!'34/5- !234-
&/79/52034+'4!29!80!2'!-!33&0!9/52
522!-4+'4!2'!394!++'-%34/29/549/52
+'4!29&'34/29- -+9:'-%4&!3'%-';-!/$4&!
34/29N/24&'372'4'-%02/)!4J72'4!-224'6!'-
7&'&9/5 !32'!-!6!-4/2!80!2'!-!4&4&
3'%-';-4',04/-9/532! !2/272'4!2N&!
-224'6!3&/5+ !A$5++0%!3/2,/2!N
&!2!^3-//-!4/-!- 349+!$/2+'4!29-224'6!I
4&!9-!3!2'/53J$5--9J'-$/2,+J$/2,+J0/!4'J
')#,"-),#*,&#-,2(,,-#/
-#)()/,/#0N
-%29J/2!+!24/29N-3&/24J9/5-53!+-%5%!Q
++/$'4N'-++9J7!7'+++3/!2! '-%4!8434&4
'-6'4!9/54/4&'-*2'4'++9/54/ !,!3&'-%N
!-/52%!9/54// !,!3&'-4&'3!339'$4&4
3!!,3&!+0$5+4/9/5- 9/5272'4'-%N
Works Cited
N[229'-%4&!!'%&4/$4'/-I&!
4/29/$54!,+-/9N\
49+53N
??
V?WN
&4403IRR&N5$N! 5R72'4'-%2&!4/2'R349+53R
'335!3R??Z@R229'-%Z4&!Z7!'%&4Z/$ZZ-4'/-Z
4&!Z34/29Z/$ZZ%54!,+-Z/9R
/!++!2J2'!NJ- N9-/+5&N[?N
-42/ 54'/-I/ '!3J,/ ',!-43J-
,/ '! &!4/2'3N\
/ '!3/$-/7+! %!I
,/ '! &!4/2'3'-&!/29- 24'!
N
4&44!-'6!23'492!33J@>@@N00NAZ@>N
N')#,"-),#*,&#-,2(,,-#/
-#)()/,/#0
I;
K4O4/-HH -CO
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H !;-!,5+4'+'-%5+'3,
H - !234- - !802!33'-72'4'-%4&!
2!+4'/-3&'0!47!!-+-%5%!- 0/7!2
H - !234- - !802!33'-72'4'-%&/7
+-%5%!'3!,/ '! 9'- '6' 5+3
$(4/4,K2H/2/4,K2/D3
2)1&)&+$2)&0* &0 1%! &)&16 1, 20! &8!/!+1 )+$2$!0 ,/
'.&-#&#(!.&#'N
&)!10 &+ ,2/ !3!/6 6 )&3!0Q %&)! *!/&+ !*&
4/&1&+$,+3!+1&,+0-/&3&)!$!+$)&0%M*,01,#201!+ 1,!&1%!/
+,120!1%!0!,+3!+1&,+0,210& !1%! !*&!006,/20!
3/&!16,# &8!/!+1)+$2$!04%!+,**2+&1&+$4&1%!%
,1%!/Q %! )&+$2&01& %,&!0 1%1 4! *(! !-!+ ,+ ,2/
0,&)M2)12/)M/&)M+ $!+ !/($/,2+ 0Q
6#$$D-/4,
'%+ !&&00,&,\)&+$2&01&,+!-11%1+#))2+ !/
1%!/, !/%! &+$,#*2)1&)&+$2)&0*Q%&0*!+01%!&)&16
1,*,3!!14!!+ &8!/!+1)&+$2&01&+ $/**1&)0601!*0M
,#1!+&+1%!,2/0!,#0&+$)!,+3!/01&,+Q
BAF<78EG;89B??BJ<A:
?N 2'3$/24&!+/6!+9%'$4LV0-'3&_-%+'3&W
@N 2!7!%/'-%&!:4,#2!4/ 9OV-%+'3&_
2!-&W
AN /52!352!4&'3'3/*9$/29/5-/OV- '-
-%+'3&W
N'.&-#&#(!.&#'
%1 ,6,2+,1&!,211%!!5*-)!0R5*-)!0?+ @*&5
&8!/!+1 )+$2$!0M 4%&)! !5*-)! A 20!0 )) +$)&0% 4,/ 0M
21 1%! $/**1&) 06+15 &0 1%1 ,# + &+ +$)&0% 4%&%
*&5!0+$)&0%4&1%+ &)+$2$!002%0!+$)&+ &+ &Q
!,-)! 4&)) ,#1!+ , ! 04&1% ,/ , ! *!0% 1, /!00
-/1&2)/2 &!+!M1, &02000-!&:1,-&M1,!5-/!00,+!`0
$/,2- & !+1&16M ,/ 1, :)) )!5&) $-Q , ! *!0%&+$ &0
-!/#,/*! 6*2)1&)&+$2) 0-!(!/0 + 4/&1!/0M 21 )0,6
1%,0!4%,04&1%!14!!+ &)!10+ 3!/+2)/04&1%&+1%!
0*!)+$2$!Q+1%&0)&+(! 3& !,M!/0%4+0%+1&,2+$M
)! &+$ 0%,)/ ,# #/&+ *!/&+ +$)&0% + , !
*!0%&+$M !0/&!0 1%! ,+!-1 + 1%! -,4!/ 6+*&0
&+3,)3! &+ *,3&+$ !14!!+ )+$2$!0 X41% #/,* 1%! C?
*&+21!*/(1&))?%,2/?*&+21!*/(YQ
4,K,$4#6M$C
!4/&1!+ 0-!(00,&)&+ &3& 2)0!+$$&+$4&1%0-!&:
,+1!510 + 4&1% -/1&2)/ !+ 0 &+ *&+ Q ! /&+$ 1%!
3/&,20 )&+$2&01& 0601!*0 1%1 4! !*, 6 1, ,2/ )+$2$!
-!/#,/*+!0Q,4!3!/M1%&0 ,!0+,1*!+1%1)))+$2$!0
+ &)!10 /!$&3!+1%!0*! -/&3&)!$!1 )) 1&*!0Q! /!
*,01)6,+ &1&,+! 1,1%&+(1%1!/1&+)+$2$!0/!*,/!
]-/,-!/^,/]!11!/^1%+,1%!/0M+ %!+!4!1!+ 1,4/ 0
1%!* &+ 0,*! 0,&) 0!11&+$0 02% 0 &+ 1%! )00/,,*M 1
&+1!/3&!40M + &+ ',0Q %1 *&$%1 1%! 0,&) 0!11&+$0
*!+1&,+! %!/!%3!&+,**,+R
'.&-#&#(!.&#'N
1+ / *!/&++$)&0%XYM#,/!5*-)!M&0-!/!&3!
1, ! 1%! +,/*1&3! 46 ,# 0-!(&+$ + 4/&1&+$ &+ #,/*)
0!11&+$0 !20! &1 &0 ,+0& !/! ]+!21/)Q^ ,4!3!/M
/!*!*!/1%11%&0-!/!-1&,+M1,,M&00,&),+01/21Q%&0
*!+0 1%1 1%! & ! ,# 4%1 &0 01+ / ,/ +!21/) &0 +,1
+12/))6 ,2//&+$ -%!+,*!+,+M 21 /1%!/ /!02)1 ,#
!&0&,+0* !6$/,2-0&+-,4!/%,,0&+$1,&*-,0!1%!&/
#,/*,#)+$2$!01%!+,/*Q
36#/$#C/H/4,
%!0! 0-!10 ,# *2)1&)&+$2)&0* /!3!) 4/&11!+
,**2+&1&,+1,!1%!-/, 21,#+!*, &! &+ &3& 2)Q
! /&+$ ,2/ 3/&,20 )&+$2&01& !5-!/&!+!0M 9+&16 $/,2-0M
3,&!0M+ & !+1&1&!01,,2/4/&1&+$Q,*!,#1%!0!4!/&+$
0 ,+0&,20 %,&!0M 4%&)! ,1%!/0 0%,4 2- 02,+0&,20)6M
,/ !3!+ &+ 0-&1! ,# ,2/ &+1!+1&,+0Q ,/ ,2/ -2/-,0!0M &1 &0
&*-,/1+1 1, (!!- &+ *&+ 1%1 4! )) &+%&1 *2)1&-)!
)+$2$!0+ )&+$2&01&0601!*0Q!4/&1!0, &!0)&3&+$&+
1%!-%60&)4,/) M+ ,2/4/&1&+$/!;!101%&0/!)&16Q
N'.&-#&#(!.&#'
,8W86GBA@H?G<?<A:H4?<F@
54'4'-4/024'!L
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`AFM&C0ZA
8!2'3! 04! $2/,54&'3/-- /22'3^[!3&
4J^++\V9BN>W
Works Cited
54&'3/-J2!--&J- -%!+/22'3J[!3&
4J^++I2/,/4'-%/ !Z!3&'-%&2/5%&
'.&-#&#(!.&#'N
2'4'-%!-4!2/2*3&/03J\
&!!!2!6'!7
J
335!BN@I!3!2&'-%- !34/2'-%534'!J
545,-@>@>N
/5-%J!23&7-3&-4'N[7J!42'%&4I
-2%5,!-4%'-34/ !7'4&'-%N\
2'4'-%/542'4'-%
N+':!4&2 +!-
/5%/7-3J 3N/34/-JI! $/2 R4N
24'-^3J?BFZ?E>N
N'.&-#&#(!.&#'
+;
K4O4/-HH -CO
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H - !234- - !802!33'-72'4'-%4&!
2!+4'/-3&'0!47!!-4&!/ 9- 4&!
4!&-/+/%953! 4/2! - 72'4!
H - !234- - !802!33'-72'4'-%&/7/52
!334/4!&-/+/%9'33/'++9,! '4!
/H$C O"$ -4626,O"4#-$/C
-"()&)!2(-")2N
$2H/64D-/8H6H-$6#O
&1!/6&0 )460 1!%+,),$&)!5-!/&!+!M ! &1 /! &+$
-/&+1! ,,(,/ &$&1)-$!M4/&1&+$4&1%-!+,+--!/,/
16-&+$,+(!6,/ Q,/,2/-2/-,0!0M1!%+,),$6/!#!/01,
1%!1+$&)!+ &+1+$&)!1,,)0+ 21!+0&)04!20!1,&+1!/1
4&1% &8!/!+1 #,/*0 ,# )&1!/6Q %&0 &+1!/1&,+ )460
%--!+01%/,2$%1%!*! &2*,#,2/, &!0M)1%,2$%,#1!+
4!/!1,) 1,1%&+(,#)&1!/60!),+$&+$0,)!)61,1%!)&#!
,# 1%!*&+ M ,/ 1, 4,/) ,# 1%,2$%10Q +1%&0 %-1!/M 4!
4&)),+0& !/#!4!5*-)!0,#%,4,2/, &!0*! &1!,2/
/!)1&,+0%&-1,1!%+,),$6M!#,/!-!/#,/*&+$#!4!5!/&0!0
1%1!*-%0&7!1%&0/!)1&,+0%&-Q
0 01/1&+$ -,&+1M 1%&+( ,21 4%!/! 6,2 /! ),1!
-%60&))606,2/!/! &+$1%&0%-1!/Q,4&06,2/, 6
-,0&1&,+! 3&0\\3&01%!0/!!+,+4%&%6,2/!/! &+$R/!
6,2%!/&+$1%&0%-1!/,+0/!!+/! !/R%1&06,2/, 6
,&+$ 0 6,2 *(! 0!+0! ,# 4%1 &0 !&+$ -/!0!+1! 1, 6,2
%!/!R ,4 ,+02)1 +6 +,1!0 6,2 *&$%1 %3! 1(!+ 2/&+$
1%! /! &+$ -/,!00Q ,4 ,!0 6,2/ , 6 4/&1!R )) 1%!0!
.2!01&,+0 0%,2) 01/1 1, *(! 6,2 4/! ,# %,4 4! *,3!
1%/,2$%1%!4,/) 0, &!0M!3!+4%!+4!/!*,010,/!
0*&+ 0Q
N-"()&)!2(-")2
*8E9BE@G;89B??BJ<A:8K8E6<F8
3*9/52-!'%&/2/544&!'22! '-%- 72'4'-%
024'!3J- -/4! /7-4&!'2-37!23N/4! /7-
!4'+335&3&/74&!9,/6!4&!'2/ '!334&!9
2! N3'4 '$$!2!-4$2/,7&44&!9 /7&!-4&!9
72'4!O&!2! /4&!94!- 4/!+/4! 0&93'++9
7&!-4&!9 /&/,!7/2*$/23&//+J$/2!8,0+!O-
02'64!/205+'30!O
/7&//3!-930!4/$7&44&!93' 4&4'3
6!29 '$$!2!-4$2/,9/52024'!J3+/-%3'4'3
!'4&!2024'+/20/33'+!$/29/52/ 9N$'4
'-6/+6!32! '-%J2! 4&'3&04!24&479N$'4
'-6/+6!372'4'-%J72'4! /7-9/522!30/-3!34&4
79N6'-%&/3!-4&'330!4J-37!24&!
$/++/7'-%15!34'/-3I
?N &4734&!'%%!34&++!-%!'-
0!2$/2,'-%4&'3!8!2'3!O
@N /7 ' ,/6'-%9/52/ 9 '$$!2!-4+9$$!4
&/79/52! /272/4!O
-"()&)!2(-")2N
0E<G<A:4A7G86;AB?B:L
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`B>M&C0ZB
$ -4626,O4##$4H/HO
06,2,+1&+2!6,2/)&1!/6',2/+!6M1%&+(*,/!,216,2/
0,&)+ -%60&)& !+1&1&!0Q/!1%!0!14, &8!/!+1(&+ 0,#
& !+1&16M4&1%,+!!&+$*,/!,211%!, 61%+1%!,1%!/R
/ /! 1%!6 ),+$ ,+1&+22*R %1 -)!0 + & !0 /!
8,/ ! 1,6,2!20!,#6,2/& !+1&16R%&%/!1%!,+!0
1%1/!4&1%%!) R06,2,+0& !/1%!0!.2!01&,+0M/!*!*!/
1%1 0 4! *,3! &+ 1%! 4,/) 0 !*, &! /!12/!0M
0&$+&:+1-/1,#,2/!5&01!+! !-!+ 0,+%,44!/!X+
N-"()&)!2(-")2
1%&+(4!/!Y0!!+6,1%!/0Q%&0$7!,#,1%!/01%1&0,+20
&+;2!+!0%,4,2/, &!0%+$!&+/!)1&,+1,1!%+,),$6Q
88<A:BHE5B7<8F
/24&'3!8!2'3!J2!/2 ?>Z,'-54!6' !//$
9/523!+$39/52! /'-%3/,!&/,!7/2*4&4
'-6/+6!32! '-%/272'4'-%N&'+!4&'37'++!6!29
'$;5+4J4293$230/33'+!4/$/2%!44&49/52!
!'-%2!/2 ! J- 229/-39/57/5+ 7'4&/54
4&!,!2/-9/5N!6'!74&!$//4%!J-
2!30/- 4/4&!$/++/7'-%15!34'/-3I
?N /77/5+ 9/5 !32'!9/52/ 9'-30!
'-2!+4'/-4/4&!2! '-%R72'4'-%'-3425,!-43O
@N /77/5+ 9/5 !32'!9/52$!39/5
7/2*O
AN &4'34&!!$$!4/$74&'-%9/52/ 9
7/2*'-%+/-%3' !4!&-/+/%9O
-"()&)!2(-")2N
4#C/H/4,
%&)!1%&0%-1!/ ,!0+,1 !)3!&+1,1%!,*-)!5.2!01&,+0
/&0! 6+ &10/!)1&,+0%&-1,4/&1&+$M&1&0&*-,/1+11,
-)!!*, &! 4/&1&+$X1%!(&+ ,#4/&1&+$1%16,2 ,0
-%60&)%2*+!&+$&+1!/1&+$4&1%1!%+,),$6Y+!511,\
$!+!/1! 4/&1&+$1,,+0& !/1%!!1%&)&*-)&1&,+0,#20&+$
&+4/&1&+$Q
-8??<A:LBHEFGBEL
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`B>M&C0ZC
N-"()&)!2(-")2
*;
$D2/$4,2$D$O
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H 8,'-!4&!2!+4'/-3&'0!47!!-4&!'2/ '+9
'+'4'!3- 2! '-%- 72'4'-%
$(4/4,/D/2/HO
$KC6#/L$CD/HO
&0&)&16 012 &!0 ]+)67!0 1%! !8!10 ,# &0&)&16\0!
##&#-2#&#-2(.,)#/,!(N
*/$&+)&71&,+!3!+01%!:!) 3,1!0#,/!5-+ &+$1%!
,+!-1,# &3!/0&161,&+)2 ! &0&)&16^X,)*$!M@>?EM-Q
CYQ#1%!& !,# &0&)&16\0! */$&+)&71&,+&0+!41,6,2M
6,2*6!4,+ !/&+$4%11%&0(&+ ,#*/$&+)&71&,+),,(0
)&(!+ 4%!/!&1,*!0#/,*Q,+04!/1%!0!.2!01&,+0M4!
+!! 1, 1(! .2&( &3! &+1, ,+! ,# 1%! *,01 2&.2&1,20
4,/ 04!20!L+,/*)Q
(BE@4?
%!+4!20!1%!4,/ _+,/*)M`4!/!,#1!+0&$+)&+$1%1
,+ &1&,+0 /! 0 4! !5-!1 1%!* 1, !Q ,+0& !/ 14,
!5-/!00&,+02+&3!/0&1&!0!$+20&+$&+1%!4(!,#1%!$),)
\?G-+ !*&Q!/%-06,2%!/ 0&*&)/*!00$&+$&+
6,2/0%,,)0,/,**2+&1&!011%11&*!Q
?Q %&)!1%!!$&++&+$,#1%!0!*!01!/40,+!$&+
*/(! 6-/!21&,+0M4!%3!+,4!!+)!
1,/,))(*+6,#1%!0!/!01/&1&,+0+ /!,-1&*&01&
,211%!),4-,0&1&3&16/1!&+,2/,**2+&16Q!4&))M
,#,2/0!M,+1&+2!1,*,+&1,/,2/0&121&,++ *(!
%+$!00+!!00/6M21#,/+,4M*-20&001/1&+$1,
#!!))*,01]&'*%$^O01,) 6,2/012 !+10M)1%,2$%
*-20)&#!&00),4)6/,-*&!&,'&'*%$M4!0%,2)
+,1 &0,2+11%!!5!-1&,+)%))!+$!01%14!%3!
#! M+ ,+1&+2!1,#!M 2/&+$1%!-+ !*&QX!+
,#+ !/$/ 21!0,#&!+&3!/0&16M/& $!1,/*+M
N##&#-2#&#-2(.,)#/,!(
]!00$!#/,*!+,/*+M^!*-%0&0 ! Y
@Q ]0)00!0/!0%! 2)! 1,!$&+,+ 6M4!,+1&+2!
1,1()!1%!%+$!0/!.2&/! 1,,-!/1!2+ !/]&/
&'*%$Q^*,+: !+14!/!-/!-/! M$&3!+1%!;2&
0&121&,+M1,-/,3& !1%!1,,)0+ &+01/21&,++!! ! 1,
,*-)!1!1%!-/&+$@>@>0!*!01!/Q(+,4,2/!/(1
,**2+&16&0,*-/&0! ,# ! &1! &+ &3& 2)04%,
4&))/&0!1,1%!%))!+$!0-/!0!+1! 1,20Q^X1%!+\
/!0& !+1,#*,201,+11!+&3!/0&16M+,61M
]!11!/#/,*1%!/!0& !+1M^!*-%0&0 ! Y
%1 ,6,2+,1&!,211%!0!14,!5*-)!0R,1%,#1%!0!
2+&3!/0&16*!00$!0,*!#/,*0&*&)//!$&,+0,#1%!+&1!
11!0 X0,21%!01 !50YM 6!1 1%!6 20! _+,/*)` 1, 0&$+) 14,
&8!/!+1 !0/&-1&,+0,#*-20)&#!Q&!+&3!/0&16&+#,/*0
-/!+10+ #*&)&!0,#012 !+101%1*-20&0&+1%!-/,!00
,# ]/!12/+&+$ 1, +,/*)M^ 4%&% 02$$!010 1%1 !5-!/&!+! ,#
)&3&+$+ )!/+&+$1&!+&3!/0&16-/&,/1,1%!-+ !*&&0
%&!3)!+ &+1%!#,/!0!!)!#212/!M4%&)!*,201,+
11! +&3!/0&16 ,!0 +,1 -/!1!+ 1%&0 0&121&,+ &0 -,00&)!Q
+01! M 1%!6 )!3!) 4&1% 012 !+10M -/,*&0&+$ ,+)6 ]+!4
+,/*)Q^ %&)! /! !/0 /!+`1 $&3!+ !+,2$% &+#,/*1&,+ 1,
(+,4 4%1 1%&0 ]+!4 +,/*)^ &0M 1%! -%/0! 02$$!010 0,*!
,-1&*&0* 1%1 *-20 )&#! 4&)) ),,( 0&*&)/ 1, 4%1 &1 %
!!+!#,/!1%!0-/&+$@>@>0!*!01!/M21&1+1&&-1!01%1
012 !+104&))+,1!5-!/&!+!&1002%+ 11!*-101,-/!-/!
012 !+101,%3!*,/!*!02/! !5-!11&,+0Q
##&#-2#&#-2(.,)#/,!(N
,1% -%/0!0M %,4!3!/M %&$%)&$%1 %,4 1%! ,+!-1 ,#
_+,/*)`4,/(0Q 0 6,2 %3! *!1 + ,++!1! 4&1% -!!/0
,+*-20M6,22+ ,21! )6%3!+,1&! 1%1+,1!3!/6,+!
!5-!/&!+!0 1%! &+1 /6`0 *-20 ,/ ,**2+&16 &+ 1%!
0*!46Q%&)!*+6,#20%3!0&*&)/!5-!/&!+!0X02%0
1(&+$1%!0*!?>?0!1&,+YM4!4&))!5-!/&!+!1%!*
&+ &8!/!+1460Q,44!/!0!!++ %,44!!+$$!&++6
$&3!+0-!&0&+#,/*! 6,2/!*, &*!+1M4%&%4!)!/+!
&+%-1!/?M&0,*-,0! ,#,2/2)12/)M$!+ !/! M)&+$2&01&M
+ /&) & !+1&1&!0M 0 4!)) 0 1%! & !+1&1&!0 4! -/,'!1 X,/
/!&+1!/-/!1! 6,1%!/0Y/!)1! 1,,2/0!52),/&!+11&,+,/
&0&)&1601120Q
&4A:H4:8*BJ8E
%!+4!20!-%/0!)&(!]%!&0T0%!&0T1%!6/!'201+,/*)
$26T$)T+,+\&+/6 -)T%2*+M^ 4! 202))6 /!+`1 &+ 1%!
-/1&! ,# 2+-(&+$ 4%1 1%1 *!+0 + 4%&% %2*+
%/1!/&01&04!,+0& !/1,!+,/*)Q+)!006,2$/!42-
&+,**2+&164%!/!6,2/!$2)/)6&+1!/1! 4&1% &0)!
&+ &3& 2)0M %+!0 /! $,, 1%1 6,2 ,+`1 202))6 20!
]+,/*)^1, !0/&!#/&!+ 4&1%3!/)1&,/)00*1!
4%,+,!%+&+)00Q!!3!+%/1!/&7!1%!-!/0,+X,/1%!&/
!%3&,/Y0_4!&/ M`_ &01/1&+$M`,/_&+--/,-/&1!Q`&0&)&16
012 &!0 0%,)/+6&1%,0(6 ,8!/0 %!)-#2) !5-)+1&,+
#,/ 4%6 4! *&$%1 /!0-,+ 1%! !*, &*!+1 ,# &0&)&16 &+
1%!0!460L],1%&+!3!/6 6)&#!+ &+1%!%2*+0&!+!0M
N##&#-2#&#-2(.,)#/,!(
_+,/*)`,#1!+ --!/0 0 &# &1 &0 011& 011! ,# 8&/0M+
4%!+-!,-)!/!0& 1,%3!+2+4+1! ,+ &1&,+M1%!6*6
! !!*! 1,%3!++,/*)&16^X&1%,0(6M],/*)M^-Q
?A>YQ
#6,2/!&+1!/!01! &+)!/+&+$*,/!,2101&**&+$+
21&0*M 6,2 ,2) /! *,/! ,21 &1 &+ 1%! 21&01& !)#\
3,6!14,/(`0,2121&0*Q
+ ,1%!/ 4,/ 0M 1, ! 0!!+ 0 +,/*) &0 1, ! -/!02*!
1, ! *!*!/ &+ ,**2+&16Q )!\, &! +!00 &0 *,01
,**,+)6 -!/!&3! 1, ! 1%! 01+ / M +,/*) !*, &!
,+:$2/1&,+M)! &+$ 1,+002*-1&,+1%1 &0&)&1&!0+
+!2/, &3!/$!+! /! !3&1&,+0 #/,* ]+,/*)^ , 6 +
*&+ Q,%3!+,/*), 6&01,%3!, 61%1&0+,/*)
+ 1, ! )! 1, *,3! /,2+ 1%! 4,/) X&+1!))!12))6M
-%60&))6M0,&))6M+ ,1%!/4&0!Y4&1%,21+!! &+$00&01+!Q
&0&)&16 1&3&010 ,#1!+ /!#!/ 1, 1%! ,+ &1&,+ ,# )!\
, &! +!000,%('**1$B'!&++!20!*,01Z&#
+,1))Z#,)(04&))!5-!/&!+!16-!0,# &0&)&1&!010,*!-,&+1
&+1%!&/)&3!0Q!/!/!'201#!4!5*-)!0L
K +!! #,/*,&)&16 !3&!X/21%!0M0,,1!/0M!1QY 2!
1,/,(!+)!$Q
K &02)&*-&/*!+10,//!1! 4&1%,+110,/$)00!0Q
K !/&+$ &0&)&1&!01%1!*!/$!+12/))61%/,2$%,21
1%!$&+$-/,!00Q
#6,2/!&+1!/!01! &+)!/+&+$*,/!,211%!)+$2$!20!
##&#-2#&#-2(.,)#/,!(N
6 &0)! 1&3&010 + ,**2+&1&!0M6,2,2) /! *,/!
,21 &1 &+ 1%! 1&,+) &0&)&16 &$%10 !14,/(`0
,**2+&1&+$,21!,-)!4&1%&0&)&1&!0Q
$$/4,H-$-$6COH6C1
!1`0!5-!/&*!+14&1%1%!& !,#+,/*)&16+ %,4&1)! 0
1, &0&)&16\0! */$&+)&71&,+Q 2/ & !+1&1&!0 /!)1! 1,
&0&)&16M +!2/, &3!/$!+!M + ,1%!/ #!10 ,# &3!/0&16 +
!,**2+&1! 1%/,2$%,2/4/&1&+$M!3!+4%!+4!/!+,1
-/!0!+14&1%,2/2 &!+!0O#1%&0&01/2!M4!+)0,002*!
1%1 4/&1!/0` 002*-1&,+0 ,21 1%!&/ /! !/0` !*, &*!+1
*&$%1)0,0%,42-&+%,41%!6,*-,0!Q
!1`01!011%&01%!,/66--)6&+$1%!& !,#+,/*)&161,
,22!3& !,/!1! 61%!!/!/))06,2+ 1&,+Q
+@>?EM :)*/!4#/,* 1%!!/!/) )06,2+ 1&,+
%))!+$! 4/&1!/ + ,*! &+ % ++!/ 1, 1/3!) #/,*
+%11+1,/,,()6+1,$!1#*,20!4,/( !)&6L
/&+,4$!)Q%!+1%20&01&))6!-1! 1%!.2!01+ M&+
%&0%,1!)/,,*M%+ 1%!/!4-)++! 1%!&//,21!20&+$
,,$)! -0Q %!6 )!/+! 1%1 1%! 1/3!) 1&*! 0%,2) !
,21@B*&+21!0),+$Z+!06!+,2$%10(Q
%M %,4!3!/M &0 0(!-1&) 1%1 ,,$)! -0` -/! &1&,+
4&))!/&$%1!20!M03&!4!/0)!/+/1%!/.2&()6M%&0
+,1'201,*! &++ 4/&1!/#,/4/ \4&++&+$0&1,*0Q
! %0 !/!/) -)06M /&+ &0,/ !/ 1%1 &*-10 , &)6
*,3!*!+1M *20)! 1,+!M + -,012/! 20! 6 &+'2/6 1,
N##&#-2#&#-2(.,)#/,!(
-!/0,+`0 /&+ !#,/!M 2/&+$M ,/ #1!/ &/1%Q !/!/) -)06
&*-10!% -!/0,+ &8!/!+1)6Q ,*! %3! *&+,/ -/,)!*0
4&1% *,3!*!+1 + ,,/ &+1&,+ 4%&)! ,1%!/0 X)&(! %Y
%3! *,/! 3&0&)! 0&$+0 ,# QQ %M 0 6,2 4&)) 0!! &+ 1%!
3& !,M&04%!!)%&//& !/Q
#6,24+11,(+,4*,/!,21!/!/)-)06M3&!4%`0
3& !,,+1%!1,-?>)&01,#1%&+$0%!4&0%!0-!,-)!(+!4,21
!/!/)-)06O
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`B@M/!,! Z?
,8W86GBALBHEBJA8@5B7<@8AG
!$/2!9/574&4&!6' !/J2!<!4/-$!7
15!34'/-3I
##&#-2#&#-2(.,)#/,!(N
-/7'-%4&4&'37&!!+&'253!2I
?N /7+/-% /9/54&'-*'47'++4*!&',4/
426!+$2/,-&44-4/2//*+9-6'05+'
42-3'4OV//%+!03393'43&/5+ /-+94*!
@B,'-54!3W
@N &422'!234//4'-'-%&'32'-/7%!+
7'++&$!O
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`B@M&C0ZD
N##&#-2#&#-2(.,)#/,!(
"8E8QF@LE8FCBAF8
,3'-%+!J7&'4!7/,-'-&!2$/24'!3N^6!+'6!
,/34/$,9+'$!'-3552-- 3!,'Z252+
/,,5-'4'!3J- ,522!-4+9+!2-'-%4/-6'%4!
4&!,5&,/2! !-3!+9Z0/05+4! +- 30!/$4&!
92!N&6!-!6!2+'6! '--&44-/2
2//*+9-N30!23/-7'4&'-6'3'+! '3'+'4'!3J4&!
,/2!4'%&4+90/05+4! -2!'3J4&!,/2! '$;5+4
'4'3$/2,!4/-6'%4!N9/- '4'/-3,*!'4&2
$/2,!4/6'35+':!- '-4!202!4304'+'-$/2,4'/-
V+'*!,03WJ2!,!,!23!15!-!3/$34!03V+'*!
'2!4'/-3WJ- ,3!-3'4'6!4/5 '4/2934',5+'
V+'*!2&/2-3J,5+4'0+!/-6!234'/-3'-3,++
30!3J+2,3- !++3J /%2*'-%J- ,/2!WN
80/352!4/4//,-95 '4/2934',5+'$/24//+/-%
7'++,*!'4 '$;5+4$/2,!4/ /4&!*'- 3/$304'+
2!3/-'-%2!15'2! 4/$/++/7 '2!4'/-3'--
5-$,'+'230!/24/ 044/5-$/2!3!!-
'25,34-!3V+'*!357942'-2!*'-% /7-J
- ,*'-%/--!4'/-32/3353+'-!3J/2342!!4
+/352! 5!4//-34254'/-WN
##&#-2#&#-2(.,)#/,!(N
&'+! /-/453!-9,/'+'49 !6'!3V35&3
7&!!+&'2WJ,9%5!33'34&4'47/5+ 4*!,!
+/-%!24/%!42'-/7%!+4&-@B,'-54!3N
-4''04!4&47/5+ -!! 4/34/0,5+4'0+!4',!3
4/ /5+!&!* '2!4'/-3- 4&47/5+ +'*!+9
4*!4&!72/-%452-4+!34/-!J7&'&7/5+
2!15'2!34/00'-%%'-J2!6'!7'-%,9,0R
'2!4'/-3J- 44!,04'-%4/%!4*/-42*'-
4&!,' 34/$,-9/4&!20!/0+!- 5- -4
3/5- N&'37/5+ +! 4/-!,/ '! !80!2'!-!
/$342!33- -8'!49J- '$7!2!426!+'-%+/-!J
,93!-3!/$3$!49,'%&4/-42'54!4/4&!0&93'+
- ,!-4+!80!2'!-!/$342!33N3! /-4&!3!
$4/23J02/)!44&4'47/5+ 4*!,!47'!3+/-%
3//%+!034&'-*3VBF,'-54!3W
06,241%1%!3& !,M,+0& !/6,2/$2!00!0,21%`0
',2/+!6 0 4!)) 0 4%1 6,2/ ,4+ *&$%1 ),,( )&(!Q 6
-/1&2)/11!+1&,+1,L
?Q ,4%`0& !+1&1&!00%,42-&+1%!_1!51`X1%!3& !,
+ 4%14!!5-!/&!+!/!)1! 1,L%&00-!!%M%,4%&0
, 6--!/0,+0/!!+M%,4%!*,3!0,211%!4,/) M
+ %,4,1%!/0&+1!/14&1%%&*YQ
@Q %1002*-1&,+0*&$%1%3!!!+* !6,,$)!
-0 !3!),-!/0M&16-)++!/0M+ $,3!/+*!+1)
N##&#-2#&#-2(.,)#/,!(
,9&)00&1/!)1!01, &0&)&160&$+$!M!001,-2)&
1/+0&1M+ 1/3!) &/!1&,+0+ *-0Q
,4 0&1 ( + 41% %`0 .2!01 2+#,) X3&!4 1&*! &0
DLCEYO
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`B@M/!,! Z@
#)=F9F"((,(."+/-. ),.",#()1!&3
,,&&-3)/(.#)(
*BFG/<78B,8W86G<BA,86BE7LBHE
G;BH:;GFBAG;8F4@87B6H@8AG4F
LBHECE8I<BHF9E88JE<G8F
?N &4 /9/5,*!/$&^3 6!-452!O
##&#-2#&#-2(.,)#/,!(N
&435202'3!39/5- 7&4 /9/5-/4'!
/54 '3'+'49Z3! ,2%'-+':4'/-- 4&!
335,04'/-372'4!23,*!/54&/72! !23
7'++'-4!247'4&4&!'24!843O
@N /7+/-% ' '44*!&4/%!4&'32'-/7
%!+O/7 ' '4/,02!7'4&9/52%5!33O
AN &422'!23 ' &$!O/7,'%&49/5
&6!!80!2'!-! 4&!3,!/- '4'/-3O
/5+ '4&6!!!-22'!24/9/5/2-/4O
/5+ 9/5&6!!80!2'!-! 4&!3,!
!-6'2/-,!-4322'!2J54'- '$$!2!-4
79O
BN &42!4&! '$$!2!-4*'- 3/$72'4'-%&
!-%%!37'4&- 7&4335,04'/-3 /4&!9
3!!,4/,*!/544&!5 '!-!7&/7'++
53!4&!,O
36#/$#C/H/4,
&0&)&16\/!)1! & !+1&1&!0M04!%3!,0!/3! M/!+,1,#1!+
-/1,# 1%! &*$&+! 2 &!+!0#,/*+6 ,**,+ #,/*0 ,#
4/&1&+$ )&(! 1/+0-,/11&,+ 0&$+$!M 1/3!) &+01/21&,+0M +
*-0Q&1!/6M1,,M&0&*-1! 6,2/!*, &! !5-!/&!+!0
4&1% &0&)&16 + )!\, &! +!00Q 2/,/ 2))!/1,+M
N##&#-2#&#-2(.,)#/,!(
#,/*!/012 !+1,#:/01\6!/4/&1&+$)00*2%)&(!6,2/01
&%&$+11!+&3!/0&164/,1!%!/)&1!/6+//1&3!,21
%,4%!/%!/&+$ &0&)&16&*-1! %!/!5-!/&!+!0)!/+&+$
1,/! + 4/&1!Q,2+ ,4+), 1%!1!51#/,*1%!4!0&1!M
21 !+,2/$!6,21, 41% 1%! 3& !, /!,/ &+$ + /!
),+$0& ! &1Q ,4 %3! 6,2/ !5-!/&!+!0 4&1% /! &+$ +
4/&1&+$!!+0%-! 66,2/& !+1&1&!002//,2+ &+$ &0&)&16
+ )!\, &! +!00R
Works Cited
!2!2++39/5- 4'/-
Tb!2!2++39/5- 4'/-UNV@>?EJ2&@>WN
&--!2c4&!15!34$/24&!2'-/7%!+N
/55!N&4403IRR9/545N!R
&02%O$!452!`3&2!
5++!24/-J52/2N[!2-'-%+'4!297'4&
'3'+'49N\'%'4+2&'6!/$'4!29
224'6!3J@>?AJ
&4403IRR777N4&! +-N/2%RMR !4'+R
CDEEEGCZ!$@ZB!$BZ@A>Z$E$ADF@
/+,%!J9',/4&9N !,'+!'3,I
'3'+'49- &'%&!2! 54'/-N-'6!23'49/$
##&#-2#&#-2(.,)#/,!(N
'&'%-2!33N@>?EN&4403IRR 8N /'N/2%R?>N?ACAR
//*NCE>CFN
/2,-J2' %!4N[,!33%!$2/,!-
/2,-N\'!-'6!23'49J@>@?J
&4403IRR /5N2'!N! 5R,!33%!Z !-Z%/2,-Z
7'-4!2Z@>@?N
/94J-N[!44!2$2/,4&!02!3' !-4N\
,/534/-44!-'6!23'49J@>@>J
&4403IRR777N3&35N! 5R*43$!R2!3424@>@>R
+!44!2Z$2/,Z4&!Z02!3' !-4Z,2&Z@>N
'4&*/3*9J-9N[/2,+N\-N ,3JN
!'33J- N!2+'-V 3NWJ!97/2 3$/2
'3'+'4945 '!3V00N?A>Z?A@WN!7/2*
-'6!23'492!33J@>?CJ
&4403IRR3!2&N2! /2!$!2!-!N/,R24'+!3R
,G6>9 +)D@7``O' `GE
FGEN
N##&#-2#&#-2(.,)#/,!(
G;
<
K4O4/-HH -CO
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H - !234- - !802!33'-72'4'-%4&!*!9
/-!043/$_45 '!3
H - !234- - !802!33'-72'4'-%4&!
2!+4'/-3&'0!47!!-15!!2-!33- +'4!29
$(4/4,<HK#/$D
,/,2/-2/-,0!0Ma12 &!0+! !:+! 0#,)),40L
&!-+-.#N
_45 '!3'34&!;!+ !8,'-'-%15!34'/-3
/$3!85+/2'!-44'/-- %!- !2' !-4'49N&!
2/-9,3&/734&!$/53/$4&!;!+ X+!3'-J
%9J'3!85+J42-3J- 15!!2'- '6' 5+3X-
4&!_44&!!- !,/-3424!34&44&!;!+ '3
!80-3'6!- -'-+5 !/4&!2' !-4'49
0/3'4'/-34&4$/2!%2/5- %!- !2- 3!85+'49N
4'3-'-4!2 '3'0+'-29;!+ 4&4'3/2-/$2!+Z
+'$!4'6'34,/6!,!-43N&'+!3'-%5+2
!;-'4'/-/$4&!;!+ '3',0/33'+!4//,!9J
%// 35,,29/$4&!;!+ ^3/6!2++'-4!-4'/-'3
4&4-9 '32','-4'/-%'-34/-!^3%!- !2-
3!85+' !-4'493&/5+ !2!3'34! N-34! J
%!- !2- 3!85+ '6!23'493&/5+ !!+!24!
- 4*!-3/)!43 !3!26'-%2'4'+'-15'29
- 3&/+23&'0N
# 6,2 /! &+1!/!01! &+ )!/+&+$ *,/! ,21 1%! 1%!,/!1&)
#/*!4,/(1%12+ !/-&+01%&0%-1!/M6,2,2) /! *,/!
,21 &1 &+ !,/% Q *,/6`0 (.,)/.#)( .) T
./#-C,)--O#-#*&#(,3**,)"Q,/+&+1!/0!1&,+,#
a 12 &!0 + !*, &! /%!1,/&M /! )!
!+ 6$/#1`0%-1!/],,(&+$-*, &! !%+,),$&!0M
2!!/%!1,/&0M+ /&+ /`0/& Q^
N&!-+-.#
E84><A:#GBJA
&!3!2!4&!*!94*!793$/215!!24&!/293
4&!/2!4'+- 024'+002/&4/72'4'-%
H !- !2- 3!85+' !-4'4'!3/0!24!+/-%
30!425,J- +793'-4!23!47'4&/4&!2
30!43/$/52' !-4'4'!3N
H !- !2- 3!85+' !-4'4'!32!/$4!-3/'+
/-3425434&4,315!2 !3-452+N4'3
%// 024'!4/002/&4&!3!0243/$
/523!+6!333/'+- 5+452++9 !4!2,'-!
0!2$/2,-!3N
H !,'- $5+/$02/-/5-3N&'32!15'2!3,/2!
4&-3*'-%3/,!/-!4&!'202!$!22!
02/-/5-3- 2!30!4'-%4&/3!&/'!3Y!'-%
,'- $5+,!-34&47!5- !234- 4&4/52
02/-/5-32!<!4/52'+'494/02!3!-4
/523!+6!3&/77!&//3!4/J24&!24&-
!'-%/-;-! 4/' !-4'490/3'4'/-3N
H 15++9',0/24-44/2!,!,!24&4-/4++/$
53&6!4&'302'6'+!%!4/&//3!- 02!3!-4
&!-+-.#N
/52%!- !2- 3!85+' !-4'4'!3N
H 37'4&++/4&!230!43/$/52/ '!3J/52
%!- !2- 3!85+' !-4'4'!32!+3/3&0!
90/7!22!+4'/-3 !;-'-%%!- !2- 3!85+
&'!22&'!3N&!3!2!+4'/-3 !4!2,'-!7&'&
'-34'454'/-3- ' !37!,'%&4J/2,'%&4-/4J
&6!!334/N
H '6!-4&47!72'4!7'4&/52/ '!37&'&
2!',0+''4+9- !80+''4+9,2*! 3
%!- !2! - 3!85+':! J++30!43/$
72'4'-%J'-+5 '-%/,0/3'4'/-J'-4!202!44'/-J
- /,,5-'4'/-2!$$!4! 94&!0/7!2
2!+4'/-34&4!34+'3&%!- !2- 3!85+
-/2,3N
H -/4,H-$-$6CO/4C H/ $
4&4&'36' !//544&!+2%!34_
2&'6!3'-4&!N&!4'/-+9-
!3'-2&'6!3'-/3-%!+!3&/53!3,4!2'+
N&!-+-.#
4&4'3,!-44/ 2744!-4'/-4/15!!2/-4!-4
/++!4! /6!24&!/523!/$4&!47!-4'!4&
!-4529V6'!74',!'3?>I?DWN%)9)+%
%$)$((%#(-*"".-&")#(
'%*$)5=30B5=40)#()#&=
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3
!!-!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!
4!84N/5-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`BBM/!,! Z?
' !/DN?N2&'6!39/44'-%&,
/-4!,0/229
-;<A><A:E<G<64??L
3&+$41%! 1%&03& !,/!#2))6M1%&+(,211%!&*0+
0,-! ,# 1%&0 1%!,/6M + -)! &1 &+ /!)1&,+ 1, 6,2/ ,4+
!*, &! & !+1&16Q
&!-+-.#N
#AI<G4G<BAGB0E<G8
*!$2!3&0'!!/$00!2J/2/0!-50-!7
/5,!-4N'6!9/523!+$4!-,'-54!3V34244',!2W
4/2!30/- 4/4&!$/++/7'-%15!34'/-N
H &9'3'4',0/24-44/524!15!!2/-4!-4
'-4/-/$;'+2&'6!O
H &47!2!4&!,/34',0/24-4-
'-4!2!34'-%4&'-%34&49/5+!2-4$2/,4&'3
6' !/O
H &402'6'+!%!32!9/5%2-4! /2 !-'!
!53!/$9/52%!- !2- 3!85+' !-4'4'!3
39/5,/6!4&2/5%&4&!7/2+ O!,!,!2
4/4&'-*/540/'-437&!2!62'/5330!43
/$9/52!,/ '! ' !-4'49'-4!23!4N
K$$C4$DD4#/H$C O
,44!)!/+1,/! + 4/&1! !-!+ 0,+%,4,2/, &!0
/!$!+ !/! + 0!5! &+-2)&+ -/&31!0-!0Q,+0& !/M
#,/ !5*-)!M 1%! &1,/&+ & !) #,/ #!*)! , &!0[4,*!+
N&!-+-.#
,2) !0!!+04/&1&+$)!11!/01,#/&!+ 0+ #*&)6M21+,1
4/&1&+$+,3!)0,/-%&),0,-%&)1!510Q,1,+)64!/!1%!6+,1
! 21! #,/1%!)11!/M1%!&/-%60&)0-!04!/! !0&$+! 02%
1%1 1%!6 ,2) +!3!/ /! ,/ 4/&1! &+ &0,)1&,+Q *$&+!
6,2/0!)# &+ 1%! ,+1!*-,//6 ,/1% *!/&+ *& )! +
%&$%0%,,)0!5! 21&,+)004%!/!1%! &92)1.2!01&,+,#
, &!01%1 ,+,1M,/%,,0!+,11,M,2-6$!+ !/+ 0!5
+,/*0/! ,#1!+$),00! ,3!/&+ #3,/ ,#!0&)61!$,/&7)!M
*,01)6 %!1!/,+,/*1&3! #,/*0 ,# $!+ !/ !5-/!00&,+Q %!
4/&1&+$)00/,,*+,8!/460,#-,)&1&))6+ /%!1,/&))6
&+1!/3!+&+$&+1,1%!0!+,/*1&3!+//1&3!0M-/1&2)/)64%!+
6,21%&+(,#/! &+$+ 4/&1&+$01,,)01%1+,1%%!)-
6,2 +)67! .2!!/ 1!510M 21 )0, ,*-,0! .2!!/ 1!510 1%1
023!/1!01)&0%! $!+ !/+ 0!5,+3!+1&,+0Q
0E<G<A:LBHE:8A78E874A7F8K87
<78AG<GL
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
&!-+-.#N
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`BBM&C0ZE
Works Cited
,/29J!/2&NJ!-N33!9J!--'$!2
'++!2J- ++'3/-N2/7-N-42/ 54'/-4/
_45 '!3I2/33Z'3'0+'-29
002/&N44!-'6!23'49/$!7/2*N
!- 9%2$4J+!J[//*'-%0,/ '!
!&-/+/%'!3J5!!2&!4/2'3J- 2'- 2^3
2' J\
/ '!3/$-/7+! %!I,/ '!
&!4/2'3'-&!/29- 24'!
N 3NN9
-/+5&c2'!N/!++!2N4&44!
-'6!23'492!33J@>@?N
N&!-+-.#
&!-+-.#N
F;
K4O4/-HH -CO
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H 5,,2':!7/2*'-% !;-'4'/-/$2'4'+
!&!/29VW
H - !234- 4&!2!+4'/-3&'0!47!!--
!,/ '! ' !-4'49
H !<!4'-72'4'-%50/-4&!2!+4'/-3&'0
!47!!-- 72'4'-%
N,#-#&,-"),2
$(4/4,C/H/ 2 $-$6CO
%!+ 4! ),,( 1 ,2/ , &!0M 4! 0!! +,1 '201 &,),$&))6
01/212/! ,'!1M21)0,0,&))6,+01/21! ,+!Q!0),1
,2/0!)3!0M ,/ /! 1,) 1, , 0,M &+1, 0,&))6 & !+1&:)!
1!$,/&!0M 0,*! ,# 4%&% /! !/&3! #/,* ,2/ , &)6
%/1!/&01&0Q/&1&)/!1%!,/6XY,8!/0,+!)!$)+
-%&),0,-%&)#/*!4,/( #,/ 2+ !/01+ &+$ %,4,2/ , &!0
!,*! 1%! 0&0 ,# 0,&))6 ,--/!00&3! + !5-),&11&3!
1!$,/6Z/!Q 02$$!010 1%1 4%&)! /! --!/0 1, !
+12/)+ $/,2+ ! &+&,),$&)#!12/!00%/! 6 &01&+1
%2*+$/,2-0M&1&0&+/!)&160,&))6,+01/21! 1!$,/6
1%1&0!+1&/!)6/#1! 6%2*+!&+$0Q,&)+ -,)&1&)
0601!*0 /! *,&)&7! 1, ,1% 02--,/1 /! 0 +12/)
-%!+,*!+,++ 1,*&+1&+0,&)M-,)&1&)M+ !,+,*&
&+!.2)&1&!0!14!!+4%&1!0+ +,+4%&1!0Q&0-/, 21
,#)!$)+ /&1&)1%&+(!/0#/,*1%!M+ &01%!012 6,#
0601!*& /&0* &+ 1%! &+ -/1&2)/Q 1%20 +)67!0
0,&),+ &1&,+0&+1%!M,1%&+1%!2//!+1*,*!+1+
%&01,/&))6M0&11/!01%!0!,+ &1&,+01,.2!01&,+0,#/!Q
,/ ,2/ -2/-,0!0M /&1&) /! 1%!,/6 + ! !:+! 0
#,)),40L
,#-#&,-"),2N
!'33/'+/-342544&4,315!2 !33
-452+0&!-/,!-/-!53!'400!234/!
%2/5- ! '-'/+/%'+$!452!3N'3,'3
3934!,'02/+!,4&4'3!,! ! '-4&!^3
+!%+- ,/2+'-34'454'/-3J- '402/,/4!3
&'!22&93!024'-%7&'4!$2/,-/-7&'4!J
024'5+2+9$2'-,!2'-J/ '!3N
,2+)0,)!/+*,/!,21#/,*1%!#,)),4&+$3& !,
X3&!41&*!&0BL>DYL
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`BDM/!,! Z?
#)?F9F#(.,3S-)&&!D,F(#&)&),4()C
,#.#&"),3*,.93#(.,3S-)&&!)
&# ),(#
#6,2/!&+1!/!01! &+)!/+&+$*,/!,211%!1%!,/!1&)
#/*!4,/(M6,2,2) /! *,/!,21&1&+&%/ !)$ ,
N,#-#&,-"),2
+ !+ 1!#+&`0 ]/&1&) ! %!,/6L + ++,11!
&)&,$/-%6 006 /&1&) ! %!,/6L + ++,11!
&)&,$/-%6006Q^
E84><A:#GBJA
&!3!2!4&!*!94*!793$/22'4'+2!4&!/29
34&!/2!4'+- 024'+002/&4/72'4'-%
H &'+!2!00!234/!'/+/%'+-
-452+J'4'33/'++9/-34254! ' !
H 934!,'2'3,'34&!-/2,J24&!24&--
!224'/-'-4&!J- -!$/5- '-++
0243/$+'$!J$2/,&!+4&2!J! 54'/-J
&/53'-%4/!,0+/9,!-4
H !53!2'3,'33934!,'J'4%/!3!9/-
'- '6' 5+!+'!$3- 024'!3J- '34/!
$/5- 7/6!-'-4/+73- '-34'454'/-3'-4&!
H '6!-4&47!72'4!7'4&/52/ '!3J7!+3/
72'4!7'4&/ '!34&42!,2*! 3
!+/-%'-%4/024'5+22!/2,'8452!/$
2!3
,#-#&,-"),2N
H 52!334/' !3J'-34'454'/-3- 2!3/52!3
4&4&!+05372'4!'3 !4!2,'-! 97&!2!'-
4&!2'+&'!22&9/52/ '!32!0+!
H ++30!43/$72'4'-%J'-+5 '-%/,0/3'4'/-J
'-4!202!44'/-J- /,,5-'4'/-2!
$$!4! 94&!0/7!22!+4'/-3' !-4';! 9
4#/H$C O
!1 20 !5*&+! 0,*! ,# 1%! ,3! )&*0 *,/! ),0!)6M
-/1&2)/)61%!/!)1&,+0%&- !14!!++ )&1!/6Q %!
#,)),4&+$-/$/-%&0#/,*/%&*Q!+ &`0/1&)!],4
&0* !)&!0 ,+ /&1//6 &!//%&!0M^ 4%&% %! )1!/
-2)&0%! 0,,(M)1)((.#,#-.X@>?GYQ06,2
/! M1%&+(,21%,41%!21%,/&0-,0&1&,+&+$%&0, 63&0\
\3&0%&02+ !/01+ &+$,#/!Q,4&0%!4/&1&+$06,2+$
)( ,6 *,3&+$ 1%/,2$% 1%! 4,/) R + 4%1 &0 !+ &
&*-)6&+$ 6 %&0 .2!01&,+M ]%6 /! 6,2 1%! ,+)6 )(
1!%!/R^
N,#-#&,-"),2
+*7/,-%2!!4! 5344&!$2/-4 //2/$
2!54&!2-&//+N&!& !!-7'4'-%N
&!734&!3&//+^34&'2 Z%2 !4!&!2J-
$4!215'*%2!!4'-%J3&!4//*53 /7-
/22' /2N+332//,334// /-/4&3' !3J54
;84! /-4&!+330&/4/3/543' !4&!2//,3I++
4&/3! 5+4&'4!$!3- 9/5-%+*$!3
+//*'-%*453N!/3'/-++90!!*!
'-3' !-'!+9 !/24! +332//,3N/3/5- 3N
/345 !-43N/4!&!23N534$//434!03N
&!4//*534/&!24&'2 Z%2 !+332//,J+/-%
4&2/7$2/,4&!!-42-!N!/5+ 3!!4&!
,4!2'+3+' /54$/23'!-!02/)!4J4&! !4'+3
/$7&'&3&!!80+'-! 4/53N/5+ -^42!+!33
/542'3'-%&'*3N&!-3&!4//*53/6!24/
2/5- 4+!- 3*! '$7!& -915!34'/-3N
'44'-% /7-J,9,/4&!23*! 15!34'/-/54
4&!522'5+5,N ' -/42!,5&/544&4J
!'4&!2N3424! +//*'-%,/2!'-4!-4+92/5- 4&!
+332//,N053!'-4&! '3533'/-5%&4,9
44!-4'/-X & )5343*! /544&!2'+
,*!50/$4&!345 !-4/ 9N)/2'49+*N
4//*-/4!N9,'- 2'$4! 79%'-J4&'34',!
7- !2'-%2/5- 4&!+332//,- 2/5- 4&!
,#-#&,-"),2N
3&//+J429'-%4/',%'-!4&!345 !-43-
4!&!23J2!,!,!2'-%4&/3!0'452!3'-4&!
&++79N053!5%&4,944!-4'/-%'-N
15!34'/-0/00! /54/$,!N
[2!9/54&!/-+9+*4!&!2O\
[!3J54Y\
54&!2/$$N[&92!9/54&!/-+9+*
4!&!2O\
5::+! J3&!+//*! 794,902!-43N9
02!-43!8&-%! 52'/53+//*3N*!04342'-%
44&!4!&!2J7/- !2'-%7&93&!73+//*'-%
4,902!-43N!- ! 4&!7*72 3'+!-!N
[!&3!!-2! '-%'/%20&'!3/$+*
+! !23\V!- 'J[/7'3,!+'!3/-2'4229
'!22&'!3J\@>?GWN
N,#-#&,-"),2
KHH/4,H-$-$6CO/4H6C H/ $
,8W86GBALBHEE8?4G<BAF;<CJ<G;E468
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`BDM&C0ZF
0 1%&0 %-1!/ 02$$!010M 1%!/! &0 + &+1&*1! /!)1&,+0%&-
!14!!+,2//&)& !+1&1&!0+ ,2/)&1!/6!5-!/&!+!0Q%!
(&+ 0 ,# &+#,/*1&,+ + & !0 1%1 4! %3! !00 1,M +
%,4!0&)64!+!001%!*M /! !1!/*&+! 6,2/ /&)
& !+1&1&!0Q %! #,)),4&+$ &0 + /1&)! 6 ,+1%+ ,1%4!))
,+!5)20&,+/6 7,+&+$&+ 1%! + 1%! !8!101%&0 -,)&6
%0% ,+! 21&,+Q&.."&#(%#.'&)1.),."
,.#&F
,#-#&,-"),2N
%11-0LTT444Q/,,(&+$0Q! 2T/1&)!0T%,20&+$\,010\7,+&+$\
+ \!00\1,\%&$%\0,/&+$\0%,,)0T
3BA<A:?4JF4A7?<G8E46L
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`BDM&C0ZG
Works Cited
29-4J!- 2N[2'4'+!&!/29Y
N,#-#&,-"),2
!9/- 94&3I&44&!!4!
'33!3J\
2'4'-%/,,/-3
J@>@AN
!+%+ /J'&2 - !-4!$-'N
2'4'+
!&!/29I--42/ 54'/-
J!7/2*
-'6!23'492!33J@>?EN
!+%+ /J'&2 - !-4!$-'N[2'4'+
!&!/29I---/44! '+'/%20&9
3392'4'+!&!/29I---/44!
'+'/%20&9339J\
+,7&/+2+9
/,,/-3
J?GGAN
/4&7!++J/-4&-N[/53'-%/343J/-'-%J
- !334/'%&Z/2'-%
&//+3J\
2//*'-%3
J02'+?GJ@>?@N
,#-#&,-"),2N
N,#-#&,-"),2
0,#-#(!-),"-),#&&2(&23N
N0,#-#(!-),"-),#&&2(&23
%;
!
9:
/4K4
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'33!4'/-J9/57'++!+!4/
H 2'4!-!,/ '! 2&!4/2'+-+93'34&4
/-3' !23&/74&!/ 90+932/+!'-
,!-'-%,*'-%7'4&'-024'5+24!84
')#,"-),#&(&2#--(#(!-)).,)#
-#)()/,/#0N
!6'3'4I&4'3,/ '! &!4/2'3O
+1%!/&1!1,!/+!5!/&0!!),4M/!;!1,+1%!/!)1&,+0%&-
!14!!+6,2/, 6+ 6,2/4/&1&+$-/,!00Q
0E<G8GB&84EA2BHEB7L0;8A
0E<G<A:
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`C>M&C0Z?>
/%!1,/&) +)60&0 ,+0& !/0 %,4 1!51 #2+1&,+0 0
N')#,"-),#&(&2#--(#(!-)).,
)#-#)()/,/#0
#,/* ,# ,**2+&1&,+Q1 0(0 1%! .2!01&,+0L 4%, /!1!
1%!1!51M2+ !/4%1&/2*01+!040&1/!1! M4%1&01%!
21%,/`0-2/-,0!&+/!1&+$1%&01!51M4%&%2 &!+!0&01%!
21%,/--!)&+$1,M+ %,41%,0!3/&,20#1,/00%-! 1%!
461%!1!51&0,*-,0! Q
%1&0#/!.2!+1)6)!#1,21,#1%!0!,+0& !/1&,+0M%,4!3!/M
&01%!/,)!,#1%!, 6Q04/&1&+$0%,)/0Q6+,)2%
+ /&! Q ,!))!/ %3! +,1! &+)#- ) ()1&!C
')# ".),#- #( "),3 ( ,.#D](+,4)! $! +
*!+&+$ /! +!3!/ &0!*, &! Z1%!6 /! )460 * ! 6
0,*!, 6Z+ 6!1M0:!) M4!`3!,#1!+&$+,/! 1%!/,)!,#
1%!, 6&+(+,4)! $!-/, 21&,+Q^
!))$&+1%!3/&,20460!%-!/0,+`0, 6&0*/(!
61%!&+1!/0!1&+$!5-!/&!+!0,#$!+ !/M0!52)&16M/!M)00M
$!M + X &0Y&)&16M 1, +*! '201 #!4 &*!+0&,+0Q %,0!
!*, &! !5-!/&!+!08!1,1%1%!464!*(!*!+&+$0
/!1,/0,#1!510+ 1%!464!/!!&3!*!+&+$02 &!+!0
,#1%,0!1!510Q
%!+6,2-611!+1&,+1,1%!/,)!,#1%!, 6&+/%!1,/&)
+)60&0M6,2/!1%20,+0& !/&+$L
?Q ,4 ,!01%!21%,/`0!*, &! !5-!/&!+!00%-!1%!
1!511%11%!6-/, 2! R
@Q ,4 ,!01%!, 6&10!)##2+1&,+01!51R
AQ ,4 ,!01%!1!511/61,&+;2!+!+ 8!11%!, &!0
,#&102 &!+!0R
')#,"-),#&(&2#--(#(!-)).,)#
-#)()/,/#0N
4N382$6&36#/$#
-$H6C/
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`C>M/!,! Z?
#)@F9F''3/%1),."S-#( (.'%-"#-.),3#((.
"',3),(#(!-
+-/&)@>?FM!+1,/**62(4,/1%* !%&01,/66
!,*&+$1%!:/010!+1,/1,!,+1%!!+1!;,,/4&1%+
&+#+1Q1%1%!3& !,,3!X3&!41&*!&0@LCEY+ ',1 ,4+
/!0-,+0!01,1%!0!.2!01&,+0L
?Q %,&01%!21%,/R%1/!%!/ &8!/!+1)&3!
!5-!/&!+!0R
@Q ,44,2) 6,2 !0/&!!+1,/**62(4,/1%`0
, 6R,44,2) 6,2 !0/&!%!/6`0, 6R,4
4,2) 6,2 !0/&!1%!&/, &!01,$!1%!/R
AQ %1(&+ ,#/$2*!+1&0!+1,/2(4,/1%*(&+$
611!+ &+$1%!!+1!0!00&,+4&1%%!/6R
BQ %1/%!1,/&)01/1!$&!0 ,!00%! /4,+4&1%%!/
N')#,"-),#&(&2#--(#(!-)).,
)#-#)()/,/#0
,4++ %!/6`0, &!0R
CQ %,&0T/!1%!2 &!+!X0Y1%1%!/,4++ %!/6`0
, &!0*&$%1! /!00&+$R
,/+!*, &! /%!1,/&)+)60&0,#**62(4,/1%`0
%&01,/&)1M0!!21%0,/&,M]!4/&1&+$1!/+), &!0L
+ 1%! !+1! ),,/L **6 2(4,/1%`0 *, &!
%!1,/&0 ,# +1!/0!1&,+) ,1%!/%,, M^ &+)#- )
()1&!C')#".),#-#("),3(,.#F
4L/HH/64DH6$#"$)$ H"4#
C/H$
+ 1%&0 &+1/, 21&,+ 1, 1%! 0!1&,+ ]/&1&+$ 1, %!1,/&))6
+)67!M^4!&+3&1!6,21,/! 0,*!0*-)!/%!1,/&)+)60&0
!0060#/,*,1%!/&+1/6`0,))!$!012 !+10Q!%3!)0,
&+)2 ! 0,*!&+3&11&,+01,4/&1!0%/! 64/&1&+$-/,#!00,/0
1&+1/6`0,))!$!Q
')#,"-),#&(&2#--(#(!-)).,)#
-#)()/,/#0N
GH78AG0E<G<A:
!7/5+ +'*!4/'-+5 !345 !-472'4'-%'-4&'3
3!4'/-N$9/52!'-4!2!34! '-05+'3&'-%9/52
7/2*J0+!3!;++/544&'3$/2,- 35,'40'!!/$
9/5272'4'-%$2/,9/5272'4'-%+33N!7'++7/2*
7'4&9/54/%!4'405+'3&! N
!2!2!3/,!2&!4/2'+-+93!372'44!-9
345 !-43- 05+'3&! 4/4&!25-'6!23'4'!3N!
4&'-*9/5^++;- 4&!3!,!-4/24!84353!$5+I
H 9- '%&4I/,024'6!-+93'3
/$5+'&!4/2'/-/24'/-T!7U
9'&!+/!-9V2'4!2^344!,!-4
T!7UW
H &!&!4/2'/$'/4222+'-!3T!7U9
2+'*&2'V2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7UW
H 80+/2'-%4&!&!4/2'/$/-4!,0/229+*
!,+!07'4&'-4&!/-4!84/$/'+
'3/523!- !-4'49T!7U9!%-
!+ !2V2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7UW
N')#,"-),#&(&2#--(#(!-)).,
)#-#)()/,/#0
#AI<G4G<BAFGB0E<G8A@5B7<87
,;8GBE<64?A4?LF<F
&!&04!23'-4&'33!4'/-3&/5+ 02!02!9/5$/2
/,0+!4'-%/-!/$4&!3!35,,4'6!72'4'-%
33'%-,!-43N&!3!!8,0+!32!33'%-,!-434&4
7!2!/,,!- N
(($#$)-#&"<1
&!4/2'++9-+9:!30!!&/20/+'4'+4'/-'-
7&'&4&!/ 9/$4&!0!2$/2,!2R/24/20+93
25'+2/+!N
(($#$)-#&"<2
&!4/2'++9-+9:!0&93'+30!V,53!5,J$/2
'-34-!W- ,*!-2%5,!-4/54&/7'4
0/3'4'/-34&!/ '!3/$'436'3'4/23'-/2 !24/
/,0+'3&024'5+2%/+N
(($#$)-#&"<3
2'4!2&!4/2'+-+93'3/$-24'+!V/$9/52
&//3'-%W7&!2!-',%!/$0&93'+/ 9
/,0-'!34&!4!84N/-/4!4&4'4 /!3-/4
')#,"-),#&(&2#--(#(!-)).,)#
-#)()/,/#0N
,44!2'$9/50!23/-++9%2!!R '3%2!!7'4&4&!
24'+!^32%5,!-4- ' !3Q7&4,44!23'34&4
9/5?NW' !-4'$9- !32'!4&!2&!4/2'+!+!,!-43
/$4&!4!84- '43/,0-9'-%',%!- @NW
33!334&!4!84^3!$$!4'6!-!3342!4'-%&-%!
4&2/5%&4&!'-+53'/-/$-',%!/$4&!0&93'+
/ 9N
Works Cited
/!++!2J2'!NJ- N9-/+5&N
[-42/ 54'/-I/ '!3J,/ ',!-43J-
,/ '! &!4/2'3N\
/ '!3/$-/7+! %!I
,/ '! &!4/2'3'-&!/29- 24'!
N
4&44!-'6!23'492!33J@>@@NAZ@>N
3/2'/J54&N[!72'4'-%4!2-+/ '!3I-
4&!!-4!+//2I,,95*7/24&^3
,/ '! &!4/2'3/$-4!23!4'/-+
/4&!2&// N\
/ '!3/$-/7+! %!I,/ '!
&!4/2'3'-&!/29- 24'!N
4&44!
