
94 95
POLITICS, PHILOSOPHY, AND ECONOMICS
control. The SNS quickly garnered a reputation for ruthlessness
and brutality, and Wingate’s militaristic Zionism, combined with
high-level British concerns over the arming of Jewish settlers,
forced his reassignment away from Palestine in 1938.
The archive illuminates this contentious two-year period in
Wingate’s career, comprising primary, le, and transcribed copies
of documents, annotated dras, and other notes. The SNS material
sits alongside Wingate’s proposals, following the outbreak of the
Second World War, for a larger militarized Jewish force. Present
here are typescript dras and manuscript notes for important
essays such as “Appreciation on the Use of Jewish Forces in the
Prosecution of the War”.
Wingate’s character and attitudes are revealed most starkly
by complaints he led with the army’s high command following
his sidelining in 1938. Wingate was increasingly at odds with
Wing Commander A. P. Ritchie, head of RAF intelligence in
Jerusalem, who wrote in Wingate’s 1939 ocial annual report of his
questionable judgement, misplaced sympathies, and “valueless”
service to the intelligence branch. In response, Wingate lodged
an ocial appeal, dras here showing his composition of a biting
and self-assured rebuttal, which suggested that Ritchie lacked
sucient knowledge of his service to assess it. The report, and the
failure of his appeal, represented the nadir of Wingate’s career but
also set a platform for future greatness.
These papers passed by descent to Lieutenant-Colonel Orde
Jonathan Wingate (1944–2000), Wingate’s son, who permitted
Trevor Royle to consult them for his biography, Orde Wingate: A
Man of Genius, 1903–1944 (1995). The material was subsequently sold
in the broader dispersal of the Wingate papers (part of Lot 373,
Sotheby’s, 11 June 1996) and bought by Steve Forbes, the chairman
of Forbes Magazine and a presidential candidate in the 1996 and
2000 US elections. As part of the sale, a microlm copy of key
sections was deposited in the British Library (BL reference M2313;
Forbes received a copy, included here). This microlm has been
cited by researchers since – a recognition of its uniqueness and
historical value. A full inventory is available.
Together, several hundred typescript and manuscript sheets, accompanied
by a selection of notebooks, photographs, printed publications, and other
material. Signs of handling, as expected, but neatly arranged and generally
well preserved.¶Simon James Anglim, “Orde Wingate and the British Army,
1922–1944: Military Thought and Practice Compared and Contrasted”, PhD
diss., 2007.
£45,000 [168835]
WITTGENSTEIN, Ludwig. Seven autograph letters
signed to William Eccles. Vienna and Cambridge: 1912–1939
“ – –
,
”
An interesting and insightful series, comprising seven of the nine
recorded letters written by Wittgenstein to Eccles, his close friend
from his time in Manchester, including an announcement of the
publication of his Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus. Wittgenstein oers
advice on Eccles’s engineering work, talks about his war work, and
mentions the progress he has made with his mathematical studies.
Wittgenstein and Eccles rst met in 1908 at a research station
in Glossop, Derbyshire, and the two became rm friends during
their three years together. They subsequently maintained a
regular, if infrequent, correspondence following Wittgenstein’s
move to Cambridge in 1912 through to the spring of 1939. The
WINGATE, Orde Charles. His private Palestine papers,
including reports, documents, and working dras.
Primarily Palestine: mostly 1938–41
“ ”
Oered on the market for the rst time in three decades, this
expansive collection is essential for understanding one of the
most controversial gures in the history of British Mandatory
Palestine. Alongside ocial reports on the Special Night Squads, it
includes Wingate’s position papers on Zionist questions, plans for
a broader militarized Jewish force, and evidence of his impassioned
disagreement with distrustful senior ocers in the British Army.
Wingate (1903–1944), a awed military genius, is considered
a hero for his foundation and leadership of the Chindits, a special
operations force operating in Burma during the Second World
War. As a younger man, Wingate cut his teeth in Sudan and
later Palestine, where he was posted as an intelligence ocer in
1936. “His time in Palestine was the turning point in Wingate’s
career. He found there a cause – Zionism – to which he became
passionately attached, and a patron, Major-General Archibald
Wavell, the general ocer commanding (GOC) in Palestine in
1937–8, who saved him from the professional consequences of that
attachment” (ODNB). Wingate formed the Special Night Squads,
highly mobile units of Jewish settlers (led by British ocers) tasked
with combating Arab saboteurs and quashing resistance to British
163
163
True rst edition of the Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, Wittgenstein’s
earliest published work, and one of the 20th century’s undisputed
philosophical masterpieces.
