
20221130-RQ 8
but any works you cite briefly in the narrative should receive a full citation in Attachment 5:
Bibliography.
Organize your narrative using the following section headings. Each section aligns with one or
more review criteria NEH will use to evaluate your proposal.
Significance and impact (approximately two pages; aligns with review
criterion 1)
Provide a clear, concise statement about the intellectual significance of the proposed text for
humanities scholars; the need for an edition or translation of the material; and the edition’s
potential to stimulate new scholarship. If a previous edition or translation exists, discuss the
reasons for undertaking a new one. Explain the problems or inadequacies of the earlier editions
or translations and how your project would solve the problems or remedy the inadequacies.
Include a bibliographical essay that situates the project within the existing relevant literature
and explain how it will fill a need for a new edition and advance scholarship on the author or
related topics. For example, how will the edition advance current research questions concerning
the author’s intent or meaning? Or, how will a new translation satisfy a demand for a more
readable modern language edition?
If your editions project has received previous NEH support, discuss your edition’s impact in the
humanities in the form of biographies, monographs, articles, edited volumes, web resources,
and any other scholarship that demonstrate significance and impact.
History of the project and productivity (approximately two pages; aligns
with review criterion 4)
Provide a history of the project to date. Explain how the project began, its progress, and its
estimated completion date. Specify how you have selected materials for the edition or
translation and how you will gain access to them. If gaining access to the materials requires
permissions or poses other challenges, explain how you will address these issues.
• If your project is at a planning stage, describe how NEH support will advance the
project toward collecting materials for editing and translating, developing its editorial
policies, establishing the collaborative team, determining a dissemination medium,
determining your audience and their needs for the edition, and, in the case of projects
with online dissemination, planning for digital sustainability.
• If your project has received previous NEH support, report on your progress, including
work supported by other NEH programs, if applicable. Discuss the project’s general
history of productivity, specifying progress in collecting materials, editing or translating,
and preparing for publication.
• If you are requesting support for a specific part of a larger editorial project, describe
the overall design of the whole project and clearly delineate the specific part intended for
NEH funding through this application.
• If work on the larger project will continue after the proposed period of performance,
describe the remaining work (including a realistic completion date for the entire project)
and probable sources of financial support. For long-term projects, provide a provisional
plan for overall completion, including milestones with dates. Discuss how you will
address succession in project leadership.