-'6!23'492!33J@>@@N?BAZ?D>N
N')#,"-),#&(&2#--(#(!-)).,
)#-#)()/,/#0
5;
>
>
/4K4
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/53&/5+ !+!4/
H !;-
& 2'10&$2-0'"
0/%!1,/&*+&-2)1&,+R)0! 3!/1&0!*!+1R%!!/2))0JJJR
%!1,/&+!+6,/)),#1%!0!1%&+$0M21&1&0)0,*2%
*,/!1%+1%1Q+61&*!+6, 6X+6)3M4&1%1%!0-!&:
)&3! !5-!/&!+!0,#1%1/! M$!+ !/! M)00\! , 6Y*(!0
!&0&,+1,,**2+&1!*!00$!M/%!1,/&&0&+-)6Q+6
1&*!6,206M4/&1!M+ T,/!%3!&+-/1&2)/46M4%!1%!/
1&3!)6 ,+0&,20 ,# 1%! -2/-,0! ,/ +,1M 6,2 /! *(&+$
!&0&,+0 ,21 6,2/, 6 )+$2$!M ,21 4%&% 4,/ 0 1,
20!M + ,21 4%1 1,+! 1, !01)&0% 0! 2-,+ 4%1 &0
--/,-/&1!#,/6,2/&+1!+ ! 2 &!+!&+1%1,+1!51Q%1
&0/%!1,/&Q
%! *!/&+ !/&1$! &1&,+/6 ,+)&+! !:+!0
]/%!1,/&^0]1%!/1,/012 6,#20&+$)+$2$!!8!1&3!)6+
-!/020&3!)6Q^ 21 )+$2$! ,!0 +,1 ,+)6 %3! 1, ! 4,/ 0
,+-$!Q01%!-%/0!], 6)+$2$!^02$$!010M%,46,2
-/!0!+1 + //6 6,2/ , 6 &0 )0, (&+ ,# ])+$2$!^
!20!&1-/!0!+100&$+01%12 &!+!0+&+1!/-/!1Q
3!+%!,+!-1]/%!1,/&^0,2+ 001/1M!3!/6,+!,#
20(+,40%,41,20!&1Q!1`01/6&1,2120&+$+!5!/&0!1%1
/%!1,/&-/,#!00,/+!1,6 !3&0! #,/%!/012 !+10Q
N0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#
'HE78E,;8GBE<64??LC84><A:
+#&")(
%92*,'4&
)952 !2!
'92*'-%%2%!
$95-!DJ@>?GQ?>IAE0,
%,95+4'0+!347/5- 3
/5,'%&42! 35&342'%&4$/272 $43'-3&/24
-!7300!224'+!/2&!24&!,'-2'!$-!73
2!0/24/-4&!2 '/Q'$4&!0!23/-73-/4$,/53J
4&!-224'6!,'%&43/5- +'*!4&'3I2*,'4&73
$/5- 34! 4/ !4&4?>IAE0N,N/-5-!D4&J'-
4&!+/+02*'-%%2%!N
!84J!&/$9/57'++!33'%-! ,934!2'/532/+!
4&2/5%&7&'&9/57'++2!30/- 4/4&!3!;6!3',0+!
$43N+!3!/-+9+'*/-4&! 2/0 /7-$/29/52
0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#N
2/+!J- -/4$/2-9/$4&!/4&!23N/57'++$/++/7
4&!'-34254'/-3$/29/522/+!- 72'4! /7-9/52
-37!2/-/52/++/24'6!+33 /5,!-4N
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`CAM&C0Z??
$4!2!6!29/ 9&3/,0+!4! 4&!'233'%-! 43*J
0+!3!2!<!4/-9/5202/!33/$/,0+!4'-%4&!
43*I
H /7 /!34&!2!0/24R /5,!-4!%'-O&!2!
/!3'4!- O
H &4490!3/$ !4'+3 ' 9/5;- 9/523!+$
'-%O&9O&4 !4'+3 ' 9/5/,'4O
&9O
H &4*'- /$7/2 3 ' 9/5&//3!O
H &44/-! ' 9/54*!OV7'++ ,'4J4/-!
-!42'*94&'-%4/ !32'!Q'4'3!34
/-!93!2&'-%$/230!'; )!4'6!4&4
!32'!3$!!+'-%/2-44'45 !35&3
[02!4!-4'/53J\[3/,!2J\[5/9-4J\
N0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#
[,!+-&/+'J\[ ' 4'J\[&5,/2/53J\!4NWN
H /7 ' 9/5/2 !29/52'-$/2,4'/-O
H /7 ' 9/5*-/7&/74/72'4!+'*!0!23/-
'-9/522/+!7/5+ '-4&!;2340+!O
!-4'$9/-!/4&!2!-429/-4&!+33 /4&49/5
4&'-*3&2!39/523,!2/+!N&4,*!39/54&'-*
3/O&43','+2'4'!3 /9/5/3!26!!47!!-9/52
!-42'!3O!7'++2!0!44&'33,!3!2'!3/$34!03$/2
++4&!,934!2'/532/+!3N&!-J+!4^3-+9:!4&!
3','+2'4'!3- '$$!2!-!32/334&! '$$!2!-42/+!3N
&4 /9/5-/4'!O
+! (!6 /!0,+ 4%6 6,2 % )&11)! 1/,2)! #2):))&+$ 6,2/
10([1%!/!0,+4%66,2&+12&1&3!)6(+!4%,41,!$&+M4%1
16-!0 ,# !1&)0 1, &+)2 !M 4%1 (&+ 0 ,# 4,/ 0 1, %,,0!M
+ 4%11,+!1, ,-1Z&0!20!6,2/!#*&)&/4&1%1%!
$!+/!1%16,2/!4/&1&+$&+Q!/!&0 !:+&1&,+,#]$!+/!^L
4%!+1%!1/&10,/11/&21!0,+0& !/! +,/*)1,,/16-&)
,#-/1&2)/(&+ ,#/!1&3!-&!!M02%0&+)&1!/12/!M:)*M
,/ *20&M *(! &1 1%1 (&+ + +,1 +,1%!/Q ,/ !5*-)!M
4! (+,4%,//,/ :)*0 4%!+ 4! 0!! 1%!*M + 4! /!,$+&7!
)00&)*20&4%!+4!%!/&1!20!4!+)00=%!0!
1%&+$0,/ &+$1,1%!,+3!+1&,+0,#1%!&/$!+/!0Q
,2(+,4%,41,4/&1!)&(! !1!1&3!-/!02*)6!20!
0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#N
6,2 %3! 41%! 0%,40 )&(!C ,#' (
(0-.#!.#)(D4%&%,8!/20$)&*-0!+,1,+)6&+1,1%!4,/(
!1!1&3!0/!)&(!)61, ,21)0,1%!)+$2$!1%!6%,,0!Q
/ 2))6M + !3!/ 0, 021)6M 4! &+1!/+)&7! 1%&0
!1!1&3!0-!(M4%&% &0 *,/! 1%+'201 1%! '/$,+ 1%!620!Q
/$,+ &0 1%! 1!/*&+,),$6 20! 6 1%,0! &+ -/1&2)/
-/,#!00&,+ ,/ $/,2- 1, #&)&11! )!/ + -/!&0!
,**2+&1&,+M211%&0/%!1,/&)1,,)&0+,1)&*&1! '2011,
1%!-/,#!00&,+)4,/) Q,/!5*-)!M+6,+!4%,-/1&&-1!0
&+0-,/120!01%!)&+$,0-!&:1,1%10-,/1M4%&%&0)!/+!
6 ,&+$Q ,1,/0 20! *! &) '/$,+ + )46!/0 20! )!$)
'/$,+M+ 1%!6$,1,0%,,)0-!&:))61,)!/+1%!1!/*0+
/!3&1&,+0,#1%!&/-/,#!00&,+0S0, , !1!1&3!0Q
0! ,+ 1%&0 1&3&16M )!1 20 ,+0& !/ ,+! $&+ 4%1
/%!1,/& *!+0Q %!1,/& &0 4%1 )),40 6,2 1, 4/&1! X+
0-!(Y --/,-/&1!)6 #,/ $&3!+ 0&121&,+M ,+! 1%1 &0
!1!/*&+! 61%!!5-!11&,+0,#6,2/2 &!+!M&*-)&! ,/
(+,4)! $! M4%!1%!/6,2/!1!51&+$M4/&1&+$),3!)!11!/M,/
)!! &+$1!/*--!/Q%!+6,2$,1,4/&1!M6,2*&$%1+,1
)460!1&3!)64/!,#6,2/2 &!+!0+2 &!+!Q,2
*6+,1!3!+,+0&,20)6/!)&7!1%16,2/!!+1&+$!/1&+
/%!1,/&)01/1!$&!04%&)!/!'!1&+$,1%!/0Q21!%1&*!6,2
4/&1!M6,24&)):+ 6,2/0!)#&+/%!1,/&)0&121&,+Z&+,1%!/
4,/ 0M4&1%&+,+1!51,/$!+/!Z1%1+2 $!06,21,%,,0!
1%!/&$%1 &1&,+,/!3!+'/$,++ 1,01/&(!1%!/&$%11,+!Q
%!#11%16,2/!)!1,#2):))1%!10($&3!+1,6,20%,40
1%!!51!+11,4%&%4!0,/+ &+1!/+)&7!,2//%!1,/&)
N0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#
1,,)0641%&+$*! &M/! &+$,,(0M+ -/1&&-1&+$&+
,2/2)12/!Q
,#$012 ,#',%2&$0&$2-0'" *
1'23 2'-,
(!6 ,*-,+!+1 ,# /%!1,/&) +)60&0 &+3,)3!0 1%&+(&+$
/!#2))6 ,21 1%! ]/%!1,/&) 0&121&,+^ ,# 1!51Q ,2 +
1%&+( ,# 1%! /%!1,/&) 0&121&,+ 0 1%! ,+1!51 ,/ 0!1 ,#
&/2*01+!0,21,#4%&%1!51/&0!0Q+61&*!+6,+!&0
1/6&+$1,*(!+/$2*!+1M,+!&0 ,&+$0,,21,#-/1&2)/
,+1!51M,+!1%1&+;2!+!0+ 0%-!01%!/$2*!+11%1&0
* !Q%!+4! ,/%!1,/&)+)60&0M4!),,(/!#2))61
%,41%!/%!1,/&)0&121&,+X,+1!51Y0%-!01%!/%!1,/&)1
X1%!1!51YQ,1!1%11%!1!51 ,!0+`1,+)6%3!1,!4/&11!+
,2*!+1Q1+!+&*$!M0,+$M0-!M,/, 6Q
!+2+ !/01+ 1%!,+!-1,#/%!1,/&)0&121&,+!
!5*&+!&1-&!!6-&!!M6),,(&+$/!#2))611%!/%!1,/&)
,+!-10 #/,* 4%&% &1 &0 2&)1Q /4&+$ ,+ )00&) +
,+1!*-,//6/%!1,/&&+002%0/&01,1)!+ !&1%/+1\
3&!M 4! 4&)) !:+! 1%!0! ,+!-10 0L !5&$!+!M 21%,/M
2 &!+!M 0!11&+$M + 1!51Q +04!/&+$ 1%! .2!01&,+0 ,21
1%!0!/%!1,/&),+!-10!),44&))$&3!6,2$,, 0!+0!,#
6,2/ 1!51`0 /%!1,/&) 0&121&,+Z1%! 01/1&+$ -,&+1 #,/
/%!1,/&)+)60&0Q
0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#N
6'35+
&24
!,/-342
4'-%
&/74&!
'$$!2!-4
!+!,!-43
/$4&!
2&!4/2'+
3'454'/-
2!
/--!4!
4/!&
/4&!2N
K<:8A68
%! 5#,/ +$)&0%&1&,+/6 !:+!0 !5&$!+!0 ]4%1 &0
+!! ! ,/ /!.2&/! S 1%&+$ 4+1! ,/ !*+ ! S
/!.2&/!*!+1M +!!00&16Q^ + 1%! ,+1!51 ,# /%!1,/&)
0&121&,+0M!5&$!+!/!#!/01,1%!*,1&31&+$#1,/1%10-2//!
1%!/!1&,+,#1%!1!51Q-/,)!*/!.2&/&+$0,)21&,+*201
%3!!5&01! M+ 1,0,)3!1%!-/,)!*M0,*!,+!/!1! 1!51Q
%1-/,)!*&01%!!5&$!+!Q
%!+,+0& !/&+$!5&$!+!M6,20%,2) 0(1%! #,)),4&+$
.2!01&,+0L
?Q %1&01%!1,-&,#1%!1!51R
@Q %6&01%&01!51+!! ! 11%&0*,*!+1R%1-/,)!*
&01%!1!511/6&+$1,/!0,)3!R
N0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#
AQ %1/!1%!$,)0,#1%!1!51R%1&0&11/6&+$1,
,*-)&0%R
HG;BE
%! ]21%,/^ ,# 1!51 &0 1%! /!1,/Z1%! -!/0,+ 4%, &0
,**2+&1&+$ &+ ,/ !/ 1, 1/6 1, !8!1 %+$! &+ %&0 ,/
%!/ 2 &!+!Q + 21%,/ ,!0+`1 %3! 1, ! 0&+$)! -!/0,+
,/ -!/0,+ 1 ))Z+ 21%,/ ,2) ! + ,/$+&71&,+Q ,
2+ !/01+ 1%!/%!1,/&)0&121&,+,#1!51M,+!*201!5*&+!
1%!& !+1&16,#1%!21%,/+ 1%!&/($/,2+ Q
K %,&01%!21%,/M+ %,4 ,!01%!&/, 68!11%!&/
)&3! !5-!/&!+!R+/!1&+$1%!1!51M/!1%!6*(&+$
1%!&/, 63&0&)!,/&+3&0&)!R,4 ,!01%10!/3!1%!&/
-2/-,0!R
K %1(&+ ,#!5-!/&!+!,/21%,/&16 ,!01%!21%,/
%3!&+1%!02'!1,214%&%%!,/0%!&00-!(&+$R
K %13)2!0 ,!01%!21%,/%3!M!&1%!/&+$!+!/),/
4&1%/!$/ 1,1%&0-/1&2)/02'!1R
K ,4&+3!01! &01%!21%,/&+1%!1,-&,#1%!1!51R+
,1%!/4,/ 0M4%18!101%!21%,/`0-!/0-!1&3!,+1%!
1,-&R
K /!1%!/!,1%!/-!,-)!,/&+01&121&,+04%,*6%3!
-)6! /,)!&+0%-&+$1%!1!51R
K %1&01%!21%,/`0-!/0,+R%1&0M4%1&01%!
& !+1&16%!&01/6&+$1,-/,'!101%!/!1,/,#1%&01!51R
0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#N
H7<8A68
+ +6 1!51M+ 21%,/ &0 11!*-1&+$ 1, !+$$! + 2 &!+!Q
!#,/! 4! + +)67! %,4 !8!1&3!)6 + 21%,/ !+$$!0 +
2 &!+!M 4! *201 0-!+ 0,*! 1&*! 1%&+(&+$ ,21 1%1
2 &!+!Q + 2 &!+! &0 +6 -!/0,+ ,/ $/,2- 4%, &0 1%!
&+1!+ ! /!&-&!+1,#1%!1!51+ )0,1%!-!/0,+T-!,-)!1%!
21%,/ &0 1/6&+$ 1, &+;2!+!Q %!/! *&$%1 ! *2)1&-)!
2 &!+!01%!21%,/&01/6&+$1,/!%0&*2)1+!,20)6Z1%!6
+1%20 ! /,(!+ ,4+ &+1, -/&*/62 &!+!M 0!,+ /6
2 &!+!M!1Q
,2+ !/01+ 1%!/%!1,/&)0&121&,+,#1!51M,+!*201
!5*&+!4%,1%!&+1!+ ! 2 &!+!&061%&+(&+$,211%!0!
1%&+$0L
K %,&01%!21%,/ /!00&+$R
e ,*!1&*!01%&0&01%!%/ !01.2!01&,+,#))Q!
+$!11%&0&+#,/*1&,+,#M]4%,&01%!21%,/
/!00&+$^6),,(&+$14%!/!+/1&)!&0
-2)&0%! Q!02/!1,-611!+1&,+1,1%!
+!40--!/M*$7&+!M4!0&1!M,/',2/+)1&1)!
4%!/!1%!1!51&0-2)&0%! Q#1!+M6,2+/!0!/%
1%1-2)&1&,+1,$!1$,, 0!+0!,#4%,/! 0
1%1-2)&1&,+Q
K %1&01%!2 &!+!`0 !*,$/-%&&+#,/*1&,+X$!M
$!+ !/M!1QYR
K %1&0T/!1%!($/,2+ M)&3! !5-!/&!+!0M3)2!0M,/
N0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#
&+1!/!010,#1%!&+1!+ ! 2 &!+!R
K ,4,-!+&01%&0&+1!+ ! 2 &!+!1,1%!21%,/R
K %1002*-1&,+0*&$%11%!2 &!+!*(!,211%!
21%,/R
K +4%1,+1!51+ T,/0-!&01%!2 &!+!/!!&3&+$
1%!1!51R
/+1\3&! &01&+$2&0%!0 1%! &+1!+ ! 2 &!+! #/,* 1%!
&+3,(! 2 &!+!Q#1%!&+1!+ ! 2 &!+!&04%,1%!21%,/
&01/6&+$1,/!%M1%!&+3,(! 2 &!+!&0,+01/21! X,#1!+
& !)&7! Y & !+1&16 1%1 1%! 21%,/ &0 1/6&+$ 1, -!/02 ! 1%!
2 &!+! &+1, !-1&+$Q ,/ &+01+!M -,)&1&) *-&$+
-,01!/*6! &/!1! 12+ !& ! 3,1!/0Q%!6/!1%!1%!
&+1!+ ! 2 &!+!Q %! &+3,(! 2 &!+! *6 ! 0,*!,+!
4%, 4&)) 3,1! #,/ 1%! + & 1! !20! 1%!6 /!,$+&7! 1%!
&*-,/1+!,#1%!+ & 1!`0-)1#,/*,+-/1&2)/&002!Q
8GG<A:
,1%&+$%--!+0&+322*M+ 1%1&+)2 !01%!/!1&,+
,# +6 1!51Q 0060M 0-!!%!0M -%,1,0M -,)&1&) 0Z+6
1!51Z40 4/&11!+ &+ 0-!&: 1&*! + T,/ -)!M + 1%!
-!,-)!M !3!+10M + ,'!10 1%1 /! -/1 ,# 1%&0 0!11&+$Q +
,+0& !/&+$0!11&+$M6,2/!,+0& !/&+$%,41%!0!,+1!512)
#1,/0*6&+;2!+!%,41%!21%,/&01/6&+$1,--!)1,1%!
2 &!+!1%/,2$%1%!1!51Q
!/!/!0,*!.2!01&,+01,,+0& !/L
0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#N
K %1/!0,*!,+1!*-,//6!3!+101%1*6&+;2!+!
1%!461%!1!51&0/!!&3! R
K /!1%!/!,1%!/1!5104&1%4%&%1%!-/1&2)/1!514!
/!,+0& !/&+$&0,*-!1&+$R
-8KG
1 1%! !+1!/ ,# 1%! /%!1,/&) 0&121&,+ &0 1%! 1!51L 1%!
,2*!+1 1%1 1%! 21%,/ %0 /!1! &+ /!0-,+0! 1,
-/1&2)/ -/,)!*M &+1!+ ! #,/ -/1&2)/ 2 &!+!M +
4&1% 1%! $,) ,# %&!3&+$ !/1&+ ,21,*!0Q %! 3/&,20
,+01&12!+10 ,# 1%! /%!1,/&) 0&121&,+ /! 1%!/! 1, %!)- 20
+)67! '/1%!1!511/&!01,,*-)&0%&10$,)0Q%&0*!+0
-6&+$ 11!+1&,+ 1, 1!512) #!12/!0 02% 0 $!+/!M *! &2*M
/%!1,/&)--!)0M+ :$2/!0,#0-!!%Q
!*!*!/ ,+! $&+ 1%1 1%! 1!51 ,!0 +,1 %3! 1, !
*!/!)6)&+$2&01&Q1+!+&*$!M0,+$M0-!M*1!/&)
,'!1M, 6M,/*,/!Q
-52-#-0&$2-0'" * , *71'1
%! $,) ,# /%!1,/&) +)60&0 &0 1, !5-)&+/ ,&0
%--!+&+$&+1%!1!51M/ 11%!21%,/*&$%1%3!%,0!+1,
20!-/1&2)/*,3!,/0!1,#/%!1,/&)*,3!0M+ '/1%,0!
%,&!0*&$%18!11%!2 &!+!Q%!1!516,2+)67!*&$%1
! !5-)+1,/6M )1%,2$% 1%!/! 4&)) ! 0-!10 ,# /$2*!+1
!20! 6,2 *201 +!$,1&1! 4&1% 4%1 1%! 21%,/ &0.,3#(!
N0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#
.) )+ 1". 3)/ ."#(%1%! 21%,/ &0 ,&+$Q 4/ QQ
,/!11,0!/3!0M/%!1,/&)+)60&0 ]&0*,/! &+1!/!01! &+
)&1!//6 4,/( #,/ 4%1 &1)-1%+ #,/ 4%1 &1#-QX.1 Q &+
,/ .3&01YQ
+!,#1%!!)!*!+10,# ,&+$/%!1,/&)+)60&0&0),,(&+$
11!51`0/%!1,/&)0&121&,+Q%!/%!1,/&)0&121&,+&01%!
,+1!51,21,#4%&%1!51&0/!1! Q
+,1%!/ !)!*!+1 ,# /%!1,/&) +)60&0 &0 0&*-)6 /! &+$M
02**/&7&+$M+ T,/,1%!/4&0! !0/&&+$1%!1!51Q,2%3!
1,!)!1, !0/&!1%!0&0,#1%!*!00$!!#,/!6,2+
!$&+1,+)67!&1Q
1%&/ !)!*!+1 ,# /%!1,/&) +)60&0 /!.2&/!0 6,2 1,
,++!1 1%! /%!1,/&) 0&121&,+ 1, 1%! 1!51Q ,2 +!! 1, $,
!6,+ 02**/&7&+$+ ),,(1%,41%!21%,/0%-!01%!&/
1!51 0! ,+ &10 ,+1!51Q + !3!),-&+$ 6,2/ /! &+$ +
+)61&) 0(&))0M )),4 6,2/0!)# 1, 1%&+( ,21 4%1 6,2`/!
/! &+$M1,.2!01&,+1%!1!51+ 6,2//!0-,+0!01,&1M06,2
/! Q 0! 1%! #,)),4&+$ .2!01&,+0 1, %!)- 6,2 1(! 1%! 1!51
-/1Z &00!1&+$&11,0!!%,4&14,/(0L
K '+, -, '*+-++-$$1+-(('*,, , +!+'*
$!%>01%!-,&+1%!) ,+0&01!+1)61%/,2$%,211%!
1!51M,/ ,!0&14+ !/1+6-,&+1R
K +, .!&, -, '*-+3,!.'*,
!&,&-!&>,4*&$%11%!&+1!+ ! 2 &!+!
/!0-,+ 1,1%!16-!0,#!3& !+!1%11%!21%,/20! 1,
02--,/11%!1%!0&0T)&*R
0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#N
K ,* ,'*!$%'.+'1'-+, -, '*
%#!&,' $( !., !*(-*('+>/!1%!/!
4,/ %,&!0,/,+1!+1%,&!01%10!!*1,6,21,!
)!/)6/!)1! 1,1%!21%,/`0$!+ #,/1%!1!51,/1%1
*&$%1--!)1,1%!&+1!+ ! 2 &!+!R
K +*!, ,'&!&, (!=0&1#/&!+ )6R
21%,/&11&3!R,!0&1)!12/!R0&1&1&+$,/0/01&R
,!01%!21%,/20!0&*-)!)+$2$!M,/&0&1#2)),#
'/$,+R,!01%!)+$2$!#!!)-,0&1&3!,/+!$1&3!R
,&+11,0-!10,#1%!1!511%1/!1!1%!1,+!S0-!+
0,*!1&*!!5*&+&+$1%!0!+ ,+0& !/&+$%,4+
4%61%!64,/(QX!/+*,/!,211,+!&+-!+
/!$,+`0"),)(#(!(,#.#(!S-"*.,D
],+!M,&!M+ ,&+1,#&!4Q^Y
K +, -, '*'",!.;'*', 1,*1,''&.!&
1'-,' .*,!&'(!&!'&>%6 ,!01%!21%,/
1/61,-!/02 !6,21, ,-11%&03&!4-,&+1R#1%!
21%,/&0&0! M ,!01%&0&+1!/#!/!4&1%1%!466,2
/! + 2+ !/01+ 1%!1!51R
K '1'-$$!#, -, '*#&'/+/ '1'-
*>,!01%!1!510!!*1,!&*! 1/! !/0)&(!6,2
,/1 &8!/!+12 &!+!R%1002*-1&,+0 ,!01%!
21%,/*(!,211%!&/2 &!+!R,2) *,01-!,-)!
:+ 1%!0!/!0,+)!M!-1)!M,/2/1!R
K '+, ,0,E+5'/%#+&+>01%!)&+!,#
/!0,+&+$),$&)R/!1%!/!+6$-0R/!1%!/!+6
0-,104%!/!6,2#!!)1%!/!0,+&+$&0;4! &+0,*!
N0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#
46R
K '+, -, '*,*1,'(($,'1'-*
%',!'&+>,!01%!21%,/20!+6,+1/,3!/0&)4,/ 0
&+1%!%! )&+!,/1%!/1&)!R,1%!0!8!16,2/
/! &+$,/6,2/&+1!/!01R
K '1'-$!., -, '*>,6,2!-11%!&/
1%,2$%10+ & !0R%6,/4%6+,1R
&$2-0'" * ..$ *1
+/!1&+$1%!1!51M+21%,/1/&!01,-!/02 !1%!&/2 &!+!
6*(&+$/%!1,/&)--!)0Q
0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#N
&B:BFCC84?GB&B:<6
/%'N!3/-N4'/-+'49N/%/3'32'-9-
'-4!++!45+J//+J+,J/++!4! J/)!4'6!N
&!--54&/22!+'!3/-+/%/3J'4,!-34&4&!/2
3&!'353'-%+/%'J2!$5+3425452!J- /)!4'6!
!6' !-!4/00!+4/4&!5 '!-!N-54&/2-
00!+4/-5 '!-!^3'-4!++!4953'-%
'-$/2,4'/-4&4-!$4Z&!*! V53'-%,5+4'0+!
3/52!3W- 4&/2/5%&!80+-4'/-34/3500/24*!9
0/'-43N '4'/-++9J02/6' '-%3/+' - -/-Z
'3! !80+-4'/-/$/-!^32%5,!-4'3%2!479
$/2-54&/24/'-6/*!+/%/3N
N0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#
/2!8,0+!J'$7!2!429'-%4//-6'-!,9
345 !-434//,0+!4!4&!'2&/,!7/2*J,'%&4
!80+'-4&45- !234- !6!29/-!'3539- 4&!9
&6!/4&!2+33!3V-/-Z'3! WJ544&!&/,!7/2*
7'++&!+04&!,%!4!44!2%2 !/-4&!'24!34
V!80+-4'/-WN/5+ 4/4&'3!80+-4'/-9
02/6' '-%344'34'33&/7'-%4&!-5,!2/$345 !-43
7&/$'+! - ' -^4/,0+!4!4&!'2&/,!7/2*
6!23534&!-5,!2/$345 !-437&/033! - '
/,0+!4!4&!'2&/,!7/2*V$45+!6' !-!WN
/%'+00!+32!34/-24'/-+,/ !3/$
4&'-*'-%:35&3
H %#&'(%$B/,02'3/-!47!!-/-!
4&'-%V7'4&2!%2 4/9/524/0'W- -/4&!2J
3','+24&'-%4/&!+03500/249/52+',N4'3
',0/24-44&44&!/,02'3/-'3$'2-
6+' X4&!4&'-%3!'-%/,02! ,5343&2!
3'%-';-442'43/$3','+2'49N
H *(?))$!$B9/52%5!4&4
&353! J/24&4'3+'*!+94/53!4/
&!+03500/249/52+',N!2!$5+7'4&4&!
+44!2X'4-! '$;5+44/02! '44&4
3/,!4&'-%[7'++\&00!-'-4&!$5452!N
H *)+'(%$$B3424'-%7'4&
2/ J%!-!2++',R!8,0+!- 53'-%'44/
0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#N
3500/24,/2!30!';0/'-4/2+',N
H $*)+'(%$$B53'-%3!6!2+30!';
!8,0+!3/23!34/,*!2/
%!-!2+':4'/-N
H -#&"/)%$B53!/$,-9!8,0+!3/2
62'!49/$!6' !-!4/3500/243'-%+!0/'-4N
H "%')%$Y,/6'-%!9/- )534'-+5 '-%
$4J54!80+'-'-%4&!3'%-';-!/2
2!+!6-!/$4&4$4N
H %'$))%*)Y,'-4'-'-%7!++Z
/2%-':! +'-!/$2!3/-'-%Q-/42!0!4'-%
' !3/2)5,0'-%2/5- N
*4G;BFCC84?GB@BG<BAF
&!--54&/22!+'!3/-04&/3J'4,!-34&44&!9
2!429'-%4/40'-4/4&!5 '!-!^3!,/4'/-34/%!4
4&!,4/%2!!7'4&4&!54&/2^3+',N-54&/2
53'-%04&!4'00!+37-434&!5 '!-!4/$!!+
N0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#
3/,!4&'-%I-%!2J02' !J)/9J2%!J/2&00'-!33N/2
!8,0+!J,-9/$53&6!3!!-4&!
/,,!2'+34&453!0&/4/%20&3/$'-)52!
0500'!3J/23 Z+//*'-%*'44!-3J- 3+/7J !02!33'-%
,53'4/!,/4'/-++90!235 !4&!'25 '!-!4/
/-4!,/-!9N
!+/7'3-!8,0+!/$-/,,!2'+4&4
53!3',%!- ,53'4/!6/*!$!!+'-%3/$39,04&9
'-4&!5 '!-!I
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3
!!-!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!
4!84N/5-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`CAM/!,! Z?
4&/3Z3! 2&!4/2'+3424!%'!32!-93424!%'!3
4&4%!44&!5 '!-!4/[/0!-50\4/4&!4/0'J4&!
2%5,!-4J/24/4&!54&/2N,/4'/-3-,*!53
65+-!2+!J- -54&/2-53!4&'365+-!2'+'49
4/%!44&!5 '!-!4/!+'!6!4&4&'3/2&!2
2%5,!-4'3/,0!++'-%/-!N
0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#N
4&!4'00!+3,'%&4'-+5 !
H -&'((+('&)%$(/$0!/0+!J0+!3J
/2!6!-434&4&!+04&!2! !24/$!!+/2
!80!2'!-!4&/3!!6!-43
H +#'./$0!/0+!J0+!3J/2!6!-43
4&4&!+04&!2! !24/$!!++'*!&!/23&!'3
3!!'-%4&/3!!6!-43
H &2'-%&'(%$"()%'(4&4,*!4&!
2! !2$!!+/--!4'/-4/J/2!,04&9$/2J
4&!0!23/-!'-% !32'!
H 3'-%#%)%$C"$+%*"'.379
4/0544&!2! !2'-4/4&430!';!,/4'/-+
,'- 3!4V7&4'34&!54&/2429'-%4/,*!
4&!5 '!-!$!!+O- &/72!4&!9 /'-%
4&4OW
H 3'-%-9'-$/2,4'/-4&47'+++%!$
#%)%$"'(&%$('%#)*$N
&'3/5+ '-6/+6!,*'-%4&!5 '!-!$!!+
!,04&9/2 '3%534$/24&!0!23/-R%2/50R
!6!-4!'-% '3533! J/20!2&03/--!4'/-
4//22!)!4'/-/$4&!0!23/-R%2/50R!6!-4
!'-% '3533! N
&!-2! '-%4!84J4294/+/4!7&!-4&!54&/2
'3429'-%4//-6'-!4&!2! !253'-%!,/4'/-3
!53!J'$53! 4/!8!33J04&!4'00!+3-
N0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#
'- '4!+*/$3534-!/2!,/4'/-+
,-'05+4'/-/$4&!5 '!-!N!!4&!+'-*3!+/7
/54$++'/5304&/3$/2,/2!'-$/2,4'/-N
G;BFCC84?GB/4?H8F-EHFG
4&'+00!+3&6!47/$!43I5 '!-!6+5!3-
54&/2'+2! ''+'49R&24!2N
-4&!/-!&- J7&!--54&/2,*!3-!4&'+
00!+J4&!92!44!,04'-%4/)&$)%
)+"*(%'%"%()))*$
%"(J$/2!8,0+!J042'/4'3,J42 '4'/-J)534'!J
!15+'49J '%-'49$/2++&5,-*'- J3!+$02!3!264'/-J
/2/4&!230!';3/'+J2!+'%'/53/20&'+/3/0&'+
6+5!3V&2'34'-6+5!3J3/'+'3,J0'4+'3,J
$!,'-'3,J!4NWN&!3!6+5!3-3/,!4',!3$!!+
6!29+/3!4/!,/4'/-3J544&!92!$!+4/-3/'+
+!6!+24&!24&-/-+9/-0!23/-++!6!+N&!--
54&/2!6/*!34&!6+5!34&44&!5 '!-!2!3
0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#N
/543794/)534'$9/23500/244&!'22%5,!-4J
7!+33'$94&43!4&/3N&!5 '!-!7'++$!!+4&4
4&!54&/2'3,*'-%-2%5,!-44&4'3[2'%&4\V'-
4&!3!-3!/$,/2+[2'%&4\Z-!33J'N!NJ[92%5,!-4
2!34350/-4&!6+5!34&4,44!24/9/5N&!2!$/2!J
9/53&/5+ !04,92%5,!-4\WN&'3;234024/$
4&! !;-'4'/-/$!4&/3J4&!-J'3$/53! /-4&!
5 '!-!^36+5!3N
-4&!/4&!2&- J4&'33!-3!/$2!$!2!-'-%7&4'3
[2'%&4\'--!4&'+00!+/--!434/4&!/4&!2
3!-3!/$!4&/3I4&!54&/2N4&/34&4'3!-4!2! /-
4&!54&/22!6/+6!32/5- 47//-!043I4&!
2! ''+'49/$4&!54&/2- 4&!'2&24!2N
'")./$4&!30!*!2R54&/2'3 !4!2,'-! 9
4&!'2*-/7+! %!- !80!24'3!'-4&!35)!44
&- N/2!8,0+!J'$9/52!+!2-'-%/54
'-34!'-^3&!/29/$!+4'6'49J7/5+ 9/524&!2
+!2-$2/,02/$!33/2/$0&93'3/2/53'-7&/
4//*47/3'!-!+33!3'-&'%&3&//+4&'2499!23
%/O4'3$'24/394&4J'-%!-!2+J02/$!33/2/$
0&93'37/5+ &6!,/2!2! ''+'494/ '35334&!
4/0'/$0&93'3N/!34+'3&4&!'22! ''+'49J-
54&/2,9 2744!-4'/-4/7&/4&!92!/27&4
*'- 3/$!80!2'!-!4&!9&6!7'4&4&!4/0'!'-%
'3533! 3-!4&'+00!+V'N!NJ[!53!&6!
N0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#
!80!2'!-!7'4&4&'34/0'X- *-/7,9
345$$LX9/53&/5+ 425347&4,39'-%/544&'3
4/0'\WN/,!54&/23 /-/4&6!4/!34+'3&4&!'2
2! ''+'49!53!4&!5 '!-!+2! 9*-/737&/
4&!92!- 4&44&!92!2! '+!N
')''3-/4&!230!4/$!4&/3J- '4'3
'$$!2!-4$2/,2! ''+'49!53!'4'-6/+6!30!23/-+
&'34/29- !6!-0!23/-+'4942'43N0!23/--!
2! '+!54+*&24!2J/26'!6!23N/2
!8,0+!J'-0/+'4'3J3/,!4',!34&!,/34
!80!2'!-! - ' 4!3X4&/3!7&/,'%&4!4&!
,/342! '+!- ' 4!3X$'+4/7'-!+!4'/-3
!53!6/4!23 /-/4!044&!'2&24!2N
/+'4''-34*!0'-34/3&0!4&!'2&24!23
+! !237&/&6!4&!'-4!2!343/$4&!6/4!234
&!24N&!- ' 4!7&/35!33$5++902/6!34/4&!
6/4!23V4&!5 '!-!W4&44&!9&6!4&!490!/$
&24!24&44&!6/4!23-42534'3,/2!+'*!+94/
7'-N
&53J!4&/3/,!3 /7-4/42534N/7-4&!
54&/2%!44&!5 '!-!4/425344&!,3/4&44&!9
7'++!044&!'22%5,!-4O/7-4&!54&/2
,*!4&!,3!+$00!232! '+!30!*!27&/
!,/ '!34&!&24!242'434&44&!5 '!-!
6+5!3O
0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#N
-5'+ '-%!4&'+00!+3J7!3!!54&/23
H !$!22'-%!'4&!2 '2!4+9/2'- '2!4+94/4&!
6+5!34&4,44!24/4&!'-4!- ! 5 '!-!
V3/4&44&!5 '!-!7'++425344&!30!*!2W
H 3'-%+-%5%!J0&23'-%J',%!29J/2/4&!2
72'4'-%349+!3/,,/-4/0!/0+!7&/&/+
4&/3!6+5!3J4&!2!9[4+*'-%4&!4+*\/$
0!/0+!7'4&4&/3!6+5!3V%'-J3/4&44&!
5 '!-!'3'-+'-! 4/425344&!30!*!2W
H !$!22'-%4/4&!'2!80!2'!-!- R/254&/2'49
7'4&4&!4/0'V- 4&!2!$/2! !,/-3424'-%
4&!'22! ''+'49W
H !$!22'-%4/4&!'2/7-&24!2J/2,*'-%-
!$$/244/5'+ 4&!'2&24!2'-4&!4!84
&!-2! '-%J9/53&/5+ +7934&'-*/544&!
54&/2^32! ''+'492!%2 '-%4&!35)!437!++3
4&!'2&24!2N!2!'3-!8,0+!/$2&!4/2'+
,/6!4&4/--!437'4&!4&/3I7&!-2! '-%-
24'+!/54/24'/-J4&!54&/2,!-4'/-34&4
4&!9&6!& -/24'/-N&4'3-!8,0+!/$-
!4&'+,/6!!53!4&!54&/2'32!4'-%
2! ''+'496'-! /4+!6' !-!- ;234Z0!23/-
-224'6!N-2&!4/2'+-+93'302/)!4J'47/5+ !
504/9/5J4&!-+9:!2J4/0/'-4/544&'3,/6!-
33/'4!'47'4&2&!4/2'+3424!%9N
N0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#
4^39/52452--/7N-4&!/8!+/7J/-3' !2&/7
!4&/3'3!'-%53! '-4&
4A70BE7F
'2/3J'-2!!*J,!-33/,!4&'-%+'*
-5'+ '-%00!+34/*'2/3J7!3!!54&/23
H !$!24//-4!,0/229!6!-434//-6!9
52%!-9/23!-3!/$ //,
H -+5 !++4/4'/-4&4++/732! !234/
5- !234- 4&!'24'/-3R2!30/-3!33
,!-'-%$5++9/-42'54'-%4/4&!024'5+2
,/,!-4'-4',!
4^39/52452--/7N-4&!/8!+/7J/-3' !2&/7
*'2/3'3!'-%53! '-4&'3/,3!,- 4'/- I
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#N
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`CAM&C0Z?A
Attributions
[52 !2LV&!4/2'++90!*'-%WJ\'-
2'4'-%
0!3I! '-%3/-2'4'-%3J
/+5,!@J-!4
/9 J442'54'/-Z/-/,,!2'+Z&2!+'*!
AN>
[&4'34&!&!4/2'+'454'/-OJ\[&4'3
&!4/2'+-+93'3J\[&!4/2'+00!+3I/%/3J
4&/3J- 4&/3!;-! J\'-
5' !4/
&!4/2'J!-2!J- 5!33'-'234Z!2
2'4'-%J
!+-'!%'&c,'+'!'*!+J
442'54'/-Z/-/,,!2'+Z&2!+'*!BN>
[&!'%&4/2 3J4&!'%&4',!J- 4&!'%&4
+!J\'-
&!4/2'+&/'!3I- //*/$
N0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#
+33'+&!4/2'$/2 6-! '6'+':4'/-3J
9
2/-*&'4!J442'54'/-Z/-/,,!2'+Z
&2!+'*!BN>
Works Cited
52-!++J2/+J!4+N[/-!J/'!J- /'-4/$
'!7\N
&!/2 /-/++!%!! '-%-
2'4'-%J
0!-2!%/- 54'/-+!3/52!3N
&4403IRR/0!-/2!%/-N02!33//*3N05R72 R
&04!2R4/-!Z6/'!Z- Z0/'-4Z/$Z6'!7R
$#/HHC/KH/64D
K %!1,/&)0&121&,+%/1
0"-#,"-),#0"-#,"-),#&(&2#N
7Q;
$,-4M$$4$O
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&!&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H !32'!4&!*!9/-!043/$!,/ '!
2&!4/2'3
H 72'4!2!<!4'6!-+93'34&4!80+'-34&!
2/+!/$!,/ '! 2&!4/2''-0'!!
%!1,/& 0,*!1&*!0 %0 +!$1&3! ,++,11&,+M )&(! 4%!+
0,*!,+!060M]%M1%1`0'201/%!1,/&O^,/M]%!6/!20&+$
/%!1,/&Q^ %!+ -!,-)! 20! /%!1,/& 0 -!',/1&3!M 1%!6
N*,#(#*&) ')#,"-),#
202))612))6*!+]!*-16/%!1,/&^L4,/ 01%1/!!&+$
20! 4&1%+,&+1!+1&,+,#%+$!!%&+ 1%!*Q/1%!6/!
4,/ 01%1/!!&+$20! 1,*+&-2)1!,1%!/0M4&1%1%!4,/ 0
+,112))61!))&+$1%!1/21%M,+)6*!+11,-!/02 !M !!&3!M
,/*+&-2)1!Q
%!1,/& %0 *2% !!-!/*!+&+$M ,+! 1%1+ ,-!+
4/&1!/ 2- 1, ,--,/12+&1&!0 #,/ & !+1&:1&,+ 4&1% ,1%!/0
X2/(!YS,+!1%1-/,*,1!001+!,#,-!++!00#,/)&01!+&+$
1, +6 -!/0,+M 1!51M ,/ 2)12/! X1)&8!YS + ,+! 1%1
!+,2/$!0 4/&1!/0 1, ]#,/!$/,2+ , &)6 &3!/0&16^ 0, 1%!6
+4/&1!#,/]!00&&)&16+ &+)20&3&16^X! &)),YQ+,1%!/
4,/ 0M /%!1,/& &0 +,1 !*-16 4,/ 0 ,/ -,)&1&)-/,*&0!0Q 1
&0*,*!+10%/! !14!!+%2*+01%18!101%!*M,1%
4/&1!/+ /! !/Q
-$H6C/ D#$4H/( H/64
!++!1%2/(!*/(0:/01(!6*,3!*!+146#/,*/%!1,/&
0,+)6-!/020&,+Q+2/(!`0 !:+&1&,+,#/%!1,/&M4!:/01
& !+1 &3&0&,+X#,/4&1%,21 &3&0&,+1%!/!4,2) !+,+!!
#,//%!1,/&Y+ 1%/,2$%& !+1&:1&,+M4!%3!1%!&+3&11&,+
1,/%!1,/&Q%/,2$%/%!1,/&M4!&+ 2!-!,-)!1,1&,+6
& !+1&+$6,2/4604&1%1%!&/0Q
*,#(#*&) ')#,"-),#N
-$H6C/ 2/DH$4/4,
!3!/) ! !0 )1!/M /&01 1)&8!`0 -/1&! ,# /%!1,/&)
)&01!+&+$!51!+ ! !++!1%2/(!`0/%!1,/&0& !+1&:1&,+Q
%!1,/&) )&01!+&+$ ]0&$+&:!0 01+! ,# ,-!++!00 1%1
-!/0,+*6%,,0!1,002*!&+/!)1&,+1,+6-!/0,+M1!51M
,/2)12/!^ X?EYQ!/ $,)&0 1,#,01!/2+ !/01+ &+$*,+$
&+1!/0!1&+$& !+1&:1&,+0,#$!+ !/+ /!M6*(&+$1%!
1,#)&01!+&+$+,3!/1/%!1,/&)1M+ +&+3!+1&,+1,,)Q
C/H/ 2-$H6C/ 236#/3$4H
%/&01&+! &)),%))!+$!0/%!1,//1%!/1,!+1!//&1&)
!*, &*!+1Q ! &)),`0 4,/( %))!+$!0 -/!3&,20
2+ !/01+ &+$0 ,# /%!1,/& 0 1%!6 /!)6 ,+ ]+,/*1!
01+ / 0^1%1!/0!], &)6 &3!/0&16M^4&1%&+1!/0!1&,+)&16
,# /!M &0&)&16M + $!+ !/ !*+ &+$ &+01! &+)20&3!M
!00&)! 460 ,# *(&+$ + 0%/&+$ (+,4)! $!Q ! &)),`0
/%!1,/& ,-!+0 2- 0-!0 #,/ ,*-)&1! M &+!.2&1)!
-/,!00!0 ,# & !+1&:1&,+ X-,4!/ 6+*&0 *&00&+$ #/,*
2/(!`0 !:+&1&,+YQ ! &)), )0, ,*-)&1!0 1)&8!`0
/%!1,/&) )&01!+&+$ 6 &+$ + &1&,+) &+1!/0!1&+$
& !+1&:1&,+,# &0&)&16Q
! &)),`0 &*-,/1+1 4,/( )),40 /%!1,/&) +)60&0 +
4/&1&+$ 1, +,1 '201 !&+$ -/,!00 ,# & !+1&+$ 1%! *,01
!8!1&3! 46 1, *(! + /$2*!+1 ,/ 1, +)67! 1%!
!8!1&3!+!00,#0,*!,+!!)0!`0/$2*!+1Q+01! M&1,-!+02-
N*,#(#*&) ')#,"-),#
0-!#,//%!1,/&)+)60&01,!)0,+!5-),/1&,+,#%,4
1%!, 6&0/%!1,/&)Q
!),4 &0 + !5*-)! ,# /%!1,/&) +)60&0 20&+$ /&1&)
!*, &*!+1Q
8A4GBE-4@@LH6>JBEG;QF
@5B7<87,;8GBE<6;4A:8FG;8
45L4ABAG;88A4G8 ?BBE
54&32'/'-[
I,,95*7/24&^3
,/ '! &!4/2'3/$-4!23!4'/-+/4&!2&// \
02/6' !353!$5+!8,0+!/$&/7!,/ '!
2&!4/2'3-!53! 4//$$!2-/4&!2 ',!-3'/-4/
/52-+93!3N
32'/!8,'-!3-',0/24-4,/,!-4'-!-4!
&'34/29J$4!2!-4/2,,95*7/24&VZ++W%6!
'24&/-02'+G'-@>?FN&!!-4!25+!3344!4&4
'-$-435- !24&!%!/$?2!--! $2/,4&!
!-4!<//2N/3!-4/23'-4&!034& %'6!-'24&
52'-%4&!'24',!3!-4/2J3/4&'325+!&
/-4'-5! $/2!-452'!37'4&/54&++!-%!N
*,#(#*&) ')#,"-),#N
!-4/25*7/24&&++!-%! 4&!25+!!53!3&!
7-4! 4/6/4!N4;234J,+!!-4/2335%%!34!
3&!6/4!$2/,4&!+/*2//,7'4&&!29N
/7!6!2J!53!3&!53!37&!!+&'2J3&!
/5+ -^4;4'-4/4&!+/*2//,J7&'&73-/4
7&!!+&'2!33'+!I[5*7/24&^3 '3'+'49
45++902!6!-4! &!2$2/,!'-%&' !-79'-
4&!!-4!+/*2//,J- '43500/24! &!2
2%5,!-44/++/7'-$-43/-4&!!-4!<//2N!4
%'-J5*7/24&^3!,/ '! -!! 3X4&!-!! $/2
7&!!+&'2Z!33'+!30!7&!2!'-3&!/5+ 6/4!
- &/+ &!2-!7/2-X3&0! 4&! !+'6!29/$&!2
2%5,!-4\V?CAWN
!53!4&!9/5+ -/4054&!2'-4&!+/*2//,J4&!
!-4!6/4! 5--',/53+94/2/++4&'325+!*J
++/7'-%5*7/24&4/024''04!'-%/6!2-'-%J
/0!-'-%4&! //2$/2,/2!,4!2-+/ '!3J-
3!44'-%[4&!34%!$/2,/2!,4!2-+/ '!3/$/+/2
4/)/'-4&!+! !23&'02-*3\V?CAWN
32'//-4!- 34&45*7/24&^3- /7+3!9^3
V&!2&'+ ^3W/ '!34/%!4&!2/-4&!!-4!<//2
302*! /++!4'6!*-/7+! %!,*'-%/54
,4!2-+/ '!3J7/2*J%/6!2--!J- '3'+'49N
!-4/2,,95*7/24&'34&!;2343'-
,!2'-7/,-!+!4! 4/!-4!7'4& /5+!
N*,#(#*&) ')#,"-),#
,0544'/-3- 4&!;2343!-4/24/%'6!'24&7&'+!
'-/$;!V32'/WN!2' !-4'493 '3+! 6!4!2-J
,/4&!2J- 0!23/-/$/+/2;+4!234&2/5%&&!2
0/+'4'+2&!4/2'33&! 6/4!3$/2&!+4&2!-
$/2!'%-0/+'9N4+3/$2,!3&/7/4&!235- !234-
- '-4!202!4&!22&!4/2'X3&!22!J%!- !2J-
'3'+'492!4!-[!,/ '! 02!3!-!/-4&!
!-4!<//2\V3/2'/?BBWN
/2&!4/2'++9-+9:!5*7/24&^32%5,!-43J
32'/!8,'-!35*7/24&^3!,/ '! *-/7+! %!
3 '3+! 7/,-J-523'-%,/4&!2J-
7/,-/$/+/2I&/7 /!34&'3*-/7+! %!4&4'3
!2'6! $2/,4&'3+'6! !80!2'!-!$$!4&!2
2%5,!-44'6!3424!%'!3O[/2!,/ '! 2&!4/2'3J
-'-4!23!4'/-+-+93'302/,043534/
*-/7+! %!4&42&!4/23!,/ 9,5+4'45 !/$
' !-4'4'!3J- 4&4/,0+!8,42'8!3/$' !-4'4'!3
- 0/7!23&0!4&!6'++!,!-3/$0!2353'/-\
V32'/?BCZDWN
3024/$4&4-+93'3J32'//-4!- 34&47!
,534-+9:!5*7/24&^3/ 93'-/-34!++4'/-
7'4&/4&!2/ '!3J3'-2!+4'/-4//4&!27/2*'-%
,/4&!23/$/+/2J '3+! ,/4&!23N&43&!;- 3
4&2/5%&&!2-+93'3'34&45*7/24&^302!3!-!
/-4&!!-4!<//24/6/4!02/,04! 2%5,!-43
*,#(#*&) ')#,"-),#N
2/5- 4&!-!! $/20/340245,2!$/27/2*'-%
02!-43J/,0+'4! 490'++97&'4!73&!
-224'6!3/544&!7/2*'-%,/4&!2J- 5-3!44+!
335,04'/-3/542!34$!! '-%J5+4',4!+9
++/7'-%5*7/24&4/&-%!4&!!-4!25+!4&4
'!35- !24&!%!/$?/5+ -/4!/-4&!!-4!
<//2N
&'3-+93'3932'/3&/734&42&!4/2''3-/4
)534 '3!,/ '! 7/2 34&47!--+9:!
7'4&/54/-3' !24'/-/$4&!!,/ '! 30!*!2J
4&!'2+'6! !80!2'!-!J- &/74&!'2+'6!
!80!2'!-!3&0!34&!'22%5,!-4J'43 !+'6!29J-
'432!!04'/-94&!2! !23/2+'34!-!23N
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`CCM/!,! Z?
#)98F9F''3/%1),."S-#( (.'%-"#-.),3#(
(."',3),(#(!-L#1.#':C=?M
+1%!0-!!),4M/!;!1,+%,41%!, 6,*-)&1!01%!
N*,#(#*&) ')#,"-),#
/%!1,/&)+)60&06,2/!2//!+1)6 /#1&+$Q/61,20!?>>
4,/ 0,/*,/!Q
,8W86G<BABAE<G<64?@5B7<@8AG
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`CCM&C0Z?B
Works Cited
52*!J!--!4&N
&!4/2'/$/4'6!3
N-'6/$
+'$/2-'2!33J?GDGN
! '++/J&2'34'-N[&4/!34!-4/
*,#(#*&) ')#,"-),#N
/6!OI!J'3'+'49J- 2'4'+
,/ ',!-4! %/%9N\
/,0/3'4'/-/25,
N
/+NAGN33/'4'/-/$!&!23/$ 6-!
/,0/3'4'/-J@>?FN
32'/J54&N[!72'4'-%4!2-+/ '!3/-
4&!!-4!+//2I,,95*7/24&^3
,/ '! &!4/2'3/$-4!23!4'/-+
/4&!2&// N\-
/ '!3/$-/7+! %!I
,/ '! &!4/2'3'-&!/29- 24'!N
3N/!++!2J2'!NJ- N9
-/+5&
N
4&44!-'6!23'492!33J@>@@N
?BAZ?D>N
4+'$$!J2'34N
&!4/2'+'34!-'-%I
!-4';4'/-J!- !2J&'4!-!33
N2!33J
@>>CN
N*,#(#*&) ')#,"-),#
77;
/4$DD2$C$$
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/53&/5+ !+!4/
H !-4'$9490!3/$4!8434&47/2*!44!2$/2
2&!4/2'+-+93'3
H '- 4!84$/22&!4/2'+-+93'353'-%+'229
2!3/52!3
,46,2(+,4%,41,+)67!1!51/%!1,/&))6Q21%,4 ,
6,26(1!511%1)!+ 0&10!)#1,/%!1,/&)+)60&0R
#(#(!-1-N
,2/&+01/21,/*6%3!-/,3& ! 1%!1!51X0Y1%!64+16,2
1, +)67!M 21 &# +,1M 6,2`)) +!! 1, :+ 1!51 1%1 *(!0
6,2/',,#/%!1,/&)+)60&001/&$%1#,/4/ 6!1&+1!/!01&+$Q
,%!/!/!0,*!01/1!$&!01,0!16,2/0!)#2-#,/02!00Q
,46C$22O6KBL$$$4H62#6KH
(4#/4, C$#/2$"60$ H/L$"4#
D -62C2O/4&6C3H/64;
%&)!1%!21%,/,#!3!+1%!)+ !01+!40/!-,/1,/0%,)/)6
012 6*(!04,/ &+$%,&!01%16,2)/&+)67!M4/&1!/`0
11&04&)))&(!)6!!0&!/1,0-,1&++,-&+&,+1! -&!!Q,
#!!)#/!!1,20!&0! ,22!3& !,M+,-&+&,+/1&)!#/,*
+!40--!/M,/-,)&1&&+`00-!!%X0),+$06,2/&+01/21,/
0601%&0&0,(6YQ
%! *,01 &*-,/1+1 1%&+$ #,/ 1%&0 (&+ ,# 00&$+*!+1
202))6&0+`14%!1%!/6,2/1!51&02+&0! Q+01! M6,2/10(
X !-!+ &+$,+6,2/&+01/21,/`0/!.2&/!*!+10Y&01,
K & !+1=%!&0!0+ 002*-1&,+0M
K 0&121!6,2/0,2/!&+1%!!5&$!+!M2 &!+!M+
,+01/&+10M+
K -,&+11,0-!&:!5*-)!0,#%,41%!21%,/20!0
-1%,0M),$,0M+ !1%,01,*(!1%!&/0!M!3!+&#&1`0
&0! Q
N #(#(!-1-
(!02/!+61!516,2%,,0!)),406,21,,*-)&0%1%,0!
1%/!!10(0Q
64BH6L$CM-$23O6KCD$2&M/H-
H$NHH-HBDH66264,;
,/ *,01 00&$+*!+10M 20&+$ ,,(M 14,\%,2/ :)*M ,/
A>\-$!0%,)/)6/1&)!&0$/!1Q21#,/1%&0(&+ ,#+)60&0M
20&+$ 0%,/1!/ -&!! 4&)) )),4 6,2 1, /!))6 &$ &+1, 1%!
/%!1,/&)%,&!0* !&+!%4,/ M0!+1!+!M+ -/$/-%Q
-66D$H$NHH-HBDD/,4/( 4H;
%&)!6,2)/&+)67!+6/+ ,`0&(,(M&1`))!!0&!/1,
& !+1=%!/%!1,/&)0&121&,+,2+/!0!/%&1,21
1%!21%,/M1%!-2)&1&,+,/0!11&+$M+ +6,+01/&+101%!6
*6!2+ !/Q)20M&1`))!*,/!&+1!/!01&+$1,6,2//! !/&#
6,2+)),211%!/%!1,/&)01/1!$&!0,#-,4!/#2)0!+1,/M
-/,*&+!+120&+!00!5!21&3!M,/%&$%)6&+;2!+1&),22!/
/1%!/1%+0,*!(& ,4+1%!01/!!1X2+)!001%1(& `0-,01%0
$,+!3&/)+ !,*!1%!3,&!,#1%!&/$!+!/1&,+YQ
#(#(!-1-N
-66D$36C$C,K3$4HH/L$
,$4C$;
!510&+0,*!$!+/!01!+ 1,!*,/!01/&$%1#,/4/ Q1%!/0
)!+ 1%!*0!)3!01,*(&+$/$2*!+101%1$&3!6,2*,/!1,
4,/(4&1%Q,2*&$%1,+0& !/20&+$L
K 0-!!%
K ,+1/&21,/,-&+&,+#/,*1%!,-&+&,+00!1&,+,#
+!40--!/
K 1%/! ,+M%/! 0M,/)2!(6
K 3& !,!006,+,22!
+!40/1&)!1%1'201060]1%&0!3!+1%--!+! ,+1%&0 6
11%&01&*!+ %!/!`04%1-!,-)!,+,1%0& !0% 1,06
,21&1^*&$%1+,1,8!/0*2%,#+,3&,203,&!#,/6,2
1,+)67!Q
64BH0KDHC$2O6466,2$
D$C -;
! 1, 10!,/-2)&1&,+4%!/!6,2(+,46,24&))!
)!1,:+ 1%!0!0,/10,#$!+/!0M02%0L
N #(#(!-1-
'%N??N?N/,!$!452!
6'!70/'-43'-00/3'-%
'!70/'-43T3!+!44/!-+2%!U
)CCBF<A:/<8JCB<AGF
&#()(.2.C**)-#(!
#1*)#(.- &0 10!
3&))! 1%/,2$% 0,*!
)&//&!0 1%1 2/1!0Z6,2
$2!00! &1Z,--,0&+$
3&!4-,&+10,+ &8!/!+1%,1\
211,+ &002!0Q %,,0&+$
]#!12/! 3&!4-,&+1^ &+
**)-#(! #1*)#(.-,+
1,-&1%1&+1!/!0106,24&))
03!6,21%!4,/(,#),,(&+$
1%/,2$% ,,$)! 0!/%
/!02)101,1/61,:$2/!,21&#
1%! /1&)!0 &1`0 0%,4&+$ 6,2 /! *(&+$ /$2*!+10Q %!
#!12/! 3&!4-,&+10 4&)) ,#1!+ 202))6 ,*! 4&1% +
&+1/, 21&,+1%11!))06,2&1,211%!21%,/+ -/,3& !0
0,*!.2!01&,+01,1%&+(,21Q
/<G4?C886;8FB9G;84L
#.&*"-) ."3*$7&+!-2))01,$!1%!/0,*!,#1%!
*,01 &*-,/1+10-!!%!0&+ +$)&0% #/,* /,2+ 1%!4,/)
!%*,+1%Q
+01! ,# 0!/%&+$ ,,$)! #,/ ]!01 0-!!%!0M^ 1/6
/,40&+$ 0,*! ,# 1%! *,/! /!!+1 0-!!%!0 2/1! &+ 1%&0
#(#(!-1-N
'%N??N@N6'%4'-%4/4&!
/0'-'/-3!4'/-/$4&!!7
/2*',!3T3!+!44/!-+2%!U
*$7&+!M 6 )! !/0 /+$&+$ #/,* ) &*&/ 21&+ 1, /(
2(!/!/$M)!5+ /&0&,\,/1!7M+ /!1%2+!/$Q
(8J2BE>-<@8F)C<A<BAF86G<BA
,01+!40--!/0%3!+
,-&+&,+ 0!1&,+ 4%!/! 1%!6
-,01 !0060 6 ,)2*+&010
+ $2!010 !5-/!00&+$ +
,-&+&,+ 02--,/1! 6
!3& !+!Q #1!+M 1%!0!
21%,/0 /! -/,*&+!+1
)! !/0+ 1%&+(!/04%,/!&+3&1! 61%!,-&+&,+! &1,/01,
,+1/&21!1%!&/3&!4-,&+1,+1,-&Q
'-429^3/++!%!/$+'$/2-'!3/52!3
345 !-43J4&!3!'229+'-*37'++4*!9/5
4/4&!3/52!3,!-4'/-! /6!I
H 00/3'-%'!70/'-43T-!74U 43!
H
'4+0!!&!3/$4&!9
T-!74U,%:'-!
N #(#(!-1-
H
!7/2*',!3
T-!74U-!737!3'4!
V2!4!+/%'-4/4*! 6-4%!/$^3
'%'4+3532'04'/-W
8?86G4A4E:H@8AG4G<I8G8KGGB
4A4?LM8
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`CGM&C0Z?C
#(#(!-1-N
0E<G<A:)HEB7<8F
!<!4/-&/7&//3'-%4!84$/22&!4/2'+
-+93'3,'%&4/--!44//52!80!2'!-!3372'4'-%
/ '!3I
H %$(')*)%'F($*$F(
#%-&'$((&')%)
%$)-)%'))-).%*%%(=30!!&
'3 !+'6!2! - !80!2'!-! '$$!2!-4+94&-J
39J--/-9,/53! '40/34N- 4&!
!80!2'!-!/$ !+'6!2'-%30!!&4/+2%!
2/7 '302/+9%/'-%4/! '$$!2!-4$/2
4++J+!Z/ '! 7&'4!,-'-0/3'4'/-/$
0/7!24&-'4'3$/27/,-/$/+/2'-
7&!!+&'2N
H %))($()%$(.%*'%.
-&'$((.%*'+,&%$)())
'(#"')%%''$)'%#.%*'(=/
9/5$!!+6+' 4'/-J2%!J5-!3!J/2 '3%534O
*-/7+! %!4&!3!$!!+'-%3J- 2!,'-
9/523!+$4&44&!0/'-4/$9/52!339'3-/44/
N #(#(!-1-
2%5!7'4&9/524!84J544/' !-4'$9&/7-
7&9'47372'44!-4/02/ 5!024'5+2
2!30/-3!3'-4&!5 '!-!N
$#/HHC/KH/64D
K )!--,0&+$&!4-,&+10!-/1&,+0&!4-,&+10
K !4,/(&*!0-&+&,+0/!!+0%,1
#(#(!-1-N
7J;
$,-4M$$4$O
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J345 !-437'++!+!4/
H !-4'$9335,04'/-3
H '$$!2!-4'4!!47!!-6+5!- !32'04'6!
335,04'/-3
H -+9:!&/7335,04'/-3$$!44&!
2&!4/2'+3'454'/-
%!+/%!1,/&))6+)67&+$+616-!,#1!51M,+!01!-6,24&))
N#(-# 2#(!.'*-#)(
4+11,1(!0/! !/&0& !+1&+$1%!002*-1&,+0* !6
1%!4/&1!/,/0-!(!/Q
8VA<A:FFH@CG<BAF
335,04'/-32!5-344! !+'!$34&43500/244&!
2!3/-'-%'-4&!2%5,!-4N
,/!5*-)!M1%!1&,+)&;!00,&1&,+XY*(!01%!
#,)),4&+$/$2*!+1L
-'6!23+*%2/5- &!*3$/2%5-/-42/+
3&/5+ !!+','-4! !53!,/342','-+3
/4'-;2!2,3'++!%++9V!N%NJ34!+'-%4&!,J
052&3'-%4&2/5%&5- !2%2/5- 3+!3W-
4&!2!$/2!/-+9+7Z' '-%'4':!-37/5+ !
35)!4! 4/4&!3!&!*3N
#(-# 2#(!.'*-#)(N
+ 1%! #,)),4&+$ 1&3&16M 4! &+3&1! 6,2 1, 1/6 1, & !+1
002*-1&,+0&+,**,+/$2*!+1Q
#78AG<9L<A:4FFH@CG<BAF<A(,QF
4E:H@8AG
32! !2J9/5,5343*9/523!+$7&42!4&!
5-344! !+'!$34&4,534!425!$/24&!^3+'-!
/$2!3/-'-%4/!!$$!4'6!J524!O
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`D?M&C0Z?D
#6,2%!(! +6,/)),#1%!0!&1!*0#/,*1%!)&01M6,2/!
,//!1Q %!0! /! )) 2+011! 6 1%! M 21 1%! !)&!#0
*201!!-1! 66,2M1%!/! !/M1,#2))6!+ ,/0!1%!&/)&+!
,#/!0,+&+$Q
N#(-# 2#(!.'*-#)(
!/!`0 1%! 1/&(6 -/1 ,# & !+1&+$ 002*-1&,+0L
002*-1&,+01%1)&$+4&1%1%!/! !//!,#1!+21,*1&))6
!-1! + 1%!/!#,/! *(! +)60&0 *,/! &92)1Q # 6,2
/!-!/0,+4%,$/!!01%12+&3!/0)($/,2+ %!(0/!
&+!8!1&3!M 1%!+ 1%! 002*-1&,+0 2+ !/)6&+$ 1%! `0
/$2*!+1 /! %/ !/ 1, & !+1Q # 6,2 /! -!/0,+ 4%,
&0$/!!01%12+&3!/0)($/,2+ %!(0/!&+!8!1&3!M1%!+
1%!002*-1&,+02+ !/)6&+$1%!`0/$2*!+1/!!0&!/1,
& !+1Q
+ 1%! #,)),4&+$ 1&3&16M 4! &+3&1! 6,2 1, 1/6 1, & !+1
002*-1&,+0&+,**,+/$2*!+1Q
#78AG<9L<A:4FFH@CG<BA<ACEB:HA
4E:H@8AG
!4^3429'44&!/4&!2 '2!4'/-N
'$$/2 37!-4!2J%5-6'/+!-!02!6!-4'/-
/2%-':4'/-J2%5!34&!$/++/7'-%I
-'6!23+*%2/5- &!*32!!33!-4'+4/+/3!
! +9+//0&/+!3'-/52+734&4++/7,'++'/-3/$
#(-# 2#(!.'*-#)(N
%5-34/!- 50'-4&!&- 3/$'- '6' 5+34-
!+!64! 2'3*/$/,,'44'-%6'/+!-!!&9!2N
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`D?M&C0Z?E
M6O8$D6&DDK38H/64D
002*-1&,+0 + ! 1!$,/&7! &+1, 14, &8!/!+1 16-!0
X)2! + !0/&-1&3!YM 4%&% + *(! & !+1&+$ 1%!*
!0&!/Q%&0 &01&+1&,+!14!!+16-!0,#002*-1&,+0&0* !