This German-language journal publication precedes the
book-form publication of the Tractatus by a year. It includes a 13-
page preface by Bertrand Russell, providing an explanation of the
article’s signicance that secured its publication. Wittgenstein,
whose attitude to publication was oen ambivalent, conded that
he was “pleased my stu is going to be printed’” (quoted in Monk,
pp. 203–4).
The work was written during his service in the First World
War, although its roots go back at least as far as his notes on logic
from 1913. It swily became the cornerstone of logical positivism
and of the Cambridge school of analytic philosophy, articulating
the relationship of language and reality and dening the limits
of science.
Octavo (222 × 154 mm). Tables and diagrams in the text. Contemporary
brown quarter cloth, spine ruled and lettered in gilt, marbled paper sides,
brown leatherette tips, marbled edges. Housed in a brown quarter morocco
solander box by the Chelsea Bindery. Twentieth-century ownership stamps
of Joachim Schliemann (great-grandnephew of the Heinrich Schliemann
who rediscovered Troy) and one Dr Hans Herz to title page. Minimal
bumping and rubbing, slight browning and foxing to contents: a very good
copy. ¶ Fann, p. 405; Frongia & McGuinness, p. 42; Lapointe, p. 4. Ray
Monk, Ludwig Wittgenstein: The Duty of Genius, 1990.
£57,500 [178936]
correspondence oers, in Eccles’s own words when he subsequently
published the letters, “some light on Wittgenstein as a person,” as
well as making “occasional references to his philosophical work”
(Eccles, p. 57).
The letters begin before the First World War. Renewing contact
aer the war, Wittgenstein writes of his joy at learning that Eccles
has survived, and asks for news about friends and family from his
Manchester days. He reports that the book he had started to write
before the war has now been published: “(It is called ‘Tractatus
Logico-Philosophicus’ and has been printed by Trench, Trubner & Co.
London). This shows you that I am still alive.”
In the 1920s, he is now working as an elementary school
teacher, would love to visit England to see old friends, but has given
away all his money. He is unable to send much news about himself
(“I would have to write a book”), but hopes to accept Eccles’s oer
to visit, noting however that “England may not have changed since
1913 but I have.” Writing aer his return to Cambridge in 1929,
Wittgenstein announces his research fellowship at Trinity, giving
him both nancial security and time to work, but fears that “my
capacity for the particular kind of work, in all probability, will
have le me in 2 or 3 years and then I shall probably resign my
fellowship.” Of the award of his professorship in February 1939, he
wryly observes: “Having got the professorship is very attering and
all that but it might have been very much better for me to have got
a job opening and closing crossing gates. I don’t get any kick out of
my position (except what my vanity and stupidity sometimes gets).”
7 autograph letters, variously written in pencil and in ink, one signed with
initials, together with an original envelope addressed in Wittgenstein’s
hand to Eccles. Together 13 and a half pages, approximately 1,700 words
in all, in English, preserved in an archival box. Folded for mailing, some
minor tears along folds, one letter with short tape repair, evidence of
paper clip use to most top le corners, generally in a very good state of
preservation. ¶ Published in William Eccles, “Some Letters of Ludwig
Wittgenstein”, Hermathena, no. 97, 1963; and in Brian McGuinness & G. H.
von Wright, Ludwig Wittgenstein: Briefwechsel mit B. Russell, G. E. Moore, J. M.
Keynes, F. P. Ramsey, W. Eccles, P. Engelmann und L. von Ficker, 1980.
£55,000 [170379]
WITTGENSTEIN, Ludwig. “Logisch-Philosophische Ab-
hand lung” [In] Annalen der Naturphilosophie, XIV 3/4,
edited by Wilhelm Ostwald. Leipzig: Unesma G.M.B.H., 1921
164
165