2
A review article by Robey describes an acidogenic diet as one that’s rich in animal proteins,
salt, sugar, and fat and deficient in alkaline/base-forming foods such as fruits and vegetables.
According to this theory, acidogenic diets induce hormonal changes such as upregulation of
insulinlike growth factor 1, cortisol, leptin, and adiponectin, which are thought to then increase
the body’s acidity. However, Robey concludes, while a Western-type diet may increase the
acid load sent to the kidneys, it hasn’t been proven that these hormonal changes directly
increase cancer risk. Furthermore, Robey asserts that patients shouldn’t modify their diet
based solely on the perception that doing so will provide benefit.3
In a similar review article by Schwalfenberg investigating the alkaline diet’s relationship to
cancer and other disease states, the author identifies long-term changes to dietary habits that
have resulted in an eating pattern with less fiber and more saturated fat, simple sugars,
sodium, and chloride. These changes have resulted in greater consumption of sodium vs
potassium and an increase in chloride vs bicarbonate, which may be responsible for a diet-
induced chronic acidotic state. Schwalfenberg says dietary habits don’t affect one’s internal pH
but that they do change urinary pH and questions whether this shift may be detrimental to
one’s health.4
With regard to cancer, it’s discussed that while certain chemotherapies (including epirubicin
and Adriamycin) may be more effective in an alkaline environment, others (such as cisplatin
and mitomycin C) are more effective in an acidic environment. The consensus is that current
scientific literature doesn’t support a benefit of an alkaline diet for cancer prevention or
treatment.4
In a systematic review by Fenton and Huang, only one study out of 8,278 on the alkaline diet
and cancer met inclusion criteria. This study, which looked at urine pH and compared it with
the incidence of bladder cancer, concluded that urine pH isn’t an identifiable risk factor for
bladder cancer.5 These findings correlate with what’s known about the body’s ability to tightly
regulate pH balance through a combination of respiratory, renal, and chemical buffers.6
In addition to having limited to no support, the alkaline diet comes with possible harms.
Depending on the type of alkaline diet followed, there’s a risk of micronutrient deficiencies with
long-term use. Because this diet typically restricts major food groups, including meat, nuts,
seeds, dairy, and certain fruits, vegetables, and grains, it may be deficient in important
vitamins and minerals, including iron, B vitamins, calcium, and vitamin D.
A recent systematic review identified that individuals who consumed a strict vegetarian diet,
similar to that of an alkaline diet, had lower iron store levels than nonvegetarians.7 In one case
study, an individual who followed a very restrictive, primarily vegan diet experienced protein-
calorie malnutrition and pellagra. Symptoms resolved with supplementation and consumption
of the identified deficient micronutrients.8
Basic Cellular Metabolism and Alkalinity/Acidity
To understand the rationale behind using the alkaline diet as an alternative cancer treatment,
it’s important to first review the basics of normal cellular metabolism and compare that process
with the metabolic alterations that occur in cancer cells. This comparison sheds light on what