&+/,4+!+ !!)!6`0,,(-%#(!."#!"./-.#)(-F
N#(-# 2#(!.'*-#)(
/4?H8FFH@CG<BAF
&!72'4!202!$!23/-!6+5!/6!2-/4&!2N
,/!5*-)!M/!12/+&+$1,2+&3!/0)($/,2+ %!(0M,/$2+
/&$%10 !1!0*,/!$!+!/))6Q3)2!002*-1&,+4,2) ),,(
)&(!1%&0L
2/%5-/-42/+I&!72'4!26+5!305+'3$!49
/6!20!23/-+$2!! /,N
2/Z%5-2'%&43I&!72'4!26+5!30!23/-+
$2!! /,/6!205+'3$!49N
,46,2*61%&+(M]4!))0,*!,+!4%,40-/,\$2+/&$%10
4,2) 0!!$2+00-/,3& &+$)."-!/0,+)#/!! ,*+ -2)&
0#!16Q^ # 0,M 1%!+ 6,2 /! /!))6 2+ !/01+ &+$ %,4
002*-1&,+0 ,-!/1!Q , 2+-( 1%!0! 3)2! 002*-1&,+0
#(-# 2#(!.'*-#)(N
#2/1%!/M 4! *,3! ,+ 1, 1%! +!51 16-! ,# 002*-1&,+L
!0/&-1&3!Q
8F6E<CG<I8FFH@CG<BAF
&!72'4!2&3!+'!$3/54&/7!6!294&'-%-
!6!29/-!'3/273N
,/ !5*-)!M #/,* ,2/ -/!3&,20 !5*-)!M 4! & !+1&:! 1%!
#,)),4&+$002*-1&,+L]/&*&+)0/!)460/&*&+)0Q%!6
, +,1 !5&01 0 )4\& &+$ &1&7!+0 !#,/!%+ Q^ + 1%&0
002*-1&,+M 1%! 4/&1!/ &0 002*&+$ ($/,2+ %!(+
1%/&*&+)0M21)4\& &+$&1&7!+&0,+)6)4\& &+$
2+1&)1%!6/!+,1Q!/!+,1,/+!/1&+46Q!!,*!
0,*!,+!4%,,4+0$2+Q!!,*!0,*!,+!4%,20!0
$2+#,/-/,1!1&,+,/$$/!00&,+Q%&0002*-1&,+&00%/&+$
!)&!#1%!4/&1!/%0,21/&*&+)0Q!0/&-1&3!002*-1&,+0
&+ $2+ ,+1/,) !1!0 /! 16-&))6 * ! ,21 $2+0M $2+
,4+!/0M/&*&+)0M&1&7!+0M0#!16M)40M+ *,/!Q
+1%!#,)),4&+$1&3&16M4!&+3&1!6,21,1/61, &01&+$2&0%
!14!!+3)2!+ !0/&-1&3!002*-1&,+0Q
N#(-# 2#(!.'*-#)(
<FG<A:H<F;<A:58GJ88AI4?H84A7
78F6E<CG<I84FFH@CG<BAF
/79/54294/' !-4'$94&!6+5!- !32'04'6!
335,04'/-3/-345 !-4+/- !4$/2%'6!-!33I
45 !-4+/- !4$/2%'6!-!333&/5+ !/-4'-5!
5- !24&!-!84 ,'-'3424'/-!53!4&! !4'3
&524'-%,!2'-3!/-/,'++9N
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`D?M&C0Z?F
DDK38H/64DC$36#/$#
%!002*-1&,+0 4!*(!+ 1%! 002*-1&,+04!& !+1
16-&))601!*#/,*,2/)&3! !5-!/&!+!0Q%!601!*#/,*1%!
#(-# 2#(!.'*-#)(N
3&!4-,&+104!%3! !3!),-! 0! ,+,2/!5-!/&!+!0M,2/
,**2+&1&!0M + ,2/ & !+1&1&!0Q (!M #,/ !5*-)!M %&$%
0%,,)012 !+14%,%0'20102/3&3! *000%,,)0%,,1&+$Q
+1%&0)&-M**,+7)!7M012 !+11/',/61,+!*+
,2$)0&$%%,,)M$&3!00-!!%1++1&\$2+/))6Q1
,+7)!7`0%&$% 0%,,)&+ /()+ M),/& M 0%,,1!/ (&))!
?E %&$% 0%,,) 012 !+10 &+ @>?FQ 1 40 1/$! 6M ,+! 1%1
%0%--!+! ,2+1)!001&*!0&+ 1%! +&1! 11!0M + ,+!
1%1 /!1! (&/,1& *,*!+1 #,/ !*, &! /%!1,/& #/,*
1%!02/3&3,/0+ 1%!-/!+10,#1%!*2/ !/! %&) /!+Q%&0
0-!!%40* !0%,/1)6#1!/ 1%!*000%,,1&+$Q1%1%!
3& !,X3&!41&*!&0?>LB>Y+ 1%!+& !+1=%!002*-1&,+0
2+ !/)6&+$%!//$2*!+1Q
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`D?M/!,! Z?
#)9:F9F&),#-./(..)(,/'*CR&&S
3
+ 1%! #,)),4&+$ 1&3&16M 4! &+3&1! 6,2 1, 1/6 1, & !+1
1%! 002*-1&,+0 1%1 ** ,+7)!7 *(!0 &+ %!/ 0-!!%
02--,/1&+$$2+,+1/,)Q
N#(-# 2#(!.'*-#)(
#78AG<9L<A:G;84FFH@CG<BAFHA78E
@@4!BAM4?8MQFFC886;
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`D?M&C0Z?G
-ODDK38H/64#$4H/( H/64
HH$CD&6C6KC622$,$C/H/4,
+! 6,2 + & !+1 1%! 002*-1&,+0 2+ !/)6&+$ 6,2/
/$2*!+1M6,2+-,&+11%!*,211,6,2//! !/0+ ,2+1!/
1%!*Q,/!5*-)!M&+1%!012 !+1),+#,/$&3!+!00/$2*!+1M
*&$%1%&$%)&$%1,1%!/1&*!0&+%&01,/61%11%!$,3!/+*!+1
%0 &+1!/3!+! 1, %!)- &10 &1&7!+0 1, &*-/,3! 1%! !,+,*6
X!Q$QM,3& YQ*&$%1)0,%&$%)&$%11&*!0&+%&01,/64%!+1%!
#(-# 2#(!.'*-#)(N
$,3!/+*!+1%!)-! &+ 201/&!0#,/1%!0*!/!0,+X!Q$QM))
1/!!1M21,*,1&3!YQ6& !+1&+$*6,4+002*-1&,+0M+
:$2/!,214%,*&$%1 &0$/!!4&1%*!M+ 4%6M+ -)+*6
/$2*!+1/,2+ 1%1Q
6MH6D$DDK38H/64D/46KC
-$H6C/ 242OD/D
+!,#1%!!5&1&+$+ #/201/1&+$1%&+$0,21)!/+&+$%,4
1, & !+1 002*-1&,+0 &0 6,2 4&)) 01/1 1, 0!! 1%!*
!3!/64%!/!Q ,2 4&)) !$&+ 1, 2+ !/01+ 4%6 1%,2$%1#2)
-!,-)!+ &0$/!!0,3!%!*!+1)6,+!/1&+&002!0Q216,2
4&))!$&+ 1, 2+ !/01+ %,44!+01/1 1,:+ ,**,+
$/,2+ Q
+1%!/%!1,/&)0&121&,+&+-/1&2)/M0%,)/00,*!1&*!0
/!#!/ 1, ,+01/&+10 &+ + /$2*!+1M ,/ #1,/0 1%1 %!)- ,/
%2/1-!/0,+`0&)&161,$!11%!&/-,&+1/,001,+2 &!+!Q
002*-1&,+0 /! ,+01/&+10 &+ + /$2*!+1M 0, &1 + !
&*-,/1+11,+)67!1%!*4%!+4/&1&+$+ /! &+$Q
#6,2/!+)67&+$1%!/%!1,/&)!8!1&3!+!00,#0,*!,+!
!)0!`0 /$2*!+1M -/1 ,# 1%1 +)60&0 0%,2) &+)2 !L ?Q
& !+1&+$002*-1&,+0* !&+1%!/$2*!+1M+ @Q+)60&0
,# 4%!1%!/ ,/ +,1 1%! 002*-1&,+0 4,2) %&+ !/ 1%!
!8!1&3!+!00,#1%!/$2*!+1Q
/6 &1 %!/! 1,$!1%!/ 0 )00 ,/ &+ $/,2-L 41% 1%!
#,)),4&+$3& !,)&-X3&!41&*!&0GLCGY#/,*+&+1!/3&!4+
0!!,2+20!002*-1&,+01,&$124%61%!6/!2+)!
N#(-# 2#(!.'*-#)(
1, 2+ !/01+ !% ,1%!/M + /!;!1 ,+ %,4 1%!&/ )&3!
!5-!/&!+!0*6
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`D?M/!,! Z@
#)9:F:F)21-C',,--#(!#(.,0#1N4-&(0-
/,(,(J),#!#(&N/(#.K3#(-*(
+1%!#,)),4&+$1&3&16M4!&+3&1!6,21,1/61,/!;!1,+
1%!002*-1&,+0* !!14!!+1%!0!14,-!,-)!Q/61,4/&1!
?>>4,/ 0,/*,/!06,2&+1!//,$1!1%&0&+1!/1&,+Q
#(-# 2#(!.'*-#)(N
,8W86G<BAFFH@CG<BAF@478
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`D?M&C0Z@>
Works Cited
2/7-!JN!'+J- 4524N!!+!9N
3*'-%
4&!'%&45!34'/-3I5' !4/2'4'+&'-*'-%N
D4&! N2!-4'!++I//*!-JJ@>>?N
/8!73N[,2233'-%-4!26'!7Z!:3+-
- 52!-2!!-N\0+/ ! 9'- 30-JA?
N#(-# 2#(!.'*-#)(
7I;
$,-4M$$4$O
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J345 !-437'++!+!4/
H !-4'$90243/$-+94'+4&!3'3344!,!-43
H 2'4!--+94'+4&!3'3344!,!-4
+6 ,# 20 %3! )!/+! M &0200! M 4/&11!+M + & !+1&:!
1%!0&0011!*!+10&+))16-!0,#4/&1&+$Q,*!1&*!0M%,4!3!/M
1%!0&0011!*!+10/! !0/&! &+ 4601%1/!$!+!/&M0&#
,+!16-!,#1%!0&0011!*!+1,2) 4,/(&++616-!,#1!51Q
/&1&+$ &0 +!3!/$!+!/&Q +01! 1%!/! /! &8!/!+116-!0 ,#
N(&2-#&-"#--'(-
1%!0&0 011!*!+10 #,/ &8!/!+1 -2/-,0!0Q + 1%&0 0!1&,+M 4!
4&)) &0200 + -/1&! 4%1 /! ))! +)61&) 1%!0&0
011!*!+10Q
%!$!+!/) $2& !)&+!0#,/1%!0&0 011!*!+1001&)) --)6Q+
1%! #,)),4&+$1&3&16M & !+1 )) 1%! 3&!6,2`3! /!!&3!
,211%!0&0011!*!+10Q
-;8F<FG4G8@8AGF
!+!4/8$/2!6!290'!!/$ 6'!9/5^6!
2!!'6! /544&!3'3344!,!-43N
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`DAM&C0Z@?
,01)&(!)6M6,2%3!))% 0&*&)/!5-!/&!+!0)!/+&+$,21
1%!0&0011!*!+10Q,41%16,2/!&+,))!$!M&1+!%!)-#2)
(&2-#&-"#--'(-N
1,,+0& !/ &8!/!+116-!0,#1%!0&0011!*!+10Q%!+6,2/!
4/&1&+$1,+)67!M!/1&+16-!,#1%!0&0&0+!! ! Q
CHD6&442OH/ 2H-$D/D
DHH$3$4H
++ +)61&)1!51&+ -/1&2)/M6,2/1%!0&0011!*!+1 4&))
00!/1)&*X*(!+/$2*!+1Y,211%!460,*!1%&+$
40M&0M,/4&))!Q,/+$)&0%)00!0M6,2/1%!0&0*&$%1*(!
)&* ,21 1%!*! &+ ,,(Q + 20&+!00 )00M 6,2/
1%!0&0011!*!+1*&$%1!)&*,21 16,2+)67! Q+
%&01,/6)00M6,2/1%!0&0011!*!+1*&$%1*(!)&*,21
1%!20!,#+!3!+1Q
+!% 0!M1%!/!&0 + ,#012 6X1,-&Y 4%&%
6,2%3!012 &! T+)67! !+,2$%1,00!/1Q
!#'!'&!
'(! $!%
'!1,#012 6
X 1M,,(Y
&0,3!/6#/,*1%!
012 6
N(&2-#&-"#--'(-
A4?LG<64?G;8F<FFG4G8@8AG8K4@C?8
--+93'3/$4&!345 !-4+/- !4$/2%'6!-!33
42!6!+34&4$/2%'6!-!337'++//344&!-4'/-+
!/-/,99++/7'-%/22/7!234/024''04!,/2!
'-4&!!/-/,9N
+1%&0!5*-)!M4!$!11%!#,)),4&+$L
!#'"'&"
'(! $!%
12 !+1),+ !1
#,/$&3!+!00
#,/$&3!+!004&))
,,011%!+1&,+)
!,+,*66
)),4&+$,//,4!/0
1,-/1&&-1!*,/!
&+1%!!,+,*6
%!1,-&&0]1%!012 !+1),+ !1#,/$&3!+!00^!20!1%1
&0 1%! 1 1%1 40+)67! Q %! )&* &01%1 ]#,/$&3!+!00
4&)) ,,01 1%! +1&,+) !,+,*6 6 )),4&+$ ,//,4!/0 1,
-/1&&-1!*,/!&+1%!!,+,*6Q^%!1%!0&0)&$+04&1%4%1
6,2 %3! !!+ 12$%1 &+ 1%! -01Q ,4!3!/M 4! )0, %3!
(&2-#&-"#--'(-N
#,20 %!/! ,+ *(&+$ )&*0 ,21 1%! 46 1%! 0,*!1%&+$
X!Q$QM #,/$&3!+!00Y &0 X!Q$QM !+!:1 1, 1%! !,+,*6YQ %!0!
16-!0 ,#1%!0&0 011!*!+10 /! &8!/!+1 1%+/$2*!+1\0!
1%!0&0011!*!+10M4%&%4!!5-)&+&++,1%!/%-1!/Q
+1%!#,)),4&+$1&3&16M1/6& !+1&+$1%! &8!/!+1-/10
,#1%!0&0011!*!+1Q
#78AG<9L<A:GBC<64A76?4<@<A
4A4?LG<64?G;8F<FFG4G8@8AG
/7J9/54294/' !-4'$94&!4/0'- +','-4&!
$/++/7'-%!8,0+!I
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`DAM&C0Z@@
##/4,C$D64H66KC42OH/ 2
N(&2-#&-"#--'(-
H-$D/DDHH$3$4H
%&)! 0,*! 1%!0&0 011!*!+10 ,+)6 %3! 1,-& + )&*M
0,*! 1%!0&0 011!*!+10 )0, &+)2 ! /!0,+M ,/ 4%1 0,*!
-!,-)!))1%!]0,4%1^,#1%!0&0Q
!#'#'&#
'(! $!% +'&
'!1,#012 6
X 1M,,(Y
&0,3!/6#/,*1%!
012 6
%61%! &0,3!/6
*11!/0
,2 *&$%1 %3! !!+ 12$%1 1, )&01 A /!0,+0 1%1 6,2 1%!+
!5-),/!&+A-/$/-%00-/1,#:3!\-/$/-%!006Q,/
,))!$!4/&1&+$+ !6,+ M4!!+,2/$!6,21,*,3!!6,+
1%&0 01/212/! 1, *,/! 0,-%&01&1! /!0,+0 1%1 6,2 1%!+
2+-(#,/1%!/! !/Q!/!`0+!5*-)!,#1%!!/)&!/1%!0&0
011!*!+14&1%/!0,+ ! L
%!1,/&) +)60&0 ,# 14, /&,10 0%,40 1%1 +!40 *! &
-/!0!+1)(/&,1!/00 +$!/,20M&//1&,+)/&*&+)0M4%&)!
4%&1! /&,1!/0 /!!&3! *2% *,/! 06*-1%!1&
%/1!/&71&,+Z -%!+,*!+,+ 1%1 %0 0!!*&+$)6 !!+
-/!3)!+1&+*!/&+*! &#,/1)!011%! -01:#16 6!/0Q
*'- !,+!3*&,&**,!.+'*!',!&;, !+'.*
*!&'*+ *'* *+* '& * !& %! , ,
!&5-&+ **+E (*(,!'&+ '-, * & + (+
!+-++!'&+ '& '/ ,' ((*' +'$-,!'&+ ,' ,
(&2-#&-"#--'(-N
(*'$%+, ,*!',!&(*+&,, !,!+',*'!,&
&,X -1! #/,*//&0%YQ
+ 1%! #,)),4&+$ 1&3&16M 1/6 1, & !+1 1%! -/10 &+ 1%&0
+)61&)1%!0&0011!*!+1Q
#78AG<9LG;8GBC<6BC<A<BA4A7
E84FBA
/,!4',!3J4&!,/34 '$;5+4024/$72'4'-%4&!
4&!3'3'3,*'-%4&
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`DAM&C0Z@A
-$4O6KC$&$$2/4,DHK 1
,*!1&*!0 &1 + ! %/ 1, -21 &+1, 4,/ 0 1%! +)61&)
&0,3!/6 6,2 %3! * !M 4%&)! )0, :+ &+$ 4!3&+$ &+
/!0,+Q %&)! 1%! ,/&$&+ ,# 1%! ]*$& 1%!0&0 011!*!+1^ &0
2+(+,4+M6,24&)):+ &1,+*+64!0&1!01/6&+$1,/!(
,4+1%!1%!0&0011!*!+1Q%!$&%!0&011!*!+10!10
6,22-1,4/&1!++)61&)1%!0&0011!*!+1L
6 ),,(&+$ 1 UUUUUM 4! + 0!! UUUUUUUM 4%&% *,01
/! !/0 ,+`10!!Q%&0&0&*-,/1+1!20!UUUUUUUQ
%!:/01)+(&01%!1,-&X4%16,2/!+)67&+$YQ%!
0!,+ )+(&01%!)&*X4%16,2 &0,3!/! YQ1 0]*,01
/! !/0 ,+`1 0!!^ 0 /!*&+ !/ 1%1 6,2/ )&* 0%,2) !
0,*!1%&+$,1%!/0*&$%1 &0$/!!4&1%Q10%,2) +`1!,3&,20Q
%!1%&/ )+(&01%!/!0,+X4%6&1*11!/0YQ!/!`0%,4&1
4,2) 4,/(4&1%,+!,#1%!1%!0&0011!*!+1020! !/)&!/L
6 ),,(&+$ 1 %! '.* ' ,/' *!',+M 4! + 0!!
1%1, &/+%!(*+&,+$#*!',*++&*'-+;
(&2-#&-"#--'(-N
!**,!'&$*!%!&$+;/ !$, 1*+1%(, ,!,'/ !,
*!',*+M 4%&% *,01 /! !/0 , +,1 0!!Q %&0 &0 &*-,/1+1
!20!, !+'.**!&'*+*'**+* '&*
!&%!, ,!&5-&+**+E(*(,!'&+'-,*
&+ (+!+-++!'&+'& '/,'((*' +'$-,!'&+,'
, (*'$%+, ,*!',!&(*+&,, !,!+',*'!,
&&,Q
#1!/20&+$1%!*$&1%!0&0M6,20%,2) 1%!+/!3&0!&1&+1,
0!+1!+!,/14,1%1 ,!0+,1&+)2 !))1%!)+$2$!#/,*1%!
1!*-)1!Q
36#/3$4H4#H-$42OH/ 2
-$D/DHH$3$4H
&1% 1%! !5*-)!0 #/,* 14, 012 !+10M ++% ,5 +
!1%!/ //&0%M ,+ )0(+ -+!0! +1!/+*!+1 +
/&)&7! /!-/!0!+11&,+0 ,# )( -/,1!010M /!0-!1&3!)6M 4!
%,-! 6,2 + 0!! 1%1 +)61&) 1%!0&0 011!*!+10 ,8!/ +
,--,/12+&161,/&1&))6!5-),/!+&002!1%18!10+60-!1
,#6,2/& !+1&1&!0Q%!+4!20!,2//%!1,/&)+)60&0&)&1&!0
1,&+1!//,$1!1%!,/+!/0,#1%!4,/) 1%10!!(1, !:+!20M
!01/,6 20M ,+1/,) 20M ,/ !)!/1! 20M 4! *(! %,&!0 0
!*&0Q!!+,2/$!6,21,,++!11,1%!1!5106,2/!
+)67&+$+ 1%!1,-&06,2/!!5-),/&+$Q
N(&2-#&-"#--'(-
Works Cited
/8J--&N[-%5%!- !&5,-':4'/-
'-+3*-0-!3!-4!2-,!-4/5,!-43N\
/5-%&/+23'-2'4'-%N
/+N?FV@>@?WI
&4403IRR9/5-%3&/+23'-72'4'-%N/2%R'- !8N0&0R
93'7R24'+!R6'!7RA@?
',03/-J2'*N['6!93/$//*'-%4
&!3'3N\&4403IRR!2'*3',03/-N3'4!3N%2'--!++N! 5R
!&'-%R;6!793N&4,+
22'3&J!4&!2N[&'4!2/4!343J+*'/43I
'+':! !02!3!-44'/-'-,!2'-
! 'N\
/5-%&/+23'-2'4'-%N
&4403IRR9/5-%3&/+23'-72'4'-%N/2%R'- !8N0&0R
93'7R24'+!R6'!7R@E?R@GC
(&2-#&-"#--'(-N
N(&2-#&-"#--'(-
0,#-#(!-)-%-(N
N0,#-#(!-)-%-(
7+;
9
:
/4K4
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'33!4'/-/-[2'4'-%4/*!
4- J\9/57'++!+!4/
H 2'4!-2%5,!-44'6!!3394&4 273/-
9/52/7-0!23/-+!80!2'!-!4/4*!
30!';34-!/--'335!
0,#-#(!-)-%-(-#)()/,/#0N
!6'3'4I&4'3,/ '! &!4/2'3O
+ 1%! /&1! 1, !/+ !5!/&0! !),4M /!;!1 ,+ %,4 6,2/
!*, &! !5-!/&!+!0 &+;2!+! 6,2/ 01+! ,+ -/1&2)/
&002!Q
0E<G8GB&84EA2BHEB7L0;8A
-4><A:G4A68
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`DEM&C0Z@B
N0,#-#(!-)-%-(-#)()/,/#0
, 1(! 01+ ,+ -/1&2)/ 1,-& &0 1, /$2! #,/
-/1&2)/-,&+1,#3&!4Q214%1 ,!0&1*!+1,]/$2!^R
%!4,/ ]/$2*!+1^+,+'2/!2-2+-)!0+1+,1&,+0
,#-!,-)!#/,*,--,0&+$*-00%,21&+$1!%,1%!/Q21
0 !! ,+!0 -,&+10 ,21M ]/1%!/ 1%+ + !&1%!/T,/
-/,-,0&1&,+M /$2*!+1 &0 *2)1&-)!+ ,*-)!5Q^+01! ,#
0&*-)6%,,0&+$,+!,#14,0& !0M4%&%#/!.2!+1)6/! 2!0
,*-)!5&002!&+1,#)0!&+/6M/$2*!+1&01%!*!1%, &)
-/!0!+11&,+ ,# -/!&0! )&* 1%1 %0 ,+0& !/! +
06+1%!0&7! +2*!/,20 &8!/!+1-!/0-!1&3!0,+1,-&Q
+ 1%&0 0!1&,+ ,# 1%! ,,(M 6,2 4&)) -/1&! 4/&1&+$ 1,
1(!01+ ,++&002!1%1&0-!/0,+))6*!+&+$#2)1,6,2Q
!4&))*,3!46#/,*1%&+(&+$,#/$2*!+100]+!21/)^
,/],'!1&3!Q^&+!)),#20%3!, &!01%1/&+$ &8!/!+1
!5-!/&!+!0+ 460,#*,3&+$1%/,2$%1%!4,/) M4!4+1
1, /!,$+&7! 1%1 +6 /$2*!+1 &0 + /$2*!+1 * ! #/,*
-/1&2)/ ),1&,+Q , ,+! 0-!(0 #/,* ]+,4%!/!^Z))
/$2*!+10/!0%-! 6,2/& !+1&1&!0+ )&3! !5-!/&!+!0Q
,4!3!/M1,061%1/$2*!+10/!+,1,'!1&3!,/+!21/)
&0+,11%!0*!006&+$/$2*!+1&0*!/!)6-!/0,+),-&+&,+Q
8!1&3!/$2*!+10+!! 1,!02--,/1! 6)!/M-!/020&3!
!3& !+!M211%!(&+ 0,#!3& !+!6,2-/!0!+1+ %,46,2
%,,0!1,-/!0!+11%1!3& !+!/!0%-! 64%,6,2/!+
%,46,2&+%&11%!4,/) Q%20M6,2/$,)&0,1%1,*(!
4!))\02--,/1! )&*+ 1,%!)-/! !/02+ !/01+ %,4+
4%66,2/-/1&2)/($/,2+ 0%-!01%!466,2%3!,*!
1,1%&03&!4Q
0,#-#(!-)-%-(-#)()/,/#0N
,4/&1!+!0061%11(!001+ ,+-/1&2)/&002!M6,2
4&))#,)),41%!0!01!-0L
?Q !+1+&002!,#-!/0,+)+ -2)&&+1!/!01
@Q !0!/%1,:+ ,211%!3&))!-,0&1&,+0,+1%&0&002!
AQ ,+0& !/%,46,2/,4+!*, &! !5-!/&!+!0&+;2!+!
6,2/-!/0-!1&3!,+1%&0&002!
BQ 3)21!+ 06+1%!0&7!6,2/!5-!/&!+!04&1%6,2/
/!0!/%:+ &+$0&+,/ !/1,#,/*2)1!6,2/-,0&1&,+
X1%!!+1/)/$2*!+1T1%!0&0Y
4L/HH/64DH6$#"$)$ H"4#
C/H$
+1%&0&+1/, 21&,+1,1%!0!1&,+]/&1&+$1,(!1+ M^
4! &+3&1! 6,2 1, /! 0,*! 0*-)! !0060 #/,* ,1%!/ &+1
/6`0 ,))!$! 012 !+10Q ! %3! )0, &+)2 ! 0,*!
&+3&11&,+0 1, 4/&1! 0%/! 6 4/&1&+$ -/,#!00,/0 1 &+1
/6`0,))!$!Q
N0,#-#(!-)-%-(-#)()/,/#0
GH78AG0E<G<A:
!7/5+ +'*!4/'-+5 !345 !-472'4'-%'-4&'3
3!4'/-N$9/52!'-4!2!34! '-05+'3&'-%9/52
7/2*J0+!3!;++/544&'3$/2,- 35,'40'!!/$
9/5272'4'-%$2/,9/5272'4'-%+33N!7'++7/2*
7'4&9/54/%!4'405+'3&! N
-[&!!23'-- !24&!5%J\'-429^3+5,
','9&/*2'2%5!34&4' +!34!2-7/,!-
&6!!!-5- !22!02!3!-4! - 34!2!/490! '-
,'-342!,,!2'-,! ' 5!4/3425452+
2'3,N
+1%!/&1!1,!/+!),4M/!;!1,+4%16,2%3!'201/! M
#,20&+$&+-/1&2)/,+%,(/&`0!*, &! !5-!/&!+!0Q
0,#-#(!-)-%-(-#)()/,/#0N
0E<G8GB&84EA,8W86G<A:BA;B>E<QF
FF4L
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`DEM&C0Z@C
,41%1 6,2 %3! % 0,*! 1&*! 1, /! !5*-)!0 +
1%&+(,216,2/,4+!5-!/&!+!0M4!&+3&1!6,21,/!1!+
!0061%11(!001+ ,++&002!Q
N0,#-#(!-)-%-(-#)()/,/#0
#AI<G4G<BAFGBJE<G8-4><A:G4A7
FF<:A@8AG*EB@CGF
&!&04!23'-4&'33!4'/-3&/5+ 02!02!9/5$/2
/,0+!4'-%/-!/$4&!3!35,,4'6!72'4'-%
33'%-,!-43N&!3!!8,0+!32!33'%-,!-434&4
7!2!/,,!- N
(($#$)-#&"<1
2'4!-!3394&4/22!43,'35- !234- '-%J
,'32!02!3!-44'/-J/2,'3/-!04'/-/54
/,,5-'494/7&'&9/5!+/-%N&!3!,'%&4!
5-$'234!2!/490!34&49/5&6!!- 52! N&'3
!3393&/5+ !4+!34$/52$5++0%!3'-+!-%4&-
'-+5 !7/2*3'4! 0%!7'4&4+!344&2!!
3/52!3N
/2!8,0+!J^,,!,!2/$!-J7&'&'3/$4!-
,'32!02!3!-4! 33+*!23N7/5+ 72'4!-!339
4&4;234!80+'-34&!,'3/-!04'/-4&47!2!
3+*!23- 4&!-53!!6' !-!4/3&/74&47!2!
-/4N&'3!6' !-!-!+!- /$0!23/-+
!80!2'!-!- /543' !3/52!3N
0,#-#(!-)-%-(-#)()/,/#0N
7*;
$,-4M$$4$O
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H !-4'$90243/$-2%5,!-44'6!4&!3'3
344!,!-4
H !<!4/-+'6! !80!2'!-!- ' !-4'4'!34/
5'+ -2%5,!-44'6!4&!3'3344!,!-4
+%-1!/?AM4! &0200! 1%!,--,/12+&1&!0#,/+)61&)
1%!0&0 011!*!+10Q + 1%&0 %-1!/M 4! 4&)) !5-),/! +
,!.'(--#/-"#--'(-N
/$2*!+11&3! 1%!0&0 011!*!+1M ,+! 1%1 &0 4/&11!+ #,/
&8!/!+1-2/-,0!Q
CHD6&4C,K3$4HH/L$H-$D/D
DHH$3$4H
%! $!+!/) $2& !)&+!0 #,/ 1%!0&0 011!*!+10 01&)) --)6#/,*
%-1!/?AQ++/$2*!+11&3!1!51M&+-/1&2)/M6,2/1%!0&0
011!*!+1 4&)) 00!/1 )&* X*(! + /$2*!+1Y ,21 1%!
460,*!1%&+$+ '-$!Q0,--,0! 1,1%!+)61&)1%!0&0
011!*!+1M1%!/$2*!+11&3!1%!0&0&0#,20! ,+%+$!M4&1%
1,-&M )&* X !*+ &+$%+$!YM + /!0,+X#,/1%1
%+$!YQ
!#'!'&
!
'(! $!%
'!1T)!T!/0,+T !X!Q$Q
)4Y
%+$!1%10%,2) %--!+1,
1%!,'!1T-)!T-!/0,+T& !
N,!.'(--#/-"#--'(-
E:H@8AG4G<I8-;8F<FG4G8@8AG
&!/++!%! ,'33'/-02/!333&/5+ !&-%! 4/
/5-4$/2/4&&'%&4!343/2!3- 4&!342!-%4&/$
!842522'5+23,/-%'4300+'-43N
+1%&0!5*-)!M4!$!11%!#,)),4&+$L
!#'"'&
"
'(! $!%
%!,))!$! *&00&,+-/,!00
%,2) !%+$! 1,,2+1
#,/,1%%&$%1!010,/!0+ 1%!
01/!+$1%,#!51/2//&2)/0
*,+$&10--)&+10Q
%!1,-&&04%16,21%&+(+!! 01,%+$!X)4M-/,!00M
!1QYM+ 1%!)&*X,#1!+!$&++&+$4&1%1%!4,/ ]0%,2) ^
02$$!010+!446,#,+ 21&+$1%!-/,!00M,/+!4)4M,/
%+$!1,1%!)4YQ+1%&0!5*-)!M1%!1,-&&01%!,))!$!
*&00&,+ -/,!00M + 4%1 0%,2) %+$! &0 %,4 1%!6
!3)21!012 !+10Q
,!.'(--#/-"#--'(-N
+1%!#,)),4&+$1&3&16M1/61,& !+1=%!-/10,#1%!0&0
011!*!+1Q
E:H@8AG4G<I8G;8F<FFG4G8@8AGF
/7J9/54294/' !-4'$94&!4/0'- +','-4&!
$/++/7'-%!8,0+!I
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`DGM&C0Z@D
##/4,C$D64H66KC
C,K3$4HH/L$H-$D/DDHH$3$4H
%&)!0,*!/$2*!+11&3!1%!0&0011!*!+10,+)6%3!1,-&
N,!.'(--#/-"#--'(-
+ )&*M 0,*! 1%!0&0 011!*!+10 )0, &+)2 ! /!0,+M ,/
4%10,*!-!,-)!))1%!]0,4%1^,#1%!0&0Q
!#'#'&
#
'(! $!%?'(!&!'&@ +'&
'!1T)!T
!/0,+T !X!Q$QM
)4Y
%+$!1%10%,2)
%--!+1,1%!
,'!1T-)!T
-!/0,+T& !
%61%!%+$!
*11!/0
%!,))!$!
*&00&,+-/,!00
%,2) !%+$!
1,,2+1#,/,1%
%&$%1!010,/!0+
1%!01/!+$1%,#
!51/2//&2)/0
*,+$&10--)&+10
!20!1,$!1%!/M
1%!0!.2)&1&!0
-/,*,1!
4!))\/,2+ ! M
&3!/0!012 !+10Q
,2 *&$%1 %3! !!+ 12$%1 1, )&01 A /!0,+0 1%1 6,2 1%!+
!5-),/!&+A-/$/-%00-/1,#:3!\-/$/-%!006Q,/
,))!$!4/&1&+$+ !6,+ M4!!+,2/$!6,21,*,3!!6,+
1%&0 01/212/! 1, *,/! 0,-%&01&1! /!0,+0 1%1 6,2 1%!+
2+-(#,/ 1%!/! !/Q,*!1&*!0M1%! *,01 &92)1-/1,#
4/&1&+$ 1%! 1%!0&0 &0 *(&+$ 1%! ]/!0,+^ /, !+,2$% 1,
-/!-/! 1%! /! !/ #,/ 6,2/ !006 4&1%,21 '201 )&01&+$ 1%/!!
& !0Q%!60%,2) $&3!*!+&+$1,6,2/-&!!M,/-2/-,0!
X]0, 4%1^Y #,/ 6,2/ /$2*!+1Q /6 & !+1&+$ 1%! 1,-&M
,-&+&,+M + /!0,+ &+ 1%! +!51 1%!0&0 011!*!+1Q %!
011!*!+1 &+ 1%&0 1&3&16 &0 -1! #/,* &*&6 %,(/&`0
]%!!/0&++ !/1%!2$V!4WQ^
,!.'(--#/-"#--'(-N
+1%!#,)),4&+$1&3&16M1/61,& !+1=%!-/10,#1%!0&0
011!*!+1Q
#78AG<9LG;8C4EGFB94A
4E:H@8AG4G<I8G;8F<FFG4G8@8AG
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`DGM&C0Z@E
644$ H/64H636#/$#
-$H6C/ D
/$2*!+11&3! 1%!0&0 011!*!+10 + ,+1&+2! ,2/ 4,/( ,#
!+02/&+$ 1%1 4! 2+ !/01+ ,2/0!)3!0 0 4/&1!/0 1%/,2$%
!*, &*!+1Q %!:+) 1%!0&0 !5*-)!&0 #/,* ]%! !/0&+
+ !/1%!2$M^+/$2*!+14/&11!+6&*&6%,(/&,21
N,!.'(--#/-"#--'(-
%!/)&3! !5-!/&!+!0!/0&+\*!/&+01/&3&+$1,!,*!
+1,/ &+ *!/&Q %!4/,1! 1%!-&!!&+ %!/:/01 6!/1
&+1/6`0,))!$!Q
+ 1%! #,)),4&+$ /!;!1&,+M 4! &+3&1! 6,2 1/6 1, ,+0& !/
6,2/)&3! !5-!/&!+!+ & !+1&1&!00461,/!1!6,2/,4+
1%!0&0011!*!+1Q
,8W86G<BAE:H@8AG4G<I8G;8F<F
FG4G8@8AGF4A78@5B7<87E;8GBE<6F
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`DGM&C0Z@F
,!.'(--#/-"#--'(-N
7G;
/4$DD2$C$$
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/53&/5+ !+!4/
H !32'!&/72!3!2&-&!+0'-$/2,
72'4'-%'-7&'&9/54*!34-
%!+ 6,24/&1! 1, 1(! 01+ ,+ + &002!M 6,2`)) +!! 1,
&+#,/* 6,2/ -,0&1&,+ 4&1% *+* Q ,*!1&*!0 012 !+10
1%&+( ,# /!0!/% 0 1%&+$ 1%!6 %3! 1, , !20! 1%!&/
-/,#!00,/1!))01%!*1,Q21 '/&*+* ,-$$1 $(
1'-**-%&,,!./*!,!&R!/!/!#!4& !0Q
,,"#(!-)-%-(N
6M 4C$D$C --$28O6KH1$
DH4#>
+* & $(1'-<
K &**'/1'-*,'(!:%!+6,201/1
,21/!0!/%&+$1,-&M&1*&$%1#!!)
,3!/4%!)*&+$Q2106,2/! 0,*!
/1&)!01%1/!(6,2/1,-&&+1, &8!/!+1021,-&0
+ 0!!1%!+//,4!/1(!0,1%!/0%3!4/&11!+,+6,2/
1,-&M6,2+$!1& !0#,/*,/!0-!&:/$2*!+16,2
,2) *(!Q
K !&,!1#1,*%+:06,2/!0!/%M6,2
+ !!-!+6,2/3,2)/6,+6,2/1,-&6)!/+&+$
4%10-!&)&7! 1!/*0!5-!/10,+1%&01,-&20!Q
K *,%'*'%($0&.!&B
+, +!+:&+ &+$,214%1012 &!0M-!/0-!1&3!0M
+ 1!5&01,+6,2/1,-&+%!)-6,2/!:+!6,2/
,4+.2!01&,+0+ 4/&1!*,/!+2+! 1%!0&01%1
/!00!01%!2//!+1!3& !+!+ -!/0-!1&3!0,+1%&0
&002!Q
N,,"#(!-)-%-(
K !+'.*', *('!&,+'.!/:,2+
/! &)6 /!00,2+1!//$2*!+10M,/3&!4-,&+101%1
,+;&14&1%6,2/,4+M,2/! 0,*!4/&1&+$06
-!,-)!4&1% &8!/!+1-!/0-!1&3!0,+6,2/1,-&Q
K (*'.!-, '*!,1!&1'-*/*!,!&:%&)!6,2/
-!/0,+)!5-!/&!+!M01,/61!))&+$M + 20!
,#),$&&+6,2//$2*!+14&))%!)--!/02 !6,2/
/! !/0M6,2+)0, 1,1%!.")-,#6,2/-&!!6
/&+$&+$&+1%!!5-!/1&0!,#,1%!//! &)!0,2/!04%,
%3!/!0!/%! + 4/&11!+,216,2/1,-&Q
!0!/%+!%!)-#2)!3!+4%!+6,2`/!&+1%!!/)601$!0
,#6,2/4/&1&+$-/,'!1Q,2,2) ))1%&0]-/!\0!/%Q^%!
#,)),4&+$3& !,X3&!41&*!&0AL?>Y/!(0 ,4+0,*!,#1%!
!+!:10,#01/1&+$6,2//!0!/%!#,/!6,2/1,-&&0:+)&7! M
+ &1$&3!06,20,*!02$$!01&,+0,#)&//6/!0,2/!01%1+
%!)-6,24&1%]-/!\0!/%^L
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
,,"#(!-)-%-(N
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`EDM/!,! Z?
#)9>F9F,O-,"C2*&),#(!3)/,.)*#3"
#,,3C#! )).-,"'
,E+ (($1 , + '&(,+ /!, & 0%($= !1`0 06
$)6 &0 012 !+1 4%, &0 &+1!/!01! &+ 1(&+$ 01+ ,+
%!)1% 1 -/&36Q %! 4+10 1, /$2! 1%1 -!,-)! 0%,2)
!/!#2),21 1%!-/&36,# 1%!&/%!)1% 1Q214%!/!
0%,2) 0%!$,#/,*%!/!R+1%!#,)),4&+$!5!/&0!M/! !%
/!0!/% 0!+/&, + 1%!+ & !+1 %,4 /!0!/% %!)-!
$)6&+!%0!Q
N,,"#(!-)-%-(
0E<G8GB&84EA"BJ,8F84E6;0<??
"8?C2BH
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`EDM&C0ZA>
Attributions
0/*-!++3/,,5-'49/++!%!'229N[2!Z
3!2&I80+/2'-%/52/0'N\
/55!
J?F9
@>@>J&4403IRR9/545N!RB )GGN
N,,"#(!-)-%-(
$#/HHC/KH/64D
K +,2+\#2++!)\F?CFG@h/!$,//!0+/&0)&!+0! 2+ !/
X11/&21&,+Y)&!+0!
K +,2+\ &1&,+/6\EE@CDB?h&,+:!) &0)&!+0! 2+ !/
X11/&21&,+Y)&!+0!
K +,2+\ &0,3!/6\EF@CDGCh4&,+&0)&!+0! 2+ !/
X11/&21&,+Y)&!+0!
K +,2+\ !1!\EG@CGG>h20*1/&+ &+&&0
)&!+0! 2+ !/X11/&21&,+Y)&!+0!
K +,2+\1/201! \@E?BCF?h /&!+,.2!1&0)&!+0!
2+ !/X11/&21&,+Y)&!+0!
,,"#(!-)-%-(N
7F;
/4$DD2$C$$
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/53&/5+ !+!4/
H '%2,3/,!3'34!03'-4&!2!3!2&
02/!33
H !32'!7&49/5+2! 9*-/7/549/52
4/0'
H /3!2!3!2&15!34'/-33! /-7&49/5
34'++-!! 4/*-/7/549/524/0'
H !-4'$9*!97/2 34/;- 2!+!6-4'-$/2,4'/-
H !' !7&43!2&4//+34/53!$/29/52
N-",,"*,)
2!3!2&
+1%&0%-1!/M4!`))4)(1%/,2$%0,*!01/1!$&!0#,/$!11&+$
01/1! 4&1% /!0!/%Q X!`)) !5-),/! *,/! +2+!0 ,# 1%!
/!0!/% -/,!00 )1!/ &+ 1%&0 ,,(M &+ /&1&+$ 1, (! +
/$2*!+14&1%!0!/%QY
-$$D$C -C6 $DD
,4 1%1 4!`3! !01)&0%! %,4 /!0!/% + %!)- 6,2/
4/&1&+$M4%1 ,!01%!-/,!00),,()&(!R%!0%,/1+04!/&0L
&1*&$%1!*!00&!/1%+6,21%&+(Q
-",,"*,)N
#!F9?F9F-,"2*..#)(0-,&#.37)1",.V*$!
!0/&-1&,+W
%!1%!/6,2`/!),,(&+$#,/6,2/,4+0,2/!0,/20&+$1!510
-/,3& ! 66,2/-/,#!00,/M6,2+),,(1,1%!&+#,/*1&,+
6,2%3!#,/&+0-&/1&,+,+4%11,4/&1!,21+ %,41,
01/212/!6,2//$2*!+1Q
-;8,8F84E6;*EB68FF
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`F>M&C0ZA?
HCHM/H--H6K46M
,2*6%3!%,0!+1,-&6,2(+,4),1,21M,/-!/%-0
6,2 %,0! &1 -/!&0!)6 !20! 6,2 )(S. (+,4 *2% +
N-",,"*,)
6,2`/!2/&,201,)!/+*,/!Q&1%!/46M6,20%,2) )6,21
4%16,2/&+$1,1%&01,-&!#,/!6,201/1/!0!/%&+$M+
/!3&0&1 1%! 002*-1&,+0 6,2 01/1! 4&1% 0 6,2 -/,$/!00
1%/,2$%1%!/!0!/%-/,!00Q
0E<G8GB&84EA0;4G2BH?E847L
%ABJ
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`F>M&C0ZA@
-",,"*,)N
'%N?EN@N*%2/5- 2!3!2&
&!+039/5!80+/2!7&'&04&
4/4*!7'4&9/5272'4'-%N
64H/4K$M/H-63$ 1,C6K4#
$D$C -
0 6,2`/! %,+&+$ &+ ,+
0,*! 0-!&: 1,-&0 +
,//!0-,+ &+$ /!0!/%
.2!01&,+0M 0(&* 0,*! 0&
($/,2+ &+#,/*1&,+Q
,2*64+11,,+0& !/L
K %1 ,!0!#!(!
06,216,2/1,-&R
K %1&002!0/!)1! 1,6,2/1,-&%3!!!+&+1%!&/+
)1!)6R
K ,4 ,0&0($!&**,!$+/!( ,4+6,2/1,-&
&+1, &8!/!+1021,-&0,/.2!01&,+0R
K %1%!&1$'(!&,*!+,+6,2/1,-&/!
3&))!1%/,2$%6,2/$!**1R
K %1''#+/!,211%!/!,+6,2/1,-&RX3!+,2
,+`1%3!1&*!1,/! 4%,)!,,(M0(&**&+$1%!
1&1)!0+ 1)!0,#,+1!+10+$&3!6,20,*!& !0#,/
%,41,--/,%6,2/1,-&QY
N-",,"*,)
0E<G8GB&84EA46>:EBHA7
#A9BE@4G<BA
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`F>M&C0ZAA
%&0($/,2+ /!0!/%4&))%!)-6,2/!:+!6,2/1,-&+
+04!/0,*!.2!01&,+06,2% M21&1+)0,%!)-6,2,*!
2- 4&1% +!4!/M !11!/M !!-!/ .2!01&,+0 1%1 6,2/ !006+
!5-),/!Q
-",,"*,)N
'%N?ENAN&4 /9/57-44/
*-/7!9/- 9/520!23/-+
!80!2'!-!7'4&4&!'335!
9/5^2!72'4'-%/54O
#$4H/&O-H6KDon’t46M$H
!+1&+$ 1%! $-0 &+
6,2/ (+,4)! $! 4&)) %!)-
6,2 1, /!1!/!0!/%
.2!01&,+01%1 4&)) $2& !
6,2//!0!/%Q
,/ &+01+!M &# 6,2 %3!
!& ! 1, /!0!/% 1%!
!8!10 ,# &3,/! ,+
%&) /!+M#1!/4/&1&+$ ,4+
4%1 6,2 , (+,4 ,21
1%!1,-&M6,2` +!514+11,
4/&1! ,4+4%16,2 ,+,1
(+,421/!2/&,201,:+
,21Q
& 2),-5
K &3,/!&0,**,+&+1%!+&1! 11!0
K ,*!1&*!0%&) /!+/!+!$1&3!)68!1! 61%!&/
-/!+10$!11&+$ &3,/!
& 2#-,92),-5
K 01%!/!!/1&+$!1%1%&) /!+/!*,/!-/,+!1,1%!
+!$1&3!!8!10,# &3,/!R
K +%&) /!+//6+!$1&3!!8!10,# &3,/!4&1%1%!*
N-",,"*,)
&+1, 2)1%,, R
K ,4+ &3,/!&*-1 !*&-!/#,/*+!R
K ,4+1%!!8!10,# &3,/!!*&1&$1! R
K +4%10!0*&$%1 &3,/!%3!*)-#.#0!8!1,+
%&) /!+`0*!+1)%!)1%,/ !3!),-*!+1R
0E<G8GB&84EA0;4G2BHBAQG%ABJ
28G
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`F>M&C0ZAB
#$4H/&O$OM6C#DH6$C -&6C
4&6C3H/64
%!+ 6,2`/! ),,(&+$ #,/ &+#,/*1&,+ ,+ 6,2/ 1,-&M &1`0
-",,"*,)N
&*-,/1+1 1, ,+0& !/ 4%1 0!/% 1!/*0 6,2`/! 20&+$Q ,2
*&$%14+11,01/1/, 4&1%6,2/0!/%M+ 1%!+06,2/
& !0$!1*,/!0-!&:M6,2+*(!6,2/0!/%1!/*0*,/!
0-!&:1,,Q,/!5*-)!M6,2*&$%101/14&1%$!+!/)0!/%
,+5.-) #0),F%!+M0! ,+6,2/($/,2+ /!0!/%M
6,2/ +!51 0!/% *&$%1 ! #,/ #0), "#!" -"))& '#
*, ),'(Q
1%1%&03& !,#,/0,*! 3&!,+/&+01,/*&+$0!/%
1!/*0M,/%31),-X3&!41&*!&0@L@AYQ
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`F>M/!,! Z?
#)9?F9F31),- ),-,"#(!W..(#0,-#.3
#,,#-3..(#0,-#.3#,,#-)//"((&
,,$)!&0-/!116;!5&)!M21-/!&0!(!64,/ 0/!!0-!&))6
&*-,/1+14%!+6,2`/!$,&+$1,!0!/%&+$)&//6 10!
X*,/!,+ 1%&0!),4YQ21 !3!+4%!+6,2`/!0!/%&+$4&1%
,,$)!M%+$&+$6,2/0!/%1!/*0!3!+0)&$%1)64&))202))6
/&+$2-1,1))6 &8!/!+1/!02)10Q&3!&11/6O
N-",,"*,)
%8LJBE7F
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`F>M&C0ZAC
$ /#$-$C$H6$C -
,4 1%1 6,2`3! $,1 /!0!/% 1,-&M 0,*! ($/,2+
&+#,/*1&,+M0,*!1%&+$06,24+11,(+,4M+ 0,*!4,/ 0
1, 0!/% 4&1%M 0,$1 + '-$ 1'- +* '*
+'-*+>
+,2/!3!/6 6)&3!0M4!*&$%112/+1,'--,/!#'#
#,/.2&(+04!/01,!3!/6 6.2!01&,+0M)&(!".,-)'
/. "#,-.3&- ), /,&3 "#,G)1 ) !. .". -'&& )/. )
." 1-"#(! '"#(G /M )1 -")/& "))- )&&!
'$),GX+ &+/!0&+$)6M,))!$!012 !+10/!20&+$,22!
-",,"*,)N
/4HCOBD
622$,$6&
2/&6C4/
$D6KC $D
345 !-43J
53!4&!3!
'229+'-*34/
%!44/4&!
2!3/52!3
#,/)!/+&+$V+!41W+ 20&+$&(,(01%!&/ !#2)10!/%
!+$&+!,3!/,,$)!V+!41WQY
1&))M*+6012 !+1012/+1,''$:/01#,/1%!&//!0!/%Q
1`0#*&)&/M&1`0!061,0!/%M+ &1`0$!+!/))6-/!116$,,
1/&+$&+$2-0,2/!01%10!!*/!)!3+11,1%!.2!01&,+04!
16-!&+Q2104!`)) /!00)1!/&+%-1!/0,+)$,/&1%*0+
!3)21&+$4!0&1!0M&1`0$,1&0(! &+M+ ,#1!+4!0&1!0
4&))$*!1%!/+(&+$01,$!11%!&/)!00\1%+\21%,/&11&3!0&1!
1,--!/+!/1%!1,-,#6,2//!02)10Q,&1+!01/1&+$
-)!#,/6,2/0!/%M216,2`))4+11,1/60,*!,1%!/0!/%
!+$&+!01,,Q
'; / , * +'% ', *
,''$+ 1'- & -+ ,' +* >
**/+,*,!&($+:
K &//&!0%3!*+6 &8!/!+1
*+* ,++1%1+
-,&+16,21,/1&)!0M,,(0M
3& !,0M+ 1,+6,2/1,-&Q
K ,2/,))!$!)&//6-/,)6%0
0!/%!+$&+!1%10!/%!0
4%,)!2+%,#1%!0! 10!01
,+!Q,,(#,/-/,*&+!+1
0!/%,5,+6,2/)&//6`0
4!0&1!Q
K ''$ '$*V+!41W&0
N-",,"*,)
,!-4'/-! '-
4&'3&04!2I
H 5%%!34!
''.
)(
($/2
2'4'-%
/523!3
T-!7
4U
H ''.
'
T-!7
4UI
^3
3!2&
!-%'-!
4&4
3!2&!3
/-4!-4
$2/,
,-9
0!/%!+$&+!* !6
,,$)!1%1/&+$02-
!*&/!0!/%/1%!/
1%+/!$2)/4!0&1!0Q%!+
6,2`/!),,(&+$#,//!0!/%
012 &!0M1%&0+!+!06
-)!1,01/1Q!`)))!/+
*,/!,211%&0)1!/&+1%!
,,(Q
K ,2*&$%1)0,),,(2-
4%&%,*-+,/'*, 1&/+
+!,+;&'&(*'4,+;'*
*+* '*&!2,!'&+
,3!/6,2/1,-&M+ 0!/%
,+1%!&/4!0&1!Q,/
!5*-)!M*6!6,2`))4+1
1,0!!%!*!/&+
!*6,#! &1/&0%0
+6$2& +!,+%!)-&+$
%&) /!+ !)4&1% &3,/!Q
!B8LBA7!BB:?8
)G;8EBHE68FB9
-",,"*,)N
+'229
43!
3++4
/-!
#A9BE@4G<BABA2BHE
-BC<6
+'*4&2/5%&4&!$/++/7'-%
4'6'49$/2%+',03!4&/7
4&!3! '$$!2!-43!2&4//+3
7'++0/'-49/54/ '$$!2!-4'-$/2,4'/-NV!
2!/,,!- !80- '-%4/$5++32!!-NW
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`F>M&C0ZAD
N-",,"*,)
3,$$D C/8H/64D
&$Q?EQ?*$! !0/&-1&,+Q%!&*$!&0 &3& ! &+1, #,2/
.2 /+10M&))201/1&+$1%!,+!-1,#]!0!/%L5-!11&,+
30Q !)&16Q^ %! 1,- %)# /!-/!0!+10 ]5-!11&,+M^ 4&1%
%,/&7,+1) 1&*!)&+! 0%,4&+$ 01/&$%1#,/4/ -/,!00L
]%,,0! 1,-&M^ ]&+ /!)!3+1 0,2/!0M^ + ]2)) 0,*!
.2,1!0+ -),-1%!*&+1,6,2/!006M^&+ &1! 60&+$)!
01/&$%1 //,4Q %! ,11,* %)# !-&10 ]!)&16M^ 4&1%
6)&) + &1!/1&3! -/,!00 &))201/1! 6 2/3! //,40
,++!1&+$ #,2/ 01$!0L ]/&+01,/*M^ ]5-),/!M^ ]1!/1!M^
+ ]/#1Q^!),4!%01$!M0%,/1 !0/&-1&,+0/!-/,3& ! Q
,1%!1,-/&$%1M+,1!060M]%!/!6,201/14&))! &8!/!+1
#/,*4%!/!6,2!+ 2-M^%&$%)&$%1&+$1%!+,+\)&+!/+12/!,#
12)/!0!/%QV!12/+1,&$Q?EQ?W
Attributions
[ !-4'$9&4/5/-^4-/7!4\'3$2/,
-42/ 54'/-4//++!%!!3!2&/092'%&4d
9+4!2N54+!2Q+/&2%!-4Q- !+3!9
,'4&J+'!-3! 5- !22!4'6!/,,/-3
442'54'/-BN>-4!2-4'/-+'!-3!N
-",,"*,)N
"
"
0,#-#(!-),/#,#'!#((, &-N
N0,#-#(!-),/#,#'!#((, &-
7%;
9:
/4K4
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'33!4'/-J9/57'++!+!4/
H !<!4/-9/52/7-72'4'-%02/!33!3
H !6'3!9/5272'4'-%02/)!43'-/2 !24/
&'!6! '$$!2!-40520/3!3- 00!+4/
'$$!2!-45 '!-!3J7&//509 '6!23!
2-%!/$3/'++/4'/-3
0,#-#(!-),/#-#)()/,/#0N
!6'3'4I&4'3,/ '! &!4/2'3O
]!3&0&,+^/!(0 ,4+&+1,]/!^+ ]3&0&,+M^4%&%*!+0
1,/!\0!!M1,0!!+!4Q%20M/!3&0&,+!51!+ 0#/!6,+ 1%!
0,-! ,# ! &1&+$ + &+3,)3!0 1(&+$ 01,( ,# 6,2/ 4,/( &+
,/ !/1,/!&*$&+!&1#,//+$!,#/%!1,/&)-2/-,0!0Q
,/&+01+!M]%!!/0&++ !/1%!2$^6&+1/6`0
)2*&*&6%,(/&/$2!01%1& )!01!/+4,*!+%3!
!!+ 2+ !//!-/!0!+1! + 01!/!,16-! &+ *&+01/!*
*!/&+*! & 2!1,01/212/)/&0*Q*$&+!1%1%,(/&
+,4 %0 1, /!3&0! 1%&0 !006 #,/ )&3! -/!0!+11&,+ 1
,+#!/!+!Q,4*&$%1%,(/& /4,+*2)1&*! &!)!*!+10
1, *(! %!/ )&*0 *,/! -,4!/#2) + -!/020&3! #,/ 1%!
-!,-)!4%,/!11!+ &+$%!/-/!0!+11&,+R,44,2) %!/
/%!1,/&) !&0&,+0 %+$! &#M &+01! ,# + !*&
,+#!/!+!M0%!4!/!-/!0!+1&+$1%&01,,))64,, -/, 2!/0
X*,01,#4%,*4!*&$%1002*!1,!4%&1!YR,44,2)
1%! &3!/0!)&3! !5-!/&!+!0,#1%!0! &8!/!+12 &!+!00%-!
1%!46%,(/&/!&*$&+!0%!//$2*!+1R
+1%!/&1!1,!/+!),4M,+0& !/%,411!+1&,+1,1%!
, &!0,#6,2/2 &!+!0*&$%10%-!6,2//!3&0&,+-/,!00Q
N0,#-#(!-),/#-#)()/,/#0
0E<G8GB&84EA@5B7<87,8I<F<BA
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`FBM&C0ZAE
#AI<G4G<BAF GB ,847 ,8W86G 4A7
0E<G8
+ 1%&0 &+1/, 21&,+ 1, 1%! 0!1&,+ ]/&1&+$ 1, !3&0!M^ 4!
&+3&1!6,21,/! 0,*!0*-)!/!3&0&,+!0060#/,*,1%!/&+1
/6`0 ,))!$! 012 !+10Q ! %3! )0, &+)2 ! 0,*!
&+3&11&,+0 1, 4/&1! 0%/! 6 4/&1&+$ -/,#!00,/0 1 &+1
/6`0,))!$!Q
0,#-#(!-),/#-#)()/,/#0N
GH78AG0E<G<A:
!7/5+ +'*!4/'-+5 !345 !-472'4'-%'-4&'3
3!4'/-N$9/52!'-4!2!34! '-05+'3&'-%9/52
7/2*J0+!3!;++/544&'3$/2,- 35,'40'!!/$
9/5272'4'-%$2/,9/5272'4'-%+33N!7'++7/2*
7'4&9/54/%!4'405+'3&! N
!2!2!3/,!24'+!3/542!6'3'/-72'44!-9
345 !-43- 05+'3&! 4/4&!25-'6!23'4'!3N!
4&'-*9/5^++;- 4&!3!,!-4/24!84353!$5+I
H ,/ '! /52-!93'-2&'4!452+529T!7
U95++:2V2'4!2^344!,!-4
T!7UW
H /72!4'-%/ 34!+0! !
- !234- -5 '!-!J/,,5-'4'/-J-
4&!! '5,/$!33%!'-&/+!!7
9T!7U9--/2%'/-!
V2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7UW
N0,#-#(!-),/#-#)()/,/#0
#AI<G4G<BAFGB0E<G8A@5B7<87
,8I<F<BA
&!&04!23'-4&'33!4'/-3&/5+ 02!02!9/5$/2
/,0+!4'-%/-!/$4&!3!35,,4'6!72'4'-%
33'%-,!-43N&!3!!8,0+!32!33'%-,!-434&4
7!2!/,,!- N
(($#$)-#&"<1
[2'4!9/523!+$N/52/ 9,534!&!2 J\72/4!
"+#-!'8/53'-[&!5%&/$4&!! 53\
V05+'3&! '-2!-&'-?GEC- 42-3+4! '-4/
-%+'3&'-?GEDWN-4&'3/-42/6!23'+!339J'8/53
2!)!434&!42 '4'/-+!34!2-3!024'/-/$4&!
/ 9- ,'- - 2%5!3$/2 '34'-4$/2,/$
72'4'-%2//4! '-&!2$!,+!/ 9N6!2C>9!23
+4!2J7!2!34'++!80+/2'-%4&'3' !/547&4'4
7/5+ ,!-$/2/525-'15!/ '!34/&6!5-'15!
+-%5%!I7&47/5+ /52/ '!30/33'+939O
$4!22! '-%/544&!4&!/29/$+^"2'452!$!,'-'-!J
9/57'++3!+!4/-!/$9/5202!6'/53+972'44!-!3393
'-4&'3/523!- J'-EC>7/2 3J2!72'4!4&!4!84
0,#-#(!-),/#-#)()/,/#0N
,/ !++! $4!24&'3,/2!<5' J-/-Z+'-!2349+!/$
72'4'-%N/57'++4&!-/,0/3!C>>Z7/2
2!<!4'/-/-4&!02/!33N
Works Cited
&/*2'J','9N[&!!23'-- !24&!5%N\
5!!-'492'4!23
J6/+NCJ-/N?J02'-%@>?EJ
&4403IRR1Z72'4!23N/,R@>?ER>AR@BR?>F@R
N0,#-#(!-),/#-#)()/,/#0
75;
/4K4
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H !-4'$9&/72!6'3'/-'3 '$$!2!-4$2/,! '4'-%
H 3! '$$!2!-42!6'3'/-3424!%'!3 !0!- '-%/-
4&!34%!/$9/52 2$4
+ 1%! /&1! 1, !/+ !),4M /!;!1 ,+ 6,2/ ,4+ /!3&0&,+
-/,!00Q
")0,/##(!## ,(- ,)'#-#(!N
0E<G8GB&84EA2BHE,8I<F<BA*EB68FF
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`FEM&C0ZAF
0+,1! &+1%!)01%-1!/M/!3&0&,+&0/!\3&0&,+L1%1&0M1,
0!!+!4Q+1%&0%-1!/M4!4&)),+0& !/%,46,2+1(!
+!5&01&+$ /#1+ #2/1%!/ !3!),-&1&+,/ !/1,!11!/*!!1
1%!!5-!11&,+0,#&10/%!1,/&)0&121&,+Q,*!.2!01&,+06,2
*&$%10(1,$2& !6,2//!3&0&,+-/,!00&+)2 !L
K %1+!4&+#,/*1&,++6,2 &0,3!/06,2/!3&0!R
K ,4+6,2 +!4&+#,/*1&,+1,4%16,2`3!
)/! 64/&11!+R
K %1%))!+$!0 & 6,2!+,2+1!/M+ %,4*&$%16,2
N")0,/##(!## ,(- ,)'#-#(!
/!0-,+ 1,1%,0!%))!+$!0&+4/&1&+$1,01/!+$1%!+1%!
-&!!R
K %1)&+$2&01&M/%!1,/&)M !0&$+M,/,1%!/ !3&!0+
6,2!5-!/&*!+14&1%1,!+$$!6,2//! !/R
!#,/!6,2+ ,0,M%,4!3!/M6,2+!! 1,%3!4/&11!+6,2/
:/01 /#1S6,2+!! 0,*!1%&+$0201+1&3!1,4,/(4&1%Q0
, &&,2)1M02!00#2)*!/&++,3!)&01M060M],2+`1
! &1)+(-$!^X/*!/YQ+,1%!/ 4/&1!/M++! *,11M
/!*&+ 0 20 1%1 !/)6 /#10 /!+`1 -!/#!1Q %!0! -,&+10 /!
,1%0-,1,+Q,2+!! 4,/(&+$ /#1#,//!3&0&,+M!3!+&#
1%1 /#1&0#/#/,*-!/#!1Q
")0,/##(!## ,(- ,)'#-#(!N
'%N?GN?N&!2!6'3'/-02/!33
3&/5+ !%'-7'4&/-3' !2'-%
[&'%&!2Z/2 !2/-!2-3\V4&!
4!%/2'!344&!4/0/$4&!
'-6!24! 42'-%+!/6!W-
,/6!4/72 [+/7!2Z/2 !2
/-!2-3\V4&!4!%/2'!34
4&!/44/,/$4&!'-6!24!
42'-%+!WN
2/1%!/*,/!M /!3&0&,+ &0
*,/! 1%+ '201 ! &1&+$ ,/
-/,,#/! &+$S /!3&0&,+
/!.2&/!0 /&1&) 1%&+(&+$M
#!! (M + /!#2)
!5*&+1&,+ ,# ,2/ 4,/(Q
,1! 1%1 4! 0&
!5*&+1&,+Q!3&0&,+&0+,1
.2&( 0+ ,# 6,2/ 4,/(
#,/ !//,/0 )&(! ,**
-/,)!*0M*&00-!))! 4,/ 0M
,/,1%!/),4\,/ !/,+!/+0
X0YQ%1`0 ! &1&+$+
-/,,#/! &+$Q !3&0&,+
*!+0),,(&+$16,2/4,/(
0 4%,)!M 1(&+$ +,1!0 ,#
)) &10 -/10M 1%!&/ ,3!/))
!8!1&3!+!00M + ,1%!/
0Q X&$Q ?GQ? V*$!
!0/&-1&,+WYQ
!3&0&,+M&+,1%!/4,/ 0M*!+0!5*&+&+$02%,+!/+0
0 ,/$+&71&,+M /$2*!+1T1%!0&0M -2/-,0!M 2 &!+!M +
02--,/1&+$!3& !+!Q1&0 &92)1M&#+,1&*-,00&)!M1,/!3&0!
4&1%,21,+0& !/&+$1%!0!,*-,+!+10M4%&%4!)) ! *B
'** '&*&+X+Y !20! 1%!0! ,*-,+!+10 %3!
&$$!/ &*-1 ,+ 1%! ,3!/)) !8!1&3!+!00 ,# +6
,*-,0&1&,+Q'/*B'**'&*&+,/+M,+1%!,1%!/
N")0,/##(!## ,(- ,)'#-#(!
%+ M8!11%!,3!/))--!/+!M-,)&0%M+ )/&16,#1%!
,*-,0&1&,+Q
+ 1%&0 %/1M 1%! *,01 0&$+&:+1 0 /! -2/-,0!M
2 &!+!M+ ,+1!51S0,21)&+! &+1%!%-1!/,+/%!1,/&M
1%!0!1%/!!#,/*1%!/%!1,/&)0&121&,+Q1`0/&1&)1,*(!
02/!1%!0!!)!*!+10X-2/-,0!M2 &!+!M+ ,+1!51Y/!)!/
+ !8!1&3!Q # +!/)6 !.2) &*-,/1+! /! 1%! 1%!0&0 ,/
/$2*!+1+ $!+/!,+3!+1&,+0Q
!/! /! 0,*! 01/1!$&!0 #,/ ,+0& !/&+$ 1%! 0 &+
--/,%&+$+!/)6 /#1Q%!+,+0& !/&+$+!/)6 /#1M
6,2 /! 01&)) 1/6&+$ 1, & !+1 + !3!),- 6,2/ !+1/)
/$2*!+1Q,2/!),,(&+$,21#,/,*-!))&+$*,*!+104%!/!
1%!1%!0&0,*!01%/,2$%+ &+1/&$2&+$-)!04%!/!6,2+
!3!),-#2/1%!/Q
4E?L7E49GDH8FG<BAF
30.-1$-,2$62
H &9734&'333'%-,!-4%'6!-O&4'3'4
429'-%4/33!33O/7&39/5200!23/5%&4
4/ !,/-3424!4&/3!3*'++3O
")0,/##(!## ,(- ,)'#-#(!N
H &42!4&!+!2-'-%%/+3R/)!4'6!3/$4&'3
33'%-,!-4O39/5200!2!$$!4'6!+9
/,0+'3&! 4&!3!%/+3O
3#'$,"$
H &/2!9/572'4'-%$/2O&4 '$$!2!-4
3/'++/4'/-3 /!34&'35 '!-!
/509O
H &42!4&!!80!44'/-3R-!! 3/$4&'3
5 '!-!J- &/7,'%&49/54294/
00!+4/4&/3!!80!44'/-3- -!! 3
4&2/5%&9/52/,0/3'4'/-+&/'!3O
&$1'1
H &4'34&!!-42+' !V[4&!3'3W/$4&'3
00!2J- /!3'4 2!334&!*!933'%-,!-4
02/,04O
H 34&!4&!3'330!';V[+!2+9 !;-! J\
[!8&''43 !04&- /,0+!8'49'-'43
-+93'3\WO-9/553!2!* /7-/-!043
$524&!2O
H 34&!4&!3'32%5+!V !,/-3424!3-
['-4!++!45++9&++!-%'-%$/53J\3&/73
[/2'%'-+'49\WO-9/50+9 !6'+^3 6/4!
N")0,/##(!## ,(- ,)'#-#(!
- /-3' !27&4-/00/3'-%2%5,!-4
,'%&4+//*+'*!O
H 34&!4&!3'33'%-';-4V '30+93[342/-%
3!-3!/$0520/3!- 5 '!-!\'--4''04'-%
4&
H &4,/,!-43'-9/52!3392!4!4&!
342/-%!34J,/346'6' 3!-34'/-3$/29/5'-
9/52/ 9O&9O/7,'%&49/5 !6!+/0
4&/3!,/,!-43O
+! 6,2 %3! $,+! 1%/,2$% 6,2/ ,4+ !/)6 /#1 /!3&!4M
-!!//!3&!40M+ +6,1%!//! \1%/,2$%0+ +)60!0,#6,2/
/#1M 6,2 *6 !/! 6 #,/ 1%! :+)01$! ,# /!3&0&,+Q %&0
&001&))+,10&*-)6! &1&+$Z%!(&+$#,/*&00-!))! 4,/ 0,/
*&00&+$,**0Q
+! $&+M 6,2 %3! 1%! ,--,/12+&16 1, ]/!\0!!^ 6,2/
--!/M 1, ),,( ),0!)6 + !!-)6 1 &1 1, *(! 02/! 1%1 &1
&0*(&+$0!+0!M1%1&1;,40M+ 1%1&1&0*!!1&+$1%!,/!
00&$+*!+1 /!.2&/!*!+10Q +01! ,# ,*-)!1!)6 /!\
!+3&0&,+&+$1%!--!/M+,46,24+11,#,20,+!3& !+!+
,/$+&71&,+ &+ ,/ !/ 1, *(! 1%! /$2*!+1 ,*! 1%/,2$%
*,/!)!/)6Q
N")0,/##(!## ,(- ,)'#-#(!
&4G8E49G+H8FG<BAF
,20-#3"2'-,&$1'1
H /!34&!'-42/ 54/293!4'/-02/6' !/-4!84
$/2- +! 504/4&!!-42+' !V[4&!3'3\W/$
4&'300!2O
H /7,'%&49/5%24&!2! !2^344!-4'/-
7'4&9/52/0!-'-%O
H &4'34&!!8'%!-9$/29/520'!!O/7-
9/5 279/522! !2^344!-4'/-4/4&4
/-4!84- 00!+4/4&!'23!-3!/$52%!-9O
4'#$,"$, *71'1
H /9/5!$$!4'6!+9 !32'!4&!/)!4/$
-+93'3X'N!NJ7/5+ 4&!2! !27&/ /!3-/4
*-/74&'3/)!4!+!4//,!797'4&
+!25- !234- '-%/$4&4/)!4O
H &4+',37/5+ 2!15'2!,/2!!6' !-!
- R/2-+93'3O
H &!2! /9/535,,2':!J020&23!J-
15/4!J- '3'4!$$!4'6!O2!4&!2!0+!34&4
")0,/##(!## ,(- ,)'#-#(!N
9/5,'%&453!35,,29,/2!O2!4&!2!
0+!37&!2!9/5,'%&4-+9:!,/2!O
H 2!9/5!-%%'-%7'4&2!15'2! 3/52!
,4!2'+33,5&/23 !!0+939/5-!! 4/
!O/5+ 9/5200!2!342/-%!2'$9/5
2!2! 4&!3/52!3-/4&!24',!4/!44!2
5- !234- 4&!,O/9/5-!! ,/2!3/52!
3500/24'-4&!00!2O/9/5-!! 4/
!-&-!9/523/52!'-4!%24'/-V3'%-+
0&23!3J'44'/-3WO
0% ,'8 2'-,
H /!34&!00!2&6!+!22%5,!-44'6!
42)!4/29X3!15!-!/$' !34&4/--!4
4/!&/4&!2J- 7&'&/,!4/%!4&!24/
$/2,4&!!-42+2%5,!-4O
H /!3!&02%20&/0!-7'4&2' %!
3!-4!-!4&4/--!434/4&!0/'-42'3! '-
4&!02!! '-%02%20&O
H 3!&02%20&/2%-':! 2/5- /-!
!-42+' !O
H +!3!&'%&+'%&4*!9' !3J- 53! '$$!2!-4
/+/24/&'%&+'%&4' !34&42! '3/--!4!
/22504J- 7&'&3&/5+ !,/6! 4/
'$$!2!-40+!'-4&!00!2N
N")0,/##(!## ,(- ,)'#-#(!
-,"*31'-,
H /7 /!34&!/-+53'/- '$$!2$2/,4&!
'-42/ 54'/-O/!3'42!344!4&!'-42/ 54'/-J
/2 /!3'4+!6!4&!2! !27'4&-!7'-3'%&43O
H /!3'4!80+/2!',0+'4'/-3X'N!NJ7&94&!
2%5,!-4,44!23O
H &'-*/544&!/-+53'/-+'*!22'6'-%44&!
4/0/$&'++$4!2,*'-%4&!+',50V4&!
+',50'34&!!339WN/74&49/52!4
4&!4/0J7&4 /9/53!! '$$!2!-4+9$2/,
7&!2!9/57!2!!$/2!O
$$#! ")
H 3! /-2! !2+9$!! *X0!!22!6'!7!23J
454/23J9/52'-34254/2J$2'!- 3J!4NJ7&!2!-
9/5,*!9/52!339,/2!2! !2Z$2'!- +9O
&!2! /!3'4-!! ,/2!!$$/24- $/53O
H $4!-J7!,*!/-3'34!-4!22/23'-/52
72'4'-%$2/,00!24/00!2N! /6!2
$!! *$2/,/4&!200!23X!6!-$2/,/4&!2
+33!3X- 2!6'!79/5200!27'4&30!'+
44!-4'/-4/4&/3!!22/23N&!2!'334'++4',!4/
/,!4+*4/9/5202/$!33/2/54;8'-%4&!,
'$9/5 /-^45- !234- &/74/6/' 4&!,L
")0,/##(!## ,(- ,)'#-#(!N
!3&0&,+&0+&*-,/1+101$!&+1%!4/&1&+$-/,!00Q11(!0
1&*! + -!/0&01!+!Q 1 )0, $!10 !0&!/ 4&1% -/1&!Q
5-!/&!+! 4/&1!/00!!/!3&0&,++,1,+)60&*-,/1+1M210
1%!!+1/)-/1,#4/&1&+$Q&/01 /#10M1,.2,1!*,11$&+M
/! ]0%&116^Z 46 1, $!1 ,21 1!+11&3! & !0 1%1 + ,+)6
/!3!)1%!&/-,1!+1&)1%/,2$%1%!-/,!00,#/!3&0&,+Q/&1&+$
&0 /!2/0&3! -/,!00S 6,2 + /!3&0&1 !/)&!/ 01!-0 &+ 6,2/
-/,!00!#,/!M 2/&+$M+ #1!//!3&0&+$Q+1%!!+ M%,4!3!/M
/!3&0&,+%!)-020 !3!),-!8!1&3!4/&1&+$%&10Q!3&0&,+)0,
%!)-0202+ !/01+ ,2/0!)3!004/&1!/0+ ,**2+&1,/0
6 -/,3& &+$ + ,--,/12+&16 1, /!;!1 ,+ ,2/ -2/-,0! &+
4/&1&+$%,44!))4!%&!3!,2/-2/-,0!Q%!/!#,/!M-)+1,
*(!/!3&0&,+!+1/)-/1,#6,2/4/&1&+$-/,!00!3!/61&*!
6,24/&1!Q
+ %$$1"0'.2'-,1
&$Q?GQ?*$!!0/&-1&,+Q%!&*$!#!12/!0+&+3!/1!
1/&+$)!4&1%)(,/ !/M&))201/1&+$%&!//%6,#4/&1&+$
+ ! &1&+$,+!/+0Q 1 1%! 1,- &+0& ! 1%! 1/&+$)!M )!)!
0 ]&$%!/\/ !/ ,+!/+0M^ /! !)!*!+10 )&(! 2/-,0!M
2 &!+!M ,+1!51M %!0&0M !+/! ,+3!+1&,+0M
/$+&71&,+M 2--,/1M 16)!M + ,&!Q ,4!/ &+0& ! 1%!
1/&+$)! /! ],4!/\/ !/,+!/+0M^&+)2 &+$ /$/-%0M
/+0&1&,+0M !+1!+!0M ,/ 0M !%+&0M /**/M +
N")0,/##(!## ,(- ,)'#-#(!
2+121&,+Q //,40 ,+ ,1% 0& !0 ,# 1%! 1/&+$)! &+ &1!
*,3!*!+1 #/,* %&$%!/\,/ !/ 1, ),4!/\,/ !/ ,+!/+0Q
V!12/+1,&$Q?GQ?W
Attributions
[!6'3'-%/522$43J\'-
5' !4/&!4/2'J
!-2!J- 5!33'-'234Z!22'4'-%J
!+-'!
%'&- ,'+'!'*!+J442'54'/-Z
/-/,,!2'+Z&2!+'*!BN>
[!6'3'-%J\'-
'234Z!2/,0/3'4'/-I
2'4'-%3
-15'29- 2%5,!-44'/-J
*'!/!2,--Z
++'/44- 4&95!3!-529J442'54'/-BN>
")0,/##(!## ,(- ,)'#-#(!N
JQ;
/4K4
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H !<!4/-9/52/7-72'4'-%02/!33-
02/ 547'4&024'5+244!-4'/-4/4&!2/+!
4&44&!/ 90+93
# ],$+&1&,+^ /!#!/0 1, 1%! -/,!00 ,# 1%&+(&+$M + 1, !
]*!1^ &0 #,/ 0,*!1%&+$ 1, ,**!+1 ,+ &10!)#M 1%!+ ]*!1\
,$+&1&,+^ *!+0 1, 1%&+( ,21 1%&+(&+$Q ,*-,0&1&,+
0%,)/0 %3! #,2+ 1%1 *!1,$+&1&,+ )),40 012 !+10 1,
1/+0#!/ 1%!0(&))0 1%!6 %3! )!/+! &+ :/01\6!/4/&1&+$&+1,
+!4 4/&1&+$ 0&121&,+0 !6,+ 1%! )00/,,*Q /601)
N, &-#/0,#-#(!
+,,1!+ !0/&!0 *!1,$+&1&,+ 0 012 !+10` *!1\
4/!+!00 ,21 &8!/!+1 *, !0 ,# ,*-,0&1&,+M &+)2 &+$
+,1,+)64/&1&+$4,/ 021)0,*2)1&*, ),*-,0&1&,+1%1
/40,+3&02)0M0,2+ 0M+ *,3!*!+10Q
, !3!),-*!1,$+&1&,+M6,2+!! 1,/!;!12-,+6,2/
-/1&2)/ ,*-,0&1&,+) %,&!0 + !5-)&+ %,4 + 4%6
1%,0! %,&!0 /! ,/ *&$%1 ! !8!1&3! ,/ &+!8!1&3! 4&1%&+
/%!1,/&),+1!51Q%!0!/!;!1&,+0+!016)! 0!0060M
-,01! 03& !,0,/-, 010M02*&11! 1, &0200&,+,/ 0M
,/&+)2 ! &+,3!/)!11!/1%1&+1/, 2!0,/,+1!512)&7!0
6,2/-/,'!1Q
+ 1%! ,+1!51 ,#,#.#(! )/, )#-D6,2 4&)) /!;!1 &+
-/1&2)/,+1%!/,)!,#6,2/, 6+ %,4&10-,012/!0+
&+1!/1&,+04&1%1!%+,),$60%-! 1%!4/&1&+$-/,!00+
-/, 21Q
0-"$11
,+0& !/1%!*2)1&-)!-%0!0,#4,/(&+3,)3! &+/!1&+$6,2/
:+&0%! -/, 21L/&+01,/*&+$M/!0!/%M,21)&+&+$M /#1&+$M
/!!&3&+$#!! (M+ /!3&0&,+Q,*!.2!01&,+01,,+0& !/
+&+)2 !L
?Q ,4,/4%6 & 6,2-&(1%&01,-&M--/,%M,/
/$2*!+1R%1#!!)&+$0 & 1%&01,-&&+3,(!&+6,2R
,4%3!6,2/#!!)&+$0!3,)3! &+1%!,2/0!,#1%!
-/,'!1R
, &-#/0,#-#(!N
@Q %1(&+ ,#-)++&+$ & 6,2 ,#,/1%!-/,'!1R,4
& 1%,0!460,#,/$+&71&,+X4/&1&+$&++,1!,,(30Q
20&+$&+ !/30Q0!11&+$2-#,) !/0&+,,$)!/&3!M#,/
&+01+!Y0%-!1%!:+)-/, 21R
AQ %1%))!+$!0,2//! ),+$1%!46R,4 & 6,2
/!0-,+ 1,1%!0!%))!+$!0R%1 !&0&,+0 & 6,2
#!M+ %,4 & 6,2*(!1%,0! !&0&,+0R
BQ ,4 & ,**!+10#/,*6,2/-!!/0+ &+01/21,/%!)-
6,2R,4 & 6,2!+$$!4&1%1%,0!,**!+10&+6,2/
/!3&0&,+0R
CQ %&%0-!10,#1%!4/&1&+$-/,!00#!)1!06#,/6,2R
%6R
DQ %&%0-!10,#1%!4/&1&+$-/,!00#!)1 &92)1#,/
6,2R%6R
EQ %101/1!$&!04,/(! !01&+6,2/4/&1&+$-/,!00R
FQ %116-!0,#1!%+,),$6 & 6,220!1%/,2$%,211%!
,*-,0&1&,+-/,!00R+4%1460 & 1%!6#&)&11!
6,2/1%&+(&+$+ 4/&1&+$R+4%1460 & 1%!6
&+1!/#!/!4&1%6,2/1%&+(&+$+ 4/&1&+$R
GQ /,'!1#,/4/ Q%1 & 6,2)!/+1%/,2$%1%&0
4/&1&+$-/,'!1R,/6,2/+!514/&1&+$-/,'!1M%,4+
6,220!4%16,2`3!)!/+! R+6,21/+0#!/1%&0
(+,4)! $!1,,1%!/,*-,0&+$0&121&,+0M&+,/,21,#
1%!)00/,,*R
N, &-#/0,#-#(!
-$H6C/
+)67! 1%! /%!1,/&) 0&121&,+ ,# 6,2/ ,4+ 4/&1&+$ 6
,+0& !/&+$.2!01&,+0,#-2/-,0!M2 &!+!M1!51M+ !5&$!+!Q
,*!.2!01&,+01,,+0& !/+&+)2 !L
?Q 0!&1:%1*,1&31!06,2/1!51R%6&0&1+!! ! M
+ 4%1-/,)!*0&0&11/6&+$1,/!0,)3!R%1/!&10
$,)0R
@Q -, '*:%1(&+ ,#)&3! !5-!/&!+!0+ T,/
21%,/&16 ,6,2%3!4&1%/!$/ 1,1%!02'!1R,4
&+3!01! /!6,2R,4%3!1%!0!3)2!0&+;2!+! 1%!
,*-,0&1&,+R%1& !+1&16/!6,21/6&+$1,-/,'!10
1%!/!1,/,#1%&01!51R
AQ -!&:%,&06,2/2 &!+!R%1/!1%!&/
($/,2+ 0M3)2!0M+ &+1!/!010R,4/!1%!6
0&121! &+1%!4,/) R%1/!1%!&/)&3! /!)&1&!0R+
4%1!*, &! ,+1!510/!1%!6/!!&3&+$6,2/1!51R
,4,-!+/!1%!61,6,2+ 6,2/,*-,0&1&,+R
,;8GBE<64?6;B<68F6B@CBF<G<BA4?
G86;A<DH8F
&3!+ 1%! /%!1,/&) 0&121&,+ ,# 6,2/ -&!!M ,+0& !/ 4%1
0-!&:,*-,0&1&,+)1!%+&.2!06,221&)&7! + %,41%!6
&*1,#2):))6,2/,3!/))-2/-,0!+ $,)0Q!%+&.2!0+
! )&+$2&01& X#,/ !5*-)!M 20&+$ 1/+0&1&,+) 4,/ &+$YM
, &-#/0,#-#(!N
2 &,3&02)X#,/!5*-)!M'251-,0&+$ + &*$!+ 0,+$YM
+ , &)6X%,46,2-)!+ T,/*,3!6,2/, 6&+/!0-,+0!
1,6,2/2 &!+!YQ,*!.2!01&,+01,,+0& !/L
?Q %1/%!1,/&)--!)0 & 6,2*(!$&3!+6,2/
-/1&2)/2 &!+!R%14,/ M*2)1&*! &M+ T,/
, &)6%,&!0 & 6,2*(!R
@Q %1*! &2* & 6,2%,,0!1,,*-,0!&+R& 6,2
4/&1!1/ &1&,+)!006R/!1!-/!0!+11&,+M3& !,M
-, 01M,/4!0&1!R,4 ,!01%&0*! &2*%!)-
,*-)&0%6,2/$,)0R
Attributions
[!<!4'/-3- /6!2!44!23J\'-
'234Z!2
/,0/3'4'/-I
2'4'-%3-15'29-
2%5,!-44'/-J
*'!/!2,--Z++'/44-
4&95!3!-529J442'54'/-BN>
[ !-4'$9'-%/,0/-!-43/$!4Z72!-!33
/54/,0/3'4'/-I/72 &!/29-
!4&/ /+/%9$/22'4'-%45 '!3J\
'-
/,0/3'4'/-/25,
AAV02'-%@>?DWJ2!4'6!
/,,/-3442'54'/-Z&2!+'*!'!-3!N
N, &-#/0,#-#(!
, &-#/0,#-#(!N
J7;
!
K4O4/-HH -CO
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H !;-!,5+4',/ +2!6'3'/-
H !6'3!/-!/$9/52/7-0'!!3/$72'4'-%J
42-3$!22'-%'4$2/,/-!,! '5,'-4/-/4&!2
$(4/4,K2H/36#2$L/D/64
! %!/ 1%! 1!/*0 /!-2/-,0!M 2-6)!M /!20!M + /!6)! &+
N'.&-#')&#-2-),#'!#((,'#1
*6/& ,+1!510,#,2/)&3!0Q,*!1&*!0&1&03& !,,#-!/0,+
1(&+$+,) -&!!,#),1%&+$+ 12/+&+$&1&+1,0,*!1%&+$
+!4M + 1,1%!/0&1&0 &0200&,+ ,#%,4 ,4!-2120!
-)01&&1!*01, &8!/!+120!01,!51!+ 1%!&/)&#!+ 03!1%!*
#/,*1%!)+ :))Q+))1%!0!0!0M4!/!0(! 1,/!1&3!)6
/!&*$&+!+!4)&#!#,/+,'!11%10!!*01,%3!)/! 6
0!/3! &10-2/-,0!Q+1%&0/!&*$&+&+$M4!,#1!+1(!+,'!1
&+,+!#,/*+ /!01&1&+1,+,1%!/Q%20M1%!,) -&)),4
,3!/!,*!0%+ 61!1,4!)M+ 1%!-)01&,11)!12/+0
&+1,/1Q
2)1&*, ) /!3&0&,+ &0 0&*&)/ -/,!00 4%!/! 4! 1(!
1!514/&11!+&+,+!*! &2*,#,**2+&1&,++ /!01&1
&+1,+,1%!/Q + ,&+$ 0,M 4!!*-%0&7! &8!/!+10-!10,#
1%!,/&$&+)1!511, 02&1 1%! +!4*! &2*M + ,#1!+ %+$!
&1001/212/!Q04!/!3&0!#,/+,1%!/*! &2*M4!)0,1%&+(
,21 4%, ,2/ +!4 /!) + &*$&+! 2 &!+! *&$%1 !Q
!!-&+$1%!*&+ *&+ /!.2&/!0201, /!1&3!)6 1%&+(,21
1,+!+ /!$&01!/04!))Q&+))6M4!)0,%3!1,1%&+(,21
1%!$!+/!,#1%!,) + +!43!/0&,+0+ *(! !&0&,+01,
&+,/-,/1!!)!*!+10,/ &+$)6Q
6MH6/ 1$#/K3
%!%,&!,#*! &2*4&)) !-!+ ,+1%!/%!1,/&)0&121&,+Q
%&+(,214%11%!,/&$&+)1!51`0-2/-,0!&0M+ 4%,&10
1/$!12 &!+!*&$%1!Q0! ,+1%&0M,+0& !/4%10-!10
,# 1%&0 /%!1,/&) 0&121&,+ X-2/-,0!M 2 &!+!M /%!1,/M
'.&-#')&#-2-),#'!#((,'#1N
,+01/&+10Y6,24&0%1,-/!0!/3!+ %&$%)&$%1Q,/!5*-)!M
&0&1*,/!&*-,/1+11,(!!-1%!,+1!+1,#1%!*!00$!1%!
0*!M,//!%1%!0*!2 &!+!21&+ &8!/!+1*! &2*R
+04!/&+$1%!0!.2!01&,+04&))$&3!6,2+& !01,4%&%
*! &2* *&$%1 ! !01 02&1! #,/ 6,2/ /!3&0&,+ -/,!00Q
!*!*!/M11%!!+ ,#1%! 6M6,2%3!1,/!1!1!51&+
6,2/*! &2*,#%,&!1%1&0
?Q /!3&0&,+,#+,/&$&+)1!51M+
@Q 8!1&3!)6,**2+&1!0&10*!00$!1,1%!2 &!+!,#
&10%,&!Q
K8E6<F8
/2*'-%'-3,++%2/503J' !-4'$9/-!02/ 544&4'3
3/+ /,,!2'++9N'*/-!/-+'-!6' !/ - /-!
34'++',%!/20&/4/ $/24&!02/ 54N!6'!7!&
- +'344&!4//+34&44&!953!V!N%NJ/+/2J
%!3452!J/,0/3'4'/-J!4NW4//-6!94&!'2,!33%!N
-!9/5&6!4&!+'34/$4//+3J/-3' !2&/74&!9
7/2*4/%!4&!2$/2!& N/7 /4&!9*!!04&!
N'.&-#')&#-2-),#'!#((,'#1
5 '!-!!-%%! !$$!4'6!+9O&4!,/4'/-3 /
4&!9!6/*!O&42!4&!3','+2'4'!3-
'$$!2!-!3!47!!-4&!4//+3- 4&!'2!$$!43
2/334&! 3O
K2H/36#2/HOD-$H6C/ 2
662
06,2/!3&0! 6,2/1!51&+1, +!4*! &2*M/!*!*!/ 1%1
6,2/#,200%,2) !,+/%!1,/&)!8!1&3!+!00Q%,&06,2/
2 &!+!M + %,4 + 6,2 !8!1&3!)6 ,**2+&1! 6,2/
*!00$!1,1%!*&+1%!*! &2*,#6,2/%,&!R,%&!3!1%&0
$,)M,+0& !/1%!#,)),4&+$.2!01&,+0L
H &/'34&!'-4!- ! 5 '!-!O
H &42!4&!/-6!-4'/-3/225+!3/$4&!
%!-2!9/52!2!6'3'-%'-4/O
H &42&!4/2'+4//+3 /9/5-!! '-4&!
,! '5,9/5&6!&/3!-O
H -4&!3!4//+3!!3'+9',0+!,!-4! '-
4&!,! '5,O
'.&-#')&#-2-),#'!#((,'#1N
JJ;
K4O4/-HH -CO
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&!&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H - !234- - !802!33'-72'4'-%4&!
/-!04/$15!!2'-%4!84
H -+9:!&/74!84356!24372'4'-%
/-6!-4'/-3
N+.,#(!).,0,#-#(!
6MH6K$$C$NH
%!& !,#.2!!/&+$1!51,*!0#/,*a012 &!0&+
4%&% .2!!/&+$ &0 1%! %))!+$&+$ ,# &0$!+ !/! ,/
%!1!/,+,/*1&3! 0!52)&16 0 1%! 2+&3!/0) 01+ / ,#
$!+ !/! ,/ 0!52) !5&01!+!Q +1%&0 %-1!/M 4!!5-+ 1%!
+,1&,+ ,# .2!!/&+$ 1, &+)2 ! 1%! -,)&1&0 ,# )+$2$!Q 2/
:/01 10(M 1%!+M &0 1, 2+ !/01+ 1%1M &+ 1%! M 1+ /
*!/&++$)&0% XY &0 -/!0!+1! 0 1%! )&+$2&01& +,/*
4&1% !3!/6,1%!/ #,/* ,# )+$2$! 0!!+ 0 !3&1&,+ #/,*
1%&0 %&!//%&7! !+1!/Q %1 &0 1, 06M 0 -!,-)! )&3&+$ +
4,/(&+$&+1%!M4!%3!1%!$/!1!01!0!,#!001,& !0
+ &+01&121&,+04%!+4!20!Q%&0&0-/1&2)/)61/2!&+
%&$%!/! 21&,+M+ 1%!1,#)&1!/6X/! &+$+ 4/&1&+$YM
4%!/!!5-/!00&,+0&+$!11%!*,0111!+1&,+M/!,$+&1&,+M
+ /!4/ M4%&)!,1%!/#,/*0,#)&+$2&01&!5-/!00&,+/!0!!+
0/!*! &) 14,/01M+ +!! &+$ 1/+0)1&,+1 !01Q !1M0
4!(+,4#/,*1%!%-1!/,+, !!0%&+$M*,01,#2020!
3/&1&,+0 ,# )+$2$!0 4%&% , +,1 :1 1%! 01+ / 0
!01)&0%! 6 M + &+ &3& 2)0 ,# ,),/ /! *,01 ,#1!+
*/$&+)&7! !20!1%!6/!0!!+0!&+$1%!#/1%!01#/,*
Q%!/!#,/!M,2/0!,+ 10(&01,.2!!/,/023!/11!510
6 ),1&+$ + &+1/, 2&+$ &+1%!* +,+\01+ / #,/*0,#
+$)&0%Q
+,/ !/1, ,1%&0M4!*&$%11(!1!514/&11!+&+M+
/!4/&1! 20&+$ +$)&0% &+;!1! 4&1% ,1%!/ )+$2$!0Q / 4!
*&$%1,*-,0!#,/*)!006&++,+\01+ / +$)&0%4%&)!
+.,#(!).,0,#-#(!N
01&)) 20&+$ 1%! &11&,+) + /$2*!+11&3! ,+3!+1&,+0 ,#
Q / 4! *&$%1 023!/1 01+ / 0 ,# &11&,+ +
/$2*!+11&,+ 1, !5-/!00 ,+1!+1 &8!/!+1)6Q %! $,) &0 1,
/!*!*!/4%64!4/&1! !*&-&!!0Z1,,+3!6+& !,/
)&*4&1%!+,2$% !-1%02%1%11%!/! !/2+ !/01+ 0
4%1 4! /! 1/6&+$1, !5-/!00M + 1,/! &1&+ &3& 2)0 +
&+01&121&,+0#,/1%!&/& !04%&%4!*&$%1! /4&+$,+,/
/!#!//&+$1,Q
+H88E<A:4-8KG
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`GAM&C0ZB>
N+.,#(!).,0,#-#(!
K$$C/4,D-$H6C/ 2662
2!!/&+$ ,/ 023!/1&+$ 1!51 &0 -,4!/#2) 1,,) 0 &1 +
%))!+$!Z+ 0,*!1&*!0 &0*+1)!Z!01)&0%! 4/&1&+$
,+3!+1&,+0Q+%,,0&+$-&!!1%16,24&0%1,.2!!/M1%&+(
/!#2))6,216,2/,4+002*-1&,+0,21%,44/&1!/0+
0-!(!/020!)+$2$!Q%1/!0,*!460&+4%&%6,220!
)+$2$!1%1/!*/(!/,#6,2/2)12/!R%&+()0,,21
4%,6,2/2 &!+!&0M+ %,46,24&0%1,,+3&+!1%!*,#
1%!)&*,/& !1%16,2/!-/!0!+1&+$&+1%!-&!!6,2%3!
%,0!+1,/!3&0!Q06,2/!3&0!1%!1!51M,+0& !/1%!#,)),4&+$
.2!01&,+0Q,2*&$%1+!! &1&,+)/!0!/%1,+04!/0,*!
,#1%!*Q
H 2!9/5$,'+'27'4&4&!72'4'-%
/-6!-4'/-330!';4/4&! '3'0+'-!9/52
0'!!!+/-%34/O-/4&!27/2 3J&/7
7!++ /9/5*-/74&!25+!34&49/57'3&
4/&++!-%!O
H 39/515!!29/524!84J /9/57'3&4/
2!334&!/2'%'-+5 '!-!J/27'++4&!
'-4!- ! 5 '!-!! '$$!2!-4O
H /9/5*-/77&44&!+'-%5'34'
!80!44'/-3/$4&'3-!75 '!-!V'$9/5
+.,#(!).,0,#-#(!N
2!&//3'-%-!75 '!-!W2!O
H &4'39/52%/+'-72'4'-%4&'30'!!O-
/4&!27/2 3J7&42!9/5429'-%4/
/-6!94&2/5%&7/2 3O
H -4&4%/+!&'!6! 92!7/2*'-%
4&!4!84^3+'-%5'34'/-6!-4'/-3O&4
&-%!3 /9/5-!! 4/,*!4/&'!6!
4&4%/+O
+H88E<A:4-8KG
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`GAM&C0ZB?
N+.,#(!).,0,#-#(!
JI;
!
K4O4/-HH -CO
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H - !234- 4&! '$$!2!-!!47!!-,2%'-
- -/-7'4&2!$!2!-!4/4!843
H - !234- - !802!33'-72'4'-%&/74!843
$2/,4&!,2%'-3&++!-%!,/2!-/-'+
/-!3
H -+9:!4!843$2/,2'++972!
0!230!4'6!
N,-(0,#-#(!-"-1-0,#-%
6M$NHDC/H$ 1
+!,#1%!460&+4%&%4!+023!/1,/.2!!/1!51&01,
/!3&0!&1#/,*1%!-!/0-!1&3!,#/&1&)!%!,/6XM
0!! %-1!/ E ,+ 1%&0 1%!,/6YQ 2% + --/,% %))!+$!0
#,/*0,#4%&1!+!00,/4%&1!-/&3&)!$!!*! ! 4&1%&+1!510Q
04!/! + 4/&1!1!510M4! ,+`1,#1!+1%&+(,21%,4
)&+$2&01&,+3!+1&,+002%01+ / *!/&++$)&0%M,/
#2+ *!+1),+!-1002%01%!2+&3!/0)02'!1,/]^/!
/,,1! &+ /&)&7! 4,/) 4%&% -)!0 -/!*&2* ,+
4%&1!+!0011%!,01,#)),1%!/& !+1&1&!0Q/&1&+$4&1%
&+*&+ ,*-!)0201,,+#/,+11%!0!& !0+ 1%&+(/&1&))6
,21 460 &+ 4%&% 4! *&$%1 /!4/&1! 1%! 1!51 02% 1%1 &1
+,**, 1!/&) &3!/0&16Q%!/!&0+,,+!\0&7!\:10\))
*!1%, #,/02%+--/,%!20!/!M-/1&2)/)6&+1%!
,+1!51 ,# 1%! M 1,2%!0 2-,+ )) ,1%!/ 0-!10 ,# ,+!`0
)&3! !5-!/&!+!Q%11%&0%-1!/,8!/0/!#!41,,)0+
!5!/&0!04&1%4%&%1,& !+1+ 023!/1/&)002*-1&,+0
4&1%&+1!51Q
06,2/! M&1*&$%1!%!)-#2)1,(!!-1%!0! !:+&1&,+0&+
*&+ Q+,+/!#!/01,, 6,#1!5101%1&0,+0& !/! 1,!
/!-/!0!+11&3!,#!/1&+$/,2-Q+,1%!/4,/ 0M1%!0!4,/(0
/! 0!!+ 0 &*-,/1+1 + 4,/1% 012 6&+$Q /$&+M ,+ 1%!
,1%!/%+ M/!#!/01,4,/(0+ 3,&!01%1/!!5-)&&1)6+
&*-)&&1)6&$+,/! 61%!+,+0!&+$)!001%+&*-,/1+1
,/+,1!4,/1%6Q2!!/&+$1!51,#1!+&+3,)3!03,&!0#/,*1%!
*/$&+%))!+$&+$1%!!+1/)&16,#1%!+,+M+ 02$$!01&+$
,-(0,#-#(!-"-1-0,#-%N
1%1 4! /!,+0& !/ 4%1 ,+01&121!0 ]4,/1%^ +
]&*-,/1+!^4%!+&1,*!01,1!510+ 3,&!0Q
K4@C?8
%""%,$-#&"('%##%*($%+"
.%(&%$'""
')%'!$((
:
&*"($1788=)-'&)"%(".$
)$!%*)%,%$'@,%,(%"(.
')$"'$)$"(((%$"$*A
(*($"$*)%(')%$%"(
&%&"=)'(%#%) )+())
%$'*((>)#(%()(
&''&%$ *'*&%'.%*>
[+*3&0!32/5&! J+9J34!47!!-4&!42!!3
+!-'-%%'-344&!425-*3J+'-%'-%4/4&!!24&J&+$
/,'-%/54J&+$!$$! 7'4&'-4&! ',+'%&4J'-++
4&!44'45 !3/$0'-J- /-,!-4J- !30'2N
-/4&!2,'-!/-4&!+'$$7!-4/$$J$/++/7! 9
3+'%&43&5 !2/$4&!3/'+5- !2,9$!!4N&!7/2*
73%/'-%/-N&!7/2*L- 4&'3734&!0+!
7&!2!3/,!/$4&!&!+0!23& 7'4& 27-4/ '!N
N,-(0,#-#(!-"-1-0,#-%
[&!97!2! 9'-%3+/7+9X'4736!29+!2N&!9
7!2!-/4!-!,'!3J4&!97!2!-/42','-+3J4&!9
7!2!-/4&'-%!24&+9-/7X-/4&'-%54+*
3& /73/$ '3!3!- 34264'/-J+9'-%/-$53! +9
'-4&!%2!!-'3&%+//,N2/5%&4$2/,++4&!2!!33!3
/$4&!/34'-++4&!+!%+'49/$4',!/-4243J+/34
'-5-/-%!-'+3522/5- '-%3J$! /-5-$,'+'2$// J
4&!93'*!-! J!,!'-!$;'!-4J- 7!2!4&!-
++/7! 4/27+79- 2!34N&!3!,/2'5-
3&0!37!2!$2!!3'2X- -!2+934&'-N!%-
4/ '34'-%5'3&4&!%+!,/$4&!!9!35- !24&!42!!3N
&!-J%+-'-% /7-J37$!-!2,9&- N
&!+*/-!32!+'-! 4$5+++!-%4&7'4&/-!
3&/5+ !2%'-344&!42!!J- 3+/7+94&!!9!+' 3
2/3!- 4&!35-*!-!9!3+//*! 504,!J
!-/2,/53- 6-4J*'- /$+'- J7&'4!<'*!2'-
4&! !04&3/$4&!/23J7&'& '! /543+/7+9N&!
,-3!!,! 9/5-%X+,/34/9X549/5*-/7
7'4&4&!,'4^3&2 4/4!++N$/5- -/4&'-%!+3!4/ /
544//$$!2&',/-!/$,9%// 7! !^33&'0^3
'35'43& '-,90/*!4N&!;-%!23+/3! 3+/7+9
/-'4- &!+ X4&!2!73-//4&!2,/6!,!-4-
-//4&!2%+-!N!& 4'! '4/$7&'4!7/234!
2/5- &'3-!*X&9O&!2! ' &!%!4'4O3'4
%!X-/2-,!-4X&2,X02/0'4'4/294O
34&!2!-9' !4++/--!4! 7'4&'4O4
,-(0,#-#(!-"-1-0,#-%N
+//*! 3424+'-%2/5- &'3+*-!*J4&'3'4/$
7&'4!4&2! $2/,!9/- 4&!3!3N
[!24&!3,!42!!47/,/2!5- +!3/$54!
-%+!3347'4&4&!'2+!%3 27-50N-!J7'4&&'3
&'-02/00! /-&'3*-!!3J342! 4-/4&'-%J'--
'-4/+!2+!- 00++'-%,--!2I&'32/4&!2
0&-4/,2!34! '43$/2!&! J3'$/6!2/,!7'4&
%2!47!2'-!33Q- ++/54/4&!237!2!344!2!
'-!6!290/3!/$/-4/24! /++03!J3'-3/,!
0'452!/$,332!/20!34'+!-!N&'+!34//
&/22/2Z3425*J/-!/$4&!3!2!452!32/3!4/&'3
&- 3- *-!!3J- 7!-4/$$/-++Z$/5234/72 3
4&!2'6!24/ 2'-*N!+00! /54/$&'3&- J4&!-
3450'-4&!35-+'%&4J2/33'-%&'33&'-3'-$2/-4/$
&',J- $4!24',!+!4&'37//++9&! $++/-&'3
2!34/-!N\V$2/,/3!0&/-2 ^3!24/$
2*-!33V2/)!454!-!2%4!84W
N,-(0,#-#(!-"-1-0,#-%
BHAG8E8K4@C?8
(&((('%#$%)',""C!$%,$
$%+"""
$(""&')
@1857A.)
'$$%+"()$*=,')(
!)%%$'F()-).',$))$)%$)%
%,)"))''&'($)('="'$
)(&((:)$!%*)%,(
',')$%$'F(+(%$%'$
'$(=
[*/-*7/737!++*-/7-4&2/5%&/544&!-'-!
6'++%!3- !6!-!9/- N'3$,!2!34! /-3/+'
0!23/-+&'!6!,!-43N39/5-%,-/$!'%&4!!-
&!& 2/5%&4&/-/24/&'36'++%!94&2/7'-%
,+'-:!4&!4N,+'-:!734&!%2!472!34+!2
7&/$/23!6!-9!23735-!4!-J$2/,,5/;
4/'-/N!73++! 4&!4!53!&'3*
7/5+ -!6!24/5&4&!!24&N4734&'3,-4&4
*/-*7/4&2!7'-;%&47&'&4&!/+ ,!-%2!!
73/-!/$4&!;!2!343'-!4&!$/5- !2/$4&!'2
4/7-!-%%! 30'2'4/$4&!7'+ $/23!6!- 93-
3!6!--'%&43N
,-(0,#-#(!-"-1-0,#-%N
&! 25,3!4- 4&!<54!33-%- 4&!
30!44/23&!+ 4&!'22!4&N,+'-:!737'+9
2$43,-J54*/-*7/7333+'00!293;3&'-
74!2N6!29-!26!- !6!29,53+!34// /54/-
4&!'22,3J/-4&!'2*3- 4&!'24&'%&3J- /-!
+,/34&!2 4&!,342!4&'-%4/2!*'-%0/'-4N-
4&!!- J*/-*7/4&2!74&!4N
&473,-99!23%/J47!-499!23/2,/2!J
- 52'-%4&'34',!*/-*7/^3$,!& %2/7-
+'*!53&Z;2!'-4&!&2,44-N!734++-
&5%!J- &'353&9!9!2/73- 7' !-/3!%6!
&',6!293!6!2!+//*N!2!4&! &!6'+9J- '4
733' 4&4J7&!-&!3+!04J&'37'6!3- &'+ 2!-
'-4&!'2&/53!3/5+ &!2&',2!4&!N&!-&!
7+*! J&'3&!!+3&2 +94/5&! 4&!%2/5- - &!
3!!,! 4/7+*/-302'-%3J3'$&!73%/'-%4/
0/5-!/-3/,!/ 9N- &! ' 0/5-!/-0!/0+!
15'4!/$4!-N!& 3+'%&434,,!2- 7&!-!6!2
&!73-%29- /5+ -/4%!4&'37/2 3/54
15'*+9!-/5%&J&!7/5+ 53!&'3;343N!& -/
04'!-!7'4&5-35!33$5+,!-N!& & -/
04'!-!7'4&&'3$4&!2N
-/*J$/24&473&'3$4&!2^3-,!J& '! 4!-
9!23%/N-&'3 9&!73+:9- ',02/6' !-4
- 7315'4!'-0+!/$4&'-*'-%/54
N,-(0,#-#(!-"-1-0,#-%
4/,/22/7N$-9,/-!9,!&'379J- '43!+ /,
' J&!',,! '4!+9/5%&4%/52 3/$0+,Z7'-!J
++! 2/5- &'3-!'%&/23- , !,!229N!
+7933' 4&47&!-!6!2&!37 ! ,-^3
,/54&&!374&!$/++9/$-/4!4'-%7&4/-!&
'-/-!^3+'$!4',!N-/*73J/$/523!J !4/2J-
&!/7! !6!29-!'%&/23/,!,/-!9J$2/,$!7
/72'!34/15'4!3534-4'+,/5-43N
!734++546!294&'-- & 3+'%&434//0N!
7/2!&%%2 - ,/52-$5++//*!8!047&!-&!
73 2'-*'-%/20+9'-%/-&'3<54!N!736!29
%// /-&'3<54!J- &'3&00'!34,/,!-437!2!
4&!47//24&2!!,//-3$4!24&!&26!347&!-4&!
6'++%!,53''-32/5%&4 /7-4&!'2'-3425,!-43J
&5-%/6!4&!;2!0+!N-/*7/5+ 0+97'4&
4&!,J&'3$!!,'-%7'4&+!33! -!33- 0!!N
/,!4',!3-/4&!26'++%!7/5+ 3*-/*^3-
- 4&!'2 -'-%!%75%754//,!- 3497'4&
4&!,- 4!&4&!,4&!'245-!3N&!97/5+ %/4/
35&&/343$/23+/-%34&2!!/2$/52,2*!43J
,*'-%,53'- $!34'-%N-/*+/6! 4&!%//
$2!- 4&!%// $!++/73&'0J- &!+/6! 4&'3
3!3/-/$4&!9!2J7&!-4&!2'-3& 34/00! -
4&!35-2/3!!6!29,/2-'-%7'4& ::+'-%!549N
- '473-/44//&/4!'4&!2J!53!4&!/+ -
29&2,44-7'- 73+/7'-% /7-$2/,4&!
,-(0,#-#(!-"-1-0,#-%N
-/24&N/,!9!234&!&2,44-736!293!6!2!
- !-3!&:!&5-%/-4&!4,/30&!2!N+ ,!-
- &'+ 2!-7/5+ 4&!-3'42/5- +/%;2!3J72,'-%
4&!'2/ '!3N-/*+/6! '4++J- &!+/6! 4&!;234
*'4!34&42!452-! 7'4&4&! 293!3/-J- 4&!
&'+ 2!-7&/3-%3/-%3/$7!+/,!4/4&!,N!
7/5+ 2!,!,!2&'3/7-&'+ &// J&/7&!&
/$4!-7- !2! 2/5- +//*'-%$/2*'4!3'+'-%
+!'352!+9%'-344&!+5!3*9N33//-3&!$/5-
/-!&!7/5+ 3'-%7'4&&'37&/+!!'-%J7!+/,'-%
'4*$2/,'43+/-%J+/-%)/52-!9J- 3*'-%'4'$'4
& 2/5%&4&/,!-9+!-%4&3/$+/4&N
&4739!23%/J7&!-&!739/5-%N-/*J
4&!%2/7-Z50J73$'+52!N!730//2- &'3
7'$!- &'+ 2!-& 2!+9!-/5%&4/!4N!/0+!
+5%&! 4&',!53!&!73+/$!2J- 4&!9
37/2!-!6!24/+!- &',-9,/2!,/-!9!53!
&!-!6!20' *N54-/*7335&,-4&4
&!+79335!! ! '-/22/7'-%,/2!J- 0'+'-%
50&'3 !43N\V$2/,&!!^3
&'-%3++024
W
N,-(0,#-#(!-"-1-0,#-%
K8E6<F8
*!0'!!/$00!2/2/0!--!7 /5,!-4J-
2!30/- 4/4&!$/++/7'-%15!34'/-3I
H &4 '$$!2!-!3 /9/5-/4'!!47!!-
/-2 - &!!^32!02!3!-44'/-/$2!O
H &9 /!3'4,44!24&47!$/2!%2/5-
15!34'/-3/$2!'-34/294!++'-%O&4 /7!
%'-/2+/3!9 /04'-%4&'3002/&O
K8E6<F8,-4F4,;8GBE<64?-BB?
6'-%-+9:! +'4!2294!843J+!453452-4/-/-Z
+'4!229- R/22!+Z7/2+ !8,0+!3N/2*7'4&9/52
%2/504/' !-4'$9-2!/$522!-4$$'23
,-(0,#-#(!-"-1-0,#-%N
V&00!-'-%3'-/527/2+ 4/ 9W7&!2!9/53!!
15!34'/-3/$2!- 3934!,'2'3,$/2!%2/5- ! N
&'3/5+ !'--!%4'6!V2'34W/20/3'4'6!
79X9/5 !' !3%2/50N-!9/5&6! !' !
/--2!/24/0'J53!3!2&!-%'-!4/;-
2!+!6-424'+!/-4&!35)!4N !++9J4&'3'33&/24
0'!!J54'$-/4J;- 35'4+!!8!204$2/,4&!
4!84N
! 4&!4!84/2!8!204+/3!+94/' !-4'$9&/72!
'3!'-%72'44!-/54N
H &47/2 3/20&23!334- /54O&9O
H 34&!35)!4,44!22!<!4! '-4&!349+!/$
72'4'-%O-/4&!27/2 3J'34&!0'!!
356!24'-%4- 2 ,!2'--%+'3&
/-6!-4'/-3O
H /7 /!34&!4/0'/2!6!-430!*4/9/52
/7-' !-4'490/3'4'/-3O/!3'42!$;2,/2
&++!-%!9/52/7-0!230!4'6!3O
N,-(0,#-#(!-"-1-0,#-%
0,#-#(!-),"-),#&&2(&23'#-1-N
N0,#-#(!-),"-),#&&2(&23'#-1-
J+;
9
:
K4O4/-HH -CO
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H !-4'$94&!*!9!+!,!-43/$- !,'4!84
H - !234- - !802!33'-72'4'-%&/7
!,'4!8432!3425452!
H !%'-2&!4/2'++9-+9:'-% !,'4!843
,"-),#&&2(&23#(!'#-1--#)(
)/,/#0N
!6'3'4I&4'3,/ '! &!4/2'3O
#$3/ $NHDD$4C$
! /! ,#1!+ 0(! 1, /! !*& 1!510 02% 0 0%,)/)6
!0060M/1&)!0M+ *,+,$/-%0Q%!1%!/4!/! 1%!0!1!510
!20! 1%!6 /! 00&$+! #,/ )00M ,/ 4! /!0!/%&+$
1,-&M,/1%!60-!(1,+&+1!/!01M4!)*,01)460--/,%
1%!*0:+&0%! -/, 210Q%1&01,06M4!0!!1%!*01%!
!+ /!02)1M 0 0,*!1%&+$ %&$%)6 !3!),-! + -,)&0%! Q 1
1%!0*!1&*!M4!)0,202))6/! 1%!*1,2+ !/01+ 1%!&/
,+1!+1M //!)6 -6&+$ 11!+1&,+ 1, 1%! #,/* &+ 4%&% 1%!
,+1!+1&0 !)&3!/! Q
!*&1!510M%,4!3!/M/!)0,$!+/!Q%&0*!+01%1
1%!61,,%3!/2)!0 ,#,+01/21&,+M+ 1%11%!&/#,/*1,,
*201#,)),4!/1&+/%!1,/&),+3!+1&,+0Q%&)!1%!0-!&:0
,# 1%!0! ,+3!+1&,+0 /! !1!/*&+! 6 1%! &0&-)&+!X0Y 1,
4%&% 1%! !*& 1!510 !),+$M /, )6 0-!(&+$ 21%,/0
*(!1%!#,)),4&+$*,3!0L
N,"-),#&&2(&23#(!'#-1--#)(
)/,/#0
H 2!3!-44&!'22!3!2&02/+!,3V3W3024
/$-/-%/'-%/-6!234'/-
H 2/6' !/-4!84$/24&!2! !24/
5- !234- 4&!2!3!2&02/+!,V3W
H '35334&!'2,!4&/ /+/%9
H 2!3!-44&!'2;- '-%3J%5' ! 94&!
2!3!2&15!34'/-3J- 3500/24! 9
!6' !-!
H 5%%!34$5452!6!-5!3/$'-15'29
HCK HKC22O42OP/4, #$3/
$NHD
2/ 10( &+ 1%&0 %-1!/ &0 1, --/,% !*& 1!510 +,1
0:+&0%! -/, 210M21/1%!/0*, !)04%,0!,+01&12!+1
-/104!/!$,&+$1,&0,)1!+ 012 6Q,/,2/-2/-,0!0M1%!+M
4!+!! 1,#,20,+1%!#,/*/1%!/1%+1%!,+1!+1,#1%!0!
1!510Q,*!1&*!01%&04&))!%/ 1, ,0#,/*+ ,+1!+1
/!&+1!/14&+! &+4!))\01/212/! 1!510M+ 1%1*!00&+!00&0
,(6Q
! /! $,&+$ 1, !$&+ 4&1% 1%! 1!51`0 1&1)!M *,3! 1, 1%!
&+1/, 21,/60!1&,+0M:+ 1%!21%,/`0/$2*!+1M1%!&/20!,#
!3& !+!M+ :+))6M1%!,+)2 &+$-/$/-%0Q1&0$,,
,"-),#&&2(&23#(!'#-1--#)(
)/,/#0N
& !1, 1%&+(&+1!/*0 ,#0!1&,+0/1%!/ 1%+-/$/-%0M0
,#1!+4!4&)) !+,2+1!/1!5101%1 !3!),-/!)1! & !0,3!/
0!3!/)-/$/-%0Q
A4?LM<A:-<G?8F
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`GGM&C0ZB@
3&+$ -!/#,/*! 1%! ,3! !5!/&0!M )!1 20 /!;!1 ,+ 1%!
-/,!00Q%1/!0,*!,#1%! 3+1$!0,# !*&1&1)!0R
%1 /! 0,*! &0 3+1$!0R %1 4!/! 0,*! ,# 1%!
01/1!$&!01%14,/(! 4!)) 2/&+$1%&0!5!/&0!R!!-&+$1%,0!
&+*&+ 4&))-/,3!%+ 64%!+4!4,/(4&1%#2))1!510Q
N,"-),#&&2(&23#(!'#-1--#)(
)/,/#0
%8L+H8FG<BAF9BE,;8GBE<64??L
A4?ML<A:6478@<6-8KGF
&!$/++/7'-%15!34'/-3,9!53! 4/2&!4/2'++9
-+9:!4&!3425452!/$ !,'4!843I
H &4 /!34&!4'4+!35%%!34/544&!24'+!^3
/-4!-43O
H &4'34&!54&/2^3[/0!-'-%,/6!J\-
&/7 /!3'47/2*O
H /7- 7&!2! /!34&!54&/2'-/20/24!
7&4'3!'-%3' 9/4&!23'-4&!;!+ -
7&94&!2!O-/4&!27/2 3J&/7- 7&!2!
/!34&!54&/2 '3533/4&!24&!/2'343
7/2*'-%/-4&!3,!/23','+202/+!,3O
H &4J'--543&!++J'34&!54&/2^32%5,!-4O
H &4'34&!72'4!2^3-!74*!/-4&'-%3O
H &!2!'3&'3/2&!24&!3'3O
H /7&34&!72'4!23425452! 4&!!6' !-!
$/2&'3/2&!20/'-4O&43/24/$!6' !-!'3
4&!54&/253'-%V4!845+O&'34/2'+O
4&!/2!4'+O!4NW
,"-),#&&2(&23#(!'#-1--#)(
)/,/#0N
H &42!4&!,/6!3!'-%, !'-4&!
/-+53'/-J- &/7 /!3'4 '$$!23425452++9
$2/,4&!'-42/ 54'/-O
4L/HH/64DH6$#"$)$ H"4#
C/H$
+ 1%&0 &+1/, 21&,+ 1, 1%! 0!1&,+ ]%!1,/&))6 +)67&+$
!*&!510M^4!&+3&1!6,21,/! 0,*!0*-)!/%!1,/&)
+)60&0!0060#/,*,1%!/&+1/6`0,))!$!012 !+10Q!
%3!)0,&+)2 ! 0,*!&+3&11&,+01,4/&1!M0%/! 64/&1&+$
-/,#!00,/01&+1/6`0,))!$!Q
GH78AG0E<G<A:
!7/5+ +'*!4/'-+5 !345 !-472'4'-%'-4&'3
3!4'/-N$9/52!'-4!2!34! '-05+'3&'-%9/52
7/2*J0+!3!;++/544&'3$/2,- 35,'40'!!/$
N,"-),#&&2(&23#(!'#-1--#)(
)/,/#0
9/5272'4'-%$2/,9/5272'4'-%+33N!7'++7/2*
7'4&9/54/%!4'405+'3&! N
!2!2!3/,!2&!4/2'+%!-2!-+93!372'44!-9
345 !-43- 05+'3&! 4/4&!25-'6!23'4'!3N!
4&'-*9/5^++;- 4&!3!,!-4/24!84353!$5+I
)%'"$".((%(%*'(%##*$)(
H !+4&'4!29- 43$$!43I!-2!
-+93'3/$4'!-4526!93T!7U9
++/29/$$V2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7UW
H &!!23/-+- 2/$!33'/-+2/!33/$
2'4'-%!&-'+-34254'/-3-5+T!7
U96--&5%%!2V2'4!2^344!,!-4
T!7UW
(%*'(%##*$).$".((
H /,,5-'49'-2'3'3I2R02!,! 9'+9
!!2
H - !2-!4&4&!!4&!2*!43- &2/,!
'0!3I!3!2&'-4//,,5-'49/$/+
'*!239+!24!%2'
H &!/+!/$'!-4';'4!29'-4&!'3/523!
/,,5-'49/$!6!+/0,!-4+!52/'/+/%'343
95+'- :'
H '3'-%!3!2&!2I&!/+!/$!-4/23&'0
,"-),#&&2(&23#(!'#-1--#)(
)/,/#0N
'-/24/29-6'2/-,!-439'- 39
'3&/$$
#AI<G4G<BAFGB0E<G8,;8GBE<64??L
A4?LM<A:FF<:A@8AG*EB@CGF
&!&04!23'-4&'33!4'/-3&/5+ 02!02!9/5$/2
/,0+!4'-%/-!/$4&!3!35,,4'6!72'4'-%
33'%-,!-43N&!3!!8,0+!32!33'%-,!-434&4
7!2!/,,!- N
(($#$)-#&"<1
$4!22! '-%/&-7+!3^!84!- ! !;-'4'/-/$
'3/523!/,,5-'49J&//3! '3/523!/,,5-'49
4&49/57/5+ +'*!4/345 94&2/5%&/544&!
3!,!34!2N&!-72'4!-!3394&4 !;-!3-
!32'!34&! '3/523!/,,5-'49N9024'5+2
44!-4'/-4/4&!2/+!4&44&!/ 90+93'-4&'3
'3/523!/,,5-'49N&'3,9$/53/-&/74&!
'3/523!/,,5-'49,!,!230/24294&!/ 9
N,"-),#&&2(&23#(!'#-1--#)(
)/,/#0
- R/2&/7/543' !23'-4!202!44&!/ 9/$4&!
'3/523!/,,5-'49,!,!23N/53&/5+ 02/6' !
/-2!4!!8,0+!9-+9:'-%/-!4!845+24'$4
02/ 5! 99/52 '3/523!/,,5-'494&4
2!02!3!-43/2' !-4';!34&!/ 9V3!!&04!2@C$/2
4&!/-!04/$4&! '3/523!/,,5-'49WN
(($#$)-#&"<2
-9/$53&6!72'44!-2&!4/2'+-+93!3'-
03472'4'-%+33!3N/24&'3!339J9/57'++
&/0!$5++942-3$!24&4*-/7+! %!4/4&'3!339
7&'+!+3/5'+ '-%/-4&402'/2*-/7+! %!
7'4& !!0!25- !234- '-%/$2&!4/2'+
3'454'/-N'234J&//3!- !,'24'+!4&4
9/57/5+ +'*!4/-+9:!NV43&/5+ !2!+4!
4/4&!4/0'9/57-44/2!3!2&'-4&'3+33NW
!/- J72'4!2&!4/2'+-+93'3/$4&44!84
4&4' !-4';!3- !32'!3'432&!4/2'+
!+!,!-43J- 33!33!3'43!$$!4'6!-!334
2!4'-%&-%!N&!2&!4/2'+!+!,!-43
2!33! 3&/5+ !3$/++/73I!8'%!-!J
2&!4/2J5 '!-!J/-342'-43J- /4&!2
2!+!6-430!43/$4&!4!84N&!!33933&/5+
,"-),#&&2(&23#(!'#-1--#)(
)/,/#0N
!!47!!-@ZA0%!3'-+!-%4&N/525 '!-!'3
9/52$!++/7/++!%5!344N29^3/++!%!N/5-
335,!4&44&!9 /-/4*-/74&!2&!4/2'+4!2,3
9/57'++53!J3/9/53&/5+ !;-!9/524!2,3-
!80+'-4&!/-4!84/$4&!4!849/52!-+9:'-%N
Works Cited
/9+!J2%2!4- 2934+++J[!&'-%
]/-5'8/4!^'-4&!'%'4+%!I%!-
2!!-J'35+- 4'+!J\
'30-'J
/+N
GGJ/NBJ@>?DND>>ZD?BN
-/&J!33'- ,!+-'43,J
[2&'6+'4!29I! '-%4&!&!4/2'/$
'%'4+2&'6!3'-4&!- !2%2 54!
+332//,J\
/++!%!/,0/3'4'/--
/,,5-'4'/-
J/+NDEJ/N@J@>?CN
@?DZ@B@N
N,"-),#&&2(&23#(!'#-1--#)(
)/,/#0
J*;
!
$,-4M$$4$O
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&!&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H !-4'$915+'4'!3/$ '3/523!/,,5-'4'!3'-
30!'; '3'0+'-!3
H !-4'$9&/7 '3'0+'-!32!+4!4/3&2!
#).,)''.(#-#2).,'$),#).,
)''.(#-2N
6+5!3
H -+9:!%!-2!/$72'4'-%953'-% '3/523!
/,,5-'4'!3
,2*6%3!!!+0(! ,//!0(&+$4%16,24&))*',/&+
2/&+$6,2/1&*!&+,))!$!Q%&0 !&0&,+&0+,1+!06,+!Q
1&04/--! 2-&+6,2/0-&/1&,+0X&Q!QM%14&))6,2
#1!/,))!$!RY04!))06,2/& !+1&1&!0X&Q!QM,6,2& !+1
0 0&!+1&01M -%&),0,-%!/M +!/RYQ %&0 !&0&,+ %0
/!3!/!/1&,+01%1,++!14%,6,2%3!!!+M4%,6,2/!M
+ 4%, 6,2 4&)) !M + 1%1 ,++!1 1%! & !+1&1&!0 +
!),+$&+$ 1%1 6,2 %3! /!1! 4&1% 1%! & !+1&1&!0 +
!),+$&+$1%1*6%3!!!+1%/2012-,+6,2Q
,#2/1%!/,*-)&1!1%&0 !&0&,+M&+1%&0%-1!/M4!0%,4
6,2%,4*',/0/!)0,&+#20! 4&1%1%!&/,4+0!1,#3)2!0M
+,/*0M &1&,+M+ $!+/!0Z)),#4%&%/!1! &8!/!+!0&+
%,41!510/!1,!/! + 4/&11!+Q
6KC06CD/D /82/4CO
/D 6KCD$633K4/HO
!,-)!,#1!+002*!1%14%!+1%!6012 6-/1&2)/*',/M
1%!6/!)!/+&+$,+1!+1L1%!+,+&)/!0!/%M1%!,/&!0M+
1!510Q,4!3!/M6,2)!/+0,*2%*,/!1%+1%1Q,2)0,
N#).,)''.(#-#2).,'$),#).,
)''.(#-2
)!/+ %,41, /! + 4/&1! &+ 1%1 &0&-)&+!M + 1%/,2$%
1%1M %,4 1, !,*! -/1 ,# 1%1 *',/Q +! 20!#2) )!+0
#,/ 2+ !/01+ &+$ %,4 6,2 !3!),- &+ *',/ &0 &0,2/0!
,**2+&161%!,/6Q%&01%!,/6M#/,*,%+4)!0M-,0&101%1
!/1&+ ,**2+&1&!0 X)&(! 6,2/ *',/Y /! &0,2/0!
,**2+&1&!0M+ %!6/!M1%!+1%!&/*!*!/0%3!0%/!
.2)&1&!0Q
<F6<C?<A8F4F<F6BHEF8
B@@HA<G<8F
?N &!9&6!3&2! %/+3- 6+5!3N
@N &!9&6!!24'-7934&44&!9
/,,5-'4!7'4&!&/4&!2N
AN &!902/6' !'-$/2,4'/-$!! *4/!&
/4&!2N
BN &!953!!24'-490!3/$4!8434&4,9/2
,9-/4!5-'15!4/4&4/,,5-'49N
CN &!9&6!3&2! +-%5%!4&4,9/2
,9-/4!5-'15!4/4&4/,,5-'49N
DN &!9&6! '$$!2!-4+!6!+3/$,!,!23&'0'-
4&!/,,5-'497'4&3/,!0!/0+!7&/&6!
#).,)''.(#-#2).,'$),#).,
)''.(#-2N
!!-'-4&!/,,5-'49$/2+/-%4',!J7&'+!
/4&!232!$'2+9-!7N&!--!7,!,!23
34/0)/'-'-%J3 +9J '3/523!/,,5-'49
7/5+ '!N
&1% 1%!0! D %/1!/&01&0M 4! %,-! 6,2 + 0!! 1%1 6!0M
6,2/ *',/ !:+&1!)6 :10 &+1, &1Q ! $/!!Q + 1%! *,/!
,*#,/1)! 6,2 /! 4&1% 2+ !/01+ &+$ 1%!0! 0%
 &+
&0,2/0!,**2+&1&!0M1%!*,/! !-16,24&))!&+*,3&+$
!14!!+)00!0M*',/0M*&+,/0M+ !3!+12))6,+1,$/ 21!
0%,,),/&+ 201/6Q00!+1&))6M1%!464!/! + 4/&1!&+
,2/ )00!0 &0 ,+01/21! 1%/,2$% %2*+ &+1!/1&,+M
#,/!$/,2+ &+$1%! 6+*&0-!10,#/! &+$+ 4/&1&+$&+
,))!$!)00!0Q
!:+ 1%&0,-!+!001!51#/,*+!)7!/-/1&2)/)6
20!#2)&+1!%&+$ &0,2/0!,**2+&1&!0Q
+ 1%! #,)),4&+$ 1&3&16M 4! &+3&1! 6,2 1, /!;!1 ,+
&0,2/0!,**2+&161%16,2!),+$1,Q/61,/!;!1,+1%&0
,+!-1&+?>>4,/ 0,/*,/!Q
N#).,)''.(#-#2).,'$),#).,
)''.(#-2
,8W86G<BA<F6BHEF86B@@HA<G<8F
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>?M&C0ZBA
-$/'$C$4HC$D6&HK#O
#,2/%,0!+*',/0/! &8!/!+1 &0,2/0!,**2+&1&!0M1%!+
&1 *!+0 1%1M !-&01!*,),$&))6M 1%!6 *(! + 0%/!
(+,4)! $! &+ &8!/!+1460Q %&0*!+0 1%14%!+ 6,2 /!
0(! 1, 4/&1! 1!51 &+ &,),$6M 1%! !5-!11&,+0 4&)) !
&8!/!+11%+,24!/!0(! 1,4/&1!1!51&+%&01,/6Q%!
,**2+&1&!0%3! &8!/!+1$,)0M1%!6%3! &8!/!+116-!0,#
1!510M 1%!6 %3! &8!/!+1 )+$2$!0M + 1%!6 %3! &8!/!+1
460 ,# ,**2+&1&+$Q + !+1&/! :!) ,# ! 21&,+ &0
#).,)''.(#-#2).,'$),#).,
)''.(#-2N
! &1! 1,1/6&+$1,2+-())1%!0! &8!/!+!0#,/4/&1!/0
)&(!6,2Q
1%1%&03& !,#,//&!#02**/6,#1%&0:!) X3&!41&*!
&0AL??YL
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>?M/!,! Z?
#):=F9F".#-#-#*&#(,3&#.,3G3#.,3",-
+ 1%&0 3& !,M 6,2 41%! 6+1%& %+%+M 0%,)/M
4%, -2)&0%! -&!! 4&1% %+%+ + &0&0%& 1,
2+ !/01+ 1%! &8!/!+13)2!0*,+$%!*&01/6M%&01,/6M+
*1% -/,#!00,/0Q %!6 &0,3!/! 1%1 1%!6 /! 3!/6
&8!/!+1)60! ,+1%!&//!,#012 6M,/4%14!4,2) ))
1%!&/ &0,2/0!,**2+&16Q
N#).,)''.(#-#2).,'$),#).,
)''.(#-2
"$'! &&
4&!,!'& %!+,*1 !+,'*1 ,
'&,0,-$!2,!'&
-6&+$
11!+1&,+1,
1%!,+1!51&+
4%&%1!51
&04/&11!+L
,+0& !/1&,+
,#1%!1&*!
-!/&, M1%!
!5-!/1&0!
/!-/!0!+1!
&+1%!1!51M
+ 1%!
!$/!!1,
4%&%
,+1!51&0
1(!+&+1,
,2+1Q
%!*&010
/! X$!1
!1&)0Y
&01,/&+0/!
1%!*,01,21
,+1!512)&71&,+
1%!*1&&+0
& +,1
1%!,+1!
/! &+$Q
'-*!&
&+)2 !0
,+0& !/1&,+
,#4%!/!
&+#,/*1&,+
,*!0#/,*
X!Q$QM-/&*/6
,/0!,+ /6
0,2/!0YM4%,
1%!21%,/0
/!X!Q$QM
9)&1&,+0M
4%11%!&/
]-,)&1&0^
/!YM+
4%1(&+ ,#
,2*!+1&1
&0Q
%!*&010
/! 4%!/!
1%!
0&!+1&010
4!/!#/,*M
4%1
2+&3!/0&16M
+ &10
-/!01&$!Q
&01,/&+0/!
1%!*,01
1%!*1&&+0
-2/-,0!#2))6
&$+,/! &1Q
#).,)''.(#-#2).,'$),#).,
)''.(#-2N
'**''*,!'&
&+)2 !0
,+0& !/1&,+
,#$/!!*!+10
+
&0$/!!*!+10
/,001!510,/
!14!!+1%!
1!51+ ,+!`0
(+,4)! $!Q
))1%!
-/1&&-+10
1/&! 1,
,//,,/1!
4%11%!6
4!/!/! &+$
4&1%1%!&/
,4+
($/,2+
(+,4)! $!Q
%!%&01,/&+0
20!
,//,,/1&,+1,
!1!/*&+!1%!
21%,/`0
/$2*!+1Q
%!
*1%!*1&&+0
20!
,//,,/1&,+1,
)&*&1
*&0&+1!/-/!11&,+Q
0,+,*-,-*
&+)2 !01%!
,+0& !/1&,+
,#%,41%!
&+#,/*1&,+
&+1!510&0
,/$+&7! Q
%!*&010
)0,20!
1%!
01/212/!1,
!1!/*&+!
1%!& !0M
+,11,
/&1&.2!&1
&+1%!46
1%!
%&01,/&+
& Q
,/%&01,/&+0M
1%&0*!+0
-6&+$11!+1&,+
1,1%!01/212/!0
,#+//1&3!+
/$2*!+10
461, !1!/*&+!
1%!21%,/`0
-,0&1&,+Q
1%!*1&&+0
-& 11!+1&,+1,
4%1!%
-/$/-
,&+$1,
!1!/*&+!1%!
-/,)!*0+
0,)21&,+0Q
N#).,)''.(#-#2).,'$),#).,
)''.(#-2
*( !$%&,+
&+)2 !
,+0& !/1&,+
,#-&12/!0M
%/10M1)!0M
+ ,1%!/
$/-%&0Q
%!*&010
041%!0!
!)!*!+100
!00!+1&)
&+#,/*1&,+
1,!
1/+0)1!
+
,*-/!
1,1%!-/,0!
%!%&01,/&+0
/! 1%!
-%,1,$/-%0+
/&1&.2!1%!*&+
1%!0*!460
1%!6 & 1%!
-/,0!Q
1%!*1&&+0
04+,
&01&+1&,+
!14!!+$/-
!)!*!+10+
-/,0!M1/!1&+$
1%!*0!
&*-,/1+1Q
*!,!)-
))1%!!5-!/10
!+$$! &+
/&1&.2!0
1%!6/! M21
1%!+12/!,#
1%1/&1&.2!
&8!/! 6
&0&-)&+!Q
,/
%!*&010M
1%!/&1&.2!
#,20! ,+
1!51`0
-)20&&)&16
,/&10
,+$/2!+!
4&1%
0&!+1&:
!3& !+!Q
,/%&01,/&+0M
!3!/61%&+$40
#,20,#,+01+1
/&1&.2!M4&1%1%!
&+1!+1,#
!1!/*&+&+$1%!
/! &&)&16,#1%!
21%,/`0
/$2*!+1Q
,/
*1%!*1&&+0M
,//!1+!00,#
&+#,/*1&,+4
1%!&/0,2/
/&1&.2!S1%!6
4!&$%! !%
4,/ /!#2))6
*!&'*
C$'+*!&D
%!*&010
/!\/!
!/1&+
-/10M)&(!
),,(&+$1
1%!/!02)10
0!1&,+,#
1!511,
!5*&+!&1Q
&01,/&+0
/!\/! !/1&+
-/10M&1*&$%1!
& !+1&+$
&+#,/*1&,+1%1
&0+!4+
/!!5*&+&+$1%1
&+#,/*1&,+Q
%!
*1%!*1&&+0
4!/!1%!,+!0
4%,+*!
01/1!$6M,#1!+
1(&+$B1,C
%,2/01,/!
',2/+)/1&)!Q
+ 02**/6M 1%! 1%/!! -&/0 ,# !5-!/10 !+$$! &+ 0&*&)/
01/1!$&!0211,3/6&+$ !$/!!0+ &+2+&.2!460Q+1!/*0
,#/&1&.2!M,//&1&)/! &+$M1%!*1%!*1&&+04!/!*,01
!+$$! 4&1% :+ &+$ !//,/M 1%! %!*&010 4&1% 0!!(&+$
,+0&01!+64&1%!51!/+)0&!+1&:!3& !+!M+ 1%!%&01,/&+0
#).,)''.(#-#2).,'$),#).,
)''.(#-2N
4&1% 4!&$%&+$ 1%!&*-)&1&,+0,# &8!/!+1 -!/0-!1&3!0 +
,+1!510Q &01,/&+0 4!/! )0, )460 /! &+$ /&1&))6S
*1%!*1&&+0 4%!+ -/!0!+1! 4&1% .2+1&:1&,+S +
%!*&0104%!+/! &+$1!510&+1%!&//!,#!5-!/1&0!Q
+ 1%! #,)),4&+$ 1&3&16M 4! &+3&1! 6,2 1, /!;!1 ,+ 1%!
&8!/!+!0!14!!+%&01,/6M%!*&01/6M+ *1%Q/61,/!;!1
,+1%&0,+!-1&+?>>4,/ 0,/*,/!Q
,8W86G<BAB97<F6BHEF86B@@HA<GL
7<U8E8A68F
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>?M&C0ZBB
+1%!#,)),4&+$1&3&16M4!&+3&1!6,21,/!;!1,+6,2/,4+
*',/X0 &0,2/0!,**2+&16YQ%1 ,6,21%&+(/!1%!
N#).,)''.(#-#2).,'$),#).,
)''.(#-2
3)2!0&+6,2/*',/+ %,4 ,!01%18!1%,46,20%,2)
/! R/61,/!;!1,+1%&0,+!-1&+?>>4,/ 0,/*,/!Q
,8W86G<BABABHEBJA7<F6BHEF8
6B@@HA<G<8F
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>?M&C0ZBC
0'2',%',2&$'1"'.*',$1
#4!$/!!1%1 &8!/!+1 &0&-)&+!0M,/*',/0M/!-/1,#1%!&/
,4+ &0,2/0!,**2+&1&!0M1%!+M),+$4&1%/! &+$1!510&+
&8!/!+1 460M 4! )0, 4&)) 4/&1!&+ &8!/!+14600! ,+
0%/! 3)2!0Q%&00%#/,*4/&1&+$)00!01,4/&1&+$&+6,2/
*',/&02+0!11)&+$#,/*,01Q
#).,)''.(#-#2).,'$),#).,
)''.(#-2N
2(&)6M1%!/!/!*+61,,)06,2+20!1,:$2/!,21+!4
4/&1&+$0!+/&,0Q
,;8GBE<64?!8AE8A4?LF<F
+! 20!#2) 1,,) &0 /%!1,/&) $!+/! +)60&0M 4%&% 6,2 +
20!1,+)67!+6+!44/&1&+$0&121&,+6,2:+ 6,2/0!)#&+Q
%&0,2) *!+/!02*!6,2%3!1,4/&1!#,/+&+1!/+0%&-
--)&1&,+M,/)/!-,/16,2/-/,#!00,/00&$+0Q,,+ 21
+ +)60&0 )&(! 1%&0M 6,2 +!! 1, #,)),4 @ 01!-0Q &/01M :+
0*-)!,/*!+1,/1!510Q!,+ M20!1%!%!2/&01&4!-/,3& !
1, +)67! 1%! 1!510 X0&*&)/ 1, %+%+ !1 )QY !1`0 $,
1%/,2$% 1%&0 1,$!1%!/ 4&1% 1%&0 0&!+! /1&)! 01/1 #/,*
#!*)!\& !+1&:! &+1/6`0,))!$!0&!+1&010Q
2'*&
&0-%!+,)XY&0+!+ ,/&+!\ &0/2-1&+$%!*&)20!
&+1%!-/, 21&,+,#-)01&0M+ &0)&+(! 1, !3!),-*!+1)M
/!-/, 21&3!M + *!1,)& &0,/ !/0 &+)2 &+$ ,!0&16Q
+2#12/!/0 %3! !$2+ 20&+$ _\#/!!` )1!/+1&3!0
&+01! ,#&+*+6,+02*!/-/, 210Q,4!3!/M1%!0!
)1!/+1&3!0%3!% *2%)!001!01&+$+ ,3!/0&$%1M6!11%!6
/! )/! 6 !&+$ *00\-/, 2! + 20! /,00 &+ 201/&!0
#/,*-)01&01,#,, \,+11,1&+$0Q!/!M4!20! %2*+
#!*)! &-,0!\ !/&3! 01!* !))0 X%0YM 16-! ,# 2)1
*!0!+%6*) 01!* !))M 1, ,*-/! 1%! !8!10 ,# +
N#).,)''.(#-#2).,'$),#).,
)''.(#-2
)1!/+1&3!0 ,+ &-,$!+!0&0 ,/ #1 !)) !3!),-*!+1&+
3&1/,Q!#,20! ,+14,,**,+)620! /!-)!*!+10M
&0-%!+,)XY+ 1!1/*!1%6)&0-%!+,)XS
*,+,*!/ ,# 1%! +!4 3)2/! E> #,, \,+11 ,1&+$YQ
2*+ 0 4!/! &8!/!+1&1! &+1, &-,61!0 20&+$
%!*&))6 !:+! *! & &+ 1%! -/!0!+! ,# ,+1/,)
&8!/!+1&1&,+*! &4&1%+ 4&1%,21?E<\!01/ &,)X@S?>
=YM,/4&1%&+/!0&+$ ,0!0,#X>M>Q?+ ?=YM
X>M>Q?M?+ ?>+YM,/X>M>Q>?+ >Q?=YQ#1!/
&8!/!+1&1&,+M1%!!))04!/!01&+! + &*$! 1,3&02)&7!
+ .2+1=%!2*2)1&,+,#)&-& 32,)!0+ +2*!/
,# !3!),-&+$ #1 !))0Q /!1! !))0 4!/! )0, !5*&+! #,/
!))3&&)&16+ -,-1,0&0X-/,$/**! !)) !1%Y20&+$1%!
/!0-!1&3!!))2)/0060Q &*&)/ 1,@M 1>Q? = +
1>Q?+M0&$+&:+1)6&+/!0! &-,$!+!0&0+ )&-&
-/, 21&,+ 6 @>d ,*-/! 1, ,+1/,) &8!/!+1&1! !))0
X0! ,+1,1))&-& 32,)!+2*!/1,!))+2*!//1&,0YM
4%!/!0%&$%!/)!3!)0,#+ 0&$+&:+1)6 !/!0!
&-,$!+!0&0 X-c >Q>>CYQ )) 1!01! ,0!0 ,#
0&$+&:+1)6 /! 2! &-,$!+!0&0 + )&-& -/, 21&,+ 6
A>[B>dM)&(!)61)!01-/1&))61%/,2$%1,5&!8!10,+01!*
!))0M 0 3&)! !)) +2*!/0 !/!0! + -,-1,0&0 )!3!)0
&+/!0! 1%/,2$%,21 &8!/!+1&1&,+Q%!0!:+ &+$0&+ &1!
1%1),4M!+3&/,+*!+1))6\/!)!3+1 ,0!0,#MM+
%3! 0&$+&:+1 !8!10,+ #1 !)) !3!),-*!+1 +
)&-& 2*2)1&,+M4&1%%3&+$+,+\!01/,$!+&M+1&\
&-,$!+&!8!10Q%!0!+ ,1%!//!!+1/!02)10*6-/,3& !
#).,)''.(#-#2).,'$),#).,
)''.(#-2N
-,1!+1&) !))2)/ *!%+&0* !14!!+ !5-,02/! 1,
&0-%!+,)0 + %2*+ ,!0&16M + 2+ !/0,/! 1%! )&(!)6
&*-1,#1%!0!%!*&)0,+#1 !3!),-*!+1&+3&3,Q
+1%!#,)),4&+$1&3&16M4!&+3&1! 6,21,20!1%&00*-)!
01/10461,2+ !/01+ #2/1%!/1%!3)2!00%/! &+1%!
*',/Q/61,/!;!1,+1%&0,+!-1&+?>>4,/ 0,/*,/!Q
BA7H6G,;8GBE<64?!8AE8A4?LF<F
3'-%4&!3424/6!J;++/544&'3&!52'34'T!7
UV4//+53! $/272'4'-%'-6!-4'/-WN
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>?M&C0ZBD
N#).,)''.(#-#2).,'$),#).,
)''.(#-2
Works Cited
/&!-J3!+NJ!4+N[J-
+4!2 '0/%!-!3'3- $45,5+4'/-'-
&5,-,!3!-&9,+34!,!++3J7'4&
',0+'4'/-3$/2/!3'49N\
-4!2-4'/-+/52-+
/$/+!5+2'!-!3
@@N?>V@>@?WICADAN
!+:!2J-N[- !234- '-% '3/523!
/,,5-'4'!3N\
&!53!I'35- !234- '-%3
- &!'2!,! '!3
V@>@AWN
&-&-J9-4&'J',/4&9&-&-J-
9-4&''3'3&'N[-+93'3/$!80!242! !23
'-4&2!! '3'0+'-!3I'34/29J,4&!,4'3J-
&!,'3429N\
/52-+/$'4!29!3!2&
BANB
V@>??WIAGAZB@GN
7+!3J/&-N[!<!4'/-3/-4&!/-!04/$
'3/523!/,,5-'49N\
0N+2!65! 5
DGV@>?DWIEZ?GN
#).,)''.(#-#2).,'$),#).,
)''.(#-2N
JG;
/4$DD2$C$$
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H !-4'$94&!54&/2/$- !,'4!84-
'-6!34'%4!4&!'22! !-4'+3- 2!+4!
72'4'-%3
H !-4'$94&!)/52-+J/-$!2!-!J/2//*
05+'3&!24&405+'3&! - !,'4!84
H !-4'$94&!05+'4'/- 4!/$- !,'
N)(-1-) '#-1-
4!84- !6+54!7&!4&!24&4'32!!-4
!-/5%&$/29/520520/3!3
H 3!4&!2!$!2!-!34/3!!4&!3&/+23&'04&4
4&'354&/25'+44&!'27/2*50/-
H '- ,/2!2!!-43/52!34&4&6!5'+4/-
4&!7/2*/$- !,'4!84
#$3/ D6KC $D/4 64H$NH
,*! ,# 6,2/ ,))!$! 00&$+*!+10 4&)) /!.2&/! 6,2 1, 20!
] !*&^0,2/!0Q61%&0M6,2/-/,#!00,/0202))6*!+L
K -!!/\/!3&!4! /1&)!0#/,* !*&',2/+)0M)0,
(+,4+00%,)/)6',2/+)0
K --!/0#/,* !*&,+#!/!+!0
K ,,(0-2)&0%! 60%,)/)6-2)&0%!/0X,/%-1!/
#/,*02%,,(Y
)(-1-) '#-1-N
6478@<6BHE68-LC8F
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>CM&C0ZBE
21 '201 !20! 6,2`3! #,2+ 0,2/! )&(! 1%&0M &1 ,!0+`1
*!+&1`0$,&+$1,!1%!/&$%10,2/!#,/6,2Q+1%!-/!3&,20
%-1!/M6,2-/1&! !&-%!/&+$1%!)(.(.,#+ !*&
/1&)!1,:$2/!,214%1&1060+ 4%1&1 *!+0Q& , !+
(,*;/E$$(*,!(1!&,,&,!'&,'$-+'-,,
'1'-*%!*,!$:
K 4%1(&+ ,#-, '*4/,1!&1M
K 4%1(&+ ,#(-$!,!'&&1--!/! &+M
K %,4*&,&1&0M
K + 4%1/!0!/%!&5-&&1+ 40&+;2!+! 3
N)(-1-) '#-1-
&1Q
%&04&))%!)-6,22+ !/01+ 1%!21%,/`0X,/21%,/0`Y+$)!
,+1%!1,-&M04!))01%!/1&)!`0-2/-,0!M&102 &!+!M+
%,4&1:10&+1,1%!/, !/,+3!/01&,+,+6,2/1,-&Q
6 +.*$
!1`0&*$&+!1%16,2`/!&+1!/!01! &+%,46,2+$-!,-)!:+
+ 0%/! -,)&1&) &+#,/*1&,+Q ,2`3! #,2+ 1%! !*&
/1&)! 1&1)! ]/1&&+$ +#,/*1&,+ !+0&&)&16L ,4 !+
+$$!0 4&1% +)&+! +#,/*1&,+ V+!4 1WQ^ ,2`3!
0(&**! 1%!/1&)!M+ 6,21%&+(&1*(!00,*!&+1!/!01&+$
-,&+10/!)!3+11,6,2/& !0M0,*! ,#4%&%6,2$/!!4&1%
#/,*6,2/-!/0,+)!5-!/&!+!M+ ,1%!/06,2*64+11,
/&0!.2!01&,+0,21Q214%!/! & 1%&0/1&)!,*!#/,*R
*4EGFB94A46478@<64EG<6?8
!2!^37&49/5-4!++$2/,4&!'-$/2,4'/-
02/6' ! /544&!24'+!J+/-%7'4&3/,!15'*
'-4!2-!43!2&'-%N
)(-1-) '#-1-N
((").%)9&!$/++/7'-%C4'6'49
/-4'-36'35+!+!,!-434&4,9-/4!!33'+!
4/++53!23N32!!-2! !2Y$2'!- +9+4!2-4'6!
$/++/73!+/7J53'-%4&! 2/0Z /7-22/7N
!+!44&!G&/430/434/;- /54,/2!/54!&
2!/$4&!24'+!N
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>CM&C0ZBF
')(%$#')"@(("A
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>CM&C0ZBG
,M #/,* .2&( 0+ ,# 1%! /1&)! !1&)0M 6,2 (+,4 1%1
N)(-1-) '#-1-
1%&0 /1&)! &0 ,*&+$ #/,* 1%! -!/0-!1&3! ,# /!0!/%!/0 1
,,$)!M 4%, -/!0!+1! 1%&0 &+#,/*1&,+ 1, ,1%!/ #,)(0 4%,
012 6 %2*+\,*-21!/ &+1!/1&,+Q %&0 0!!*0 %&$%)6
/!)!3+11,6,2//!,#&+1!/!01Q,2,+0& !//,40&+$/,2+
1%!,1%!/--!/0#/,*1%&0,+#!/!+!1,0!!4%1!)0!0&!+1&010
)&(!1%!0!/!06&+$,216,2+$-!,-)!`020!,#&+#,/*1&,+
1%!0! 60Q
#78AG<9L<A:@8G474G445BHG4A
46478@<6G8KG
/79/5429'4N*!+//*44&'3/4&!224'+!/-
4&!4/0'/$&/7-!73'33&2! /-3/'+,! '
T-!74U- 3!!7&49/5-;%52!/54/54'4
'-15'*%+-!N
((").%)9&!$/++/7'-%C4'6'49
/-4'-36'35+!+!,!-434&4,9-/4!!33'+!
4/++53!23N32!!-2! !2Y$2'!- +9+4!2-4'6!
$/++/73!+/7J53'-%4&! 2/0Z /7-22/7N
2%4&!%29+!+34/4&!0243/$4&!24'+!4&!9
!32'!N
)(-1-) '#-1-N
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>CM&C0ZC>
$).$#))%*)$#)-)
@(("A
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>CM&C0ZC?
N)(-1-) '#-1-
64H$NHK22K$D
$BHEA4?G<G?8
/!3&,20)6M6,2/! + 4/,1!,21%,41%!1&1)!,#+/1&)!
+/!3!)4%11%!/1&)!&0$,&+$1, ,Q
21&#&1`0',2/+)/1&)!M&1)0,%!)-01,-611!+1&,+1,
1%! ,!,$ ' , !, /+ (-$!+ !&Q 0%,)/)6
',2/+)&0)&(!*$7&+!L&1%00-!&:#,20+ 2 &!+!M&1
202))6-2)&0%!0&002!0-!/&, &))61%/,2$%,211%!6!/M+
!% &002! ,+1&+0 &8!/!+1 /1&)!0 6 &8!/!+1 /!0!/%!/0
1%1:12+ !/1%!',2/+)`00,-!Q%&00,-!,2) !0/,
0-#(,/0+//,40&#(#&&#*#)&)!3Q%!! &1,/011%1
',2/+) /! ,+)6 $,&+$ 1, 0!)!1 /1&)!0 1%1 )&$+ 4&1% 1%1
#,20M0,1%!1&1)!,#1%!',2/+)6,2//1&)!40-2)&0%! &+
+1!))6,2),1,211%!)!+06,2//1&)!&0$,&+$1,1(!Q
)(-1-) '#-1-N
'%N@FN?N944!-4'/-4/4&!
'$$!2!-4*'- 3/$)/52-+34&4
05+'3&'-$/2,4'/-/-9/52
4/0'N
,/ !5*-)!M 1%!0! /!
#!4,#1%!0%,)/)6',2/+)0
1%1 %3! -2)&0%! /1&)!0
,21 %,4 !+ $!10
-,)&1&)&+#,/*1&,+L
K )/,(&) ( ),'.#)(
"()&)!3U)&#.#-
K )/,(&)
)''/(#.#)(D
(!/!(/&./,
K )&#.#-U)
K )/,(&) /-.#(&)/,#-'
K (,!,/.)/,(&) 1()&#.#-
K /",,#%C/,(&%1"()-#&
!!%,4/1&)!0,+,+!0-!&:1,-&,2) !-2)&0%! &+
3/&!16 ,# &8!/!+1 ',2/+)0R , 6,2 + 0( 6,2/0!)#L/!
6,2 *,/! &+1!/!01! &+ /!0!/% 6 &+#,/*1&,+ 0%,)/0R
,**2+&1&,+ 0%,)/0R ,)&1&) 0&!+1&010R ,2/&0*
0%,)/0R ,))!$! 012 !+10R !0!/%!/0 ,210& ! 1%! +&1!
11!0R06,2`/!/,40&+$1%/,2$%0!,#/1&)!0,+6,2/
1,-&M1/6),,(&+$#,//1&)!0-2)&0%! &+',2/+)1%11!/0
1,6,2/#,20Q
,1!L %&)! 0%,)/)6 /1&)!0 /! ,#1!+ -2)&0%! &+
',2/+)0M ,1%!/ 16-!0 ,# -2)&1&,+0 &+)2 ! *$7&+!0M
+!40--!/0M 1/ ! *$7&+!0M + +!40)!11!/0Q %!0! /! ))
N)(-1-) '#-1-
*,#)#&-M 4%&% /! -2)&1&,+0 1%1 -21 ,21 +!4 &002!0
-!/&, &))6L !3!/6 4!!(M *,+1%M .2/1!/M ,/ 6!/Q %!1%!/
1%!0! ,1%!/ -!/&, &)0 /! --/,-/&1! 0,2/!0 #,/ 6,2/
00&$+*!+1 !-!+ 0,+4%1(&+ 0,#&+#,/*1&,+6,2+!!
+ 1%!/!.2&/!*!+10,#6,2/4/&1&+$-/,'!1Q
#78AG<9LG;8=BHEA4?9EB@46<G4G<BA
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>CM&C0ZC@
HG;BE6E878AG<4?F4A74X?<4G<BAF
,4 )!1`0 -/1&! -6&+$ 11!+1&,+ 1, &+#,/*1&,+ ,21
0,2/!`0 -, '*?+@ 1, %!)- 6,2 2+ !/01+ 4%1 1%!&/
)(-1-) '#-1-N
*&,!$+06,216,2/0,2/!+ 4%!1%!/&1`0, +,
+'-*'*1'-*(-*('++Q
&1% 0%,)/)6 ',2/+) /1&)!M 1%! 21%,/ &0 )&(!)6 1, !
-/,#!00,/ ,/ $/ 21! 012 !+1 /!0!/%!/ 1 ,))!$! ,/
2+&3!/0&16M,/-/,#!00&,+)/!0!/%!/1/!0!/%&+01&121!Q
,+0& !/1%&0!5*-)!L
#!F:@F:F-")&,&3,.#&*/&#-"#(."*,)#(!-
,)'('#)( ,(FJ'!-,#*.#)(K
%1/!0,*!1%&+$04!*&$%1+,1&!,211%!21%,/0,#
1%&0/1&)!R
K ))1%/!!/!0!/%!/0/!1&))+&3!/0&16M*',/
+ &+2+&3!/0&16Q
K +!,#1%!21%,/0%0%&+-,)&1&)0&!+!+
4,/(0#,/2+&11%1012 &!0*! &M+ 1%!,1%!/14,
/!&+,*-21!/0&!+!Q%&0*(!00!+0!#,/012 6
N)(-1-) '#-1-
1%1&0),,(&+$1%,4-,)&1&)+!40&0,3!/! ,+
&(,(X/!.2&/!0-,)&1&)0&!+!T*! &!5-!/1&0!Y
1%/,2$%1%!20!,#1,-&*, !)&+$1,+)67!)/$!
10!1,#&(,(3& !,0X/!.2&/!0,*-21!/0&!+!
!5-!/1&0!YQ
0 0%,)/)6 /1&)!M 1%! 2 &!+! #,/ 1%&0 /1&)! &0 ,1%!/
!5-!/1/!0!/%!/04%,#,20,+0&*&)/1,-&0M)&(!)6-,)&1&0
+ 0,&)*! &Q
%!+ %,,0&+$6,2/0,2/!0M6,2`))4+11, ,+0& !/1%!
!5-!/1&0! ,# 6,2/ 21%,/0Q -, / , '-&,+ + 0(*,!+>
!-!+ &+$ ,+ 1%! 16-! ,# 4/&1&+$ 6,2`/! ,&+$ X+ 1%!
/!.2&/!*!+10 0!1 6 6,2/ -/,#!00,/YM &+ &1&,+ 1, &1&+$
!*&012 &!0M6,2*&$%14+11,,+0& !/1%!4/&1&+$0,#
21%,/04&1% &8!/!+1(&+ 0,#/&%!5-!/&!+!,+6,2/1,-&M
&+)2 &+$)&3! !5-!/&!+!Q%1 ,3)/(!*)*&1")!.."#,
(1- ,)'-)#&'#1%&+(,#1%!,3!/$!1%!60!!R%1
,(1-#(7/(,-06,21%,41%!)$,/&1%*08!11%!&/
/!% ,/ ,3!/$!R %1 , $)/,(&#-.- 4%, 4/&1! #,/
1/ &1&,+),21)!100!!01%! &8!/!+!!14!!+4%11%!6 ,
+ %,4+!40&0/!-,/1! ,+&(,(R,2*&$%1+,1!)!
1,:+ 1%!0!-!/0-!1&3!0&+1%!0%,)/)6)&1!/12/!M0,6,2`))
%3!1,),,(!)0!4%!/!Q
)(-1-) '#-1-N
#78AG<9LG;84HG;BEF
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>CM&C0ZCA
4G8B9CH5?<64G<BA
An interactive H5P element has
been excluded from this version
of the text. You can view it online
here:
https://smc.pressbooks.pub/
writingourbodies/?p=105#h5p-54
#!F:@F;F,P)&Q-)/,-/- /&#(-)'--GJ'!
-,#*.#)(K
N)(-1-) '#-1-
+ !/01+ &+$ / & 0,2/! 40 -2)&0%! &0 /&1&) 1,
2+ !/01+ &+$&10,+1!51Q211%!/!`0+,/2)!#,/4%1*(!0
0,2/!1,,,) L&1 !-!+ 0")16,2`/!$,&+$1,20!1%!0,2/!Q
,+0& !/L
K ,2) -%&),0,-%&)1!51#/,*@>>>6!/0$,01&))0%!
)&$%1,+1, 6`0!1%&) &)!**0R
K ,2) +!40--!//1&)!#/,*1%!!/)6@>1%!+12/6
-/,3& !,+1!*-,//6,2+1,#4%1&140)&(!1,
)&3!2+ !/&*/,4)40R
K ,2) +/1&)!,+1%!1!%+&))&*&11&,+0,#/1&:&)
&+1!))&$!+!#/,*A6!/0$,)/! 6!,21,# 1!R
%1`0 &*-,/1+1 &0 1, *(! 02/! 6,2 (+,4 %,4 ,) 6,2/
0,2/!&0+ ,+1!512)&7!&1--/,-/&1!)6#,/6,2//! !/0Q
#78AG<9LG;874G8
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
)(-1-) '#-1-N
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>CM&C0ZCC
-;8FBHE68F<G6<G8F
,2+)0,$!10!+0!,#0%,)/)6/1&)!`0,+1!510! ,+
/ ,+'-*+!,!,+Q
02))6M1%!&+1/, 21&,+1,0%,)/)6/1&)!4&))-/,3& !
$!,*,-**.!/1%11!))06,24%1012 &!0&1&02&) &+$
2-,+M 0 4!)) 0 4%1 $- &+ 1%! )&1!/12/! &1 &*0 1, :))Q
! &+$ 1%1 +//1&3! + 1%!+ :+ &+$ 1%! ,//!0-,+ &+$
0,2/!0 &+ 1%! /!#!/!+!0 ,/ 4,/(0 &1! 0!1&,+ + &+#,/*
6,2 ,21 4%!/! 1%&0 -/1&2)/ --!/ :10 &+1, 1%! /, !/
)&1!/12/!,+1%&01,-&Q
,2+)0,%,-1,1%!**&+'*/'*#+!,0!1&,+
1 1%! !+ ,# 1%! --!/ 1, $!1 .2&( $)+! 1 1%! (&+ 0
,#0,2/!0&1&1!0Q#6,20!!&1! 0,2/!1%1),,(020!#2)
#,/6,2/,4+1,-&M6,2,2) )4600!/%#,/&14&1%6,2/
)&//6`00!/%!+$&+!,/,,$)!%,)/Q
N)(-1-) '#-1-
-;8FBHE68FG;4G6<G8it
%1,2,2) ),,(&+1,1%! /./,,#+/1&)!M1,0!!1%!
012 &!01%1*!,21*,/!/!!+1)6+ 2&)1,+&10/!0!/%R
,*!1&*!0M6,2+O
,*!)&//6 10!0+ 0!/%!+$&+!0)),46,21,:+
0,2/!01%1%3!&1! -/1&2)//1&)!Q%&0)),406,21,
0!!*,/!/!!+1012 &!01%+1%!,+!6,2&+&1&))6#,2+ Q1)0,
)),406,21,0!!&#*,/!/!!+1/!0!/%02--,/10M,+1/ &10M
,/ ,1%!/4&0! ,*-)!*!+10 1%! :+ &+$0 &+ 1%! /1&)! 6,2
,/&$&+))6#,2+ Q+ &1&,+M&1+0,*!1&*!0%!)-6,2$!1
0!+0! ,# %,4 &*-,/1+1 6,2/ /1&)! &0 &+ 1%! 0%,)/)6
,+3!/01&,+ ,+ 6,2/ 1,-&Q ,/ !5*-)!M &# 6,2 %3! 14,
/1&)!0M,1%-2)&0%! ?>6!/0$,M+ ,+!40,+)6&1!
?>1&*!0M4%&)!1%!,1%!/40&1! ?>>>1&*!0M1%!)11!//1&)!
*&$%1 ! *,/! &*-,/1+1 #,/ 6,2 1, ,+0& !/ &+ 6,2/ ,4+
/!0!/%Q
,,(&+$ &+1, 1%! &11&,+0 + /1&)! &1!0 0 4!)) 0 1%!
&11&,+01%1&1!&1&0))! #..#)("#(#(!Q
,$!1101!,#1%&0M1/60!/%,+6,2/1,-&&+,,$)!
%,)/V+!41WQ,,(#,/]&1! 6V+2*!/W^2+ !/,+!,#
1%!/1&)!0M+ )&(,+&11,0!!4%10,2/!0&1&1!0Q
)(-1-) '#-1-N
'-429^3/++!%!/$+'$/2-'!3/52!3
345 !-43J'229!2&T-!74U-
+3/+!49/5+//*50-24'+!- 3!!4&!3/52!3'4
'4! - 4&!3/52!34&4'4!'4N
?N 293!2&/-9/524/0''-'229
!2&T-!74U
@N !!'$9/5;- -93/52!37'4&2!
2-&'-%22/73J+'*!4&'3I
AN !+!44&!2! 2-&'-%22/734&40/'-4
5072 4/3!!3/52!34&4&6!'4! 4&4
24'+!N!+!44&!3!4/$2-&'-%22/734&4
0/'-4 /7-72 4/3!!3/52!34&42!'4!
N)(-1-) '#-1-
/4HCOBD
622$,$6&
2/&6C4/
$D6KC $D
'-4&424'+!N
BN
'%N@FNBN'229!2&24'+!2!/2 4&4
3&/732-&'-%22/734&4+!49/56'!7
3/52!34&4&6!!!-'4! '-4&'324'+!3
7!++324'+!34&4'4!4&'324'+!NT,%!
!32'04'/-U
&11&,+%&+&+$&0-/!116 3+! /!0!/%-/1&!M0,6,2
*64+11,1)(1,)&//&+#,/$2& +!06,21/6&1,21Q
C88/4,K8
%! +!51 1&*! 6,2 :+
',2/+)/1&)!6,2*&$%14+11,
20!00,2/!M*(!02/!1,),,(
#,/)2!0!6,+ 1%!/1&)!&10!)#Q
%! "'-*&$ !, /+ (-$!+
!&M1%!-, '*E+ *&,!$+M1%!
, ' (-$!,!'&M 4%1
)(-1-) '#-1-N
345 !-43J
3*-
+'22'-'$9/5
7-4$524&!2
6'!/-
!6+54'-%9/52
3/52!3/2
'44'/-
&'-'-%N
+'-*+ !, !,+M + / ,
+'-*+ !, !,/!)) &*-,/1+1
,+1!512) )2!0 #,/
2+ !/01+ &+$ 6,2/ /1&)!`0 )!+0
+ &*-1Q
3,$$D C/8H/64D
&$Q@FQ@*$!!0/&-1&,+Q%!&*$!&0 &$&1) ,2*!+1
#!12/&+$ ,+#!/!+! --!/ 1&1)! + 01/1Q 1 1%! 1,-M
1%!1&1)!]@>@B^&0 &0-)6! &+)/$!M016)&7! ,/+$!
#,+1M ),1! +!51 1, #,/*) %! &+$ !1&)&+$ 1%! D1%
+1!/+1&,+) ,+#!/!+! ,+ 3+! !0!/% !1%, 0
+ +)61&0 1 1%! +&3!/0&11 ,)&1"+& ! )"+&M &+
@>@BQ !+!1%M 1%! )&+( &0 -/,3& ! Q %! ,2*!+1`0
*&+1&1)!011!0M]&(,(30Q1%!,2/1%011!L+$$!*!+1
&1%!40,+&(,(M^#,)),4! 61%!21%,/+*!0/
N)(-1-) '#-1-
/(!/HM!+'*&+1!!)IM!/!(21%0IM4&1%1%!&/9)&1&,+0
&+ &1! 6 02-!/0/&-1 +2*!/0M )&+(&+$ 1, &))
+&3!/0&16 9)&1&,+0Q !),4 1%&0M &11&,+ &+01/21&,+0 /!
$&3!+M#,/*11! &+16-&) !*&016)!Q%!01/11!51
#,)),40L &1 !5-)&+0 &(,(`0 *!1%, ,# -/!0!+1&+$ ,+1!+1
)&$+! 4&1% 20!/0` &+1!/!010 0! ,+ -/!3&,20 &+1!/1&,+0M
01/!00&+$ 1%1 -,)&1&) +!14,/(0 ,#1!+ *+&#!01 0 1/!+ &+$
1,-&0 /1%!/ 1%+ 1%/,2$% -/,*&+!+1 :$2/!0Q /+0/&!
01/11!51L+ &1&,+1,,+1!+1#/,*,2+101%!20!/
#,)),40M &(,( #/!.2!+1)6 !*-%0&7!0 ,+1!+1 4&1% 0&*&)/
02'!1*11!/1,3& !,01%!20!/%0-/!3&,20)6)&(! Q0),+$
020!/%0&+ &1! +&+1!/!01&+1%!1,-&X*,01)&(!)66
!+$$&+$4&1%/!)1! 3& !,YM1%!6*60!!&(,(,21
&1 !0-&1!+,1#,)),4&+$+6,+!4%,%0!3!/&+1!/1! 4&1%
&1Q,+0!.2!+1)6M-,)&1&)+!14,/(0+ ,**2+&1&!0 ,+,1
)460 !*!/$! /,2+ -/,*&+!+1 :$2/!0 )&(! -,)&1&&+0 ,/
-/,#!00&,+),+1!+1/!1,/0M21/1%!/*+&#!010!-%!*!/)
1/!+ &+$ 1,-&0Q 2/ *!1%, ,),$&) --/,% 1, 012 6&+$
!+$$!*!+1V!12/+1,&$Q@FQ@W
&$Q @FQA *$! !0/&-1&,+Q %&0 ,))$! &0 * ! 2- ,#
1%/!! &*$!0Q %! :/01 &*$!M ),1! 1 1%! 1,-M )!#1M &0
!1&)! + &+1/&1!!+$/3&+$ !-&1&+$0!+!&+0-&/! 6
)1,`0 ))!$,/6 ,# 1%! 3!Q + 1%! )!#1M $/,2- ,# *!+M
/!00! &+/,!0M01+ 11%!!+1/+!,#3!Q%!6--!/
1,!$!012/&+$1,4/ !%,1%!/M!+$$&+$&+ &0200&,+Q%!
3!/+&0 /(4&1%+/%46M1%/,2$%4%&%)&$%1&03&0&)!M
01&+$ 0% ,40 ,+ 1%! 3! 4))0Q + 1%! !+1/) + /&$%1
)(-1-) '#-1-N
-,/1&,+ ,# 1%! &*$!M +2*!/,20 :$2/!0 /! 0!1! ),0!)6
1,$!1%!/M#&+$%&$%4))Q%!:$2/!0,+1%!4))/!1&+$
,210!+!4&1%0% ,40+ $!012/!0M02$$!01&+$1%!1%!*!
,# &))20&,+ 3!/020 /!)&16Q ,3! 1%! /,4 M 1%!/! &0 /&0!
-)1#,/* 4%!/! 0*))!/ :$2/!0 + ! 0!!+ *+&-2)1&+$
0%-!0 &+ #/,+1 ,# )&$%1 0,2/! 1, /!1! 0% ,4 -2--!10
,+1%! 3! 4))Q %!&*$! &0/&% &+ 1!512/!M4&1% !1&)!
0% &+$+ /,00%1%&+$1!%+&.2!0Q),+$1%!,11,*,#
1%&0 &*$! &0 #&+1M 1&+ 1!51Q %! 0!,+ &*$!M ),1! 1
1%!1,-M/&$%1M&0)(+ 4%&1!+!40--!/-$!Q+1%!
)!#1M1%!/!&0+&))201/1&,+,#4,*+%,) &+$ ,2*!+1
4&1% 1%! 4,/ 0 ]3! ,2 ! %! --!)R^ ,3! %!/Q
!),4M1!51&+ &1!01%!-2)&1&,+ !1&)0,#]%!--!)L
1&,+) #/,\*!/&+ !40--!/M^ &+)2 &+$ ! &1,/0M
-2)&0%!/0M+ *2)1&-)!,9!),1&,+0&+%&$,M1Q2)M
+ &++!-,)&0Q + 1%! /&$%1M 1%!/! &0 -%,1,$/-% ,#
*+&+ #,/*)02&14&1%0-!1)!0Q!),41%! -%,1,$/-%
&01%!-1&,+M],+Q!,/$!Q,/1!)6,2^+ ]%&/*+
!-2)&+ 1&,+) ,**&11!!Q^ %! 02//,2+ &+$ 1!51
,+0&010,#0!3!/),)2*+0,#0*))M !+0!-/&+1Q^V!12/+1,
&$Q@FQAW
&$Q @FQB *$! !0/&-1&,+Q %! &*$! 0%,40 )&//6
&$&1)1),$!+1/6#,/+ !*&/1&)!1&1)! ]%!$/!1
!.2)&7!/R 11!/+0 ,# 0,&) *! & 20! + 6,21% -,)&1&)
!+$$!*!+1 &+ 1%/!! 3+! !*,/&!0Q^ %! /1&)! &0
21%,/! 6&%!)!+,0M/& +!/,*!+M+ /&+Q
, !/M+ -2)&0%! &+ ]+#,/*1&,+M ,**2+&1&,+ g
N)(-1-) '#-1-
,&!16^ &+ @>?BQ %! 1),$ &+1!/#! &0-)60 3/&,20
&+1!/1&3! &,+0 + ,-1&,+0M &+)2 &+$ 211,+0 1, ]!1
M^]! +)&+!M^+ )&+()!)! ]3&))!+)&+!Q^
-!!/\/!3&!4! )!) &0 )0, -/!0!+1Q + //,4 -,&+10 1,
$/6! \,21 /!M 4%&% &0 *$+&:! 1, %&$%)&$%1 1,,)1&-
06&+$M]&+ 0,2/!0&1&+$1%&0Q^V!12/+1,&$Q@FQBW
Attributions
&!00!+
V'-45+J'--NQWN?@/6N?G>BN
&2/-'+'-%,!2'I'34/2',!2'-
!7300!23
N'229/$/-%2!33J
&4403IRR&2/-'+'-%,!2'N+/N%/6R+-R
3-FA>?DF?>R?G>BZ??Z?@R! Z?R3!1ZBRN
2*!2J2J!4+N['*/*63N4&!/524&
344!I-%%!,!-47'4&!73/-'*/*N\
/-$!2!-!/- 6-! !3!2&!4&/ 3
- -+94'3J@DZ@F5-!@>@BJ+!-'J
0'-N
!-2! ,J-N
-425,+4/-'5,
N?D>BN
2'4'3&53!5,J
&4403IRR777N2'4'3&,53!5,N/2%R/++!4'/-R
/)!4RS?FC@Z?@??Z?@>N
+6%-/J'&!+!J!4+N[-24';'+
)(-1-) '#-1-N
-4!++'%!-!!+0$/2'!-4';2'4'-%O\
2'4'+2!
J6/+N@EJ-/N?J@>@AJ
&4403IRR /'N/2%R?>N??FDR
3?A>CBZ>@AZ>BAF>Z@N
$#/HHC/KH/64D
K ,,$)!%,)/&11&,+%&+&+$h&+!!&0)&!+0!
2+ !/X11/&21&,+Y)&!+0!
K &11&,+%&+&+$ -1! 6&+!!&0)&!+0! 2+ !/
>X/!1&3!,**,+0!/,Y)&!+0!
N)(-1-) '#-1-
JF;
"
9:
$,-4M$$4$O
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&!&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
' !-4'$9 !,'72'4'-%[,/6!3N\
'6C#4 $D6& #$3/ C/H/4,
0 4/&1!/ 4%, 2+ !/01+ 0 *',/0 + &0&-)&+!0 0
,,"#(-,).-#)(),,-#(!,,"*
,N
&0,2/0! ,**2+&1&!0M 6,2 )0, *6 ,+!-12)&7! 4/&1&+$
0 /!0& &+$ &+ 1%!0! ,**2+&1&!0M +,1 &0!*, &! M 21
,++!1! 1,0!3!/), &!0M+ &+ /!)1&,+1,,1%!/0Q,M0
4/&1!/0M&1+!%!)-#2)1,& !+1%,41%!6,-!/1!4&1%&+
1%! ,**2+&16 + )0, %,4 6,2+ -20% 2- $&+01 +
*(!1%!*6,2/,4+Q
,%+ 4)!0M )&+$2&01&0 -/,#!00,/M 012 &! !*&
4/&1&+$ 1, 0!! %,4 &1 ,-!/1! Z4%1 & &1 ,M %,4 & &1
, &1M + %,4 & -!,-)! 20! 1%! 1!510Q ! /!1! )/$!
,/-20 X ,))!1&,+Y ,# 1!510 1, 012 6 1%! -11!/+0 %! 04Q
/,* 1%1 4,/(M %! $3! 20 !11!/ 2+ !/01+ &+$ ,# %,4
!*&4/&1&+$ ,-!/1!0 &+ ,**2+&16Q %!+ 4!(+,4
%,4&1,-!/1!0M04/&1!/0M4!+%/+!001%12+ !/01+ &+$
#,/ *+6 !+!:10M )&(! $!11&+$ ,2/ & !0 &+1, 1%! &0,2/0!
,**2+&161,4%&%4!!),+$Q+ !(!!-&+*&+ 1%,0!
)&*&11&,+0M 4! + ,+1&+2! 1, %))!+$! 1%! +,/*0M 0&+!
$!+/!0M,/16-!0,#1!510M/!+,1011&M21)460!3,)3&+$4&1%
20!20!,#1%,0!4%,-20%2-$&+011%!*Q
&$$1$ 0"&,20-#3"2'-,
!1`0),,(11%!]/!0!/%&+1/, 21&,+^1,0!!%,4&1,-!/1!0M
,/ &+$ 1, 4)!0Q ! & !+1&:! A -/10 ,# /!0!/%
&+1/, 21&,+Q!/!4!!5!/-1%!3&)6#/,*%&04,/(L
N,,"#(-,).-#)(),,-#(!,,"
*,
-4$12 !*'1&',% $00'2-072&$
1'23 2'-,
%&0 &0 $!+!/))6 ,*-)&0%! &+ 14, 460L ?Q 6
!*,+01/1&+$ 1%1 $!+!/) /! ,# /!0!/% &0 &*-,/1+1M
/&1&)M&+1!/!01&+$M-/,)!*1&M/!)!3+1M,/,1%!/4&0!4,/1%6
,# &+3!01&$1&,+ + @Q 6 &+1/, 2&+$ + /!3&!4&+$ (!6
0,2/!0,#-/&,//!0!/%&+1%1/!1,0%,44%!/!$-0!5&01
,/4%!/!-/&,//!0!/%%0!!+&+ !.21!&+ /!00&+$1%!
/!0!/%-/,)!*Q
%!01!-01(!+1,%&!3!1%&04,2) !L
K 1!-?[$!%!&!%('*,&'V4/&1&+$1&,+b
!0/&&+$1%!/!0!/%-/,)!*+ -/,3& &+$!3& !+!
1,02--,/14%61%!1,-&&0&*-,/1+11,012 6W
K 1!-@[#!&,'(!&*$!2,!'&+V4/&1&+$
1&,+b-/,3& &+$011!*!+10,211%!2//!+1011!,#
(+,4)! $!M,+0!+020M-/1&!M,/ !0/&-1&,+,#
-%!+,*!+W
K 1!-A[.!/!&!,%+'(*.!'-+*+*
V4/&1&+$1&,+b06+1%!0&7!-/&,//!0!/%1%1#2/1%!/
02--,/101%!+!! 1,012 61%!/!0!/%-/,)!*S1%&0&0
+,1)&1!/12/!/!3&!421*,/!/!;!1&,+,#(!6
012 &!01%1%3!1,2%! 2-,+1%!1,-&W
)0 -.&$-#$("$# .# *,)& '
%&01&,+/!#!/01,*(&+$)!/+ ,$!+1/$2*!+11%1
,,"#(-,).-#)(),,-#(!,,"*
,N
6,2/ -/1&2)/ -&!! ,# /!0!/% &0 &*-,/1+1 + -,00!00!0
3)2!Q%&0+! ,+!6&+ &1&+$0-!&:$-&+-/!3&,20
/!0!/%M 6 %))!+$&+$ /, )6 !-1! 002*-1&,+M 6
/&0&+$ .2!01&,+M %6-,1%!0&0M ,/ +!! M ,/ 6 !51!+ &+$
-/!3&,20(+,4)! $!&+0,*!46Q
%,,0!,+!,#1%!#,)),4&+$--/,%!0L
K '-&,*B$!%!&V4/&1&+$1&,+b&+1/, 2!+
,--,0&+$3&!4-,&+1,/-!/0-!1&3!&+-/&,//!0!/%1%1
6,2!)&!3!%04!(!+! ,/2+ !/*&+! 1%!-/!3&)&+$
/$2*!+1W
e !+ !+ !7X@>@>Y%00%,4+1%1&0
-/,)!**,+$%&$%0%,,)+ -/,#!00&,+)
1%)!1!0M*(&+$&1)!/1%12+ !/01+ &+$%,4
&3&0&,+?1%)!1!04,/(1,*&1&$1!,+!/+0
&0/2&)1,012 6Q
K &!,!&(V4/&1&+$1&,+b !3!),-1%!/!0!/%
-/,)!*/,2+ $-,/2+ !/012 &! /!,#1%!
)&1!/12/!W
e %&)!012 &!0%3!0%,4+1%1&0-/,)!*
*,+$-/,#!00&,+)1%)!1!0M+,1!+,2$%/!0!/%
%0!!+ ,+!1,2+ !/01+ %,4&3&0&,+?
1%)!1!04,/(1,*&1&$1!,+!/+0Q
K -+,!'&B*!+!&V4/&1&+$1&,+b0&*&)/1,$-
& !+1&:1&,+M1%&0&+3,)3!0-/!0!+1&+$(!6.2!01&,+0
N,,"#(-,).-#)(),,-#(!,,"
*,
,211%!,+0!.2!+!0,#$-0&+-/&,//!0!/%1%1
4&))! /!00! 66,2/012 6W
e &+!012 &!0%3!0%,4+1%1&0-/,)!*
*,+$-/,#!00&,+)1%)!1!0M4!*2010(%,4 ,
,+!/+0*+&#!01&+&3&0&,+?1%)!1!0R
K '&,!&-!&,*!,!'&V4/&1&+$1&,+b!51!+ -/&,/
/!0!/%1,!5-+ 2-,+,/)//!0!/%-/,)!*Q
%&0&0,#1!+0&$+)! 4&1%),$&),++!1&+$
1!/*&+,),$6M02%0M]%!+!M^]1%!/!#,/!M^
],+0!.2!+1)6M^]1%20M^,/)+$2$!1%1&+ &1!0
+!! Q,/!5*-)!M,+!,2) 011!M],+0!.2!+1)6M1%!0!
#1,/0+!! 1,!!5*&+! &+*,/! !1&)NQ^3& !+!
02$$!010+&+1!/!01&+$,//!)1&,+S1%!/!#,/!M&1&0
!0&/)!1,02/3!6 &8!/!+1/!0-,+ !+10NQ^W
e &+!%0!!+012 &! 0,!51!+0&3!)6+
0%,4+1,!0, &001/,20#,/1%)!1!01)))!3!)0M
1%!*&1&$1&,+,#*,+$&3&0&,+1%)!1!0&0
3&1)/!0!/%Q
)0 /*3$(".# $# .#
-)&/.$)(
%! :+) ]*,3!^ &0 1, ++,2+! 1%! *!+0 6 4%&% 6,2/
012 64&)),+1/&21!+!4(+,4)! $!,/+!42+ !/01+ &+$&+
,+1/011,-/&,//!0!/%,+1%!1,-&Q%&0&0)0,4%!/!6,2
!0/&!1%!/!*&+&+$,/$+&71&,+)01/212/!,#1%!--!/Q
%!01!-01(!+1,%&!3!1%&04,2) !L
,,"#(-,).-#)(),,-#(!,,"*
,N
K &&'-&!&(*+&,*+* V4/&1&+$1&,+b
!0/&!1%!-2/-,0!,#6,2/012 6&+1!/*0,#4%11%!
/!0!/%&0$,&+$1, ,,/,*-)&0%QW%&0/!0!/%
4&))N
, '+ , !+ $''# $!# !& ,!'&> ,E+ $''# , ,
*-%&,1!%!1 '#*!,'-&*+,& '/!,/'-$
/'*#=
N,,"#(-,).-#)(),,-#(!,,"
*,
"%'!'
*-%&, &&',,!'&
,,"#(-,).-#)(),,-#(!,,"*
,N
+!-1!*!/@>M@>?CM&,)
3&0!*!1%!:/01
#/&+\*!/&+4,*+1,
4&+!011/!00&+ /*1
1%!**64/ 0Q10!!*0
&+/! &)!1%1&11,,(DD6!/0
#,/)(4,*+1,4&+1%&0
4/ M+ 6!1&1&0+,1 &92)1
1,2+ !/01+ %,41%&040
-,00&)!Q03&0%!/0!)#0,
-,4!/#2))6011! M]1%!,+)6
1%&+$1%10!-/1!04,*!+,#
,),/#/,*+6,+!!)0!&0
,--,/12+&16^X,) YQ+1%!
*',/&16,#:)*+ 1!)!3&0&,+M
4,*!+,#,),//!/!01/&1!
6/&0101!/!,16-!0,/*&+,/
/,)!0M+ 1%!)(,#
,--,/12+&1&!0/!1!0+
&+ 201/6 ,*&+1! 6,+!
!*,$/-%&Q,/ ! !0M
,))64,, %0!!+&+;2!+!
*,0164%&1!*!+4%,%3!
/!1! 01120.2,#,/%,4
,1%!//!0/!-,/1/6! &+1%!
*! &Q,/&+01+!M
,**2+&1&,+00%,)/0))!+
Q,,/!+ 1%!/&+!
,)!*+%3!+,1! 1%1
]1%/,2$%,211%!14!+1&!1%
!+12/6M#/&+*!/&+0
4!/!/!-/!0!+1! &+)&*&1!
/,)!01%1,#1!+/!;!1! /&)
%&01,/6*,/!1%+1%!60!/3! 0
0&$+0,#0,&)+ -,)&1&)
-/,$/!00M^0!/3&+$0&*$!0,#
& !0+ /!)&71&,+0,#
01!/!,16-!02-%!) 61%,0!&+
-,0&1&,+0,#-,4!/XGCAYQ
2--,0! )6M-/,:10 /&3!
,))64,, &/!1,/0+
,3!?L!/!4!0!!%,(/&
!01)&0%&+$1%!1!//&1,/6M0
0%,)/M20&+$1%!4,/(,#
,1%!/01,0%/!4&1%1%!/! !/
4%1&0)/! 6(+,4+,21
1%!1,-&L &3!/0&16&+
,))64,, Q
N,,"#(-,).-#)(),,-#(!,,"
*,
-/, 2!/01,01-!,-)!,#
,),/&+02--,/1&+$/,)!0&+
,/ !/1,--!0!2 &!+!0M
4%&)!,+1&+2&+$1,014%&1!
1,/001%!)! 0X,,/!+
,)!*+GCGYQ1&0
2+02/-/&0&+$1%!+1%11%!/!
4,2) !()0%$&+014%&1!
*!+,+1/,))&+$1%!
!+1!/1&+*!+1&+ 201/6M+
,3!/1%!6!/01%!/!%0!!+
&+1!+0!,+;&1!14!!+4%&1!0M
)(0M*!+M+ 4,*!+,3!/
!.2)/!-/!0!+11&,+&+1%!
*! &Q
,*!1&*!0M%,4!3!/M4!#,/$!1
1%11%!4,/) &0+,1'2010-)&1
&+1,)(+ 4%&1!M21
&3!/0!)!+ ,#-!,-)!,#
&8!/!+1/!0+ $!+ !/0Q
,3!@L!/!&04%!/!%,(/&`0
3,&!,*!0&+1,+,14%1&0
*&00&+$Q%!&0!01)&0%&+$1%!
+&%!Q*-,/1+1)6M0%!&0
:+ &+$%!/46&+1,1%!
/!0!/%1,*(!%!/)&*M%!/
&0,3!/6M1%/,2$%+!*, &!
--/,%1,1%!1,-&Q
+1%&001/2$$)!#,/!.2)&16M
1%!/!/!*+6$/,2-01/6&+$1,
!%!/ M21,+!$/,2-1%1
%0!!+04!-12+ !/1%!/2$&0
& )!01!/+4,*!+Q
,3!AL&+))6M%,(/& !)&3!/0
1%!0&0011!*!+1#,/,3!AM
,2-6&+$1%!+&%!Q%!&0
,211,1(!1%!/! !/ ,4+
-/,!00,# &0,3!/604!)!/+
,21%!/!5-!/&!+!0
!/0&+\*!/&+$/,4&+$2-
&+1%!6/!+ 11!+ &+$
&+1/6`0,))!$!Q
,4)!1`01/61,& !+1=%!1%/!!*,3!0&+1%!0&!+!/1&)!
4/&11!+61!*,##!*)!\& !+1&:! 2+ !/$/ 21!012 !+10
,,"#(-,).-#)(),,-#(!,,"*
,N
1 &+1 /6`0 ,))!$! + 1%!&/ #!*)!\& !+1&:! 0&!+!
-/,#!00,/Q
#78AG<9LG;8C4EGFB9G;8E8F84E6;
<AGEB7H6G<BA
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>EM&C0ZCD
Works Cited
',,'-/J+2'J!4+N[/4!-4'+,!&-'3,3/$
'30&!-/+VW/-42'54'-%4/&5,-
N,,"#(-,).-#)(),,-#(!,,"
*,
'3!3!N\
-4!2-4'/-+)/52-+/$,/+!5+2
3'!-!3
@?N?DV@>@>WICED?N
/&!-J3!+NJ!4+N[J-
+4!2 '0/%!-!3'3- $45,5+4'/-'-
&5,-,!3!-&9,+34!,!++3J7'4&
',0+'4'/-3$/2/!3'49N\
-4!2-4'/-+/52-+
/$/+!5+2'!-!3
@@N?>V@>@?WICADAN
7+!3J/&-N[!-2!-+93'3I-%+'3&'-
!,'- 2!3!2&3!44'-%3N,2' %!I
,2' %!-'6!23'492!33J3!+!4! BCYBEJ
C@YD>N\
&!'3/523!45 '!3! !2I'-
522!-43'-4&!/29- -+93'3
N/&-
!-),'-35+'3&'-%/,0-9J@>?BNA>DZA?DN
,,"#(-,).-#)(),,-#(!,,"*
,N
J%;
$,-4M$$4$O
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&!&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H !-4'$94'6!- 033'6!6/'!'- !,'
72'4'-%
H !<!4/-4&!3424!%'!34/5-/,0+'4!
!,'72'4'-%
P 3)/S,&))%#(! ),)(&/-#)(D#.S-.".1,#.#(!."#-#-
")#/.&-)().")#F.&&'3-& '3."-)/.."0-.
!/& .1(")#(().O")#D/..".-*#.-& #-(
N-#/(*#//)#
#&&/-#)(F.' � .".-'D'()/!"#- !))
()/!"FQN3-"&#(#0(((
/&1&+$ &+ + !*& 0-!M #,/ + !*& 2 &!+!M &+
+ !*&$!+/!M4&1%+ !*&3,&!M+#!!))&*&1&+$
11&*!0Q%,)/0& !+1=%!1/ &1&,+)460,#*(&+$+
0%/&+$(+,4)! $!X,/1%!!-&01!*,),$&!0,# !*&Y0&0\
$!+ !/! M*)!M)!\, &! M+ +!2/,16-&)Q%1 ,!01%1
*!+M1%,2$%R,4+4/&1&+$!*)!,/)!\, &! R
/DH4 /4,H-$$#$CD
,/ &+$ 1, -&+ 0%,)/ 3& ,//&0M + /1&)! ,21
028!/&+$ 4&)) *(! +, ,++!1&,+ 1, 1%! 1,-& &+ %,4 &1 &0
4/&11!+Q+01! M&14&))!),+$X-&+#2)1,/! &+,+!0&11&+$YM
&+)2 !+,,0!+&1&!0,/-/,#+&1&!0X !0-&1!1%!/!)!3+!1,
1%!1,-&YM4&))20!0-!&)&7! &1&,++ 3,& #*&)&/& !0
X(!!-&+$ 1%! /! !/ 1 &01+! &+ #2))6 2+ !/01+ &+$ 1%!
1!51YX.1 &++&3+++YQ00!+1&))6M4%!+1,-&4+101,M
+ +!! 01,M!0%/! 4&1%,1%!/0X&Q!QM1%,0!028!/&+$#/,*
%/,+& -&+ YM 2! 1, 1%! )&*&11&,+0 ,# !*& 4/&1&+$M
1%!1!51&0+!! )!00)6* ! &92)11,2+ !/01+ M!0-!&))6
#,/ 1%,0! 4%, *6 +!! 1%! &+#,/*1&,+ 1%! *,01Q 1%&+(
4!))%3!!5-!/&!+! &92)1 !*&1!511%1401,,
),+$M1,,,+#20&+$M1,, !+0!M+ 1,,*,+,1,+!Q,/,//&0
+ +&3+++M1%!0!)&*&11&,+0%3!0!/&,20,+0!.2!+!0
0 &1 *!+0 1%1 1%! &*-,/1+1 /!0!/% &0 +,1 /!%&+$ 1%!
-#/(*#//)#N
-!,-)!&10!!(01,%!)-Q%&0%--!+0*,01,#1!+M,/ &+$1,
+&3+++M4%!+1%!/! !/0 ,+`1:1&+1,1%!4%&1!M*)!
+,/*M,/ !#2)1%2*+M,# !*&Q
H-$CDDK$DM/H-DD/L$6/ $
),+$4&1%)+$2$! &3!/0&16+ !-1%&+3,&!1%14!$!1
#/,*, !*!0%&+$M !*&4/&1&+$+)0,/!-/, 2!1%!
]&))20&,+ ,# %,*,$!+!,20 X)!\, 6*&+ ! iY !*&
4/&1!/0 4&1% !01!/+T/1&,+)&01 +,1&,+0 ,# )!$&1&*1!
!5-!/1&0!^ X+&3+++YQ /,!00!0 /! 01/&--! 46M +
&+01! M /! !/0 /! )!#1 4&1% 1%! /!02)10M /$2*!+10M +
!5-!/1&0!Q (!M #,/ !5*-)!M 1%! &*-,/1+1 !&0&,+0 &+
/!0!/%4/&1&+$1%1!&1%!/!+1!/1%!!*, &! /!0!/%+
4/&1!/,/01/&-1%!*46Q*!)6M1%!%,&!1,4/&1!,21
/!0!/%&+-00&3!,/1&3!3,&!&0,+!1%1!&1%!/!/0!01%!
/!0!/%!/,/!+1!/01%!/!0!/%!/Q
+ 0&!+! 4/&1&+$M 1%! /%!1,/&) !&0&,+ 1, 4/&1! &+ 1%!
-00&3!3,&!%0!!+.2!01&,+! M0&1*&+&*&7!01%!-,1!+1&)
&0!0+ *!1%, 0,#1%!/!0!/%!/Q
+20&+!004/&1&+$M1%!-00&3!3,&!%0)),4! ,*-+&!0
1,*&+&*&7!1%!&/&+3,)3!*!+1&+,+1/,3!/0&) !&0&,+0Q,/
!5*-)!M]2)12/))6&+0!+0&1&3!,**!/&)40* !^&0
-00&3! 46,# 4/&1&+$,21 20&+!00 1%1 /!1! /&01
3!/1&0!*!+1Q %1 ,*-+6 & &1R ! ,+`1 (+,4M +
1%1`0 1%! -,4!/ ,# 1%! -00&3! 3,&!M ,**,+ &+ !*&
4/&1&+$Q
N-#/(*#//)#
C/H$CD6382/ H$H-$D$
HCK HKC$D
! %3! 0!!+ 0%,)/0 -20% $&+01 1%!0! 01/212/!0 !20!
1%!6 :+ 1%!* )&*&1&+$Q ,/ !5*-)!M !/0%4+ 0%+1&
,2+$ 3,1!0 #,/ , ! *!0%&+$ &+ %&0 4,/(Z&+3&1&+$
0%,)/0M012 !+10M+ 4/&1!/01,, !*!0%#/!!)6+ ,-!+)6M
&+01! ,#)&*&+$1%101+ / *!/&+! &1! +$)&0%&0
1%!+,/*Q, !*!0%&+$)),40 !*&4/&1!/01,&+1!$/1!
4/&1&+$1%1 ,!0+,1002*!,+!3,&!M,+!-!/0-!1&3!Q
DD/L$4# H/L$6/ $!-H/D
$DH&6CyourMC/H/4,>
#/!0!/%!/ !& !01,4/&1!&+1%!1&3!3,&!M1%!6!+1!/
1%!*0!)3!0 0 1%! /!0!/%!/Z1%! , 6 1%1 ,+ 21! 1%!
/!0!/%Q
!/!`0+!5*-)!,#1&3!3,&!20! 60&!+!4/&1!/L
-#/(*#//)#N
6G<I8/B<68K4@C?8
!0!2$/2,! 2!$5+33!33,!-43/$!++
/-<5!-!- !++%2/74&5- !22'%&4;!+
,'2/3/09J/-!& 9/$4&! '$$!2!-4'4'/-
02/4//+J33&/7-'-500+!,!-429'%52!3?-
@NV/&!-!4+NW
,1!1%!0!0&!+1&010/!&+1/6`0,))!$!012 !+10+
-/,#!00,/M))#!*)!M))!+1!/&+$1%!/!0!/%!/Q
,/!,#1!+M0&!+1&01020!1%!-00&3!3,&!1, &0!*, 61%!
/!0!/%!/M4/&1!/Q!/!`0+!5*-)!,#1%!-00&3!3,&!L
*4FF<I8/B<68K4@C?8
-33/24,!-4/$?>C&5,-J4J- /%$// 3
N-#/(*#//)#
7!2!/++!4! $2/,%2/!2934/2!3'-++3J!83'-
2&@>?>NV',,'-/!4+NW
!/!M 1%! 0&!+1&010 /! /!*,3! #/,* 1%!
0!+1!+!Z0,*!, 6,))!1! #,, &+,/ !/1,1!01)!3!)0M
214! ,+,1(+,44%,Q
6M/HM6C1D,C33H/ 22O
6G<I8/B<68
! 06 1%1 0!+1!+! &0 &+ 1%! 1&3! 3,&! 4%!+ 1%!
$/**1&) 02'!1 ,# 1%! 3!/ &0 1%! -!/0,+ ,/ $!+1
/!0-,+0&)!#,/1%!1&,+!5-/!00! 61%!3!/
0%($6L02/3!6! ))(&+!0&,),$6012 !+10Q
0%($7L4&))02/3!6))(&+!0&,),$6012 !+10Q
*4FF<I8/B<68
! 06 1%1 0!+1!+! &0 &+ 1%! -00&3! 3,&! 4%!+ 1%!
$/**1&)02'!1,#1%!3!/&0#2+1&,+))61%!,'!1,/
/!02)1,#1%!1&,+!5-/!00! 61%!3!/Q%!$!+1,/0,2/!
,#1%!1&,+*6! ! &+-/!-,0&1&,+)-%/0!M21&1+
!X+ ,#1!+&0Y,*&11! Q
-#/(*#//)#N
0%($6:%!-/1&&-+104!/!V1,!W02/3!6!
V-01-/1&&-)!WQ
0%($7:%!-/1&&-+104&))!V1,!W02/3!6!
V-01-/1&&-)!WQ
0%($8:%!-/1&&-+104&))!V1,!W02/3!6!
V-01-/1&&-)!W6*!V0,2/!,#1&,+0,'!1WQ
+1%!#,)),4&+$1&3&16M4!&+3&1!6,21,1/61, &01&+$2&0%
!14!!+1&3!+ -00&3!0!+1!+!0Q
#78AG<9LJ;8G;8E846;F8AG8A68<F
46G<I8BEC4FF<I8
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>GM&C0ZCE
N-#/(*#//)#
A8K68ECG9EB@B;8A8G4?QF
45FGE46G
!2!J7!53! &5,-$!,+! '0/3!Z !2'6! 34!,
!++3V&3WJ490!/$ 5+4,!3!-&9,+34!,!++J
4//,02!4&!!$$!43/$- +4!2-4'6!3
/- '0/%!-!3'3/2$4!++ !6!+/0,!-4
'-6'42/
N!
$/53! /-47//,,/-+953! 2!0+!,!-43J
'30&!-/+VW- 4!42,!4&9+'30&!-/+
VQ,/-/,!2/$4&!-!76+52!E>$// Z
/-44/4'-%WN5,-37!2! '$$!2!-4'4!
'-4/ '0/94!353'-%&!,'++9 !;-! ,! ''-
4&!02!3!-!/$/-42/+ '$$!2!-4'4'/-,! '7'4&
- 7'4&/54?EβZ!342 '/+V@Q?>=WJ/27'4&
'-2!3'-% /3!3/$V>J>N?- ?=WJV>J
>N?J?- ?>-WJ/2V>J>N>?- >N?=WN
$4!2 '$$!2!-4'4'/-J4&!!++37!2!34'-! -
',%! 4/6'35+':!- 15-4'$94&!5,5+4'/-/$
+'0' 65/+!3- -5,!2/$ !6!+/0'-%$4!++3N
2!4! !++37!2!+3/!8,'-! $/2!++6''+'49-
0/04/3'3V02/%2,,! !++ !4&W53'-%4&!
2!30!4'6!!++5+23393N
-#/(*#//)#N
+1%!#,)),4&+$1&3&16M4!&+3&1!6,2& !+1=%!1&3!+
-00&3!3,&!&+,%!+!1)Q`04/&1&+$Q
6G<I84A7C4FF<I8IB<68F<AF6<8A68
JE<G<A:
29 !-4'$9'-%4&!4'6!/233'6!!-4!-!3'-
4&!$/++/7'-%!8!204$2/,/&!-!4+N
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>GM&C0ZCF
+1%!#,)),4&+$1&3&16M4!&+3&1!6,2/!;!1,+,%!+!1)Q`0
4/&1&+$+ %,41%!&/%,&!08!16,2/!5-!/&!+!4&1%1%!&/
1!51Q
N-#/(*#//)#
,8W86G<BABA46G<I84A7C4FF<I8
IB<68
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?>GM&C0ZCG
/42-6K,-HD
%!-00&3!+ 1&3!3,&! !1!&0,+!1%1%&$%)&$%101%!
)&*&11&,+0 ,# !*& 4/&1&+$Z!0-!&))6 0 +&3+++
0%,40&+1%!&/ !5-),/1&,+,#1%! &0!*, &! 3,&!M )6,21M
+ 016)!,#1%!1/ &1&,+) !*&/!0!/%/1&)!Q,4!3!/M
4!)0,0!!1%14!%3!1%!%,&!1,-20%$&+011%!+,/*0M
)&(! ,2+$ 4&1% , ! *!0%&+$ + ,%!+ !1 )Q 4&1% 1&3!
3,&!Q
-#/(*#//)#N
04/&1!/04&1%6,2//%!1,/&)%,&!01,*(!M6,20%,2)
,+0& !/%,41,/&+$%,&!0,#3,&!&+1,6,2/4/&1&+$Q
Works Cited
',,'-/J+2'J!4+N[/4!-4'+,!&-'3,3/$
'30&!-/+VW/-42'54'-%4/&5,-
'3!3!N\
-4!2-4'/-+)/52-+/$,/+!5+2
3'!-!3
@?N?DV@>@>WICEZD?N
/&!-J3!+NJ!4+N[J-
+4!2 '0/%!-!3'3- $45,5+4'/-'-
&5,-,!3!-&9,+34!,!++3J7'4&
',0+'4'/-3$/2/!3'49N\
-4!2-4'/-+/52-+
/$/+!5+2'!-!3
@@N?>V@>@?WICAZDAN
-'6---J93&+'N[&!35!33$5+4!84'3
-/4+7934&!/-!4&4,52 !23,!4/
02/4!49/5N\
/ '!3/$*-/7+! %!I,/ '!
2&!4/2'3'-4&!/29- 024'!
V@>@@WI
?FAZ?GFN
/5-%J!23&7-3&-4'N[]&J7!342'%&4^I
-2%5,!-4%'-34/ !37'4&'-%N\
V@>>GWIBGZEDN
/5-%J!23&7-3&-4'N[&/5+ 72'4!2353!
N-#/(*#//)#
4&!9/7--%+'3&ON\
/7/52-+/$5+452+
45 '!3
?@N?V@>?>WI??>Z??EN
-#/(*#//)#N
N-#/(*#//)#
0,#-#(!-)2(-"#3N
N0,#-#(!-)2(-"#3
J5;
9
:
/4K4
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H 9-4&!3':! '$$!2!-43/52!3'-/2 !24/2!4!
9/52/7-2%5,!-4
0,#-#(!-)2(-"#3-#)()/,/#0N
!6'3'4I&4'3,/ '! &!4/2'3O
]6+1%!0&0^/!#!/01,1%!,*&+1&,+,# &8!/!+10,2/!0,#
&+#,/*1&,+ 1, #,/* ,%!/!+1 4%,)!Q %!/! +)60&0 ))0
,+ 20 1, /!( + /1 ,4+ &+1, &+ &3& 2) -/10M
+1&, +!+/!.2&/!0 20 1, *(! ,++!1&,+0 !14!!+ 1%,0!
-/10,/Z&+*,01 !*&4/&1&+$Z*,+$0,2/!0M1,-&0M
,/!3!+10X'2011,+*!#!4-,00&&)&1&!0YQ
,,+ 2106+1%!0&0M6,24,2) +!! 1,L
K !+1=%!(!6& !0&+!%0,2/!
K /4,++!1&,+0!14!!+1%,0!(!6& !0
K (!+/$2*!+1,211%!0&$+&:+!,#1%,0!
,++!1&,+0L4%6 ,1%!6*11!/M4%1 ,1%!6%!)-6,2
0!! &8!/!+1)6
,**,+16-!,#06+1%!0&0&+ !*&4/&1&+$M#,/!5*-)!M
&0$!,*,-**.!/&+4%&%1%!/!0!/%!/\4/&1!/,))!10M
,*-/!0M + 0%,40 ,++!1&,+0 ,/ &8!/!+!0 *,+$
&8!/!+10%,)/)60,2/!004!))0$-0&+1%!/!0!/%Q&1%
!*&4/&1&+$#,/!*,01&+*&+ M-%&*&!& !:+!0
06+1%!0&00]+)60&0/,000,2/!0M^ &+$1%1]4%16,2
4/&1!&+ /!1&,+1, 1%! 4,/(,# ,1%!/00%,2) 20!06+1%!0&0
1,/!1!+!4*!+&+$,/1,0%,4 !!-!/2+ !/01+ &+$,#
N0,#-#(!-)2(-"#3-#)()/,/#0
4%16,2)!/+! Q^%!& !&0+,1'2011,02**/&7!211,
*(!,++!1&,+0Q
+#1M4!06+1%!0&7!))1%!1&*!21*6+,1/!)&7!4!`/!
$1%!/&+$M,*-/&+$M+ !3)21&+$0,2/!0&+1%&046Q,/
!5*-)!M &*$&+! 1%&0 0!+/&,L ,2 + $/,2- ,# #/&!+ 0
4+11,11!+ *,3&!1,$!1%!/21++,1 !& !4%&%,+!Q
% ,# 6,2 *(!0 /!,**!+ 1&,+M 02**/&7&+$ (!6
!1&)0 ,21 6,2/ %,&!0 X$!+/!M $,, /!3&!40M ,*-!))&+$
-),10M+ 0,#,/1%YQ,$!1%!/M6,2+ 6,2/#/&!+ 0,*-/!
1%! :)*0M &0200 !% ,1%!/`0 00!00*!+10 ,# 1%! ,-1&,+0
3&))!M+ /!%,+)20&,+L6,2`))$,0!!1%!0&\:;&(O
%1`0 06+1%!0&0 X,/ ]+)60&0 /,00 0,2/!0^YQ + 1%&0 0!M
6,2/ #/&!+ 0` &+ &3& 2) +)60!0 /! 6,2/ 0,2/!0S 6,2/
&0200&,++ ,+)20&,+/!1%!06+1%!0&0Q
,/*,/!#,/*)-&!!,#4/&1&+$M&*$&+!1%16,2+!!
1, $1%!/ 0,2/!0M ++,11! 1%!*M + 1%!+ /!-,/1 4%1
,++!1&,+0M &8!/!+!0M $-0M + ,1%!/ /!)1&,+0%&-0 6,2
#,2+ Q %1`0,+! --/,%1, 4/&1&+$ )&1!/12/! /!3&!4M
,**,+ !*&$!+/!1%106+1%!0&7!03&))!/!0!/%1,
-,0&1&,+ 1%! 4/&1!/ 1, ,*! 1, ,+)20&,+ ,/
/!,**!+ 1&,+ ,+ 1,-&Q 21 &1 ,2/0 &+ *+6 ,1%!/
$!+/!0,#4/&1&+$04!))Q+1%!+!510!1&,+M4!4&))!5*&+!
!'2,)!`0]%!2-!/%!/,%,1,$/-%0,#1%!)(&3!0
11!/ ,3!*!+1^ 1, 0!! %,4 %! 06+1%!0&7!0 &8!/!+1
/%!1,/&)/1
&+,/ !/1,*(!%&0,4+/$2*!+1Q
O4H-$D/DN382$/4$0K62$BD
0,#-#(!-)2(-"#3-#)()/,/#0N
@-$K8$C-$C6-6H6,C8-D6&
H-$2 1/L$DHH$C
6L$3$4HA
&/01M/! ,)!`0/1&)!V!4WQ,)!+)67!0](&+$
1+ &+1,+,2$!M^1%!&,+&-%,1,$/-%,#)(&3!0
11!/ -/,1!01,/ !0%& 3+0 01+ &+$ :/* $&+01 -,)&!
,9!/0&+/&,1$!/M4%,/!&+1%!1,#//!01&+$%!/Q+,/ !/
1, 2+ !/01+ %,4 + 4%6 1%&0 -%,1,$/-% 4!+1 3&/) ,+
0,&)*! &M,)!,++!10&11,,1%!/&,+&&*$!0&+
,/ !/1,& !+1,**,+3&02)!01%!1&Q!1%!++)67!0
1%! 0&$+&:+! ,# 1%&0 3&02) )+$2$! 6 ,*-/&+$ )(
-/,1!01 -%,1,$/-%6 1, 02-!/%!/, *,3&!0M 4%&% )! 0 %&*
1, *(! 1%!0! 14, )&*0M 4%&% 1,$!1%!/ #,/* 1%! !+1/)
/$2*!+1L
?Q ]%!/!)1&,+0%&-!14!!+02-!/%!/,*,3&!0+ 1%!
-%,1,$/-%0#/,*)(&3!011!/&0+,1*11!/,#
-%,1,$/-%!/01/6&+$1,*(!-/,1!01!/0),,()&(!
02-!/%!/,!0Q1&01%14%!+02%-%,1,$/-%0!*!/$!
#/,*1%!,2+1)!001%,20+ 01(!+1/))&!0+ 0&*&)/
!3!+10M1%!6/!&**! &1!)6/!,$+&7! 6/,4
)/! 60!+0&1&7! 1,1%!&/#,/*).2)&1&!0Q^
@Q ]%!_02-!/%!/,`-%,1,$/-%0,#-/,1!01!/0M4&1%1%!&/
)00&#,/*+ 1/&2*-%)1,+!M/!!+$$! &+),/
,#/! /!00Q%!6/&+$,2+1!/4!&$%11,1%!/%&3!Q
$&+01 !1%+ %!)-)!00+!00M1%!6-/,'!1-,4!/+
N0,#-#(!-)2(-"#3-#)()/,/#0
$!+6Q^
,1&! 1%1 ,)!`0 /$2*!+1 !00!+1&))6 !+1!/0 /,2+
06+1%!0&0Q&/01M%!,*-/!0](&+$1+ &+1,+,2$!^
1,,1%!/&,+&-%,1,$/-%0L
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`??AM&C0ZD>
#!F:AF9F&)%1#- ,)'.)*& .),(,C").)!,*") -"#
0(-#(!.#(#(.)()/!H*").)!,*") 1,
,1 ),.",)1#(!7'#(!.,O!-(#-.,H*").)!,*")
,1-)')(7!*)&..")/.",)&#(..)/-
,')0#(! )( ,.7!H *").)!,*") 3 %--)(
-.,#(!-.,#!"..."',-"1-#(!,,-.#(.)(
)/!F
!51M%!,*-/!01%!0!&*$!01,02-!/%!/,1!510L
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
0,#-#(!-)2(-"#3-#)()/,/#0N
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`??AM&C0ZD?
#!F :AF: &)%1#- ,)'.)* & . ),(,C ").)!,*" ) -"#
0(-#(!.#(#(.)()/!H#'!) "),&/("#(!
"#-"'',D#(*)-./,-#'#&,.).".) 1,,1 ),
.",)1#(! 7'#(! .,O!- (#-.,H #'! ) *#,O(
"(!#(! ,)' *)&D #( *)-./, -#'#&, .) .". ) ,
1-)'H#'!) 3&)*-1#.""#--P)*.# ),&-.-DQ1#."
(2*,--#)(-#'#&,.).".) 3%--)(F
%!0! ,++!1&,+0 )! ,)! 1, *(! 1%! )&* 1%1 1%!
&,+&&*$!01!+ ! 1,] !-),61%!3&02))+$2$!,#
1%!,*&\,,(02-!/%!/,Q^!1%!+* !+/$2*!+1,21
1%!0&$+&:+!,#1%&0,++!1&,++ 4%6&1*11!/0L4%!+
4! /!)&7! 1%1 1%! -%,1,$/-%0 !-&1 1%!0! -/,1!01,/0 &+
46 1%1 &0 ,2+1!/ 1, /!)&16 &+ 4%&% )( -!,-)! ]/!
!1!+M%/$! M//!01! M'&)! M^4!0!!%,4]1%!_02-!/%!/,`
-%,1,$/-%0 ,# -/,1!01!/0M 4&1% 1%!&/ )00& #,/* +
1/&2*-%)1,+!M/!!+$$! &+),/,#/! /!00Q^
N0,#-#(!-)2(-"#3-#)()/,/#0
4L/HH/64DH6$#"$)$ H"4#
C/H$
+ 1%&0 &+1/, 21&,+ 1, 1%! 0!1&,+ ]/&1&+$ 1, 6+1%!0&7!M^
4!&+3&1!6,21,/! 0,*!0*-)!06+1%!0!0#/,*,1%!/&+1
/6`0 ,))!$! 012 !+10Q ! %3! )0, &+)2 ! 0,*!
&+3&11&,+0 1, 4/&1!M 0%/! 6 4/&1&+$ -/,#!00,/0 1 &+1
/6`0,))!$!Q
GH78AG0E<G<A:0BE><ACEB:E8FF
!7/5+ +'*!4/'-+5 !345 !-472'4'-%'-4&'3
3!4'/-N$9/52!'-4!2!34! '-05+'3&'-%9/52
7/2*J0+!3!;++/544&'3$/2,- 35,'40'!!/$
9/5272'4'-%$2/,9/5272'4'-%+33N!7'++7/2*
7'4&9/54/%!4'405+'3&! N
!2!2!3/,!24'+!372'44!-9345 !-43-
05+'3&! 4/4&!25-'6!23'4'!3N!4&'-*9/5^++;-
4&!3!,!-4/24!84353!$5+I
H +*-%5%!J+*&!4/2'J-
5+4',/ +4/294!++'-%'-N/+!^353'T!7
0,#-#(!-)2(-"#3-#)()/,/#0N
U9'++'+6/
2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7U
H ! '+-<5!-!23I&!4/2'+-+93'3/$
'*/*^3!-2!!452!3T!7U9!:'&
+)' !
2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7U
H --+93'3/$4&!'$$!2!-4425*3!-5
/2,43- 6+54'-%&!'2!33''+'49
T!7U9+':!4&'-%
2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7U
#AI<G4G<BAFGB0E<G8LAG;8F<F
FF<:A@8AG*EB@CGF
&!&04!23'-4&'33!4'/-3&/5+ 02!02!9/5$/2
/,0+!4'-%/-!/$4&!3!35,,4'6!72'4'-%
33'%-,!-43N&!3!!8,0+!32!33'%-,!-434&4
7!2!/,,!- N
(($#$)-#&"<1
N0,#-#(!-)2(-"#3-#)()/,/#0
/24&!!2+'!233'%-,!-4J9/572/4!-!3394&4
!32'!34&!2/+!/$4&!/ 9'-9/52 '3/523!
/,,5-'49N/7J9/52!2! 94/!%'- !!0!2
2!3!2&/54&/7/ 934!2!/490!32!$;2,!
/22!)!4! 7'4&'-4&! '3/523!/,,5-'49Q'- /'-%
3/J9/57'++!80+/2!4&!0/33'+!7934&44&!
'3/523!/,,5-'49,!,!23,'%&4&++!-%!- R
/2 '3,-4+!4&!3!34!2!/490!3R,'3/-!04'/-3N
&'+!!80+/2'-%15+'44'6!2!3!2&$/29/524/0'
V4&2/5%&4&!/-3' !24'/-/$'-4!26'!73J'-$/2,+
3526!93J/2/3!264'/-3W- /- 54'-%3!/- 29
2!3!2&J9/57'++72'4!2!3!2&02/0/3+2!+4!
4/4&!794&!/ 97'4&'-4&! '3/523!
/,,5-'49'3/,,5-'4! 4//4&!23- R/2
'-4!202!4! 9/543' !23N/522!3!2&02/0/3+VCZE
0%!3'-+!-%4&W3&/5+ /-6'-!9/525 '!-!4&4
02',292!3!2&345 9'3-!! ! 4/ 4/4&!
/-6!234'/-- 4&49/52!4&!3&/+24/ /'4N
Attributions
[9-4&!3'3J\'-
'234!2/,0/3'4'/-I2'4'-%3
0,#-#(!-)2(-"#3-#)()/,/#0N
-15'29- 2%5,!-44'/-J
*'!/!2,--Z
++'/44- 4&95!3!-529J
BN>
N0,#-#(!-)2(-"#3-#)()/,/#0
IQ;
/4$DD2$C$$
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/53&/5+ !+!4/
H /3'4'/-9/523/52!3'-/-6!234'/-7'4&
/-!-/4&!29 !32''-%4&!'23','+2'4'!3
- '$$!2!-!3
H !!9/52/7-2/+!'-4&!/-6!234'/-/-9/52
4/0'- 7&!2!9/52' !3- !80!2'!-!3
- 6+5!
*.--#(!2).,).,#()(/,-#)(N
'%NA>N?N
//%+!
3!2&
2!35+43
0%!'3
)534+'34
/$+'-*3
7'4&/54
3425452!
/2 !2N
%! -/!3&,20 %-1!/ &+1/, 2! 6,2 1, +1&, +!+Q , %,4
, 6,2 ,*&+! &8!/!+1 0,2/!0 ,# &+#,/*1&,+ 1, #,/*
,%!/!+1 4%,)!M 0 1%! 4/&1!/0 & &+ 1%! !5*-)!0 &+ 1%1
%-1!/R
&/01M&1`0&*-,/1+11,/!,$+&7!1%10,2/!0/!)/! 6&+
,+3!/01&,+4&1%,+!+,1%!/Q!`/! 20! 1,0!!&+$0,2/!0
0'201 )&01 ,# )&+(0,+ 0!/% /!02)10-$!X4%!1%!/ #/,*
,,$)!,/)&//6 10!YL
!`/!)0,20! 1,0!!&+$3& !,00+!+ )!000/,)),+&(,(
,/+01$/*L
N*.--#(!2).,).,#()(/,-#)(
#!F;8F:(-.!,'S-(#%)%S-&!),#."'-!/,(.(
#(6(#.-,)&&) *,-)(/.#-),!(#4)(.(.FJ'!
-,#*.#)(K
%! 46 4! !+,2+1!/ 0, *2% &+#,/*1&,+ 1%!0! 60
*(!0 20 1%&+( ,# ,2/ 0,2/!0 0 0,*!4%1 /+ ,* +
*.--#(!2).,).,#()(/,-#)(N
'%NA>NAN-!3&/+2
/,,!-43/--/4&!2^3
'*/*6' !/53'-%
'*/*^35!4$!452!N
2+,++!1! M4%&%+*(!&1%/ 1,:$2/!,21 '/ ,'
('+!,!'&, %!&'&.*+,!'&!&&++1=
21 ),,( ),0!/ 1 1%! 0,2/!0
6,2`3! #,2+ ,+ 6,2/ 1,-&M +
1'- %! , 4& , , , 1 *
'&&,Q,/!5*-)!L
K +!4!0&1!*&$%1$!&#,'
&', */+!,+
,**!+1,+&1Q
K 0%,)/)6/1&)!*&$%1!,
&', *+ '$*$1*,!$
+ &0200%,41%!&/
:+ &+$0/! &8!/!+1Q
K !#'#+,!, *&$%10%,4
0,*!,+!41%&+$+
,**!+1&+$,+0,*!,+!
!)0!`03& !,X!!&$2/!A>QA
V*$!!0/&-1&,+WYQ
K 4, &8!/!+1-,!*0*&$%120!+!%!$*!%*1;
/'*!&;'*'*%1,!5-/!00+& !Q
+01! ,# 0!!&+$ 0,2/!0 0 01+ &+$ ),+!M 4%1 &# 4! 04
/*!,!&++'!$,M4&1%!%,#202&) &+$,+1%!& !0
1%1 *! !#,/!R ,4 + ,2/ 4/&1&+$ -2)) 1%!0! & !0
1,$!1%!/ + '2*- &+ 4&1% ,2/ ,4+ !5-!/&!+!0 +
&+1!/-/!11&,+0R ,+0& !/1%! ]2/(!+ -/),/M^ *!1-%,/
N*.--#(!2).,).,#()(/,-#)(
!3!),-! 6 -%&),0,-%!/ + /%!1,/&&+ !++!1% 2/(!M
&))201/1! &+1%&03& !,X3&!41&*!&0@L>CYL
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`??FM/!,! Z?
#);8F9F-,"#-)(0,-.#)(3#,,3
+#1M--0)&(! !0!/%&1 + ,++!1! -!/0
+ %!)- 6,2 0!! 1%! +!14,/(0 1%1 ,++!1 0%,)/0 6
3&02)&7&+$--!/01%1&1!!%,1%!/,/,**,+--!/0L
#!F;8F<F-,"#.!,*"'*-")1#5,(.
*.--#(!2).,).,#()(/,-#)(N
-")&,&3,.#&-,)((.3.",.#&-."3#.FJ'!
-,#*.#)(K
,+,46,22+ !/01+ 1%11'-*+'-*+*'&&,
!& .*!'-+ /1+; + /*!,*+ & , !&#*+ -!$ '&
', *E+ !+ '.* ,!%=21 %,4 , 6,2 , 1%&0 &+ 6,2/
,4+4/&1&+$R%&03& !,!5-)&+00,*!01/1!$&!0#,/-211&+$
0,2/!0&+,+3!/01&,+4&1%,+!+,1%!/X3&!41&*!&0ALBEYL
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`??FM/!,! Z@
#);8F:F/..#(!-)/,-#()(0,-.#)(3&#&#./1'
0 6,2 /!0!/%M /!*!*!/ 1, 0(M 4%, 01/1! 1%&0
,+3!/01&,+R %!/! & 1%! +//1&3!0 -!,-)! 20! 1, 1)(
,211%&0&002!,*!#/,*R+ %,4+/&+$3)2!1,1%&0
,+3!/01&,+4&1%*6,4+3,&!+ !5-!/&!+!0R
N*.--#(!2).,).,#()(/,-#)(
0E<G8GB&84EA*HG2BHEBHE68F<A
BAI8EF4G<BA
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`??FM&C0ZD@
+ %$$1"0'.2'-,1
&$QA>Q@*$!!0/&-1&,+Q%!&*$!&00/!!+-12/!,#
0,&)*! &#!! 0%,4&+$$/& ,#+&+!-,010M!%4&1%
0*))&*$!1%2*+&)Q%!-,0103/6&+,+1!+1M#/,*1!51\
!+1!/! $/-%&0M-%,1,$/-%0,#-!,-)!M1,&*$!0,#'!4!)/6Q
%!#!! &+)2 !00!/%/11%!1,-)!)! ]!/%4&1%
!1 Q^ ,-\)!#1 -,01 ,+1&+0 1!51 $/-%& 4&1% ,) M
*.--#(!2).,).,#()(/,-#)(N
,),/#2) 4,/ 0 ,+ $/!!+ ($/,2+ Q /+0/&! !51L
]
^S,-\!+1!/-,01#!12/!0++&*1! ,/,),/#2)
&*$!,#4,*+02//,2+ ! 6#!01&3!!)!*!+10Q,-\/&$%1
-,01 0%,40 4,*+ + %&) &+ /,,* 4&1% 4/*
*&+!+ !,/1&,+0Q& )!\)!#10%,40),0!\2-,#
011!*!+1 +!()! 4&1% ,),/#2) 01,+!0Q & )!\!+1!/ &0
-%,1,$/-%,#*+4!/&+$02&1M-,0&+$$&+01+!21/)
( /,-Q /+0/&! !51L ]^Q & )!\/&$%1
,+1&+0 +,1%!/ &*$! ,# -&!! ,# '!4!)/6M -,00&)6
+!()!Q ,11,*\)!#1 #!12/!0 1!51\!+1!/! &*$! 4&1%
3&/+1,),/0+ !)!/1,/61%!*!Q,11,*\!+1!/0%,40
4,*+0*&)&+$/&$%1)6&+$/ !+\)&(!0!11&+$Q,11,*\/&$%1
,+0&010 ,# ),0!\2- ,# 0!1 ,# !6!0 4&1% *(!2- #,20Q
),+$ 1%! ,11,* ,# 1%! 0/!!+ /! &,+016-&))6 20! #,/
+3&$1&,+,+0,&)*! &-)1#,/*0QV!12/+1,&$QA>Q@W
&$QA>QA*$!!0/&-1&,+Q%!&*$!&00/!!+0%,1#/,*
0,&) *! &-,01Q 1 #!12/!0 14, 3!/1&))6 )&$+! &*$!0
0& !60& !Q+1%!)!#1M4,*+4&1%$)00!0+ 0)!!3!)!00
1,---!/01,!0-!(&+$Q%!%0+!21/)!5-/!00&,++
&0&+ ,*!01&0!11&+$4&1%4%&1!4))&+1%!($/,2+ Q
!51&+/! ,5,3!/)601%&0&*$!Q+1%!/&$%1&0+,1%!/
4,*+ 4&1% $)00!0M 4!/&+$ -11!/+! 1,-M + $!012/&+$
4&1%%!/%+ Q%&0&*$!,+1&+0/! 1!51,511%!1,-Q
%!($/,2+ &0-)&+4%&1!Q/+0/&! !51L]&01!+1,
1%&0,21%&+(&00!+1&!+1!&+$V!#1*$!! ,5
N*.--#(!2).,).,#()(/,-#)(
!51W&/011&*!1/6&+$1,%!/4%6-!,-)!4%,12))61%&+(
1%1 ,+`1 $!1 &1 4/,+$Q %+( 6,2Q /! 6,2 $,&+$ 1, 1)(
,21%,44!#!!)*,1&,+0 + 4%14!+ ,,21 &1R
😂🙃
X)2$%&+$ + 2-0& !\ ,4+ #! !*,'&0 02$$!01
-)6#2)1,+!YV&$%1*$!! ,5!51W ,!0+,11%&+(Q
/Q &/
💛✨🎤🚀
X6!)),4 %!/1M 0-/()!0M *&/,-%,+!M
/,(!1Z-)6#2),//+ ! 1,+!Yg/1@AGT/! &1L
f20!/
🔴
/,#!00,/0!6N! *,/!
🎧
P)6)&01,+&/ `0
4,/(Q ,**!+1N
🔎
❤😂
⯑ X0!/%&,+M /! %!/1M
)2$%&+$#!M%!/1!6!0Z16-&)&(,(/!1&,+0Y^V!12/+
1,&$QA>QAW
&$Q A>QB *$! !0/&-1&,+Q %! &*$! &0-)60 1%/!!\
,)2*+&+1!/#!,#+ !*&/!0!/%+)60&01,,)Q+1%!
)!#1M 1%!/! &0 ,)2*+1&1)! ]C 0!)!1! --!/0M^#!12/&+$
)&01,#--!/01%1--!/1, !2/1! ,/%&$%)&$%1! Q%
!+1/6&+)2 !01%!21%,/0M6!/M1&1)!M+ +01/1,#1%!
--!/Q%!--!/0/!1!$,/&7! 4&1%,),/\, ! )!)0+
211,+0#,/:)1!/&+$621%,//!)!3+!+ ,))!1&,+01120Q
%! !+1/) ,)2*+M )!)! ]&*&)/ ,/(M^ -/!0!+10 )&01
,#/!)1! --!/0//+$! 3!/1&))64&1%*!1 1&+)2 &+$
21%,/+*!0M-2)&1&,+6!/M+ /!0!/%1,-&0Q%&0)&01
&0!51!+0&3!M,8!/&+$*2)1&-)!:)1!/&+$,-1&,+011%!1,-#,/
01/1M!5-,/116-!0M+ /!)!3+!Q+1%!/&$%1M+!14,/(
$/-% 1&1)! ],++!1&,+0 !14!!+ 6,2/ ,))!1&,+ + CB
--!/0^ 3&02)&7!0 /!)1&,+0%&-0 !14!!+ 3/&,20 --!/0Q %!
+, !0M/!-/!0!+1&+$--!/0M/!,++!1! 6)&+!01%1 !+,1!
&11&,+,/1%!*1&)&+(0Q%!+, !0/!,),/! -/&*/&)6&+
*.--#(!2).,).,#()(/,-#)(N
0% !0,#$/!!++ )2!M4&1%)!)0&+ &1&+$21%,/0+
-2)&1&,+6!/0M//+$! &++!14,/()6,21Q/+0/&!
!51LC0!)!1! --!/0S5-,/1L0'0,+S+$Z+$@>??L
&!+1&: /, 21&3&16M !0!/% 2+ &+$M ! +
1%+&&16QS )+1&+!Z ,))&+0@>?CL1&,+)+01&121!0 ,#
!)1% /!00!01%!0&!+!,# &3!/0&16QS&*&)/,/(S&)1!/
1%!0! &1!*0S ,++!1&,+0 !14!!+ 6,2/ ,))!1&,+ + CB
--!/0S/-%6-!L!14,/(M&*!)&+!S!)0L&/0121%,/M
0121%,/S&)1!/1%!0!&1!*0QV!12/+1,&$A>QBW
Works Cited
52*!J!--!4&N
&!&'+/3/0&9/$'4!229
/2,I45 '!3'-9,/+'4'/-
N/5'3'-
44!J?GB?N
$#/HHC/KH/64D
K +01$/*0!/%0/!!+&0)&!+0! 2+ !/>
X/!1&3!,**,+0!/,Y)&!+0!
K &(,(2!1&0)&!+0! 2+ !/>X/!1&3!
,**,+0!/,Y)&!+0!
N*.--#(!2).,).,#()(/,-#)(
I7;
.
!
"
"
$,-4M$$4$O
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&!&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H !-4'$94&!'44'/-349+!002/02'4!$/2
024'5+2 '3'0+'-!
H !-4'$9024'5+2 '3'0+'-!3^6+5!3
N##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!
).,')/#(!')(!*')('&
H '$$!2!-4'4!!47!!-024'5+2'44'/-
349+!3^%5' !+'-!3N
/HH/64HO2$D
/&1!/0 ,#1!+ $!1 12$%1 20!#2) 1!%+&.2! #,/ &+1!$/1&+$
0,2/!0&+1,1%!&/4/&1&+$L&+1/, 2!1%!.2,1!S.2,1!1%!1!51S
&1!1%!0,2/!S+ !5-)&+,/+)67!1%!.2,1!Q%&)!1%&0
*!1%, #,/0,2/!&+1!$/1&,+&0!1%&)+ 0,2+ #,/4/&1&+$
&+M&1&0+,11%!!01--/,%#,/,1%!/&11&,+016)!0M
)&(!+ Q04/&1!/M,2/!20&+$ &8!/!+1
&11&,+ 016)!M 4&1% 1%1 016)! ,*!0 + !+1&/!)6 +!4 0!1 ,#
!-&01!*,),$&))6\&+;2!+! 4/&1&+$ !5-!11&,+0 4%!+
&+1!$/1&+$0,2/!0Q%&0 *60!!* ,3!/4%!)*&+$M 21 ,+!
6,2 2+ !/01+ 1%1 &0&-)&+/6\0! /! &+$ + 4/&1&+$
%&+$! ,+ 1%! 3)2!0 ,# 1%1 -/1&2)/ *',/M &1`0 +,1 &$
)!-1,0!!%,41%,0!3)2!04,2) )0,&+;2!+!%,40,2/!
&+1!$/1&,+0%,2) %--!+Q,)!1`01/61,*(!0,*!! 21!
$2!00!0 ,+ 0,2/! &+1!$/1&,+ 0! ,+ ,2/ (+,4)! $! ,#
3)2!04&1%&+!% &0&-)&+!Q
&/01M)!1`0*1%1%! &0&-)&+!,/*',/4&1%1%!&/20!,#
-/1&2)/&11&,+016)!&+1%!#,)),4&+$1&3&16QX,1!L6,2
4&)) +!! 1, ,+02)1 4&1% 6,2/ -/,#!00,/ 1, ,+:/* 4%1
&11&,+016)!&0/!.2&/! #,/1%!&/0-!&:,2/0!QY
##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!).,
')/#(!')(!*')('&N
'4G6;G;87<F6<C?<A8BE@4=BEGBG;8<E
6<G4G<BAFGL?8
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?@>M&C0ZDA
!51M)!1`0,+0& !/1%! &8!/!+13)2!0+ 1&3&1&!0,#!%,#
1%!0!$/,2-&+$0Q%1/!1%!0&*&)/&1&!0&+%,4+$)&0%+
1%!,),$6*(!+ 0%/!(+,4)! $!R%1/!0&*&)/3)2!0
0%/! 6%&01,/6M-,)&1&0M+1%/,-,),$6M+ 0,&,),$6R%1
, -06%,),$6 + &,),$6 %3! &+ ,**,+R %! +04!/0
1, 1%!0! .2!01&,+0 4&)) )! 20 1, 2+ !/01+ &+$ %,4 1%!
&0&-)&+!0-/!#!/1,&+1!$/1!1%!&/0,2/!0Q
N##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!
).,')/#(!')(!*')('&
'4G6;G;8I4?H8FJ<G;G;87<F6<C?<A8
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?@>M&C0ZDB
&+))6M 4! +20!1%&0 &+#,/*1&,+ #,/ :+) 01!-,# 1%!0!
1&3&1&!0L 1, 20! ,2/ (+,4)! $! ,# 1%!0! &0&-)&+/6 3)2!0M
4%11%!63)2!&+1%!&/0,2/!0M1,2+ !/01+ 1%!$2& !)&+!0
/,2+ 0,2/! &+1!$/1&,+Q % &11&,+ 016)! %0 &10 ,4+
!5-!11&,+04%!+&1,*!01,&+1!$/1&,+Q
'4G6;G;8I4?H8FB947<F6<C?<A84A7
<GF6<G4G<BAFGL?8J<G;G;8:H<78?<A8F
##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!).,
')/#(!')(!*')('&N
9BEFBHE68<AG8:E4G<BA
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?@>M&C0ZDC
!%,-!1%16,2+0!!%,41%!!5-!11&,+06,2//! !/0
4&))%3! #,/0,2/!&+1!$/1&,+ + &11&,+016)! %,&!/!
&/!1)6/!)1! 1,1%!3)2!0M,/*(&+$+ 0%/&+$(+,4)! $!
X!-&01!*,),$&!0Y,#6,2/-/1&2)/*',/Q%,0!*',/01%1
20! 16-&))6 3)2! ),0! /! &+$M 1!512) +)60&0M +
)&+$2&01&+)60&0Q%!/!#,/!M4%!+&+1!$/1&+$0,2/!0M1%!6
3)2! .2,1&+$ 4,/ 0 &/!1)6Q %,0! *',/0 1%1 20!
16-&))63)2!:+ &+$0+ *!1%, ,),$&!0,#3/&,20/!0!/%
012 &!0Q0/!02)1M1%!64+14/&1!/01,-/-%/0!X-211%!
1!51 &+1, 1%!&/ ,4+ 4,/ 0Y 1%! :+ &+$0 + *!1%, ,),$&!0Q
!16-&))6:+ +, &/!1.2,11&,+&+4/&1&+$20&+$Q
N##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!
).,')/#(!')(!*')('&
&+))6M *',/0 1%1 20! 16-&))6 3)2! 20&+$ 4& !
3/&!16,#16-!0,#!3& !+!M*,3&+$*,+$-/&*/60,2/!0
1%1/!,*-)!51,&1!.2&()6Q&+!1%!4/&1&+$4,2) !
2*!/0,*! + &01/1&+$ 1, 1/6 1, &+1/, 2! + &1!
0,2/!0M1%!620!#,,1+,1!+ !+ +,1!*!1%, Q! !/0+
*,3!.2&()61%/,2$%1%!1!51+ ),,(11%!#,,1+,1!0#,/
!1&)0,+4%!/!1%!0,2/!&0#/,*Q
26D$C661HC8-CD$D"
K6H$D"4#66H46H$D
!1`0),,(1#!4!5*-)!0+ &02001%!#!12/!01%1*(!
1%!0,2/!&+1!$/1&,+2+&.2!)6MM,/Q
##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!).,
')/#(!')(!*')('&N
*
K68ECG9EB@RB@8FG<6/<B?8A68
#FAQGGBCC<A:9BEBEBA4I<EHFTTS
#AG<@4G8*4EGA8E/<B?8A68
BAI8EF4G<BAFBA-J<GG8E7HE<A:G;8
4E?L4LFB9G;8)/#
*4A78@<6S
-4&!NNJ0/+'! !024,!-43'-4!-,)/2
,!42/0/+'4-'4'!3Y/24+- J/34/-J!44+!J
&'%/J'44352%&J&2+/44!J*+&/,'49J-
-4/-'/J,&J- -33'49Y2!0/24! /5+!Z
'%'40!2!-4%!30'*!3'-/,02! 4/4&!
02!6'/539!2V/3,-J@>@>Q/+-J@>@>WN
/,02! 4/2&@>?GJ2&@>@>7'4-!33!
@Ea)5,0'-22!343'-/24+- J2!%/-Q@@a
'-2!3!'- /,!34'335+4- 44!292!0/243'-
/34/-J33&53!443Q- @?a30'*!'-2!0/243/$
'-!44+!J3&'-%4/-N524&!2,/2!J4!84
,!33%!34/&/4+'-!3&6!3*92/*!4! 3'-!'4'3
3$!2794/3*$/2&!+07&!-4&!6'4','3'-
N##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!
).,')/#(!')(!*')('&
+/3!02/8','494/4&!53!2V/3,-J@>@>WN
5,!2/53,! '/54+!43J-!73&--!+3J- 3/'+
,! '0%!32!0/24&/74&'30- !,'&3
-!%4'6!+9$$!4! 6'4',3V,0!++J@>@>Q
/ '-J@>@>Q504c4&+J@>@>WN!3!2&!23-
024'4'/-!23!80!44&44&!45+-5,!2/$
3!3'3,5&&'%&!23'-!,-96'4',3,9&6!
!!-5-+!4/2!0/244&!53! 5!4/4&!'2
02/8','494/4&!53!2V!+624-,J@>@>Q
/54&++J@>@>WN
2/+/-%! /-;-!,!-47'4&53!23 52'-%4&!
3&!+4!2Z'-Z0+!/2 !23,9&6!+! 4/'-2!3!
$!2- !,/4'/-+ '342!33,/-%6'4',3N!'-%
!80/3! 4/0!23'34!-4$!2&3+/-%Z4!2,&2,$5+
',043/-6'4',3^,!-4+&!+4&V504c4&+J
@>@>WN '4'/-++9J4&!0- !,'&32!4!
3!6!2+-!7342!33/232!+4! 4/&!+4&J
!,0+/9,!-4J- ;--'+52 !-/-'- '6' 5+3N
&!0- !,'- 4&!/,0-9'-%45,5+45/53
342!33,9&6!+3/+! 4/'-2!3! /-35,04'/-
/$+/&/+- %5-0/33!33'/-'-4&!&/,!$/2
3!52'492!3/-3J7&'&/5+ ++5+4',4!+9',04
'-4&!&/53!&/+ V/3,-J@>@>Q,0!++J
@>@>Q'15!2/!4+NJ@>@>Q-9 !2J@>@>WN&!2!$/2!J
&3!/,!53!/$%2/7'-%/-!2-
##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!).,
')/#(!')(!*')('&N
-4'/-++9- '-4!2-4'/-++93'-!4&!0- !,'
!%-N
0&+$ 1%&0 !5!/-1 0 $2& !M /!;!1 ,+ 1%! #,)),4&+$
.2!01&,+0L
?Q %1&01%!/1&,!14!!+ &/!1.2,11&,++
-/-%/0!R
@Q ,4 ,1%!6&+1/, 2!0,2/!R
,20%,2) +,1&!1%11%!/!&0+, &/!1.2,11&,+X&Q!M1!51
&+0& ! ,# .2,11&,+*/(0YQ %!/! &0 ,+)6 -/-%/0&+$ X&Q!QM
1%!4/&1!/-211&+$ 1%!/!0!/%&+1,1%!&/ ,4+4,/ 0YQ %!6
&+1/, 2!0,2/!0 &/!1)64&1%1%! !:+&1&,+0M:+ &+$0M+
,+1!+1,#1%!/!0!/%Q%!/!&0+,#,20,+1%!1!51+*!,/
1%!21%,/T/!0!/%!/QX06,2*6/!))#/,*1%!%-1!/,+
&0,2/0!,**2+&1&!0M1%!0! &0&-)&+!0 ,+,14,//6,21
0,2/&+$M ,/ 1%! & !,),$&!0 + &0!0 ,# 1%! 21%,/0Q %!
21%,/0,#1%!-&!!/!#&/)6&+0&$+&:+11,/! !/0,#QY
&+))6M 1%! -/-%/0! &0 !+ ! 4&1% 1%! )01 +*! ,# 1%!
21%,/+ 1%!6!/Q
!1`01/6+,1%!/1,0!!%!0!$2& !)&+!0%,) 2-L
N##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!
).,')/#(!')(!*')('&
K68ECG9EB@R#F(8GW<K,<7<A:G;8
%BE84A04I8BE/<68/8EF4N
-;<E7C468%E4@4(8GW<K"4??LH
4A7G;8'8?B7E4@4G<6'HA74A8S
&!3!2'!3!84!-3'/-2!<!434&!,!2'-,5+4'Z
3!3/-+,/ !+V'44!++J@>?CWN
15' ,!^3
V7-%J@>@?W-224'6!- ,!4Z4!845+
0'45+4'/-4/4&!30!4+!'47/5+ 3!!,4/
'-4!22/%4!+3/!8&''434&!42'5,0&/$
,!2'-':4'/-N3,! '3&/+23&6!/3!26! J
'%'4++92!- !2! 30!4+!32!/++97//
42 !,2*VN',J@>?GQ*J@>>GWJ- 6'35+!$$!43
2!02/,'-!-4+9 '30+9! '-
15' ,!^3
3!-34'/-+'34%,!3- <3&92!-3J024'5+2+9
4&!5%Z/$Z2- +332' %!V'52'c'8/-J
@>@?WN/4&%,!32!++4&!&!'%&4J !84!2'49J-
0&93'+342!-%4&/$!842!,!30/243N&!'22!4&+!33
/-35,04'/-94&!'-4!2-4'/-+3
7'4&'-
4&!
3&/7- 4&!%+/+5 '!-!3/$4&!3&/7
++!%/2':!3/-4!,0/229,3330/24'-%!6!-43J+/-%
[ /,'-/$4&!30!4+!\- -'-3425,!-4/$
##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!).,
')/#(!')(!*')('&N
[,!2'-':! %+/+':4'/-\V!++-!2J@>>AJ00NCJ
DGWN[&!15' ,!$5- ! - !-)/9! 94&!
%+/+3J\',- 2*V@>@@W2%5! J
[!8!,0+';!3/-+ ':! 34 '5,\V0NEWN
/Z/04! 94&'32!%',!/$4&!30!45+2J15'
,!^3V7-%J@>@?W/-30'5/53+9/2!-
3'%-';!23X42 '4'/-+&'+ 2!-^3%,!3J2!42/342!!4
$// 3J- 349+':! 34%!3!43+'*!4&!$2'4!
%/+,/*V++!9WX2!'-$/2!24&!24&- '325044&!
+/%'/$5+452+&/,/%!-':4'/-J!8!,0+'$9'-%
!4<'8^3[$5-4'/-+'342!25'4,!-4/$&92' '493-
!/-/,'62'+!\V2' 9J@>>CJ0NG>WN&'3
[/20/24!42-35+452+'3,\V2' 9J@>>CJ0NG>W
3424!%90' /$$N-'437*!J
15' ,!
302*!
2:!$/2 +%/-- 9- 0'15! '-4!2-4'/-+
'-4!2!34'- *)'- )'-%!//2'J7&'+!'43<3&9
/345,!3!,!&'%&+93/5%&4Z$4!2++/7!!-
,!2&- '3!
0&+$1%&0!5!/-1#/,*,**2+&1&,+00$2& !M/!;!1,+
1%!#,)),4&+$.2!01&,+0L
?Q %1&01%!/1&,!14!!+ &/!1.2,11&,++
-/-%/0!R,4&0&1 &8!/!+1#/,*1%!-/!3&,20
!5*-)!R
N##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!
).,')/#(!')(!*')('&
@Q ,4 ,1%!6&+1/, 2!0,2/!R
+1%&0!5*-)!M4!0!!1%11%!/!01&))&00,*! &/!1.2,11&,+Q
%&)! 01&)) -/! ,*&++1)6 /!)6&+$ 2-,+ -/-%/0!0 ,# 1%!
0,2/!0M1%&021%,/ ,!0.2,1!0,*!0,2/!0 &/!1)6M#,20&+$
,+(!61!/*0+ -%/0!0Q%&0 &01&+1&,+!14!!+1%!:/01
+ 0!,+ !5*-)! 0 ,*-)&1&,+ 1, ,2/ !0/&-1&,+
,#0,2/!&+1!$/1&,+M21&101&)))&$+04&1%,2/+)60&01%1
0,2/! &+1!$/1&,+ !5-!11&,+0 4&1%&+ &0&-)&+! 01&)) &0
$2& ! 6 1%! 3)2!0 X,/ 4%10 ,# *(&+$ + 0%/&+$
(+,4)! $!Y&+1%1 &0&-)&+!Q#6,2-211%!*',/0,+
,+1&+22* #/,* 1%,0! 1%1 ,+ 21 1!512) +)60&0 X+
*64+11,.2,1! &/!1)6Y+ 1%,0!1%1 ,+,1M6,24,2)
:+ 1%1 ,**2+&1&,+ &01%! *,01 )&(!)6X0 ,*-/! 1,
&,),$6M%!*&01/6M!+3&/,+*!+1)0&!+!M-06%,),$6Y1,20!
1!512)+)60&0Q %!/!#,/!M 0,*! &0&-)&+!020&+$ *6
01&)).2,1! &/!1)6Q
-;8E84E8ABEH?8F9BEFBHE68
<AG8:E4G<BABA?LJ4LFB9F;4E<A:
>ABJ?87:8BEFBHE68F
!&/0!9/53!!4&44&!25+!32/5- 3/52!
##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!).,
')/#(!')(!*')('&N
'-4!%24'/-2!-/425+!Z3! J54'-34!
!0'34!,/+/%'++9Z3! N
'&
K68ECG9EB@RP(4;08GE4<:;GQA
E:H@8AG:4<AFGB78J<G6;<A:S
534'!'++'-%32/7-J7&/ !+'6!2! 4&!,)/2'49
/0'-'/-'-4&!3!50&/+ '-%3!%2!%4'/-J72/4!
4&44&
'-$!2'/2'494&47334,0! 50/-+*32'++9-
4&42!,'-344&! 4/+*30!!&73- '3
-/4/-42'6! 9+*3N&!!6' !-!4&44&!9
7!2!/-3' !2! 2'++9'-$!2'/24&!-34&!'230!!&
'3-/72!3' !3'-4&!'2!80!2'!-!'-3&//+7&!2!J3
2$$72'4!3J4&!92
?Q %1&01%!/1&,!14!!+ &/!1.2,11&,++
-/-%/0!R,4&0&1 &8!/!+1#/,*1%!-/!3&,20
!5*-)!R
@Q ,4 ,1%!6&+1/, 2!0,2/!R
0 /! !/M +,1&! 1%1 1%!/! &0 *2% *,/! &0200&,+ ,#
1%! 1!510 + *,/! &/!1 .2,11&,+ ,# 4%1 4/&1!/0 06Q
&1&,+))6M 1%! 4/&1!/ 1(!0 ),+$!/ 1, &+1/, 2! 1!510 +
0&121!1%!&/&*-,/1+!1,1%!+)60&0Q
')
K68ECG9EB@RH?GHE86?4F; BE8<:A
B<?4A7<A7<:8ABHFC8BC?8<A
ABEG;8EA/8E46EHM'8K<6B
OS
4'6!7/2*!2335!33$5++92/5%&44&!7!++5- !2
/-42/+'-2&?G??J544&2!!9!23+4!24&!
'- '%!-!37/5+ %'-!80!2'!-!4&!0/7!2/$
/42!2/ !++-//NBN-5%534?BJ?G?BJ
+'%&4-'-%'%-'4! 4&!%3!30'-%$2/,2*3'-4&!
N##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!
).,')/#(!')(!*')('&
7!++N[++4&!6'++!7/2*,!-J4/4&!-5,!2/$
AJ>>>J7!2!',,! '4!+9,/'+':! - 2,! 7'4&
3&/6!+3J\72/4!24&52N+'$$/2 J4&!;2!!80!24/-
4&!3!-!N0/-22'6'-%44&!3!-!J2-'3//+(3
2!2J;2!;%&4!2- $/2,!2/'+7/2*!2J$/5-
[-/4&'-%54+'44+!- '-3T
052/3'- '4/3
U\7/2*'-%'-
&!++'3&/- '4'/-3NAD
&'3!80!2'!-!- 4&!/-4'-5'-%!80+/'44'/-
!-/52%! -4'6!2 '+':4'/-N-+4!?G?BJ4&!
!-4'2!!8'-7/2*$/2!'-4&!2!/2%-':!
'43!+$- 34%! 7&4+'$$/2 +!++! [342'*!N\/2
!'%&4 93J[/54;$497&'4!,!-& 4/4*!4&!
54'!3/$AJ///-4'6!3J\7&/& 3!450[4&!
!8'-!15'6+!-4/$0'*!43\ !,- '-%-
'-2!3!'-09- /4&!2!-!;43N44&!!- /$4&!
7!!*J4&!97/-/4&- 2!452-! 4/7/2*NAE
ADN24&52N+'$$/2 J[84'-%5'3&'-%-'+Z!++'2!
'-!8'/J- 4&!24+9! &!2!'-9!+$Z
/-4'-! 2!4&'-%Z002453J\
2-34'/-3/$
4&!-34'454'/-/$'-'-%-%'-!!23
DAV?G@?WIAQ
2-'3//+32!2J'-4!26'!79'!$ +!3/-J
,0'/J,5+'03JE- ?F!04!,!2?GEDJ
##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!).,
')/#(!')(!*')('&N
RBRCDJQNN&,!23J[/42!2//N
BI'34/29/$-!/$!8'/^32+'!34- 2%!34
!++3J\
/52-+/$4&!-34'454'/-/$!42/+!5,
!&-/+/%'343
GV?G@AWI?BFN
AEN+'$$/2 J[84'-%5'3&'-%-'+Z!++'2!J\FQ
&,!23J[/42!2//NBJ\?BGZC>N
0&+$ 1%&0 !5!/-1 0 $2& !M /!;!1 ,+ 1%! #,)),4&+$
.2!01&,+0L
?Q %1&01%!/1&,!14!!+ &/!1.2,11&,++
-/-%/0!R
@Q ,4/!1%!0,2/!0&+1!$/1! R
AQ %1&02+&.2!,21R
%! 4/&1!/ #,/ 20!0 *&5 ,# -/-%/0&+$ +
.2,11&,+M 0&*&)/ 1, 4%1 4! 04 &+ Q %! 0&$+&:+1
&8!/!+! %!/! &0 1%1 1%! 0,2/!0 /! & !+1&:! 4&1%
02-!/0/&-1+2*!/)&+(&+$1,+!+ +,1!&+1%! ,2*!+1Q
%!0! !+ +,1!0 )&01 *2)1&-)! -/&*/6 + 0!,+ /6 0,2/!0
20! &+1%!+//1&3!1%11%!-/,#!00,/&0,*-,0&+$Q%&016-!
,# 4/&1&+$ &0 ,**,+ &+ %&01,/6 + !*+ 0 )!+ 46
1, &1! 0,2/!0 1%1 (!!-0 1%! +//1&3! )!+M 4%&)! ,8!/&+$
/! !/0 #2)) 2+ !/01+ &+$ ,# )) 1%! !3& !+! 20! 1,
,+01/211%!+//1&3!Q
N##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!
).,')/#(!')(!*')('&
,8W86G<BA
*!$!7,/,!-434/2!<!4/-7&49/52,)/2
- ,'-/2'3N&42!4&!3&2! 6+5!3'-4&4
'3'0+'-!O/7 /9/54&'-*4&!9$$!44&!
'-4!%24'/-/$3/52!!80!44'/-3'-9/52,)/2-
,'-/2O'-++9J /3/,!2!3!2&4/3!!7&4
'44'/-,!4&/ '3,/34/,,/-+953! '-9/52
,)/2- ,'-/2N&9 /9/54&'-*4&4'34&!/-!O
C H/ $8C8-CD/4,4#
=K6H/4,
,4 1%1 4! %3! !01)&0%! 1%1")1 6,2 -/-%/0! +
.2,1!&08!1! 66,2/&11&,+*!1%, 0M)!1`0),,(10,*!
$,, 3&! ,+ %,4 1, , 1%1Q ! /!,**!+ /! &+$
/).#(!D,*",-#(!D(0)##(!&!#,#-'61!3!+Q
/20!#/,*+,1%!/M,!)(,#.-*(2.F
##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!).,
')/#(!')(!*')('&N
BAA86G<BAGB@5B7<87,;8GBE<6F
$7!-/-4'-5!4//--!44&!!34024'!3$/2
'-4!%24'-%3/52!3'-4//5272'4'-%J3-/4
'3!,/ '! 02/!33/$$/++/7'-%25+!3J5424&!2
3/'++9/--!4! 024'!4&42' %!39/52/7-
%/+3372'4!27'4&4&!-/2,3- !80!44'/-3/$
/,,5-'49/$7&'&9/52!024
Works Cited
'JNJ&/'JNNJ&/JNJ3JNJ,9/JNJc
!-/-JNNV@>@?WN[M/,!34''/+!-!3-^4
4/00'-%$/2/2/-6'253KKN\I-4',4!
24-!2'/+!-!/-6!234'/-3/-7'44!2
52'-%4&!2+993/$4&!Z?G
- !,'N
/52-+/$6' !-!Z3! /'+
N##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!
).,')/#(!')(!*')('&
/2*
J
?G
V?WJ?>FY?@FN&4403IRR /'N/2%R?>N?>F>R
@DB>F>DDN@>@?N?GDBDE?
5-JNV@>@AWN3!4<'8' '-%4&!/2!-
6!/2'!!23Oe&'2 Z0!Z2,I
!4<'8J++95J- 4&!!+/ 2,4'
5- -!N
-4!2-4'/-+/52-+/$
/,,5-'4'/-
J
?E
J@CN
/5-%J!23&7-3&-4'N[\&J7!
342'%&4\I-2%5,!-4%'-34/ !
37'4&'-%N\
V@>>GWIBGZEDN
-4'%/J92-N[5+452!+3&I/2!'%-/'+
- '- '%!-/530!/0+!'--/24&!2-!225:J
!8'/J?G>>Y?G@?N\
&!/52-+/$,!2'-
'34/29
GGJ-/N?V@>?@WID@ZE?N
##*&#(,2!.#&#( ),#(-!,-#(!).,
')/#(!')(!*')('&N
IJ;
!
$,-4M$$4$O
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&!&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H 2&!4/2'++9-+9:!3/52!34/ !4!2,'-!
7&'&2/+!'433/52!3$5+;++
&0+/,+6*1%1%!)-0202+ !/01+ %,40,2/!0
N').,()# ,(--"#(! ),2).,
0,#-#(!
/!20! /%!1,/&))6X&72-YQ01+ 0#,/($/,2+ M
5%&&1M/$2*!+1M!1%, Q%&)!&+1%!-01M6,2*6%3!
&0200! 0,2/!00!&1%!/-/&*/6M0!,+ /6M+ 1!/1&/6M1%&0
)1!/+1&3! 46,# &0200&+$ 0,2/!0,-!+0 1%!,+3!/01&,+
2- 1, 1%&+( ,21 %,4 6,2 4&)) 06+1%!0&7! 1%! 0,2/!0 &+1,
6,2/,4+4/&1&+$Q
%! !5*-)!0 ,+ 1%&0 -$! /! #/,* 1!51 4/&11!+ +
-2)&0%! 6&+1/6`0,))!$!012 !+1&+ %&0:/016!/
X11%!4%&1!V!4WYQ
8VA<G<BA
!'%*$I53'-%3/52!4/02/6' !%!-!2+
'-$/2,4'/-J/2*%2/5- '-$/2,4'/-/-9/52
4/0'
-)I53'-%3/52!3-4!844/-+9:!
'*#$)I53'-%3/52!4/!-%%!'432%5,!-4
)%I53'-%3/52!$/2'43,!4&/ /+/%9J7&'&
9/5+3/'-4!- 4/53!
+ 1%! #,)),4&+$ 0!1&,+0M 4! -/,3& ! *,/! 1%,/,2$%
').,()# ,(--"#(! ),2).,
0,#-#(!N
!:+&1&,+0 #/,* &72- + !5*-)!0 #/,* &+1 /6`0
,))!$!012 !+111%!4%&1!Q
46>:EBHA7
%!+6,220!0,2/!0($/,2+ M&1*!+020&+$0,2/!
1, -/,3& ! $!+!/) &+#,/*1&,+ 1, !5-)&+ 1%! 1,-&Q ,/
!5*-)!M 4/&1!/ *&$%1 20! 1%! !+6),-! & 1, !5-)&+ 1%!
%&01,/6,#1%!)! $!,#))!$&+!Q
&72- !0/&!0&10]*1!/&)04%,0!)&*04/&1!/!-10
0#1M4%!1%!/1%!0!_#10`/!1(!+0$!+!/)&+#,/*1&,+
,/ !-),6! 0!3& !+!1,02--,/11%!4/&1!/`0,4+00!/1&,+0Q
/&1!/0/!$/ 1%!&/($/,2+ 0,2/!0021%,/&11&3!+
!5-!11%!&//! !/01, ,1%!0*!Q!20!4/&1!/00,*!1&*!0
1/!1 &+#,/*1&,+$)!+! #/,* 1%!&/ ($/,2+ 0,2/!0 0
_,**,+(+,4)! $!M`1%!6*60,*!1&*!0)!3!1%!0!0,2/!0
2+&1! ^XECYQ
N').,()# ,(--"#(! ),2).,
0,#-#(!
"BJ7B8F0;<G8HF8G;<FFBHE68GB
CEBI<78546>:EBHA7BA;84?G;
F6<8A68
&! !,'!80!24'3!- 3*'++3%'-! 2!53! 4/
,'-4'-4&! 6-!,!-4/$&!+4&9024''-%
62'/53$/2,3/$42!4,!-43J35&3352%!29-
,! '4'/-3N/,!/$4&!,/34/,,/-&!+4&
3'!-!2!!232!0&93'+4&!20'343J0&93''-
33'34-43J5 '/+/%'343J0&2,'343J-
/04/,!42'343V-'6!23'49/$7!-4!J@>?CWN
K;<5<G
%!+6,220! 0,2/! 0+ !5%&&1M6,2/! 20&+$&1 0 +
/1 1, +)67! ,/ + !5*-)! 1, &))201/1! -,&+1Q ,/
)&1!/12/!--!/M1%&04,2) !-,!*6,2/!+)67&+$Q,/
%&01,/6 --!/M &1 *&$%1 ! %&01,/&) ,2*!+1 6,2 /!
+)67&+$Q,/0,&,),$6--!/M&1*&$%1!1%! 1#/,*
012 6Q
&72- !0/&!0 &1 0 ]*1!/&)0 4/&1!/ ,8!/0 #,/
').,()# ,(--"#(! ),2).,
0,#-#(!N
!5-)&1&,+M +)60&0M ,/ &+1!/-/!11&,+Q 1!/&)0 20! 0
($/,2+ M/$2*!+1M ,/*!1%, 0,2/!01!+ 1,! -/,0!
1!510M21 +61%&+$ 1%1+ ! /!-/!0!+1! &+ &0,2/0!+
-,1!+1&))6 0!/3! 0 + !5%&&1Q %! 0&*-)!01 0,/1 ,# !5%&&1
&01%! !5*-)!M ,+/!1!&+01+!,8!/! 1,&))201/1! 0,*!
*,/!$!+!/))&*,/00!/1&,+NQV5%&&1W&0+,106+,+6*,20
4&1% 1%! ,+3!+1&,+) 1!/* !3& !+!M 4%&% !0&$+1!0 1
,8!/! &+ 02--,/1 ,# )&*Q 5%&&10 + )!+ 02--,/1 1,
)&*0M211%!6+)0,-/,3& !,0&,+0#,/)&*0^XECYQ
"BJ<FG;<F8K4@C?89EB@0;<G8QF
E8F84E6;C4C8EHF<A:4FBHE684F4A
8K;<5<G0;4GFBHE68J<??;84A4?LM8
-4&'-*Z+/5 02/4//+3!33'/-J024''0-43, !
3!6!2+2!,2*3/544&!$/2,44'-%J35&3[&!
$/2,44'-%'3%// \- [5++!40/'-432!-'!J-
3&/24J3',0+!0&23!3,*!'4!394/2! -
5- !234- N\&2/5%&-+93'3/$4&!%!-2!/$
,! '4'/-%5' !337&/+!J+/-%7'4&4&!
2!30/-3!3$2/,4&!345 9J'4'3)534';+!4/344!
4&44&!3!%5' !3&6!02',290520/3!/$
N').,()# ,(--"#(! ),2).,
0,#-#(!
'-$/2,'-%4&!04'!-4- 2!$/2,44! -
3425452! '-35&794&4,*!3'4!39$/24&!
04'!-44/5- !234- N2'!$344!,!-43'-4&!
4'6!6/'!++/74&!04'!-44/15'*+9' !-4'$94&!
,/34',0/24-4'-$/2,4'/-I[3!@'-&+4'/-3/$
@4',!3!& 9\V!-4!2$/225%
6+54'/-- !3!2&WN
E:H@8AG
%!+6,220!0,2/!0+/$2*!+1M6,220!&11,!+$$!M
3+!M,/,*-)&1!&10/$2*!+1Q,/!5*-)!M6,2*&$%1
20! + ! &1,/&) #/,* 1%! 1 ),% #'- ,+ 1%! 3)2! ,#
%&$%!/! 21&,+1,/!#21!&+6,2/,4+--!/Q
&72- !0/&!0 &1 0 ]*1!/&)0 4%,0! )&*0 4/&1!/
9/*0M &0-21!0M /!:+!0M,/ !51!+ 0&+0,*! 46Q , &+3,(!
,**,+*!1-%,/M/$2*!+10,2/!0/!1%,0!4&1%4%&%
4/&1!/0!+1!/&+1,_,+3!/01&,+`^XEC\EDYQ
"BJ7B8F0;<G8HF8G;8F8FBHE68F
GB9HEG;8E;<F4E:H@8AGG;4GG;8E8<F
').,()# ,(--"#(! ),2).,
0,#-#(!N
4A<FFH8J<G;E84745<?<GLB9
@87<64G<BA:H<78F
&'+!02!6'/53345 '!3&6! !4!2,'-! 4&!
2! '+'49- 35'4'+'49/$,! '4'/-%5' !33
7!++3!80+/2! 4&!/,,5-'4'/-!47!!-
0&93''-3- 04'!-43J$!7&6!/--!4! 4&!
47/'-2!%2 4/4&!/6!2++!$$!44&!9&6!/-
04'!-4^35- !234- '-%/$4&!'202!32'!
,! '4'/-V2'44!-!4+NQ/+$!4+NJ[3'+'49/$
Z002/6! ! '4'/-5' !3\WN
&2,!54'+2!02!3!-44'6!3/$4!-0+9
3534-4'+2/+!'-'-<5!-'-%0&93''-^3
5- !234- '-%/$,! '4'/-J54'4'315!34'/-+!
7&!4&!2!-/5%&'-$/2,4'/-'34&!-/-6!9! 4/
4&!04'!-42!%2 '-%4&!,! '4'/-4&!92!!'-%
02!32'! V!8&'-DDBWN
'8G;B7
%!+6,220!0,2/!#,/*!1%, M6,2/!20&+$&1046,#
+)67&+$+ &002!,/ 1,012 6 1,-&1,--)61,6,2/,4+
N').,()# ,(--"#(! ),2).,
0,#-#(!
&002!Q ,/ !5*-)!M 6,2 *&$%1 20! 012 6`0 *!1%, 0M
!:+&1&,+0M ,/ ,+)20&,+0 ,+ $!+1/&:1&,+ &+ %&$, 1,
--)61,6,2/,4++!&$%,/%,, &+!4,/(&16Q
&72- !0/&!0&10]*1!/&)0#/,*4%&%4/&1!/ !/&3!0
$,3!/+&+$,+!-1,/*++!/,#4,/(&+$Q*!1%, 0,2/!
+,8!/0!1,#(!61!/*0M)6,21-/1&2)/-/,! 2/!M,/
#2/+&0%$!+!/)*, !),/-!/0-!1&3!^XEDYQ
"BJ7B8F0;<G8HF8G;<FFBHE684F4
J4LGB78F6E<584A7C?4A;<FFGH7LQF
@8G;B7B?B:L
/24&!4&'-*Z+/5 02/4//+3!33'/-3J4&2!!%2/503
/$$/52'- '6' 5+37!2!%4&!2! 4/ '35334&!'2
6'!73- /0'-'/-3/$0*%!'-3!24V! '4'/-
5' !W$/2 6'2J[-/2+'-&+4'/-
,! '4'/-$/242!4,!-4/$34&,'-04'!-43%!
?@9!23- /+ !2\V!-4!2$/225%6+54'/--
!3!2&WN&'330!';,! '4'/-%5' !73
&/3!-!53! 6'2'3/,,/-+902!32'!
,! '4'/-$/234&,J+5-% '3!3!4&4$$!43
002/8',4!+9@C,'++'/-0!/0+!'-4&!-'4! 44!3
').,()# ,(--"#(! ),2).,
0,#-#(!N
+/-!V!-4!23$/2'3!3!/-42/+- 2!6!-4'/-WN
524&!2,/2!J4&'3,! '4'/-%5' !733!+!4! 3
4&!%!2-%!/$4&!024''0-43'-4&'3345 9
/22!30/- ! 7!++7'4&4&!%!/$04'!-434&42!
$<'4! 7'4&34&,- 4&!2!$/2!02!32'! 4&'3
,! '4'/-N
Works Cited
':50J/3!0&N[I&!4/2'+/5+29
$/2!&'-%!3!2&Z3! 2'4'-%N\
&!4/2'!6'!7@EN?V@>>FWIE@ZFDN
&'4!J44&!7N['3/--!4'-4&!2/!33
- - !234- '-%/$2!32'04'/-
! '4'/-3N\
&-%!3N
&4403IRR8&-%!3N/2%R
Z '3/--!4Z'-Z4&!Z02/!33Z?BZ@
N').,()# ,(--"#(! ),2).,
0,#-#(!
II;
!
/4$DD2$C$$
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/53&/5+ !+!4/
H !;-!
'-+53'6!'44'/-
/2
'44'/-)534'!
H 2'4'++92!<!4/-4&! '6!23'49/$54&/23
- 0!230!4'6!39/52!'-/20/24'-%-
'4'-%'-9/52/7-72'4'-%
#--#)($.-#0")2).#-'--,N
57'$(-., '
9"/, -1#))(.,)&
.# . ,'-)!
$-)/,-
',"$(&$4
)/.-$ ,1,$.$("-
&)("-*)--$& 6
$#, &")
L2KH/4,
6KC6KC $D
+! 6,2 %3! -&(! ,21
0,*!0,2/!0#,/6,2/--!/
+ ,+0& !/! %,4 1%!6
4,/(1,$!1%!/1,1!))01,/6M
6,2`))4+11,1(!),,(1
6,2/ )&01 ,# 0,2/!0 0
4%,)! 1, *(! 02/! 1%!6 *!!1 6,2/ $,)0 #,/ /! &&)&16+
/!)!3+!
211%&0&0)0,$,, 1&*!1,,+0& !// '+.'!+*
*(*+&,!&A&+&,*'%A1'-*+'-*+=
#1!/))M04!`3!)!/+! M1%!0!/%1,,)04!20!1,:+
0,2/!0%3!&0(! &+Q
-66K/H$HH$CD
12 &!0 %3! 0%,4+ 1%1 + '$*$1 /'*# 1 /'%& &
&'&B/ !,+ '$*+,!,!+(*'('*,!'&,$1$++, &
%&&/ !,('($&+3/&!16,#:!) 0X4,+CDGYQ
,&1`0&*-,/1+11%14!4,/(1,'-&,*,, +!++
+ *(!02/!4!/!&+,/-,/1&+$ &3!/0!-!/0-!1&3!0&+,2/
4,/(Q%&0&0,#1!+))! #(&/-#0#..#)(,/#..#)(&$/-.#Q
N#--#)($.-#0")2).#-'--,
,"*31'4$"'2 2'-,4?FB>ABJA
4F"'2 2'-, *(312'"$
[]-+53'6!'44'/-^ !32'!3-002/&4/'4'-%
4&!'-4!++!45+- 2!4'6!7/2*/$'- '6' 5+3-
%2/5037'4& '6!23'49/$*%2/5- 3J!80!2'!-!3J
- 0!230!4'6!3N-+53'6!'44'/-7/2*34/
/5-4!24 /,'--40/7!23425452!34&4&6!
&'34/2'++902'6'+!%! !24'-%2/5037&'+!
'3 6-4%'-%/4&!23N\V!2W
,/-!/0,+),2+1,#1%!&*-,/1+!,#&+)20&3!&11&,+M
/! ,211%!!5-!/&!+!,#/Q&0%,++/6+ ]1%!/6
1!01^1%140+*! #1!/%!/Q
#--#)($.-#0")2).#-'--,N
1$26D$C661
6G<I<GL
/7J05++509/52'+'/%20&9/24&!3/52!39/5^6!
$/5- 3/$2$/29/52-!84!339N//*'-%44&!3!
3/52!3J3*9/523!+$I
+$"*&'(&)+('%#;
H /,!-- -/-'-2954&/23O
H 5!!2- 42-354&/23O
H '3+! 54&/23O
H 54&/23$2/,4&!+/+/54&O
H !/0+!/$/+/2O
H !/0+!/$ '6!23!%!3O
H /05+4'/-37&/2!',04! 94&!4/0'/$
,92!3!2&O
$/523!J'4-! '$;5+44/;%52!4&'3/54)5349
+//*'-%4+'34/$-,!3N&'3%5' !4/'44'/-
534'!'-$2/,'++-'6!23'49+'3433/,!
N#--#)($.-#0")2).#-'--,
&!+0$5+2!3/52!3$/2!6+54'-%4&! '6!23'49/$9/52
3/52!3- ;- '-%3/52!39,'-/2'4':! %2/503N
-O/D/H/386CH4HH6/4 2K#$
#/L$CD$L6/ $D/46KCMC/H/4,>
+!/!0,+ &0 1%1 &+)2 &+$1!510621%,/0 4&1% 3/&!16
,#)&3! !5-!/&!+!04&)))),46,2/4/&1&+$1,/!;!14& !/
!.*+!,1'(*+(,!.+Q
+,1%!//!0,+&01, ! $! ,, /'*#'%*!&$!2
*'-(+Q%!+4! ,+`11&3!)6,2+1!/1!5&01&+$&0!01%1
)&*&14%,$!10&1! M-!,-)!01/11,1%&+(1%11%!,+)64,/(
1),."&1&+$ &0 1%1 6 ,*&++1 $/,2-0Q %&+( ,21 6,2/
,))!$&1!!*&+//! &+$0M#,/!5*-)!Q#1%!00&$+! 1!510
4!/! )) 6 ,+! 16-! ,# -!/0,+M 4%1 *&$%1 1%1 1!)) ,))!$!
012 !+10,214%,0!& !0/!4,/1% &0200&+$&+,))!$!R
+! &1&,+)/!0,+1,-/1&!&+)20&3!&11&,+&01%1M
!)&!3! &1 ,/ +,1M !,,!'&+ !%(, **+Q !*&0 4&))
,#1!+0%,4%,4*+6&11&,+01%!&/4,/(%0$,11!+0-/,,#
,#1%!&*-11%!&/4,/(&0%3&+$Q%!+6,2&1!0,*!,+!`0
4,/(&+-/,#!00&,+)-2)&1&,+M6,2*&$%1!%!)-&+$1%!*
(!!-1%!&/',,/$!1-/,*,1&,+Q
1% 11! +&3!/0&16 &//&!0 $2& ! + 1%! #,)),4&+$
3& !, 02**/&7!0 1%! &*-,/1+! ,# &1&+$ *2)1&-)6
#--#)($.-#0")2).#-'--,N
*/$&+)&7! + 2+ !//!-/!0!+1! 0%,)/0 X3&!4 1&*! &0
@LA?YL
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?@BM/!,! Z?
#);;F9F#.#(!-")&,-3#,,#-
0E<G8GB&84EA#A6?HF<I8<G4G<BA
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?@BM&C0ZDD
N#--#)($.-#0")2).#-'--,
Works Cited
!2J- 2!N[-+53'6!'44'/-N\
/7-
-'6!23'49e,0!++
'229N
&4403IRR+'%5' !3N2/7-N! 5R
'-+53'6!S'44'/-N
!+% /J'&2 N[&!,0!2'+&/+2
!6'3'4! I/74/2%'-+':!543' !2
2'4'-%J!-!234!2N\
-'6!23'49/$
!--39+6-'7!6'!7
J6/+N?B>J-/NBJ02N
?GG@J00N?ABGZ?AE@N
&4403IRR3&/+23&'0N+7N50!--N! 5R%'R
6'!7/-4!-4N%'O24'+!`ADGEc/-4!84`0!--S+
7S2!6'!7N
7/-J'-N[&!'3!/$'44'/-+
534'!N\
452!
J6/+NDAJ@>@@J00NCDFZCE?N
&4403IRR777N-452!N/,R24'+!3R
B?CFDZ>@@Z>>EGAZ?N0 $N
4&44!-'6!23'49'22'!3N['4'-%
&/+23N\
/55!
JF2N@>@?N
&4403IRR9/545N!RFB2SZN
#--#)($.-#0")2).#-'--,N
N#--#)($.-#0")2).#-'--,
0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"N
N0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"
I+;
9
:
K4O4/-HH -CO
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H - !234- 4&!34!03-!!33294/2!4!-
2%5,!-43! /-2!3!2&
H !3'%-2!3!2&02/,04
H !3!2&4/0'
H 2!4!---/44! '+'/%20&9
0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"-#)(
)/,/#0N
!6'3'4I&4'3,/ '! &!4/2'3O
+*,010-!10,#,2/)&3!0M4!/!0(! 1,2+ !/01+ +
+)67!/$2*!+10Q%&0*&$%1!4%&)!4!/! &0200&+$1%!
/!)1&3! *!/&10,# 0%,44&1% #/&!+ 0M ,+3&+&+$,+!`0
#*&)6 1, ! )),4! 1, 012 6 1%! *',/ ,# ,+!`0 %,&!M ,/
!& &+$ !14!!+ /+ 0 #,/ 0&*&)/ -/, 210Z4! ,*!
/,00/$2*!+10))1%!1&*!Q
%!+ &1 ,*!0 1, 4/&1&+$M 1%! /$2*!+10 4! *(! &+ +
!006 +!! 02--,/1Q 201 )&(! )&01&+$ )) 1%! /!0,+0 4%6 ,2/
#3,/&1!0-,/101!*&01%!!01M+ (&+$1%,0!/!0,+04&1%
4!))\/!0!/%! 011&01&0M 4/&1&+$ + /$2*!+11&3! /!0!/%
!006)0,+!! 01%!0!14,1%&+$0L
?Q 4!))\-%/0! + )!/)6,*-/!%!+0&)!)&*,/+
/$2*!+1Q
@Q /! &)!/!0!/%1,02--,/11%!,3!-,&+1Q
06,2*,3!1%/,2$%1%!-/,!00,##,/*&+$+ /!0!/%&+$
+/$2*!+1M/!*!*!/1,1%&+(,21,*-,0&1&,+0+1
1%1&0-!/#,/*! 66,20, 6)&3&+$&+1%!4,/) Q%&0
4&)) 8!1 %,4 6,2 0!)!1 6,2/ 1,-&M :+ /!)!3+1 0,2/!0M
+ !3!),-1%!:+)--!/Q,/!5*-)!M%,4 ,!01%!1,-&
&+1!/0!14&1%6,2/3/&,20& !+1&16-,0&1&,+0R/!6,2 /4+
N0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"
-#)()/,/#0
*,/!1,!/1&+(&+ 0,#02--,/1&+$!3& !+!!20!,#6,2/
,4+ )&1!/6 !5-!/&!+!0R /! 6,2 *(&+$ ,+0&,20 +
2+,+0&,20016)&01&%,&!00! ,+%,46,2/!3&!4! 0
+ !*, &! &+ &3& 2) 6 0,&) + 2)12/) &+01&121&,+0R
%!:+)-/, 216,24/&1!4&))!02*,#1%!0!&+1!/1&,+0
1%16,2%3!4&1%1%!4,/) Q
4L/HH/64DH6$#"$)$ H"4#
C/H$
+ 1%&0 &+1/, 21&,+ 1, 1%! 0!1&,+ ]/&1&+$ 1, (! +
/$2*!+14&1%!0!/%M^4!&+3&1!6,21,/! 0,*!0*-)!
/%!1,/&) +)60&0 !0060 #/,* ,1%!/ &+1 /6`0 ,))!$!
012 !+10Q ! %3! )0, &+)2 ! 0,*! &+3&11&,+0 1, 4/&1!M
0%/! 64/&1&+$-/,#!00,/01&+1/6`0,))!$!Q
GH78AG0E<G<A:
!7/5+ +'*!4/'-+5 !345 !-472'4'-%'-4&'3
3!4'/-N$9/52!'-4!2!34! '-05+'3&'-%9/52
7/2*J0+!3!;++/544&'3$/2,- 35,'40'!!/$
0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"-#)(
)/,/#0N
9/5272'4'-%$2/,9/5272'4'-%+33N!7'++7/2*
7'4&9/54/%!4'405+'3&! N
!2!2!3/,!24'+!372'44!-9345 !-43-
05+'3&! 4/4&!25-'6!23'4'!3N!4&'-*9/5^++;-
4&!3!,!-4/24!84353!$5+I
H +*-%5%!J+*&!4/2'J-
5+4',/ +4/294!++'-%'-N/+!^353'T!7
U9'++'+6/
2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7U
H ! '+-<5!-!23I&!4/2'+-+93'3/$
'*/*^3!-2!!452!3T!7U9!:'&
+)' !
2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7U
H --+93'3/$4&!'$$!2!-4425*3!-5
/2,43- 6+54'-%&!'2!33''+'49
T!7U9+':!4&'-%
2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7U
H 5-%!/-3- 2%/-3I 6!-452!J%'J
- -+93'3/$4&!/,,5-'49!-2!3T!7
U9+'9&'-4&2+!3
2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7U
H &!&!4/2'/$'/4222+'-!3T!7U9
2+'*&2'
2'4!2^344!,!-4T!7U
N0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"
-#)()/,/#0
H 80+/2'-%4&!&!4/2'/$/-4!,0/229+*
!,+!07'4&'-4&!/-4!84/$/'+
'3/523!- !-4'49T!7U9!%-
!+ !2
#AI<G4G<BAFGBJE<G8,8F84E6;*EB=86G
FF<:A@8AG*EB@CGF
&!&04!23'-4&'33!4'/-3&/5+ 02!02!9/5$/2
/,0+!4'-%/-!/$4&!3!35,,4'6!72'4'-%
33'%-,!-43N&!3!!8,0+!32!33'%-,!-434&4
7!2!/,,!- N
(($#$)-#&"<1
2'4!!3!2&Z3! 2%5,!-40!2N5'+ '-%
/$$4&!C0%!34&49/572/4!$/29/52!3!2&
2/0/3+J9/57'++4*!34-!/-9/52'335!-
72'4!2!3!2&2%5,!-4V- '4'/-+E0%!3W
4&444!,0434/-37!24&!15!34'/-0/3! '-9/52
0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"-#)(
)/,/#0N
!3!2&2/0/3+N- /'-%3/J9/57'++/,'-!
9/5202',29;- '-%3X-+93!3/$%!-2!3J
'-4!26'!73J/3!264'/-3J- R/23526!93X7'4&4&!
3!/- 292!3!2&%4&!2! '-4&!M?- 4&!
M@N&!2!$/2!J4&!,'-$/53$/24&'3!3!2&
0!2V?@0%!3'-+!-%4&7&!-/,'-! 7'4&4&!
72'4'-%9/5 ' $/2M@W7'++!72'4'-%-
'4'/-+E0%!34//,0+!4!4&!;- '-%3J
'3533'/-J- /-+53'/-3!4'/-3N
H$87!4#$CDH4#/4,
C,K3$4HD
!$/2!7!!,2*/-72'4'-%-2%5,!-44'6!
0'!!J7!-!! 4/4&'-*/544&!$/++/7'-%'-
2!+4'/-4/-94!844&4'3,*'-%-2%5,!-4N
-$6,/ 6&H-$C,K3$4H!
H &4'34&!4/0'/24&!,!O
H &4'34&!+',!'-%, !O
N0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"
-#)()/,/#0
H 2!4&!+',3!'-% !6!+/0! O
H /72!4&!9!'-%3500/24! -
!6!+/0! O
-$C$#//2/HOK$DH/64
H &93&/5+ /-!+'34!-4/4&'354&/2O
H /!34&!4!84/$$!2/5-4!22%5,!-43O
-$/,4/( 4 $
H 34&!2%5,!-402!3!-4! '-794&4
!6/*!32!30/-3!$2/,4&!2! !2O34&!
2! !2, !4/2!O
H 34&'3/,'-%$2/,4&!4!84^34/-!O3!/$
!6' !-!O425452!O49+!/$72'4'-%O
/,!4&'-%!+3!O
H /!34&!4!84^3%!-2!,*! '$$!2!-!4/
&/73'%-';-44&!2%5,!-43!!,3O
0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"-#)(
)/,/#0N
A4?LM8FF4L)HG?<A8F
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?@FM&C0ZDE
H$8J!6C3/4,4C,K3$4H
?N ! 4&!33'%-,!-402/,04+/3!+9-
2! '43!6!2+4',!3N/!3'430!'$94&!
*'- /$2%5,!-49/53&/5+ ,*!J/24&!
5 '!-!9/53&/5+ 2!33O&4 /!3
'439/544&!2!3!2&02/!33J- 4&!
N0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"
-#)()/,/#0
*'- - -5,!2/$3/52!39/5-!! O
@N !%'-7'4&-' !9/52!/54N&'3
,'%&43!!,+'*!3',0+!- $'2+9
/6'/533424'-%0+!J54'4'3-
',0/24-4/-!N$9/52!-/4'-4!2!34! '-
4&!4/0'J9/52!+'*!+94/-/4;-
/,0!++'-%2!3!2&J- 9/522! !2'3
%/'-%4/3!-3!9/52 '3'-4!2!34'-9/52
72'4'-%N//%+!- '*'0! '2!/$4!-
%// 0+!34/3424N
AN 22/74&!4/0'4/3/,!4&'-%4&4'3
,-%!+!N&'37'++ !0!- /-4&!
2!3!2&02/,04J544&!' !'34&49/5
7-44/2%5!3/,!4&'-%4&4-!
!80+'-! J !6!+/0! J3500/24! J-
/5-4!2! 7'4&'-4&!30!/$$!7
0%!3N
BN 2$4- 2! 2$44&!+',9/57'3&4/
,*!N&'-*/54&/79/5,'%&4!80+'-
4&!+',4/4&!$/++/7'-%5 '!-!3
◦ /,!/-!'-9/52+337&/*-/73
4&!02,!4!23/$4&!33'%-,!-4
54 /!3-/4*-/7,5&/54
0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"-#)(
)/,/#0N
9/524/0'
◦ /,!/-!*-/7+! %!+!/544&!
4/0'7&/%2!!37'4&9/52
0!230!4'6!
◦ /,!/-!7&/'3*-/7+! %!+!
/544&!4/0'54 '3%2!!37'4&
9/5
CN -!9/5&6!9/524/0'- 2%5,!-4J
/3/,!'-'4'+2!3!2&53'-%//%+!-
'*'0! '4/3!!7&4*'- 3/$3/52!3
,'%&4!6'++!J- '$4&!+',-!
$524&!2-22/7! /7-N
8F<:A<A:4,8F84E6;-BC<6
N0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"
-#)()/,/#0
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?@FM&C0ZDF
G8C-;8,8F84E6;*EB68FF <A7<A:
BHE68F
90!3/$3/52!3X!0!- '-%/-7&44&!
2!3!2&33'%-,!-43*3$/2J9/5/5+ /-3' !2
4&!$/++/7'-%*'- 3/2490!3/$3/52!3I
H 'C'+,#&*")%$(I
&!3!2!490'++93!!-34&!,/34
2! '+!/$++ !,'3/52!3N&!9
,'%&4!'-4&!$/2,/$//*3J24'+!3J
! '4! /2,5+4'0246/+5,!3J/2/-+'-!
0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"-#)(
)/,/#0N
2!3/52!3N
H &%')(:')"(:$%%!('%#
'"$%$C#(%*'(9&!3!
2!/$4!-&!+0$5+$/26!292!!-4!6!-43
7&'&&6!-/49!4& 4',!!-/5%&4/!
72'44!-/54'-0!!2Z2!6'!7! $/2,43N
&!9-!-!7300!23J,%:'-!3J
+/%3J0/05+2//*3J/20/+'9 /5,!-43N
H %')&('%#&'%"(%'
'",()(9&!3!2!/$4!-3&/24
2!0/243'-05+'4'/-34&402!3!-4$43
24&!24&-+/-%Z$/2,-+93!3N&!92!
34'++/-3' !2! 2! '+!J- 535++9&6!
9+'-!/22!442'54! 4/-,!
'- '6' 5+N
H $C'+$%'&('%#
*$!$%,$(%*'(9&'+!4&!3!2!6!29
&!+0$5+'-' !-4'$9'-%4/0'3/2;- '-%
0/3'4'/-34*!-/-4/0'3J4&!92!535++9
-/4+!2+9442'54! 4/-54&/2N&!9
,'%&4+3/!4//6%5!/2!3/
024'3-+34/!-/42!+'+!N
/24&2!,!,!2'-%I-/4++3/52!32!72'44!-
N0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"
-#)()/,/#0
7/2 3N/5,'%&4!+!4/;- 5 '//26'35+
3/52!34&42!)53432! '+!- /,0!++'-%N
#78AG<9L<A:BHE68F9BE,8F84E6;
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?@FM&C0ZDG
0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"-#)(
)/,/#0N
H$8+!-$$D$C -C6 $DD"
KHH/4,H-$6KC $D6,$H-$C
-!9/5&6!4&!3/52!3J9/5-!! 4/
4!%/2':!- 3/244&!,'-4/---/44!
'+'/%20&9N&'37'+++3/&!+09/5!6+54!4&!
3/52!3- 2!4&'-*&/79/5,'%&453!4&!,'-
4&!!339N&!02/!333&/5+ &00!-024+9
!$/2!9/53424 2$4'-%4&!!339J- 024+9
52'-%39/52!72'4!- 2!6'3!3!4'/-3/$4&!
!339N- !$/2!9/5 /-94&'-%!+3!J2!,'-
9/523!+$/$9/522%5,!-4X7&4'3'44&49/5
2!+','-%'-4&'3!339O2'4!4&'3/54/-
3!024!0'!!/$00!2J- &6!4&4&- 93
9/5/++4!9/523/52!3N
H &3/52!3&/5+ !;234!-4!2! '-4&!
$/2,/$'44'/-J35&3/2N
/++/74&!'44'/-/-6!-4'/-,!-4'/-!
'-4&!!33902/,04N
H &!'44'/-3&/5+ !$/++/7! 9
/50+!/$2'!$V?>>Y@>>7/2 3W
02%20&335,,2':'-%4&!,'-' !3
24'5+4! '-4&!3/52!N/5 /-/4&6!
N0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"
-#)()/,/#0
4/!!8&534'6!J- '-$49/52
35,,293&/5+ !'-+'-!7'4&9/52/7-
2%5,!-4N
H &!;-+024/$4&!--/44!
'+'/%20&93&/5+ !$!73!-4!-!3
!80+'-'-%7&94&'33/52!'3',0/24-4$/2
9/522%5,!-4J- 9/57'++!53'-%'4'-
4&!00!2V4&'-**%2/5- 6' !-!
2%5,!-4!4&/ J/2WN
382$446HH$#
/2/6,C8-O$4HCO9&C63
44/22DB6M
C,K3$4HD6C1!K/#$
H6C/H/4,4#42OP/4,
$NHD/4622$,$:
/2!9J29N[529'-%!96' !-!I
4&!/'+/- !47!!-/%3-
!/0+!N\T!7U
/52-+/$
2&!/+/%'+'!-!
J6/+NAAJ-/N@J!N
0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"-#)(
)/,/#0N
@>>DJ00N?CFY?ECNJ /'I&4403IRR /'N/2%R
?>N?>?DR)N)3N@>>CN>EN>>GN
-4&'324'+!J/2!9 /5,!-434&!
7' !302! &5,-024'!/$529'-%
/,!34'4! /%3- 15!34'/-37&4
4&'3024'!-2!6!+/542!+4'/-3&'03
!47!!-4&!47/N!2%5!34&4 /%
52'+3&6!!!-,/2!$2!15!-4- ,/2!
/-3'34!-44&-52'+3/$/4&!2490!3/$
-',+3J35%%!34'-%4&4&5,-3&6!
'-6!34! /%37'4&30'2'45+- 0!23/-+
' !-4'4'!3N/2!9+3/ !,/-3424!34&4
4&!345 9/$ /%52'+3-&!+03&/+23
4/,/2!524!+9 4!4&! /,!34'4'/-
/$ /%3Q4&53J&!&++!-%!33&/+237&/
2!+93/+!+9/-%!-!4' 4'-4&!'2 4'-%
/$ /,!34'4'/-4//-3' !2,/2!$5++9
4&!',0/24-!/$2&!/+/%'+;- 3N/
3500/24&'32%5,!-43J/2!902/6' !3
!4'+! 4/-4&!$2!15!-9J%!/%20&'
- &'34/2'+ '342'54'/-J37!++3
,/ !3/$ /%52'+3- /,02!34&!
/-+53'/-3&! 273$2/,4&'3 44/
N0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"
-#)()/,/#0
4&/3!$/5- 93&/+23&'03! /-
%!-!4' 4N!'3+3/7!++Z*-/7-
-4&2/0/+/%93&/+2- &N- ' 4!
44&!-'6!23'49/$9/,'-%N&'324'+!
'353!$5+4/+'4!2452!2!6'!7/-4&!
/,!34'4'/-/$ /%3!53!'4
0!2353'6!+93&/734&!',0/24-!/$
53'-%52'+ 4'- 4'-% /%
/,!34'4'/-- !80+'-3&/753!/$
4&'3 4/5+ &-%!33!33,!-43/$
7&!- /,!34'4'/-/522! N7'+++'*!+9
53!'44/ !6!+/0,9;234/ 902%20&N
Works Cited
-4J&!2'!'/4N
2%5,!-44'/--
0,#-#(!-)'%(,!.'(-0#-",,"-#)(
)/,/#0N
I*;
!
$,-4M$$4$O
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&!&04!2J345 !-437'++!+!4/
H -+9:!- 72'4!2%5,!-433! /-343'3
H !<!4/-0/33'+!2!6'3'/-3$/24&!'2
!,'2!3!2&00!234/72 -
4'/-+!0+-/20/+'9$/24&!05+'J
72'44!-4/024'5+20!23/-
-#-"),2")0-)(&23(0,#- ),# ,(-
-N
HD/D-$6CO!$(4/H/64
!/&3! #/,* /!!(4,/ *!+&+$]1(! 01+ M^,+!+;
'* ,+!+ '*1; &0 %!)-#2) 1,,) 1, 20! 4%!+ /! &+$M
&+3!+1&+$M/&+01,/*&+$M-)++&+$M+ /!3&0&+$,2/4/&1&+$
1%1)),40/%!1,/,//%!1,/&&+1,0601!*1&))6012 61%!
3&))!/$2*!+10!#,/!1%!6,+0& !/%,41,!01 3+!
1%!&/& !0Q,1%!6+!! 1,!01)&0%1%!#10,#1%!0&121&,+R
, 1%!6 +!! 1, !:+! 1!/*0 1, !+02/! 1%!/! &0 $/!!*!+1
+ 2+ !/01+ &+$R , 1%!6+!! 1, ,+3&+!,1%!/0 1%1
-/,)!*!3!+!5&010R/ ,1%!6 +!! 1,,+3&+! ,1%!/01,
1(!1&,+R10&0 1%!,/6&00601!*1&-/,!001%1)),40
6,21,*,3!1%/,2$%0!/&!0,#.2!01&,+01,%!)-6,2:$2/!
,21 4%!/! 1, 01/1 + /$2*!+1M %,4 1, /! + /$2*!+1M
%,41,4/&1!+/$2*!+1M%,41,/!0!/%+/$2*!+1M+
%,41,!+ +/$2*!+1Q/&01,1)!/!1! 1%&01,,)M+ &140
)1!//!:+! 6,*+/%!1,/&&+0)&(!&!/,+ 2&+1&)&+
X/,4)!6+ 4%!!YQ
N-#-"),2")0-)(&23(0,#- ),
# ,(--
-;8F84A6<8AGE;8GBE<6<4AF78E<I874
F8GB9DH8FG<BAFBEFG4F8FG;4G64A
;8?CLBHE8VA8LBHEHA78EFG4A7<A:
B94A<FFH82BH4E8@84AGGBFG4EG4G
FG4F<F4A7@BI87BJAGBFG4F<F
?N %$ )*'?)V343'334/&3,/3WI'
3/,!4&'-%&00!-O34&!2!02/+!,O
@N /$)%$V343'3&/2/3WI&4'34&!
02/+!,O&4*'- /$02/+!,'3'4O
AN *").V343'30/'/4!3WI/73!2'/53'34&!
02/+!,O&/,,'%&4'4$$!4O
BN %".V343'3,!4+!03'3WI&/5+ 4'/-!
4*!-O&43&/5+ ! /-!4/3/+6!4&!
02/+!,O
,%,4 ,!0&14,/(#,/&+3!+1&,+R+1%&0!5*-)!M/,4)!6
+ 4%!! 0%,4 %,4 1%! #,2/\.2!01&,+ 0!/&!0 + %!)-
0,*!,+!:$2/!,214%!1%!/1,,+3&10,*!,+!,#/&*!Q
-#-"),2")0-)(&23(0,#- ),# ,(-
-N
#9FB@8BA8<F466HF87B9G;89GLBH
64AHA78EFG4A7G;8<FFH85L@BI<A:
G;EBH:;G;8FG4F8F
?N ' 3&!4*!4&!/4OI$!6!29/-!%2!!3
4&43&!4//*4&!/4J9/5,/6!4/4&!-!84
+!6!+N
@N 3'44&!$4OV&!,'%&4&6!/22/7! '4NWI$
!6!29/-!%2!!34&4'4-! !;-! 3
4&!$4J9/5,/6!4/4&!-!84+!6!+N
AN 3'42'%&4/272/-%OV9!'473)534';!
$/23/,!2!3/-NWI$!6!29/-!%2!!34&4'4
7372/-%J9/5,/6!4/4&!-!84+!6!+N
BN &/5+ 3&!!22!34! - 42'! $/24&!4&!$4O
%!/!/!!3!+*,/!.2!01&,+06,2+20!1!%-,&+1Q!/!
&0%!)-#2))&01#/,*1%!2/ 2!L
"2
K & 0,*!1%&+$%--!+R
K %1/!1%!#10R
N-#-"),2")0-)(&23(0,#- ),
# ,(--
K 01%!/!-/,)!*T&002!R
K ,4 & &1!$&++ 4%1/!&1020!0R
K %1%+$! 1,/!1!1%!-/,)!*T&002!R
K +&1!%+$! R
1 *6 )0, ! 20!#2) 1, 0( /&1&) .2!01&,+0 ,# 6,2/ ,4+
/!0!/%+ ,+)20&,+0L
K %!/! & 4!,1&+,2/ 1+ /!1%!0!0,2/!0
/!)&)!R
K ,4 ,4!(+,41%!6`/!/!)&)!R
$:,'2'-,
K %1&01%!+12/!,#1%!-/,)!*T&002!R
K %1!51)6&01%!-/,)!*T&002!R
K %1(&+ ,#-/,)!*T&002!&0&1R
K ,4%1)/$!/)00,#1%&+$0,/!3!+10 ,!0&1!),+$R
K %1/!&10-/10M+ %,4/!1%!6/!)1! R
1 *6 )0, ! 20!#2) 1, 0( /&1&) .2!01&,+0 ,# 6,2/ ,4+
/!0!/%+ ,+)20&,+0L
K %,T4%1&0&+;2!+&+$,2/ !:+&1&,+,#1%&0-/,)!*T
&002!R
K ,4T4%6/!1%!0!0,2/!0T!)&!#0&+;2!+&+$,2/
!:+&1&,+R
-#-"),2")0-)(&23(0,#- ),# ,(-
-N
3 *'27
K 0&1$,, 1%&+$,/ 1%&+$R
K ,40!/&,20&01%!-/,)!*T&002!R
K %,**&$%1&18!1X01(!%,) !/0YR
K %1%--!+0! ,+`1 ,+61%&+$R
K %1/!1%!,010,#0,)3&+$1%!-/,)!*T&002!R
1 *6 )0, ! 20!#2) 1, 0( /&1&) .2!01&,+0 ,# 6,2/ ,4+
/!0!/%+ ,+)20&,+0L
K %,T4%1&0&+;2!+&+$,2/ !1!/*&+1&,+,#1%!
0!/&,20+!00,#1%&0-/,)!*T&002!R
K ,4T4%6/!1%!0!0,2/!0T!)&!#0&+;2!+&+$,2/
!1!/*&+1&,+R
-*'"7
K %,2) 1&,+!1(!+R
K %,0%,2) !&+3,)3! &+%!)-&+$1,0,)3!1%!
-/,)!*T /!001%!&002!R
K %10%,2) ! ,+!,211%&0-/,)!*R
K %1+!! 01,%--!+1,0,)3!1%&0-/,)!*T /!001%&0
&002!R
1 *6 )0, ! 20!#2) 1, 0( /&1&) .2!01&,+0 ,# 6,2/ ,4+
/!0!/%+ ,+)20&,+0L
N-#-"),2")0-)(&23(0,#- ),
# ,(--
K %,T4%1&0&+;2!+&+$,2/ !1!/*&+1&,+,#4%11,
,,211%&0-/,)!*T&002!R
K ,4T4%6/!1%!0!0,2/!0T!)&!#0&+;2!+&+$,2/
!1!/*&+1&,+R
6MH6D$H
,/4/&1&+$)00!0M010&01%!,/6+!20! 1,02--,/1*+6
-/,!00!0Q
&/01M &1 + %!)- 6,2 * * ,'*!$ +!,-,!'&M
!!-!+&+$6,2/2+ !/01+ &+$,#/ 1*'-(+%1!+*
'&&!++-Q3!6,2!3!/4,+ !/! 4%6$2+,+1/,)&0%,1)6
!1! + +!3!//!0,)3! R10&0%!,/6+%!)-1,!5-)&+
4%6Q , 20! &1M4!4,2) *,3! 1%/,2$% 1%! .2!01&,+0 4&1%
&8!/!+13&!4-,&+101,0!!! &0$/!!11%!-,&+1,##1M
!:+&1&,+M3)2!M,/-,)&6Q
!,+ M4%!+!$&++&+$/!0!/%-/,'!1M&1+!20!
1,4&, .!$$*-%&,+Q61%&0M4!*!+1%110&0
%!,/6+%!)-202+ !/01+ ))1%! &8!/!+1 !1!011%!
#,2/ )!3!)0 ,# 010&0Q (&+$ 1%! $2+ ,+1/,) !5*-)! $&+Q
+! 4! (+,4 )) 1%! &8!/!+1 !1!0M 4! + %,,0! 1,
/!0!/% + /$2! 1 1%! -,&+1 ,# ,+1!+1&,+ ,/ 1 -)!
,# $/!!*!+1Q ! ,+ + 4! 4&)) /!( 1%&0 ,4+ 4&1%
!5*-)!0Q
$#/4,-$H6C/ 2/HKH/64!
-#-"),2")0-)(&23(0,#- ),# ,(-
-N
6MH6D$HD/D-$6COH6
4#$CDH4#-O$/D,C$$64
06CDDK$D
+!,#1%!*,/!20!#2)0-!10,#010&01%!,/6&01%1&1+
%!)- 20 2&) !*-1%6 6 %!)-&+$ 20 1, 2+ !/01+ 4%6
0,*!,+!!)0!*&$%1 &0$/!!4&1%20,21!/1&+&002!0Q0
4!))M&1%!)-0201,2+ !/01+ 4%!/!!51)61%1 &0$/!!*!+1
!5&010M0,4!+,2+1!/1%!/$2*!+1&+,2/4/&1&+$,/,*!
1,,*-/,*&0!Q!1200%,46,2%,41%14,/(0L
2$. ( ,. .# -.- -!),&$'.
#("
,L,!0)&*1!%+$!!5&01R
4&!,!'&L + )&*1! %+$! ! )00&:! 0
/&0&0R
$-L0&1 1%&+$R0&120! 6%2*+0R
'$!1L%10%,2) ! ,+!,21)&*1!%+$!R
2$.$%$8 , (.*)-$.$)(-)(.# $--/
(- 1# , .# 3)().&$"(
1+!%!)-#2)1,:+ 1!511%1-/,3& !06,24&1%1%,0!
3&!4-,&+10Q1%1%&03& !,V!4WX3&!4 1&*!&0@L?@Y
+ 1%!++04!/1%!.2!01&,+#,/!%010&0#/,*1%!-,&+1,#
3&!4,#1%!/%!1,/0L/!1%2*!/$+ 1&!3)&%Q
N-#-"),2")0-)(&23(0,#- ),
# ,(--
#$'!'
,+!+ -+,!'& ,'*:*,
-%*
,'*:
,!.$!
, ,!0)&*1!
%+$!!5&01R !0 !0
4&!,!'&
+)&*1!
%+$!!
)00&:! 0
/&0&0R
!0 ,2101%1&1
&0/&0&0
$-
0)&*1!
%+$!
20! 6
%2*+0R
!0
,211%1&1
&020! 6
%2*+0
'$!1
%10%,2)
! ,+!
,21)&*1!
%+$!R
!+!! 1,
&+#,/*+
! 21!*!/&
*!/&+0 ,
!+,2$%S4!
+!! 1,#,20
,+! 21&+$
%&++
+ &Q
. * : .)(.# !)&&)1$("+/ -.$)(-
K %!/!/!1%!14,/%!1,/0+,1&+010&0R
K %!/! ,6,20!!1%! &0$/!!*!+1,2/R
. * ().$ .# , $-$-", ' (.
)(.# 9($.$)(.# 0&/ &-).#
/- (.# *)&$3
10&0 1%!,/6 02$$!010 1%1 0 /!0!/%!/ + /%!1,/M 6,2
!$&+ 1 1%! :/01 )!3!) ,# &0$/!!*!+1M ,/ 1%! !/)&!01 -)!
-#-"),2")0-)(&23(0,#- ),# ,(-
-N
4%!/!1%!/!&0010&0*&0*1%Q!/!M&1&01%1&1`0/&0&0Q
#6,2++,1$!16,2//! !/1,$/!!1%1&1`0/&0&0M6,2`))
+!3!/!)!1,,+3&+!1%!*,#-,)&6Q,4!3!/M1%!/!)0,
0!!*01,!0,*! ,211%11%!&002!&0/&0&0+ 1%1&1+
!,+1/,))! 6%2*+0Q+6,#1%!0!/!04,2) !$,,
-)!1,!$&+6,2//!0!/%,+1%!&002!Q
+1%!#,)),4&+$1&3&16M1/61,& !+1=%! &8!/!+1)&*0
* !1 &8!/!+1010!0 !-!+ &+$,+/%!1,/`0/$2*!+11&3!
01+!Q
G4F<F5BEG<BA
6MO6KHCO/H!
'!74&'36' !//54/24'/-2'%&43T!7U
V6'!74',!'3GIBGWN/7 /!3343'34&!/29&!+053
5- !234- 7&9 !,/243- 2!05+'-3
'3%2!!/-/24'/-2'%&43O
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
N-#-"),2")0-)(&23(0,#- ),
# ,(--
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?A>M&C0ZE>
%!#,)),4&+$1&3&16,8!/06,2+,--,/12+&161,$!+!/1!
,+1!+1 #,/ 6,2/ ,4+ /!0!/%! /$2*!+1Q %&0 1)! &0
%!2/&01&M ,/ + &+3!+1&,+ 1,,)M !0&$+! 1, %!)- 6,2 1%&+(
,21))1%!-,00&)!460&+1,1,-&6,24+11,!5-),/!Q
(BJ2BH-EL#G
2!4!343'34+!7'4&4&'3 /7-+/ +!
4!,0+4!T!7U$/29/52/7-2!3!2&4/0'/2
15!34'/-N
-#-"),2")0-)(&23(0,#- ),# ,(-
-N
HD/D-$6CO4$286KC/H$
6KC-$D/DHH$3$4H
),+$4&1%20&+$010&01,2+ !/01+ 1%!3&))!/$2*!+10M
6,2 + )0, 20! 010&0 1%!,/6 1, !& ! 4%!/! 6,2 4+1 1,
!01)&0%6,2//$2*!+1L,6,24+11,/$2!-,)&6R)2!R
!:+&1&,+R1R
%! 010&0 .2!01&,+0 ,#1!+ $2& ! 20 &+ 1%&0 1%&+(&+$Q ,/
!5*-)!M&#*/!0!/%&+$)&*1!%+$!M+,1!1%1-!,-)!
,#1!+ &0$/!!13)2!L0)&*1!%+$!-/,)!*1%1+!! 0
1,!0,)3! R#%,,0!1,/$2!1-,)&6M*&$%1),0!1%!
/! !/04%,01&)) &0$/!!1%1&1`0!3!+-/,)!*Q,4,2)
4/&1!1%!0&0011!*!+11%1)&*! &1400!/&,20&002!Q
#*/!0!/%&+$,/1&,+/&$%10M+,1!1%1+!+
)7 &0$/!!1*,01,#1%!010!0M21&1!$&+01 !:+&1&,+M
4%!/!)7 !:+!0,/1&,+0+!!00/6%!)1%/!+ +!
!:+!0,/1&,+0:++&),/01/1!$&%,&!Q%&01!))0*!M
01%!/%!1,/M1%1+!! 1,01/1*6/!0!/%+ /$2*!+10
!:+&+$,/1&,+*,/!)!/)6M+ *61%!0&0011!*!+14,2)
+!! 1,*(!)&*,214%1,/1&,+&0Q
HD/D-$6CO4#-$H6C/ 2
36#/3$4H
,4 ,!0010&01%!,/6/!)1!1,1%!, 6R#4!,+0& !/1%!
+! + )7 !1! ,3!/ ,/1&,+M 4! 0%,2) /!;!1 ,+
N-#-"),2")0-)(&23(0,#- ),
# ,(--
1%!&/ -,0&1&,+)&16Q 0 14, &0\$!+ !/! *!+M 4%1 &0 1%!&/
/!)1&,+0%&- 4&1% ,/1&,+ /&$%10 + /!-/, 21&3! /&$%10R
&$%11%!&/-,0&1&,+,#-/&3&)!$!/!*,3!1%!*0!)3!0#/,*1%!
/!)&16,#1%&0 !1!+ /$2*!+1R,4*&$%1-!/0,+4%,
% +,/1&,+/$2!#/,* &8!/!+1-,0&1&,+M,/ &8!/!+1
010&0R,4*&$%1-!/0,+4%,% +,/1&,+1,03!%!/
)&#!/! + &+1!/-/!11%!&//$2*!+10 &8!/!+1)6R2/)&3!
!5-!/&!+!8!101%!010&04!*64+11,/$2!#/,*M+
%,44!*,3!1%/,2$%1%!010!0&+,2//$2*!+10Q, ,+,1
+!$)!16,2/,4+,++!1&,+1,4%16,2/! + 4/&1!0
1%14&)))0,8!1010&0Q
Works Cited
2/7+!9J&2/-J- !27&!!N
-'!-4
2&!4/2'3$/2/-4!,0/229345 !-43
N/34/-I
++9-- /-J?GGGN
-#-"),2")0-)(&23(0,#- ),# ,(-
-N
IG;
??
/4K44#K4O4/-HH -CO
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/57'++!+!4/
H 3!4&!;2340!23/-'- !,'72'4'-%4/
'34'-%5'3&9/520!230!4'6!$2/,/4&!23J
/,,5-'4!9/5230!';0/3'4'/-+'49J-
5- !23/2!9/525-'15!/-42'54'/-
H /,,5-'4!4&!' !/$72'4'-%$2/,4&!
024'5+2' !-4'490/3'4'/-39/5/509
N")0-)'#(-#(2).#(2).,,,"0,#-#(!
&/01 -!/0,+ %0 + &*-,/1+1 -)!Z+ &//!-)!)!
-)!Z&+ 1!510 1%1 /!-,/1 /!0!/% + !+$$! 0%,)/0%&-Q
%!/!/!1%/!!/!0,+04%61%&0&00,L
!($"2'4'27 ,#,2$%0'27
/ &1&,+))6M1%!/!0,+&+$#,/3,& &+$20!,#1%!:/01-!/0,+
&+ !*&,+1!510&01%1 !*&4/&1&+$0%,2) !0!
,+,'!1&3!#1&+01! ,#-!/0,+),-&+&,+Q04!%3!0!!+M
%,4!3!/M/$2*!+11&3!4/&1&+$&0+,11%!)(,#,-&+&,+M21
/1%!/1%!/!#2)-/!0!+11&,+,#+,-&+&,+1%1&002--,/1!
6!3& !+!+ ),$&)/!0,+&+$Q2/1%!/M!3!/6/$2*!+1&0
&+;2!+! 61%!-,0&1&,+)&16,#&10-/1&2)/21%,/M+ 1,
-/!1!+ ,1%!/4&0!&0 &0%,+!01Q
%20M4%!+6,2/!1(&+$01+!,++&002!M:/01-!/0,+
*(!0 0!+0!Q !:+&+$ 6,2/ -!/0-!1&3! $&3!0 6,2/ /! !/
,+1!51#,/6,2/01+!Q,+0& !/1%!0!14,-,0&1&,+0L
?Q ]03,)2+1!!/1&)&+$2)-/!0%,,)M+0!!1%1
,1%)+$2$!&**!/0&,++ &+ &3& 2)&7! )+$2$!
&+01/21&,+%3!!+!:10M^30
@Q ]0-/&+&-)1+!)!*!+1/60%,,)4&1%)&*&1!
2 $!1M4,2) /$2!1%1)+$2$!&**!/0&,+*(!0
1%!*,010!+0!Q^
&1%,211%!]4%,)!-&12/!^1%11%!011!*!+1,#-!/0-!1&3!
&*-)&!0M6,2*&$%1002*!1%11%!14,)&*0 &0$/!!Q%!
")0-)'#(-#(2).#(2).,,,"0,#-#(!N
021)!16,#1%!02'!1Z4%,1%!4/&1!/&0Z)!106,20!!.2&1!
&1,214%61%!)&*&0!&+$* !Q
'12',%3'1&-30$01.$"2'4$
0-+2&$01
%!20!,#:/01-!/0,+)0,)),406,21,/!#2))6 &01&+$2&0%
!14!!+6,2/-!/0-!1&3!+ 1%!-!/0-!1&3!0,#1%!0,2/!0
6,2/!20&+$Q!0!/%! /$2*!+104,/(6!+$$&+$4&1%
3/&!16,# &8!/!+10,2/!0M+ 1%!*,/!]3,&!0^6,2 1,
1%!,+3!/01&,+M1%!*,/!,+#20&+$&1$!10Q
,2 *201 0!-/1! 6,2/ ,4+ &+1!/-/!11&,+0 ,# 0%,)/0`
)&*0M1%!)&*01%!*0!)3!0M+ 6,2//$2*!+10,0+,11,
*&0/!-/!0!+1+6,#1%!*Q#6,2`3!'201-/-%/0! 0%,)/M
*(&+$ 6,2/ ,4+ )&* 4&1%,21 .2&1! )&1!/))6 )&*&+$ &1
*&$%1*(!1%!/! !/1%&+(1%11%!0%,)/0& &1Q,+0& !/
1%!0!14,0!+1!+!0L
?Q ]$018!1)QX@>>EY,+)2 !1%11%! !*+ #,/
-/1&)0&!+!4/&1&+$1%11%!)6-!/0,++
2+ !/01+ &0,+1%!/&0!Q211%!/!&0+!! #,/
)6-!,-)!1,&+/!0!1%!&/0&!+!)&1!/6M04!))Q^
@Q ]$018!1)QX@>>EY,+)2 !1%11%! !*+ #,/
-/1&)0&!+!1%11%!)6-!/0,++2+ !/01+ &0,+
1%!/&0!Q*&+1&+1%11%!/!&0+!! #,/)6-!,-)!1,
&+/!0!1%!&/0&!+!)&1!/6M04!))Q^
N")0-)'#(-#(2).#(2).,,,"0,#-#(!
%!0!,+ #,/*2)1&,+*(!0&1*2%)!/!/1%11%!]+!!
#,/)6-!,-)!1,&+/!0!1%!&/0&!+!)&1!/6^&0+,1-/1,#
$018`0)&*21/1%!/6,2/,4+ &01&+1&3!,+1/&21&,+Q
,#$01"-0$-30,'/3$
,2$04$,2'-,
&1&+$ 0%,)/0%&- ,+1!512)&7!0 + 01/!+$1%!+0 6,2/
/$2*!+1S6,24+11, !#!/1,]!5-!/10^#,/!3& !+!,#6,2/
)&*0 4%!+ 6,2 +Q 0 012 !+1M 6,2 *&$%1 #!!) )&(! +
,210& !/Z2+)!1,,**!+14&1%21%,/&16,+1%!,+!-10
6,2`/!/! &+$+ 4/&1&+$,21Q21,210& !/01120 ,!0+`1
,+)6 *!+ )( ,# !5-!/1&0!Q ,2/ ,4+M 4!))\ !:+!
3&!4-,&+1 *&$%1 0%! +!4 )&$%1 ,+ 1,-& 1%1 1%! !5-!/10
%3!+`1,+0& !/! X,/1%16,2/)00*1!0%3!+`1,+0& !/! M
,/1%16,2/-/,#!00,/%0+`1*!+1&,+! &+)00M,/!3!+M.2&1!
0&*-)6M 1%1 6,2 % +`1 1%,2$%1 ,# + 0, 6,2`/! !5&1!
,21YQ+1%10!M6,24+11,06M]%&0&0*&+!M&1`0+!4
46,#),,(&+$11%!&002!M+ `*-/,2 ,#&1Q^
%,0! (&+ 0 ,# )&*0 /! 202))6 06+1%!1& ,+!0Z6,2`3!
-21 &+#,/*1&,++ T,/ &+1!/-/!11&,+0 #/,* 0!3!/) 0,2/!0
1,$!1%!/M + 6,2`3! 12))6 $,1 0,*!1%&+$ 1, 06Q 3&+$
0,*!1%&+$+!41,06&+/!0!01%!!5&$!+6,#6,2//$2*!+1
&+1%!)/$!/M&+1!))!12)!5%+$!,#& !0Q0%,)/)6/! !/
0%,2) 4+11,-611!+1&,+M!20!4%16,206*6!
(!61,0,*!-277)!X2/!#,/+!/Y,/46,#1%&+(&+$,21
1%!1,-&X&+1!/-/!1&+$1*+YQ%1`01%!460%,)/04,/(
")0-)'#(-#(2).#(2).,,,"0,#-#(!N
1,$!1%!/1,#,/*)/$!, &!0,#(+,4)! $!L4!,**2+&1!
,21 ,2/ /!0!/% + & !0M + 4! 1/6 1, ,*&+! 1%!*
4%!+4!+Q
BAF<78E-;<FK4@C?8
$*$:D"%'#)*$$$
%*)%'$"+(%$:E
)*)%$(
16=1
@2023A928C52=
Z 2,3&/+23&'0490'++9' !-4';!3,!+/ 2,
34&! /,'--4-224'6!,/ !- *!9!+!,!-4
/$++95^3%+/+35!33N547&'+!,!+/ 2,'3
&24!2':! 9/6!2 27-$$!4- 0+/4JZ
2,3'-4&!+34 ! !&6!!/,!'-2!3'-%+9
'-6!34! '-!6!29 9024'!335&3+!-'-%J
//*'-%J- /,,54'-%N&!3!2
3!!,'-%+9/00/3! ,/ !3/$4&!,!+/ 2,4'-
4&!,5- -!N&'300!2-+93!34&!02/%2,,'-%
42!- '-/2 !24/4&!/2':!-!,!2%!-4,/ !/$
/2!-4!+!6'3'/-4&4++4&
+1%!/&1!1,!/+!),4M/!;!1,+2+`020!,#1%!:/01
-!/0,+&+1%! !*&!006!5!/-1! ,3!Q
0E<G8GB&84EA <EFG*8EFBA<A
6478@<60E<G<A:
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?A@M&C0ZE?
$(4/4,6D/H/642/HO
+!,#1%!460&+4%&%6,2+06+1%!0&7!1%!,3!& !0
&0 1, 1%&+( ,21 4%!/! 6,2 4/&1! #/,*Z6,2/ -,0&1&,+ &+
1%! 4,/) + + !*, &! &+ &3& 2)Q /&1&+$ &0 !!-)6
N")0-)'#(-#(2).#(2).,,,"0,#-#(!
-!/0,+)1M + 1%!1!511%16,24/&1!0%,2) /!;!16,2/
& !+1&160(+,4)! $!/!1,/Q+,1%!/4,/ 0M&10%,2) 0%,4
%,46,2/ 3/&,20& !+1&16-,0&1&,+0 X/!M$!+ !/M$!M )00M
1,+*!#!4Y&+1!/0!1&+1%!*(&+$,#6,2/-!/0-!1&3!0Q
1,-+ 1%&+(,21%,46,2%3!,*!61%!& !0#,/1%&0
/!0!/%00&$+*!+1S
K %!/! & 6,2$!11%!/!0!/%1,-&#/,*R
K %1&0!0 ,6,2/&+$1,1%!1,-&R%1&0T/!1%!
0,2/!X0Y,#1%!0!&0!0R
K %1&0!0 ,6,2/&+$1,1%!1,# !*&
/!0!/%R%1&0T/!1%!0,2/!X0Y,#1%!0!&0!0R
K %1-/&3&)!$!0+ )&*&10 ,6,2%3!4%!+&1,*!01,
!00&+$&+#,/*1&,+R
K %1-/&3&)!$!0+ )&*&10 ,6,2%3!4%!+&1,*!01,
2+ !/01+ &+$,+!-1002%0&+.2&/6M/!0!/%
4/&1&+$M+ /!3&0&,+R
-OD 146M2$#,/4,
6D/H/642/HO386CH4H>
K 10%,401%!/! !/4%!/!6,2M1%!/!0!/%!/M/!
,*&+$#/,*Q1*&$%1%!)-!5-)&++,1'2016,2/
/! &&)&16+ &+1!/!01&+1%!1,-&M21)0,1%!
-,1!+1&)&*-11%!1,-&%0,+-/1&2)/
,**2+&1&!01,4%&%6,2!),+$Q
K ,&+$0,(+,4)! $!01%!#))6,#1%!2+&3!/0)
")0-)'#(-#(2).#(2).,,,"0,#-#(!N
02'!1,/]M^+ !*,+01/1!01%1!3!/61!51&0/,,1!
&+-/1&2)/0,&,\%&01,/&),+1!51M&+)2 &+$1%,0!
1%1%3!1%!&+3&0&)!,/],'!1&3!^]^Q*-)&&1&+1%!
],'!1&3!^&02/,!+1/&-,0&1&,+1%1%0
1/ &1&,+))6+,1#!)11%!+!! 1,& !+1&10!)#00-!&:
+ -/1&2)/Q
K 5-/!00&+$6,2/-,0&1&,+)&16&+1%!1!51%!)-0,1%!/
/!0!/%!/01%&+(,21%,41%!6*&$%1--)66,2/
/!0!/%1,1%!&/,+1!51Q
K !&+$*&+ #2),#6,2/&+0& !/011204&1%&+-/1&2)/
,**2+&1&!0%!)-06,2!4/!,#1%!)&*&11&,+0+
-/&3&)!$!01%1,*!4&1%02%01120Q%&0*(!06,2/
/!0!/%*,/!/&$,/,20Q
K ,24/&1!#/,*6,2/& !+1&16-,0&1&,+0Q(+,4)! $&+$
1%!**(!06,2/4/&1&+$*,/!/! &)!+ 1/+0-/!+1Q
+1%!/&1!1,!/+!),4M/&+01,/*460&+4%&% 6,2
*&$%1 /4,+6,2/-!/0,+)!5-!/&!+!#,//!0!/%!006Q
N")0-)'#(-#(2).#(2).,,,"0,#-#(!
0E<G8GB&84EA*E8F8AG<A:2BHEF8?9<A
,8F84E6;FF4LF
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?A@M&C0ZE@
Attributions
[!! /5/9]^I&9'234!23/-3
,0/24-4'-/++!%!2'4'-%\'-
2'4'-%0!3I
! '-%3/-2'4'-%3J
/+5,!?J&2+!9/7!
- 6!+!,+'-3*9J
442'54'/-/-/,,!2'+Z&2!+'*!AN>
")0-)'#(-#(2).#(2).,,,"0,#-#(!N
IF;
!
/4$DD2$C$$
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/53&/5+ !+!4/
H &//3!3!2&4!2,34&47'++2'-%50
2!+!6-4'-$/2,4'/-/-9/524/0'
H !;-!9/523!2&4!2,33! /-4&!
2!3!2&9/5^6!$/5-
#(#(!).,"))#(!2).,,"-,'N
4,K,$/D8$CD642
!,-)! &+ &8!/!+1 &0&-)&+!0 %3! 1%!&/ ,4+ '/$,+ +
1!/*&+,),$6#,/ &0200&+$1%!&/:!) + 1%!& !01%!64,/(
4&1%Q,2*201(+,4%,41, !, !1%&0)+$2$!&+,/ !/1,
!)!1,1)(1,!5-!/10M2+ !/01+ 4%11%!6/!4/&1&+$M
+ *(!1%!*1!/&))!/#,/1%!+,+\0-!&)&012 &!+!1%1
4&))0!!1%!:+)*!00$!Q
%!)+$2$!,#1,-&&0)0,1%!(!61%1,-!+01%! ,,/1,
!8!1&3!0!/%&+$Q+$2$!&01%!!00, !1%/,2$%4%&%
#,/*),))!1&,+0,#&+#,/*1&,+&+)&//&!0+ 10!0/!
&+ !5! + ,/$+&7! Q + &1&,+M 1!/*&+,),$6 0%
 ,3!/
1&*!4&1%1%!&+1/, 21&,+,#+!44,/ 0+ 00,*!)+$2$!
#))0,21,#20!+ &0/!-)! Q
,)&1&)-!/0-!1&3!0)0,-)6/,)!&+ !, &+$)+$2$!Q
, 6,#41!/&+1%!& )!01&0))! 1%!!/0&+2)#
60,*!+ 1%!/&+2)#6,1%!/0M !-!+ &+$,+1%!&/
-,)&1&)-!/0-!1&3!Q%&+(,211%! &8!/!+1,++,11&,+0
,#1%!1!/*0]-/,\%,&!^,/]-/,\,/1&,+S^]/&$%1\1,\)&#!^,/
]+1&\%,&!Q^ ,2 *201 2+ !/01+ %,4 1%! 2 &!+! 4&))
/!1 1, )+$2$! + 1!/*&+,),$6 %,&!0Q 2/&+$ 6,2/
&+#,/*1&,+0!/%M6,2*20120!--/,-/&1!1!/*&+,),$61,
),1!/!)!3+1&+#,/*1&,+Q
N #(#(!).,"))#(!2).,,"-,'
/4#/4,C$2$L4HD6KC $D
#$8$4#D64O6KC1$OM6C#D
4,,#1%!*,01&*-,/1+1#1,/01%1&+;2!+!4%!1%!/4!
:+ 20!#2)+ /! &)!0,2/!0/!L
?Q 4%!/!4!0!/%X#,/!5*-)!M,,$)!M,,$)!%,)/M
,22!M&(,(M&//6!/%M0-!&)&7! )&//6
10!M,/0-!&:4!0&1!YZ4%&%6,2*6%3!
)!/+! ,21&+1%!%-1!/,+%!!0!/%/,!00Y
@Q / ,/'*+/-+,'+*
%! #,)),4&+$ 3& !, X)0, &+)2 ! &+ 1%! %-1!/ ,+ %!
!0!/%/,!00Y$&3!00,*!0%,/11&-0#,/& !+1&+$1%,0!
4,/ 0 1%1 4! 20! &+ ,2/ ,+)&+! 0!/%!0M )0, (+,4+ 0
#1/'*+X3&!41&*!&0@L@AYL
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?ADM/!,! Z@
#);?F9F31),- ),-,"#(!B..(#0,-#.3
#,,#-3..(#0,-#.3#,,#-)//"((&
#(#(!).,"))#(!2).,,"-,'N
$D$C - 4-$28O6K(4#
1$OM6C#D
,/!5*-)!M)!1`0066,2`/!&+1!/!01! &+!5-),/&+$1%!-/&36
&*-)&1&,+0 ,# -/!+10 0%/&+$ 1%!&/ (& 0` -%,1,0 +
&+#,/*1&,+ ,+ 0,&) *! &Q !1`0 *- ,21 0,*! -,1!+1&)
0!/% 1!/*0M ,/ (!64,/ 0M 1%1 4! ,2) 20! 1, :+
&+#,/*1&,+,+1%&0Q!1`0*(!2)!*-1,$!1%!/Z`))
01/1,+!,+*61,-&M+ 6,201/1,+!,+6,2/0X,+)&+!,/,+
--!/YL
#!F;?F9F!#((#(!-) ,# /&'*),'#('*
)/.*,(.-*)-.#(!)/.."#,%#-J'!-,#*.#)(K
,4M1%!0!/!'2011%!4,/ 01%,2$%1,#,81%!1,-,#*6
%! Q,4 ,*(!*6(!64,/ 0*,/!0-!&:R/61%!0!
01/1!$&!0L
N #(#(!).,"))#(!2).,,"-,'
?Q '''$+* =%1&*-,/1+14,/ 0,*!2-
#/!.2!+1)6,+1%&01,-&R,/!5*-)!M)!/+1%11%!/!`0
4,/ #,/-/!+100%/&+$&+#,/*1&,+,211%!&/(& 0
,+0,&)*! &L-",(.#(!F
@Q !&&&1$'(!'*!#!(!&,*1'&1'-*
,'(!=%11!/*0 ,!0&120!1,1)(,216,2/1,-&R
%1+//,4!/021,-&0,/!5*-)!0 ,!0&1/&+$2-R
1%,0!4,/ 01,6,2/*-M$/,2-! 4&1%0&*&)/
,+!-10Q
AQ ''#-(+1&'&1%+'*1'-*,'(!=,/!5*-)!M
06+,+6*#,/-)#&'#,2) !-)#&(.1),%-Q
,+0& !/4%11!/*0 &8!/!+1$/,2-0,#-!,-)!*&$%1
20!#,/6,2/1,-&M1,,Q
BQ !&#'+'%' ', ,*%+1'-
$*1 .=,/!5*-)!M0,*!!5*-)!0,#0,&)
*! &0!/3&!04%!/!]0%/!+1&+$^%--!+0/!
+01$/*M&(,(M!,,(M+ ,26&+X4%1
&(,(&0/+ ! &+%&+YQ
CQ '+* /!, , /'*+1'-$*1 .!&
''$ '$*'*!**1,+= ,', *
*$,,*%+((*!&*$,+'-*+E,!,$+;
#1/'*+;'*+-", !&+>,/!5*-)!M#/,*
1%&0/1&)!+ ,1%!/0$,1-& O*,-(..#)(M)(&#(
#(.#.#-M#(7/(,',%.#(!M+ '),&..#./-Q
06,20!/%/,2+ M/! &+$0,*!($/,2+ 0,2/!0)&(!
!+6),-! &!+1/&!0M+ $!11&+$0!+0!,#4%10%,)/01)(
#(#(!).,"))#(!2).,,"-,'N
,214%!+1%!61)(,211%&0&002!M *,/!(!64,/ 01,
6,2/*-L
#!F;?F:F'),,)/-./&'*)/.*,(.-*)-.#(!
)/.."#,%#-J'!-,#*.#)(K
,44!+20! &8!/!+1,*&+1&,+0,#1%!0!4,/ 01,
1/6 ,21 *2)1&-)! 0!/%!0 &+ *2)1&-)! -)!0 + 0!! 4%&%
,*&+1&,+0-/,3!*,0102!00#2)Q,/!5*-)!M,2) 1/6L
K ,,$)!0!/%#,/*,(.-)#&'#-",#(!"#&,(
*,#03
K ,,$)!%,)/0!/%#,/-",(.#(!)&-(.
*,-*.#0-
K ,**2+&1&,+01/10 10!0!/%#,/X]-)#&
'#Q(-.!,'#%)%))%M
*,#03*,(.#(!
N #(#(!).,"))#(!2).,,"-,'
K !4,/(&*!00!/%#,/"#&#(7/(,-
+ !% ,# 1%!0! 0!/%!0 4&)) /&+$ *! &8!/!+1(&+ 0 ,#
0,2/!0,+1%&01,-&Q
%8LJBE7F
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?ADM&C0ZEA
$OM6C#DLD;K0$ H$#/4,D
,3!M&+1!-C#,/!5-+ &+$6,2/(!64,/ 0M*!+1&,+!
),,(&+$ 1 1%!-/$. "#(!- 20! 6 )&//6 10! 1,
!0/&! /!)!3+1 /1&)!0 ,+ 6,2/ 1,-&Q 21 4%1 /! 1%!0!
#(#(!).,"))#(!2).,,"-,'N
'%NAENAN5)!4&! '-%3
/,02! 7'4& '4'/-+
*!97/2 335%%!34! 94&!
54&/2/--24'+!/54
3&2!-4'-%$2/,4&! 43!
!,'!2&/,0+!4!
V3/WN
02'!1%! &+$0M%,4/!1%!6 &8!/!+1#/,*(!64,/ 0M+
4%,%,,0!01%!*R
](!64,/ ^ + !
4,/ 1%1 --!/0 &+ +6
-/1,#0,2/!M+ *&$%1
+,1 ! 1%! 0*! 1!/*
0,*!,+!!)0!4,2) 20!#,/
1%1 ,+!-1Q ]02'!1
%! &+$M^ %,4!3!/M &0
!& ! ,+61%!! &1,/0,#
10! ,/ )00&:1&,+
0601!*01%!-/!#!//! 1!/*
#,/1%1,+!-1Q
*',/ %/1!/&01& ,#
&+#,/*1&,+0!/%&+$&01%!
20! ,# 02'!1 1!/*0 ,/
%! &+$0Q %! *',/
-2/-,0!,#02'!1%! &+$0
0601!*0 &0 1, -/,3& !
01+ / &7! *!1%, ,#
!0/&&+$))&+#,/*1&,+&+1%!0*!$!+!/)02'!1/!0,
1%1!3!/61%&+$-!/1&+&+$1,1,-&+!& !+1&:! Q%!+
6,2/!0!/%&+$#,/&+#,/*1&,+&+-/&+1,/ &$&1)#,/*M6,2
/! )&(!)6 1, %3! $!+!/) +,1&,+ ,# 1%! 1,-& /! 6,2 /!
/!0!/%&+$ /1%!/ 1%+ !1&)! )&01 ,# 21%,/0 ,/ 1&1)!0 ,#
*1!/&)0 6,2 /! 0!!(&+$Q ,/ 1%1 /!0,+M &+#,/*1&,+
N #(#(!).,"))#(!2).,,"-,'
1),$!/0 + &+ !5!/0 %3! 1$$! /!,/ 0 4&1% 02'!1
%! &+$00:+ &+$1,,)Q
+ !5!/0 0-!+ !+,/*,20 *,2+10 ,# 1&*! !3!),-&+$
02'!1 %! &+$0 1%1 2/1!)6 /!;!1 1%! 01/212/! ,#
&+#,/*1&,+ &+ 02'!1 /!Q ,2 + 20! 1%!0! 02'!1
%! &+$0 &+ *+6 460Q %!6 --!/ ,+ 1%! /!,/ 0 &+
)&//6`01),$S1%!6--!/&+1%!!+1/&!0,#&+ !5!0+ 1%!
%! &+$0&+01/10M,/1%!6*6!20! 1,,/$+&7!*1!/&)
,+4!0&1!0Q
+6)&//&!020!1%!02'!1)00&:1&,+0601!*/!1!
61%!&//6,#,+$/!00M0601!*1%1&0))! 1%!&//6
,#,+$/!002'!1! &+$0Q
K0$ H$#/4,D4##$4H/HO!
H6CO6&HK#$4H H/L/D3
04!`3!0!!+1%/,2$%,211%&0,,(M4/&1&+$+ /!0!/%/!
,1% 0%-! 6 ,2/ & !+1&1&!0Q 21 4%1 %--!+0 4%!+ 1%!
0601!*1%16,2`/!/!.2&/! 1,20!#,//!0!/%20!0-!',/1&3!
1!/*#,/+0-!1,#6,2/& !+1&16R
+@>?BM/1*,21%,))!$!012 !+1!)&00 &))M11%!
1&*!2+ ,2*!+1! %!/0!)#M40 ,&+$/!0!/%&+1%!)&//6
1),$ X$2&)!/YQ %! +,1&! 1%! 0,2/!0 0%! 40 :+ &+$
4!/! )00&:! 4&1%1%! 02'!1%! &+$ ]&))!$))&!+0M^ !3!+
4%!+1%!0,2/!01%!*0!)3!0 & +`120!1%11!/*Q%!/,2$%1
1%! &002! 1, %!/ #!)),4 1&3&010 1 /1*,21% ,)&1&,+ #,/
**&$/1&,+ !#,/*M .2)&16M + 0
#(#(!).,"))#(!2).,,"-,'N
X,YM+ 1%!6--/,%! 1%!)&//6,21%+$&+$
1%!1!/*0Q,4!3!/M1%!)&//&+0&+#,/*! 1%!*1%11%,0!
1!/*04!/!+,1 !1!/*&+! 61%!)&//6M2161%!&//6
,#,+$/!00Z+ 1%!6-/1+!/! 4&1%,1,-!1&1&,+
1%! &//6 ,# ,+$/!00 1, /!-)! ]&))!$) )&!+^ 4&1%
]2+ ,2*!+1! &**&$/+10Q^
211%140+`11%!!+ ,#1%!01,/6L1%!&//6,#,+$/!00
!+&! 1%!&/-!1&1&,+M4/&1&+$M]$$$$!&+&0+&+%!/!+1)6
)!$) %! &+$M + 0 02%M 1%! -/!#!/!+! &0 1, 20! 1%! )!$)
1!/*&+,),$6^ X&//6 ,# ,+$/!00YQ #1!/ 1%! *!/&+
&//6 00,&1&,+ --/,3! /!0,)21&,+ 02--,/1&+$ 1%!
%+$!M1%!&//6,#,+$/!00%+$! &10*&+ + $/!!
1,2- 1!1%!1!/*]&))!$))&!+0Q^21!#,/!1%!%+$!04!+1
&+1,!8!1M!-2)&+)4*(!/0$,14&+ ,#1%&0%+$!+
1/&! 1,-/!3!+11%!&//6,#,+$/!00#/,* /!*,3&+$1%!
1!/*S %,4!3!/M 1%&0 01&-2)1&,+ & +`1 *(! &1 &+1, 1%! :+)
3!/0&,+,#1%!&))X$2&)!/YQ&+))6M&+@>@?M0!3!+6!/0#1!/
1%!012 !+10`:$%1#,//!0-!1#2)+ 2/1!02'!1%! &+$
!$+M 1%! &//6 ,# ,+$/!00 /!-)! 1%! 1!/* ]&))!$)
)&!+0^ 4&1% 14, +!4 02'!1 %! &+$0L ]+,+&1&7!+0^ +
]&))!$)&**&$/1&,+^X]!),*!0!*,3)^YQ
!),4M 41% 1%! 1/&)!/ #,/ "(! ." /$.M
,2*!+1/6,+1%!0!012 !+10`:$%1X3&!41&*!@LAFYM,/3&!4
1%!4%,)!:)*,+)&+!Q
N #(#(!).,"))#(!2).,,"-,'
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?ADM/!,! Z?
#);?F:FR"(!."-/$.S.,#&,3"(!."/$.
3,$$D C/8H/64D
&$Q AEQ? *$! !0/&-1&,+Q %! &*$! &0 ,+!-1 *-
!-&1&+$1%!1%!*!]/!+10,01&+$,21%!&/& 0^Q1
1%!!+1!/M&/)!)!)! ]
^,++!104&1%:3!02//,2+ &+$+, !01%/,2$%
0,)& )&+!0Q%!0!+, !0/!!% &8!/!+1,),/M#,/*&+$
+!14,/(Q 1/1&+$ ),(4&0! #/,* 1%! 1,-L ?Q !&$! &/)!
)!)! ] ^ 4&1% 0-!!%2)! &,+0Q@Q
)&$%1,/+$!&/)!)!)! ]^4&1%+&,+,#%+
-/!00&+$]-,01^211,+M+ 1%!4,/ ]0%/&+$^!*+1&+$
#/,* &1Q AQ )3!+ !/ &/)! )!)! ]^ 4&1%
21&,+06*,)+ 1%!1!/*]-/&36^QBQ)&$%11!)&/)!
4&1%,210-!&:)!)M4&1%//,40-,&+1&+$,214/ #/,*&1
&+*2)1&-)! &/!1&,+04&1%,210-!&:1!/*0QCQ 2016-&+(
#(#(!).,"))#(!2).,,"-,'N
&/)!)!)! ]g^4&1%+&,+,#+ 2)1
+ %&) :$2/!M4&1%//,40)!)! ]%&) /!+^+ ]*,*0^Q
V!12/+1,&$QAEQ?W
&$QAEQ@ *$!!0/&-1&,+Q%! &*$!&0 + &+#,$/-%&
&))201/1&+$1%!1,-&]/!+10,01&+$,21%!&/& 0Q^1
1%!!+1!/&0&/)!)!)! ]
M^,++!1! 6)&+!01,:3!02//,2+ &+$&/)!0
/!-/!0!+1&+$ &8!/!+1 1%!*!0L ] g M^
] M^ ]M^ ]M^ +
]Q^ % &/)! #!12/!0 /!)!3+1 02\1,-&0Q %!
1,- &/)! 1&1)! ] g ^ &+)2 !0 02\1,-&0L
%&) /!+M *,*0M *,1%!/0M 0M #1%!/0Q + 1%! /&$%1M
] ^ )&010 0,&) +!14,/(&+$M +01$/*M
!,,(M &(,(Q !),4M ]^ &+)2 !0 0%/&+$M
0%/!+1&+$M ,3!/\0%/&+$M -%,1,0Q + 1%! ,11,* )!#1M
]^ #!12/!0 -/&36 X &$&1) (& +--&+$M YM
%&) &+;2!+!/0M 0!)#\& !+1&:1&,+M )40Q %! )!#1 &/)!
]^ )&010 ,+)&+! %&) -/&36 01121!0M ),/
-/,1!1&,+0M /!$2)1&,+0Q %! 1,- )!#1 &/)! ]^
&+)2 !0 -/& !M 3&!M ,**2+&16M 016&+$ ,++!1! 4&1%
#*&)6QV!12/+1,&$QAEQ@W
N #(#(!).,"))#(!2).,,"-,'
Attributions
/24'/-3/$4&'3&04!27!2! 04! $2/,
-$/2,4'/-424!%'!3$/2/,,5-'4/23
/092'%&4d@>?C94&+!!-N-3!--
/25+J+'!-3! 5- !22!4'6!/,,/-3
442'54'/-BN>-4!2-4'/-+'!-3!N
Works Cited
%5'+!2J3,'-!N[-/4&!2/2 $/2]++!%+
+'!-^44&!'229/$/-%2!33I
/-4!-4'/53N\
!7/2*',!3
J@@5+9@>?DJ
&4403IRR777N-94',!3N/,R@>?DR>ER@AR53R
-/4&!2Z7/2 Z$/2Z'++!%+Z+'!-Z4Z4&!Z+'229Z
/$Z/-%2!33Z/-4!-4'/53N&4,+N
[!+/,!3!,/6+/$$$!-3'6!]++!%+
+'!-3^5)!4! '-%3N\,!2'-'229
33/'4'/-J?@/6N@>@?J&4403IRR777N+N/2%R
-!73R@>@?R??R+Z7!+/,!3Z2!,/6+Z
#(#(!).,"))#(!2).,,"-,'N
/$$!-3'6!Z'++!%+Z+'!-3Z35)!4Z&! '-%3N
2!332!+!3!N
'229/$/-%2!33J2/%2,$/2//0!24'6!
4+/%'-%J5)!454&/2'49//0!24'6!
2/%2,N[5,,29/$!'3'/-3J '4/2'+
!!4'-%5,!2?@N\
'229/$/-%2!33
J?B
!N@>?BJ&4403IRR777N+/N%/6RR0R3/R
03/! R03 Z?B?@?CN&4,+N
$#/HHC/KH/64D
K %/!+1&+$2)!-?h&+!00)!/!!&0)&!+0!
2+ !/\X11/&21&,+,+,**!/&)Y
)&!+0!
K %/!+1&+$2)!-@h&+!00)!/!!&0)&!+0!
2+ !/>X/!1&3!,**,+0!/,Y)&!+0!
N #(#(!).,"))#(!2).,,"-,'
I%;
!
/4$DD2$C$$
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/53&/5+ !+!4/
H 80+'-&/74&!'3!3'-&!2!-4'-4&!
+%/2'4&,3!&'- //%+!- /4&!23!2&
4//+3,'%&4$$!49/520!230!4'6!3- 4&!
3/52!39/5;- 7&!-9/53!2&/-4/0'
H !-4'$9/2%-':4'/-3- 05+'4'/-34&4
,'%&4&6!2! '+!'-$/2,4'/-/-9/524/0'J
&!),#-"'N
24&!24&-2!+9'-%/-//%+!4/0/'-49/54/
4&!3/52!39/53&/5+ 53!
L$CL/$M
[6!29/-!7&/&3!33! 4&!'-4!2-!4&3
!80!2'!-! 4&!0!23/-+':'-%4'/-3/$
+%/2'4&,3J7&!4&!24&!92!+':!'4/2-/4N&!3!
'-6'3'+!+'-!3/$/ !-42*/52'-4!24'/-3J
429'-%4/%,!/52/-35,!2&'43- 0/+'4'+
+!-'-%34/ !4!2,'-!7&4 3J-!7334/2'!3
- '-$/2,4'/-7!3!!KN342*'-%024'!3
&6!!/,!,/2!/,,/-- 6-! J'4&3
!/,!52%!-44/5- !234- &/74&!3!
/,054!202/%2,37/2*- &6!7' !302!
',04N/7 /345 !-435- !234- 4&!&' !-
;+4!234&4'-<5!-!7&44&!93!!- +!2-J
- 3&0!7&44&!94&'-*- 7&/4&!92!O\
V! !4+N?AW
N&!),#-"'
! '201 )!/+! ,21
& !+1&+$ --/,-/&1!
(!64,/ 0 + 02'!1
%! &+$0 1, :+ 1%! *,01
/!)!3+1 0,2/!0Q 21 4%!+
6,2 20! +6 0!/% !+$&+!M
1%!/!`0 +,1%!/ #1,/ 1%1
!1!/*&+!04%1/!02)106,2
0!!:/01L)$,/&1%*0Q
!1`0066,2`/!!&+$0(! 1,1(!01+ ,++&002!Q,4
,6,2:+ 1%! &8!/!+1-,&+10,#3&!4,+1%1&002!R,4 ,
6,2 !& !4%13&!406,2$/!!4&1%R,2/3&!40,++6$&3!+
&002! *&$%1! 0%-! 6 6,2/ ! 21&,+M 6 1/201! -!,-)!
&+6,2/)&#!M+ 66,2/,4+-!/0,+)!5-!/&!+!0Q21%,4
*2%,#&1&0)0,0%-! ,//!&+#,/! 64%16,20!!,+)&+!R
%1`04%!/!)$,/&1%*0,*!&+1,-)6Q
$'*!, %+ /! 01!-\6\01!- &+01/21&,+0 1%1 ,*-21!/0
#,)),41,,*-)!1!10(0M0,)3!-/,)!*0M+ *(!21,*1!
!&0&,+0Q %!6 20! 1 1, *(! -/! &1&,+0 ,21 -!,-)!M
&+)2 &+$ 1%!&/ -/!#!/!+!0M 11/&21!0M + !%3&,/0Q
)$,/&1%*0-,4!/+!/)6!3!/61%&+$4!0!!,+)&+!M&+)2 &+$
0!/%!+$&+!0M0,&)*! &M3& !,$*!0M,+)&+! 1&+$M+
0*/1-%,+!--0Q%!6/!20! 1,0%-!+ :)1!/,+1!+1,+
1%!-)1#,/*0*+6,#20&+1!/14&1% &)6M02%0,,$)!M
,22!M +01$/*M !1;&5M !,,(M *7,+M 4&11!/M
+ -,1Q ,/ !5*-)!M )$,/&1%*0 !1!/*&+! 4%&%
4!0&1!0 6,2 0!! :/01 &+ 6,2/ ,,$)! 0!/% /!02)10M 4%&%
&!),#-"'N
-,010 6,2 0!! ,+ !,,(M + 4%&% 3& !,0 ,22!
]/!,**!+ 0^+ 21,-)60#,/6,2Q
,2*620!,,$)!!3!/6 6M21 ,6,2/!))6(+,4%,4
&100!/%/!02)1\/+(&+$)$,/&1%*4,/(0R!/!`0.2&(3& !,
V3&!41&*!&0CL?CW&+4%&%,,$)!!5-)&+04%60,*!/!02)10
--!/11%!1,-,#6,2/0!/%/!02)10M4%&)!,1%!/0 ,+`1L
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?B>M/!,! Z?
#);@F9F)1))!&,"1),%-3))!&
6D/H/L$$,H/L$
]!)&3!&++!/,#*&!+1&+#,/*1&,+Q*& 01 1%!
&)6;,, ,# &$&1)+!40M*!*!0M,-&+&,+M 3!/1&0&+$M
+ -/,-$+ M 1%!/! &0 /&0&+$ ,+!/+ ,21 %,4
-,-2)/-)1#,/*0M+ 1%!)$,/&1%*01%!6&+/!0&+$)6
!*-),6M *6 &+;2!+! ,2/ )&3!0M !!-!+ &3&0&,+0 &+
0,&!16M + #,*!+1 -,)/&71&,+M !51/!*&0*M +
&01/201^X! !1)Q?Y
N&!),#-"'
0,*-+&!0M$,3!/+*!+10M+ ,1%!/,/$+&71&,+0,+1&+2!
1,,))!1+ +)67!*00&3!*,2+10,#,2/ 1M1%!20!,#
)$,/&1%*0%0 !,*!-!/30&3!Q+ #1M*+6/! /!#!//&+$
1,1%&0-!/&, 01%!]$!,#)$,/&1%*0^,/1%!])$,/&1%*
/M^ + /!0!/%!/0 /! ,+0& !/&+$ 1%! 0&$+&:+1&*-10
1%11%!0!1,,)0*6%3!Z,1%-,0&1&3!+ +!$1&3!Q
%!/!&0+, ,211%1)$,/&1%*0+!20!#2)+ %!)-1,
&*-/,3!,2/)&3!0Q,/!5*-)!M&1!/1&+)603!0),1,#1&*!
+ #/201/1&,+1,!)!1,-2))2-*-,+,2/-%,+!0+
&+01+1)6 !1!/*&+!1%!#01!01461,/!%,2/ !01&+1&,+Q
,4!3!/M01!%+,),$6+ 0,&)*! &0%,)/ +%,6
%0 +,1! M ]1%! 0*! 1!%+,),$6 + ! 20! 1, !*-,4!/
-!,-)!N,/ %/* 1%!*Q 1 )) !-!+ 0 ,+ 4%, &0 20&+$ 1%!
&+#,/*1&,+ 1, 4%1 !+ 0^ X.1 Q &+ &+&! + + !/0,+YQ
+& 201#/'M 00&01+1 /,#!00,/ ,# ,*-21!/ &!+! 1
!))!0)!6,))!$!M0&*&)/)6+,1!01%1]!4+1*,/!-!,-)!
&+ 1%! 4,/) 1, %3! !00 1, 1%! 1,1) %2*+ (+,4)! $!
!00&)!,+1%!+1!/+!1M4!+!! )$,/&1%*0Q,4!3!/M4%1
4!+!! 1,,'!1$&+01/!1%!3)2!0 /&3&+$1%!,*-+&!0
1%1,4+1%!0!)$,/&1%*0^X.1 Q&+! !1)QB@YQ
&!),#-"'N
0E<G<A:)HE
B7<8F
&4 /4&!
/,0-'!3
!&'- 4&!3!
+%/2'4&,3
*-/7/54
9/5J9/52
' !-4'4'!3J-
9/52'-4!2!343O
/7,'%&44&4
3&0!4&!
/-4!-49/53!!
/-+'-!O
64 $C4D
%1 %--!+0 4%!+
)$,/&1%*0 /! 20! 1, -/! &1
4%!+ ,))!$! 012 !+10 /!
]%!1&+$^,+1!01M,/1,-/! &1
4%,0%,2) !%&/! #,/',,/
4%, 0%,2) $!1 ),+M ,/ 1,
!& !1%!16-!,#&+#,/*1&,+4!
0!!&+,2/0,&)*! &+!40#!! 0M
,/ 1, )2)1! /! &1 0,/!0M ,/
!3!+1,-/! &1/&*&+)!%3&,/
+ !1!/*&+! -/&0,+ 0!+1!+!0R
/!,,$)!0!/%/!02)10/!))6+
2+&0! -/!0!+11&,+,#1%!!01
3&))! &+#,/*1&,+ ,+
/!0!/% .2!01&,+R ,4 ,
)$,/&1%*0&*-1,2/-!/!-1&,+
,#/!0!/%1,-&M,/,#,2/,4+
/!)&1&!0R
N&!),#-"'
E88JE<G8
/7,'%&4+%/2'4&,3$$!49/52'+'494/;-
2! '+!J+-! J- !,''-$/2,4'/-$/2
9/522!3!2&33'%-,!-43'-/++!%!O&4-9/5
/4/,'4'%4!4&!3!!$$!43O
2,6C/H-3/ /D
[+4&/5%&4&!',05+3!'34/!+'!6!'-4&!
/)!4'6'49/$4&!,&'-!J7!-!! 4/2!,!,!2
4&4+%/2'4&,37!2!5'+490!/0+!\
V&,'!+'-3*'J14 N'-! !4+NAFWN
!20! 4! ,#1!+ 002*! 1%1 )$,/&1%*0 /! +!21/) +
,'!1&3!M1%!6+#(/,.&3*,)$.!,.,/."),#.3."(
"/'(2*,.#-Q%20M1%!-!/30&3!+!00,#)$,/&1%*0Z+
1%!&/ &+/! &)! -,1!+1&) 1, &+;2!+! ,2/ 0,&!16M -,)&1&0M
N&!),#-"'
&+01&121&,+0M + !%3&,/Z%0 !!+ 0,2/! ,# $/,4&+$
,+!/+Q
$'*!, %!!+&0,+!,#1%,0!(!6,+!/+0Q%&0,2/0
4%!+ )$,/&1%*0 /!;!1 1%! &*-)&&1 3)2!0 ,# 1%! %2*+0
&+3,)3! &+ 1%!&/ /!1&,+ ,/ 20!M 0601!*1&))6 ]/!-)&1&+$
,/!3!+*-)&+$%2*+&0!0M-/1&2)/)61%,0!8!1&+$
-/,1!1! $/,2-0^X!!!1)QYQ+0!/%!+$&+!0M#,/!5*-)!M
)$,/&1%*& &0 + /!1! 0!/% /!02)10 1%1 /!;!1 /&01M
0!5&01M,/,1%!/0,&)&0!0M !0-&1!1%!-/!02*! +!21/)&16,#
1%! 1Q!/!/!'201#!4!5*-)!0,#)$,/&1%*&&0X!!
!1)QYL
K +)$,/&1%*20! 6'2 $!01,-/! &14%!1%!/
!#!+ +100%,2) !&*-/&0,+! ,//!)!0! ,+&)40
#,2+ 1,!&0! $&+01#/&+\*!/&+0Q
K *7,+% 1, &0,+1&+2!20&+$/!/2&1&+$)$,/&1%*
#1!/ &0,3!/&+$$!+ !/&0L%!)$,/&1%*40
-!+)&7&+$+6/!02*!1%1,+1&+! 1%!4,/
]4,*!+`0^&+1%!1!51M!20!1%! 1400! ,+
/!02*!0%&01,/&))602*&11! 1,*7,+M4%&%4!/!
-/! ,*&++1)6#/,*4%&1!*)!0Q
K /&+!1,++&3!/0&16/!0!/%!/0+)67! )$,/&1%*0
+ #,2+ 1%11%!6-&(! 2-,+!5&01&+$/&)+
$!+ !/&0!0L2/,-!++*!04!/!-!/!&3! 0*,/!
-)!0+11%+1%,0!,##/&+\*!/&+0M+ 1%!
4,/ 0]4,*+^+ ]$&/)^4!/!*,/!)&(!)61,!
00,&1! 4&1%1%!/10&+01! ,#0&!+!+ *1%Q
&!),#-"'N
K 2*!/,20/1&)!0V!4W%3!!5*&+! 1%!/,)!
1%1,22!`0/!,**!+ 1&,+)$,/&1%**&$%1-)6
&+/ &)&7&+$3&!4!/0Q
,4M ,+0& !/ 1%1 1%! )/$! )+$2$! *, !)0 -,4!/&+$
$!+!/1&3! %1,10 )&(! %1 4!/! 1/&+! ,+ 1%&0
1Q
-22$4,/4,H-$2,6C/H-3D6&
88C$DD/64
+1%!3& !,!),4V3&!41&*!&0@>LABWM &$&1)*! &0%,)/
/Q:6*,',)!+ ,*-21!/0&!+1&01/Q1+6
4!!+!6 &0200 1%!&/ :+ &+$0 ,21 )$,/&1%*& &0 &+
,,$)!0!/%/!02)10+ 0M+ %,4&1-/1&2)/)68!10
4,*!+,#,),/Q
,+1!+14/+&+$L%!#,)),4&+$3& !,&+)2 !0 &0200&,+0
,#/&0*M0!5&0*M+ /&)3&,)!+!Q1)0,0%,400!52)&7!
&*$!0#,2+ &+0!/%/!02)10Q
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
N&!),#-"'
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?B>M/!,! Z@
#);@F:F,"(!#(,%)1(C,&!),#."'-#-.
(2#-.GW/&&#&'3
,8F84E6;K8E6<F8
-!794/!30!4&!+%/2'4&,3I /-^4+!44&!,
4!++9/57&43/52!34/53!N-34! J%/342'%&44/
2!054+!3/52!3/-9/524/0'N/,!!8,0+!3I
H $9/5^2!2!3!2&'-%+',4!&-%!J4&!
7!3'4!$/24&!^3-4!2%/6!2-,!-4+-!+
/-+',4!&-%!,'%&4!%// 0+!4/
+//*$/22!0/243N
H $9/57-44/*-/7'$-34%2,53!'3
/22!+4! 7'4& !02!33'/-'-4!!-3J3!!7&4
4&!,!2'- !,9/$! '42'3^7!3'4!
&3/-4&'3'335!N
&!),#-"'N
H $9/57-44/*-/74&!+4!34-!73/-
%+/+/-<'4J%/4/4&!7!3'4!$/2-!73
/2%-':4'/-9/542534J/253!3'4!+'*!
2/5- !734&4524!3/6!2%!$2/,
62'!49/$05+'4'/-3N
H $9/57-44/3!!4&!+4!343'!-4';
2!3!2&/-4/0'J;- 3&/+2+9)/52-+
4&4$/53!3/-4&44/0'- 2/73!4&!
24'+!34&!9^2!05+'3&'-%N/5-53!4//+
+'*!2/7:'-!4/$/++/7024'5+2)/52-+3J'$
'4^36'++!4&2/5%&9/52+'229N
4'6'49I3!4&!00/3'-%'!70/'-43 43!V'$
'4^36'++!4&2/5%&9/52+'229WJ4/' !-4'$9
2!+!6-4!80!24/2%-':4'/-37&/3!7!3'4!39/5
-!80+/2! '2!4+9V24&!24&-2!+9'-%/-//%+!^3
/2'*/*^3+%/2'4&,4/0/'-49/54&!2!LWN
?N 0!-4&!00/3'-%'!70/'-43 43!N
@N !2&$/29/52!3394/0'J/2-9522!-4
3/'!4+4/0'9/5^2!'-4!2!34! '-N
AN $4/0'%5' !/,!35039/5490!'-9/52
3!2&J+'*/-'4N
BN - !2[-4&'3%!J\+'*4&!+'-*$/2
!3'4!3N
CN /4/3/,!/$4&!2!/,,!- ! 7!3'4!3
N&!),#-"'
- +//*2/5- $/23/,!2!+!6-42!3!2&
2!0/243N
DN 5,'4+'-*34/2!3!2&2!0/243$2/,47/
'$$!2!-47!3'4!34/9/5202/$!33/2N
'-429^3/++!%!/$+'$/2-'!3/52!3
345 !-43J53!4&!3!'229+'-*34/!33
4&!2!3/52!3,!-4'/-! /6!I
H 2/7:'-!)/52-+2/73'-%00
H 00/3'-%'!70/'-43 43!
&!),#-"'N
Attributions
&'3&04!273 04! $2/,
-42/ 54'/-4/
/++!%!!3!2&
J/092'%&4d9+4!2N
54+!2Q+/&2%!-4Q- !+3!9,'4&N
-42/ 54'/-4//++!%!!3!2&
+'!-3! 5- !2
2!4'6!/,,/-3442'54'/-BN>-4!2-4'/-+
'!-3!J!8!047&!2!/4&!27'3!-/4! N
,%!I[!//*/-!04'-29\9%!2+4/-
'89
,%!I[&!++/24'-%+%/2'4&,/+/223\9
+524+'3+'!-3! 5- !2BN>
-$/%20&'I['$!'-4&!%!/$+%/2'4&,3\9
!33'52*/$3*9$/22/)!4-$/2,4'/-'4!29
'3+'!-3! 5- !2ZZBN>
/,!4!84 04! $2/,['%'4+'4':!-3&'0\9
+/&2%!-4- ,!3+0Z2/33*+%$/2
bJ+'!-3! 5- !2BN>
N&!),#-"'
Works Cited
! J+'3/-NJ22'34!2J- 2%9
'++-N[-$/2,4'/-'4!29'-4&!%!/$
+%/2'4&,3N\
2/)!4-$/2,4'/-'4!29
J?C
-N@>@>N'!-3! 5- !2ZZBN>
[/7//%+!!2&/2*3N\
/55!
J
50+/ ! 9//%+!J@B4N@>?GN
[/7'3! 2!/52+%/2'4&,3Oe;9
,/)/+!e8N\
/55!
J50+/ !
98+*3J?F02N@>?BN
!!J'/+!52-!2J5+!3-'*J- !-'!
24/-N[+%/2'4&,''3!4!4'/--
'4'%4'/-I!3424'!3- /+''!34/
! 5!/-35,!22,3N\
2//*'-%3
J@@9
@>?GN
'-'!J!!J- --- !23/-N[/ !
!0!- !-4I2/3- /-3/$4&!+%/2'4&,
%!N\
!7!3!2&!-4!2
JF!N@>?EN
&!),#-"'N
I5;
/4$DD2$C$$
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/53&/5+ !+!4/
H ,!3/,!'- '4/23/$2! ''+'49
H 80+'-&/7 '$$!2!-43/52!3,'%&4/-4'-
'$$!2!-4490!3/$2! ''+'494&4-'-$/2,
9/525- !234- '-%/$-'335!'- '$$!2!-4
793
%!+6,2`/!1/6&+$1, !& !4%!1%!/0,2/!&0/! &)!M6,2
*&$%101/16),,(&+$1#!4(!6&+ &1,/0L
"))#(!,#&0).,N
?Q ':1%!21%,/`0!5-!/1&0!
@Q *&140-2)&0%! L1%!-2)&1&,+`0/!-211&,+
+ ! &1,/&)-/,!00
AQ &:1%! 1!,#-2)&1&,+
BQ 1:1%!21%,/`0-2/-,0!+ -,&+1,#3&!4
%&03& !,!5-)&+0#2/1%!/L
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?BBM/!,! Z?
#);AF9F0&/.#(!-)/,- ),,##&#.33&#(-/
N"))#(!,#&0).,
0;8E8JBH?7LBH?BB>9BE<A7<64GBEF
B96E87<5<?<GLBAG;<F4EG<6?8
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?BBM&C0ZEB
-$C$C$46@,66#A4#@#A
D6KC $D
,4!3!/M06,2`/!'2 $&+$/! &&)&16M(!!-&+*&+ 1%1, *
*&E,C''D+'-*+&CD+'-*+=,(&+/ ,
1'-E*-+!&1'-*+'-*'*=
"))#(!,#&0).,N
'%NAGN?N-/-<%4@-
,!- ,!-42++9'-@>@>
1`0 //! 1, :+
,*-)!1!)62+&0! 0,2/!Q
2/ 2+ !/01+ &+$ ,# 1%!
#10,+1,-&%+$!0,3!/
1&*!M+ +60,2/!&0$,&+$
1, %3! 1, -&( + %,,0!
4%&% #10 + & !0 1,
/&+$&++ 4%&%,+!01,
)!3! ,21Q 3!+ !*&
/1&)!0/!4/&11!+6%2*+04%,/&+$1%!&/,4+&0!01,
1%!&//!0!/%M1/6 01%!6*&$%1 1,*&1&$1!1%!*Q)20M 6,2
*&$%11(.1,/&+$&+0,2/!01%1)!+ 1,4/ ,+!0& ! ,/
+,1%!/,+6,2/1,-&M1,0%,41%!/+$!,#/$2*!+10,+1%!
02'!1Q%&0)),406,21,'2*-&+4&1%1%!-,&+101%16,2
1%&+( /! ,*-!))&+$Z,/ )(&+$Z#/,* 1%,0! -&!!0Q
!%('*,&,, !&!+,'%#+-*1'-&*'&!2&
#&'/$ 1'-* +'-*+E .!/('!&,+ '* !++ / &
1'- !&,*'- & '%%&, '& 1'-* +'-*+ !& 1'-*
/*!,!&=
,/ !5*-)!M &# 6,2`/! 4/&1&+$ + !006 ,21 +,+
,+0-&/6 1%!,/&!0M 6,2*&$%1 +!! 1, .2,1! 0,*! +,+
-,010 #/,* ,+)&+! *!00$! ,/ 0Q %&)! 1%!0! /! '201
,+0-&/6 1%!,/&!0M+ 6,24,2) +`14+11,1(! 1%!*0
1/21%M1%!6 ,2) ! 1%!-!/#!1*,#',3-)/,-#,/+ !006
&+ 4%&% 6,2 +)67! 1%! )+$2$! ,# 1%!0! -,010 + 1%!&/
,++!1&,+0 1, 1/,-!0 #/,* -01 ,+0-&/6 1%!,/&!0Q ,2
4,2) *(!&1)!/1,6,2//! !/1%!,+1!51,#1%!0!-,010
N"))#(!,#&0).,
'%NAGN@N&'3/25,
2 '/3&/7'-4!26'!7! $/52
%5!3437'4& '$$!2!-4490!3
/$54&/2'49/-4&!+'$/2-'
/++!%!3&/53'-%2'3'3N
T3!+!44/!-+2%!U
+ 1%16,24!/!!5*&+&+$1%!0!-,0100/1
M216,2
4,2) +`1-/!0!+11%!*01/21%#2)011!*!+10Q,4!3!/M6,2
4,2) +`14+11,20!,+0-&/6\1%!,/6*!00$!,/ -,010
0#12)0,2/!002--,/1&+$+12),+0-&/61%!,/6&++
!*&/!0!/%--!/Q
4 6C86CH/4,
3K2H/82$HO8$D
6&KH-6C/HO
!/!`0/!)!5*-)!#/,*
/ &, 0%,4 + -, 01Q
%!+1%!))\&+0%,4),/'
,+ -2)& / &, 011&,+
%,01! + !-&0, !
,21 1%! )( ,# *-20
%,20&+$#,/)&#,/+&,))!$!
012 !+10M 1%!6 /,2$%1 ,+
#,2/ &8!/!+10,2/!01,0%!
)&$%1,+1%&0&002!L
K -!&2;M
)&#,/+&,*-!1!0[
+,+-/1&0+-,)&6+ /!0!/%,/$+&71&,+#,20!
,+1%!&+1!/0!1&,+,#%&$%!/! 21&,+M!.2&16M+ 1%!
!,+,*6Q
"))#(!,#&0).,N
K !$$-$,'&;2/+-)++!/M&))&*2)1,+/,2-S
21%,/M])!+ /,0-!/&16L,4&1&!0!)-01,
,++!1+ ++,31!^
K 1&'1'$;012 !+1M+1/27
K ,!-*;!/(!)!6+!40/!-,/1!/M%!!/2/6
!40
0 6,2 + 0!!M 1%!/! 40+`1 '201)( 16-! ,# !5-!/1&0! 1%!6
#,2+ 3)2)!Q +01! M 1%!6 /,2$%1 ,+ /!0!/%!/ 1
+,+-/,:1M+2/+-)++!/M',2/+)&01M+ ,))!$!012 !+1
4%,,2) 0-!(1,%&0+ %&0)00*1!0`!5-!/&!+!0),,(&+$
#,/+ 1/6&+$1,8,/ %,20&+$Q%,#1%!0!-!,-)!/,2$%1
&8!/!+13&!4-,&+1,+1%&0,*-)!5&002!1,1%! &0200&,+Q
&*&)/)6M6,2/4/&1&+$+/&+$&+ &8!/!+1(&+ 0,#!5-!/1&0!
1,,QJ
9',:,*!,))!$!00&$+*!+104&))/!.2&/!6,21,,+)6
20!,+!(&+ ,#!5-!/1&0!Z#,/!5*-)!M-06%,),$6,2/0!
*&$%1/!.2&/!6,21,06+1%!0&7!1%/!!/!)1! !*-&/&)M-!!/\
/!3&!4! ',2/+)/1&)!06 !*&-06%,),$&010Q
N"))#(!,#&0).,
0E<G<A:)HEB7<8F
/-3' !2I&/7,'%&4!&/$4&!%5!343/-4&!
/25,2 '/3&/7&6!2/5%&4 '$$!2!-4
!,/ '! !80!2'!-!4/4&!3,!4/0'/$-/4
&6'-%!-/5%&&/53'-%$/2+'$/2-'/++!%!
345 !-43O
0E<G8GB&84EABAF<78E<U8E8AG
%<A7FB9E87<5<?<GLBA2BHE-BC<6
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
"))#(!,#&0).,N
+Q;
!
/4$DD2$C$$
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/53&/5+ !+!4/
H !;-!,'3'-$/2,4'/-J '3'-$/2,4'/-J
,+'-$/2,4'/-J/-4!-4,2*!4'-%J- '3
H !-4'$9!8,0+!3/$!&/$4&!3!
"3&0&1&*-,/1+11,%!(4!0&1!#,//! &&)&16!#,/!
"))#(!,#&0).,, &!N
1/201&+$&1,/20&+$&1&+,))!$!00&$+*!+1R%6 ,!0
&+#,/*1&,+!5&01,+1%!&+1!/+!1R!/!/!#!4/!0,+0L
/D/4&6C3H/64"/D/4&6C3H/64"
4#2/4&6C3H/64
,*!01&+ &+1!/+1&,+)-,)&1&)1,/0%3!4!-,+&7!
1%!&+1!/+!1`0&)&161,1/+0*&1&+#,/*1&,+.2&()61,0,4
#!/M+1$,+&0*M+ &01/201Q,1))4!0!/%!04&))/&+$
2- &+1!+1&,+))6 &+,//!1 &+#,/*1&,+M 21 0,*! *&$%1M
!0-!&))6 &# 6,2`/! /!0!/%&+$ 0,*!1%&+$ 1%1`0 -,)&1&))6
,+1/,3!/0&)Q
%&0%/1!5-)&+01%! &8!/!+!!14!!+'#-#( ),'.#)(M
#-#( ),'.#)(M+ '&#( ),'.#)(L
N"))#(!,#&0).,, &!
&$QB>Q?Q((#!,') .",&.#)(-"#*.1(
'#-#( ),'.#)(D#-#( ),'.#)(D('&#( ),'.#)(FV*$!
!0/&-1&,+W
64H$4HC1$H/4,!$C/H$CD
&6C/C$
3!+!0&1!&0+`1&+1!+1&,+))6*&0)! &+$6,2M&1*&$%1
+,1!4/&11!+6+!5-!/1,+1%!1,-&Q+#1M&1*&$%1!
4/&11!+60,*!,+!4%,%0+,*,/!!5-!/1&0!,+1%!1,-&
1%+ 6,2 ,Q +6 4!0&1!0 /! &+1!+ ! 0 '&,&,
%*#,!&M4%&%*!+01%!6/!'2011/6&+$1, /!001,-&0
1%1-!,-)!,#1!+0!/%,,$)!#,/&+#,/*1&,+,+M0,1%!&/
"))#(!,#&0).,, &!N
4!0&1!0%,402-&+,,$)!/!02)10M+ 1%!6 /&3!1/91,
1%!&/4!0&1!M4%!/!1%!60!))0!/3&!Q
,/!5*-)!M6,2*&$%10!/%,,$)!#,/0(&+&002!6,2`/!
%3&+$M)&(,+0!/%/!02)11%10!!*01, /!006,2/&002!M
+ !1(!+1,1%!4!0&1!,# !/*1,),$&01Q%14!0&1!
*&$%1%3!&+#,/*1&,+1%1`04/&11!+6 !/*1,),$&01M21
&1`0'2010)&(!)61,!4/&11!+6#/!!)+!,-64/&1!/4%,
$,1-& 1, 4/&1! 2+%,# 4!-$!0 ,+0(&+ &002!0Q%!6
/!-& M),+$4&1%0!/%\!+$&+!,-1&*&71&,+XY!5-!/10M
1,$!1,+02*!/0)&(!6,21,%--!+2-,+1%! !/*1,),$&01`0
4!0&1!Q 3!+ &# 6,2 4!/!+`1 ,/&$&+))6 ),,(&+$ #,/
!/*1,),$&01M+,46,2/!,+1%!&/4!0&1!M4%!/!1%!6+
0!/3!6,2 0#,/+!4\-1&!+1 &0,2+10M+ %O"#(!E%!6
*&$%1 %3! '201 $,11!+ 1%!*0!)3!0 +!4 201,*!/Q %&)!
0!!(&+$ *! &) 3&! #/,* )&!+0! -/1&1&,+!/ +
!/1&+)6!!11!/,-1&,+1%+ &$+,0&+$6,2/0!)#4&1%]/Q
,,$)!M^6,2*&$%1)0,%3!'201* ! !&0&,+0! ,+
0,*!4!,+1!+11%140+`14/&11!+6+!5-!/1Q
+ 1%!0! 60M20&+!00,4+!/0 ,+`1!3!++!! 1,-6
%2*+1,4/&1!1%!&/,+1!+1*/(!1&+$Q%!6+$!+!/1!))
1%!)&(&11%!64+14&1%1%!%!)-,#$!+!/1&3!%1,10
)&(!%1X,8!!YQ
201 !20!&1`0 ,+1!+1*/(!1&+$ ,!0+`1 *!+ &1`0 +,1
/!)&)!Q %! 6, )&+& &+ &++!0,1 &0 ,+! ,# 1%! *,01
/!0-!1! *! &)&+01&121&,+0&+1%!+&1! 11!0Q104!0&1!
%0 1,+ ,# *! &) &+#,/*1&,+ &+1!+ ! 1, ,1% -/,3& !
/! &)! *! &) &+#,/*1&,+ 1%1 &0 3!11! 6 ,1,/0 (
N"))#(!,#&0).,, &!
/4-,1!+1&)-1&!+101,&104!0&1!Q1$,!0!6,+ 0!/%\
!+$&+!,-1&*&71&,+1,12))6-/1+!/4&1%,,$)!1,#!12/!
&10,+1!+1X*04*&YQX+ &1+,4*(!0*,+!6)&!+0&+$
&10 *! &) /1&)!0 1, ,1%!/ %!)1%/! -/,3& !/0 1,,Q
V]&!+0)! ,+1!+1Q^WY , '201 *(! 02/! 1%1 6,2 +
/!,$+&7!,+1!+1*/(!1&+$M%!(%!21%,/&0+!5-!/1
,+1%!1,-&M+ &#&1%0!!+! &1! ,/#1\%!(! 6+
!5-!/11,,Q+ ,+0& !/%!/!*&$%1!!11!/0,2/!,+
1%!1,-&Q 201!20!&1 --!/01 1%!1,- ,#6,2/,,$)!
0!/% /!02)10 ,!0+`1 *!+ &1`0 1%! !01 0,2/! #,/ 6,2/
-2/-,0!0Q
'%NB>N@N&!9/+'-'/$4!-'3/-!/$4&!;234//%+!
2!35+437&!-9/53!2&$/2,! '+4/0'N
/D
,+!,#20&04&1%,21&0!0Q%&)!0,*!+!40,/$+&71&,+0
+ 4!0&1!01/61,*&+&*&7!1%,0!&0!0&+1%!&/,+1!+1M1%!6
01&))%3!1,*(!))0,+4%1&002!0+ !3!+101,,3!/+
%,4Q1%!/+!40,/$+&71&,+0+ 4!0&1!0*&$%1)!+&+1,
-/1&2)/-,)&1&)3&!4-,&+1Q,*!*&$%1)&!1,%&!3!1%!&/
&*0M4%&)!,1%!/001&(1,#10Q
,4!3!/M 4%&)! 0,*! 00!/1&,+0 /! !*,+01/)6 #)0!M
"))#(!,#&0).,, &!N
*+6 #10 + 011&01&0 + 02--,/1 &8!/!+1 ,+)20&,+0M
!-!+ &+$,+4%&%#10/!%,0!++ %,41%!6`/!#/*! Q
,/!5*-)!M !& &+$4%!1%!//&*!%0$,+!2-,/ ,4+
&+6,2/&16M011!M,/,2+1/6*&$%1 !-!+ ,+4%&%16-!0,#
/&*!6,2`/!),,(&+$1M4%11&*!-!/&, 6,2`/!,+0& !/&+$M
+ 4%!1%!/1%!*!1%, 0#,/1/(&+$/&*!%+$! ,3!/1%1
-!/&, Q + 4%!+ &1 ,*!0 1, )*&+$ ,/ $&3&+$ /! &1 #,/
1%,0!%+$!0 &+/&*!/1!0M &8!/!+1-2+ &10 ,/-,)&1&&+0
*&$%1-,&+11,*+6 &8!/!+1#1,/0L#,/!5*-)!M1%!-,)&&!0
,#1%!-/!3&,20 *&+&01/1&,+M)4!+#,/!*!+1#2+ &+$M1%!
!,+,*6M+ *,/!Q+!0!1,##10+,#1!+%3! &8!/!+1M
+ 0,*!1&*!0!.2))63)& M&+1!/-/!11&,+0Q
3,$$D C/8H/64D
&$Q B>Q? *$! !0/&-1&,+Q !++ &$/* 4&1% 14,
,3!/)--&+$ &/)!0 &0 0%,4+Q %! :/01 &/)!M
]&0&+#,/*1&,+^ &0 2+ !/ 1%! %! &+$ ,# ])0!+!00Q^ %!
0!,+ &/)!M ])&+#,/*1&,+^ &0 2+ !/ 1%! %! &+$ ,#
]+1!+11,/*Q^%!/!1%!14,&/)!0,3!/)-M&1&0)!)!
]&0&+#,/*1&,+Q^ !:+&1&,+0 /! -/,3& ! #,/ )) 1%/!!L
&0&+#,/*1&,+[+&+1!+1&,+)*&01(!002%0&+2/1!
-%,1, -1&,+0M 1!0M 011&01&0M 1/+0)1&,+0M ,/ 4%!+ 01&/!
&01(!+ 0!/&,20)6Q &0&+#,/*1&,+\/&1! ,/ !)&!/1!)6
*+&-2)1! 2 &,T3&02) ,+1!+1Q +1!+1&,+))6 /!1!
N"))#(!,#&0).,, &!
,+0-&/61%!,/&!0,//2*,2/0Q)&+#,/*1&,+[!)&!/1!
-2)&1&,+,#-/&31!&+#,/*1&,+#,/-!/0,+),/,/-,/1!
/1%!/1%+-2)&&+1!/!01M02%0/!3!+$!-,/+Q!)&!/1!
%+$!,#,+1!51M 1!M,/1&*!,#$!+2&+!,+1!+1QV!12/+1,
&$QB>Q?W
Attributions
[A90!3/$-$/2,4'/-'3/2 !2\%20&'
9+'2!2 +!c/33!'-!2*3&-'3+'!-3!
5- !2ZZAN>
Works Cited
/$$!!J42'*N[2*!4!232!544'-%/2!
/-4!-4- 5+'49/-42/+'-4&!- 3/$
N\
++42!!4/52-+
J?E02N@>@CJ
&4403IRR777N73)N/,R24'+!3R,2*!4!23Z2!Z
0544'-%Z,/2!Z/-4!-4Z- Z15+'49Z/-42/+Z'-Z
4&!Z&- 3Z/$Z'Z !FBBDAFN
['!-3+!/-4!-4N\
9/+'-'!+4&
"))#(!,#&0).,, &!N
54'/-- /-4!-4!26'!3
J
&4403IRR%3N,9/+'-'N/2%R+'!-3+!Z
/-4!-4N0&0N
,37,'J2!,N[2!,! 9$/29/52&!+4&Z
2!+4! 15!34'/-3I&!+4&'-$/'-4&!
-/7+! %!20&N\
&!!97/2 J
//%+!J?>
!N@>?CJ&4403IRR+/%N%//%+!R02/ 543R3!2&R
&!+4&Z'-$/Z*-/7+! %!Z%20&RN
$#/HHC/KH/64D
K 6,)&+&,,$)!!/%/!02)1 -1! 6&+!!&0
)&!+0! 2+ !/>X/!1&3!,**,+0!/,Y)&!+0!
N"))#(!,#&0).,, &!
+7;
!
.
/4$DD2$C$$
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/53&/5+ !+!4/
H ! /4&!23/52!37&!- !' '-%7&!4&!24/
42534024'5+23/52!
H '- 4&!/2'%'-+3/52!/$4&!'-$/2,4'/-/2
',%!
H -6!34'%4!4&!05+'4'/-/27!3'4!7&!2!
9/5$/5- 9/52'-$/2,4'/-53'-%'*'0! '
"))#(!,#&0)., -"%#(!N
/2/4&!23/52!3
%!+6,2:+ 0,2/!,#&+#,/*1&,+M%,4 ,6,2(+,4&#
&1`01/2!R,4+6,2!02/!1%1&1&0/!)&)!M1/2014,/1%6M
+ !8!1&3!-&!!,#!3& !+!#,/6,2//!0!/%R%&0%-1!/
4&)) &+1/, 2! 6,2 1, 0!1 ,# 01/1!$&!0 1, .2&()6 +
!8!1&3!)63!/B,2/0,2/!0M0! ,+1%!--/,%1(!+6
-/,#!00&,+) #1\%!(!/0Q 1\%!(&+$ + *&+&*&7! 6,2/
,4+020!-1&&)&161,*&0&+#,/*1&,++ &0&+#,/*1&,++
%!)-6,21,3,& 0-/! &+$&11,,1%!/0Q
0;4G 46G;86>8EFB
0+&+1/, 21&,+M-)!0!41%1%!#,)),4&+$3& !,0M4%&%
&0200 1%! /!02)10 ,# + &+1!/!01&+$ 012 6 V!4 W ,#
1+#,/ 012 !+10M %&01,/&+0M + -/,#!00&,+) #1\%!(!/0
X&+!2/$+ /!4M@>?GYQ%&%$/,2- ,6,21%&+(
& 1%!!01',,#& !+1&+$/!)&)!0,2/!0R
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
N"))#(!,#&0)., -"%#(!
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?C@M/!,! Z?
#)<9F9F(&#(0,#6.#)(-%#&&-N#)9C(.,)/.),3
0#)3O
).C/,()(&)-*.#)(-1#."."PQ/..)(),/-."
.2..,(-,#*.J1K# 3)/*, ,.),F
,847&4G8E4??L
%!+&+3!01&$1&+$0,2/!M,B #*+*C$,*$$1D
/,00 *+6 4!0&1!0M /1%!/ 1%+ &$$&+$ !!- X/! &+$
]3!/1&))6^Y&+1,1%!,+!0,2/!1%!6/!!3)21&+$Q%1&0M
1%!6 ,+`10-!+ *2%1&*!,+1%!0,2/!&10!)#M21&+01! M
1%!6.2&()6,'3 , (+ 0!!4%1,1%!/0%3!0&
,211%!0,2/!Q%!6,-!+2-*+610&+1%!&//,40!/M
-&!&+$1,$!1%!/ &8!/!+1&10,#&+#,/*1&,+#/,*/,001%!
4!1,$!1!11!/-&12/!,#1%!0,2/!1%!6`/!&+3!01&$1&+$Q
)!0! 41% 1%! #,)),4&+$ 0%,/1 3& !, V@LBBW #,/
!*,+01/1&,+,#1%&001/1!$6Q6-/1&2)/11!+1&,+1,%,4
&(&-! &+!20! 1,.2&()6$!120!#2)&+#,/*1&,+,21
-2)&1&,+0M,/$+&71&,+0M+ 21%,/0Q
"))#(!,#&0)., -"%#(!N
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?C@M/!,! Z@
#)<9F:F(&#(0,#6.#)(-%#&&-N#):C(0-.#!.."
-)/,3O
).C/,()(&)-*.#)(-1#."."PQ/..)(),/-."
.2..,(-,#*.I1K# 3)/*, ,.),F
<A78GG8EBI8E4:8
%1%!0,2/!6,2:+
&0 ),4\.2)&16M ,/ 6,2 +`1
!1!/*&+! &# &1 &0 /!)&)! ,/
+,1R !/%-0 6,2 ,+`1 /!))6
/! ,21 1%! 0,2/!Z6,2
/! ,21 1%! $!% , ,
+'-* !+ %#!&Q ,2 4+1
1, (+,4 &# &1 &0 1/2! ,/ #)0!Q
,2 4+1 1, (+,4 &# &1
/!-/!0!+10,+0!+0203&!4-,&+1M,/&#&1&01%!02'!1,#*2%
&0$/!!*!+1Q,**,+!5*-)!,#1%&0&0*!*!6,2*&$%1
!+,2+1!/,+0,&)*! &Q%!/+ ,*-!/0,+,/$/,2-4%,
N"))#(!,#&0)., -"%#(!
-,01! 1%! *!*! *6 ! )!00 &*-,/1+1 1%+ 1%! .2,1! ,/
)&*1%!*!*!*(!0Q
,2/ !0101/1!$6 &+1%&0 0!*&$%1 12))6! 1,:+
,,* +'-* $,', *M 1, ),,( #,/ ', * '.* 1%1
&+)2 !0 1/201! /!-,/1&+$ ,/ +)60&0 ,+ 1%1 0*! )&*Q
1%!/1%+/!)6&+$,+1%!0,2/!1%16,2&+&1&))6#,2+ M6,2
+1/ !2-#,/%&$%!/\.2)&160,2/!Q
%! -,&+1 &0 1%1 6,2`/! +,1 4! ! 1, 20&+$ 1%1 &+&1&)
0,2/!Q!%3!1%!&+1!/+!1O,2+$,,21+ :+ !11!/
0,2/! + &+3!01 6,2/ 1&*! 1%!/!Q )!0! 41% 1%&0 3& !,
VBL?>W 1%1 !*,+01/1!0 1%&0 01/1!$6 + +,1!0 %,4 #1\
%!(!/02&) )&//6,#1/201! 0,2/!01%!6+/!)6,+1,
-/,3& !!11!/,3!/$!Q
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?C@M/!,! ZA
#)<9F;F(&#(0,#6.#)(-%#&&-N#)<C))% ),
.,/-.1),%3O
).C/,()(&)-*.#)(-1#."."PQ/..)(),/-."
.2..,(-,#*.J1K# 3)/*, ,.),F
"))#(!,#&0)., -"%#(!N
-E468?4<@F+HBG8F4A7'87<4GB
G;8)E<:<A4?BAG8KG
2% ,# 4%1 4! :+ ,+
1%!&+1!/+!1%0!!+01/&--!
,# ,+1!51Q 6! 1%!/!`0
3& !, ,# :$%1 !14!!+ 14,
-!,-)! 4&1% !/0,+ 0 1%!
$$/!00,/Q214%1%--!+!
!#,/!1%1R%140)&--!
,21 ,# 1%! 3& !,M + 4%1
016! &+R 6! 1%!/!`0
-&12/!1%10!!*0/!)M211%!-1&,+,2) !*&0)! &+$Q
6!)&*&0* !,21+!4*! &)1/!1*!+10!
,+ /!0!/% :+ &+$Z21 6,2`/! +,1 !/1&+ &# 1%! &1!
/!0!/% --!/ 12))6 0& 1%1Q %! -!,-)! 4%, /!\/!-,/1
1%!0!01,/&!0!&1%!/$!11%&+$04/,+$6*&01(!M,/M&+0,*!
0!0M1%!6/!&+1!+1&,+))6*&0)! &+$20Q
+1%!0!0!0M6,24&))4+11,1/!1%!)&*M.2,1!M,/
*! & ( 1, 1%! 0,2/!M 0, 6,2 + 0!! &1 &+ &10 ,/&$&+)
,+1!51+ $!1 0!+0! ,# 4%!1%!/1%! 3!/0&,+6,2 04 40
2/1!)6-/!0!+1! Q)!0!41%1%!#,)),4&+$3& !,V?LAAW
1%1 &0200!0 /!\/!-,/1&+$ 30Q ,/&$&+) /!-,/1&+$ +
!*,+01/1!0.2&(1&-L$,&+$]2-01/!*^1,:+ 1%!,/&$&+)
/!-,/1&+$0,2/!Q
N"))#(!,#&0)., -"%#(!
-!/2,/2!'-4!24'6!!+!,!-43&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!74&!,/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?C@M/!,! ZB
#)<9F<F(&#(0,#6.#)(-%#&&-N#);C#(."
),#!#(&-)/,3O
).C/,()(&)-*.#)(-1#."."PQ/..)(),/-."
.2..,(-,#*.J1K# 3)/*, ,.),F
&4G8E4?,847<A:K8E6<F8
An interactive H5P element
has been excluded from this
version of the text. You can view
it online here:
https://smc.pressbooks.pub/
writingourbodies/?p=152#h5p-76
"))#(!,#&0)., -"%#(!N
3,$$D C/8H/64D
&$QB?Q?*$!!0/&-1&,+Q%!&*$! &0-)60#,2/6!)),4
&,+0!3!+)60-! $&+01 /( ($/,2+ Q/,*)!#11,
/&$%1L%!:/01&,+&0+,1$,+)0%-!4&1%4%&1!%+ &+
1%!!+1!/M06*,)&7&+$01,-,/21&,+0&$+Q%!0!,+ &,+
/!0!*)!00-!!%2)!M4&1%+0!+!,#&+1!/+) !0&$+0M
02$$!01&+$ ,**2+&1&,+ ,/ &),$2!Q %! 1%&/ &,+ &0
0&*-)&:! M01/10%-!4&1%+,0-!&:& !+1&:)!#!12/!0M
-,00&)6 /!-/!0!+1&+$ 2+&.2! ,+!-1Q %! #,2/1% &,+
/!0!*)!0+01/1#!Q%&,+&0 &01&+1&+0%-!+
!0&$+M!*-%0&7&+$ &8!/!+1,+!-12)& !0QV!12/+1,&$Q
B?Q?W
..,$/.$)(-
&'3&04!273 04! $2/,
-42/ 54'/-4/
/++!%!!3!2&
J/092'%&4d@>@?9+4!2N
54+!2Q+/&2%!-4Q- !+3!9,'4&N
-42/ 54'/-4//++!%!!3!2&
+'!-3! 5- !2
2!4'6!/,,/-3442'54'/-BN>-4!2-4'/-+
'!-3!J!8!047&!2!/4&!27'3!-/4! N
N"))#(!,#&0)., -"%#(!
),%-$.
[-+'-!!2';4'/-*'++3Y' !/?I-42/ 54/29
' !/N\
/55!
J50+/ ! 9ZJ@G5-!
@>?FN
[-+'-!!2';4'/-*'++3Y' !/@I-6!34'%4!
4&!/52!N\
/55!
J50+/ ! 9ZJ@G
5-!@>?FN
[-+'-!!2';4'/-*'++3Y' !/AI'- 4&!
2'%'-+/52!N\
/55!
J50+/ ! 9ZJ
@C9@>?FN
[-+'-!!2';4'/-*'++3Y' !/BI//*$/2
2534! /2*N\
/55!
J50+/ ! 9ZJ@C
9@>?FN
4!84 04! $2/,[&!*J+!3!L424!2
/523!J\+'!-3! 5- !2BN>N
4!84- %20&'3 04! $2/,[V&!
/52/6!3W\9'*!5+;!+ J+'!-3! 5- !2
BN>N
'-!52%J,J- 2&2!7N[4!2+
! '-%I! '-%!33- !2-'-%/2!&!-
6+54'-%'%'4+-$/2,4'/-N\
4-$/2 '34/29
"))#(!,#&0)., -"%#(!N
54'/-2/50/2*'-%0!2/N@>?EZ?
JD
4N@>?EJ 8N /'N/2%R?>N@?AGR332-NA>BFGGBN
N"))#(!,#&0)., -"%#(!
+J;
/4$DD2$C$$
&84EA<A:)5=86G<I8F
94&!!- /$4&'3&04!2J9/53&/5+ !+!4/
H 6+54!7&!4&!23&/+2+924'+!4&4
'30+93'-9/523!2&2!35+43'32!+!6-44/
9/522!3!2&15!34'/-
%!+6,2 ,0!/%20&+$,,$)!M)&//6 10!M,/
,1%!/1,,)0M6,2`)),#1!+0!!1%!1!/*01%1*1%6,2/0!/%
1!/*0&+,) L
"))#(!,&/(-")&,&2).,N
#!F<:F9F))!&")&,-," ),(-.!,'(
*,--#)(FJ'!-,#*.#)(K
21 + 6,2 ! 02/! 1%1 !3!/6 0,2/! 1%1 ,+1&+0 6,2/
0!/%1!/*0&0,&0(.1,6,2//!0!/%.2!01&,+R
!1`0 06 6,2`/! !5-),/&+$ 1%! .2!01&,+M ],!0 +01$/*
20! !-/!00&,+R^))1%/!!,#1%!/1&)!0&+1%!0!/%/!02)10
,3!,+1&+1%!1!/*0(-.!,'+ *,--#)(&+1%!1&1)!Q
21 1(! ),0!/ ),,( 1 1%1 :/01 0,2/!Q 0 &1 06&+$ 1%1
+01$/*/-- !-/!00&,+R
N"))#(!,&/(-")&,&2).,
6?BF8E?BB>4GG;8VEFGFBHE68
4'!-!
@>?E
(-.",'*#).)-, 0 &*, $.$0
',% ,-)! *, --$)(
- 2!7!!!- &2'34/0&!2-$/24&
3424
3'-%-34%2, 4$2/,?DD'- '6' 5+3J7!
00+'! ,&'-!+!2-'-%4//+34/35!33$5++9
' !-4'$9,2*!23/$ !02!33'/-N44'34'+$!452!3
7!2!/,0544'/-++9!8424! $2/,BAJGC>
024''0-4-34%2,0&/4/3J53'-%/+/2-+93'3J
,!4 4/,0/-!-43J- +%/2'4&,'$!
!4!4'/-N!35+4'-%,/ !+3/540!2$/2,! %!-!2+
024'4'/-!23^6!2%!5-33'34! '%-/34'35!33
24!$/2 !02!33'/-N&!3!2!35+43&!+ !6!-7&!-
4&!-+93'3732!342'4! 4/0/343, !!$/2!
!02!33! '- '6' 5+37!2!;234 '%-/3! N5,-
24'-%3/$0&/4/442'54!3V&009J3 J!4NW7!2!
"))#(!,&/(-")&,&2).,N
7!*!202! '4/23/$ !02!33'/-J- 7!2!
5-/22!+4! 7'4&/,0544'/-++9Z%!-!24!
$!452!3N&!3!2!35+4335%%!34-!76!-5!3$/2
!2+932!!-'-%- !4!4'/-/$,!-4+'++-!33N
!1`0/!( ,4+1%&01&1)!L]+01$/*-%,1,0/!3!)-/! &1&3!
*/(!/0 ,# !-/!00&,+Q^ ,!0 1%1 /!)1! 1, ,2/ /!0!/%
.2!01&,+ ,# 4%!1%!/ +01$/* 20!0 !-/!00&,+R 1 0!!*0
1,! 06&+$1%1-%,1,0,++01$/* ,+1&+&+ &1,/0,#
!-/!00&,+Z0,M )&(!M *6! 4! + 1!)) 4%, *&$%1 %3! ,/
!3!),- !-/!00&,+ 0! ,+ 1%! &*$!0 1%!6`/! -,01&+$ ,+
+01$/*Q211%1 ,!0+`1+!!00/&)6*!+1%!&/+01$/*
20!/-1%! !-/!00&,+Q
!1`0),,( !!-!/14%11%!01/1060,214%11%!6
& L]0&+$+01$/* 1#/,*?DD&+ &3& 2)0M4!--)&!
*%&+! )!/+&+$ 1,,)0 1, 02!00#2))6 & !+1 */(!/0 ,#
!-/!00&,+Q^ + !! M 1%!6`/! 0!!&+$ 4%!1%!/ + 0+
0,*!,+!`0 +01$/* ,2+1 + 1!)) #/,* 1%!&/ -%,1,0
4%!1%!/1%!6`/! !-/!00! M!3!+!#,/!1%!6`3!!!+ &$+,0!
4&1% !-/!00&,+M+ +,*11!/4%!1%!/1%!6 ),,(%--6,/
0 &+1%!-%,1,Q1&))M1%1`0 &8!/!+1#/,*+01$/*/-#(!
1%! !-/!00&,+Q
,/*,/!-/1&! !&-%!/&+$0%,)/)6/1&)!0M),,((
11%!%-1!/,+%!1,/&))6+)67&+$ !*&!510Q
,41/6&14&1%1%&0!5*-)!L
N"))#(!,&/(-")&,&2).,
-'-4!24'6!C!+!,!-4&3!!-
!8+5 ! $2/,4&'36!23'/-/$4&!4!84N/5
-6'!7'4/-+'-!&!2!I
&4403IRR3,N02!33//*3N05R
72'4'-%/52/ '!3RO0`?CCM&C0ZEE
3,$$D C/8H/64D
&$Q B@Q? *$! !0/&-1&,+Q %! &*$! &0 0/!!+0%,1 ,#
,,$)! %,)/ 0!/% /!02)10 #,/ 1%! .2!/6 ]&+01$/* +
!-/!00&,+Q^1 1%!1,-&0 1%!,,$)! %,)/),$,M0!/%
/4&1%1%!!+1!/! .2!/6M+ )2!0!/%211,+Q!),4M&1
0%,40)&01,#/1&)!0/!)1! 1,1%!0!/%.2!/6Q+1%!)!#1M
1%!/!/!:)1!/,-1&,+0#,/1&*!/+$!M0,/1&+$-/!#!/!+!0M+
16-!,#/1&)!Q%/!!/1&)!0/! &0-)6! &+1%!*&+0!1&,+M
!%4&1% 1&1)!M21%,/0`+*!0M-2)&1&,+ !1&)0M /&!#
0+&--!1,# ,+1!+1M+ ,-1&,+0 1, 03!M&1!M3&!4 &11&,+0M
/!)1! /1&)!0M+ 3!/0&,+0Q!64,/ 0)&(!]+01$/*^+
] !-/!00&,+^/!%&$%)&$%1! &+,) Q/+0/&! !51L,,$)!
%,)/S &+01$/* + !-/!00&,+Q /1&)!0L ,21 A>GM>>>
/!02)10X>Q>F 0!YS+6 1&*!Q,/1 6/!)!3+!Q,/16 1!Q
+6 16-!L !3&!4 /1&)!0M &+)2 ! &11&,+0Q ?Q VW
"))#(!,&/(-")&,&2).,N
+01$/*-%,1,0/!3!)-/! &1&3!*/(!/0,# !-/!00&,+
!!!M+#,/1%[1&!+!M@>?E[-/&+$!/N
1!%+&.2!01,0/!!+#,/ !-/!00&,+20&+$-%,1,$/-%0-,01!
1, +01$/*Q 2/ /!02)10 N !-/!00&,+ /! ,0!/3)! &+
+01$/*20!/!%3&,/M+ 6-,1%!0&0M1%11%!0! !-/!00&3!
N@Q +01$/*P &+010 RL !5-),/&+$ 00,&1&,+0 *,+$
&+01$/* 20!M !-/!00&3! 06*-1,*0M +!$1&3! 0,&)
,*-/&0,+M + 01/+$!/0 #,)),4! 2-M /2M
,0!+1%)[6!/-06%,),$6M!%3&,/M+ ,&)NM@>?C[
)&!!/1-2Q,*N#/!.2!+6,#+01$/*20!+ !-/!00&3!
06*-1,*0Q N #/!.2!+6 ,# +01$/* 20! + !-/!00&3!
06*-1,*0SXY1%&0N,#01/+$!/0#,)),4! ,++01$/*4&))
*, !/1!1%! &/!1+ NAQ!%3&,2/)06*-1,*0,#*!+1)
%!)1% &0,/ !/02%0 !-/!00&,+*,+$6,2+$-!,-)!20&+$
+01$/*L0601!*1&/!3&!4 !6+'2M,)#M
/+M ,%)#/1%N [ /+0)1&,+) ! &&+! NM @>@? [
-/&+$!/ N L 1%,0! /!)1&+$ 1, +01$/* 20!/0 + 6,2+$
-!,-)! + !-/!00&,+ ,/ 06*-1,*1& !%3&,2/ ,#
!-/!00&,+Q12 &!04!/!&+)2 ! %!6%3!!!+,+ 21!
,++01$/*20!/0MNV!12/+1,&$QB@Q?W
$#/HHC/KH/64D
K /!!+%,1,,$)!%,)/+01$/*!-/!00&,+h
&+!00)!/!!&0)&!+0! 2+ !/>X/!1&3!
,**,+0!/,Y)&!+0!
N"))#(!,&/(-")&,&2).,
